Gladio Free Europe, E1: Yegor Letov and the National Bolshevik Party https://www.gladiofreeeurope.com/episodes/yegor-letov-and-the-national-bolshevik-party [0:00:16] And we're back with another episode of Gladio Free Europe. I'm Abram, and today I'm joined by Russian Sam. [0:00:22] Yo. [0:00:23] Liam. [0:00:24] How you doing? [0:00:25] And Halal Sam. [0:00:26] Hello. [0:00:28] And if you haven't listened to this podcast before, it's a sort of history, sort of movie podcast. We're going to mostly discuss movies and try to discuss the historical context of movies. And so today, we are going to the late 20th century USSR and the beginnings of the Russian Federation to look at one of the most interesting cultural figures from that pretty crazy time and place. [0:00:51] Yeah. [0:00:52] So this episode is going to be part one of our multi-part series on the National Bolshevik Party. So Nazbols, you've probably heard of them. And if you haven't heard of them, you know, this should be a fun one. So straight off the bat, what is your guys' impression of who the Nazbols are going to this? [0:01:11] I kind of took them as a bit of a joke, to be honest, because their imagery is so ridiculous, but which it turns out there is some truth to it because it grew out of the punk movement and it grew out of this kind of embrace of extreme looking things. I mean like the motto yes death and the their flag being literally just the Nazi flags with a hammer and sickle swapped in for a swastika. It's like they are going for a shock aesthetic, but it turns out to be a little more we'll get into it. [0:01:39] Before I really knew about the Nazbols, I just thought of them as a meme. And now that I know a little bit more, I still think they're a meme, but I think they're a meme that can tell you a lot about what Russian culture and society was like in the early 90s. And also where we're headed today. [0:01:53] Absolutely. [0:01:56] My impression was: yeah, Sami Zoo, Amy's do like they're a joke, but I thought they were like, I don't know, the Nazi party, but because Russians have an aversion to like Nazism, it's just like the Nazi party with some like Soviet flourishes. And for some people, it is kind of like that, but that isn't really what the party's about. [0:02:16] Yeah, I mean, I got into, but later I do want to talk about the fact that I got into their music because I do feel there is some parallels, as Sam, Russian Sam, said, between our moment in America today and the Brezhnev era, USSR. [0:02:29] So, as Halal Sam alluded to, this party comes out of the punk movement in the 80s, 90s Soviet Union. And two of the main three founders were punks themselves. First is Edward Limonov, who was a Russian author who was living in exile in the West, you know, the United States and somewhere in Europe. [0:02:52] Paris. [0:02:52] Yeah, Paris. So in the 70s, and he hung out with like a lot of famous punks. And, you know, that punk scene in New York. He hung out with like the Ramones and stuff. [0:03:02] Famous chaotic bisexual. [0:03:04] Oh, yeah, that too. He wrote a couple of pretty famous books. I mean, he's written a lot of books, but the two most famous ones are It's Me Eddie and Memoir of a Russian Punk. But he's a topic for like another episode. In this episode, we're going to talk about the other punk founder of the National Bolsheviks, who is Yegor Letov, a front man of a famous underground punk band, Civil Defense, or in Russian. [0:03:30] Grazhdanskaya Oborona. [0:03:31] Thank you. Prior to being a founder of the NBP, he was one of the Soviet Union's most famous underground musicians, or one of the most famous underground punk musicians at the very least. And before he even turned 30, he put out something like 50 full-length albums between his personal projects and side projects and collaborations and stuff. It's unbelievable. [0:03:58] Drugs work. [0:03:59] Drugs work, kids. [0:04:00] Yeah. [0:04:02] Even of the material that's available on Spotify, there's just so much of it, both through his solo work and in his various side projects, the various bands that he was involved with. [0:04:13] Well, this is a bit of a cultural thing, I think, because in general, Russian musicians in the Soviet period were much more prolific than Americans are because they didn't have the same studio system where, you know, they have to put out an album every two to three years based on the statistics and whatever the label thinks is appropriate. These guys were just recording when they felt the inspiration to. [0:04:37] That's really interesting. [0:04:38] Yeah, and we're going to get more into like the broader Soviet music scene or Soviet punk scene later. But so yeah, in this episode, we're going to mostly talk about him, Letov, his life and music career, and his personal contributions to the NBP and his life afterwards. [0:05:37] So as Russian Sam said, the Nazbols were mostly famous for their Nazi Germany flag with the hammer and sickle. And they're also famous for like marching in the streets, dressed all black, like waving the flag, you know, making a big scene and like protests and stuff. And yeah, I mean, ideologically, like most people think of them as fascists. Like, that's what we all thought. But ostensibly, they're supposed to be a coalition of extremists. So you have far-left communists and far-right nationalists, and they're united under the national Bolshevik flag. [0:06:15] It's the party of the deplorables. [0:06:17] Here's my big question about the Nazbols, which I never understood and I still don't understand. That hopefully you guys can clear up. Obviously, they have a flag very clearly inspired by the Nazi flag. Like we said, it's the red field with the white dot, but instead of a swastika, it's the hammer and sickle. It kind of reminds me of that Simpsons gag about the Nazi communists. But anyways, so my big question is, to what extent were these guys Nazis? Like, what did they actually borrow from the actual Nazis and from Nazi ideology beyond the aesthetics? [0:06:51] Not much, really, because a big thing is it's kind of different depending on people who were involved in the party in like membership sense, and people who were like higher up. And even then, the higher ups were kind of mixed on what this party really was. But it is a punk party. And most of these people genuinely were in it just for like the punk aesthetics and just like making a scene. And just they weren't actually, I mean, they probably had their own ideology or like views on how the country should be, but most of the actual members were basically just joining this to like make a scene. They weren't really joining this to like advance a political project. [0:07:32] So I guess to some extent, you can kind of compare it to like Sid Vicious, how he would wear like a swastika all the time, even though as far as I know, he never once held a political belief at all. [0:07:42] Well, it's worth pointing out that's actually more bold in Russia, the country where tens of millions of people were killed by the Nazi Germany. [0:07:53] And I would also point out that in terms of, I mean, when we think of Nazism, we do tend to think of German ethnic nationalism as part of the core of the ideology. And I think it's important if we're talking about Letov and his political beliefs to emphasize that he was not an ethnic nationalist. In an interview, he describes himself as a Soviet nationalist. He says, I think that over the 70 years of Soviet rule, a new nation emerged, the Soviet nation and the Soviet people. Everyone is now so mixed together that it's impossible to speak of nationalism. Mother's side, I'm descended from Cossacks, and my father's, I'm Buryat, blah, blah, blah, blah. He doesn't believe in the ethnic Russians kicking out all the Tatars and all these other groups. [0:08:32] I'm going to start blutting Boden, it's just Boden. [0:08:34] Yeah. [0:08:35] That actually is a huge distinction from what we think of as Nazism, you know. And of course, Russia at this time did have plenty of genuine and still does have plenty of like actual ethno-nationalists. [0:08:47] Yeah, this is like a big problem that left-wing nationalists have had for years because you want a nationalist party if you're like a small country that's you know a client state of some you know larger neoliberal power and you want to be able to lean on people's sense of pride in their country and their culture and sense of duty to their country and you know but you also do not want to encourage right-wing nationalist beliefs such as the view that a country is a specific ethnic like group and obviously in the case of russia or soviet union like it's a very multi-ethnic country so you really do not want to encourage that but it's this fine balance that many nationalist movements left-wing nationalist movements in the world have grappled with and we'll say that the Nazbols grappled with it too and yeah you know they do as good a job as anybody else i'll say i would just like to say that the real umbrella of the Nazbols aside from being against the the russian government that arose after 91 was collectivism because in russia in this time period you it's well i wanted to say that it was unfathomable what was happening to people but that's really no longer the case if you look at videos of what's happening in san francisco for example and all these massive homeless encampments that's essentially what was happening in the soviet union on a much larger scale so so the thing that united them was the fight for collectivism against loneliness and against alienation. [0:10:33] I personally think it's all very stupid, but we're going to have a much bigger discussion on whether it was or not at the end of the episode. [0:10:39] But before we really go deep into national bolsheviks, let's discuss Yegor. Sorry, I'm gonna butcher this. Grazhdanskaya Oborona, Russian for civil defense, often abbreviated to Grob, which coincidentally means coffin in Russian. [0:10:55] Is like that a funny thing? [0:10:56] Or is it's clever, but I wouldn't really call it funny. [0:11:00] It's another dark joke. It's another little dark twist, you know. [0:11:03] Like it's called our name is coffin. [0:11:05] Yeah, exactly. It fits for a punk band, I'll say. But yeah, I'll try to use the English name civil defense throughout the episode, just so our English-speaking listeners can have a good idea. So I say he's the most famous underground musician. And what does that mean? [0:11:21] So in the Soviet Union, you have official musicians and underground musicians. Official musicians are the people who were legally allowed to perform at shows, at venues, and have their music played on the radio. And, you know, any music journalists were allowed to cover their activities. And those bands were essentially decided by the government bureaucracy, the Ministry of Culture, and the Ministry of Composers, I think. [0:11:51] Yeah, they were called vocal and instrumental ensembles, often shortened to VIA, Soviets. [0:11:57] And those bureaucracies were in charge of all official music. So they're the ones who decide what you can sing about and what kind of music you're allowed to play. And they were very strict about what was and wasn't allowed, and they only approved a very small amount of bands in general. So the overwhelming majority of bands that existed in the Soviet Union were unofficial underground bands. [0:12:23] It's a fundamentally different model of music distribution and production than what we have. [0:12:27] Yeah. [0:12:28] And I gotta wonder if, to some extent, if like the embrace of like, you know, Nazi aesthetics, both among the Nazbols and to a lesser extent in the earlier work by Letov, is because like if you're part of a musical scene that's rebelling against the Soviet system, you're probably gonna be pretty rebellious in your aesthetics. [0:12:46] Yes, I would say that the big part of the Nazi aesthetics was they're they were doing this as a way to draw equivalence between the Soviet system and the Nazi system. Not saying that's correct, but that's how they saw it. [0:12:59] It's not correct. [0:13:00] No, it's of course not. Yeah. [0:13:02] For the record, it's important to state that. [0:13:05] Yeah. Yes, but basically what they were doing is they were staging these provocations by creating this sign of equivalency because it was a way to call out the system under which they were living and many of them languishing. [0:13:20] On one level, you were kind of allowed to do whatever the hell you wanted as an unofficial musician as long as, you know, like KGB agent didn't like think you were like up to bad news or whatever. [0:13:31] You're fine as long as you're not on the shit list. [0:13:33] And I mean, that's basically the thing with the Soviet system is that you had a bunch of rules that oftentimes were not enforced. But once the KGB wanted to get rid of someone, you can bet your ass that they will be enforced to the fullest extent of the law. So you never really know at what point you might be targeted. [0:13:53] Yeah. [0:13:55] So in this episode, I'm going to be editing in a lot of music because there's really no point in trying to like describe the music in depth, like sonically. You just kind of have to listen to it. So, if you're listening to this episode at like one and a half times speed or whatever, just adjust your podcast app now. Okay, let's hit it. I haven't planned advanced what like song goes where, but hopefully, you just listened to a good one. And hopefully, you also understood that the lyrics were very emotional and you know, like just a lot of anger, frustration, and occasionally they sound like hardcore lyrics, like hardcore punk lyrics. And, you know, sometimes they sound like very dour, you know, very kind of just disappointed in the state of things. And the content of the lyrics is very anti-Soviet that we can actually get into depth in. [0:15:44] So, as we said earlier, that some of the lyrics try to equate an equivalency between the Soviet system and the Nazi system. And that was obviously a theme in some songs, but not every song. So, what kind of themes do you hear in his music? [0:16:04] Either it's the Sams? [0:16:06] I would say that he was more anti-the people running the Soviet Union than against the Soviet system itself. Although he was very inconsistent on this, that's how I describe his beliefs, describe his beliefs overall. He did very much have a lot of fondness for a lot of the Soviet ideals, but the people who ran the system, and especially the KGB, were basically demons to him. [0:16:27] Yeah, and in the 90s, he expressed regret that he had expressed his beliefs in such a childish manner about equating the Soviet and the Nazi system. He felt like he had contributed to the mood of the time in a negative manner, and he was trying to make amends for that. [0:16:45] Well, here's a question: Besides being against individualism and liking collectivism, what exactly did Letov like about the Soviet system, and what did he dislike about its leadership in the 80s? [0:16:56] Well, I would say that he disavowed individualism. He very much was an individualist. If you look at many of his songs, like for example, I Will Always Be Against. What he liked was revolutionary energy and the idea that the old world is destroyed, and so now you have an opportunity to really create something new and to be infused by this energy that, you know, can only exist in this period of time. And he felt that as the Soviet Union matured, it got increasingly bureaucratized, which again would have been his direct experience as a targeted musician in the Soviet Union. And it was basically just state capitalists running the show, just these guys in suits who really want to maintain the status quo at all costs rather than risking something that might create substantial change. They just wanted everything to be nice and peaceful. That was really the ethos of the Brezhnev era. [0:18:06] Yeah, they were kind of Soviet bureaucrats, but in a lot of ways, they were kind of like the small business tyrants we know in America. [0:18:14] Yeah, KGB Agen says boat dealership guys. [0:18:18] But yeah, his music was obviously extremely different from the main music that you would get on the radio in the Soviet Union. I listened to some rock music to just compare, and the stuff in the 60s and 70s, and even up into the 80s, is very reminiscent of like 60s American rock music. You know, stuff like Pet Sounds or, you know, like The Monkees. So it wasn't like bad music, but there had been like a lot of advances in like rock music in those decades in like the West. And somehow you didn't get any of that on the radio in the Soviet Union. [0:18:55] Yeah, I think that's kind of like that's kind of the image that we have as Westerners of the USSR, that it was like always a couple decades behind the US culture. [0:19:03] Yeah, and the content of the lyrics is always like, I mean, the music is always, not always upbeat, but like a lot of times it's kind of upbeat. And like the lyrics were definitely like positive and you know, everything was kind of happy. [0:19:15] Very apolitical. [0:19:17] Yeah. Apolitical too. And just kind of like, yeah, just going on a date with my sweetheart, that kind of bullshit. And some when, you know, the state of the country is in decay, just listening to that on the radio is obviously very aggravating, which, you know, makes sense why punk musicians would become like so popular in the Soviet Union this time. [0:19:36] You don't want to listen to the songs about how cool Komsomol is all day long. [0:19:39] Yeah, just to give you guys a concrete example, I'm sure you're all aware of that song that was really popular like a decade ago as a result of the meme. [0:19:48] The Russian one that's like yeah, of course, yeah. [0:19:53] Yeah, so the story behind that is actually that originally there were supposed to be lyrics there, and it was supposed to be about a cowboy out in the field somewhere in America, and he's just dreaming about going home to his sweetheart and finally being with her. And so he submitted the lyrics to the Soviet censors and they just kept rejecting it. So at a certain point, he just thought that it was pointless to try to navigate the system and he just released it. Like he kept the melody, but instead of lyrics, he just started trolling. [0:20:25] It's a great video. [0:20:35] Okay, before we get into like the Soviet bureaucracy, let's get into Yegor Letov a little bit. So 1982, he's 18 years old, going to college in Moscow, drops out after like a few months of like not showing up to class. But in Moscow is where he kind of develops his appetite for music and like what kind of music he was into, which ends up being like punk music. In 1984, he moves back to Omsk from Moscow. And time to clear up some misconceptions about Omsk and Siberia. So, Omsk is a large city in Siberia. And most Americans, I feel, think of Siberia as on the very, very far east of Russia. [0:21:17] It's more of in the middle. [0:21:19] Yeah, it's right in the middle. It is cold and industrial, but still heavily populated. So, there was the city Omsk, and there's another sister city, Novosibirsk, which is like a nine-hour drive away. And both of those cities have a population of over one million people. And I looked this up on Wikipedia, and the climate and population line up almost perfectly with Milwaukee, Wisconsin. [0:21:44] For Omsk or Novosibirsk? [0:21:46] For both of them. [0:21:47] Oh, shit. [0:21:48] So, think of Siberia as like the Midwest of Russia or the Mideast. [0:21:55] Although we should probably highlight, though, it is like it's really far to get from Omsk to Moscow. Like, apparently, it's... [0:22:01] Yeah, it's a 36-hour drive. [0:22:03] Yeah, yeah. [0:22:04] Yeah, another thing is, Soviet Union is like nearly twice as wide as the continental United States. [0:22:10] Oh, yeah, yeah. [0:22:11] So it's enormous. [0:22:12] Still very big. [0:22:13] Three-quarters of Eurasia. [0:22:14] Yeah, I just have this feeling because I know a lot of people only know Siberia as like, you know, some Soviet dissident was exiled to Siberia. [0:22:23] Yeah, they assume it's, yeah. [0:22:24] And they sort of assume like Siberia is the punishment. It's like the punishment is going to prison. The prison just happens to be Siberia. [0:22:31] Yeah, yeah. [0:22:32] The punishment is that it's far away from everyone you know. But there are still people there. [0:22:37] Well, Siberia itself is also a bit of a punishment. Like it's freezing outside for six months of the year and there's really fuck all to do because, yeah, you're far away from like the centers of culture. [0:22:48] But is that any different than like getting sent to Alcatraz or like... [0:22:52] No, it's much less, I would think, because like there are cities in Siberia. There's not a city in Alcatraz. [0:22:56] That's true, yeah. [0:22:57] We have island prison. [0:22:58] Yeah, yeah. [0:22:59] I think the Midwest is a good example, especially because I think that when we hear, like Abram was saying, we assume that Siberia is the most remote part of Russia, but that's not necessarily the case. [0:23:08] Yeah, people think it's a frozen tundra, yeah. They think, yeah, it is very cold at the winters, but again, like just as cold as Milwaukee, and you know, people survive in Milwaukee. [0:23:16] Do they though? [0:23:18] They survive. I'm not saying they enjoy it, but they live it. [0:23:25] So, yeah, Letov also has an older brother named Sergei, and Sergei himself is a musician, a jazz musician. And this is another good way to clear up some misconceptions. So, up until this point, we've discussed Soviet cracking down on musicians, but I want to make it clear that they're cracking down on rock musicians. Because Sergei, who was a jazz musician and experimental jazz musician, doesn't really get into any kind of trouble with the government as Igor does. And my understanding of why this is is basically the Soviet government was deathly afraid of Beatlemania. They were definitely afraid of a situation like in the West where bands like the Beatles or Elvis Presley or Rolling Stones, or you know, any of those bands became larger than life, like mythical figures, and you know, became like something that the culture could not like rein in. So, a big thing that the Soviet government was doing is cracking down musicians when they got too big. [0:24:33] But, you know, if you were like an underground musician that wasn't really causing any trouble, you're kind of allowed to do whatever the hell you wanted. [0:24:39] It's a lot like how every Twitch streamer eventually gets cancelled. [0:24:42] Exactly. [0:24:43] Yeah, and again, we don't really get to the mass persecution stage until like 82, 83, 84. Before that point, it was annoying, and some people did get into serious trouble, but mostly it was like it wasn't really a big concern. [0:25:01] Yeah, and that's actually a very good point because, for the most part, okay, there were definitely just like some soulless bureaucrats in the government, sure. But a lot of the people like in the Ministry of Culture or whatever, or even the Ministry of Composers, were musicians and understood that like a heavy-handed government is just going to stifle creativity and like stifle culture. And they don't want that. They want like a vibrant Soviet culture and like Soviet artists to like flourish. So there was like a constant back and forth with like wanting to cultivate a rich culture and like being deathly afraid of a specific artist or band just getting too big to like control. [0:25:40] And that seems to be the story we see almost all the time in the USSR because there are so many incredible artists who are now like among the greatest in their fields, but they always did have these issues with censorship, you know, from like Shostakovich up all the way to like what's his name? The director, Tarkovsky. [0:25:57] Oh yeah, yeah. And just give you a quick timeline. [0:26:00] So 1980, things open up. You know, you're allowed to like do whatever the hell you want. So rock clubs start popping up in like Moscow and like Leningrad. You know, like bands are being formed and you know for music and like selling their stuff. And then 84, the fear sets in. And then the repression comes. I'm just like, you know, oh my god, we're going to like crack down on these guys. They're getting too big. And, you know, rock clubs are getting shut down. Bands are like being split apart. Like, some people are like being thrown in prison. And then a few years later, 87, the regret sets in. I'm like, oh my God, what have we done? We shouldn't have done this. And then they open up back again. So it is like a constant back and forth over how much should we meddle into this. [0:26:43] Yeah, and the funny thing is that the Soviet Union actually had its war on drugs around the same time as America was ramping it up. A lot of these musicians that they got, they arrested under Article 224, which is possession or selling of drugs. So that was one way that they were able to lock these people up. [0:27:01] Or just even like a band was performing at a venue where people were consuming drugs and alcohol. [0:28:22] So yeah, 1984 Letov is living in Omsk. He has a job painting murals of Lenin, like in factory floors and stuff. And that's kind of music. [0:28:35] I don't know. [0:28:36] It's a living. [0:28:37] Yeah, but he played music on the side. He had a band named Posev. And there were, of course, some albums. And a lot of that is just lost because, you know, lost some time. But some of it still exists. I think some of it's still on YouTube. It's very, you know, it's very early days. They don't have like a crack at songwriting just yet, but it exists out there if you're curious. And around this time is when he meets his two lifelong friends, Konstantin Ryabinov, nicknamed Kuzma, and Oleg Sudakov. [0:29:12] Yeah, by the way, do you want me to mention what Posev is? Like where the name comes from? [0:29:16] Oh yeah, sure. [0:29:16] Yeah, so this is actually going back to the discussion about symbols. Posev was actually the name of an organization that was created to a large extent by veterans of Vlasov's army, who was a Soviet general who defected to the Nazis and then continued to fight on their side. And Vlasov himself is killed in Prague, I believe, in the final days of the war. But the veterans, a National Salvation Front, I believe it was called, they started putting out this magazine called Posev, which was sort of like fascist corporatist in orientation, and they would also publish a lot of dissident literature. So it is interesting that Letov went with this name. [0:30:09] This project kind of just fizzles out, but him and Kuzma end up making the new project, which is civil defense, and that becomes, you know, their main project for the rest of their lives. [0:30:21] Yeah, that was in the autumn of 84. [0:30:23] And those two are the main members of civil defense throughout his lifetime, except a brief period where Kuzma was preoccupied. But yeah, those two are the main members. And, you know, there's like people coming in and going, filling in the roles for like other, playing other instruments, but they kind of honestly don't matter. Civil Defense becomes like a part of a growing punk scene at this point. So in Novosibirsk, in Omsk, some other outlying cities, there are bands like Instructions for Survival, Close Company, Bombs. [0:30:59] Bombs. Which I think means like a homeless bum or something like that. [0:31:03] Oh, it's funny. [0:31:05] Not all of them were like great musicians. Most of them weren't. [0:31:08] Yeah. [0:31:09] Roman Neumoev, who's the front man for Instructions for Survival, he describes his music at the beer as like mostly copycat stuff and just like just taking riffs that they heard on like Western music and just like putting Soviet lyrics over it. But the entire scene was like heavily anti-Soviet. Like all these bands were not exactly the same politically as Letov, but all of them hated the repression and just like how shitty the country is at this point. [0:31:39] Some of them were not great guys by any stretch of the imagination. So, for example, the lead man in Instruktsiya po Vyzhivaniyu, Instructions for Survival, was a massive anti-Semite, like to the extent that the band had a song called Kill the Jew. [0:31:54] Jesus Christ. [0:31:55] So these were, yeah, these were the guys who were like, these were not the guys who would become the Nazbols. These were the genuine Nazis, essentially, in Russia. [0:32:03] Yeah, these are the guys who would become the more monarchists, I would say. These are the guys. [0:32:09] So these are the guys, you could argue, these are guys that the Nazbols were parodying to the same extent that they were parodying the Communist Party. [0:32:18] Roman was, yeah, as you said, front band of Instructional Survival. He has like a lot of fondness for the monarchy. [0:32:25] I think the idea of being a punk rock monarchist is so embarrassing. [0:32:29] Yeah, fuck, what was his name? I forget the monarch's name. [0:32:33] Nicholas. [0:32:34] Yeah, Nicholas. Yeah, Nicholas is like. He has like fucking portraits of him in his house and shit. It's like very embarrassing. [0:32:39] Oh, what a loser. Just the idea of like breaking shit, you know, like in allegiance to some like inbred hemophiliac little fancy boy. It's hilarious. [0:34:04] They were anti-Soviet because they wanted freedom to like make the music they wanted. And again, like you're not allowed to make money off your music at this point. Like you're allowed to like distribute it and you know play at shows. I should point out like shows for these bands aren't playing on a stage. They are playing in like a factory floor, you know, after like everybody's gone home from work or playing in like people's apartments, even like in the kitchen, like kitchens in people's apartments, or even like sometimes just like I've seen photos of like Letov just like playing acoustic guitar on somebody's couch and just like a bunch of people like from the neighborhood sitting inside this person's apartment. [0:34:45] Yeah, apartment concerts were a big thing in the Soviet Union. Russian Sam, can you tell us a tiny bit about that? There's a name for it that I can't pronounce. [0:34:52] Yeah, so they're called kvartierniki from the word kvartiera, which is apartment. And it wasn't just music, it was also like in general, cultural output that was not officially recognized. [0:35:07] Yeah, like poetry or like acting and stuff like that. [0:35:10] Yeah, lots of poetry, lots of novel readings, but also I'd like to add a small caveat to what you said before about them being anti-Soviet because they just wanted to be able to make their music. I would say that that definitely was the case for many of them, but for people like Letov, for example, he definitely had a larger ideological mission in mind rather than just being able to play his music. He wanted to create a genuinely revolutionary society with like this very vital culture that's truly revolutionary rather than just reboiled Western crap from a decade ago. [0:35:51] Again, we're gonna play music, but I should say I'm not like a big lyrics guy, and obviously I don't understand Russian, so I don't really understand these lyrics. But the instrumentals on like civil defense songs are like beautiful. Like I'm a big metal guy, so I really just like listening to like hardcore instrumentals. [0:36:10] And really pretty melodies too. [0:36:12] In preparing for this episode, I was like linking songs that I liked in like a group chat I have with some metal fan friends and it turns out like a bunch of them you know had no idea about like who this guy is or his backstory but have listened to his music like in the past and like were fans of it. [0:36:28] Yeah, he spans ideology and time. [0:36:30] Yeah, there's also an interesting juxtaposition between the quality of the music itself and the sound quality. And this was partially a result of circumstance and partially a result, like an intentional choice because basically Letov wanted to keep the snobs away. He didn't want a bunch of groupies cropping up because it sounds cool or whatever. He wanted people to be into his music because they're down with the message rather than just because it has a pretty melody. And so, because of that, these early albums were recorded on these home recording devices, which were really awful. And he did a bunch of tinkering to intentionally make the sound quality bad. And that was also compounded by the fact that they had no official way of distributing these, of course. So people were making copies of copies of copies of these initial discs. [0:37:26] Cassettes, initial cassettes. [0:37:28] Yes, cassettes, exactly. [0:37:30] Oh, wow. [0:37:30] Yeah, it's funny. Yeah, so if you've never tried copying a cassette, there isn't like really a way to copy cassettes cleanly. It is, you basically have to play one cassette and record another cassette if you have like a two-cassette stereo. And so yeah, there's it's a very, very terrible like system because just playing a cassette degrades the quality. So every time you like play a cassette, it sounds worse. Every time you copy a cassette, it sounds much, much worse. And it's the best analog that I can come up with is like seeing like a deep-fried meme on Twitter or something where it's like screenshot it and cropped and resized and uploaded and stuff. And then eventually you might be seeing it like after it's been shared like 50 times or something and just like so much like pixelation and like so much detail is just like gone. [0:38:22] But this is like that to the extreme. Like think of it as every time you copy a cassette, it's like deep-frying a meme 10 times. [0:38:30] Well it definitely adds to you it's here. [0:39:34] One day while practicing, the mother of one of the band members overhears what they're playing, and she's like immediately mortified by like their lyrical content. And she calls the KGB and reports that these guys are engaging in anti-Soviet activities. So a couple of days later, KGB agent knocks on Letov's door. And it's like early morning, him and Kuzma were like hanging out in his place and they interrogate them. They interrogate other bandmates, his friends, his family, like everybody he knows. And they wanted to put him on trial for like terrorist activities. I think they made up some shit about him wanting to plant a bomb at like an oil refinery or something. [0:40:17] Which would have been pretty cool. [0:40:18] But I mean, he didn't. It's just, he was just playing music. But, you know, that's the kind of shit they have to come up with to like give this guy in prison. [0:40:26] Yeah, no parallels to modern-day American society at all. [0:40:29] And not really knowing what to do to get out of this, he just kind of like writes a note saying, I've decided to kill myself, basically. And the charges get dropped, but Kuzma gets shipped off to the army. which he wasn't supposed to because he has like a heart condition, but he gets shipped off to the army. And because he had written this letter, Letov is now thrown into a psychiatric facility. And he was there for three months, I think. [0:40:58] And how did he get out, Russian Sam? [0:41:00] So Letov's brother, Sergei, as I said, this was the beginning of 87, so perestroika had officially started. And Sergei found out that the best way to get Letov out of the psychiatric hospital was not to do a frontal assault per se, but rather to do it in this really backhanded way, where he was going around and talking to his friends. And he was like, oh, yeah, if they don't release my brother, then I'm going to call all these Western journalists and hold a press conference. And I'm going to tell them that perestroika is a sham, that everything is staying the same way as it was, there's no real change, etc. And shortly after that, Yegor is finally released. [0:41:40] And this event, these few months in the psychiatric ward, basically are, well, I think the first thing that elevate him from just a regular musician to like a sort of mythical figure on his own right. Because in interviews from now on, this is like a topic that comes up a lot. Whenever he's written about, or like there's a video about him, or even like in his Wikipedia article or anything, this instance is like mentioned. Like, even in researching this, I was like reading books about like other things, and like he's there for like three sentences, and one of those sentences is about his stay in the psychiatric ward. I'll just read a couple of quotes about what he says about his time there. I got enhanced support and received antipsychotics. These are suppressive drugs that make a moron out of a person. The effect is similar to a lobotomy. [0:42:28] A person becomes soft, complacent, and broken after the treatment. I realized at some point that I had to create not to go crazy. I walked and composed all day, wrote stories and poems. Every day that Oleg Sudakov came to me, I gave him through the bars everything that I wrote. Yeah, like if you read that in interviews, like a bunch of times, you really kind of, that really elevates him to like more than just like a musician who is like rebelling. Like, this is somebody who actually faces repression and faces traumatizing repression for most people. [0:42:59] Yeah, but on the other hand, he felt that this experience really added to his own worth as an artist. [0:43:06] Builds character. [0:43:07] Yeah, yeah, exactly. Like, he has, I mean, in another interview, he says that in a certain way, yes, as in, I did enjoy my time there because it was the first time that I learned what I was capable of. [0:43:20] What doesn't kill you makes you stronger. [0:43:21] I was desperately afraid because there was a certain mythology surrounding the KGB that they'll pump you full of truth serum and you'll sing like a bird. In the hospital, they pump me full of antipsychotics, and I understood that there's a certain mental block that you can put in. I understood that it's bad for the mind, bad for all that. I even went blind for a bit when they pumped me full of a new BTO. I was blind for about four hours. It was white darkness. That's when I understood that I could put in a mental block and it'll be okay. After that, I began to write very actively and began to write more songs. The Dostoevsky from before, before he stood on the hangman's platform with the bag over his head and the noose around his neck, and then he was pardoned. And then you had a new period, and that's when he began to write The Brothers Karamazov and whatnot. [0:44:05] This is what happened to me, so I'm thankful for this time. [0:44:08] Just from that quote, you get that he was in the hospital, he was pumped up full of drugs, he almost went blind, he almost went crazy. He even quotes Dostoevsky. Like, he's really building this up. And I mean, I'm not saying, like, obviously it's all true, but like, if you're reading this and you're like just kind of a casual fan of this music, you're just like, holy shit, like, this is this guy's the real deal. Like, this is. [0:44:30] And I think it's kind of interesting that, you know, Dostoevsky himself spent a few months in like a Tsarist-era gulag, which I'm sure probably he might have seen as some kind of like similar experience. [0:44:41] Yeah, I believe Dostoevsky was his favorite author at this point. [0:44:45] Dostoevsky, he comes up a lot in Letov's statements. There's like another thing that we'll get to in a bit. This is the main one that really elevates him beyond just a casual musician in people's minds. [0:44:57] Just another quote about his time immediately after. He says, We were untouchables in Omsk. Nobody wanted to have anything to do with us. They were all afraid. And from this time, I understood that I need to do everything myself. I got the equipment on the down low from people who weren't afraid, tape players, a microphone, and so on. They said to me, We won't play with you, but you're on your own. And immediately after getting out, well, not immediately, but in the years after getting out, he records many, many albums. Like in 87, he records five civil defense albums. You know, if you're reading these interviews and you're saying, oh, yeah, I was in the psych Ward, and then when I got out, like, nobody wanted to do anything with me. And I had to record these five albums on my own, you know, just playing each instrument and then, you know, mixing the tracks together by myself. [0:45:43] That's like, again, really elevates him beyond like any casual musician. [0:45:47] Yeah, he was very much a do-it-yourself type of guy. And of course, you know, a lot of do-it-yourself guys, their music just isn't that excellent, honestly. But like in this case, you know. [0:45:57] It's like very good music. And also this backstory on top of it, just like really, this is why he was basically the most famous underground punk musician of this period. But, I mean, we can't really blame the mother for like pulling the KGB on him. Because everybody was like extremely afraid of the KGB. You know, I'm pretty sure her thing was the KGB is going to find out about this and put all of them in prison. So if I do something now, maybe I can save my son. Even he says he was afraid like of the KGB pumping him full of truth serum. But after that experience and realizing that they don't have like magical powers, I think that's what really makes him get much more serious about his music. So he records five albums in 87, three in 88, and six in 1989. [0:46:44] Yeah, but it should be noted that these numbers are just for the output of Grazhdanskaya Oborona. He was also involved in many, many different side projects. [0:46:52] Yeah. So in the months immediately after getting out of the psych ward, he's obviously he doesn't have any of his old crew because they all had to sign like papers with the KGB saying they would never associate with him again. But he was still performing shows in people's apartments. You know, there was photos of him in this time, you know, performing in apartments. He also found a new crew where he performed a little bit of music with. And they record a couple albums. One of the albums was named Hospital, where they play some of the music of that album at the Novosibirsk Music Festival, which occurs in April 1987. So that's 13 months after he is let from the psych ward. [0:47:39] So, Novosibirsk Music Festival, let's get into that a bit. As I said earlier, you know, there was repression in like 84, and then there was regret a few years later. And this is a result of that regret where we're opening up again. We're allowed to have a music festival, and all these unofficial bands that were regulated to the sidelines level now are actually allowed to perform on stage for the first time in their music careers. So it was a big deal. But of course, there was still the bureaucracy telling them what they could and couldn't perform. And a couple of bands at the closing of this festival were basically denied by the bureaucracy. So somebody approaches Letov and says, hey, come on, you should perform in this music festival. You and Civil Defense perform. And not realizing that Kuzma is still in the army at this point. [0:48:31] So Civil Defense barely exists. But, you know, he does have these couple of guys that he was performing with. They have their album, Hospital, that they have songs from. So they, you know, say, okay, yeah, we're Civil Defense. Let's play. [0:48:46] And yeah, closing out the show, they get up on stage. They're all made up. They have a sort of not really corpse paint, but you know, that kind of like metal paint where the paint their face is white and then they add like black eyeliner and stuff. Looks nice. But yeah, get up on stage, turn off the guitars, and introduce themselves as Adolf Hitler. [0:49:11] Honestly, dudes rock. [0:49:12] This music from this band still kind of exists. I'll link a couple of songs in the show notes. Adolf Gittler, they would call it Adolf Gitter. The lyrics are also on genius.com. And earlier we said they wanted to show an equivalency between the Nazis and the Soviet Union. And it's like, once you read those lyrics, it's just like, no, they were just fucking around. Like, this is completely meaningless bullshit. [0:49:36] No, yeah, this is people trying to be very provocative. And it was very provocative. It's also worth noting, there are still, there are still veterans of the Great Patriotic War alive at this point. Like, there are still people who fought in Stalingrad. [0:49:51] Very, very, very many. Like, you know, a huge percent of the population were veterans. [0:49:56] Yeah, and everyone had lost an uncle or a brother or a father or a sister. Like, basically, there was no family left unaffected from the war. It was only 40 years later. [0:50:08] It's an insanely provocative thing to do. [0:50:11] I should say, a big thing about these festivals or just like live shows is KGB agents are like walking up and down the aisles and like making sure people don't go like stand up on stage, go nuts. It's like, again, like they're afraid of Beatlemania. You're not even allowed to like stand up and like go nuts at a music concert. So yeah, these guys on stage introduce themselves as Adolf Hitler playing music and you know people in the audience are very unsure of what to do now. I think eventually they just kind of like rage against it because yeah, as we say, like probably they realize at this point, oh shit, my uncle died in World War II and this is offensive. [0:50:51] Yeah, there's this really great moment when they finish their set when the festival organizer gets on stage and he basically says, hey, what the fuck are you doing? You know that there are people who are supposed to play after you, right? You're gonna ruin it for everyone else. Like, fuck off, get off stage. [0:51:59] This is again another thing that elevates him to mythical status: he did this stunt, and of course, the KGB was not too pleased with this. By some miracle, he was able to get back to Omsk from Novosibirsk without getting arrested immediately. Which is honestly insane. But he understood that, like, the KGB is coming for him at any second now. So, he took his shit, like, whatever money he had. He took this woman named Yanka, we'll get into it in a bit, and they just went around the Soviet Union for like a year. Yeah, like fugitives, you know, playing out wherever they could. [0:52:36] Yeah, and that's really when Letov flew to Stardom because that's when people started really distributing his tapes. Because, like, aside from the fact that the music itself is great, there's now this very powerful aura around this man. As in, like, oh, who was this brave guy who just dared to do something like this at a time when he had already been in a psychiatric hospital, like, he could very easily land there again, and yet he still felt bold enough to actually do this. [0:53:09] Yeah, and this was 30 months after he got out. So, again, he was, it didn't take very long for him to just forget all about that and just decide to like be a punk again. But, yeah, I mean, I'll quote him from his experience in this period. He says, They wanted to put me in a psychiatric hospital a second time, and Yanka and I were on the wanted list. We were on the run until December 87. Traveled all over the country, left among KPs, sang songs on the roads, ate what God sent, and stole food from bazaars. So, I had the experience of a wandering life in all its glory. Wherever we lived, in basements, abandoned carriages, and attics. In the end, thanks to the efforts of my parents, the search was stopped, and I was left alone. Moreover, a new stage of perestroika began, and no one needed dissidents anymore. [0:53:55] In a way, you could say that he was a wandering mendicant of sorts. I don't have the list of where he went in front of me, but he went as far as Ukraine. And so, yeah, he traveled very far from his home in Siberia. [0:54:08] Yeah, he went all over the country to Moscow, St. Petersburg, Tallinn, yeah, over the Baltics, Ukraine, you name it. [0:54:17] When he gets back, after this search for him ends, and he starts a side project that was him and Kuzma and their good friend Oleg Sudakov, who was just a friend at this point, but now he's a musician collaborator. And they released 14 albums in three years. So they record two in 88 and 10 in 89 and 2 in 90. So that's 31 albums between 1985 and 1990 for civil defense and communism. And again, it's not even 30 at this point. So any 20-somethings listening to this, you too can record 50 full-length albums before you hit 30. [0:54:59] Yeah, just do lots of drugs, get fucked up, get arrested, and the inspiration will come to you. [0:55:05] There was a guy who did release a song while he was on the run from the law. [0:55:08] It was a shitty song. [0:55:09] That's true. So that's actually a really good point. So that's the best way to think of Letov. He's not like a fascist or whatever. He's just the Russian version of Tay-K. [0:56:28] So you mentioned Yanka briefly. Let's get a little bit into her. She's not very important to our overall national Bolshevik story that we're doing, but she is a very good musician. And very important to Letov as a person. And I want to include a bunch of her songs in this episode's edit. [0:56:45] If you've seen Adam Curtis's HyperNormalisation, you've heard one of her songs. [0:56:49] Oh, cool. [0:56:50] If you've visited Massive Attack in Concert, you might have heard one of her songs. [0:56:54] She is very famous in a particular scene, and that is because her music is actually quite good. And also, she died very young. [0:57:02] And I believe she had no eyebrows, which was a cool look. [0:57:05] It adds to the mystique. [0:57:07] Yeah. She's a Siberian punk singer. She was not really involved in the Novosibirsk punk scene, but she was interested in it. And she meets Letov at the Novosibirsk Music Festival. I guess she liked him so much that she decided to run away with him, like after meeting him for a day and live the nomad life for a year. And they never officially get married, but in interviews, he says that they were essentially married. Just, you know, not officially. Yeah, they were together up until her death in 1991, where she dies at age 24, tragically. She's a great musician. She's arguably one of the most talented musicians from this punk scene, her and Letov. She doesn't have like as big as a catalogue as he does, but she has a couple of like solo albums are like worth listening to. And she also performs vocals on some communist tracks. [0:57:59] Communism being the name of a band, not communist tracks, as in, yeah, sorry, but yeah, I will link some of her music in the show notes to charoti on the shepherd's colour. [0:59:17] So, we haven't really delved into like specific lyrics so far. Let's try to get into that right now. So, is there a particular song you guys want to discuss? [0:59:27] Yes, I want to talk about everything's going according to plan or Russian Sam, pronounce it for me, please. This is a song that is kind of deeply ironic. It's it lets us he takes it from the point of view of an ordinary Soviet man, kind of talking about the state of the society at the time the song was written in 1988. [0:59:48] That is, this song was written not from my perspective, but from the perspective of a certain person who's not just tired. Let's say he comes home and starts banging on his table with his fist and singing what comes to mind, and the song is just that. [1:00:01] He means that in terms of the political, the political and economic state of the society at the time, essentially. [1:00:08] Yeah, the idea for the song came to him while he was watching television one evening in a really crappy mood, and he was just thinking about what a normie would be thinking for all intents and purposes. And the song is just that. It is from that perspective. [1:01:41] As you can hear from the audio, it's very like grating and angry and bitter. And you can hear that in his speech, even though you don't under if you're even if you don't understand Russian, which I don't for the record. But he basically talks about everything going according to plan in a very kind of sarcastic, bitter way. [1:02:01] He said, sorry, a verse I'd like to read. And they fed my wife to the crowds. With the fist of the world, they trampled in her chest. With worldwide liberty, they tore her flesh. So bury her in Christ, and everything shall go according to plan. Only our grandfather Lenin was a good leader. All the other ones are such shit. All the other ones are enemies and morons. Over bloody Russia falls a torrent of snow. Over the homeland, the land of our fathers, an insane snow is falling. So it's obvious. Only Lenin was a good leader. Everyone else is so full of shit. Everything fucking sucks now, but it's not questioning the fundamentals of the system, just the people running it. But it's just very bitter and angry. [1:02:43] There's a couple of mentions of Lenin throughout his songs that I've heard, and it does feel like, yeah, he has a fondness for Lenin. And as we've discussed previously in the episode, he is not an anti-communist. He's very much a communist and a leftist and has fondness for like the Russian Revolution and the Socialist Revolution in general, but very dissatisfied with the country. [1:03:09] I would say that he was more opposed to the bureaucratic state as it existed than the idea of the Soviet system. [1:03:15] Yeah, exactly. [1:03:16] But let me get more into the weeds here onto what this was actually like on a personal scale. So my family is from there, both my parents were born and raised there and educated there. And basically, like imagine the stuff that we hear in school about George Washington cutting down a cherry tree and talking about how he admitted to it because he could tell no lie. Like that's basically what the Soviet education system was giving to kids. And granted, they grew out of the Uncle Lenin stuff as they got older. But nevertheless, like this was something that was very much shoved down their throat. Like if you went to university, you had to take courses in Marxism-Leninism, for example, and you had to read a lot of Lenin. So in this environment where you're not really doing it because you want to do it, but rather because it's mandated, you're obviously going to come out of this with a very cynical attitude. [1:04:11] Yeah, although I will say people should read Lenin. Just you should read Lenin. [1:04:15] Oh, yes, absolutely. You should. You should. But when a system gets ossified and no one really believes in anything anymore and they're just going through the motions, there's going to be a lot of discontent. [1:04:27] This song is part of what got me into Grob, probably, I'd say early on in quarantine, I guess, and somewhere around that era, early 2020. Was there, I kind of listened and I looked at the lyrics and lyrics translate and started getting into a bit of an obsession about this stuff. And I kind of realized along the way that part of that was because there is a similar feeling of decay, I think, in American society today and the American state also. Not exactly the same as the Brezhnev era, Soviet Union, or the Gorby era, I guess is the two. But kind of just there is a general feeling of decay and things are getting shittier and people don't actually believe in these institutions anymore. And I kind of connected with that in his music a lot. And I think that's why also that is still relevant in Russia today, even if it's under a very different ruling system. [1:05:24] Which is why his music is still relevant in Russia today. [1:05:26] When we get communism, it'll be fucking great. It will come soon. We just gotta wait. Everything will be free there. It'll be like we're high. We probably won't even have to die. I woke up in the middle of the night and understood that everything is going according to plan. And this really captures the atmosphere because these people had grown up hearing that they're going to reach communism within their lifetime. Khrushchev, rather infamously in the 50s, said that communism would be constructed within 30 years. And so 30 years came and went, and things just seemed to be getting shittier. So there were a lot of jokes going around. [1:06:04] He was trying. [1:06:05] And of course, the song came out in 88. [1:06:08] So Soviet Union falls apart in just like a couple of years. And even when that happens, a lot of people weren't excited, but a lot of people kind of didn't give a shit, honestly. [1:06:19] Well, I would say that it was a very mixed feeling because on the one hand, like, it's important to understand that people on the ground absolutely did not want the dissolution of the Soviet Union. This is something that was wanted by the Communist Party elites because they realized that without the Soviet system in place, they would be able to get a lot richer and they'd be able to buy as many bananas and jeans as they wanted. They'd be able to get those fancy Mercedes. And they did. They were able to become as after the fall and the destruction of the Soviet Union, they were able to become as rich as their American and European counterparts. [1:06:51] Yeah. No, well, famously, yeah, Gorbachev sold out the USSR to Pizza Hut. [1:06:56] Yeah. [1:06:57] I mean, fucking Aliyev in, or brother Aliyev's father in Azerbaijan was a KGB guy. And yeah, lots of KGB guys everywhere. [1:07:05] Oh, yeah, I know. The KGB guys played a huge role in the breakup of the Union. [1:07:09] It's almost like security services tend to undermine the state sometimes. We would never have any other examples of that. [1:07:15] So again, the people on the ground did not want the free market hell that came afterwards. Their idea was more of a socialism with the human face, which is also something that Gorbachev was presenting as what perestroika would bring. Like, the idea wasn't that, oh, all of the national assets will be liquidated and your savings will be destroyed by inflation. The idea was we're going to have some reforms, we're going to have some more freedom of expression, we're going to have more active anti-corruption measures so that these factory bosses and party leaders weren't able to steal as much and then we can finally be a healthy, prosperous society on the path to development of socialism. [1:07:56] It's also worth noting that at this point, China is doing its own reform thing, and people in the Soviet Union are watching that and watching this happen in other places. So that is like that is part of the backdrop this is against. [1:08:09] Yeah, China kept the political reform aspect to a minimum and just focused on free market reforms. And which one is still around today? [1:08:17] The one that shouldn't be. [1:08:18] I'm gonna disagree with you there. [1:08:20] I mean, the one that should be around is Yugoslavia, but that's unfortunate. [1:08:23] They should all be around. [1:08:24] Hey, Yugoslavia was cool too. [1:08:26] No, hey. I'll always have a soft spot for Tito. Even if I shouldn't. [1:09:45] This is a song called Moya Oborona, which translates to My Defense. It came out in 1989. And Liam, why don't you read us a verse from that one? [1:09:53] All right. The plastic world has won. The mold turned out to be stronger. The last ship has gone cold. The last flashlight is tired. And clumps of memory are stuck in my throat. [1:10:04] So here we go. This idea of the plastic world, of an artificial world, is something that Letov keeps coming back through. This idea of this ossified Soviet bureaucracy that keeps alive the symbols of the revolutionary Soviet legacy while at the same time being just these decrepit old guys who really don't give a shit and who just want to live a good life without necessarily delivering on their promises to the wider population. [1:10:32] That's interesting because the way I would have read that is when he says the plastic world has won, I would assume America, because that is, I mean, even Americans call America the plastic world. [1:10:44] He very much saw America and the late USSR as two sides of the same coin. [1:10:48] Yeah, let me just read this quote from another interview he gave. [1:10:51] We were not at war with Soviet power per se. We fought against the manifestation of it, which existed at the moment. It had nothing to do with communism. That is, the Brezhnev regime had nothing to do with communism. This was state capitalism, the same mafia. These are the same people. [1:11:06] He's not wrong about the same people being in power. I mean, like, the last guy in charge of the Kazakh SSR was Nazarbayev, who was the president of Balkan Kazakhstan until like, I don't know, three years ago? Nazarbayev, who was, you know, I mean, country after country, it's the people who were presiding, who had power at the end of the union who retained power, political power at least. And that is something to be grappled with. [1:11:34] Yeah, the party by this point was very much rotten. Like by the time that you got to the higher echelons, like, first of all, people weren't joining out of conviction in communism. They were joining to get special privileges and goodies, and because for some occupations, you needed to be a party member. [1:11:51] We could talk about Musical Day, but I think we're going to leave it here. [1:11:56] Obviously, probably listen to a lot of music already edited out through this episode, and we'll have a link to all of those in the show description. But this concludes the music portion of this episode. Letov and Civil Defense continue on until he dies in 2008. But by 90, his creative peak is over. They didn't put out any music between 91 and 97. Letov has his own solo projects at that period, but he wasn't making punk music anymore. It was more like folk, psychedelic-inspired music. You know, much more laid-back. It wasn't like the same energy that you've probably heard throughout this episode. [1:12:39] Yeah, and he actually dissolved Grazhdanskaya Oborona in 1990 because he felt that it had gotten too commercialized, and he felt that that very much went against the spirit of his music. That he didn't want to just be a product, he wanted to be something that people deeply feel. And then it would reunite in 1993, from which point Letov would get really active in politics. And at that point, he saw it very much as a political vehicle, as something that would allow him to distribute his ideology on a much wider scale than just like writing articles or going to demonstrations in itself would be able to. [1:13:21] In between dissolving civil defense and then getting back together, the Soviet Union collapsed. And it was a big thing. It was on the news. Thing was like on CNN and shit. So we're not going to go too deeply in what happened there. Read a book, I guess. Or listen to the Radio War Nerd episode. [1:13:41] Yeah, but again, Soviet Union's bands and a bunch of punk bands from the scene that we mentioned previous kind of go their own separate ways because you know the markets were finally open up so a lot of people decided to just go into business and you know they had mixed success honestly most soviet people had mixed success because you know i i've heard that people who were over 40 or over 50 when the soviet union collapsed just never got accustomed to the new capitalist system i would say that most people were just thoroughly fucked like like their savings were liquidated they lost their jobs it was a hellscape yeah it was the it was a it was a societal collapse instructions for survival they were one of the bands that broke up to pursue a life in business and they were also a band that failed miserably and essentially just reformed the band as a way to like make money just doing you know what they knew which is be musicians and in 1993 they team up with letov and civil defense as part of his you know more political experiments and they form a concert or you know like a touring concert called russian breakthrough and this concert would eventually be the culture wing of the national bolshevik party so before we get into that clear up a couple of misconceptions so in researching with this episode and you know if you look up the wikipedia about the national bolsheviks you will see a couple things you'll see the list of founders, which are Edward Limonov, Alexander Dugin, and Yegor Letov. [1:15:21] And then when you go deep into it, it says Letov was given the Nazbol membership card, number four, signed by Edward Limonov. And you're thinking, well, how does that work? Was he like a founder? Was he a founding member? Like, what's the deal there? So he was a founding member, but like I said at the top of the episode, he was likely the most consequential founder. Because the idea to form a party that combines the extreme right and left, that was the idea of Limonov and Dugin. The idea to name it the National Bolsheviks, that was the idea of Dugin. The idea to form a punk newspaper called Limonka, that was like another mix of the two, but I think that was mostly Limonov if we're going to read between the lines. And the idea to get Letov and the punk scene involved was the idea of a third guy who was a friend of Limonov, but Limonov is the one who did it. [1:16:16] So this political project was already an idea that existed and was developed by these two guys, Limonov and Dugin. What Letov provided to the project was membership, because the overwhelming majority of members to the Nazbols in the first few years were fans of Letov, and they knew about the Nazbols because in this Russian breakthrough concert scene, every time Letov and Civil Defense performed, they had the banner of the National Bolsheviks in the back. And that's really what drove membership. Oh, and one last thing. The logo, the famous Nazbol logo, that was a design somebody made for one of Limonov's books. And he just decided we use that as the flag for the National Bolsheviks. Oh, and one last thing is: if you've seen photos of the Nazbols, they normally dress in all black. [1:17:11] Yeah. [1:17:11] And that came from Letov. I think. [1:17:14] The punk influence. [1:17:15] Yeah, one time Limonov just, or somebody just asked Letov why he always dresses in all black and just like, I don't know, it's like cheap, like cheap clothes or whatever. And then Limonov had the idea to make that the official uniform of the National Bolshevik Party. So that is another one of his main contributions to the party. [1:17:34] So I mentioned Alexander Dugin. He is the philosopher king of the National Bolshevik Party. And he's really the one who had the idea of like, we need to get these extremists to like form the party base. But he's also the most boring, honestly. So we're probably not going to discuss him very much. We're really going to discuss is Limonov because he is the cultural influence of the party, you know. He's the one who made it a punk party. He's the one who made the National Bolshevik Party newspaper Limonka, which is a very punk newspaper and a newspaper that Letov himself is not a huge fan of. I think in one I was reading Limonov's live journal because he had one of those. He's a very prolific blogger. But in his live journal, he recounts a time in the early days where Letov was displeased with the spelling mistakes in Limonka and saying, my fans, they're smart people. [1:18:37] They're not going to put up with this shit. So an early party split. And also, like, another split is, again, Letov is a communist. [1:18:47] And also, and also literally, fascists were like marching in the streets right beside him. And he was very uncomfortable with that for quite a while. [1:18:53] Well, he started calling himself a fascist at that point, actually. [1:18:56] Oh, really? This is an interesting thing. I mean, I want to get into that interview in just a second, but my impression is that at no point was Letov fully on board with this political project, but he made an effort to say he was on board in every single interview. But, you know, let's read some of his interviews. Sam, can you read that part? And yeah, all these interviews are going to be linked in the show notes below. [1:19:20] You are often associated with the fascists. Why is that? Because, if we're being honest, that's what we are. I consider us to be the communo-fascists. We present the most radical wing of the opposition. We are the Red Browns. Fascism is a very strong concept. It has not taken root as an ideology in the minds of the masses. Because what is fascism? In the public's consciousness, it is terror, no? No, not terror. Fascism is binding together. It is the same thing as communism. It is the primacy of society or the collective over the individual, everything we've always done. Me personally, I am not an individualist, nor am I an egoist. What they did in Germany, pardon me, was not the result of ideology, but of their national culture. Because an idea introduced somewhere is added to the culture of that place. If one was to condemn fascism, then one must also condemn Christianity because it birthed the Inquisition, the Reconquista, and so on. [1:20:09] Are you a nationalist? Yes, I am a Soviet nationalist. A Soviet nationalist? Yes, I think that over the 70 years of Soviet rule, a new nation emerged: the Soviet nation and the Soviet people. Everyone is now so mixed together that it is impossible to speak of nationalism. On my mother's side, I am descended from Cossacks, and on my father's side, I am a Buryat, the native son of the poorest peasants of the towns of the Urals. [1:20:33] You get the idea. [1:20:34] This is something that's very hard to parse because I'm just going to say this. I do not think you should take this as face value, as like what he genuinely believes. Because, on one hand, he is a punk. [1:20:46] A troll. [1:20:47] He is the guy who was the head of the band, Adolf Hitler, you know. So there is a level of punk irony to him and to the National Bolshevik Party in general. And of course, we understand from his contents of his lyrics that he is a genuine communist. So I'm pretty sure he's saying he's a fascist in this instance, either as shock value or because, you know, the mastermind Dugin basically just wrote some shit off and gave it to him. He's like, here's the party line. This is what you're going to be saying in interviews from now on. [1:21:19] I think that's part of it, but also there was the element of the fact that in the other interview, he says that when the house is burning, the first thing you've got to do is put out the fire. So essentially, he just wanted to create this image of unity between the communists and the fascists so they could get to the task at hand. And then later down the line, when the biggest threat is defeated, then they can settle matters between them. [1:21:41] Yeah. And I, as we said earlier, Roman Neumoev of the band Instructions Resurval, he himself was like a very right-wing reactionary guy. And he's also one of the co-founders of the Russian breakthrough concert movement. Letov is very comfortable with like having, you know, more right-wing people just be part of whatever political project he's doing, as long as it's against, you know, the bullshit the government is doing and not really of the Ren. [1:22:09] I mean, well, they killed all his kids, so never mind. I guess that's impossible. [1:22:13] There are descendants of the Romanov dynasty, and they fight amongst themselves who is the legitimate heir to the throne. [1:22:19] Yeah, there's some who claim, yeah, I mean, they intermarried with everyone in Europe. When you're that inbred and that intermarried with the rest of the European royal families, there's always some descendant somewhere. [1:22:29] But really, I mean, what I'm trying to say is, there is really no possibility of Roman Neumoev getting his monarchy reinstated. So it's perfectly fine to have a political concert movement with him because, you know, really what they're trying to do is just like resist capitalism. They're not really trying to do anything beyond that. [1:22:48] Although the trajectory of the movement shows you how well that works out. [1:22:52] Yeah. I mean, I should say, the Russian breakthrough movement, this is Letov's idea. And basically his entire idea was a protest concert, right? Like just protest capitalism, basically. He didn't really have any political ambitions, or he had like political ideas in mind, but he didn't have like very concrete ambitions. That came from Limonov and Dugin, who had this political party and basically said, your protest movement concert shit should be part of this political party because then, you know, people watching the concerts and feeling the energy will join the party and then that party will go on to attempt to like hold actual political power in the system. And it doesn't actually happen, but I mean, it's a good try. [1:23:38] It's a very interesting episode of recent history, either way, whatever you think about it. [1:23:42] And what do we think of this Red-Brown alliance thing in general? Like, how do we... [1:23:46] obviously it doesn't work out here but do we hold any ideas that maybe this could work out in some fashion no but it's very funny oh yeah no no no it's bullshit I think that it's clear that the the Nazbols were basically not a serious political movement, honestly. I think they had serious political motivations and energies, but it really seems like that their whole thing was just shock value beyond any actual attempt to unite fascism with communism. [1:24:15] Yes and no. I mean, they did actually become powerful in the streets in like the late aughts and early tens Russia. Like they in the like 10, 2010, 2011. [1:24:25] But were they actually trying to impose any kind of fascist order? It seems like... [1:24:31] I don't think they could have imposed anything, honestly. It was kind of that there was just a huge vacuum and they were the only people there to fill it, kind of. Who weren't just complete, you know, I mean, there's dweebs like Navalny and other people like that. [1:24:44] Although he was on the nationalist side then, especially. [1:24:47] Well, here's a question. Well, here's something that I really want to get. In the landscape of Russian politics in the early 90s, how important were the Nazbols really? Were they more prominent than the communists? Were they more prominent than the actual fascist Nazis on the street? [1:25:02] The KPRF was the second biggest party. [1:25:04] Yeah. [1:25:05] But the idea was more to be a sort of cultural vanguard rather than to actually directly seize power. And that's actually why Dugin split with the party, because he wanted to work behind the scenes to actually have influence rather than doing all this performative straight stuff and just harassing government ministers. [1:25:29] Yeah, no, Dugin is an actual right-wing ideologue, and he didn't, like, this was an art project, essentially, in his eyes, especially. [1:25:36] I should say, if you look up Alexander Dugin on Wikipedia, his Wikipedia page says a featured article in fascism. [1:25:44] Okay, yeah. [1:25:44] But if you look at his Russian article, because, you know, there's a huge stigma against calling people fascists there, that's not there. But the English editors of Wikipedia certainly think he's a fascist. [1:25:55] I think he's right about the Lithuanian problem. [1:25:58] We're not going to get into that at this episode. [1:26:00] Okay. [1:26:00] This is my view of Red-Brown Alliance stuff: where he says in an interview, I am a Soviet nationalist. I am not an ethnic nationalist, essentially. And that's the fundamental problem with the left-wing attempt at nationalism: so often than not, there is an ethnicity attached to the idea of the country. And then that leads to negative things. [1:26:26] Like, yeah, absolutely. And of which there was plenty of in Russia, especially there was an enormous problem of Russian chauvinism within the Communist Party. The idea of this alliance was to tear down the edifice of the Russian capitalist state, as I said before, and then from there to work towards your own goal. [1:26:46] A reading between the lines of what Letov says in that other interview about this Red-Brown Alliance: when your house is on fire, the first thing you do is put it out. Like, the implication there is that there's going to be a civil war after this government is gone, and that's when we really settle the differences between ourselves. But of course, if you know that's always on your mind, then there's a very good chance that people are going to jump the gun and try to settle those differences before civil war or the revolution happens. [1:27:16] Also, civil war in Russia in the 90s was not unthinkable. [1:27:20] Certainly after 93. [1:27:21] No, especially with like, yeah, tanks in the streets, you know, in the stopping the attempted KGB coup. And I mean, tanks in the streets in fucking 93 and the the you know the the successful coup, the Yeltsin coup. And, I mean, civil wars in many surrounded countries, Tajikistan, for example. [1:27:41] Yeah, yeah yeah and in a sense, there are arguably was, because you could say that what was going on in chechnya yeah yeah of course there no there was chechnya i mean and there were other separatist movements that didn't get nearly as far of course there was yeah and of course all of yugoslavia's shit was going down yeah no it's a very there was it was very unstable it took really until putin to build something stable in the new russia not good but stable at least as stable as an inherently unstable system like capitalism can be managed as stable as and you won't wake up one morning and find out that your bank account is basically five dollars when you had five thousand dollars before yes exactly the currency has worth has value the currency has value the trains run on time kind of well the moscow metro trains to their credit do run on time very punctual perfect absolutely perfect and stunning stations I'm I wasn't sure how to translate ass idiomatically into English in that context. [1:29:39] Like to be in the ass is to be fucked. Or Liet. It's yeah. I mean that's one of the that's one of the songs. We're in a deep ass. That's the second song on Necrophilia. This is one of the most tragic songs I have ever composed. The song is about how the homeland rises from its knees, which in fact does not exist, which not only is not rising from its knees, but which gets deeper and deeper into an unprecedented ass of a situation. Tighter and all the more hopeless. When a handful of people were firing back while they were being hit by tank shells, everyone thought that we would win. The albums are about this, in fact. When a person is completely lost, he sings of how he won and wins. The people, it seems to me, still do not understand anything. [1:30:19] Yeah, so this song, Rodina, was written in November of 1993 when the coup that Yeltsin launched happened in October. So this was very much an immediate reaction. And what he's talking about there is how the Russian parliament literally got shelled with the tanks and there were snipers targeting people on the street just killing random people. [1:30:45] It was a coup. It was an actual coup. [1:30:48] Yeah, exactly. [1:30:49] But again, we won't go too deep into it. Just listen to the Radio War Nerd episodes on it to really hear the episode, hear this episode done historic justice. [1:30:59] So the song itself, Liam, would you do the honors? [1:31:03] I see my motherland rising up from its knees. I see my motherland rising from the ashes. I hear my great motherland singing. My motherland is once again rising up from its knees. My epic nation is unbending its back. Our wrathful power is moving apart the walls. The sun calls us to follow it on campaign against deadly cold, against pitch black night. I'm not very good at poems, so my translation is probably not as it doesn't convey the full beauty. [1:31:31] Well, we can see, no, it's fine. We can see that it's very clear nationalistic statement, which is why it's quite interesting that the nationalism, as we've talked about, is not Russian nationalism, but Soviet. He says it in many verses of the song. And I think this is really what separates him from other people who were associated with the Nazbol movement, and by other people, I mean, Dugin. [1:31:56] Honestly, when countries falling apart, I feel like everybody's a patriot because, you know, it's one thing to say your country's shit when it is shit, but it's another thing when the country's actually falling apart right in front of you. And just like, oh my god, no, I actually do love this country. As terrible as it is to live here, I do love this country and I do want a better future for it. And just seeing like all that hope just disintegrate in front of you. [1:32:20] Yeah, I mean, the last verse of the song is: let me just read it real quick. I see my motherland rising from its knees. I see my motherland rising from the ashes. My motherland fiercely blazes inside me. I hear my Soviet motherland sing. [1:32:34] So you can hear my Soviet motherland. It's very specifically his Soviet motherland. He's from Siberia, and Siberia borders Kazakhstan. And at this time, Kazakhstan is a separate country. [1:32:48] Yeah, and in fact, he was born in Kazakhstan. [1:32:50] But yeah, he was born in a place that is no longer his country. And that's gotta be. [1:32:55] So, while he was definitely, in my opinion, the most consequential member, and this political project probably would have fallen apart without his input, because I really don't see any way for national Bolsheviks of just Dugin and Limonov to get anywhere near the kind of membership they would need to continue doing this thing for however many years they did it. But, you know, after that, after being so important in the founding of this party, he decides to leave after a few years because he decides to endorse the communist candidate. And the national Bolsheviks go a different route. My memory's a little fuzzy on this. So, Russian Sam, can you catch us back up on what happens here? [1:33:43] Yeah, so at this point, the Russian Communist Party is led by this fellow named Gennady Zyuganov. [1:33:50] It still is. [1:33:50] Yeah, he's still there. [1:33:51] Yeah, it still is. [1:33:52] That decrepit old piece of shit. [1:33:55] What have the gerontocracy ever done a bad thing for the Communist Party in Europe? Or anywhere else for that matter? [1:34:03] So Zyuganov, he was sort of very much a middle-of-the-road man in the Communist Party. He was very much against perestroika, but he also didn't occupy a very high position. He was in the Moscow city council when the breakup of the Soviet Union happens and there's no longer a Soviet Communist Party. He reconstitutes the Communist Party of the Russian Federation. And so he's not really that serious in terms of opposition. But nevertheless, he's still a symbol of he's basically the return to tradition guy. Not in a bad way. In 1996, you have the elections happen in Russia for the post of presidency. And Yeltsin is in very, very deep shit. His approval rating is like 2%. As I said, the economy has gone down the drain under his tenure. And as a result of that, and this noticeable decline in people's living condition is compounded by the fact that the man is a total buffoon. [1:35:14] As in, like, he was a total alcoholic. He was always getting drunk at public meetings. One time when he was visiting Washington, D.C., they found him wandering the city in his underwear. [1:35:26] Famously, yeah, yeah. Looking for pizza, yeah. [1:35:29] Yeah, there's also a lot of news footage of like him standing next to Bill Clinton, just archive version. It's very obvious he's drunk. [1:35:36] Visibly drunk. [1:35:37] Yeah, yeah. [1:35:38] If anyone's seen the recent movie Another Round, the whole segment where they pause just for footage of drunken Yeltsin. [1:35:44] Yeah, so very unpopular fellow. But there was a man in America, a man by the name of Bill Clinton. [1:35:51] Was there ever? [1:35:52] Who was a friend of our dear friend Yeltsin? And Yeltsin was able to secure a huge amount of aid, like to the tune of hundreds of millions of dollars directly, so people's salaries could get paid. People weren't getting paid for months because there wasn't any money in the coffers. And on top of that, the oligarch-aligned media was able to really whip up a storm against Zyuganov and to say that if he were elected, there would be a rerun of the Stalinist purges and the country would be flung into civil war and it's going to get even worse than it is now. So, despite the fact that Zyuganov was the frontrunner for a while, Like, funnily enough, like everyone thought it was a done deal to the extent that in 1996 he went to the IMF meeting as the presumptive president of the Russian Federation because everyone thought that he would be the guy who was running the show. [1:36:56] But our comrades, the Americans, with tons of input from the local oligarchs who had made it big under Yeltsin's regime, were able to pull up his polling numbers and he was able to win a very slim majority. So, what happened, getting back to the main story with Letov, is that he supported Zyuganov's candidacy in 1996. I guess he was sort of the lesser of two evils guy by that point, while the other members of the NBP just saw him as controlled opposition and that, first of all, he would not be allowed to win, which he wasn't. And second of all, even if he was allowed to win, he's a wet blanket. Nothing is going to fundamentally change. [1:37:39] After he breaks up with NBP, he kind of goes back to music and just loses all hope with politics in general. In interviews, he describes himself as apolitical at that point, and he goes on to describe his time with NBP as a deeply embarrassing time and just how stupid politics is, and how you really have to get involved in it to understand just how stupid and pointless it all is. But he still makes music, and he still, you know, holds these, you know, communist beliefs, but they're not as front and center as they were in the 80s when he was a radical punk, and in the 90s when he was a founder of a radical political party. So let's discuss his later career. [1:39:28] In 2001, he released the album called Zvezdopad, or Starfall. And that one is mostly covers of Soviet folk songs and World War II songs, some songs from movies, that kind of stuff. So it wasn't really original, but it's it's great. And his sonic style has shifted completely now. As I said before, in the 90s, he was doing more psychedelic folk projects on the side, and now at this point, this is basically what he's doing full-time. So, no more punk, really. I mean, he still plays punk songs at shows, but his new material is much more psychedelic inspired and just less angry. [1:40:13] Yeah, I would say that Letov in the 80s has a meth vibe, whereas Letov in the 2000s has a mushrooms vibe. [1:40:20] Letov in the 80s himself looks like he's on heroin. [1:40:23] He very well might have been. [1:40:25] I mean, he probably was. [1:40:26] Yeah, and then his final album was really very much psychedelic. It was Zachem Snyatsya Sny, or Why Do We Have Dreams? And that was the final album that was actually released. [1:40:42] He passes away in 2008 at 43 years old. [1:40:47] He was never really in good health. [1:40:48] No, but which honestly, it's a little bit later than the period we're talking about, but that seems to be kind of a pattern in post-Soviet Russia. Just a severe drop in life expectancy that, from what I understand, has never really been recovered. [1:41:04] It has been reversed, but it has not gone back to where it should be. [1:41:08] I believe it dropped to 57 or 50, yeah, for men, probably, I think, in the mid-90s. [1:41:14] Yeah. [1:41:14] In his later life, Letov had a lot of trouble escaping his NBP phase because, you know, he described himself as a fascist in interviews. And he was part of a party that everybody considered a fascist party. So, you know, it was a whole thing. I mean, I think he was banned from some countries forming, like Estonia and Latvia, I think it was. [1:41:38] Oh, those aren't real countries anyway. [1:41:39] Of course, again, the NBP. [1:41:42] Yeah, and of course, he also had a lot of fascist fans to his death. You know, it's a very tragic end. It's a real shame because he was somebody who was like an incredible musician and very politically motivated. But it's very unfortunate that he ended up hitching his wagon to something that was so stupid that was honestly just gonna like make his life miserable no matter what. [1:42:05] Yeah, he's a fascinating cultural figure, a problematic fave, I suppose, of mine. But his decision to affiliate with the NBP and describe himself as a fascist and do things like go on stage as Adolf Hitler, or a band naming calling itself Adolf Hitler, certainly makes it hard to tell people to check out his music sometimes. [1:42:29] Yeah, but again, this stuff has a very different resonance in the Russian context than it would in the American context. That's something that also needs to be explained to people. [1:42:40] He lives on. He's still a very popular, famous musician. His popularity has skyrocketed to where it was in the 90s, even. Like, you'll see people wearing shirts with his face on it, and he's just... [1:42:55] And it's finally okay to talk about him in a reverent tone in Russian media. So you have a lot of articles praising him on his anniversary and whatnot, and he really left a founding mark. But a lot of the political content of his songs was stripped out. It's no longer about communism per se, but now it's just a general mark of rebellion against Putin. [1:43:23] Yeah, and even his involvement with NBP is kind of sanitized at times. Studying for this episode, we watched a couple of documentaries, Russian documentaries, I think both released around 2014. In those, the NBP doesn't come up a lot. And even I watched some other stuff and Russ himself in... It's kind of like a footnote. For whatever reason, people are just... They would rather remember him as a musician. [1:43:47] Speaking of his popularity going to new heights, there was an effort to try to get his name as the name of the Omsk airport, which unfortunately didn't go through. I guess somebody on the committee to rename the thing kind of vetoed that as one of the online suggestions. But yeah, still a lot of love for him in his hometown. [1:44:10] Yeah, and his apartment is now a museum. [1:44:12] Yeah, so to close out the airport saga, after the committee refused to rename the Omsk airport in his honor, there was a small, like an even smaller regional airport in Popovka, which became the Letov Airport. But that was actually closed in 2019 because it turned out that the owner was illegally using agricultural land as a runway, which is... [1:44:37] Welcome to Russia. [1:44:38] Well, I think that's going to do it for this episode on Yegor Letov. The strange life and sad death of one of the weirdest people in... [1:44:46] You could say one of the strangest people in modern history, I feel like, at least in terms of musicians. [1:44:50] One of the strangest musicians I've ever known. [1:44:52] Yeah, definitely. [1:44:53] Yeah, yeah, yeah. Obviously, a lot of musicians have, like, you know, participated in stuff like Ozzfest, right? Or just, you know, concerts about AIDS and stuff. You know, stuff that has a political tint. And, you know, some of them endorse political candidates. That's like a big thing all the time. But none of them found a political party and encouraged their fans to join said political candidates. [1:45:16] Absolutely. You know, like, say you will, say what you will about the Nazbols, but it's kind of funny to compare them to the much more impotent association of countercultural music in like the 60s and 70s. How, like, you know, it's American rock stars really thought they were going to end the war in Vietnam. And guess what? Protest songs don't do shit. [1:45:35] Yeah, Letov says, I think that Russian rock has always been different from your rock. In the West, rock was popular music, that is pop music, an attribute to mass culture. While in Russia, it was a religion. It's more than music. It's more than rock in and of itself. Our rock has always been religious. It's the music of revolt. For us, that is our rock groups. It is war. It is revolt. It is a constant process of overcoming, with the help of which we break through from an esoteric and metaphysical point of view to the other side. In terms of style, every restyling is a small revolution. [1:46:07] And I feel like that's great note to leave off on. Thanks for listening. [1:46:11] Yeah. And hey, thanks. Thanks to Russian Sam for these incredible translations. [1:46:15] Yeah, seriously, these are very good. [1:46:17] You can add a lot of shitty translations for Letov online. [1:46:20] Well, I gotta serve the people and the national Bolshevik cause. [1:46:23] Thanks to Sam for that. Thank you for listening. I'm Abram. I was joined by Russian Sam, Liam, and Halal Sam. You can find all our ads in the description if you want to follow us on Twitter. And this was Gladio Free Europe. [1:46:35] Yeah. [1:46:35] And we'll see you guys soon. [1:46:37] Yada bye. [1:46:38] Later.