Gladio Free Europe, E2: The Wind That Shakes the Barley (with James) https://www.gladiofreeeurope.com/episodes/the-wind-that-shakes-the-barley [0:00:20] And we're back with another episode of Gladio Free Europe. I'm Halal Sam, and with me I have Liam and Russian Sam. And we've got a very special guest with us today. We have James here. [0:00:31] Hi, James, Dominized or whatever. [0:00:36] And we're here with a very special episode, I would say. [0:00:39] That's right. We watched the 2006 Ken Loach movie, The Wind That Shakes the Barley. This kind of epic story of Irish independence and civil war. And we're here to give our lovely takes on it. [0:00:54] We're here to talk about the Irish question. [0:00:56] Exactly. [0:00:57] So yeah, first question to you, James. The Irish. Do they, we, deserve rights? [0:01:04] I would say we perhaps deserve more rights. [0:01:08] Well, what if I were to propose a modest proposal? [0:01:11] Oh, oh. [0:01:13] I like that. [0:01:15] We Irish are known for being very tasty. [0:01:17] I don't know. They seem kind of underfed. [0:01:19] Oh, well, in this movie, yes, in fact, they are. [0:01:23] Yeah, yeah. Well, hey, before we get into the movie, James, you are someone that I've been following on Twitter for a pretty long time now. You're a very fun account. You post a lot about a lot of stuff. I was wondering that because Irish history is a pretty big interest of yours, I was wondering if you could share how you got into that, how that started with you, what attracts you to the history of Ireland. [0:01:48] Sure. I mean, my family's all from all, you know, good Irish Catholics from New England. So, therefore, you know, as a kid, I was told, you know, we're Irish, and then, you know, maybe there'll have been a little thing that says like Erin go Bragh on it or something, right? You know, some classic, you know, home decor. It wasn't really until high school when I, you know, when I was about when I was like 15 or 16, when I started actually, you know, reading into it. And reading into it at that time, you know, was kind of experiencing a political awakening. I was, you know, reading books for the first time. And, you know, I found a figure that I just really threw him. Everything just kind of clicked into place. [0:02:35] James Connolly. Just everything about Ireland clicked in with him. Like, I was a kid who bought a goddamn Starry Plough and made and made my parents fly it out on Easter Sunday. Yeah, I was a cool kid, you could say. [0:03:00] Yeah, and how much about that is because his name is also James? [0:03:05] You know what? It's the best name. It does come from, I will say, it does come from the Hebrew, you know, one who supplants, one who overthrows, you know, Hakolis or whatever. [0:03:21] It does, and it's very relevant to James Connolly. Sadly, you know, Connolly was dead and buried by the time that this movie gets started, but he was just such an important figure in just the history of Ireland. It's, you know, because like it really seems like so much of the anti-treaty side that we'll get into was really about trying to affirm his vision of what Ireland should be. [0:03:44] Yeah, I mean, there is, you know, there is the character who's basically a stand-in for the Connolly generation, if you want to call it. [0:03:53] No, probably the best character in the movie. [0:03:55] Oh, absolutely. [0:03:56] Certainly the most intelligent character. [0:03:58] But yeah, Connolly's legacy. I mean, you know, a couple of years back, like RTE or I believe it was RTE did a poll of, you know, the 100 greatest Irishmen. And, you know, when they do that in Britain, it's always, you know, fucking Churchill. [0:04:15] Yeah, Churchill, Oscar Wilde. [0:04:18] The greatest Englishman, I see him. [0:04:19] Yeah, the BBC did a poll, yeah. [0:04:21] Yeah. God, no, Churchill, as characters that note in this movie, was not a popular man. Yeah, sorry. I believe in fourth place in the RTE poll of Greatest Irishmen was James Connolly. So his shadow and his legacy loom over Ireland incredibly much today, as I can get into later. [0:04:43] You know, tragically, numbers one, two, and three were Bono and then the two guys from Oasis. [0:04:51] Yeah, and they're still mad about, you know, who got to be two and who got to be three. [0:04:58] Those damn Gallaghers. [0:05:01] You know, his legacy looms so much that, you know, today one of the largest Communist organizations in Ireland, for youth anyway, is the Connolly Youth Movement. You know, there are people who definitely see, you know, his Republic of 1916 as what they're fighting to preserve. [0:05:22] If you don't mind me asking, you have had some encounters with the Connolly Youth Movement, right? [0:05:27] Encounters is a strong word, but I've talked to a couple online. Yeah, they're good people, good people. I would highly suggest anyone interested in the communist movement as it exists in Ireland today to definitely check them out and keep an eye on them. [0:05:47] I think that what I'm just so much love with this movie as a film, but what I like politically about it is that it's one of the only mainstream accounts that really gets into the socialist elements of the Irish emancipatory struggle, which still to some extent exists today. I think that Americans who might have some like token support for Irish independence or even for the IRA in more recent years either downplay or totally misunderstand the extent to which Irish independence is often a socialist struggle. [0:06:17] I mean, they were fighting the premier reactionary power in the fucking world, the British Empire, like the bastion of reaction in Europe. [0:06:25] Yeah, I mean, you know, Mayor Lindsay in New York in 1969, you know, was shocked when he gave the key to the city to Bernadette Devlin. And then she said, you know, go fuck yourself and give it to the Black Panthers, you know? People don't, yeah, Americans have this, and part of it, I would think, is just not only American, but also Irish media in the Republic of Ireland. I mean, how that government has tried to present the image of itself, which is an image of, you know, idyllic hills, a simple country life. You know, nothing too intelligent going on is basically how they kind of portray themselves. [0:07:20] Yeah. Well, it's like there was a guy, Peter King, the congressman from Long Island, until like this year, who was a Republican, but also a supporter of the other Republicans. [0:07:30] I know. And you know what? [0:07:32] Critical support to the Republican Party. [0:07:34] Political spectrum of Irish nationalism goes from Peter King to Gaddafi. Like, that's amazing. [0:07:39] Yeah, it's a wilderness. [0:07:42] Which are, when you really think about it, that is a Ben Shapiro is. [0:07:47] I might have to, hmm, I might have to rethink that boy. [0:07:52] Yeah, no. And I mean, that's true not only internationally support of the IRA, but, you know, as we can talk about later, even within the Republican movement, it's not a. Many, many people will try to claim, oh, it's inherently a socialist movement, oh, it's inherently, you know, a Catholic movement, you know, inherently a nationalist movement, whatever you want to say about it. It's very. When you actually get into it, it is a very varied movement. [0:08:21] Right, yeah, absolutely. And just like with the Gallaghers themselves, there's a lot of brother against brother, as we'll see. [0:08:29] Exactly, you know, a lot of Irish people with a lot of different opinions. Yeah, and, you know, Noel and Liam, you know, divided over Corbyn. Liam loves him. Noel heard that Liam likes something and decided he hates it. [0:08:45] Yeah. [0:08:46] Well, yeah, I guess we should get into the movie, but I wanted to give a little bit of context before we get into the story. Just that this movie is set in 1920, which is really pretty far into the independence struggle. Because, you know, obviously, Britain had had some degree of influence over Ireland for like 700 years. But the really big event preceding this was 1916, the Easter Rising. And, you know, the people who, as we find out later, a character in the movie is someone who participated in the Easter Rising. And so that generation of men, they were older now, but they were still there and they were still, you know, they were still around. [0:09:29] Let's maybe recap what the Easter Rising was for listeners who might not be aware of it. [0:09:33] Oh, absolutely. Yeah. 1916, led by James Connolly, Patrick Pearse, and others, an independent Irish Republic was declared. The GPO, the post office was occupied. Some people involved were Tom Clarke, James Connolly, Constance Markievicz, Eamon de Valera, Michael Collins. And excuse me. So they attempted to create a socialist independent republic and were immediately shelled by the British military from massive cannons on ships that they had sailing into Dublin just absolutely demolished them. Connolly shot dead in a chair because they beat him so much that he couldn't even stand to be executed. Just real brutal, brutal stuff, yeah. [0:10:32] Yeah. It essentially wiped out a generation of leaders. You know, and the ones who survived, like most notably Valera and Collins, and also, you mentioned Constance Markievicz. They were there to put the pieces back. [0:10:46] Do we maybe want to read some excerpts from the proclamation because it rules? [0:10:50] Oh, yeah, go ahead, Russian Sam, please. [0:10:53] Irishmen and Irishwomen, in the name of God and of the dead generations from which she receives her old tradition of nationhood, Ireland, through us, summons her children to her flag and strikes for freedom. Having organized and trained her manhood through our secret revolutionary organization, the Irish Republican Brotherhood, and through her open military organizations, the Irish Volunteers and the Irish Citizen Army, having patiently perfected her discipline, having resolutely waited for the right moment to reveal itself, she now seizes that moment. And supported by her exiled children in America and by gallant allies in Europe, but relying in the first on her own strength, she strikes in full confidence of victory, we declared the right of the people of Ireland to the ownership of Ireland and to the unfettered control of Irish destinies to be sovereign and indefeasible. The long usurpation of that right by a foreign people and government has not extinguished that right, nor can it be extinguished except by destruction of the Irish people. [0:11:45] I love the little shout out to Irish Americans. You know, if only they knew what we would become. [0:11:49] God, I can't remember the name of it. I believe the official name was like the Holland 3. It was, I believe it was Ancient Order of Hibernians, was the one who commissioned it. It was a tiny one-man submarine. [0:12:02] The Fenian Ram. [0:12:03] That's what they call it. Yeah. [0:12:05] This is news to me. [0:12:07] Yeah, in the Northeast U.S., this, you know, Irish guy in America decided that he was going to build and design a one-man submarine that could be used to ram into British ships to help. [0:12:21] Oh my god, that's so cool. [0:12:23] Yeah. [0:12:23] Irish excellence. [0:12:25] You know what? That is Irish Excellence. [0:12:28] Irish Boy Magic, building your own submarine. [0:12:32] Yes, this is absolutely going to be an Irish boy summer, especially with what's been popping off lately. [0:12:37] We have a no-current events rule, so we're not going to talk about that. [0:12:41] Instead, I want Halal Sam to talk to us about Eamon de Valera. [0:12:46] Him being an American basically saved him. His father was Spanish, possibly Cuban, which I think is, which I like to believe because that's more fun. But he grew up basically in Ireland, and it seems kind of like he was such a staunch nationalist, you gotta wonder if he thought he had something to prove. And he was also born out of wedlock, which is kind of a big deal if we're talking about Irish people back in those days. We're talking about the Catholic Church, I mean. [0:13:10] Yeah, oh, yeah. [0:13:11] Well, you know, one important event that we haven't talked about, which is really relevant here, is World War I, because this was really the backdrop of the Easter Rising. The big question in Ireland was: are the Irish going to start to be conscripted? Because the war wasn't going amazing for any side, really. And what happened in 1918 was that the Germans had this sudden new offensive, and the British started bleeding a lot. So the British made this pretty insane proposal to Ireland. You guys know what the proposal was? [0:13:42] Yeah, it was the Conscription Act of 1918, which passed, but was never really implemented because the uproar in Ireland itself was so strong. [0:13:50] Yep. So what happened, basically, what they said was, we will give you home rule, which was sort of, which was a very vague phrase that meant potential either independence or some kind of a dominion status that we'll get into later. But the condition was, but we're going to conscript you. And there was an immediate outcry to this. And this is what led to in 1918, you had the, I'm going to say it wrong, so James, please correct me, but the Dail Eireann was formed? [0:14:19] Yeah, the Dail Eireann. [0:14:22] Dail Eireann, thank you. [0:14:23] And we have to get when we're speaking. [0:14:28] The Dail Eireann was the secret first Congress, essentially, of Ireland. What happened was that in the 1918 parliamentary elections, Ireland could vote. So they voted for the pro-independence party, Sinn Féin, which of course still exists today. And then all the Sinn Féin members said, fuck Britain, we're not going to declare, we're not going to take part in any British Assembly, we're going to form our own independent assembly. And so they, following the leadership of the failed Easter Rising two years before, the members of the Dail Eireann proclaimed, or you could say, reaffirmed the Irish Republic. [0:15:05] And also, it's important to note that Sinn Féin had a blowout victory. They won 73 seats out of the 105 seats. [0:15:12] Absolutely, yeah. [0:15:13] Yeah. [0:15:14] And I was just going to ask: can anybody guess? Only one country in the world gave any recognition to this new Irish Republic that was declared. Can anybody guess who it was? [0:15:25] Germany? [0:15:25] No? Think about the year. This is 1918. [0:15:28] It wasn't Iraq, was it? [0:15:30] No, it was the Soviet Union. The early USSR. [0:15:33] Of course. The early USSR was the only government to recognize the independent Ireland. [0:15:38] I mean, that's unsurprising for a number of reasons. [0:15:42] It's also worth noting that the policy of not giving any legitimacy to British parliaments and not sitting in them is still continued by Sinn Féin today. [0:15:49] Yeah, yeah, kind of based. Yeah. [0:15:52] I would say quite based. [0:15:54] Yeah, they've kept that policy for fucking a hundred years. [0:15:57] And yeah, so then basically after this happens, the IRA is formed and war is formally declared against the British. And really soon after war is declared, war ends on the continent. And as soon as World War I ends, you have tens of thousands or maybe hundreds of thousands of British troops coming back home. But they weren't allowed to rest because instead, you had very many of these troops being given new uniforms and sent to Ireland. And what color were the new uniforms? Black and tans. That's right. [0:16:32] I have a question, actually. Were these, were any colonial troops sent into Ireland to quell the rebellion, or was it just British troops? [0:16:40] Oh, no, no, absolutely not. That would have been terrible optics to have colonial soldiers putting down the Irish rebellion. And also, I'm sure the British didn't really trust these colonial troops to actually carry out the mission because I'm sure Indian troops would have felt a large degree of sympathy. [0:16:55] They trusted them at the Somme. [0:16:56] Sure, but that was in the direct war. That wasn't putting down a different colonial uprising. [0:17:02] That's true. [0:17:03] Yeah, you don't want to give them any ideas. [0:17:04] Yeah, and also, like, the British refused to recognize this as a war. The entire time their refrain was that, oh, this is a mutiny. This is an uprising. Which is very reminiscent of in India during the so-called mutiny there or the quote-unquote emergency in Malaysia. This refusal to admit that they are at war against the people. [0:17:23] Yeah, yeah. And one important backdrop to all of this is that there were rebellions breaking out all throughout the British Empire in like 1918, 1919. In 1920, of course, you had the Iraqi revolt, which is mentioned in the song, Come Out, You Black and Tans. And there was also unrest in India at this time, too, in the immediate aftermath of World War I. [0:17:45] Yeah, so in 1919, you also had the Jallianwala Bagh massacre in Punjab, which is an absolutely infamous event. If it's like one of the things that you know about British India, where basically a peaceful demonstration was happening in this garden, and so the British commander ordered his troops to open fire, and at least 300 people were murdered. Thousands were injured. [0:18:09] That's worse than anything in Ireland. [0:18:12] Because we all know that the British would never open fire in a peaceful demonstration in Ireland again. [0:18:18] Oh, yeah, well, yeah, well, let's go back to Ireland. [0:18:21] I think it's time we get into the movie. [0:18:24] So, The Wind That Shakes the Barley starts right now. It starts immediately after World War I with thousands of black and tans being sent to Ireland. These were World War I veterans who were not exactly soldiers, probably accordance to the policy of not recognizing the Irish Civil War or the Irish War of Independence as a war. They were actually police, which is interesting. So, they were British Army soldiers folded into the local Irish police. And the movie begins with a game that I thought was hockey, but I have been informed is something called hurling. [0:18:58] You know what? That actually gets to my point: about I'm going to start telling the truth about hurling, Boston hockey, and epigenetic memory fire. Let's in. Call me Dr. Peterson because I'm about to get into some psychology. But no, hurling, hurling as a sport is, you can think of it like definitely hockey or field hockey, you know, a similar sense in that it's you're knocking about a ball with these curved hurleys, the sticks. And it definitely was seen as a particularly good game for Irish nationalists to promote because it was an Irish game, it was a very old Irish game. Rather than simply just playing soccer, you know, it was a way in order to not only have young men exercise, you know, just give kids a game to play, but also one that you could use as a jumping off point to instill pride in Irish nationalism. [0:20:06] Yeah, like playing this game was in some of the sort of a political statement, as the movie shows. [0:20:11] Oh, most certainly. Yeah, yeah. [0:20:13] And so the big thing here is that there's been some kind of order banning demonstrations of Irish men. [0:20:18] Defense of the Realm Act. [0:20:20] Yes, Defense of the Realm Act. [0:20:21] Yeah, banned all public meetings in Ireland, especially. Yeah. Yeah. [0:20:26] And the interesting thing about the Defense of the Realm Act is that it was actually passed in 1914 as a war measure. So in other words, they just invoked this thing that was supposed to be a temporary emergency in the context of a global war. And now they're just using it to harass teenagers playing hurling. [0:20:48] Even though they wouldn't even recognize the situation as a war. [0:20:52] And no other government would ever use a World War I era measure in order to repress its citizenry. The Espionage Act, as we all know, has never been used following the armistice of 1918. [0:21:06] Yeah, and the Patriot Act just disappeared the moment we killed Osama bin Laden. [0:21:11] Yeah, it's awesome. Yeah. [0:21:14] Yeah. [0:21:14] Well, you know, that's also like, bring it back to, you know, the Palmer Raids and all the American first Red Scare stuff, this was kind of in general a worldwide revolutionary moment, which is pretty interesting. [0:21:26] Yeah, I mean, the Soviet Union is like a few years old at this point. [0:21:30] Oh, no, no, no, no. It had been formally declared at this point. It was still the Russian Socialist Federation. [0:21:36] Or what was that? [0:21:37] Or Russian Socialist Something Republic. [0:21:40] My point is that the Russian Revolution had happened and that the Civil War is happening and that all over Europe you're still getting the aftermath of, you know, and Austria-Hungary is crumbling and this revolutionary movement's there, blah, blah, blah. Germany also, you know, overthrew its own king in a very revolution that obviously very much included, you know, labor in a very frightening way for the rest of Europe. [0:22:02] Prayers up for Rosa. [0:22:04] Yeah, well, yeah, her, you know, the dock workers all going on strike at the end of the war. [0:22:09] Yeah, and Kiel. [0:22:10] It was absolutely, absolutely. It was a time of almost, and they discussed this in the movie, not only in Ireland, but worldwide, there was a feeling of electric energy. People were starting to see, which they hadn't for quite some time, especially in Europe, that the world that they lived in could be changed. They could not only enact their will, but they could enact their will in such a way that frightened those who were in power. And they could win. [0:22:41] Yeah, like, they were fucking terrified. [0:22:44] So, do we want to start getting into the events of the movie more specifically? [0:22:48] Yeah, absolutely. [0:22:49] Here we meet our two main characters at this hurling game. They are Damien O'Donovan, played by Cillian Murphy and his cheekbones. [0:22:58] Extremely sexy man. Like, like, one of the sexiest men in cinema by far. [0:23:02] I thank you for bringing it up because I was too embarrassed to, but absolutely. Cillian Murphy, if you're listening to this, please, you know my phone number. I've sent it to you in letters. Just, you know, text me back sometime. [0:23:15] And unfortunately, his brother, Teddy, who we meet, did not inherit those genes. He is, at the beginning, more of a committed revolutionary. [0:23:23] The main character, Damien, seems to be a little bit less committed because he has a job lined up in London because he's a medical student about to go to work as a resident. And, you know, just sort of showing, you know, at the time there was division in young men, you know, young men who were about to begin their careers, maybe. Because as we learn later, and obviously as we can tell from the fact that Damien has gone to university, you know, studied anatomy for four years, about to become a resident. They are from a fairly well-off family, you know, at least, you know, their dad, their parents have passed away, but their dad, this mention of it made later on, you know, was employing other people in some sort of business. We don't find out. But, so, you know, especially for these people, there is a question of, you know, what to do. [0:24:14] And, you know, the other boys that they were just playing hurling with, you know, are ribbing him, you know, saying, oh, why are you going to London? There aren't any sick people here in Ireland, you know. [0:24:24] Well, you know, that gives, to bring this home a little bit, my grandfather, his his father was a teacher, but his father's brother was in the IRA. So it's a little bit kind of the similar dynamic. [0:24:38] Yeah, it was the IRA certainly drew from, I would say, the poor elements rather than the richer ones, simply because they just had less to lose. But it definitely did kind of draw from, I would say, almost all strata of Irish society, right? [0:24:55] And the first moment that really starts to awaken the revolutionary spirit within Damien is when the police come and break up the hurling game. [0:25:03] The black and tans come and they're exceptionally brutal. They're, as we mentioned, because of the Defense of the Realm Act, they're saying that all public gatherings are banned, and they line up all of the hurling players and ask for their names. [0:25:14] And one little 17-year-old rebellious twerp, I think his name was Micheail. [0:25:20] Yeah, he answers in Irish, not in English. [0:25:23] Yeah, and they, when they tell him to answer in English, he refuses to. He continues to answer in Irish. [0:25:30] Yeah, and then they take this guy into the back of the house and they just bayonet him just for saying his name as Micheail rather than Michael. That's all it took. [0:25:40] Yeah, it's unbelievably brutal. And I know this is fiction, and we should keep in mind that these are not real people, but this kind of brutality does not seem out of the ordinary for what was happening in the Civil War. Like, there's a reason why the Black and Tans had this, have to this day, this devilish reputation. [0:25:59] Absolutely. [0:26:00] No, this was not out of the ordinary for like the British Empire in terms of counter-insurgency tactics. [0:26:06] No, yeah, yeah. This is this is the kind of violence that happens in occupation in many places all over the world, including the US. [0:26:12] When I was watching this movie before I had started doing research, because I'm not very familiar with Irish history in general, so I was watching this and I was like, well, they must have embellished this for the sake of the plot, right? But then I start looking into the actual history of the Black and Tans in England, in Ireland, and I realize, oh, okay, this is probably not an exaggeration. This kind of shit probably happened. [0:26:35] Yeah, yeah, yeah. So, yeah. And then, so this really horrifies Damien. This woman named Sinead, who's the boy's sister, she's there and she's just completely, she and her grandmother, I believe, are just totally bereft. And then after this happens, there's some talk about like, should we take up arms against them? But Damien is resistant. And then pretty soon afterward, he's going, he's in a train station, he's going to board a train, and then he sees that the black and tans are there at the train station. [0:27:04] Oh, can I mention something that happens before that? [0:27:07] Oh, of course, yeah. [0:27:08] So we see a scene at Micheail's funeral, and everyone is just talking about, oh, what is to be done? We got to become revolutionaries and whatnot. And we find out that this small rural community had got several young kids to the Black and Tans in the last couple of weeks. Like, they got one guy for just like crossing a field to get somewhere. And it's like, like, no shit that people are going to be very angry and very willing to take up arms against the British. They just did not think this through. They just thought that they would be able to pacify through sheer brute force, not realizing that this is only going to draw people closer to the nationalist cause. [0:27:53] I think we should mention it, you know, before we go on. [0:27:57] This film does take place in County Cork, which, you know, to this day is known as the Rebel County. You know, this is, you know, it's not quite the Gaeltacht of the West, but there were still at this time, even, you know, pockets of Irish speakers in and around County Cork. And we saw that with Micheail, Micheail. And so it's not only that they're speaking Irish, it's also that Cork was a place, a hotbed of revolutionary sentiment in Ireland, especially, which I think definitely you see playing out. And I think the British either just thought enough force could pacify this area, or they just underestimated the revolutionary movement in Cork. [0:28:52] Yeah, so, right, so we see Damien trying to get on a train, but there's a stoppage. And the stoppage is that the train won't go because the train driver is refusing to transport members of the Black and Tans. The train driver comes out, he's a man named Dan, played by Liam Cunningham. You might know him as the Onion Knight from Game of Thrones, Davos. And he refuses. And he says that he's in a union that has made it clear that they are not going to participate in the occupation of Ireland. [0:29:25] Specifically, I should say, yeah, the train working unions at this time issued a declaration saying that they would not transport any arms or ammunition on their trains. So it was not just a vague, you know, sort of, you know, do what you want, but don't do anything to help the occupation. It was a specific order not to transport arms and ammunition. [0:29:49] And, of course, the Black and Tans beat him savagely, and they arrest Dan. And then they say, we'll find someone else who can drive the train. And after witnessing this, this is what causes Damien to make the leap. And shortly afterwards, he joins the IRA. He pledges his support to the Dail Eireann, I'm sorry, the Dail, which has convened in secret, and he becomes revolutionary. [0:30:14] Yeah, and this is like his, yeah, this is his turning. [0:30:16] Yeah, yeah. Pretty soon afterwards, Sinead, the sister of Micheail, the boy that was killed, she gives Damien his pendant, his cross of St. Christopher. And this is something that he keeps with him throughout the film. Sort of his reminder, the reminder of what he's fighting for. [0:30:34] So you guys want to talk about the next scene, which is the attack on the pub, the first mission that they send Damien on? [0:30:39] Cool guys doing cool guy stuff. They're all just chilling at the pub. You hear the local old men are talking about how they're worried about things escalating. And if you listen closely, one of them is saying that, oh, they're going to do us like they did the Boers. And then they come in, these Black and Tans. They all come in just to get a pint or whatever. And then Damien and Teddy, they leave the room. And then what happens? [0:31:05] Well, you know, at that point, well, specifically, they had, you know, patted them all down, all the young men, for weaponry. [0:31:13] Oh, sorry. [0:31:14] Yeah, yeah, yeah. When Teddy and Damien came in, yeah. [0:31:17] And they're pals. [0:31:18] And this is after, yeah, this is after they've already started the training with the IRA. And I don't know if any of you caught this, but normally, you know, because obviously they don't have enough rifles, they have, you know, guys training with wooden rifles. In this case, they didn't even have wooden rifles. They had them training with hurling sticks. They had them training with hurleys instead of rifles. But yeah, so I believe a Sinead comes in and hands them each a couple pistols. Clearly, she'd been waiting outside just in case something happened. Because they didn't have pistols when they padded them down. They go in and as they're coming in with the pistols, the old man, one of them goes, oh, Jesus, crosses himself because they know what's about to happen. They go in, shoot all four of them dead right there. These four British officers, I should say, not just soldiers. [0:32:08] I believe they were officers. [0:32:09] You're right. Yeah. Yeah. [0:32:10] It was an assassination, not just a massacre or anything like that. [0:32:13] Yep. [0:32:13] Yep. It was an assassination. And the thing they take, you know, isn't money or whatever. You know, they reach behind them, take out all their guns, and then get the hell out of there. [0:32:23] Every last rifle you can get, boys. Every last one. [0:32:25] Absolutely. [0:32:26] Yeah, and as we'll find out, that was the main obstacle. The IRA had no weapons at all, essentially. It was a huge issue for them throughout the entire War of Independence and then throughout the Civil War. But despite that, the IRA really remarkably led this guerrilla campaign. And of course, eventually they won, as we'll get to, but they really had the odds against them. But the leadership of people like Michael Collins was able to find new tactics to resist the British despite their lack of material wealth or whatever. [0:33:00] Yeah, because they refused to play that by the rules of conventional warfare. In fact, Eamon de Valera, who was the president of the Dail, he wanted it to be like a conventional war where it's just like troops going against each other in like an organized manner with uniforms and whatnot. And they tried to do that against one customs house, and it was a massacre, needless to say. So, of course, the IRA much preferred to engage in more of a guerrilla warfare, just ambushing convoys as they're passing through. [0:33:32] Yeah, yeah. [0:33:33] And then, and so one of these guys that participated in the pub raid, in the pub assassination, Chris, this teenager, we see that he actually works on the estate of a local British landowner. [0:33:44] Sir John Hamilton. [0:33:46] Oh, yeah. Just a shithead. [0:33:49] Perfectly cast. [0:33:50] Perfectly cast. [0:33:51] Absolutely. Absolutely. You know, this guy's grandchildren are writing for The Guardian today. [0:34:03] Just, yeah, an awful man. And what happens is that some Irish police and British police and an officer come by and they say that they believe that they have heard a report that this young man Chris is part of the IRA. And so they corner him and they say, is it true? If you want your family to be left alive and all that, you gotta help us. And panicking, this kid Chris, he says, okay, sure, I'll help you find my comrades. And then this kid Chris leads them to his friends, really, his comrades. And they find this forest hideaway, and Damien and Teddy are both arrested. [0:34:46] And tortured. [0:34:47] Yes, yeah. They go to jail. Initially, Damien, Cillian Murphy, insists that actually he is his brother, Teddy. He tries to take his brother's place. [0:34:59] Yeah, because they were specifically looking for Teddy. Because at this point, Teddy had been, I believe, the commander of their local IRA squad. [0:35:06] Yeah. [0:35:07] Their local flying column. [0:35:10] Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Teddy's the leader, and our protagonist, Damien, is the new guy, essentially. And we can tell that Damien is really the savvy, educated one, because the moment he's taken into booking, he demands to be listed as a political prisoner. [0:35:25] Absolutely, yeah. [0:35:26] And yeah, so they torture Teddy, but Teddy refuses to give up any of the safe houses, any of the weapons caches. He has his fingernails ripped out, but refuses to relent. And then while he's being tortured, Damien leads the other men in singing patriotic songs to drown out his screams. [0:35:46] Specifically, they sing Arana Fein, currently the national anthem of Ireland. [0:35:53] Yeah, a soldier. [0:35:54] Yeah, in Irish, the title translates to A Soldier's Song. And it's, you know, just given strength to, you know, not give up any of that information, which proves pretty crucial. [0:36:08] And, well, so specifically, actually, the scene in which he demands that he and everyone else arrested be treated as political prisoners actually comes right after that scene. [0:36:22] Yes. [0:36:22] Which is a really interesting scene because it has the guy says, no, you're not, you're murdering gangsters, who's young men in the back. And they get into a screaming, you know, him and the Brit get into an argument. And eventually the Brits start screaming about how these men were up to their necks in vomit at the Psalm and etc., etc. All this World War I shit is very just, it's in the air. [0:36:43] Yeah, he's just talking about how, like, oh, all my guys are battle-hardened. They saw their friends getting blown to pieces at the Psalm, and they will not hesitate to kill you. [0:36:51] And then he calls in one of these guys who's like, Yeah, looks, looks, yeah, looks like a kid. Yeah. [0:36:56] Yeah, a child. [0:36:58] Does anyone remember his name? [0:36:59] Because he shows up later in Johnny Gogan, I think was his name. [0:37:02] Yeah, Johnny Gogan. [0:37:03] That's what it is. Yeah. Yeah. [0:37:05] And the thing is, yeah, and so and the older officer hands him a pistol and demands that he shoots Damien, and he does, but there's no bullets in it. It was a mock execution. [0:37:14] Yeah, but you know, the whole time the kid is saying, I can't do this. I can't do this. [0:37:18] Yeah, yeah, he's clearly conflicted. And also, this kid, we should mention, is a World War I veteran of Irish descent who is now fighting in Ireland. [0:37:27] Yeah. Yep. He says, actually, in a bit, well, first, let's get to this scene in which Dan and yeah. [0:37:35] Yeah, yeah, right. So, so, okay, so they tell Damien after the mock execution, they say, We're actually going to kill you tomorrow because tomorrow you're going to be sentenced and executed for illegal possession of a firearm. And then, so as Damien is essentially awaiting his death, he's moved into a different cell. And here he meets, like you said, James, he meets Dan, the train conductor. [0:37:58] They first calve into a bit of a conversation in which, yeah, so yeah, on him, you know, he sees behind him, you know, names etched into the wall of people who've clearly been executed. Sean Og in a little drawing of a tricolor next to his name. And then next to that, written in much finer, looks like a pen or pencil, you know, is an excerpt from William Blake, which is interesting on a number of levels. But, you know, he starts, you know, Damon's, you know, holding a candlelight up, you know, reading it aloud, and Dan, the other prisoner, who we haven't seen since the train station scene, finishes the line for him when, you know, Damien can't quite make out the last words that are written. And, yeah, he says, you know, this is where Dan reveals that he had actually been fighting with James Connolly during the Easter Rising and was, you know, as part of his sentencing, he was exiled. [0:38:57] And, you know, he started to really, you know, read, you know, literature, poetry, all of that stuff, you know, started to really understand it, and where he really honed his political education as well, which had begun with Connolly. [0:39:12] Yeah, because, yes, because Dan is a Marxist. [0:39:16] Dan is absolutely a Marxist. [0:39:18] Yeah. [0:39:18] Yes, he is. [0:39:19] And we learned that Cillian Murphy, you know, being the big dick guy that he is, agrees with him, has similar political aspirations. They quote at the same time, which was very cute. [0:39:34] Perhaps Connolly's most, oh my god, yeah, perhaps Connolly's most famous quote: If you remove the English army tomorrow and hoist the green flag over Dublin Castle, unless you set about the organization of the Socialist Republic, your efforts will be in vain. England will still rule you. She would rule you through her capitalists, through her landlords, through her financiers, through the whole array of commercial and individualist institutions she has planted in this country and watered with the tears of our mothers and the blood of our martyrs. [0:40:04] Which, god damn, if that's not true as all have. [0:40:09] Yeah, I know. We will, yeah, we will get into later, I think, the free state as it emerged following the Civil War. [0:40:17] Yes, yeah, even Ireland today as just the world's largest tax colony. [0:40:23] Oh, God Christ, yeah, it does. God, yeah. [0:40:27] James Connolly fought for Apple's right to not pay taxes. [0:40:34] So fully expecting his death, there's suddenly a knock on the door of the cell, and it's that kid. [0:40:42] Yeah, Johnny Gogan. He says, I'm Johnny Gogan. My father's from Donegal. I won't have your deaths on my hands. [0:40:48] And immediately, Dan immediately jumps up, which I thought was quite funny. There wasn't even a moment of confusion. They jump up, they get as many as they can out of there. [0:41:00] Johnny does not have the keys to the final cell. [0:41:02] Yeah, three men were still left behind. They weren't able to get them out. [0:41:06] Yeah. [0:41:08] And yeah, and then so, yeah, so they get out, and then they can't get all the people out, but they escape. And then the first place they go is back to that English motherfucker who sent them there, Lord Hamilton. [0:41:22] Sir John Hamilton. Well, actually, oh, sorry, no, I think we're missing a bit of a. I think we're jumping ahead just a bit. [0:41:28] Sorry. [0:41:29] Actually, the next scene actually right before that was the attack on the barracks. Which here we're really introduced to Sinead as a member of Cumann na mBan, as a member of this woman's auxiliary unit of the IRA. Yeah, because we first see her and we don't know how actually organized she is just by handing them pistols for that, you know, the pub assassination. But here we're seeing her as a courier, which is one of the jobs of Cumann na mBan. And yes, so she, from one of the, you know, Cumann na mBan spies, one of the Irish women who's a typist at the local, at the nearby barracks, is able to get an entire layout of the barracks. And, you know, so Sinead comes, gives them this map, and they start planning a raid on the barracks in order to get arms specifically. And so it starts off with: clearly, they're planning on just setting off an explosive device right in front of the front gate, basically. [0:42:41] There's a problem where it's not lighting. One of the officers clearly wakes up in the middle of the night, pokes his head out the window, and goes, Oh, what you doing out there? What's all this then? And the guy very smartly starts acting like just some simple drunk Irishman, literally singing The Wild Rover as he just pretends to be stumbling about. And then as soon as the guy gets out, grabs him by the neck, puts a gun to his head, and says, You're taking me up the stairs. You're not saying a word. So they manage to, so far, they still have not. Yeah, so far, the pub are the only people that they've killed so far. And yeah, they managed to get those rifles, which again are absolutely crucial. This film does not, this film reminds you, I believe at one point it says, you know, there's only like 3,000 rifles or something in the whole country or something. [0:43:31] Yeah, 3,300. [0:43:33] Yeah. And they're going against, it's 3,000 rifles against the fucking British Empire. [0:43:39] Britannia's Huns and their long-range guns. [0:43:42] Against, yeah, 10,000 British soldiers, it says in Ireland, which includes the Black and Tans, artillery, cavalry. [0:43:49] And the population of a third of the world. Like, they didn't end up, of course, we mentioned they didn't actually bring in colonial troops, but they just had a much larger pool of manpower. Britain could hypothetically afford to bleed a lot more than Ireland could. [0:44:03] Absolutely. Yeah. [0:44:05] Well, theoretically, yes. [0:44:07] Theoretically, is doing a lot of polling right there in that sentence. [0:44:10] That's a good point. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. [0:44:12] Yeah, speaking of not dealing with casualties, Russian Sam. So, what happens? What do they say when they get into Sir John Hamilton's home? [0:44:21] Yeah, so they just walk into this super fancy room with this really nice rug, which Chris had been afraid to walk on because he had just been walking on the stables when the cops came for him. And he says, I don't want to get the rug dirty, sir. And so they're in this room. They just barge in and they say, Oh, such a beautiful room. It's hard to imagine a man scream from here. [0:44:42] And yeah, and because, sorry, so the IRA, specifically one of the women in the barracks, who, you know, clearly the British hadn't found out about her yet, had managed to steal and make a copy of a letter from Sir John Hamilton in which it says, I was informed, you know, we've interrogated one of my employees, Chris, and found out that, you know, in fact, this is where the weapons cache are and this is where they're staying in the woods. So they know exactly who the leak was. [0:45:19] Yeah. And they make him sign a new letter where he proclaims that if the three IRA men who are still in prison are killed, then his own life will be forfeit. And shortly after this, they find out that those three IRA men have been executed. They grab Sir John, but they also grab Chris. [0:45:39] Yes. And there is debate about what to do with Chris. [0:45:46] Ken, exactly. [0:45:47] And Damien's known him since they were five. [0:45:52] He's known since they were kids. [0:45:54] But so there's debate about what do we do? Can we just exile him? And someone says, man, this is a war. You know, where do you think we are? We have to. So, you know, they go and shoot this big, fat, awful Englishman. And there's, you know, really not, you know, Damien is still like, I've studied anatomy for, you know, four years and I'm about to shoot a man to death. So, you know, he's like, oh, you know, I don't really like killing people. But, you know, not too much with him. You know, he, you know, gives the letters he has to, you know, be mailed to his wife and children and then dies screaming, you'll never beat us. And just immediately all of them just, they don't even wait for him to turn around. Just all Damien just unloads the entire pistol on him, which was very, it was very satisfying. But then. [0:46:51] It's a very satisfying, beautiful moment. I could watch that on a loop for two hours. [0:46:55] Yeah, and then there's some mood whiplash here because as because as soon as they pop this blood-sucking tick, they turn around and there's Chris. There's the teenager. [0:47:07] Someone's like, Damien, do you want me to do this? And he says, no, I have to do it myself. I have to. [0:47:12] Yeah, yeah. [0:47:13] Which is an comes back in a tragic way. So, Damien has to be the one to kill this kid. And the thing that the kid says is he doesn't want to be buried next to the Englishman. He's scared about that. Damien tells him, you know, we'll bury you up the chapel down by the road. Not with him. [0:47:35] Yeah, and they also ask him for a letter to his mother, and he says that he hadn't thought of what to write, and his mother doesn't know how to read anyway. And it's just, ugh, it's such a heartbreaking scene. [0:47:44] It's absolutely a heartbreaking scene, yeah. [0:47:47] Because he just says, just tell her that I love her and that I'm sorry. [0:47:51] Yeah, no, but I was just saying, you know, he's, you know, he's a kid. He says, you know, Damien, I'm scared. He says, I'm sorry, I know you have to do it. I'm sorry, but I'm scared. Damon just says, did you say your prayers? Chris goes, yes, I did. And Damien just says, don't worry, they'll protect you. And then he kills him. [0:48:11] So the deed is done. Chris is shot dead. And Damien says, I hope the Ireland we're fighting for is worth it because he just killed this kid whom he had known his entire life and who was in a way himself a victim in this situation who just got scared. But yeah, he did what he thought he had to do in the moment. Chris did. [0:48:32] And I think that this really shows, it's so smart of Ken Loach, the director, to juxtapose the two killings because it shows the fun side and the horrible side of revolutionary violence. [0:48:43] Exactly. It's very easy to glorify revolutionary violence and it can be glorious. It can be glorious as it was watching that prick Englishman just get fucking. [0:48:52] Most people who die in revolutions aren't prick Englishmen. [0:48:55] Exactly. That's exactly it. Most of the time you're deciding, okay, are you going to kill a child? Are you going to do that? Like, you know, are you willing to, for the fact that you're cut, you know, your little sister might get hunted down? [0:49:10] And I think, and to me, that scene is what elevates this movie from being more than just patriotic propaganda. Because there's so many movies, so many movies with these same themes would not have included a scene like the killing of Chris. And this is really what makes Ken Loach just such a talented director and what makes this such a strong movie and such a strong, and I would argue, such an honest work of history. [0:49:32] Absolutely. Yeah. [0:49:34] This movie actually, unsurprisingly, well, actually, surprisingly a bit, I think he only printed like 30 reels to be shown in the UK itself. [0:49:43] Yeah, which is very funny. Yeah. [0:49:45] Even though, yeah, Ken Loach is British. He's English, but he didn't expect it to be popular. [0:49:49] Yeah, Ken Loach, to be clear, is a British man. Yeah. Ken Loach also is a very socialist British man. But yeah, I mean, the campaign against this movie that I've seen written in articles in The Guardian, in the Daily Mail, all of the predictable places of British establishment. [0:50:12] By the grandchildren of Sir Hamilton. [0:50:14] Yeah, exactly. Yeah. By the grandchildren of Sir John Hamilton. These just, which also somehow employ what appears to be a third of the entire population of the UK. These people, you know, talking about, oh, well, you know, he's, you know, dramatizing history. He's dressing it up. He's making the occupation look more cruel than it was. And if anything, you know what? No, it wasn't as cruel as he could have been. You know, Ken Loach could have, Ken Loach absolutely could have, and he could have justified it in a filmmaking way. He could have included the countless rapes and sexual assaults that the British did against the women of Ireland. But he didn't. He didn't. Because he was focusing on the story of these people. [0:51:02] Well, we do have a scene that's very suggestive towards the end. I mean, it's, yeah, he suggests certainly abuses of women, right? [0:51:12] There is at one point in which we're going to get to it later, but the soldiers are laughing and calling Sinead a Fenian whore. But we do not see specifically any sort of the mass rapes of the women of Ireland that the British Army carried out. Not necessarily by official order, but certainly it was expected. [0:51:33] Yeah. [0:51:34] As the British did across the world at this time in all of their anti-insurgency campaigns. [0:51:41] Do you guys want to guess what percentage of the Black and Tans were called up for disciplinary action? [0:51:46] I'm going to guess zero. [0:51:47] 18%. And 9% were actually dismissed for their conduct. Like, even the British looked at this and thought, oh, this is going too far. [0:51:56] In a way, the killing of Chris in that previous scene kind of prefigures the ongoing splintering of the Irish independence movement. Because as soon as this happens, we see that there are two camps decidedly emerging within the IRA, which basically are the socialist side led by figures like Dan and the side that is much more moderate, concerned only with revolution. There's this, the IRA begins, as they start to occupy territory, they set up courts and they deal with arbitrations between Irish landlords and Irish tenants. And a lot of the nationalist crowd thinks that economic concerns are completely irrelevant. All that matters is making Ireland a republic separate from Britain. But Dan and increasingly Damien start to wonder if perhaps that isn't the case. [0:52:46] Well, one interesting thing about that in Teddy's justification for his position is: how are we going to buy weapons if we don't have the support of the local bourgeoisie and their funding? And so this back to the shortage of weapons. [0:52:56] Yeah, but it kind of, yeah, well, this kind of reminds me of Fred Hampton, you know, he's got that great quote about how a capitalist in a dashiki is still a capitalist. Damien starts to figure out that a capitalist for the Shalali is still a capitalist. [0:53:11] Yes. Yeah. But I mean, well, crucially, even before this, Damien was explicitly familiar with Carnelly's writings. He says, you know, in university, I actually used that quote of his in a debate. And he says, yeah, and he says, you know, I guess that was all talk then, you know. And he talks about, you know, his brother's always been the man of action. He's always been the man of thoughts. [0:53:38] To bring this back to Ben Shapiro, Damien is perhaps the only good debate guy. [0:53:45] Yeah, but even he even he has to rise above being a debate guy and go and take arms. [0:53:51] Yeah. And we see him having a debate up here because he talks with Sinead about how he's personally conflicted about his own actions in the IRA because he really is hit hard by the killing of Chris and he starts to think that maybe this isn't what he should be doing. Maybe that, like, you know, he said before, like, I hope it's worth fighting for. He starts to wonder if it is worth fighting for. [0:54:11] But very soon afterwards, he realizes, yes, it absolutely is, because Sinead and her family are attacked by the British. [0:54:18] Brutally. [0:54:19] Very brutally. [0:54:20] I guess it starts because, or not because, but it begins with an attack that the IRA leads on a British convoy where one of their members is killed and they ambush and massacre. No, I shouldn't say massacre. They take out a convoy of British soldiers, and then on their way back, they see that Sinead's family's farm has been destroyed. [0:54:38] Yeah, they walk to the scene just as the Black and Tans have gotten to the cabin and they set a fire to it and they start harassing Sinead and her mother. They're just tearing her hair out, literally. They're shearing it. [0:54:52] Yeah, they're shearing it with sheep shears. [0:54:54] Yeah. [0:54:55] Yeah, and one of them lays her down on a crate, which is the suggestive scene that I was talking about. It almost seems as if he's about to actually rape her, but then they decide to go. And you have this horrible situation where Damien and the rest of the IRA guys, they're watching all of this, but they're unable to do anything about it because they don't have any more ammunition. [0:55:15] Oh, we should probably bring up the ambush scene a bit. So, I mean, the ambush was, you know, they have one person dressed in clearly a hat and a uniform, which you can guess where they got it of one of the Black and Tans, you know, pretending that his bike is broken down. You know, they have all of the men. This is what you've seen them training for earlier in the film. All of them are, you know, set up with their rifles. [0:55:41] One man has a it might have been actually two men have you know World War I era machine guns even so clearly they had you know clearly they one of their raids went very well in order to get one of those yeah they got a good loot box yeah absolutely yeah well you know what this kind of reminds me of how like a military action against British troops was met with civilian reprisals. [0:56:03] We hinted at this earlier, but probably the most, really most disturbing event of the Irish War for Independence was right around this time, something called Bloody Sunday. [0:56:13] Yeah, absolutely. Please, please talk about that. [0:56:15] Yeah, yeah, sure. Yes, so I know all of you guys are familiar, but so Michael Collins, who is a figure we never see in this film, but he's often discussed, the IRA commander, he led targeted assassinations of British intelligence officers who were stationed across Ireland. And as an unbelievably brutal reprisal, that Sunday, Sunday 1920, the British rolled armored cars into a soccer game and simply started firing. What was supposed to happen is they rolled into this field, assuming that some of the gunmen had hidden themselves in the crowd. And yeah, and then the crowd obviously starts panicking, and so the British soldiers start shooting them. And 12 people were killed by the shots, two more people died as a result of being trampled, and many more people were injured by the bullets. Yeah, I think something like, I believe altogether there were something like 90 victims, most of whom survived, but still, it was just horrible. [0:57:18] This would not be the first time in which a soccer stadium would be used in a European civil war by a far-right force for executions. I remember reading, I believe it's the book, I believe it's included early on in the book, Spain in Our Hearts, about the Spanish Civil War, in which the Francoist forces in one of the areas that they've taken over turn one of, turned the local football stadium, the local soccer stadium, into essentially an execution chamber. With they've completely cleared it out. They have just in the center of the stadium a truck with a machine gun on it, and they are just marching men, women, children, political prisoners, regular prisoners, anyone they've rounded up just in a row to be just immediately gunned down. And the description says, yeah, the description says that the blood in and around the stadium coagulated and was about two inches thick for about a week. [0:58:20] Stadiums as places for mass killing have gone on for a while. [0:58:23] Yeah, I mean, Chile is another Chile is another obvious example under Pinochet. [0:58:28] Oh, Jesus. [0:58:29] Yeah, Chile, yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. [0:58:31] Victor Jara was killed in a football stadium in Chile. [0:58:34] Yeah. [0:58:34] It's smarter people could probably come up with some sort of poetic analogy to about spectacle, but I think those are smarter than men than me. [0:58:45] Yeah. Well, I guess this really was just clearly the climax of British anti-Irish violence during the War of Independence. [0:58:54] Well, of the British military. [0:58:57] There are, yes, it is brought up later in the film, specifically, much later in the film, which we'll get to, but attacks by sectarian forces in the north of Ireland, in those northern six counties, in Belfast, specifically, they say. We have Sinead literally says that her family there were burned out of their homes. Yeah, burned out of their homes, which did very, very famously happen and continued to happen even after Michael Collins had the treaty signed. Yeah, which we will get to that, yeah. [0:59:33] So back to Sinead. As soon as she basically recovers from her really horrific attack, where her hair's been shaved off, you know, she's been assaulted terribly, a young boy pedals along who has a message. He almost lost it along the way. [0:59:48] Yeah, he remembers it was a T-word. It was a T-word, but he can't quite remember what. [0:59:55] And the T-word was truce. That a ceasefire has been declared between the IRA and the British. And the war is essentially over. [1:00:04] And what this means is that there will never be any more bloodshed in Ireland ever again. [1:00:11] Yeah. [1:00:12] Peaceful from here on out, smooth sailing. [1:00:14] Yep. [1:00:15] Problem solved, everybody. [1:00:17] And yep, the movie ends. The movie actually just ends like, yeah, like about like 45 minutes in. [1:00:25] Yeah, it was pretty awesome. [1:00:27] But no, yeah, so at this point, people, all they know is a cease, not a treaty has been signed, but specifically a truce. A ceasefire has been signed. [1:00:39] Yes, the treaty will come later. We'll take a little break right here, but we'll get back. We'll get to the treaty very shortly. [1:00:45] Absolutely. [1:00:56] And we're back. All right, so where we last left off: peace and freedom forever. The truce has been signed. Michael Collins, revolutionary leader, he goes to Britain and he takes part in the very rapid signing of the Anglo-Irish Treaty. How would you describe the Anglo-Irish Treaty, James? [1:01:17] How would I describe the treaty? I would show my where I'd fall down. I'd say the treaty was a betrayal of every single thing that anyone had died for. Every single person who voted for it deserved every bullet they got. And I expect to get a visit from the Gardai very soon for my defense of the rightful assassination of the tyrant Michael Collins. That's right, I'm saying it. [1:01:47] Yeah, so yeah, yeah, yeah. Michael Collins certainly suffered the consequences, but he signed the treaty, and among its stipulations were that Ireland would be nominally independent as a Dominion. [1:01:57] Oh, so specifically, we learned about this in a scene set in a very actually delightful scene that I didn't expect to be in this movie. [1:02:05] Oh, I mean, in the movie theater. [1:02:06] Yeah, exactly. It's in a movie theater. They're playing a newsreel, and there's a man in the corner playing the piano the whole time. Even as everyone gets progressively angrier, he's still playing away. And again, Ken Loach, best to ever do it. Hats off to him. [1:02:24] Well, so something I gotta say, although I do love that scene, and although this scene does it much better, that's actually lifted from an identical scene in the movie Michael Collins from the pro-treaty perspective. [1:02:35] Oh, is it really? [1:02:36] Isn't that funny? You see the characters watching this newsreel about the treaty. But what's funny is that I would say it works to a much greater effect in The Wind That Shakes the Barley, because here you're not seeing these important, lofty figures in the movie theater. You're seeing everyday Irish people. Yeah, everyday Irish people. [1:02:55] And specifically, I want to bring out, I want to bring up, there is one man who is reading it aloud, which implies that there are people in that room who are still illiterate. [1:03:04] That's great. [1:03:05] That is really good. [1:03:07] He's still, he's reading out each line each slide as it comes up, which shows you, again, as they brought up earlier, illiteracy in Ireland was still a very common problem. Not just illiteracy in Gaelic, but also with literacy in English, which at this point, at this point, the vast majority of Ireland spoke English. There were still Irish-speaking places in the west, in the southern area, and I think a bit in the center, but mostly along the southern and western coasts. [1:03:37] Russian Sam. You dragged up that really frightening statistic about, what was that? About 1870 to 1890 or 18. [1:03:46] Yeah, so while I was doing research, I came across this book called The Irish Revolution and its Aftermath. Really great book if you're looking for a primer about these events. [1:03:57] What was the stat? [1:03:58] The decline of the Irish language in the 19th century is best illustrated by census figures showing that between 1861 and 1891, Ireland as a whole contained fewer Irish speakers than the province of Connacht, the smallest Irish province in terms of population, had during the previous 30 years. [1:04:13] Yeah, so just a complete decimation of the Irish language. [1:04:16] Yeah, and there were a number of factors contributing to this. First of all, there was the famine, which resulted in the loss of 2 million people by death or immigration, and those people were disproportionately likely to be Irish speakers. But also, you had a more mundane reason, which is that English was seen as sort of the language of modernity as opposed to Irish, which was this retrograde peasants' language, which no longer had anything of value. And so, in a lot of families, even ones that were Irish-speaking, children just were not taught Irish. [1:04:46] This kind of gets at the struggle right here about what kind of relationship should Ireland maintain with the British Isles, with England. [1:04:53] And oh, so sorry, just really quick, I wanted to add that Connacht to this day, that is where the Gaeltacht is currently in that western part of Ireland, which is still the least economically developed, the most rural, the least populated, as you say. So that statistic, less than the number of people in Connacht, is harrowing. It is absolutely frightening. Yeah. [1:05:21] Yeah, absolutely. [1:05:23] Yeah. [1:05:23] And so, yeah, they start debating the treaty, and we see that Damien and his brother Teddy are on different sides of this early, early conflict. [1:05:31] Yes, literally brother against brother. [1:05:33] It is, yeah, yeah. [1:05:34] Because Damien insists that Michael Collins, the leader, was seduced by, what do you say, seduced by British wining and dining, and that he couldn't negotiate a proper treaty. [1:05:44] Which, for the record, I don't think that was a fair characterization. Like, certainly, whether or not it was true, the important part is that there were people at the time who felt that way, right? [1:05:58] And actually, actually, I will say that that didn't come from Damien. Actually, Liam, that came from a woman. [1:06:08] Damn, I'm erasing women. I can't believe it. [1:06:11] Again, Ken Loach does not erase women in this movie. Ken Loach does not erase the Cumann na mBan. [1:06:16] Yeah, no, not at all. Like, and going back to the courtroom scene where we originally see these ideological splinters emerge, the judge is a woman. Yeah, like the people running that courtroom are all women. [1:06:28] Oh, yeah. You're right. [1:06:30] Exactly, yeah. [1:06:30] The Cumann na mBan is a prominent feature. I don't think they say specifically the name of the Cumann na mBan. [1:06:37] They don't. [1:06:37] That in the film. Yeah, but they are absolutely shown as things such as spies, couriers, and then later, you know, judges, arbiters, positions within the government, which... [1:06:52] And well, of course, it goes right at the top. Countess Markievicz was a really prominent member of the revolutionary movement. She was one of the biggest leaders. [1:07:00] But even after, she maintained. [1:07:04] She died pretty soon after the civil war ended, but she was a big figure throughout. [1:07:10] But yeah, so then someone else, I believe it was Teddy, says that they have to ratify the treaty because Britain simply because Britain simply would not allow them to ever become fully independent. And what Teddy says is like, look at India and Africa. What's it going to mean for those places if little old Ireland gets to be fully independent before them? [1:07:34] Exactly, exactly, exactly. He says that the British will not allow a green light for full independence rather than a, we should specifically talk about sorry, the dominion status that the treaty entailed, which entailed primarily those involved in the Irish government of the new republic. First of all, it dissolved the Irish Republics of 1916, 1920, right? It created a new government, and it said that their primary oath was to... [1:08:08] To the king. [1:08:09] No, actually. And this is actually a concession that Collins was able to get. The primary oath of allegiance was to the new Irish government. But then there was a secondary and required still oath of fidelity to the king rather than a flat oath of allegiance entirely, which is exactly what these, what would then become the pro-treaty faction, would use as an example of how it was actually more revolutionary than it was. [1:08:45] But I know Russian Sam, you seem to follow more on the pro-treaty side, but one thing I would say in defense of the anti-treaty crowd is that there was a very long history of Irish rule over England, but it wasn't always direct. There was a long history of British influence waxing and waning. And so it seems like a lot of the anti-treaty crowd who rejected this piece feared that this was just going to be one of so many periods of British retreat that would be followed by a period of British retrenchment. [1:09:17] Right. And can I just say that I really appreciate Ken Loach after seeing this movie, but this scene especially, because you see this debate going on, and he doesn't really cast anyone in a bad light, so to speak. He shows that both sides have good points and that this is a complicated matter, that you can't just willy-nilly say that one side was 100% correct and the others were just monsters who were just looking out for themselves, and etc. He shows that there's a deep level of complexity to all of this, and it only makes it even more painful to see what comes. [1:09:53] Absolutely. So what we're learning at this point, right, in these debates is, you know, despite the fact that Ken Loach might have intentionally actually cast this guy to make us hate him, but we are introduced in the scene, I believe introduced here, to Teddy's right-hand man, who I don't know if he's ever named. He looks kind of like Irish Steve Buscemi, is the best way I can describe him. Do you guys know the guy I'm talking about? The one with the very sunken eyes. He looks very much like a rat or a lizard. And, you know, whether he just, unfortunately, the actor, who I'm sure is a, I'm sure he's a fine person, you know, whether he just looks like that naturally. But I think it was probably a characterization very, very subtly by Ken Loach to show which side he thinks that he would have landed on if he had been Irish in this situation. [1:10:52] Yeah, Ken Loach personally very clearly has an anti-treaty position, but nevertheless, he is able to portray the pro-treaty side as being people who have their own reasons stemming from not necessarily their own material interests, but rather a pragmatic understanding of the war as they saw it. [1:11:12] Exactly. And we're going to get specifically into that material interest in a second, I think. That's an excellent point. Ken Loach does an absolutely amazing job with this film in portraying both sides. [1:11:24] So at this point, you know, we hear, I wrote down just a couple of things that people said. You know, someone asked me, you know, is this what we fought for? Someone says that actually, you know, the British, what was the exact phrasing, if I remember that? [1:11:42] A long and terrible war. [1:11:44] Immediate and terrible war. [1:11:46] Yeah, immediate and terrible war if the Irish did not accept it. And some people, some people say, some people take that threat at face value. Some people take that threat and say that it was bluffing. [1:11:57] And happening concurrently to this was the Iraqi revolt, which was met with immediate British aerial bombardment. They just, the Iraqis started rebelling, and then immediately the British, early British Air Force came in and just bombed the shit out of these villages. [1:12:13] Yeah, and it should be noted that the British really were acting with kid gloves. If you look at a number of casualties in this war, for example, we see the many terrible things that they've done, but they were still being restrained. [1:12:25] Does anyone want to take a guess as to how many people died in the war? [1:12:28] 2,000. [1:12:30] That's it. Yeah. [1:12:32] Well, so what. Well, where's that statistic from, though? That could be like war dead, especially in the 20th, early 20th century, but even today, actually, is really tough to quantify. So I'd be very cautious with any statistics. [1:12:45] Yeah. [1:12:46] The British actually, if you look, the British only counted Protestants among the human dead. [1:12:50] Jesus, did they really? [1:12:51] No, I'm joking. No, no, no, no, no. [1:12:53] Oh, sorry. Liam, you can't, Liam, you can't. You can't tee me that. Oh, Liam, you know how I get. I get heated. You can't tee me up like that. All right. [1:13:02] Well, I apologize. I'm a man. I almost said a man of the cloth. I'm a man of the yellow and white flag. Come on. You know me. [1:13:11] So, actually, a couple of things that I want to bring up. One that I forgot to mention back during that courtroom scene in which the court sides against a person charging extortionate interest rates, an accumulative interest rate, against an elderly widow of 500%. The court orders him to repay her. And Teddy, you know, basically undermines the court and says, you know, don't antagonize the capitalists basically because we need their money. But sorry, so what they say right before that scene is that, right before they go in, is something about hunger strikers, which obviously is a very old Irish political tradition, and I mean, political tradition around the world, but specifically in Ireland, has a lot of yes, because if there's one thing the Irish are good at, it's starving. [1:13:57] Oh, yeah, Liam, I'm taking you in, boy. We're going to see the father, but it is specifically a hunger strike situation. That is obviously as we see much later with I should say member of parliament Bobby Sands. [1:14:16] Yeah, hell yeah, Bobby Sands, and obviously he was not the only one. It was multiple and there and their five demands, yeah. [1:14:26] There were those sisters who also led a very successful hunger strike, absolutely, which increasing unbelievable human bravery through suffering. [1:14:34] Just, I have to say that, just cannot, it cannot even begin to fathom the strike those people had. [1:14:41] Yeah, starving yourself to death is not a fun way to go at all. [1:14:45] No, it is one of the most horrific and slow and painful ways to go. But they do say, so someone asks, how are the hunger strikers? And they say they're holding up, they're holding up. [1:14:56] And they also say in this scene that they have the support of not only the rail workers, which beforehand were taking a completely hands-off approach, saying we're not transporting any weapons. Now, they've now they've firmly come on on the IRA side, as well as the dock workers who are not letting anything through the ports. Which, which for an island nation like Ireland, not letting anything through your ports, not letting any British guns or soldiers or anything through your ports, that is massive. It's essentially, you know what it is? It's a hunger strike on a national scale. [1:15:31] Absolutely. [1:15:32] That is essentially a general strike. [1:15:35] That is essentially a general strike. And with the rail workers, I mean, rail today in Ireland is a joke. It's an absolute joke, and that's due not only to partition, it's due to the neoliberal governments of both the North and in the Republic of Ireland itself. You can literally look at a map of railways in Ireland in, say, like the 1920s and 1930s. There were more rail lines in service then than there are today, specifically between the North and the South. [1:16:04] Like now, like Donegal, which again came up earlier with the soldier whose father's from there, that is, it's not called the forgotten county for no reason. It's not called that simply, you know, it's not like Delaware, right, where just no one thinks about it because it's irrelevant. It's forgotten because it's forgotten by both Northern Ireland, which it borders directly on the west, or to the to the west of, I should say, and by the Republic of Ireland. [1:16:35] It's the flyer of a county. [1:16:37] Yes and no, kind of, right? You know what I mean? It's not just that it's like deemed by culturally irrelevant, right? It's also that specifically the economic life of people in Donegal was absolutely upended by partition. And I'm just going to go through this really, really quick, just because I feel like it has to be brought up simply because it's not brought up enough. Donegal, it was for a very, very, very, very long time, right? Since basically industrialization. What many people in Donegal would do is they would be able to at least move to or simply work in and then come home, depending on how close, depending on how far we say, I guess, in Donegal they were, to cities like Belfast, Derry, right? These industrial centers where there were jobs. And with the partition, they suddenly could no longer do that. And they had to rely on the economy of Donegal, which, if we're going to be honest, is not much. [1:17:39] It has some industry, it has some agriculture, but really it was in a position in which its closest industrial city was completely cut off from it. Completely cut off from it. And, you know, this movie, of course, deals with Cork in the southwest of Ireland. But we have to remember, especially when we talk about the treaty, we cannot forget what it did to Irish people in the north. Whether they were Catholic or Protestant, what it did to Irish people in the north. Because there were people who, there were countless people, I shouldn't say countless, I simply don't have the number on me, of people who gave their lives fighting for the cause of an independent republic in Ireland in this war of independence, and in countless risings and wars of independence before that, who were dead, wounded, traumatized forever, went through hell and back only to be completely abandoned. [1:18:40] In their eyes, at the very least, whether or not you think that they were fully abandoned, whether or not you think, whether or not you believe the accounts that came out about Michael Collins in private saying to people that one day we will, you know, we won't, we won't force the North, we won't force the northern counties at gunpoint, right, to join us, but we will create goodwill and eventually bring them in. Whether you think he was telling the truth or whether you think his approach to that was feasible, a different question. Those people who survived and the family of those people who died saw it as a complete betrayal of them by these people. That is, yeah, so again, I feel it very necessary in all conversations about the Irish War of Independence and the Civil War to bring up the North of Ireland because it comes up huge in the treaty. [1:19:37] And of course, one big stipulation of the treaty, in addition to the territorial concerns, was the fact that it meant a political system essentially unchanged from what existed before. They were taking down one flag, just as James Connolly had predicted, putting up a new one over Dublin Castle. But the bones of society were going to remain the same. [1:19:57] And this is where we see, yes. [1:19:59] Yeah, so Dan the man, train guy. [1:20:03] He was a train guy. [1:20:04] Yes. [1:20:05] Shout out. [1:20:06] Shout out all my train boys out there. [1:20:09] This truly, this shows the brilliance of Ken Loach. [1:20:12] Absolutely. [1:20:13] He was ahead of his time. He knew. My man laughing because he knows. So Dan begins by reading the proclamation of the Dail in 1919, which reads, The nation's sovereignty extends not only to all the men and women of the nation, but to all its material possessions, the nation's soil and its resources, all the wealth and all the wealth-producing processes of the nation. And then Dan is speaking, that means all of us here and all of us in our country own a bit of that country. And that's what we all signed up for when we voted for the Dail, right? If we pursue this, every child in this country will have an equal chance. If we don't, we don't have a chance in hell. If we ratify this treaty, all we're changing is the accents of the powerful and the color of the flag. [1:21:01] Color of the flag. [1:21:02] Absolutely. Yeah. And he says this because I mentioned this earlier with the when you brought up that he didn't just portray the pro-treaty side as simply acting in some sort of material interest. He specifically calls out two of the people who are siding with Teddy in this debate, right? And he says, How much money have you got in your pockets? And eventually they pull it out and they have basically, they have like maybe like two shillings. [1:21:30] Yeah, they have nothing. [1:21:31] He asks them, you know, oh, sorry, no, this was the courtroom scene, but yeah, still, still specifically just showing because those same people show up on Teddy's side in this debate as well. He says, how much land do you own? And says, you know, do you have a blade of grass in your name? And he says, no, I haven't a blade of grass in my name. And he says, you know, then what are you doing fighting for a side that is siding with the local bourgeois against the British bourgeois, basically? [1:21:59] I have very mixed feelings about this. As Michael Collins said, the treaty was about the freedom to pursue freedom. And essentially, the Irish nationalists were in such a position that they couldn't not accept the aid of these bourgeois nationalists. They did need their money to import arms. They needed them to cooperate at this phase. So, again, I don't think it's as simple and as clear-cut as these are the good guys, these are the bad guys, and we must not sully ourselves by allowing them to participate. [1:22:32] Right, but in any case, as we can see by the scene where Dan and Damien provide medical care to that starving family, nationalism alone can't save people. And this is nationalism isn't going to feed people. [1:22:43] So, I want to just get into a couple of the arguments of that time that are presented in this debate. So, specifically, one woman brings up that the British, you know, the British threatening invasion, right? [1:23:00] Immediate and terrible war. [1:23:01] Right, immediate and terrible war, which in this case means a military invasion, right? One of the women says, listen, they won't actually do that because they can't afford to lose face with, they can't afford to lose face with America right now, invading Ireland. She says America specifically, and that currently this war is costing the British government 10,000 pounds a day. That is how much the British government is having to spend every single day in this war of independence. [1:23:36] After years of World War I draining their finances, it should be noted. [1:23:40] Absolutely, yeah. Yeah, so she is correctly pointing out that absolutely the British government does not have these endless coffers, right? Which with which they can pay at this point in time. They are strained financially, they are strained economically. She is making a rational, a literal, a rational fact, factual-based argument, right? [1:24:06] You know, she's going Shapiro mode. [1:24:13] And someone else brings up the sectarian thugs in Belfast and says specifically, this treaty will mean that the British will arm those sectarian thugs. And the pro-treaty side, Teddy and his, you know, weasel-faced friend, they both say, well, if you read the treaty, it actually says they can't do that. And someone just says, and someone just says, oh, come on, you really, really? And as we know from history, the British, in fact, did exactly that. The treaty meant absolutely nothing to the British. They, in fact, not only armed, they specifically trained, supplied, financed every single one of those Irish, or no, every single one of those sectarian thug gangs in Northern Ireland. [1:25:08] Yeah, and in fact, the militarization of the South Irish of the Catholic nationalists happened in response to the Ulster nationalists, the so-called Ulster volunteers who were mobilized in response to the passing of the Home Rule Treaty. [1:25:19] Absolutely, absolutely. [1:25:21] Someone brings up the fact that under Dominion status, the country would have a governor general and specifically says the governor general would essentially have a puppet parliament. And people can say, and people can say, oh, the governor general, you know, in Dominion States, doesn't really have that much power. I would say, look at Australia in the 1970s, in which the governor general carried out a coup d'état through parliament, carried it out on behalf of the Central Intelligence Agency, MI6, and Australian Business Interests. [1:25:51] Who was the Prime Minister's name at the time? The leftist? [1:25:54] Oh, Gough Gough Whitlam. [1:25:56] Gough Whitlam. [1:25:57] Yes, he led, yeah, leader of the Labour Party of Australia. [1:26:01] Yeah, this was in 1975. Yeah, he was dismissed by Governor General Sir John Kerr. [1:26:10] And yeah, absolutely. So bringing up a very legitimate concern about the structure of Dominion status governments being still having an undemocratic institution controlled by a foreign power. [1:26:28] So, yeah, so after this debate, we move on to watching a very, very fun scene that everyone in it is clearly enjoying, which we start off just by hearing boom, boom, boom, boom, boom. We hear the, you know, the British war drum beating, and we see someone, yeah, all the men are standing outside the pub going, I never thought I'd see the day. And it's the British Army leaving Ireland, which we all know they left the entirety of the island for the final time, never to return. [1:27:07] Yes. Well, while it was unfortunately not complete, I'm sure it must have been a powerful moment because, again, it is the end. It is, at least in the lower two-thirds of Ireland, it was a more than that. It was the end of a 700-year legacy of formal domination. You know, you could argue there is still quite a bit of influence to domination, but at least on the formal level. [1:27:28] I would actually bring up, they don't discuss with the movie, but I believe this did phase out after a while, for the same reason why Ireland is not a dominion status today. [1:27:38] Yeah, I think it was in the 30s they worked out a different situation after the Civil War. [1:27:41] Yeah, in 37, they passed a new constitution, and then it formally became a republic in 49. [1:27:48] But specifically, I was going to say the British, as they love to do, anywhere they go in the world, anytime they decide they can't control an entire territory, they say, okay, but we still have port rights. There are, I am not kidding, Cyprus, Cyprus. [1:28:07] Oh, are we about to tell the truth about Cyprus on this one? [1:28:10] Oh, that's another. [1:28:13] Let's not go there. [1:28:15] Am I ready to have... Am I ready to have two countries at once come after me to assassinate me? [1:28:24] Two separate occupied islands split in two? [1:28:28] Yeah. Oh, I was going to say that both the Greeks and the Turks would not like me. But, you know, they're seeing the come out, they're seeing them walk out, which, yeah, you know, they did have those port rights in the south of the southern coast of Ireland for until they solved that whole situation. But yeah, militarily, this is them leaving Cork, which no one thought they'd ever really live to see the day to do. [1:28:56] And going 300 miles up the road. [1:28:58] Exactly. Specifically, we see behind them, we see the forces of the pro-treaty crowd following behind them in uniform, and someone says, Jesus, that's Teddy. That's Teddy in a that's Teddy in a treaty uniform. [1:29:14] Yeah, and this is what I was getting at. And that they say, oh, yeah, we took out the black and tans, but we brought in the green and tans. [1:29:20] Exactly. Yeah, I literally had that one written down, yeah. [1:29:25] So then we are introduced. He might have actually shown up earlier in the movie, but one of the actual historical figures in this film, Rory O'Connor. They really only refer to him as Rory, but Rory O'Connor, who was the leader of, or at least one of the leaders of the anti-treaty forces. Damien and some of his fellow men from his column are approached by Rory O'Connor. And Rory O'Connor tells them, keep up the training. We are creating a new headquarters for the anti-treaty forces in Dublin. Seven out of ten officers of the IRA are anti-treaty at this time. That's what he tells them. [1:30:13] But fairly accurate, actually. Yeah, most officers of the military, not the politician figures, but most officers of the actual IRA were anti-treaty. [1:30:25] Right. [1:30:26] And of course, even but yeah, but it went very high up because both Markievicz and de Valera were anti-treaty. Whereas Michael Collins, Michael Collins, was the leader of the pro-treaty side, of course. [1:30:37] Yes. And Michael Collins had that's that's a man where we only know so much about what he said in public versus what he is said to have said in private. And that, of course, is a very murky. [1:30:50] You're saying that you're saying there's a Michael Collins hadith. [1:30:56] Absolutely. Absolutely. Yes. [1:30:59] The Hadiths say one thing that are not said in the actual Michael Collins Quran. [1:31:08] But yes, so Rory O'Connor, he's going to set up, and we learn that this is, as Rory O'Connor did, set it up in the Four Courts in Dublin. [1:31:20] Before then, we do get another training scene, this time of specifically anti-treaty people. And a woman comes up over the hills to Damien and says, Are you the doctor? And he says, Yes. And he goes in. She says, You know, I have a sick child here. She goes in. There's three young girls, little girls, sitting out in the front of the house. And he goes in and he sees his boy lying in bed, very sick. And, you know, he's giving him a medical examination. He's saying, you know, open your eyes for me. Okay, you know, stick out your tongue. Saying, ah, you know, let me see if there's anything on your stomach or chest. You know, and one of the other men from his column comes in and asks him, is the child going to be all right? You know, what's wrong? And the kid says, sorry, and Damien says, the kid's half starved. [1:32:15] He's half dead from starvation. He's not sick with anything other than starvation. These people are starving. [1:32:22] So then we get into what is called the Battle of Dublin in 1922, which is. [1:32:31] Right, back to the Four Courts. [1:32:33] Yes, the Four Courts in Dublin. [1:32:35] We're into the actual civil war. [1:32:37] Yeah, the civil war has started in earnest. This is the beginning of the actual civil war. [1:32:42] Yes. [1:32:43] So Rory O'Connor has taken over the Four Courts in Dublin. [1:32:47] Held it hostage. [1:32:48] Yeah, he took some people hostage there. And they've set up a headquarters of a military one, which, you know, that gets into accusations that especially foreign media at the time made that he was trying to set up a military dictatorship. [1:33:07] Okay, yeah. [1:33:07] Speaking of military dictators, needing munitions to oust him, Michael Collins went on to procure British weapons. [1:33:16] Specifically, well, not, I would say, not just weapons. They don't say this explicitly in the movie, but I did look into it. And so they do say in the film that the Free Staters bombarded the Four Courts. Four quarters, the Four Courts. Yes, with 30-pounder artillery shells, which they had borrowed from the British military. What they didn't say was that they also received assistance in operating this artillery from members of the British military who were still in Dublin. [1:33:55] God. And you know, and that's just this incredible symmetry. The War of Independence begins, arguably, in 1916 with the bombardment of the post office, and then here, six years later, once again, the British are bombarding Irish nationalists now holed up in the Four Courts. [1:34:13] Yep. [1:34:14] And now they're doing it with the assistance of other Irishmen. [1:34:17] Now we're doing it with the assistance of other Irishmen. [1:34:22] What did Connolly say? Britain will still rule you? [1:34:25] Here we are. Here we fucking are. [1:34:30] Yeah, so Battle of Dublin. [1:34:33] Next scene we have, after they learn about the Battle of Dublin. [1:34:37] It's the church scene? [1:34:37] Yes, it is the church scene. They're all en masse, and this priest, in a classic early 20th century priest way, whether you're Catholic or I actually learned it was the same also in Wales. Yeah, goodness, I can't remember which actor it was, but he was saying, you know, guys, before me in Wales, before, you know, I was one of the first people to actually be like a film actor, before then you become a priest, because then you get to give a performance from the pulpit. My God, if this man isn't giving a performance from the pulpit. Yes, so for the first time, we have the opportunity for peace and prosperity, you know, pleading with the Irish people to accept the treaty. And as we all know, the Catholic Church has always had the best interest of the Irish people at heart. [1:35:26] Doesn't he, am I making, did I make this up? Doesn't he decry the anti-treaty crowd as Bolsheviks? [1:35:33] He says that they're nationalized. He basically says they'll nationalize your toothbrush, essentially. [1:35:37] Yeah, exactly. [1:35:38] He says, they're not content to just, you know, to just nationalize, you know, your pension or your savings. Next, they'll be coming to nationalize the 12 apostles. And, you know, there's a small laugh from the people in the church. But obviously not everyone's laughing because half of them are anti-treaty people, including Damien, including Damien and Sinead. And Damien then stands up and this becomes very dramatic. [1:36:08] Yes, and the big shocker here is that the priest says, he declares that in a court, that all of the bishops of Ireland have decided that any members of the anti-treaty movement will be excommunicated. [1:36:20] Not excommunicated officially, but they will, whatever sins they commit, specifically, because this was a letter. [1:36:29] They were denied sacraments, I believe. [1:36:31] Yes, they were denied sacraments. Their sins involved the sins of particularly their involvement in the anti-treaty fight could not be absolved in confession. [1:36:43] He said, in other words, excommunication, but it's not excommunication. [1:36:46] Yeah, yeah, he says, he says, in other words, it was in effect excommunication. Yeah, and he stands up, he fights back against him, and as he's leaving, he says, once again, the Catholic Church, with honorable exception, sides with the rich. It's just an absolutely amazing scene. And we will get on, we talk about the free state post-Civil War, about their relationship with the church. [1:37:13] And then, as soon as they leave the church, Teddy pleads with his younger brother, telling him that this is a senseless fight. You're my brother. Think of our father. He wouldn't want us to be on two different sides of the conflict like this. And Damien rebukes him. [1:37:29] Yeah, Damien rebukes him, says a quarter of our people are out of work. Specifically, the anti-treaty side has been printed pamphlets talking about nationalizing, talking about labor rights, talking about creating a socialist republic. And Damien says, you know, look at this shit. You know, do you think people are actually going to fucking buy into this shit? You know, what the fuck do you do? What the fuck do you think you're doing? And he says, fucking a quarter of people are out of work. I've seen women and children starving. And he says specifically, do you expect them to just go off to New York like before? He specifically brings up, like, what do you want them to do? Just fucking leave the country again? Do you want that to keep happening? [1:38:16] Yeah, and this is a country where the population had been dropping precipitously for the last 50 years. [1:38:22] Yeah, Ireland's greatest export is its own people. [1:38:25] It didn't start growing until the 1960s. It was stuck at 3 million for decades. [1:38:29] Yeah, and now it's still at about 4 million, which is, I want to say, about the population it had before the famine. [1:38:37] No, no, before the famine, it was 9. They still haven't exceeded pre-famine level, the famine level. [1:38:42] Yeah, it's. [1:38:42] You are right. [1:38:43] Yeah, yeah, they still have not. It is horrific, horrific. [1:38:48] Fuck the British. [1:38:49] Sink the island. [1:38:51] Absolutely. [1:38:54] But Teddy's excuse is: give the treaty a chance. See what we can do with the treaty. See what we can do with this new government. [1:39:03] And Damien says, You have wrapped yourself in the Union Jack. [1:39:09] In the butcher's apron. [1:39:10] In the butcher's apron. That's what it was, yeah. And he specifically brings up a time in which their father had fired a guy who he was employing, and he says the two of them couldn't even look his son in the eye just because of the shame of it. It's just saying, like, listen, I'm fighting for something bigger. I'm fighting for something more. I am not letting this continue. We can't have our people continue to suffer. [1:39:38] So then, yeah, so then there is officially a fight in a fight between the pro- and anti-treaty sides. A truck of pro-treaty people are killed by anti-treaty people. And Teddy orders a reprisal against the anti-treaty side. And this is where, in this attack on a place where the anti-treaty people were hiding out, Dan is shot. He's shot. He falls down. Damien drops his rifle and says, he puts his hands up and says, don't shoot. Listen, he's been shot. I'm a doctor. Let me see if he's okay. And the pro-treaty person, and this is definitely, I would say, Ken Loach's characterization, I would say an accurate one of what would become the attitude. Because this is a very, very metaphorical scene, I would say. [1:40:40] The killing of the dream. [1:40:42] Exactly. This free stater officer, his face immediately, all humanity almost leaves it. And as he fires off five rounds into the back of Dan as he's lying on the ground, just becoming this inhuman monster, just this fucking disgusting, reprehensible figure, shooting five rounds into a man lying on the ground, into his back, into a man who not only had fought with Connolly and with this movement, a man who represented a different vision of what Ireland could be. Just brutal, the brutal murder of a vision of not only the entire generation, but an entire vision of what Ireland could be that would take a generation, two generations, three generations for Irish people, for that vision to finally once again gain momentum in the Republic of Ireland proper. Just this disgusting, awful state emerging to just fucking suck all life, all vision, all hope out of the people and just bleed them dry for everything they've got. [1:41:58] With so much of the Irish independence movement crushed from within, really all that was left was the church. [1:42:05] Absolutely. All that was left was church. And I've said it before. I'll say it again. This is exactly what the British wanted. This is exactly the outcome the British wanted. [1:42:15] The British, so let's finish up with the movie and then we can get to Ireland today. So yeah, so of course, so yeah, so Dan is killed and Damien is captured. Once again, he's in jail. This time, his brother is not his cellmate. His brother is his jailer. In fact, in the same cell as he was earlier. And Teddy begs him, says, please, just tell us where, just tell us where, just tell us where the weapons caches is. Tell us where Rory O'Connor is. [1:42:45] And Rory O'Connor would, of course, later go on to be captured and executed. And in fact, any person who signed his execution, Rory O'Connor was his best man at his wedding. [1:42:55] Wow. That's awful. [1:42:58] Wow. [1:42:59] Yeah, this was a war that absolutely tore apart an entire generation. And objectively, the bad guys won. [1:43:06] The bad guys fucking won. [1:43:08] And in this movie, it's literally a war of brothers. Which, like, at first, it seems kind of cheesy, but it works so well in this movie. Trust me. If you haven't seen it, like, just watch this movie. It's awesome. [1:43:20] This is, again, it's a Ken Loach movie. You're going to love it. It's also an absolutely fantastically crafted film. [1:43:27] And then Damien tells him, basically, listen to me. I shot Chris Riley in the heart. I'm not going to give up anything right now. I have crossed so many lines. I've gone so far. You are going to have to kill me. [1:43:41] He writes his letters. Also, he writes his letters. It's important. [1:43:44] To Sinead, to Sinead. [1:43:45] Yeah. [1:43:46] So the execution comes. He's tied up to a post. And one of the soldiers there says, you know, turns to him and quietly asks, you know, I can give the order. And his brother Teddy says, no, I have to give the order myself. [1:44:02] Just like with Chris. [1:44:03] Exactly. Just like Damien with Chris. [1:44:05] Well, hold on. Well, hold on. First, he actually, you actually miss. There's one important thing where he tells, before he gives the order, he goes up to Damien, who's tied up there, and he tells him, you know, Damien, it's not too late. And then Damien asks, for me or for you? [1:44:24] Brutal. [1:44:25] Fucking brutal. Yeah. And then here, here's when he gives the order. [1:44:30] Yeah, the order is given. He's shot dead. And Teddy just absolutely breaks down. He just immediately bursts into tears. [1:44:37] Yeah. He can't even give the order to put arms away. He's already crying. [1:44:43] Yeah. And then, of course, really to twist the knife into the gut of the audience is then when he bends down and notices that in his brother's hand is the cross of St. Christopher that belonged to Micheail, the boy who's killing, started all of this. [1:44:58] The one that Sinead gave him. [1:44:59] Yeah. So he goes to deliver the letter that Damien wrote to Sinead. He goes to deliver it personally. [1:45:07] The letter and the cross to Sinead. [1:45:08] Yep. [1:45:09] And Sinead is still living in the burned-down house where her grandmother, in fact, said actually earlier when it was burned down, that she wouldn't even move anywhere else, despite the fact that the IRA was saying, we'll find you a place to stay. She said, when I was four years old, the British forcibly evicted my family. I'm not going to move again. I'll live in the chicken coop if I have to. [1:45:33] And the chicken coop is where Micheail was killed. [1:45:36] Yeah. And so he comes, you know, on his little motorcycle, gives her a letter, gives her the necklace. [1:45:45] Yeah, in uniform, gives it to her personally. [1:45:49] She reads, and he's just so sheepish. He can't even look at her. She reads it, just completely fucking loses it, starts hitting him, telling him to get the fuck out, that she never wants to see him again, which is the same thing that the mother of Chris said actually to Damien earlier when Damien showed her Chris's grave. She said, after she made him bring, after she made him walk with her six hours to see the grave, yeah, six hours to see the grave, she said, I never want to see her face again. And I hear Sinead says the same thing to Teddy. And he rides off, and this is the end of the film as Oro Se Do Bheatha Bhaile plays. And that is, that is the film. [1:46:35] And it's incredible. [1:46:38] It's fucking amazing. [1:46:39] It's absolutely incredible. [1:46:41] So we want to talk about Ireland after the Civil War. [1:46:44] Yes, let's talk about the priestly states. So, quickly to just characterize the two states that emerged, the best way that I have had it described is that this was the greatest thing that could have happened to the British. Because they were with a partition, because they were able to create a fascist state, a fascist orange state in the north, and a practically theocratic Catholic state in the south, neither of which would actually challenge capital, right? Neither of which would challenge Irish or British capital because British capital was still incredibly invested economically in Ireland after this war, still. [1:47:27] Yeah, Ireland doesn't have any kind of, I mean, the economy of Ireland remains basically completely in the shitter for generations. [1:47:34] I mean, yeah, I mean, Jesus Christ, you know, you want to talk about the housing crisis in the U.S. Fuck it, you want to talk about the subprime loans? I mean, my God, in the 80s and 90s in Ireland, just by showing up to the bank, you got a loan. You got a loan for anything. It was absolutely insane to the point where today in Ireland, there are so many unused homes in Ireland. It is absolutely baffling. Even still. Yeah, even still. Because again, everyone was making money hand over fist for building homes, for giving out home loans. Whether or not you could actually pay for the home loans, they did not care. And unsurprisingly, yeah, the Irish economy is not great, especially with having some of the most industrial parts of your country cut off by a literal armed and guarded border. [1:48:30] Well, the way that the way that Matt Christman characterized the Republic of Ireland is that they just jumped straight from the sack of potatoes peasant stage to like a post-industrial financialized state, and it really kind of fucked them in the transition psychologically. [1:48:47] Yeah, it's not great. Not great at all. [1:48:51] Yeah, they had to have something to cling on to. [1:48:54] It's funny because Ireland today is quite wealthy. You know, like they're one of the more prosperous countries on the planet, but it's all very hollow. [1:49:00] Isn't it like essentially all centralized in Dublin? [1:49:02] Oh, I'm sure. Yeah, it's probably all Dublin. [1:49:04] Yeah. But even in Dublin, across the entire Republic of Ireland, especially for young people, basically all of them have just accepted whether or not they're fighting against it is another matter, but they've all accepted the reality that they will basically never be able to move out of their parents' place because they can't afford rents. They can't afford to buy anything. They can't afford to fucking rent anything. Everything is absolutely unbelievably, exorbitantly highly priced, and none of them can make any fucking money. It is a neoliberal hell dominated by two identical parties, which did emerge from, they did emerge from this pro- and anti-treaty split. [1:49:44] Fianna Fail, yeah, Fianna Fail, De Valera and Markievicz break from Sinn Féin and form Fianna Fail. Yeah, well, I guess it was because Sinn Féin was too based for them because they Sinn Féin kept up the abstentionist policy from what I understand, even in the Republic of Ireland in the early post-Civil War period. [1:50:07] Exactly. Exactly. [1:50:09] One thing I think to take a quick step back that we should mention is that the Civil War ended pretty soon after the movie ends. The big event was that Michael Collins, who was working toward a ceasefire, was killed. Initially, there were some other forces that were very opposed to a ceasefire. Then the leaders of the IRA were killed, most notably Liam Lynch. And then after this happened, eventually it was basically the anti-treaty side realized that they couldn't keep doing this, keep up this insurgency. And so they buried all the weapons caches, and then they did ceasefire. And then clemency was declared. And so Markievicz and De Valera, who were on the anti-treaty side, they resumed their work in Sinn Féin. But at this time, Sinn Féin was abstentionist. [1:50:53] Those weapons caches would obviously come, they would come in useful later. Yeah, come back later, and yeah, and there would once again be another split in the IRA, of course, along, again, partly ideological lines between the provisionals, the Provos, and the official IRA, which took a more Marxist stance. And as that devolved into... [1:51:18] Maybe I'm wrong about this, but I was under the impression that the Provos had rejected the Marxism of the official IRA because they were really more interested in a more immediate, less economic. [1:51:31] Yeah, yeah, that's what I said. Yeah, the official IRA were explicitly Marxist. [1:51:37] Yeah. [1:51:37] And as that devolved into whatever you want to say about what happened with the split between the IRA and different IRA groups and them infighting and the connection and the conflict over, you know, you want to say money or drugs is, I would say people try to make, people try to pin that into something inherent to Ireland rather than something inherent to civil wars specifically of that era. Because you see the you saw the exact, the exact same thing happening in Colombia. [1:52:10] The exact same thing happening in Colombia. [1:52:12] And Peru. [1:52:13] And Peru. And anywhere with a situation like that. [1:52:17] Yeah. [1:52:18] Yeah, yeah. [1:52:19] And of course, so we mentioned how the Sinn Féin splits, Fianna Fáil, which is the more right-wing elements of Sinn Féin. [1:52:29] And then, of course, there were the real psychos, which were Fine Gael. [1:52:31] Yeah, Fine Gael. [1:52:33] Fine Gael, who are to this day still called Blue Shirts. Because the Blue Shirts, okay, so the Blue Shirts was an organization formed in the early 1930s in Ireland. [1:52:46] Former comrades of Michael Collins. [1:52:49] Absolutely. Which again goes back to my belief that Michael Collins deserved to die, and no one should fucking shed a tear over that asshole. Which I'm sure will get many people to yell at me over this. [1:53:02] Yeah, yeah, the blue shirts were explicitly fascist. They were corporatist in the Italian sense of the word, not just in the vague. [1:53:10] No, literally along the lines of the Italian Fascist Party. Organized explicitly, along those lines. [1:53:16] Exactly, yeah. [1:53:17] Organized explicitly along those lines. [1:53:19] Yeah, abstromously. [1:53:21] They had their march, just like the march on Rome, they organized a march on Dublin in an attempt to create a fascist state in Ireland, essentially. [1:53:28] Yes. And they were not. Whereas the Italian party, sorry, the fascist party in Italy did have a somewhat complicated relationship with the Catholic Church, simply due to the fact that the Catholic Church owned, literally owned territory in that sense. There was no such independent state or threats of an independent state in Ireland. This was more like the Ustasha in Croatia in terms of relationship with the church. [1:54:00] It was very much like the Ustasha in Croatia. [1:54:02] It was incredibly similar to the Ustasha. So, yeah. [1:54:09] So, and again, this, the Catholic Church in Ireland essentially held until fairly recently, incredible power in the Irish legislature, in Irish courts, in lawmaking in general, and government in general. It was, when people bring up a theocratic nature of the free state in Ireland, they are not, there is some intentional exaggeration there, but it's the core of what they're getting at is absolutely true. [1:54:46] Yeah, it's the same way that Britain, it's the same sense that, like, yes, Britain doesn't formally dominate, but informally, it absolutely dominates. The Catholic Church does, it's not a formal theocracy, but informally, the Catholic Church absolutely dominates. From what I understand, De Valera kind of charted this very awful middle course where he gave, he never gave explicit state power to the Catholic Church, but he enshrined within the Constitution, he fought for a special relationship, which meant that there was a lot of powers that were sort of under the table delegated to the church. Most infamously, things like orphanages. [1:55:19] Sure, it wasn't quite Salazar's Portugal, right? But it was certainly more than France, if you get what I mean. [1:55:30] Right, yeah, yeah, yeah. From what I understand, there was never, there was never oppression of non-Catholics in Ireland to any significant extent. [1:55:40] Not really, no. [1:55:41] Yeah. Which is good, but but it meant that there was, but that the Catholic Church was allowed to maintain incredible power over the social lives of its adherents. I think as a contrast, if you ever read about like modern or not really early 19th century German history, there was a big struggle where in Germany, there was a big struggle to wrest the power of the church away from the social lives of Catholic Germans. In Ireland, it was the opposite. The Catholic Church was able to extend its authority even further after independence. [1:56:14] They filled in the vacuum where the British state parsed part of that vacuum. [1:56:19] I get it with things like orphanages. [1:56:20] Yeah, yeah. [1:56:21] Yes, the most infamous example, most likely, is the Magdalene laundries. Unmarried mothers, their infants were essentially forced to be surrendered to these nunnery, I'm sorry, to these laundry houses run by the Catholic Church, where women would be forced to work as slaves in these laundry houses. Their children would be forcibly taken, often essentially given away to wealthy American adopters. And those are the children who survived. [1:56:54] And if anyone thinks we're exaggerating, the word slave here is actually appropriate. Like, we're literally not from... [1:57:00] Yeah, it is unpaid labor. [1:57:02] Yes. [1:57:03] Yeah, and I remember what's really horrific is that there was an excavation of one of these, the grounds of a closed Magdalene laundry several years ago from the early 20th century. And in the excavation, they found the bones of like a hundred small children thrown into a well. And that's just what they found. [1:57:26] Yeah, that's the Irish government in the past couple years has opened. It's been a couple years ongoing now, an official investigation into these Magdalene laundries. And what they found is just unbelievably horrific. [1:57:42] And it is, again, I will say this again, because people use this and people have used this, and the British have used this in their depictions and descriptions and their ideas of Ireland as actually one character, I believe it is Sir Hamilton, says it's a land infested by priests. Priest-infested backwater is the term he used. Yes, priest-infested backwater. That is the term that is used, and that is a characterization internationally, largely, of Ireland as this backwater. [1:58:21] Well, what's that phrase? Worst person you know just made a great point. [1:58:25] Well, no, no, no. Actually, I'm going to say it implies that it is a result of a situation created by the Irish. [1:58:31] It's what the British wanted. [1:58:33] Exactly. It is what the British wanted. Because it ensured that no one would challenge capital on an island nation directly west of the UK. And it ensured that no all-Ireland movement would be created. It ensured that the North would forever, in the British eyes, rather than in the actual course of reality, in which that is not a sure thing, let's say, that the North would forever be a fascist orange state controlled directly from Whitehall. This is exactly what they want. Because also, they don't want to compete with Irish capital, right? They don't want to have to compete with it. So if you can keep an economically subservient, basically, actually, I should say not subservient, economically dominated, right? Country economically dominated, you can keep it from developing its own industry, you can keep it from developing its own economy and its own course of action, right? You can make sure that you will never have to deal with competition from Irish industry, which the British haven't, really. [1:59:45] No, all they really have at this point is just like, oh, maybe some of the banks will go over to, you know, to move to Dublin so they can take advantage of EU laws or whatever the fuck at this rate. That's, oh, maybe they'll use an Irish tax haven instead of a British one. [1:59:57] Was there ever a liberation theology type movement within the Irish Catholic Church before, like, the 70s? [2:00:04] Before the 70s? Oh, that's a good question. Well, there is a passage, I forget what it's from, specifically of the Limerick Soviet, which part of this pre-independence war, which the only reason why they called that war the independence war is because it actually resulted in independence. But so that one, there was actually a passage in which the Limerick Red Guards, right, it says, you know, they're sitting in the church on Sunday, and it said that, you know, the Red Guards of Limerick Soviet rose from their pews, and were blessed by the priest. Which, I mean, come on, that's just beautiful. [2:00:58] That's the dream. [2:01:01] Yeah, which is why Damien says he doesn't just say, once again, the Catholic Church sides with the rich. He says, once again, the Catholic Church, with honorable exception, sides with the rich. [2:01:13] Oh, shit. I didn't pick up on that. [2:01:16] That's cool. The history of Marxism in Ireland alone could be a really fun subject to look into. And I gotta say, the name Limerick Soviet might be the best name of any government in history. [2:01:27] Oh, absolutely. Yeah, and those, I mean, those, I mean, again, the connection between the Soviet Union, or even at that time, what would become officially the Soviet Union, and the country of Ireland are very, very deep. I mean... [2:01:41] I mean, the connection between the Irish and revolutionary movements in general, it's a very interesting subject. I mean, like, from, you know, France to fucking Palestine. [2:01:49] Oh, sure. Sure, sure, sure. Oh, God, yeah, absolutely. [2:01:53] But, I mean, even just the connection between Lenin as a person in Ireland. I mean, you know, the person, yeah, his English instructor, his English instructor was Irish. Like, when the Guardian interviewed him, he spoke with an Irish accent. [2:02:06] And of course, all the potatoes and hard drinking. [2:02:11] Kindred spirit, kindred spirits. [2:02:14] Well, this has been a really fun talk about a really fun movie. I think it's clear that Ireland truly is a land of contrasts. [2:02:23] It very much is. Yeah, this is absolutely. Again, if you can, absolutely check out this movie. Wind That Shakes the Barley. Ken Loach, amazing director, amazing just figure in world politics and world film, and just unbelievable film. Absolutely check it out. [2:02:49] Yeah, no, your grains will be shook. [2:02:51] Yeah, well, yeah. Well, thank you so much, James, for coming on. This was really, really a fun experience. [2:02:57] Thank you so much. I had a great time. Thank you very much. And thank you. Thank you, Halal Sam. Thank you, Russian Sam. Thank you, the incredible Abram, our co-host and producer. Just, you know, what an amazing, amazing group of people you've gathered here. [2:03:18] Well, yeah, and hey, shout out to the lovely Emerald Isle. Hopefully, one day Ireland will be unified. [2:03:24] From the sea to the sea, Ireland will be free. [2:03:27] Yeah. [2:03:28] From the sea to the sea.