Gladio Free Europe, E24: Kievan Rus' https://www.gladiofreeeurope.com/episodes/kievan-rus [0:00:15] And we're back today with another episode of Gladio Free Europe. I'm Russian Sam, and I'm joined as I usually am by my co-hosts, Liam. [0:00:21] Hello! [0:00:22] And Sam B. [0:00:23] Hey there. [0:00:24] Today we're going back to medieval times because we really love our medieval episodes and we just wish we could keep doing them. [0:00:31] Yeah, this is going to be a straight into the veins nerd episode, some hardcore medieval history, but even if that's not your thing, this is going to be really exciting. There's some pretty fun stuff in here. [0:00:42] Return to tradition, baby. Return to tradition. [0:00:45] Yes. Very, very nasty traditions involving, let's talk, dismemberment. [0:00:50] Yeah, people being buried alive. Yeah. [0:00:53] Girl bosses setting people on fire. [0:00:56] It's all great. [0:00:56] Yeah, Kievan Rus is the precursor state of modern-day Russia, Ukraine, and Belarus. [0:01:02] They put the Rus in Russia. [0:01:03] Yes, yes, they did. But before we proceed, I just want to caution against saying that Rus is medieval Russia, because this is really a big problem in the historiography of the East Slavic countries. [0:01:18] And a huge political fight. [0:01:19] Oh, it's huge. And it's been going on for over a century at this point. This is not Russian history. This is the precursor to Russian history, as well as Ukrainian and Belarusian history. And both of these states also have very valid claims to this legacy. And to say medieval Russia is really to privilege the Imperial Russian perspective. The idea that, you know, the Russians are the original and Ukrainians and Belarusians, they're just, you know, these derivative micro-people who speak these like fake languages that are just very derivative of Russian. [0:01:52] Which isn't actually true. If anything, it's really just historical chance that Russia proper was the East Slavic country to become predominant and not Belarus or Ukraine. [0:02:02] Yeah, and yeah, history has a funny way of working. [0:02:05] But anyway, before we proceed, Sam, you live in New York and Liam, you live in LA. What do you guys know about what was going on in these places in the 10th century? [0:02:14] In the 10th century, the Tongva people lived in Southern California. [0:02:18] Yeah, it was Lenape here, I think. That's all I know. All I can tell you is the name. [0:02:23] Yeah, I know that the Lenape lived in the Hudson Valley. Yeah, that's all I know. Just Lenape. Don't know much about their history, frankly. Or at least I don't know their history in the 10th century, I would say. [0:02:32] Yeah, like this is a very common thing for Americans, especially, because our country is relatively recent in the grand scheme of things. We basically genocided the people who actually have a longer history over here. So history going this far back, it just doesn't seem very material to us. [0:02:47] Well, if you go over to Europe, if you go to a country like England, for example, I'm sure you'd find that the average English person knows much more about what was going on in England in the 10th century than the average American knows what was going on here. [0:03:00] Yeah, I'm sure, yeah, people in England, they might know something about the Vikings. They'll probably tell you the name Alfred the Great, but that might be it. [0:03:07] Yeah, they might know a ton. But once you go, especially as you keep going east, it becomes more important and more real. Especially in countries that only became independent in the last hundred or so years. [0:03:17] Absolutely. [0:03:19] Russians have a very different relationship to history than Americans. I'm not sure if you guys know this, but I'm Russian. I was raised in a Russian family. But Russians in general, like the Boomer generation, they are crazy well-read. Like, it's just really unfathomable for an American to ever really approach that level of literacy and knowledge. And, like, our generation is, I mean, they grew up after the Soviet Union fell. They grew up with the internet. They grew up with a lot more television. And so they got kind of America-brained, as I like to call it. But yeah, like for people of my parents' generation, you have people going back and reading works of history that were written all the way back in the 18th century, just reading these people like Lomonosov and Tatishchev. Whereas Anglos, they don't really know history books that old, really. Like we sort of know about like Rome and Greece, and we might know Gibbon's decline and fall of the Roman Empire, but we don't really, aside from that, read any other historical writers from the 18th century. [0:04:23] And this is really what, in as much as a national ethos can be said to exist in a generalizable way, the Russians are a deeply historical people. [0:04:32] Right, and I think that in particular, medieval history is a lot more present in the Russian imagination and in the Ukrainian imagination and in the Belarusian imagination than it is for Americans or even Brits. [0:04:46] Absolutely. Yeah, and I think that part of the problem with people reading medieval history in places that actually have medieval history is that, like, they maybe in high school read some excerpts from some chronicles that were just very dry and uninspired, lists of like when a hailstorm happened and the crops failed and suddenly cowpox is everywhere. But it doesn't have to be like this. [0:05:09] Russian history, to a large extent, is based on a very different kind of chronicle. And to give you guys some idea of how much Russians value their medieval history, in November 2016, right outside of Red Square, right by the Kremlin, by the Lenin Mausoleum, by St. Basil's Cathedral, just like across the street, they put up this giant statue of Vladimir the Great, who is considered like the first major prince of Kievan Rus'. Like it's huge. It's something like 50 feet tall. He's like, he has a very stern expression. He's holding a giant cross. And by the way, the fact that like this is across the street from the Lenin Mausoleum might not be a coincidence. [0:05:51] The two wolves of Russian history right there. [0:05:53] Yeah, so the fact that the Russian government cares enough to sponsor these kinds of statues about figures from over a thousand years ago really shows you how serious they are about history. [0:06:03] Yes. I think that that's the perfect example of how the early medieval past is so much more present in Eastern Europe than it is in Western Europe. Can you imagine if the British government would spend a million dollars building a statue of Edward the Confessor? [0:06:18] Yeah, exactly. And no one in France cares about like Philip II or whatever. [0:06:22] No, yeah, yeah. They hardly care about Clovis over there, which is fine. [0:06:26] I don't think that medieval history has to be part of a national consciousness. You know, this isn't a judgment. [0:06:32] Yeah, no, because that often has very creepy or very troublesome nationalist implications. [0:06:37] Yeah, like again, this statue is very unnerving. Like just Google Vladimir statue, Moscow, and look at it. [0:06:43] Yeah, that cross is fucking huge. [0:06:45] Yeah, no, yeah, absolutely. It's a nationalistic statement, I think. Its inclusion right next to the Lenin Mausoleum says something about how modern-day Russians perceive themselves. And I think that a big part of this episode can be describing that link. Why exactly is the history of the Kievan Rus so present in the modern-day Russian and Eastern European in general nationalist imagination? [0:07:11] Yeah, so why don't we give you guys an introduction to Kievan Rus by introducing you to the first girl boss, possibly ever. Olga of Kiev ruled the Rus as regent for her son Sviatoslav after her husband Igor was dismembered violently while collecting tribute from the Slavic Derevlians tribe. The primary chronicle says, After the killing of Igor, the Derevlians said, See, we've killed the prince of the Rus. Let us take his wife Olga for our Prince Mal, and then we shall obtain possession of Sviatoslav, and work our will upon him. So they sent their best men, 20 in number, by boat, to Kiev. Olga was informed that the Derevlians had arrived and summoned them to her presence with a gracious welcome. The Derevlians announced that they had slain her husband because he was like a wolf, crafty and ravenous, but that their princes were good, and they explained that Olga must now come and marry their Prince Mal. [0:08:09] Olga thought and made this reply: This pleases me. Indeed, my husband cannot rise from the dead, so I can marry again. I desire to honor you tomorrow in the presence of all my people. Return now to your boat, and I'll send for you on the morrow. The people of Kiev worried that night that when the Derevlians returned, Olga would marry this foreign prince and that they themselves would be slaves. But that night, Olga commanded that a large deep ditch should be dug inside her castle. The next morning, Olga sent for the strangers. Her messengers approached them and said, Olga summons you to a great honor. But they replied, We will not ride on horseback nor in wagons, nor go on foot. Carry us to Olga in our boats. So Olga's men picked up the boats of the Derevlians and walked them with the boat on their shoulders over to the castle. [0:08:58] And the Derevlians were so proud at this display, they were puffed up in their benches. They were carried all the way into the great hall, but as soon as they were brought before Olga, instead of setting the boat down, Olga's men dumped the boat into the ditch, trapping them underneath it. The men cried out in pain and said that this was even worse than what they had done to Igor. But Olga then simply commanded that these men be buried alive underneath the boat. But did she stop there? No, she did not. Olga then sent messages to the leaders of the Derevlians, saying that if they really required her presence, they should send after her their most distinguished men. And when the noblemen of the Derevlians arrived, Olga then commanded them a bath should be made ready and invited them to appear before her after they had bathed. [0:09:42] The bathhouse was then heated and the Derevlians entered it to bathe. Olga's men closed up the bathhouse behind them and she gave the orders to set it on fire from the door so that the Derevlians were all burned to death. Yeah, but that's not the end of the story. Olga then sent to the Derevlians the following message. I am now coming to you, so prepare great quantities of mead in the city where you killed my husband, so that I may weep over his grave and hold a funeral feast for him. When they heard these words, they gathered great quantities of honey and brewed mead. Taking a small escort, Olga made the journey with these, and upon her arrival at Igor's tomb, she wept for her husband. She bade her followers pile up a great mound, and that they had piled it up. She had also given them the command that a funeral feast should be held. [0:10:29] Thereupon, the Derevlians sat down to drink, and Olga bade her followers wait upon them. The Derevlians asked Olga what happened to the nobles who had been sent to her. She replied that they were following her husband's bodyguard. When the Derevlians were drunk, she bade her followers follow upon them and went about herself egging on her retinue to the massacres of the Derevlians. So they cut down 5,000 of them. But Olga returned to Kiev and prepared an army to attack the survivors. [0:10:58] That's crazy, like 5,000 men. That must be enough, right? She's finally had her revenge? [0:11:03] Nope. [0:11:03] No. [0:11:04] The next year, Olga and her son Sviatoslav gathered a large and valiant army and proceeded to attack the land of the Derevlians. After many great victories, Olga hastened with her son to the city where her husband had been slain. The Derevlians barricaded themselves within the town walls and they fought valiantly from it, for they realized that because they had killed the prince, if they surrendered, a terrible fate would await them. Olga waited a full year at the city gates, but the Derevlians did not lose their resolve. Unable to wait much longer, Olga needed a plan. Her men approached the gates of the town with a message, asking the Derevlians, Why do you persist in holding out? All your other cities have surrendered. They've submitted tribute. Their inhabitants can now cultivate their fields in peace, but you would rather die here of hunger without submitting to tribute. [0:11:52] The Derevlians replied that they would be glad to submit to tribute, but they feared Olga wanted much more than tribute to avenge her husband. Olga answered, Since I have already avenged the misfortune of my husband twice on the occasions when your missionaries came to Kiev, and a third time when I held a funeral feast, I do not desire any further revenge. After I've received your tribute, I shall go home. The Derevlians asked her then, What is the tribute you want? And Olga said, Give me three pigeons and three sparrows for each house. I don't desire a heavy tribute, because I know you are impoverished by the siege. The Derevlians were confused by this request, but they rejoiced at her mercy, and for each house they collected three pigeons and three sparrows, which they sent to Olga with their thanks. As soon as Olga got the birds, she gave each soldier in her army a pigeon and a sparrow, and ordered each soldier to attach to the bird a piece of sulfur bound with a large piece of cloth. [0:12:52] When night fell, the soldiers released the pigeons and the sparrows, and they flew back to their nests in the eaves of the houses. And with that, the whole town was lit aflame. Not one building survived. The people fled from the ruins, and when they fled, Olga ordered her soldiers to hunt them down. Many were killed outright. Others were captured, made slaves for Olga and her followers. The survivors were left alive to pay a heavy, heavy tribute. [0:13:21] Daenerys Targaryen is obviously taking notes right now. [0:13:24] God, yeah, no, no, I gotta say, George R. Martin, he's a plagiarist. Come on. [0:13:29] From the story, we can really clearly see that the Rus are the most valiant of the East Slavic people and that they're. [0:13:35] Yeah, at least according to myth. Yeah, yeah. [0:13:38] These are pretty ruthless people. [0:13:39] But are they East Slavic? And that is the big question of the history of the Rus. Are they East Slavic after all? [0:13:48] I think before we go too deep into the Rus, we'll return to them pretty soon. Let's just do a very quick dive into the earlier history of the Slavs. If anyone's not familiar, Slavic languages are a really major group of the Indo-European language family. Russian, Polish, Czech, a whole bunch of languages. Most languages in Eastern Europe, are part of the Slavic family. [0:14:10] Bosnian, Serbo-Croatian, Bulgarian. [0:14:13] Yeah, yeah, so many. There's too many to list. But interestingly, these languages weren't spoken in their current locations until relatively recently on a linguistic time scale. Really, until about 1500 years ago, the Slavs were just a tiny blip on the map of Europe. Today, Slavic peoples live in roughly half of the European continent. And also, because of Russia, all the way east to the Pacific Ocean. [0:14:42] The first record we have of potential Slavic people are this group called the Veneti, later known as the Wends, if you want to read about this, Russian Sam. [0:14:52] We're coming back to Tacitus. We're coming back to Germania. [0:14:56] Yeah, and any old heads will know Tacitus from our ancient Germanic episode. [0:15:01] Yeah, so here's what Tacitus has to say about the Veneti. I do not know whether to class the tribes of the Peucini, Veneti, and Fenni with the Germans or with the Sarmatians. The Veneti have borrowed largely from Sarmatian ways. Their plundering forays take them all over the wooded and mountainous country. Nevertheless, they are to be classed as Germani, for they have settled homes, carry shields, and are fond of traveling fast on foot. In all these respects, they differed from the Sarmatians who live in wagons or on horseback. [0:15:30] And I find this passage kind of interesting because he's basically suggesting that, like, to be a Sarmatian or to be a Germani isn't really an ethnic marker or a linguistic marker as much as it is about the way you live your life. [0:15:45] Right, and that's a really good point because that's why it's such a tricky issue and so problematic to try to link modern ethnic identities with these ancient tribal groups because they almost always thought of themselves very differently than their modern descendants might think of themselves. [0:16:00] I think we should also point out that he keeps mentioning the Sarmatians in that quote. If anyone's not familiar, Sarmatians, who were basically a type of Scythian, if you know that name, they were these nomads who formerly lived across much of Russia and all the way into Central Asia. And although they aren't really around anymore, except for a tiny group in the Caucasus, they actually spoke a language closer to Persian than anything else, which is interesting. [0:16:27] Wait, are they the ancestors of the Ossetians? [0:16:29] Ossetians, yeah, Ossetians, yeah, that's right. They're still around, at least in some places. [0:16:34] Yeah, they still speak their language. [0:16:36] Yeah, but they used to be all over Russia. And the main change was that the Slavic peoples moved in. So like I said, the Slavs went from being a tiny blip in Northeast Europe to occupying, or I shouldn't say occupying, to settling across like 50% of Europe today. [0:16:54] And all the way to the Pacific. [0:16:55] All the way to the Pacific, yeah. The ancient Slavs were probably closest to the Baltic peoples, like the Lithuanians, you know, but they pretty quickly started expanding elsewhere. [0:17:05] Yeah, it's an insane amount of spread. [0:17:07] Yeah, yeah, they pushed into the land of the Scythians and Sarmatians. And I'm hoping in the future, actually, we can do an episode just on the connection between Slavs and Scythians, because it's pretty interesting. [0:17:19] But in any case, the Slavic migrations totally changed the linguistic, cultural, ethnic map of medieval Eastern Europe. A big focus here was that the Huns had previously moved through, and when the Huns left, the Slavs were able to pour in. So by 500 AD, there's all these different groups in Europe, but by 700 AD, most of these groups are replaced by Slavs. The main groups you have by 700 are the Slavs, who have their various divisions, also the Khazars in Southeast Europe along the Black Sea, who we'll get into later. So even though this was a huge migration, at least in terms of its impact, we don't really know too much about it because Slavic peoples at this time were not literate, at least not widely literate. This means that all of our sources from 500 to 700 are foreign writers, mostly Greeks or Franks from Central Europe. [0:18:15] And the fact that most of what we know about these people comes from outsiders is going to be a recurring theme in this episode. [0:18:21] Yeah, early medieval historians were not very good at distinguishing Eastern European peoples from each other. And a lot of the references to tribes that we have from those times, they may have been early Slavs, but they are often described as Scythians or Turks, regardless of what they actually spoke. [0:18:36] It's just like we said before, how there's a lot of confusion and question about what actually is an ethnic group, what constitutes an ethnic group. [0:18:44] Exactly, yeah. [0:18:45] There's a lot of references to different and probably overlapping groups like the Obotrites, the Wends, the Lechites. [0:18:52] Yeah, and the Wends, as we mentioned, those are the ones that Tacitus noted before. So that's one of those possibly overlapping ethnic labels that comes up again and again. [0:19:01] Yeah, who were this tribe that invaded the Byzantine Empire, the Eastern Roman Empire, in 518, which would mark the start of a 1500-year-long Slavic presence in what's now Bulgaria. And then eventually the Antes would become a vassal tribe of the Byzantines, which is basically the same thing that happened to the Goths a century earlier. [0:19:16] But the most important Slavic group to enter this historical record would have to be the Rus. [0:19:21] Yeah, so what do we know about the ancient Rus and how do we really know it? [0:19:26] Well, what's funny, one thing that a lot of people listening might know about the Rus, which is going to be a main point of contention in this episode, was even though they were an East Slavic group, did they have Norse origins? Just spoiler alert, the answer is yes. The question is to what extent was this Norse origin important? But the cool thing is that the word Rus most likely comes from the word Roa, which was the Norse word for rowers, which is kind of funny. And there's some Norse sources that mention Rothsmen who went all the way east into continental Eurasia. And a lot of these guys were presumably never heard from again. [0:20:02] And the original pronunciation of Rus is closer to Ruos. [0:20:05] Vikings love to row and raid territories as we went over in episode 15. [0:20:11] Yeah, yeah. [0:20:11] Last Kingdom, yeah. [0:20:13] So unfortunately, there aren't really any substantial surviving primary sources from the Rus that was from before the 11th century that was written by the Rus themselves. But we do have a bunch of other sources. [0:20:24] Right. We have a couple scant references from other Norse people, not the Norse who went into Russia, but the ones who stayed home. So there are some Skaldic poems and all that that discuss people who went east, the eastern route. There are a lot of runic inscriptions that talk about somebody who had gone east. Presumably this means into the Baltic and Russia. What's kind of interesting is that in the Icelandic sagas, the name for Russia is Gardariki, which I think comes from this Slavic word Gorod, which means fortified town, which is kind of interesting. [0:20:58] Novgorod. [0:20:59] Yeah, yeah. And Reek, the Reek part means kingdom, you know, like how in German today, Frankreich or whatever is France. Really, what Gardariki means is the kingdom of cities or the kingdom of forts. That's what they called Russia. [0:21:11] Yeah, because it was a very urbanized society, as we'll get into a bit more. [0:21:15] Yeah, right, which totally goes against the stereotypes a lot of Westerners might have of Russia. The fact that it was not this, like, you know, totally rural plain. It was actually very developed, probably more so than much of Western Europe at this time. [0:21:28] Another kind of funny name that some Scandinavians used for Russia was they actually just called it Greater Sweden. Because from their frame of reference, if you're in Denmark, Sweden is the easternmost thing you know. So anything east of there is just Greater Sweden. And I think that's kind of funny. [0:21:43] Well, the Swedes continued to harbor those ambitions all the way until the 17th century, so. [0:21:47] Oh, yes, that's true, yeah. And the fact that I think a big theme in this episode is going to be arrogance and expansionist tendencies from Germanic-speaking peoples. And that right there is why this issue: were the Rus Slavic, were they Norse or a mix of both? [0:22:04] Is so contentious. [0:22:05] So, one of the bigger sources of information about the Rus in this early period are the Byzantine sources, which have a lot more to say. So, in the year 860, the Rus raided Constantinople and the surrounding areas. This is from Serhii Plokhy, The Gates of Europe, which is a history of Ukraine. Patriarch Photius, the supreme Christian and imperial official in the city, called for divine protection in his sermons and prayers. In one of his homilies, he described the helplessness of the inhabitants before the invaders. The boats went past the city, showing their crews with swords raised as if threatening the city with death by the sword. And all human hope ebbed away from men, and the city was moored only with recourse to the divine. The intruders were gone by August 4th, when Photius attributed the city's miraculous survival to the protection of the Mother of God. [0:22:50] This grew into a legend that laid the basis for the later celebration of the Feast of the Protection of the Mother of God, Pokrova. Ironically, the feast never took hold in Byzantium, but became extremely popular in Ukraine, Russia, and Belarus, the lands from which the Vikings had come to attack Constantinople. [0:23:05] And another big source we have is this text called De Administrando Imperio, which means on governing the empire. So, here, authored by around the year 950, this is probably the most extensive Byzantine source about the Rus. And this text is really kind of a guide for foreign policy. So, it basically says, you've got these dangerous Rus guys right on the frontier. How do you deal with them? And one thing it says that's kind of interesting is that you can play the Rus off of the Pechenegs, another tribal group, and get them to fight each other. Because as long as they're at war with each other, that means Byzantium is going to be safe. But if the Rus are ever at peace with the Pechenegs or ever conquer the Pechenegs, then Constantinople is going to be next. [0:23:50] Yeah, and sometimes the Rus and the Pechenegs would come together to raid Constantinople, so watch out for that. [0:23:56] Yeah, me and the boys, you know, raiding those rich Greek guys and taking home some booty. [0:24:01] I guess sometimes, though, relations with the Rus and the Byzantines were peaceful because Constantine actually wrote another book called The Book of Ceremonies, which just detailed all the stately visits during his reign. And one of the stately visits was Girlboss Supreme, Olga of Kiev. So she actually is mentioned in this book, and it seems like her encounter with the Byzantines was very peaceful. [0:24:23] Another big source from this time are the medieval Arabs, who in this era were really having their heyday. And so Al-Yaqubi and Al-Masudi both interestingly refer to the Rus as Majus, which is related to the word Magi and means Zoroastrian, which is kind of interesting, because, you know, the Zoroastrians are non-Muslims. The Norse, the Rus are non-Muslims. So these Arab Muslim writers, they start kind of conflating the two, which I think is very interesting psychologically. [0:24:54] Yeah, and you also dug up the fact that Europeans would call Viking Saracens, which was, you know, the word for Muslims. [0:25:00] Absolutely, yeah, absolutely, yeah, yeah. That comes from Children of Ash and Elm, which is a source I've used a couple times in this episode. And yeah, by the high middle ages, after the Vikings were gone, you start having, like you said, Western European writers would basically confuse the Norse Viking pagans with Muslims, because they saw all non-Christians as the same. [0:25:22] Do you want to read Ibn Fadlan's text? This is probably one of the most famous sources we have about the Rus. And because the Rus at this time were probably still basically Vikings, this text had a very big impact on the popular perception of Vikings worldwide. [0:25:39] So he was a faqih, which is, in essence, someone who deals with fiqh Islamic jurisprudence. And he was sent as part of an Abbasid embassy to the Volga Bulgars in 921. He encountered many different peoples, and the Rus were among them. There's a lot of interesting anthropological information, including descriptions of a funeral, but also this. They are the filthiest of God's creatures. They do not clean themselves after urinating or defecating, nor do they wash after having sex. They do not wash their hands after meals. They are like wandering asses. Every day a young servant girl comes every morning with breakfast and with a great basin of water. She proffers it to her master, who washes his hands and face in it, as well as his hair. He washes and disentangles his hair using a comb there in the basin. Then he blows his nose and spits and does every filthy thing imaginable in the water. [0:26:26] When he has finished, the servant carries the bowl to the man next to him. She goes on passing the basin round from one to another until she has taken it to all the men in the house in turn. [0:26:37] So, Europeans have always been disgusting. [0:26:42] Oh, yeah, anyone who's watched the 13th Warrior with Antonio Banderas has seen that scene in a movie. [0:26:48] I mean, look, Islam values cleanliness. Wudu is a part of, like, it is an actual important thing. So, of course, they would have been horrified at seeing the just squalor. [0:26:59] Yeah. [0:27:00] Although, I should note, this, like, this crude display of cleanliness is probably a lot better than other parts of Europe at this time. [0:27:07] Yeah, like, at least they were brushing their hair in the first place. [0:27:09] Oh, no, he would have had a heart, he would have had a heart attack if he visited some other places. [0:27:13] Oh, for sure, yeah. [0:27:14] England, Ireland, yeah. [0:27:15] Well, hey, Russian Sam, tell us about the Slavic sources we have from this time. [0:27:19] Yeah, so the main Slavic source that we have is the so-called Povest Vremennykh Let, which in English is known as the Rus Primary Chronicle, which is really the most important source both for the focus of this episode as well as for understanding these various national mythologies. [0:27:37] Right, right, and just to go a little bit deeper on that point, it's because this is the best source explicitly connecting the Kievan Rus with Scandinavians. Because I don't know if we made this clear enough, but the predominant theory is that the society of the Kievan Rus was established when traders or soldiers from Scandinavia came into Russia. Into what's now Russia, we should say. Right. [0:28:00] I'm just going to say Rus Primary Chronicle so you guys don't get confused. But for this episode, I'm mostly relying on the translation of the Laurentian Codex by Samuel Cross. And that one is from the city called Vladimir-Suzdal, which is really one of the first cities to be brought up. And unlike the Western European Chronicles of this time, the Primary Chronicle was written in the vernacular of the time, which was Old East Slavonic. So it... [0:28:26] So people were writing this in the language that they actually spoke in their day-to-day life. And I'm sure that had something to do with the fact that it's a very engaging text. [0:28:35] Yeah, yeah. [0:28:37] This is what we were reading before when we told the story of Olga of Kiev, you know, what she did to all the emissaries and then how she, you know, burned the city with birds. So it's a very fun text. [0:28:46] Yeah, so traditionally it's thought that the primary chronicle was authored by a guy named Nestor the Chronicler, who lived from the middle of the 11th century to the beginning of the 12th century. But there are doubts. Some people think that Nestor may have been just a compiler of various fragments, and some other people think that Nestor wasn't involved with the project at all. He just had his name attached to it because he was kind of a big deal in his day as a writer. There are really, really huge problems with the text, chronology being chief among them. Like whoever compiled this text just hated getting their dates correct because they just keep giving the wrong years. Yeah, so for example, the Rus Primary Chronicle says that Olga went to Constantinople in 955, but the Book of Ceremonies, well, it's kind of unclear when exactly she visited, but it's either 942 or 957. [0:29:39] Yeah, yeah, and I think to jump on that, so there's definitely some question about how legitimate the Primary Chronicle is as a history source. But, but and for instance, we don't even know if Rurik and Olga were necessarily real people, to be honest. [0:29:53] But there is indisputable archaeological evidence that there was a lot of Norse activity in Russia at this time, particularly coming from modern-day Sweden. We have a lot of evidence of boats of Viking artifacts found in modern-day Russia. And interestingly, we also have a fair amount of Russian artifacts found in Viking graves, suggesting that these guys were bringing back a lot of plunder from Eastern Europe. [0:30:19] Yeah, and one of the most famous Norse sites in what is today Russia is a place called Staraya Ladoga, which is sort of like right on the border of what's today Finland. [0:30:29] Well, it's right, it's right on, it's right next to modern St. Petersburg, right? It's pretty close. [0:30:33] It's in the same oblast, so like it's probably a couple of hours to get there. [0:30:37] Okay. [0:30:37] But that settlement was founded around 750. [0:30:41] Yeah, which is pretty early. So that's before the Vikings started raiding Britain, even. And Britain's a lot closer to Scandinavia, I think, or about it. At least it's no farther than Russia is. I think like Russia is closer. [0:30:56] I seem to remember that they started by raiding the Baltics originally. [0:31:01] Oh, okay. So I guess, uh-huh, okay. [0:31:03] Then like they basically plundered all they could plunder and they started to have to go further afield. [0:31:08] Oh, okay. That makes sense, yeah. [0:31:10] Yeah, so that's Staraya Ladoga. [0:31:13] But speaking of cities, speaking of old cities, Kiev, you may know it today as the capital of Ukraine. And of course, it's the city that gives its name to the so-called Kievan Rus', which is not something they called themselves. It was just an invention of the historiography. Not that it's bad, but it's not what they would have called themselves. [0:31:33] Yeah, no, it's the same as the Byzantines. They would have just thought of themselves as Romans. [0:31:36] Romans, yeah. [0:31:37] And I think that I think it's quite interesting and very important that the Rus were so central to the history of Kiev and vice versa, because that presents an interesting historical problem. You have Belarus, you have Russia, and you have Ukraine all claiming the Rus as their heritage. But the fact that the Rus were basically based out of Kiev, a city in modern-day Ukraine, might be troublesome. [0:32:00] Well, it took them a while to be based out of Kiev. [0:32:03] Yeah, because Kiev is quite, it's very far from Scandinavia. It's really quite far down south. [0:32:08] They would have gone down, they would have rode all the way up the rivers, like the Dnieper and the Don, as far as they could. Yeah, so back to Kiev itself, it's a very old city. Quite it predates the events that we're going to be talking about by centuries. [0:32:22] Yeah, and I think that's quite significant because, like we said, the Vikings called this land the kingdom of cities. They were surprised by the level of development and urbanism, which wasn't found in Scandinavia at this time. And I think that's really important to keep in mind as we talk later on about the ways that this history has been abused by people who think that Scandinavians or Germans or whatever are somehow superior to Russians. Or even that there's just this big separation between these people all throughout history, which, as we've shown here, is just not true. [0:32:57] Yeah, no, there was a lot of contact during this time between Eastern Europe and Scandinavia. Yeah, so according to legend, and this comes to us from the Primary Chronicle again, Kiev was founded by this guy called Kyi and his two brothers Shchek and Khoriv, as well as their sister Lybid. And here's what the Primary Chronicle has to say about them. While the Polyanians lived apart and governed their families, for before the time of these brothers, there had already been Polyanians, and each one lived with his gens on his own land ruling over his kinsfolk, there were three brothers, Kyi, Shchek, and Khoriv, and their sister was named Lybid. Kyi lived on the hill where the Borichev trail is now, and Shchek dwelt on the hill now named Shchekovitsa, while on the third resided Khoriv, after whom this hill was named Khorevitsa. They built a town and named it Kiev after their oldest brother. [0:33:54] These men were wise and prudent. They were called Polyanians, and there are Polyanians descended from them living in Kiev to this day. [0:34:01] And I find the story quite interesting because the three brothers trope is extremely common in Indo-European mythologies and stories. [0:34:08] Yeah, yeah. [0:34:09] Yeah, so for example, in Hinduism you have the triumvirate of the most important aspects of God being Brahma, Shiva, and Vishnu. And then in the Greek pantheon, you have Zeus, Hades, and Poseidon. The Nordics have the same. [0:34:21] Yeah, Nordics have Odin, Vili, and Ve. And then for more earthly stories, the Goths have an origin story, again involving three brothers named Hamdir, Sorli, and Erp. And of course, finally, you have the famous Slavic origin story of Lek, Czech, and Rus, who basically ended up settling in different places because they went to hunt different animals. And that's really cool. I think the fact that the origin story of Kiev seems to tap into such an ancient mythological tradition might speak to the antiquity of Kiev. [0:34:54] Yeah, and also interestingly enough, there is some evidence that Kiev really was a conglomeration of three towns before it became united under one. And another name for Kiev that has survived thanks to Constantine VII says that Kiev, also known as Sambataz, which is, you know, another name for Kiev. And the most common explanation for this is that this is really a Turkic word, because, you know, the Khazars ruled this land for centuries. So one hypothesis is that it means strong heights, a high fortress, basically. Right. [0:35:26] Yeah, actually, just one quick note in the Khazars, or a couple quick notes right now that we should mention because they become important to this story, that this is a time when much of modern-day Russia was Turkic speaking, which is pretty interesting. So there are still remnants of this today with groups like the Chuvash and the Tatars. The Khazars, though, were one of the main groups at this time. Probably, and the most famous thing, which a lot of you guys listening are going to know, is that they famously converted to Judaism, which is probably the only time, or one of the only times in history, that such a large group of people have converted en masse to Judaism. It was probably only the nobility, but in any case, it was a pretty significant event. And this has led to a lot of very interesting historical discussion and a lot of very wild speculation, oftentimes very irresponsible speculation since then. [0:36:13] Yeah, so the Primary Chronicle says that people of Kiev paid tribute to the Khazars for a very long time. But there is also an alternative etymology which says that it might come from the Nordic word sambad, which is basically a place where tribute was collected. [0:36:28] And I've personally found this explanation very interesting because was there perhaps a Rus Khaganate? [0:36:34] So the earliest reference to Rus that we found is one from the year 839. It's from a chronicle called the Annals of Saint Bertin. It's West Frankish. So basically, think northeast France and Northwest Belgium. So the entry for the year 839 reads. Theophilus also sent with the envoys some men who said they were called Russians, Rus, and had been sent to him by their king, whose name was Khagan or Khagan. Theophilus requested in his letter that the emperor, in his goodness, might grant them safe conduct to travel through his empire and any help or practical assistance they needed to return home. When the emperor investigated more closely the reason for their coming here, he discovered that they belonged to the people of the Swedes. And that's from the Annals of St. Bertin. [0:37:18] And what's funny is that that's probably right, that Sweden does seem to be the primary origin for a lot of the Norse people who went into Russia. So in other words, the Byzantine embassy sent to the court of Louis the Pious included representatives of the Rus who are said to be Swedish whose king called himself the Khagan, which is Turkic. [0:37:35] Yeah, so that really gives you an idea of the kinds of cultural synthesis that would have been happening at this time. It's really, you cannot break this into these were just the or the this is just the history of Ukraine or this is just the history of Russia. It's just not intellectually honest. [0:37:48] Yeah, no, absolutely, yeah. And what's kind of cool is that the word Khagan or Khagan continued to be applied pretty long into modern-day history, or at least into medieval history, for the Grand Prince of Kiev. And there's even graffiti in the Cathedral of St. Sophia that reads, God, save our Kagan. So this word was being used by everyday people, presumably, for a long time. In the 11th century, you have a Sermon on Law and Grace that repeatedly talks about our Khagans, Khagans. And then in the 13th century, the lay of Igor's campaign, you have many different references to Khagans. Said Boyan, songmaker of the times of old, of the campaigns of the Khagans, Sviatoslav, Yaroslav, Oleg. Hard as it is for the head to be without shoulders, bad it is for the body to be without head, for the Russian land to be without Igor. Yeah, so there you go. [0:38:41] Three princes of Kiev and Rus who get called Khagans. [0:38:45] Yeah, you know, one other interesting kind of potential Khazar link is that there's this anonymous writer known as the Bavarian geographer who compiled a list of peoples in Central Eastern Europe around 850-ish, and he mentions a group called the Rusi or Rutsi right next to the Khazars. So clearly, the Khazars and the Rus were in very close contact, even though they spoke different languages and had different religions. There seems to have been a lot of cross-pollination. [0:39:12] And if you think that this influence has gone into the dustbin of history, you would be very wrong. So Turkomongolic groups generally have these things called tamgas, which are sort of like royal seals. Like you put it on stuff to denote ownership. And the national symbol of Ukraine is the trident, the trizub, which was the personal Tamga of Vladimir. And fun fact, just something that I found very humorous. I mean, you know how nationalists are. Like, sometimes you just want to have a flame war, just do a little bit of trolling. So sometimes the Ukrainian nationalists use the fact that they use the Trizub to argue that they are in fact the true inheritors of the legacy of Rus, as opposed to the Russians, who basically had their national symbols Mongolized as a result of the Tatar yoke. And just leaving aside the Turkic origins of the tamgas for a minute, the Trizub was only adopted as a symbol for Ukraine in 1918 at the suggestion of the Ukrainian national historian Mykhailo Hrushevsky. [0:40:13] So it's not actually even an ancient symbol for Ukrainians. It was just dug out of history books. [0:40:19] Which isn't exactly unique in the world's nationalist symbols. [0:40:21] I mean, the Star of David is another obvious example. [0:40:24] Yeah, and speaking of Vladimir, Vladimir was descended from this guy named Rurik, who was sort of the center of contention for this episode a bit. And I just want to start out by saying that I'm not a fan of the great man of history theory. I don't think it's very helpful for understanding what's actually going on, but given the kinds of sources that we have, there's just no way to structure this without talking about the reigns of these various princes. [0:40:52] Yeah, as much as we want to behave like proper Marxists here and not do any great man stuff, if you're talking about the Chronicle, it's hard not to. [0:40:59] Yeah, unless you're just going straight archaeology, it's difficult to avoid that. And especially considering that this is something that preoccupies so many people to this day. [0:41:06] Yeah, so according to the Primary Chronicle, the Vikings first made an appearance in 859 when they successfully imposed tribute on the local peoples. But in the next few years. In 860 to 862, the tributaries of the Varangians drove them back beyond the sea and refusing them further tribute, set out to govern themselves. There was no law among them, but the tribe rose against tribe. Discord thus ensued among them, and they began to war against one another. They said to themselves, Let us seek a prince who may rule over us and judge us according to the law. They accordingly went overseas to the Varangian Ruses. These particular Varangians were known as Ruses, just as some are called Swedes, others are called Normans, English, and Gotlanders, for they were thus named. The Chuds, the Slovenes, the Krivitchians, and the Ves then said to the people of Rus, Our land is great and rich, but there is no order to it. [0:42:00] Come to our land and rule over us. Thus, they selected three brothers with their kinfolk, who took with them all of the Ruses and migrated. The oldest brother, Rurik, located himself in Novgorod. The second, Sineus, at Beloozero, and the third, Truvor, in Izborsk. Yeah, so before we continue, again, three brothers. [0:42:20] Yeah, I also think it's kind of cool that it's a very multi-ethnic group. So, like the Chuds and the Vesses, they are of a Finnic origin, like, you know, obviously modern-day Finns, Slovenes and Krivicians, they're Slavs. And then Turkic peoples were also around, and Magyars, too, had recently arrived in Europe from the steppe. Add the Norse to the mix, and this is a really interesting, very diverse cast of characters at this time. [0:42:44] Yeah, so Rurik, he supposedly reigned from the year 862 to 879. [0:42:49] By invitation, supposedly. [0:42:51] Yeah, what do you guys think of this? Does this sound legit to you? [0:42:54] I'm skeptical. I can imagine a situation where there was Norse contact before. There might have been some kind of dynastic dispute, and this guy swept in to pick up the pieces. But considering the history of Viking settlement and conquest in so many other parts of Europe, I think it seems a lot more likely that there was a violent conquest of this part of Eastern Europe. And later on, historians claimed it was by invitation to make it maybe a little more flattering. [0:43:21] Yeah, I would agree. Yeah, and in fact, there's even some question about whether Rurik existed in the first place, because basically the above passage and like two more sentences in the Primary Chronicle, plus maybe a couple of more in some of the other variants, these are the only sources we have for Rurik's existence. [0:43:38] That's crazy. And that's crazy because for so many centuries, the ruling family of Russia claimed direct descendants from Rurik. [0:43:46] Yeah, into the 20th century. [0:43:48] Yeah, well, when the Anglo-Saxons first got to England, they also believed that they were descended from Odin. Even the Christian writers talking about them thought they were descended from Odin. [0:43:57] Yeah, yeah, yeah. [0:43:58] So if Rurik is mythological, that would definitely not be out of keeping for European dynastic clans. [0:44:04] Yeah, no, that's something you find all over the world, from England to Japan. [0:44:09] But, but, there is another theory. There's a theory that explains who Rurik is supposed to be. And the prime suspect here is a guy named Rorik of Dorestad, who was basically a man of Danish origins, a Viking who ruled parts of what is today the Netherlands and northwestern Germany. And he was said to have been born around the year 800. His father had received this land, and then later, when he himself inherited the land in 843, it was taken away from him from the Carolingian emperor, Lothair I, and the guy basically went on to become a pirate, just raiding, going back to his ancestors' ways. [0:44:49] Interesting. [0:44:49] So, clearly, Rorik was a nuisance because Lothair basically returned his lands to him in 850, but then he took them back again in 855. [0:44:59] His tantrum worked at least for five years, yeah. [0:45:02] And of course, also in 850, we have this note in the Frankish annals, which suggests that this guy Rorik was presumably kind of a rock star in his day, if there's multiple sources of him, you know. So, this one says: Rorik the Northman held the vicus Dorestad with his brother Harold in the time of the Emperor Louis. After the deaths of the emperor and his own brother, he was denounced as a traitor, falsely, as it said, to Lothair. He was captured and imprisoned. He escaped and became the man of Lewis, king of the Eastern Franks. He stayed with the Eastern Lewis for some years. He collected a not insubstantial force of Danes and began his career of piracy, attacking places in the northern coast of Lothair's kingdom by the North Sea. He came to Dorestad, seized it, and held it. Because the Emperor Lothair was unable to drive him out, he was received back into fealty. [0:45:51] And then he pops up again in 863. In January, Danes sailed up the Rhine towards Cologne after sacking the emporium called Dorestad. Then they reached a certain island and they encamped there until about the beginning of April. The Danes therefore followed Rorik's advice and withdrew. Yeah, so at this point, Rorik is basically on the side of the Carolingian Emperor again, convincing Vikings to, you know, go back where they came from and not raid this place. I mean, then he shows up yet again in 870 when Charles the Bald, quote unquote, went to the palace at Adiem again to hold discussions with the Northman Rorik, whom he bound to himself by a treaty. And of course, it should be noted that the dates given here totally contradict the primary chronicle. It's impossible for Rorik to have been both in the West and the East. [0:46:38] I like the idea of a Rus Emperor Jimmu, who just doesn't is just completely mythical, but I could see it if the idea of this kind of borrowing of this guy and his legacy. Yeah, the Vikings moved around so much that I wouldn't be surprised if a guy who'd previously been in Germany and then raided Friesland had gone over into Russia. But I think it's probably more likely there were just like multiple people running around named Rurik. I think that's probably more likely. [0:47:04] I agree with Liam, yeah. [0:47:06] Yeah, so Rurik lived until 879. And I mean, shortly before he died, the Primary Chronicle says that these two men called Askold and Dir asked him to go down south to Constantinople, but of course, that's not what they did. Instead, they just captured Kiev and started ruling it. And this is actually a very interesting moment because we do have a reference to a king named Dir found in the book called Meadows of Gold by al-Masudi, who is like one of the big Abbasid era historians. And he refers to, quote, King Eldir, first among the kings of the Saqaliba, which was the Arabic word for Slavs. [0:47:47] But I hear you asking right now, where's Askold? What happened to Askold? Yeah, so according to one theory, this was just one guy. So apparently, there is this old Norse word called Oskilder, which translates to strange. So basically, the theory here is that the chronicler who was compiling this information didn't recognize this as a Norse word. He assumed it was the name. So rather than being, quote, Dir the Stranger, it just becomes Askold and Dir. [0:48:15] Right, yeah. And I should note that Dir or Dyer the Stranger is a name that a lot of Crusader kings players might know because he's one of the default characters in the Viking Age part of the game. [0:48:25] Yeah, so Askold and Dir, they're ruling Kiev. They're living it up, having the time of their lives. They took Kiev away from the Khazars. Now the Polyanians are paying tribute to them. [0:48:35] You should add that these guys are seen basically as the usurpers, right? Like Rurik was the rightful leader, and then these bastards have come in and taken the city from him. [0:48:42] Yeah, and so before Rurik died, he had a relative named Oleg the Seer, or his Norse name would have been Helgi, who reigned from 879 to 912. And the Primary Chronicle tells us that once Oleg had heard that Askold and Dir are living it up down south and basically, you know, stealing territory from the son of Rurik, who was supposed to actually rule this land, he decides to go pay them a visit, just a friendly chat with some soldiers. Oleg, he goes down south to Kiev. He presents himself as just the normal traveler who is on his way to Greece, and he asks to meet Askold and Dir because he's also a Norseman. And I mean, hey, we're of the same race. We should hang out a little bit. It's the thing I say to my friends all the time. Askold and Dir, they take the bait, they come out, and they're suddenly surrounded by all of these troops. [0:49:38] And then before killing them, Oleg says, You are not princes, nor even of princely stock, but I am of princely birth. And then he killed them, which really highlights the central point of the primary chronicle, which is basically to gas up the Rurikids to say that they are the only legitimate rulers of Russia possible, and that if you're not one of those guys, you have no business ruling Russia. [0:50:02] It also seems to imply that the Rurikids are just an especially nasty and devious ruling dynasty, because not too long after Oleg comes in, you've got Olga, who mentioned before, who used all of her famous treachery to consolidate power across modern-day Russia and Ukraine. [0:50:20] Yeah, well, Olga wasn't so bad. Sometime after this, I guess she felt kind of bad about what had happened, and she goes down to Constantinople and decides to become a Christian, which is why she's currently a saint in the Eastern Orthodox Church. And it's not that Christianity was totally foreign to this area. In fact, we have some references going back to like the second or third century about Christian missionaries working among the Scythians. [0:50:46] Specifically Orthodox Christians, I'm guessing. [0:50:49] Oh, of course, yeah, that would have to be, yeah, yeah. Yeah, of course, the rest of the Rus wouldn't be Christianized for a little bit later, but before that happens, the Rus go back to Constantinople, this time, not as friendly. There's the famous attempted sacking of Constantinople, where all these Viking ships go down into the Black Sea, but Greek fire, they burn up, you know. [0:51:12] I think that a famous season two of Game of Thrones moment might have been inspired by what really happened here when these ships were burned up by Greek fire. However, they did, not too long after, succeed in sacking Itil, which was at the time the capital of the Khazars, and this probably is what led to the eventual disappearance of the Khazars from the historical record. [0:51:34] Yeah, they hung around for like a century more, but after that, they just sort of disappeared. And instead of the Khazars, you suddenly have a new Turkic steppe group on the scene called the Pechenegs. [0:51:43] Right. Yeah, yeah. Constantine mentioned this before. [0:51:45] Although I gotta say, come on, like, what's cooler than like a Jewish barbarian Turkic tribe? Come on. Like, personally, I think the Khazars should have stayed around. I think it's a real shame of history. [0:51:56] And speaking of religion and speaking of the Khazars, I think we should talk about now. Let's go back to Vladimir the Great. And this is the guy, mind you, who now has a big-ass statue in Moscow right next to Lenin's tomb. [0:52:08] Yeah, so Vladimir the Great, he ruled from 980 to 1015 or thereabouts. And he got a lot done during his reign. He considerably expanded the territory under his domain, but he would also be most famous for embracing Christianity in the year 988. But this actually wasn't his first foray into experimenting with religion. In fact, a couple of years before that, he decided that he needs a state religion, and he thought he was going to accomplish this by doing a formalization of these pagan cults. So basically, paganism isn't really a thing, it's just like the stuff that the peasants believe. [0:52:47] Yeah, yeah, yeah. It certainly was rarely a coherent ideological practice. [0:52:51] So Vladimir was trying to create an official state pantheon featuring gods like Perun, who is the Slavic thunder god. [0:52:59] The thunder god, yeah, yeah. I think Thor is believed to be a cognate of Perun oftentimes. [0:53:04] Oh, and of course, and Chernobog, for anyone who's seen Disney's Fantasia, he makes an appearance. [0:53:08] But unfortunately for Vladimir, being pagan at this time was not a great way to make friends. [0:53:15] No. And just as a tiny, you know, just as a tiny bit of context for here, this is the end of the 10th century, around the year 1000. You see a whole bunch of groups of people in Europe becoming Christian at this time. The Poles around the year 1000, the Danes around the year 1000. So I think Vladimir might have known which way the winds were blowing. The only holdouts essentially are in like the Baltics, I think. [0:53:37] Yes, the incredibly Chad Lithuanians kept on for a while. [0:53:41] Vladimir did not have that resolve, clearly. Yeah, well, so the story, which some people might know, because this is another story that's somewhat well known, is that before he officially became Christian, Vladimir was visited by emissaries from a whole bunch of different religions. [0:53:56] So in 996, Vladimir was visited by a missionary from the Bulgars of the Muslim faith, who told him, Though you are a wise and prudent prince, you have no religion. Adopt our faith and revere Muhammad. Vladimir inquired what was the nature of their religion. They told him they believed in God, and that Muhammad instructed them to practice circumcision, to eat no pork, drink no wine, and that after death, there would be complete fulfillment of all their desires. Muhammad, the Bulgars asserted, will give each man 70 fair women. Vladimir listened, for he was very fond of women in indulgence. But circumcision and the ban on pork and the ban on wine were disagreeable to him. And here, Vladimir said his famous line: Drinking is the joy of the Rus. We can't exist without that pleasure. [0:54:42] That's it, I guess. We're going back to paganism? [0:54:44] No, they did not have the commitment to do that. Yeah, yeah. Next came the Germans. Thus says the Pope: Your country is like our country, but your faith is not like ours. We worship God who has made heaven and earth, but your gods are only wood. Vladimir inquired what their teaching was. The Germans replied, Their faith was about fasting according to one's strength. But whatever one eats or drinks is all the glory to God, as our teacher Paul has said. Then Vladimir answered, Depart from here. Our fathers accept no such principle. And last, the Jewish Khazars had heard of these missionaries, and they came forward with their own. [0:55:20] But I think, unfortunately, for this part, I'm gonna need you, Halal Sam, to read this. [0:55:25] The Christians believe in whom we crucified, but we believe in one God, of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. Then Vladimir inquired what their religion was. They replied that its tenets included circumcision, not eating pork or hare, and observing the Sabbath. Prince then asked where their native land was, and they replied that it was in Jerusalem. Hey, see, Zionism is correct. No, I'm kidding, of course. It's evil. When Vladimir inquired where that was, they answered, God was angry at our forefathers and scattered us among the Gentiles on account of our sins. Our land was given then to the Christians. The prince then demanded, How can you hope to teach others while you yourselves are cast out and scattered abroad by the hand of God? If God loved you and your faith, you would not thus be dispersed in foreign lands. Do you expect us to accept that fate also? [0:56:07] Which, honestly, as a Jew, I kind of understand the argument that, hey, God clearly hates you. [0:56:12] Yeah, you know what? Something tells me that these aren't the most accurate representation of these interactions. [0:56:18] No, I don't think that the Khazars came and going, hey, so how about that Jesus we killed? [0:56:26] Yeah, well, yeah, that's true. [0:56:27] We should mention that, although there is a lot of question about the historicity of all of these stories about the Rus, the Rurikids themselves did keep power for a very long time in the sense that for about 700 years, the ruling family of Russia called themselves the Rurikids. So we mentioned before that the English saw Odin as their mythic ancestor. I think this is even a more direct comparison because the name of their house is simply the House of Rurik. I would even wonder if the fact that the Rurikids lasted so long maybe has something to do with the fact that the early origins of the Rus and the Rurikids are such a big part of modern-day history, you know? Because the Rurikids didn't lose power until the end of the 16th century. [0:57:14] And then just a little bit more than a century later, in the early 18th century, this is when you see interest in the Kievan Rus really pick up again. [0:57:24] Basically, this was the reign of Peter the Great, the great reformer. And as part of his reforms, he was trying to modernize Russia, which is basically bring Russia into a modern European fold. And of course, all of these states were at the time in the process of creating their own national historiographies, their own national stories and myths. Yeah, so naturally, Peter wanted Russia to have the same thing. So one of the people he invited to Russia for this purpose was a German, Friedrich Müller. [0:57:53] He was from Leipzig. [0:57:54] Yeah, he was invited to Russia to co-found the Imperial Academy of Sciences, which isn't just sciences, by the way. Science is a very broad definition here. It also includes history and the humanities. And Müller, he was one of the first people from Central or Western Europe to have a strong interest in the history of Kievan Rus'. And he basically saw their Scandinavian origin as a link between Russia and the German-speaking West. So he published a number of papers basically arguing that it was in fact the Scandinavians who had brought civilization to Russia that they had built all these great cities because obviously the Primary Chronicle says that they were always fighting each other unless they had a Viking to rule over them. [0:58:43] So we should mention this is a really tricky time for this argument to be made because this is really the start or not too long after the start of European colonialism where there begins to be this kind of increasing trend toward the idea that Western Europe, which generally includes Germany, is superior to other parts of the world. And so when you have this German guy, even a German guy invited to Russia, making this argument, it starts to have some unfortunate implications. [0:59:12] Very unfortunate. [0:59:12] Yeah, yeah. [0:59:13] Yeah, but not everyone was on board with this project from the very beginning. In fact, one of the other co-founders of the Imperial Academy of Sciences, who was actually Russian, was also one of the early historians. His name was Lomonosov, and he basically just got so outraged by Müller's arguments that he just yelled at him incessantly to the point where Müller was just afraid to present any more of this work until after Lomonosov had died. [0:59:42] It's funny. [0:59:43] But yeah, not all Russian historians actually were as strongly anti-Norman as Lomonosov himself. [0:59:50] We should probably define what that means. When we say Norman, we're not talking about the Normans in France and in England. We mean the fact that Normanism was the name of the theory that the Rus had a strong Scandinavian influence, and that anti-Normanism was either the rejection of any Scandinavian influence and the denial that the origins of the Rus were in Scandinavia, or a more moderate stance that says there was some Scandinavian influence, but it was not the prevailing cultural climate of the Rus. [1:00:22] Like, we've been at a point now for a very long time where it's just physically impossible to deny that there was indeed a Viking element. [1:00:29] Oh, yeah, yes, yeah. Vikings were everywhere. They were definitely in Russia. They were doing a lot in Russia. [1:00:34] Yeah, so the only people who are still saying, no, no, there were no Vikings, it was entirely Slavic are cranks. [1:00:40] Yeah, yeah. [1:00:41] And basically, this has been the question at the heart of Russian historiography ever since the question was raised, all the way back in the beginning of the 18th century. And not all Russian historians were as anti-Norman as Lomonosov. Karamzin, for example, who was another famous early Russian historian, he was not totally on board with Müller's argument, but he was like, yeah, okay, there's something here. He's exaggerating it, but we can't really deny that this was an element. Basically, as things stand right now, anti-Normanism was strongly associated with Soviet historiography. This wasn't the anti-Normanism of the cranks. This was just saying that the Slavs had already started to build a foundation of civilization. Obviously, they were building all these cities. And they couldn't have done that if they were not capable of governing themselves. They would have had trade networks. [1:01:38] No, absolutely. [1:01:39] And I think that what we should add that while we're talking about cranks, we really need to mention that in the 19th and early 20th century, you started seeing a lot of Western European cranks really hyping up the potential Norse origins of the Kievan Rus, basically as a way to suggest that somehow all that is great about Russian civilization had to be the work of Germans or Swedes because they believed that those groups were somehow innately superior to Russians. [1:02:06] I think an interesting analog to this is how a lot of racists in America denied that the mounds of Cahokia could have been made by Native Americans. They thought that they were simply incapable. [1:02:19] Or then when the Boers got to South Africa and Zimbabwe, when they saw the famous castles of Great Zimbabwe, they assumed that, oh no, that could have been the Africans who built that. It must have been somebody else who built those castles. [1:02:31] Yeah, it's just these people must be too primitive. They cannot possibly get. [1:02:35] Right. And this is what's happening here. [1:02:36] You know, most notoriously, actually, and unsurprisingly, Hitler, Adolf Hitler, was very invested in this theory, the Normanist theory. And he claimed that if the Vikings had not civilized the Russians, they would be still living like rabbits, in his words. And, you know, considering what Hitler would wreck upon the Russian people very shortly thereafter, that's just a disgusting thing in context. [1:03:01] Exactly. No, this has real historical, this has real implications in even relative recent history. [1:03:07] Yeah. [1:03:07] So I really, yeah, so even though it's, even though anti-Normanist theories often go too far, it's pretty hard to fault Russian historians in context for wanting to move away from the idea of Scandinavian influence over their earliest histories. [1:03:23] In this day and age, there's no escaping the racial science implications of it. [1:03:28] Yeah, so you want to tell us about the Viking of Prague, William? [1:03:31] Sure, because this is actually, this is a perfect case study. So in 1928, a Ukrainian archaeologist named Borkovsky found a 9th or 10th century skeleton underneath the castle of Prague, which is, yeah, pretty cool, like this old skeleton. And like many early medieval skeletons, he was found with all these martial grave goods, armor, and weapons. But what was funny about this guy was that unlike other skeletons found in the region, his grave goods were totally Scandinavian. He had a Viking helmet, a Viking sword, a Viking shield, the whole works. So presumably, this guy was probably a migrant from Scandinavia, right? Probably he was a mercenary or a merchant. He got to Prague, and then maybe, you know, he ate something bad. Next thing you know, he's dead, and they buried him there. But this has some interesting political implications. Because barely a decade after this was discovered, the Nazis rolled to Prague. [1:04:22] And now, a whole bunch of Nazi archaeologists and Nazi historians start going into the archives and they learn about this skeleton and they start getting really interested in the so-called Prague Viking. And a German historian named Lothar Zotz, which I gotta say, if you need a name for a Nazi scientist, it's hard to get better than Lothar Zotz. He declared that the presence of these Viking weapons had actually proved that, therefore, Prague must have been founded or conquered by ancient Germanic peoples. Therefore, there's a precedent for the current Nazi occupation, and that it's only natural for Nazis or Germans to rule this area. And as soon as this happened, Borkovsky was actually forced to quit all of his ongoing research that would have basically shown that no, everything else in this site is incredibly Slavic. There's just one guy who might have been from Scandinavia. [1:05:15] Yeah, and the really funny thing about all this, I mean, especially now that we have access to DNA sequencing technology, is that the Czech people are basically the same, they have the same ancestors as the Germans. They just happen to have been assimilated into a Slavic culture. [1:05:31] Race, ethnicity, these are all, these are social constructs. So the Nazis were convinced that different groups were inferior to others, but within the confines of Northern Europe, especially, there's really not a standing distinction. [1:05:43] But, anyways, thankfully, the Nazi reign in Prague would not be that long. Six years later, it comes under Soviet control, and again, there's a strong interest in the so-called Viking of Prague. But this time, there's a totally different perspective. Because this guy has Scandinavian artifacts that were associated both with the Swedes and the Danes, but also with the Kievan Rus, from the Soviet perspective, this actually suggests that maybe this guy had connections with the Rus, which kind of implies maybe just as the Nazis thought it was natural for Germans to be occupying and wrecking Prague, the Soviets were wondering: maybe it's a little more natural for Prague to be in the same sphere as the Rus. [1:06:27] This stuff has very clear implications in the modern world. [1:06:30] Yeah, no, of course. You find one guy who maybe is from a place, buried in another place, and you just claim that, you know, that's your place. [1:06:39] Yeah, so it's the year 2021. We've gone quite a long way since the Viking of Prague and whatever the Nazis and the Soviets wanted to make of him. So, what was actually the state of Scandinavian influence? What did they actually leave behind? So, there's now a general agreement that the Scandinavian element of the Rus was both very large and unusually socially diverse. Judging by the material culture, they appear to have primarily come from Svealand and the Malar Valley, which was the heart of Viking Age Sweden. And despite their significant numbers, these Scandinavian immigrants seem to have merged rapidly with the Slavic population. Assimilated, in other words. And this transition in material expressions of identity may represent the formation of a class-based community in which the expressions of ethnicity were not prioritized as a means of identifying between different groups. [1:07:27] Yeah, yeah, the really remarkable thing about the Rus is that even though all these guys had Viking names, all the way up to Olga, who was Helga, after a certain point, they just started having Slavic names. [1:07:41] Although, actually, the names are one of the few elements that kind of stick around. I've come across some guys from like the 13th century who are still named Ingvar. [1:07:51] Yeah, some of them, yeah, some of these Norse influences were lasting. [1:07:54] Yeah, another example perhaps is the institution of the druzhina, which is sort of like your retinue of warriors. And that very much reminds me of the Norse model, where you basically Tavas have a sort of a charismatic personality, and then you have a retinue of warriors. [1:08:11] His boys, yeah, his fellows, yeah, yeah. [1:08:14] And of course, we should mention that the influences at this time they really went both ways. Like, it wasn't simply that this, like, you know, the amazing Vikings bringing their amazing Viking culture to Russia. You also have Scandinavia absorbing a ton of Eastern influences. One of the kind of most famous influences is that you start seeing Eastern clothing styles, popular in Russia, Byzantium, even Iran and the Middle East, coming into Scandinavia. Like, at the beginning of the Viking Age, you see Scandinavians wearing like very tight leg wraps. By the end of the Viking Age, they're wearing these big baggy pants, the kind that you might imagine Aladdin wearing. In addition, evidence also suggests that the Vikings who were operating in Eastern Europe probably weren't all conquering warlords. A lot of them were actually, really were there in some kind of invited context, usually as mercenaries. A lot of our listeners probably know that some Vikings served in the Varangian Guard. [1:09:10] We've talked about Varangians before. That was the Greek word for the Scandinavians. So a lot of them actually were guards of the Byzantine Empire. There's famous graffiti on the Hagia Sophia left by Vikings, but others actually served as mercenaries in Georgia and among the Khazars who've been talking about. One thing that's pretty cool is that in the Swedish city of Birka, there are all these burials of Scandinavian people wearing Turkic armor, presumably from the Khazars. So this suggests that a lot of these Vikings who went into Khazar land probably absorbed some of these cultural influences from the Khazars and they bring them back with them when they go home. [1:09:49] And, I mean, of course, the migration of people wasn't unidirectional. You had people going both ways. There was an early Icelander named Geirmund Hjorsson, who was the son of a Scandinavian merchant and an indigenous Siberian woman. He's been nicknamed quote-unquote black-skinned for his unusual appearance, but there's really no evidence that he would have been seen as a permanent outsider. And he became one of the early leaders of Iceland. [1:10:15] Yeah, one other little bit of evidence for foreign people arriving in Scandinavia is that there's the famous Oseberg burial, and that one of the people in this burial is a woman of Iranian or possibly Turkic ancestry, which is pretty wild. And even though she's a foreigner, she doesn't appear to have been a slave or a servant because she was buried in really fine clothing and jewelry, which suggests that maybe she was the wife of a chieftain or maybe she was a very important noblewoman or merchant in her own right. But for some reason, her ancestors had been from a more eastern part of the world. You know, you can imagine maybe one Norse guy marries off his son to the daughter of a Khazar chief and they both go back to Scandinavia. You know, there's a lot of ways that we can imagine this happening in a time when there are these clear, ongoing, bi-directional links between Scandinavia and Eastern Europe and Iran. [1:11:08] And in right about that, I would just like to say one more thing. Of course, this shows that people have always been moving around, that there's really no such thing as like a purebred anyone. But all that being said, you shouldn't really confuse this stuff for our modern-day interpretations of multiculturalism or something like that. These people would not have been conceptualizing these things in this way at all. And in fact, they often did have some very violent conflicts. But it's also important to push back on the idea of that there's some sort of primordial race for driving history and that people have just always been killing each other by default. [1:11:45] Yeah, no, no, we talked before about the dangers of the kind of the bowling ball or billiards ball model of history, that it's kind of a paradox where there's been a lot of human migration in history, but it's not as simple as discrete cultural groups moving from one place to another. [1:12:03] What do you think, guys? Have we solved the Rus question? Are the nationalist historiographers of Russia, Ukraine, and Belarus going to unite around us? [1:12:11] I think that's it. [1:12:12] Yeah, yeah, I think we solved it. [1:12:14] You know, Russians, Ukrainians, Belarusians, they have nothing to argue about. I think if they all say they're brothers anyway, why can't they just get along? You know? [1:12:22] We have healed the schism between the Russian, Ukrainian, and Belarusian peoples. Yeah, yes. [1:12:28] So if anybody, if you have Russian nationalists, friends, relatives, politicians, Ukrainian nationalists in your family, Belarusian nationalists, if any of you guys are Lukashenko's 15-year-old son, listen to this podcast, have him listen to this podcast, have your mom listen to this podcast, and we together can solve the problem of Slavic nationalism. [1:12:49] Yeah, Gladio Free Europe is the only pan-Slavic podcast. Let that be known. [1:12:53] Yes, and I think with all that said, thank you so much, Russian Sam, for putting together this really fun episode. And don't be dinner to everybody. [1:13:00] Yeah, great job.