Gladio Free Europe, E84: The Ainu Before Japan https://www.gladiofreeeurope.com/episodes/the-ainu-before-japan [0:00:18] And we are back after a brief delay to Gladio Free Europe. I am Liam, joined here by the incredible Russian Sam. [0:00:26] Hello, hello. [0:00:27] And we have a really exciting, really cool episode, a lot to go over. I think we're just going to jump in. As you can tell by the description, we are going to the northern island of Hokkaido, the north of the main islands of Japan, to take a look at the absolutely incredible, unbelievably fascinating Ainu culture. The indigenous people of this island, whose history, both before, during, and after contact and eventually conquest by the Japanese is just so interesting. The Ainu story has a lot of parallels to other colonial narratives. There's a lot of attention given to this kind of topic, comparing the history of the Ainu to that of other colonized peoples. We're going to talk about that. But this is such a big topic. We're going to have to split this into two episodes. This first episode is really going to focus on the history of the Ainu before Japan. [0:01:26] Russian Sam, you really led the research for this one. You've just done some incredible work digging up so much of this history. Do you have any thoughts on the Ainu more broadly and how you first became interested in this topic before we dive in? [0:01:39] Yeah, well, I'd vaguely known about the Ainu for a very long time, as all Wikipedia warriors are wont to do. I just grew up on the internet, and of course, I got to hear all about the mystical white people of Japan whose origins are unknown. [0:01:55] Right. The Amazon. Yes, yeah, we'll certainly get into that myth. [0:01:58] Yeah, yeah. Something that I hadn't realized before deciding to expand the scope of this episode to cover the entirety of Ainu history is that I had known a little bit about the colonization of Hokkaido and how the Japanese had treated the Ainu in many ways that paralleled what the Americans had done to the natives. But as I began to look into this history, I saw that this kind of treatment actually predates American contact by a very long time. The Hokkaido process was, of course, in the context of a very rich intellectual process that spanned the Pacific Ocean and that incorporated all of these discourses that were cropping up in the Americas. But as it turns out, a lot of these events that we're going to be covering began independently of outside influence. Yeah, so this really led me to the conclusion that I feel like the stuff we associate with American settler colonialism was probably much more common in history than we give it credit for. [0:02:58] And we just don't really know because this kind of research into history from this particular lens is so recent. [0:03:05] Right, right. [0:03:05] And I think also that there are very real connections, not just parallels, between American and Japanese colonialism that we're going to get into in the next episode. There were American advisors brought in to help with the 19th century subjugation of Hokkaido. But additionally, you have to understand this process in the specific lens of Japanese history, which is a very different scope with very different concerns and processes going on. And what I think is so interesting is that the colonization of Hokkaido in the later 19th century happened at the exact same time that the southernmost islands, the Ryukyuan Islands, like Okinawa, were formally being integrated into Japan. So there's just really kind of parallel expansion of the state, with unfortunately very bad repercussions on the people who are already living there. The Ainu language is nearly extinct. It is just absolute anthropological tragedy. And from what I understand, the Okinawan language is doing better, but it's not doing great. [0:04:03] And this kind of shows that, you know, even though the colonization of Hokkaido and the conquest of Okinawa weren't that similar, Okinawa was a much less settler colonial process. There are interesting parallels, and I would certainly guess very similar motivations. Both of these places are, you know, home to minority cultures whose relationship to the main ethnic group of Japan, the Yamato, is complicated. Generally speaking, the Okinawans and the Ainu are not considered Japanese, but many Japanese people do want to include them in that umbrella. And there's been a lot of forced assimilation in both groups. And so, this question of the apartness of the Ainu has been of huge interest both to Japanese and to Western scholars, who often bring a lot of their own baggage to this question that really obscures Ainu history and culture rather than explaining it. There is this very long history of people making wild guesses about the relationships that the Ainu might have to other people. [0:05:04] You mentioned one of them earlier. All of these guesses have basically been proven incorrect for the most part. But we're going to go into all of this. And really, with this episode, we want to explain the Ainu on their own terms, independent of their relationship to cultures with a more, you know, rigorous written record. Because recent breakthroughs in archaeology have allowed people in and outside Hokkaido to understand the past of these people much, much more clearly. That really gives you a better understanding of what kind of relationships existed with Japan before the colonization. Before we do all that, though, let's mention that Gladio Free Europe, although it's a free podcast, we've got a Patreon. If you guys are enjoying what you're hearing, please feel free to, you know, give us a donation. We're doing this for fun. This is not for profit or anything, but if you guys want to show your support, we would certainly appreciate that. [0:05:54] Also, if anybody has any suggestions for future episodes, totally give us a shout out. We'd love to know what kind of topics you want to get into next. [0:06:04] Yeah, absolutely. My DMs are open. They're kind of fallow. So just hop on in there and tell me what you think about this. And if there are any other particular directions you'd like me to break my chops on. [0:06:18] All right, so let's jump in into the frosty island of Hokkaido. So as we mentioned at the top, there's been a long history of the Ainu being connected somewhat spuriously to other cultures, almost always simply on the basis of physical appearance. It's long been understood that the Ainu look a little different from other Japanese people. They're stereotyped as being hairier, with more robust physical features. A lot of times when somebody in Japan is, you know, particularly hairy or has a bigger nose than somebody else, people might say, oh, I bet you're part Ainu. I bet you've got some connection there. Because that's this kind of association in Japanese culture. This is why a lot of early attempts at Ainu anthropology from the West claimed some specific kinship with Europeans. We should say right now, this is not true. The Ainu have no relationship to the peoples of Europe. [0:07:12] That is not any more than other Asian cultures do. They are distantly genetically connected in the way that all humans are distantly genetically connected. But the Ainu are not some lost tribe of Caucasians. This is a really popular myth even today, and it's based on absolutely nothing except some complete coincidences in literal skull shape. It is, it's nonsense. This is this myth, though, is very central to the history of Ainu scholarship. It's been a big motivating factor in the European interest in the Ainu that really took off in the 19th century, but began a little bit earlier. We also should mention that although it's an area that's been pioneered by European scholars, the attempts to connect the Ainu to Europeans actually do slightly predate that interest because the very first references to Russians made by the Japanese after Japanese sailors and Russian sailors had some brief interactions were: hey, these guys look kind of like the Ainu. [0:08:12] So, in early Japanese records, up until I think until the early 19th century, Russians were sometimes referred to as red Ainu, based on this idea that their beards, their faces were kind of similar, just you know, with red hair, not black hair. But the Europeans very quickly jumped onto this comparison. This really took off the 19th century. There are some traces even earlier. [0:08:34] In 1548, when the Jesuits were very active in Japan, we've had a whole series of episodes on that. [0:08:40] Yep, 74 and 75. Go check them out. [0:08:42] Yeah, yeah. The first Japanese Christian, the pirate named Anjiro, described the Ainu to some Jesuits. He said that in the northeast is the island Ezo. The inhabitants thereof are white with long whiskers. They wear their hair on top of their heads. They are tall and they fight fearlessly, one against a hundred, just like the Germans. It's kind of funny, you know, they're already like making these parallels. Eventually, some Jesuits would meet Ainu people firsthand. One of them actually was Luís Fróis, who we also talked about before. He was the Jesuit who was a friend of Yasuke, who'd become probably only black samurai, as well as a close confidant of Oda Nobunaga. He would write, if you wanted to jump in here, Fróis was probably the first European among the few of the era who speculated on Ainu origins. [0:09:26] Like his Portuguese colleague João Rodrigues, who briefly referred to Ezo as quote the Tartar Island, Fróis called the locals Tartars and alluded to their quote long hair and beards hanging down as with the Muscovites. Another fellow Jesuit, Gaspar Vilela, looked for the answer in the opposite geographical direction. In a 1571 letter, he suggested that the Ainu were related to the Amerindians because the island was close to the American continent. That's from Kowner, From White to Yellow. But and by the way, he was actually accidentally correct, as we're going to get into. [0:09:56] Yeah, yeah, yeah, it is true. Like there certainly are much closer genetic connections between the Ainu and Native Americans. Not that close, you know, and there's been some interest in the fact that Ainu clothing and patterns look a little bit like some of the fashions of the Pacific Northwest. That's totally coincidental, as far as I can tell, but it's really interesting. You know, it kind of shows maybe that, you know, in a similar environment, a similar latitude, you start to see these, you know, similarities in material culture. That's all I can think of. A lot of shared interests in whales and salmon also, but again, that's just because that's like that's the plentiful food. [0:10:29] But eventually, as Christianity began to be looked upon with more suspicion by Japanese people, especially during the 17th century when it was eventually banned, some Japanese Christians actually fled to Hokkaido because conditions there were more lax. Jesuits followed them and would have even more contact with Ainu people, leading to even more speculation about their possible origins. There was some talk about trying to convert the Ainu to Christianity, but eventually the ban on Christianity would be extended so this wouldn't happen. [0:10:56] But we should mention that one Jesuit, seeing that the Ainu would actually incorporate cross patterns into their patient, was convinced that actually these people were somehow already Christian. And they speculated that Thomas the Apostle, who had supposedly died in India, might have actually made his way all the way up to Hokkaido and converted them. [0:11:15] Yeah, that rocks. Just back in the day, you could just say anything and get away with it. [0:11:19] Oh, absolutely. Yeah, no. And this is the backdrop for you. I mentioned before. There is a Japanese village in northern Honshu that believes Jesus died there. You know, it's kind of funny. [0:11:27] It's like, yeah. All right. But so after Japan became closed to most Europeans in the Tokugawa era, the Ainu would basically fade away from the European imagination and then be rediscovered in the 19th century with the Meiji Restoration, when this trade with Europe suddenly very quickly recommenced. There is not that much documentation about Ainu culture and identities before the 19th century, both because of European contact when a lot of Europeans were writing about Japan, but especially because, as we mentioned, the 19th century is when Hokkaido was colonized and formally brought into the Japanese fold. Like we said, this looked a lot like American Manifest Destiny. We're going to talk about this, but it means that before this period, what we know about the Ainu is much more scant. So we're going to have to talk about the Ainu less through very detailed written histories and more through the literary record, through folklore, through references to other peoples who we know had a very close relationship with the Ainu. [0:12:28] But still, even if this record is fragmentary, it paints a really compelling picture of the Ainu as this really fascinating, proud culture who were somewhere in between farmers and hunter-gatherers for a very long time, practicing a really interesting interesting lifestyle and with a lot of martial prowess that gave the Japanese people a lot of trouble for a very long time. [0:12:51] We should mention that although the word Ainu is used as an ethnonym in Japanese today, this actually isn't traditional. Throughout the Middle Ages and early modern period, the Ainu people were referred to as Ezo, the same word used for the island, Hokkaido. Ezo, it's a traditional word. The Ainu first enters the historical record actually through the Russians. It seems like it used to just mean human being, like many ethnonyms. It just means person, basically. So the first records we see in Japanese are that usage. And it's meant to really differentiate humans from animals or from the gods, known as kamuy. [0:13:27] Also, a big thing about the Ainu is that they are widely recognized as the indigenous minority of Japan, which has very important implications therein. But this status wasn't actually recognized by the Japanese government until 2019. Previously, the Ainu Shinpo, or the Ainu New Law of 1997, recognized the Ainu as a different ethnicity and called for respect to their cultural traditions, but had no real enforcement power beyond that. Then, just a couple years ago, the Ainu Promotion Act suddenly gave Ainu communities the right to petition for special access to natural resources, like forests that might have some ritual importance, or rivers and estuaries that could have economic importance for fishing to the Ainu way of life. There's also now suddenly specific funding to preserve the Ainu language. The language of the law obligates the government to adopt policies to facilitate people's understandings of the traditions of the Ainu and the importance of diversity that ethnic groups contribute to society. [0:14:27] This is a pretty big deal because there really is this overriding assumption in Japan that Japanese society is uniquely and fundamentally homogeneous. Obviously, that's not true. This has never been true. And the Ainu are the best example of how this cannot be true. That they are a culture who might have some interesting parallels and connections to the Yamato Japanese, but they really are not Japanese in the same sense. This law also bans discrimination against the Ainu for the very first time. This was hailed as a huge step forward because, like so many other indigenous cultures in North America or South America, prejudice against these people continues to contribute to really awful gaps in income and attainment. The Japanese sociologist Sakaya Saito argues that part of why this recognition took so long is that the very existence and the survival of the Ainu flies in the face of the nationalist self-conception of Japan as a homogeneous society. [0:15:24] And because the Japanese have long been understood as fundamentally culturally and physically distinct from the Yamato, many Japanese nationalists had viewed their existence as a threat to Japanese homogeneity and therefore stability. So historically, many Ainu had been treated much like foreigners. They were given these condescending compliments about how good their Japanese is. Although by this point, every Ainu speaks Japanese as a native language. Probably the most visible consequence of this legacy of colonization and discrimination is that the Ainu language today only has five native speakers. There's only a few hundred people who have any level of non-native proficiency, although classes are being expanded to some degree or another. [0:16:05] Yeah, yeah, I know, definitely. Not my place to comment on Ainu politics. It seems like this law in 2019 was definitely a huge step forward, but the status of Ainu culture in the Ainu language is so dire that I think a lot more drastic action will have to be done if this language is going to survive. [0:16:22] Yeah, right. It was very difficult to be Ainu in Japan for a very long time. As a result of this really long history of discrimination and forced assimilation, the Ainu today aren't very visible. There are around 25,000 people who identify as Ainu, but this is probably an undercount. Many people are still hiding their Ainu ancestry because of the stigma attached to it. Of that 25,000, around half of them live on the main island of Hokkaido, which is one of, but not the only traditional homeland of the Ainu. [0:16:52] Now, the Ainu call the lands that they inhabit the Ainu Moshir, the world of humans, which is also the name of a recent movie about the Ainu. It's okay. I watched it. I mean, it's like just the typical film festival fare about this teenage boy trying to come to terms with his Ainu identity. It's all right if you have like an hour and a half to kill it, but not my favorite, but it's unfortunately one of the only pieces of media about the Ainu. But anyway, in addition to Hokkaido, there's also small Ainu communities in what is now Russia, particularly on... [0:17:25] Yes, we'll get into that. [0:17:26] Yeah, particularly on Sakhalin and the Kuril Islands. The Eurasian Knot Podcast actually recently put out an episode about them. It's really funny. It's basically covering this Russian guy who decides to become a weeaboo for the Ainus and starts to talk about how gentle they are and how their traditions spanned for thousands of years. Just the usual noble savage fare. He's well-intentioned, but it really is cringeworthy at parts. But yeah, I would recommend listening to that to get a sense of what being Ainu is like in Russia. [0:17:58] We should mention that, unfortunately, just like in Japan, there is a very long history of mistreatment of the Ainu and that the Soviet Union would deport a lot of Ainu people to Japan when they took the Sakhalin Islands after World War II. [0:18:10] Right, and as a result of lots of assimilation, basically coerced assimilation, many Ainus today aren't that distinguishable from the Yamato Japanese. And because there's such a long history of intermarriage, the supposed physical features of the Ainu are not necessarily as visible as you might expect. But a century ago, the Ainu were much more culturally distinct. Like we said, they had really fascinating clothing with geometric designs incorporating like crosses and other geometric shapes that do look kind of like Native American designs, especially the Haida people. [0:18:38] Additionally, Ainu had a lot of really interesting tattoos. If some of our listeners are probably already familiar with the tattoos that women would wear, these really unusual black smiles tattooed on their face. Like, honestly, I hate to say it, but like, kind of like the Joker, which apparently would prevent evil spirits from entering through the mouth. These traditions are basically gone now, but the community continues to maintain many other customs to the best of their abilities. And unfortunately, in another parallel to Native Americans, many Ainu people have to reenact their very sacred customs to outsiders to earn a living. [0:19:17] For instance, by the 19th century, the Ainu had mostly reverted to a largely hunter-gatherer lifestyle after previously being much more agricultural. For various reasons, including prolonged contact with the Japanese and eventually dependence on trade with Japan for food, they mostly abandoned agriculture. Their lifestyle mostly revolved around fishing instead, and many of their settlements were right by the rivers. These settlements were called kotan and usually had just maybe five to twenty households. These kotan would be a few miles away from each other and they'd often be formed into political confederations called iwor. Resource rights were tied to individual villages and they had to come to agreements about allocations. But a lot of times these agreements fell through. And Ainu oral epics called Yukar have a lot of stories of different communities fighting about access to fishing rights or hunting in various forests. These conflicts were called topatumi and became much more common actually as a result of Japanese commerce. [0:20:17] Once Japanese goods started coming in, there was basically more to compete over. And because the Japanese lived right by the river, fishing was really important to them. In fact, their word for salmon literally means divine fish. [0:20:28] Yeah. [0:20:29] I saw one estimate that said around 40% of their calories came from fishing and around 30% each came from hunting and gathering, which doesn't include the rice that would be introduced by Japanese trade, so I'm not sure where that fits into it. But again, traditionally, they weren't doing rice cultivation, really. They were involved in various kinds of grains. [0:20:50] Right, right. [0:20:51] And I said, the importance here of like fishing rights and the kind of low-level violence between these communities over these rights, that reminds me a lot of what we talked about with the indigenous peoples of New England immediately prior to English contact. And I feel like it might not entirely be a coincidence because New England is actually on the same latitude as Hokkaido. This means that it's a very cold place in the winter. And so, in the winter, there's a tradition, a very important religious tradition, that the hearth, the fire in the center of the home, must never go out. And that is really essential even today to Ainu religion, the idea of this eternal flame in every household. [0:21:29] Yeah, they had a gendered division of labor. The men generally hunted, fought, traded, and carved, while the women would generally forage, make clothes, and mats, cook, and took care of children. But both men and women would fish. And as Liam mentioned earlier, the Ainu women were often very heavily tattooed, especially on the face. By the 19th century, the Ainu were mostly monogamous, but according to the Yukar, polygamy was very widespread in the olden times. For whatever reason, it just faded out of existence slowly. [0:21:58] Yeah, interestingly, and that's true with Japan too. Medieval Japan was incredibly polygamous and then stopped being so. [0:22:04] The Ainu religion is also super, super interesting. It's gotten a lot of attention kind of to compare it to Japanese Shinto. The relationship therein is very confusing and not quite known. I personally think that any similarities are probably through contact with Japan, starting in the maybe the 1500s and going into the 19th century, once, you know, Japanese speakers began living on Hokkaido. I don't think this speaks to any ancient connection, but there are some connections with the Japanese, with the Ainu religion and Japanese Shinto. The most obvious is that gods in the Ainu language are called kamuy, which is almost certainly a cognate with the Japanese word kami. But like we said, the Ainu religion is considered animistic, which means that traditionally, every living thing is basically considered to be animate in some sense. [0:22:55] Specifically, and this is to quote the text Ainu, Spirit of a Northern People, every being is a god and visitor to earth from the god world. These gods spend time on earth and make their bodies, their material forms, available to people for food, timber to build houses, grass to make mats, and elm bark for weaving clothing. People are meant to use these godly gifts, but must do so with respect, and after using them, must return the spirit to the world of the gods with a specific ceremony. The most elaborate sending ceremonies are reserved for the chief Ainu deities, bears, owls, and foxes. But even the spirits of small animals like songbirds or inconsequential objects like a broken kettle or knife may have to have its spirit sent off to the world of the gods with a special prayer. Ainu believed that when these rituals were denied, the earth would soon become barren and lifeless, for the gods would no longer be willing to visit to offer their material bodies and life. [0:23:51] Therefore, in this way, the Ainu pay respect to all worldly beings and treat them as living entities, as partners with human existence. [0:23:59] Yeah, and this is something we're going to touch on later, but if you guys are familiar with the Studio Ghibli film Princess Mononoke, you'll know that these kinds of themes should be vaguely familiar to you because a lot of, and because Miyazaki, he was a bit of an Ainu boo, and he really tried to incorporate a lot of these sorts of themes into this movie in particular. [0:24:24] Yeah. All right, so that's basically the status of Ainu culture and religion as of at the point of contact with Japanese settlers and European observers. But that is only a small portion of their history. [0:24:37] The Ainu have been around for a very long time, and obviously their existence greatly predates foreign contact. So let's get into who the Ainu were historically and what we know about their origins. Because I think what's so interesting here is that just as Japanese homogeneity is a myth, the Ainu are themselves not a homogeneous people. Rather than being some ancient snapshot of the Stone Age past, as many Japanese people once saw them, the Ainu themselves have a very illustrious history of contact with mainland Asia and with the Japanese main islands, including, as we'll get to eventually, they went to war with the Mongols. It's crazy, right? [0:25:15] Yeah. [0:25:15] All right, but let's, but we'll get to that later. So the peopling of Hokkaido really begins with the ancient hunter-gatherer people called the Jomon. We've talked about them before. They're super interesting. They made probably the coolest pottery in human history. Their name comes after this specific pottery style. They were very sophisticated hunter-gatherers who lived in Japan, all of the main islands of Japan, for a very long time. They had a sedentary hunter-gatherer lifestyle, which is pretty unusual. Those peoples of the Pacific Northwest, the Haida, are another rare example of this, where resources are abundant enough that permanent villages could be centered around foraging. Eventually, a group of people known retroactively as the Yayoi would come in, probably from China or Korea, who introduced metallurgy, rice cultivation, and especially the Japanese language. These guys are really the primary genetic and cultural ancestors of the Yamato Japanese, but they would intermix heavily with the pre-existing Jomon people, everywhere, really except for Hokkaido. [0:26:18] Pockets of Jomon-related peoples would exist throughout Japan in addition to Hokkaido, most importantly in the northern part of the main island of Honshu. Honshu is the big island where all of the famous Japanese cities are, like Tokyo, Osaka, Kobe, Kyoto, that's all in Honshu. But the northernmost part of Honshu, called Tohoku, was not the domain of the Yamato Japanese for a pretty long time, not until the Middle Ages. So again, the Ainu were once assumed to be a snapshot of this ancient Jomon past. This is no longer believed to be true. But despite that, the Jomon contributed a ton to the genetics of the Ainu people, and it's very possible that their language could be a descendant of whatever was spoken by the Jomon. [0:27:08] But genetics paints a much more complicated picture. As scientists have gained access to more samples of ancient Jomon DNA, as well as medieval and early modern Ainu DNA, it shows that the Ainu have always been in contact with neighboring peoples. 2017 paper published by Adachi et al. in the American Journal of Physical Anthropology shows that most of the matrilineal ancestry of the modern Ainu people is indeed related to the ancient Jomon, but their patrilineal ancestry is mostly from other sources. A mix of Japanese settlers who came not just in the 9th century, but somewhat earlier as well. But also, interestingly and somewhat surprisingly, there's a lot of Siberian ancestry as well that came over in the early Middle Ages. [0:27:51] Right, and we see that this actually lines up with the introduction of the Okhotsk culture on the island of Hokkaido around 1500 years ago. These people would have come down from the far east of what is today Russia, and they didn't have any of that Neolithic Jomon ancestry. Instead, they were much more closely related to the Paleo-Siberian cultures that still exist in that part of the world, like the Nivkh and the Evenk. And because the Okhotsk people contributed so much of the genetic ancestry to the Ainu, it's possible that the Ainu language is not a remnant of the language of the ancient Jomon, but instead a medieval introduction into Siberia. These debates are still ongoing. But just because a migration happened into Hokkaido doesn't mean that we can assume that the native language has to be replaced. We know that this was not the last major migration into pre-colonial Hokkaido either, because just 400 years after the Okhotsk culture came down from the north, a group known as the Satsumon culture migrated up from the south, which was probably the first migration into Hokkaido from the main island of Japan. [0:28:51] Right, right. And so the Satsumon culture is really cool because although it comes from Honshu, the main island of Japan, it wasn't Japanese. This was not a migration of Yamato Japanese people. Instead, it was a migration of other descendants of the Jomon. Because you know how we mentioned that the northernmost part of Honshu did not yet become part of the Japanese domain? This is the group that we're talking about. They enter the Japanese historical record as the Emishi. They are described as fearsome horse riders who are somewhat barbaric, but also incredibly brave. And they figure pretty prominently in both early Japanese history and especially Japanese literature and folklore. Because they apparently predate the arrival of the Yayoi and their Yamato descendants, they have traditionally been associated with the Ainu. I think this association is very important and real, as we'll get into. It's also a very complicated relationships. [0:29:45] Sometimes the Emishi are described as Ainu. This is incorrect. We have no idea if their languages were similar or even related, but they did have a very close cultural and economic relationship that became much closer with the formation of the Satsumon culture when a group of Emishi people crossed the straits from Honshu into Hokkaido. Around this time, once the Emishi start crossing into Hokkaido, you see these burial mounds called Kofuns start to pop up. These are pretty famous throughout Japan. The preceding period in the main islands is actually just called the Kofun period. So this shows that even though the Emishi were not Yamato Japanese, they had a lot of shared culture with the Yamato. And so a lot of Yamato traditions start entering the Ainu culture through these Emishi intermediaries. While Japanese literary sources associate the Emishi with horse riding, it doesn't seem like they brought horses with them to Hokkaido. [0:30:41] The Satsumon culture is not that kind of culture at all. It's possible that a horse riding elite took the island and then settled down, which is kind of the process you see in a lot of ancient societies. You know, like conquerors from the steppe eventually adopt the traditions of, you know, China or Europe. This happens a lot in the Middle Ages and the ancient past. [0:31:00] I also have the impression that a lot of the, as we'll get into, a lot of the Emishi were basically taken prisoner by the Japanese kingdom and forced to resettle in other parts of Japan where they often worked as soldiers. So I'm thinking maybe the people who escaped wouldn't have been this warrior elite, but rather the people who the Japanese saw no use for. [0:31:20] That's also possible, yeah, absolutely. An interesting thing about the Satsumon culture is that when they came to Hokkaido, they established a much more intensive agricultural culture than would exist later. So, this means that the people of Hokkaido in like the year 1200 were a lot better farmers than the people of 1800. One archaeological site called Sakushu Kotoni Gawa shows that they had a really huge variety of crops, a bigger variety than expected, and that they were basically growing every kind of crop you would have seen in the main island of Japan, which again really kind of belies the image of the Ainu as semi-nomadic hunters. Hokkaido in this period had access to plants even from mainland China, showing that they had a lot of connections with the outside world that again, you might not expect given the stereotypes of the Ainu as isolated. Over time, the material distinction between the Satsumon culture and the Siberian Okhotsk cultures would eventually dissolve away into what would be called the Tobinitai culture. [0:32:19] So, it really seems like eventually the various peoples of Hokkaido would come together really in the formation of the modern Ainu people, which seems to be mostly descended from, at least culturally, from these Emishi migrants. My personal guess, this is just a hunch, is that the Ainu language is probably related to the Emishi language. We have no idea if anything similar to this language was spoken prior to the arrival of the Emishi, but this might explain why the word for God looks a lot like the Japanese word for god, kamuy and kami, because the Emishi had a lot of contact with the Yamato Japanese that other peoples in Hokkaido probably would not have had. So, it's clear again that the Ainu are not any kind of primitive relic. Instead, they are a people who lived in this very dynamic medieval world with connections to other parts of Asia, including Siberia and China. [0:33:17] This kind of cultural contact is really what led to the development of the Ainu culture. So, again, both the Ainu culture and the mainland Yamato culture, even though they might appear somewhat homogeneous, have very interesting, very disparate origins. [0:33:30] And I think that's pretty cool. [0:33:31] And speaking of those connections, we see that there are a lot of similarities between Ainu religion as well as what's practiced in Siberia. And the most famous example of these is the bear worship aspect, which is found in Siberia and all the way into Finland. They traditionally had these kinds of rituals, which speaks to just how widely they got distributed. But anyway, one Ainu religious rite that's now protected under the 2019 law, which had been the subject of controversy for a very long time, is the so-called Iyomante ritual, in which a bear cub is kidnapped, worshipped as a god, raised by a village, and then ritually sacrificed. [0:34:09] Yeah, because it traditionally, in early spring, as the mountain snows begin to melt, Ainu men would go up into the hills to find hibernating families of bears. They would use poison arrows to kill the mothers in their sleep and then capture any newborn cubs they could find. The cubs would be taken back to the village and given to the care of prominent women, including usually the wife of the chief. And for the rest of the year, this baby bear would be raised in the village, treated somewhere in between a family member and a living god. [0:34:37] Yeah, for the record, they would even be breastfed by women. [0:34:40] Yeah, it's yeah, really, yeah, basically treated as a human infant. It's really interesting. And so they were treated this way for about nine months as they slowly got bigger and they started, you know, they would feed on breast milk and human food. And then eventually, once the bears were about a year old, because they would usually be kidding, they'd usually be taken when they were about, you know, a couple months old, suddenly it was basically time. It was decided that it was time for the bear to return to the world of the gods. So, the women who had been raising the bear would start brewing a huge amount of sake, usually made from millet, and they'd share it with the people of the village. And then they would get the bear, the little baby bear, drunk on sake too. Once the bear had gotten drunk, it would be taken out of the home and placed in a bamboo cage where it would be killed. [0:35:21] This caged bear would be shot with poison arrows, just like the kind that had killed its mother. And as soon as it was dead, the people would pray over its corpse and then skin the bear and turn its hide into this ritual object. According to Ainu religious beliefs, once the fur had been deified this way, the spirit of the bear had become an immortal god who would now watch over the village forever. The night of the sacrifice, people would then have a huge banquet in which the spirit was the honored guest. And they'd also invite in all of the ghosts of dead people from the village who were now able to come back to the town in this very important day. According to the anthropologist Takako Yamada, there was a sentimental aspect to this because it was understood that the ghost of this baby bear might be anxious or nervous about becoming a god. [0:36:06] So the children of the village would play games and sing songs to make the bear calmer and cheer him up during this potentially traumatic transition to the god world. The day after, the villagers would wake up and have a breakfast prepared from the meat of the bear cub. Once his body had become one with theirs, a member of the tribe would shoot an arrow into the clouds to clear a path for the spirit of this bear to enter the world of the gods. This entire ritual was seen as necessary to upholding the balance between the human world and the god world. And like we said, if they didn't do these rituals, it was believed that the gods would curse the earth and that punish them with bad harvests or less plentiful salmon stock. [0:36:44] Right, you can actually see videos of the ceremony being performed, although it can get a bit graphic for the record. So, if that's not your thing, I'll steal that. But yeah, it's really interesting. This ritual is actually the central plot point of that movie I mentioned earlier. [0:37:00] Oh, sure. [0:37:01] And again, this is usually seen as a connection between the Ainu people and the peoples of Siberia. One group that's particularly implicated in this is the Nivkh from far eastern Siberia. They are probably connected to the Okhotsk culture. Most likely, the people who came to Hokkaido in this time spoke something like the Nivkh language. And again, my guess is that the modern Ainu language was probably introduced later by the Satsumon, who were the Emishi migrants. I think that if we can infer anything about the Ainu from the Emishi, and that's one of the big ifs of this episode, it's not because they're both descendants of the ancient Jomon, but it's because of the Satsumon. These two cultures, the Emishi and the Ainu, who were themselves related, came much closer together in the early modern period with the formation of the Satsumon culture. For a parallel here, it's kind of like how Scotland and Ireland are both considered Celtic countries, but the reason why their languages are so similar is not because of the ancient Celtic peoples, but because the medieval Gaels introduced the Irish language, the Gaelic language, to Scotland. [0:38:08] If that parallel makes sense, I think that's kind of what's going on here. The Ainu and the Emishi had a shared origin, but the real reason of their similarities is because of their much later reconnection across the straits. [0:38:21] All right, let's get back to Japan and kind of get out of this dry archaeology and into the fun stuff, the historical record, because really it's all in color from here on out. So before we get to the Japanese written record specifically, there's one reference to be found to the Emishi and possibly to the peoples of Hokkaido as well, or at least to their ancestors in a really surprising place. [0:38:43] The Chinese Book of Song, which was written more than 1500 years ago, which is sort of a compilation of the official history of the Song dynasty, includes a letter sent by the king of Wa. [0:38:53] Oh, and just to confirm here, not the not the famous, not the Song Empire, but a much earlier Song kingdom. Same name, but different place. [0:39:02] Right, yeah. So, this king of Wa, which was what Japan was called back then, wrote the following letter: Quote: Since ancient times, our ancestors have donned armor and traversed mountains and rivers without a moment's rest. They campaigned to the east, subduing the 55 nations of the hairy men. To the west, they brought 66 assorted barbarian nations under their control, and crossing the vast sea to the north, they conquered 95 nations. [0:39:24] We should mention that the hairy men in Chinese sources usually refers to a mythological demon. In Chinese, it's called maoren, and it's possible that this is a complete fiction, but the details are really interesting because, first of all, they are campaigning to the east. That's northeastern Honshu, which is where the Emishi were indeed living. And then across the sea to the north, which is almost certainly Hokkaido, both the Ainu and the Emishi were stereotyped as being very hairy. At the very least, this passage indicates that very early into Japanese history, during the Kofun period that we mentioned earlier, the Japanese were either fighting military campaigns in Hokkaido or at least bragged to the more powerful Chinese that they were to show that they're not barbarians like the rest of the other peoples, you know? [0:40:05] Yeah, yeah. And then we get another reference to the hairy men around 200 years later in the new history of the Tang Dynasty, which records another encounter with the hairy men. It writes that in the year 663, quote, an envoy came to the Chinese court accompanied by some hairy men. The hairy men also dwell on these islands. The beards of the hairy men were four feet long. They carried arrows at their necks and without ever missing could shoot a gourd held on the head of a person standing several tens of steps away. [0:40:31] Unfortunately, this in and of itself isn't really much to go by, but thankfully the Japanese record from the 8th century onwards is much more extensive. [0:40:39] Particularly, there's a book called the Nihongi or the Nihon Shoki, which means the Japanese chronicle. [0:40:45] Yeah, and so this was composed in the early Nara period, which was when strong influences from mainland Asia really first started to take root in Japan. These influences included Chinese characters, which is the basis of the Japanese writing system today, the Buddhist religion, and also the art and architecture of the Tang court. If you ever go to the city of Nara, there's this absolutely beautiful temple complex that is directly based off of the layout of the Chinese capital of Chang'an. [0:41:11] Yeah, they were really big on copying the Chinese in every aspect they could muster, really. [0:41:16] Right, and this is why the Nihongi, this text, is written in Chinese, not in Japanese, which is pretty interesting. As a comparison, it's like how medieval Europeans would usually write in Latin, not in their local languages. This also means that just as medieval Europeans were very much influenced by the earlier Roman view of the world, using Roman and Greek classical references in their histories, the Japanese were very influenced by the Chinese view of the world. And so it's really important when looking at these early Japanese records, understand the ways that they might be deliberately imitating Chinese philosophical and political concepts. For instance, the entire view that outsiders are barbarians. They, you know, like although the Japanese would have been considered barbarians to the Chinese, just like how the Romans were considered barbarians to the Greeks, the Japanese then took this concept, flipped it around, and said that actually everybody who's not Japanese or Chinese is a barbarian. [0:42:09] Right. And there are a couple of references in the Nihongi to groups that appear to be ancestral to the Ainu, aside from the Emishi. First, there is a tantalizing mention of a people called the Mishihase, which reads: At Cape Minabe on the north side of the island of Sado, that's an island off the coast of central Honshu, there arrived men from Sushen in a boat and stayed there. During the spring and summer, they caught fish, which they used for food. The men of that island said they were not human beings. They also called them devils and did not dare to go near them. [0:42:40] Yeah, and Sushen is another pronunciation of the same characters for Mishihase. It's Japanese is very confusing that way. [0:42:47] The Mishihase came into conflict with the Emishi, and a man named General Abe, mentioned in a lot of other semi-legendary sources, was invited to cross the sea and fight them. So this guy Abe assembled a fleet of 200 ships and an army that included some Emishi and traveled to an island that was probably Hokkaido. When he landed there, he was met by a crowd of local Emishi already living there. Again, this is maybe a reference to the Satsumon culture. And they said that another fleet of these Mishihase, or Sushen, had arrived and were killing them. So the heroic Abe vanquished these Sushen pirates, won the trust of the local Emishi, and then went on to suffer an embarrassing defeat in Korea. [0:43:28] Which I feel like is kind of a recurring theme in Japanese military history. [0:43:31] Yeah. Yeah, so that's all we know about the Mishihase, but scholars are quite cautious about identifying these guys with any modern culture just because there's so little to go by. But earlier historians were a little more cavalier with their theories. So if you really throw caution to the wind here, there's a clear narrative where the Satsumon, who are the Emishi colonists, are in conflict with the Okhotsk, who are a different cultural group with the seafaring tradition. And this conflict is won decisively by those Emishi colonists with the help of the powerful Japanese allies, the Yamato, which circumstantially does line up with early Japanese sources and even earlier Chinese ones, and maybe with the archaeology. But again, it's very spotty work on the whole. [0:44:11] Yeah, you know, and one last thing about the Mishihase is that their name, which is alternatively read as Sushen, actually comes from a much earlier Chinese name. So this kind of shows the way that everything we know about these people needs to be interpreted in the lens of Chinese influence in Japan. The much earlier Chinese people lived in Manchuria. And so there's been a lot of speculation about whether or not there is any actual connection between those Chinese references to Sushen and the Japanese references to Sushen. Is this simply Japanese people being fancy by using a classical reference to describe two different barbarian peoples? Or is there a real connection there? I personally have no idea, but I will say that geographically, it seems like the place that the Okhotsk culture comes from does line up with the place described in much earlier Chinese records. So it seems like that both of these types of references do seem to be referring to, if not the same cultures, people from the same place. [0:45:11] Which that is like the northeastern Russian Far East, basically. The area near like Sakhalin, not too far from the Kamchatka Peninsula. [0:45:19] Right. [0:45:20] And all that being said, let's get more acquainted with the Emishi right now. They are sort of the protagonists of Princess Mononoke, the village that you see in the opening scene. That's supposed to be an Emishi village. The prince, that's an Emishi prince. And although Miyazaki, he doesn't really go that into depth in what these people believe, there is nevertheless this sort of vibe that these are people who are much more in tune with nature and who are happy to live in harmony with nature as opposed to the Japanese who are creating this industrial town and destroying the surrounding forest in the process, which really angers the spirits. [0:45:56] Right. [0:45:57] And so, and so, yeah, so again, so the Emishi are very much clearly descendants of the Jomon. And although, you know, although the Yamato Japanese people most likely speak a language introduced from mainland Asia, the Emishi language was probably a descendant of the ancient Jomon language. They were therefore cousins with the Jomon people of Hokkaido, but they had diverged thousands of years before. So we don't know how similar the cultures were of the Emishi and the kind of proto-Ainu before the formation of the Satsumon culture, when the Emishi would cross into Hokkaido. The name Emishi is Japanese for shrimp barbarians. It's very derisive, and this is actually kind of a common aspect of medieval East Asia. It's another Chinese trend that would be copied by neighboring countries. Some of our listeners might know that the Japanese themselves were once subject to one of these mean nicknames. [0:46:47] They were called wo, which means dwarf. And an event that feels very modern to me, emissaries from Japan during the Nara period told, expressed their offense at this term and started insisting on being called a much more positive but similar sounding word, wa, which means harmonious. [0:47:05] So you're telling me that the medieval Japanese invented wokeness? [0:47:08] They did. And it seems like this actually worked. Although, again, the wo, the offensive name, did still survive in kind of folk culture for a little bit. Many centuries later, Japanese raiders during the Sengoku era would be called wokou, which means dwarf pirates. [0:47:25] Yeah, and later during World War II, Chiang Kai-shek would revive it again. [0:47:28] Oh, I know that makes sense. I didn't know that, but yeah, there you go. [0:47:31] Speaking of condescending attitudes, during the Nara era, references to the Emishi are not very positive. It's hard to know if their name refers to the eating of shrimp or perhaps their facial hair that reminded the Japanese people of shrimp whiskers. It might also be a phonetic transliteration of what these people called themselves. There's been some speculation that it's related to a Japanese word meaning archer or an Ainu word meaning sword. It might even be connected to an Ainu word meaning human, just like the word Ainu itself. It's another word for human. Hard to know. [0:48:03] The theory that I think is most interesting is that actually it's not really any real reference to their way of life at all, but simply the way the Japanese understood them, if you wanted to explain this. [0:48:14] According to Japanese folklorist Ōbayashi Taryō, the Nara era text like the Nihongi borrowed a Chinese influence for describing the emperor's authority on all three domains of the realm. That is the earth, the air, and the sea. Therefore, the Emishi might have been called the shrimp barbarians because they were the sea part of the imagined barbarian triad that surrounded the Yamato. The other two big enemies of the Yamato in this early period are the Kumaso, that is the bear people, and the Hayato, the falcon people. We mentioned these guys a couple of episodes ago in our ancient Southeast Asia episode because these guys were probably speakers of an Austronesian language, possibly from Taiwan or the Philippines. [0:48:50] Yeah, and again, this shows that like the idea of Japan as always homogenous is not true at all. It's, you know, this is a product of basically modern politics and assimilation. [0:49:00] Also, you know, we mentioned that the Emishi were renowned as horse riders, kind of in a way it's not too dissimilar from like the Mongols, which is kind of cool. They weren't nomadic, but they were just really renowned for their cavalry abilities. I think this is kind of interesting because the ancient Jomon had no horses at all. Horses were very much introduced from mainland East Asia by the Yayoi along with the Japanese language and rites. But, you know, just like Native Americans on the Great Plains, the pre-existing Jomon people learned how to use horses very, very quickly. And they then began to use horses to defend their ancient homeland against these, you know, Yayoi invaders. When recounting the earliest legends and records of Japanese history, the Nihongi describes how the founder of the Japanese royal house, a guy named Jimmu, made a name for himself by slaying lots of Emishi bandits during wars of conquest. [0:49:50] And not by the most heroic means. In the story that gives us the first mention of the Emishi by that name, he ordered his general to entice some of them to a banquet with all the sake that they could drink. And then, as soon as the enemy was nice and drunk, the general began to sing, At Osaka in the great house, though men in plenty enter and stay, we the glorious sons of warriors, wielding our mallet hammers, wielding our stone mallets, will smite them utterly. As soon as he sang these words, the emperor's warriors drew their swords and slew the Emishi at their seats so that, quote, there were no eaters left. That is, no one was left alive. And clearly, still feeling inspired, the general decided to sing a little more amidst the spurting stumps. Although folks say that one Emishi is a match for 100 men, they do not so much as resist. [0:50:34] Right, and so this, which comes from William George Aston's translation, shows us first that the Emishi were understood as really tough barbarians, and also that theater kids have always existed. [0:50:44] Yeah, and I'm sure that sounds much better in the original Japanese, by the way. George Aston's translation is really annoying to read, honestly. And for whatever reason, the Nihongi has never been translated since. This was like the 1890s, really. So if you're looking to go into grad school for Japanese studies, please think about translating the Nihongi. [0:51:04] Yes, yeah. [0:51:05] You know, and just get back to one line in the song, that one Emishi is a match for 100 men. That's really important because there's this idea that although the Emishi are barbaric, they're really brave. And so for that reason, the name Emishi actually entered Japanese as a given name, which is kind of funny. Maybe it's kind of like how, you know, in English, like Frank is a given name, but it means like the ancient Frank people. I don't know, something like that. It's kind of interesting, right? [0:51:28] Yeah. I also found it interesting that that reference to 100 men is also what Anjiro told the Jesuit earlier, the quote, Yes, you're totally right. [0:51:37] Yeah, yeah. And yeah, because there's this very strong folkloric association between the ancient Emishi and the modern Ainu, and it sees these stereotypes would survive like a thousand years. Really interesting. [0:51:48] Eventually, another emperor named Keiko is said to have really brought the Emishi to heel. He had an advisor named Takeru, who was amazed by the beauty and fertility of Tohoku, which is northernmost Honshu, the domain of the Emishi. And so the emperor sent out an army to claim this land for the Yamato domain. But about a decade after the beginning of Japanese rule of Tohoku, the local Emishi people rebelled. But Keiko wouldn't have that. Quote, so the emperor took a battle axe and giving it to Takeru said, We have heard that the eastern savages are of a violent disposition and are so much given to oppression, their hamlets have no chiefs, their villages no leaders, each is greedy of territory, and they plunder one another. Moreover, they are in the mountains, malignant deities. On the moors, there are malicious demons who beset the highways and bar the roads, causing men much annoyance. [0:52:34] Among these eastern savages, the Emishi are the most powerful. Their men and women live together promiscuously. There is no distinction of father and child. In winter, they dwell in holes. In summer, they live in nests. Their clothes consist of furs and they drink blood. Brothers are suspicious of one another. In ascending mountains, they are like flying birds and going through the grass. They are like fleet quadrupeds. When they receive a favor, they forget it. But if an injury is done them, they never fail to revenge it. Therefore, they keep arrows in their topknots and carry swords within their clothing. Sometimes they draw together their fellows and make inroads on the frontier. At other times, they take the opportunity at the harvest to plunder the people. If attacked, they conceal themselves in the herbage. If pursued, they flee into the mountains. Therefore, ever since antiquity, they have not been steeped in the kingly civilizing influences. [0:53:15] Now we mark that thou art mighty of stature and thy countenance is of perfect beauty. Thou hast strength sufficient to raise tripods. Thy fierceness is like thunder and lightning. Wherever thou dost turn thy face, there is none other to stand before thee. Whenever thou dost attack, thou dost surely conquer. [0:53:30] Jesus, do you think you took a breath after that? [0:53:33] Man, that is mean. [0:53:36] Yeah, yeah, it's just crazy. It's just a complete barrage of insults. Really, something. [0:53:43] Oh, man. Yeah. [0:53:44] And then the next part of this narrative is also just as condescending because it shows that despite their, you know, being so fierce, once Takeru actually reaches the Emishi lands, they take one look at him and realize this guy must be a god and they start worshiping him. Kind of reminds me of very, you know, condescending and not true stories about the Aztecs in the Spanish. [0:54:05] Right, but even within the context of, but even within the context of the Nihongi, none of this should be taken at face value because the pages of the Nihongi are just filled with all of these Emishi rebellions. Like, like first they're submitting for supposedly for all time, and then they're back up in arms, and yada yada yada. It just never ends. [0:54:24] No, totally, totally. [0:54:25] And so, as we move through the historical record, the stories become a little bit less legendary, and the references to the Emishi become more specific. And also, one thing that's kind of interesting here is that in the last passage, they mentioned that it seems like the Emishi were not understood as the only barbarian people of Northeast Honshu, but they're the only ones we know about. Any other cultures that might have existed, maybe possibly other Jomon descendants, have been lost to time. And so, the only ones that really entered the record at all are, yeah, these guys, the Emishi. [0:54:53] Another passage of the Nihongi describes a meeting between Tang Chinese officials and some Japanese diplomats. In describing the peoples of Japan, not just the Yamato, the envoys say they are three Emishi groups: first, the gentle Emishi, who are closest culturally and geographically to the Yamato, the rough Emishi, who are presumably a little bit less so, and then the most distant Tsugaru Emishi. The Tsugaru survive in historical memory because they actually give their name to the northernmost part of the Honshu Island, which really bumps it up against Hokkaido. So, these Tsugaru guys might have had some kind of cultural connection to the early Ainu. Eventually, the delegate presents some of these gentle Emishi to court to entertain the mandarins with dances or folk songs. [0:55:40] Bringing back that Roman comparison, these three groups kind of remind me of how the Romans understood the Gauls in different parts, one of them being the very Romanized toga-wearing Gauls of northern Italy, but then also more barbaric types of Gauls on the wrong side of the Alps. [0:55:57] Right. And there are just so many different types of Emishi. Brett Walker, in his book, The Conquest of Ainu Lands, which is one of the major sources for this episode, mentions that, quote, in the 10th century, Japanese chroniclers began to make passing references to a new group called the Watarishima Emishi, a people who appear to differ from earlier Emishi groups. In tribute, for example, the Watarishima Emishi bring animal skins rather than horses. The name Watarishima Emishi can be roughly translated as Emishi who crossed from the island. [0:56:27] Right, and I think that means that these guys, this reference here in the 10th century, might be the first really unambiguous reference to the Ainu that we have. [0:56:35] Right, well, at least some kind of people that lived on Hokkaido. But yeah, this might be a direct reference to the Satsumon culture, or it might be someone else. We really have no way of knowing, unfortunately. [0:56:48] But in any event, we've talked a lot about the relationship between the Emishi and the Ainu and how they could be sort of understood as distant cousins who reunited at a later point in history. But we shouldn't overstate the similarities, even though many do. In the Tokugawa period, when Japan was fully reunified after 150 years of civil war, and pretty much all foreigners and Christians were kicked out, there was a lot of new introspection about Japanese identity and history. And we're going to get into this in the next episode much more, but this happened at the same time as there was an increased conflict between the Ainu and the Japanese. We've talked about how Japanese historians often rely on classical sources, sometimes in ways that makes things tricky to understand for modern readers. And one example of this is that the writers of the 16th and 17th century would often bring up imagery from a thousand years earlier, their legendary past recounted in the Nihongi, to make connections to the modern, to the then modern day residents of Hokkaido. [0:57:49] So the Ainu of Hokkaido were equated with the Emishi of northern Honshu, Tohoku. [0:57:54] Right, right. In other words, it would be basically the colonization of Hokkaido, which began in the 19th century, but had kind of some precedent in the 17th century, was seen as an extension of the ancient battle against the Emishi. You know, it's kind of, it's, yeah, it's like ancient justification for a modern kind of war. [0:58:14] And the traditional Japanese name for Hokkaido, Ezo, in fact, began as an alternative pronunciation of Emishi, and this pronunciation began to gain prominence in the Kamakura shogunate and would continue to be used all the way until the second half of the 19th century when the island was renamed to Hokkaido, which literally means the northern sea passage. [0:58:36] Very secular colonial name there, honestly. Right. [0:58:39] So let's now get into some of the differences between the Emishi of Honshu and the kind of proto-Ainu of Hokkaido groups like the Satsumon culture. Because even though the Satsumon culture had an origin in the Emishi, they were probably better farmers than either the Emishi people or the later Ainu, which is really interesting. They didn't bring their horse cavalry techniques to Hokkaido. And they also have architecture, settlement patterns, and burials that are very different from the Emishi. They really kind of became their own thing here, probably due to some increased cultural connections with the peoples of Siberia as well as the kind of indigenous late Jomon people of Hokkaido. But there's still, like I said, of course, many interesting connections. The names Emishi and Ainu might be connected. Also, many toponyms in northern Honshu have an Ainu connection. They tend to end in Betsu, which is believed to be related to the Ainu word pet, meaning river, or Nai, which is Ainu for stream. [0:59:46] Yeah, in the next episode, we're going to get much, we're going to get pretty deep into the weeds of the subjugation of the Ainu at the hands of the Japanese, but already in the medieval era, this was already happening to the Emishi several centuries before. There are many parallels between what happened on Hokkaido and what's happening in this period. [1:00:05] In the decades after the publication of the Nihongi, we get many more stories of wars against the Emishi, but there is one particularly intense conflict that we can't skip, and that's the 38 Years' War. If you thought the 30 Years' War was bad, just you wait, because it gets worse. [1:00:24] Right, because 774 to 812, the Japanese court led five separate campaigns into Tohoku. That's the northern part of Honshu where the Emishi lived. Japanese rule was ostensibly already established in the era, so from the perspective of the court, they were dealing with a rebellion. It wasn't a conquest, it was a pacification. But the Emishi began a campaign of hit-and-run mounted guerrilla warfare, which would deeply influence Japanese military history for centuries to come. [1:00:51] Yeah, and they had a really tough time fighting these attacks off. Here are how some sources from the time describe these attacks: They swarm like bees and gather like ants, but when we attack, they flee into the mountains and forests. When we let them go, they assault our fortifications. Each of their leaders is as good as 1,000 men. [1:01:08] So, the 8th century in Japan is mostly taken up by the Nara period, when the Japanese court was at the height of attempting to emulate Chinese models of governance and administration. This is the period when the Nihon Shoki was written. But the Nara period would give way to the Heian period in 794 for many reasons, but the strains of the 38 Years' War really forced Japan to adapt different models after depleting the manpower and resources that they had at their disposal, largely because they were fighting this war and not very well most of the time. The imperial household hoped to have centralized control over the entire island chain, as that was their right as emperors of Japan. To this end, they focused their attention on Tohoku, a relatively recent addition to the realm and one with a long-standing history of rebellions that we mentioned. To that end, the court littered the landscape with fortifications in a move that would become very familiar, and in a move that would become very familiar to future encounters with the Ainu, settlers were used as a tactic of pacification. [1:02:15] Yeah, so quoting from Farris's Heavenly Warriors here, the court had 1,000 wealthy households from six eastern provinces move and distributed them across the Mutsu province. It was assumed that the wealthy families would use their personal ties to the court to extend government control into the hinterlands. Court-sponsored migration continued through the middle of the 8th century, although the colonists usually were poor individuals rather than wealthy families. Quote, the court allotted 233 male slaves and 277 females to the Okachi Palisade. So. [1:02:45] Right. And so when fighting officially broke out in 774 around the vicinity of Fort Monou, it later eventually spread down and 20,000 Japanese soldiers were sent to meet it at the area of Mutsu. The Kanto regions were expected to provide troops for the endeavors, and the effort so exhausted them that their tax burden had to be lightened. The Tohoku expedition would ultimately be the reason for Japan's move away from this conscription system, which would weaken the court over time and instead give more prominence to the shogunate. [1:03:14] Yeah, so whatever the reasons for the initial revolt, it's kind of vague. At least parts of it came on to take an Emishi versus Yamato angle. In 780, just a couple of years after this all began, a lieutenant of Emishi origin named Iji no Kimi Azamaro launched an attack on Japanese soldiers, killing the head of the army. Azamaro was apparently angry at being denigrated for his Emishi origins, and he led his troops to the south in a campaign to destroy Fort Taga. More Emishi would do similar things with time. And these officers, they raised an army of rebels who burned down the castle where they had once served the Japanese Emperor Kanmu. The Emishi then repelled a large counterattack by the Japanese and started to gain more and more support from the surrounding Emishi villages. A second Yamato army was then sent to deal with the rebels, but this time using total brutal war tactics of burning Emishi villages and farms to starve out the enemy. [1:04:07] One of the few Emishi that we know by name from this period was a general named Aterui, who led a cavalry charge against this plundering force that scared the Yamato so much that they fled across a rushing river where they apparently lost thousands of men to drowning. This was the Battle of Koromo River of 789. It was a massive fumble. [1:04:29] Yeah. And it seems that by this point, the government in Nara realized that the strategy wasn't working. The rebels were still marching, going south as far as the city of Sendai. They realized for the first time that if they didn't figure out how to meet this rebellion, these Emishi might eventually be partying in Nara. So this also came at a time when the court was forced to end conscription due to that great burden of fielding the expeditions. It was also when smallpox first came to Japan. So this was really just a terrible decade for the Japanese government. [1:04:59] So because of that, they drastically changed course in a way that would really transform Japanese history in a huge way. First, they would switch to a honey-not vinegar approach to bribe various Emishi chiefs into defecting away from the rebellion and back toward the imperial service. Additionally, a really important guy named Sakanoue no Tamuramaro was appointed to lead a 100,000-strong army using the same kind of horse archery tactics the Emishi were known for. This guy, Sakanoue, was given a permanent post as the military leader of northeastern Honshu with a fancy title, Barbarian Subduing General Isimo. In Japanese, Seii Taishōgun, or in short, Shogun. [1:05:43] Yeah, so Sakanoue became presumably the first shogun of Japanese history, and he avoided major military encounters with the fearsome Emishi because he had seen what happens when you try to confront them straight on. He would instead hunt the rebel general Aterui through the mountains. Presumably using some combination of spies and local Emishi turncoats, Sakanoue managed to track down Aterui, who was surrounded by a contingent of just 500 men by this point. Those who did not resist were captured alive and many of them were deported to western Japanese provinces, and their relatives were also encouraged to follow them. This had the effect of scattering the core of the rebel movement, but Aterui himself was brought to Nara, where the emperor ordered his death. According to later Japanese literary sources, Emperor Kanmu was so scared of Aterui that he demanded that he be executed outside of the city walls so that his ghost could not enter the town of Nara and haunt those who had ordered his death. [1:06:39] After Aterui's killing, resistance would continue, but it seems like the cause had basically broken down into isolated pockets of guerrilla violence. And so the last 10 years of the 38 Years' War was just a slow, unpleasant process of counterinsurgency and reprisal. Colonization schemes were once again implemented, but this time they actually worked. Across the 9th century, Emishi cultures and identities would really begin a slow process of dissolution. Many of those who submitted, referred to as Fushu or Ifu, were resettled to other parts of Japan, with as many as 10,000 Emishi sent to Kanto alone. Traditions associated with the Emishi eventually would just become regional traditions of Tohoku. Many aristocratic families of the later Sengoku period who came as settlers would eventually claim, possibly spuriously, possibly based in some true history, that they were themselves descended from Emishi chieftains. [1:07:37] Yeah, just doing some glizwar and shit as a daimyo. [1:07:40] Really cool. [1:07:41] Right, and so as we move into the Kamakura period, named after the new capital city, the shogun, which was created to deal with these Emishi, would become increasingly prominent. Eventually, the shogun would basically become a hereditary monarch or dictator over Japan, significantly more powerful than the emperor, but not always able to rein in the more powerful local lords. This conflict eventually leads to the Sengoku period that we've talked about. The shogunate was, of course, also associated with the rise of the samurai class, a sort of military aristocracy always compared to European knighthood. When conscription was brought to an end in 792, this effectively meant that the aristocracy accumulated power, paving way for the rise of local military elites. Emishi ways of war really influenced the rise of the samurai. Farris argues that the Emishi sword called the Warabite spread through Japan along with the exiled Emishi and eventually displaced the Chinese-style straight sword. [1:08:35] This kind of means that in a weird way, the Emishi might be responsible for the development of the famous katana, which is kind of cool. The Emishi also forced the Japanese to become more acquainted with horseback archery and light leather armor. This was the package that would also kind of define the samurai for years to come. [1:08:52] Right, and although mentions of the Emishi become increasingly infrequent during the Kamakura period and afterwards, the pacification of the so-called Eastern Barbarians was still a major duty of the shogunate. These barbarians seem to have been remnants of the Emishi on Honshu, but also relatives of the Emishi on Hokkaido. And remember, the traditional name for both Hokkaido and the Ainu from the Kamakura period, Ezo, first referred to the Emishi. It's the same characters, just pronounced in a different way. [1:09:21] Now, we know basically nothing about these military excursions, although some Ainu folklore does give us clues. Their oral traditions, which as we mentioned previously, are called Yukar, which passed orally for hundreds of years, describe Japanese warriors moving north to fight the Ainu, but sometimes defecting and going native. There was one famous nobleman named Minamoto no Yoshitsune who died mysteriously in a dynastic war when he was just 30. But some Ainu traditions maintain that he actually fled his enemies into the Ainu lands where he became one of them. [1:09:54] Right, yeah. And so we'll never know if this actually happened, but there certainly were small numbers of Yamato people who spoke Japanese who moved to Hokkaido in the late 12th and 13th centuries. It seems like the island was kind of a de facto penal colony, which that's something that would come back many centuries later, where many exiles would be sent. Japanese people in this period really feared going to Hokkaido for any reason, because it was understood as a place haunted by ghosts. And the Ezo people, whose understanding was influenced by earlier stories of the Emishi, were basically understood as demons. But by the 13th century, the Ainu probably weren't that concerned with this small number of Japanese people coming across the straits. [1:10:33] Because in the 13th century, they had a much bigger problem, the Mongols. So by the 1250s, the Mongols under Chinggis Khan's grandson Möngke had taken about two-thirds of China and had recently turned their sights back to the north, where they forcibly vassalized the native Siberian peoples of what is now the Russian Far East. One of these groups was the Nivkh, who we mentioned earlier as being possibly connected to the Okhotsk culture, which was one of the main ancestral ingredients of the Ainu. But by now, relations had clearly soured with their cousins on Hokkaido. We unfortunately don't know why this happened. It could have been dynastic disputes, it could have been arguments over fishing rights, or it could have been just plain old expansionism. But the Ainu began expanding north out of Hokkaido into the territories of the Nivkh, first the Kuril Islands and then the long chain of Sakhalin, both of which would be contested between Japan and Russia for centuries. [1:11:26] And eventually the Ainu would even settle on the Nivkh homeland on mainland Asia. This would be a huge mistake, as it turned out, because the Nivkh were Mongol vassals by this point, and this invasion was seen as a slight against the entire Mongol Empire. So around this time, when Möngke Khan died, there was a brutal succession war among his brothers. The victor was the second most famous Khan of all of them, and this was certainly a guy you wouldn't want to offend. This was Kublai Khan. [1:11:56] Right, so he was famously the first Mongol Khan to proclaim himself Emperor of China, leader of a dynasty. But even before he finished uniting China proper, he shored up support in his northeastern territories, including the very distant Nivkh frontier. This area was super far away from any city in the empire, but it was a major source of furs, which were beloved both by the Chinese elite in the cities and also by the Mongol army. So Kublai began sending generals to take care of these Ainu troublemakers. And remarkably, at first, the Ainu did a really good job fending them off. [1:12:30] Right. They seem to have realized that the Mongols had a perennial problem of not being good seafarers. So even the really narrow strait between mainland Asia and Sakhalin was too choppy for the Mongols to effectively cross. For years, the Ainu would send raiding parties to infiltrate the Mongol Empire and to harass their Nivkh enemies. So people in Yuan cities like Beijing were terrified of accounts of these interlopers shooting travelers with poisoned arrows. Something had to be done about this. Eventually, the Mongols realized that in the coldest weeks of the year, the straits would freeze over entirely. Their armies would be able to cross into Sakhalin on foot, which would force the local Ainu to kneel as vassals of the great Yuan Emperor. [1:13:12] Right, and so a big question here, which has no answer, unfortunately, but it's very, a very interesting one, is once they successfully conquered the Ainu of Sakhalin, and most likely learned about the Ainu of neighboring Hokkaido, is it possible that this success in the 1270s could have sparked the Mongols' subsequent, very brief, but very intense interest in Japan? It's hard to know if the Mongols understood how close Sakhalin was to Japan. They might not have realized these places were proximate, but it really seems like there was this kind of parallel interest in overseas eastern islands that included Ainu. [1:13:51] Right, so shortly after successfully entering Sakhalin, the Mongols and so shortly after and So shortly after successfully entering Sakhalin, the Mongols launched a much more ambitious invasion of Japan. We mentioned in our Sengoku episode 74-75 that although those armies would fail largely because of weather and the Mongols' ineptitude at sea travel, the Mongols who did make it to the shores of Honshu were slaughtered by low-ranking Japanese noblemen, the samurai. Historians believe that this event allowed the samurai to promote themselves as the saviors of Japan, who now deserve new rights over the commoners and more freedom vis-à-vis any central authority. So again, this increased militarization that we're talking about, that's further destabilizing the center, even in the shogun period, and it's really not going to end well. [1:14:39] No, and also the interesting thing is that this kind of militarization is always connected either directly or indirectly to the Emishi and the Ainu. Shogun means attacker of barbarians, and it seems like this Mongol invasion of Japan was probably not unrelated to the Mongol war against the Ainu. And yeah, this militarization would lead to the Japanese seeking to cement their control over their closest island to the north, Hokkaido. [1:15:02] And just to guess, I kind of wonder if part of why they began, if part of why the interest in Hokkaido began was initially out of the fear that it could be a sort of a launch pad for invasions. [1:15:14] I don't know, just to guess. [1:15:15] But regardless of this motivation, by the 14th century, the Muromachi period, Japanese daimyo for the first time would begin formally crossing the straits. There's really early references to, like we mentioned earlier in the Nihongi, of possible Japanese invasions of Hokkaido, but the first kind of concrete evidence of this happening is in the 1300s, when Japanese forts started being built on the southernmost point of Hokkaido, really right butting up right against across the straits from Honshu. [1:15:45] Right. [1:15:46] And we should mention that these contacts weren't always entirely negative. Around this time, the Ando clan of Northern Honshu, who might have also been of Emishi descent, began to build trade networks with Hokkaido. A document around this time called the Suwa Daimyojin Ekotoba describes a kind of exchange and that a group of Japanese speakers called the Watarito were essential in facilitating it. These might have been earlier Japanese settlers to Hokkaido, maybe the descendants of the prisoners who were sent there, or it could have been people of mixed Japanese and Ainu descent who got there by other means. Here's how the source describes them: three groups known as the Hinomoto, Karako, and the Watarito inhabited the islands. The Watarito began to visit Sotogahama in Mutsu province to carry out trade. The land of the two groups known as the Hinomoto and Karako is contiguous with foreign countries. [1:16:42] Their appearance is like that of demons, forever changing. As for their customs, they ate the flesh of fowl, beasts, and fish, and they are unfamiliar with the cultivation of the five grains. It is difficult to understand their speech, even with the aid of interpreters. The Watarito resembled the people of Wakoku, that is Japan, but they have much hair on their faces and all over their bodies. Their speech is uncouth, but it is for the most part comprehensible. So, presumably, these people, the Hinomoto or the Karako, one of these would have been the Ainu, because this book is also the first written attestation of the word Ainu as a suffix and a personal name. [1:17:17] That's really interesting. [1:17:18] And we know that these guys, these probably mixed-descent people, the Watarito, were backed by the power of the Ando clan, even if they were seen as kind of these like country bumpkins. And they had close relations with local Ainu leaders. They sold luxury goods as intermediaries between Japan and the Ainu, and they would also even purchase Siberian furs that the hunter the Ainu had gotten from the Nivkh territories of mainland Asia. These trade negotiations, however, clearly favored the Japanese over the Ainu. But it seems that in this period, relations were generally good despite that, and business was booming. A cache of 400,000 coins dating to this era was found near Hakodate, which was a city that began as a manor house for a powerful samurai who settled at the bottom of Hokkaido. We should mention that this part of this area is so close to the main island of Honshu that if relations ever got bad, the samurai would be able to flee to Honshu across the straits before the Ainu could reach him, which is kind of funny to think about. [1:18:15] This kind of proto-colonization was very limited, but still had a major impact on the demographics south of the island. It may be comparable to the English pale of settlement in Ireland, where you had a small area of Japanese-speaking settlers surrounded by a more sparsely populated area of natives who did not speak Japanese. This southernmost part of Hokkaido came to be known as Wajinchi, or the Japanese land, and the rest of the island was known as Ezochi or Ainu land. As a result of this colony being established, eventually Japanese influence would radiate across the rest of the island. [1:18:51] Yeah, and so as the trade developed, the Ainu people would become somewhat dependent on the trade, and it would only intensify with time. Japanese and even Chinese ceramics became so widespread that native pottery actually vanishes, according to the archaeologist Mark James Hudson. Foreign pots were so important that they even began to take on a ritual significance and would often be associated with the Ainu fire goddess Ape Kamuy. So even today, the Ainu believe that a fire underneath the pot must never go out, and some Ainu communities have a tradition of keeping a flame eternally lit to honor this goddess. [1:19:26] And with time, the exploitation that was happening would take on a much more pronounced character. So in 1454, the Ando clan suffered a really big defeat at the hands of another clan, and they temporarily fled to their colony across the straits. They'd make a lot of noise in turning the small colony into their new base of power, and they built even more fortresses across southern Hokkaido on the Oshima Peninsula. Their presence began to disturb the Ainu. In 1456, a Japanese blacksmith killed an Ainu man who had complained that a blade he had sold him was dull. In a vacuum, this seems like a fairly minor trade dispute, and it could have been settled by other means, but it seems that all was not well between the Wajin and the Ainu. In this context, the dispute festered until the following year, when a chief called Koshamain used it to rally the Ainu. [1:20:18] He was able to sack 10 of the 12 garrisons established by the Ando before his troops were finally beaten back by Kakizaki Nobuhiro and peace was restored. The Kakizaki clan, who were Ando vassals, became increasingly powerful on Ezo, and by 1514, the shogun gave the Kakizaki the right to tax all ships coming to and from the island. The Kakizaki ultimately made very well for themselves, seemingly at the expense of the Ainu. From Koshamain's war onwards, the record shows skirmishes and even battles between Japanese settlers and the Ezo, some of them escalating to sacks, like in 1471 and 1501. But the Japanese would often resort to underhand tactics to subdue the Ainu, repeating the scenario we saw in the Nihongi many times when important Ainu would be invited somewhere and just slaughtered while they're drinking sake. [1:21:10] Yeah, and then you gotta hear the general singing about it. God, it would suck. [1:21:13] These many conflicts likely began to solidify the ethnic divide between the Ainu and outsiders. Although it should be noted that these conflicts were rarely entirely along ethnic lines, there would usually be some Ainu fighting on the Japanese side, and probably vice versa. And clan loyalties were very complicated here. [1:21:31] This was also not a period of completely unidirectional advantage to the Japanese, because in 1551, Kakizaki Suehiro came to an agreement which split trade profits from the Japanese and the Ainu. This initially worked in the Ainu's favor, but it had the secondary effect of establishing a Kakizaki monopoly over all trade on Hokkaido, which resulted in deteriorating relations with the Ainu over time. The Ando were able to maintain their power during the Sengoku period, the Warring States era, but they ultimately backed the winning horse by pledging fealty to Oda Nobunaga. But good times could not last forever. [1:22:08] Right, because with the death of the clan head Andō Chikasue in 1587, a succession struggle arose. The so-called Minato War began as a local affair, but its impact quickly radiated outwards and threatened to disturb the peace by bringing more clans into this dispute. After a succession struggle of his own, Toyotomi Hideyoshi was determined to keep the domain from once again spiraling out of control. To this end, he issued his Sōbuji orders, which called for an immediate end to all hostilities in Japan. The Ando disregarded this warning to their own great peril, as it turned out. As we talked about on episode 74-75, the Sengoku period and the years immediately after it was the time of the Gekokujo, which translates to the low overpowers the high. Seeking to punish the Ando for their insubordination and needing a reliable lord on Hokkaido, Toyotomi would invest power in the Kakizaki, independent of the Ando, under his own direct personal vassalage. [1:23:08] From 1599, the Kakizaki would be renamed the Matsumae, and they would continue to be the lords of Ezo until the Meiji Restoration. [1:23:16] So, what did this mean for the Ainu in practice? Here's a quote from Walker: The Shinra no Kiroku flamboyantly crows that when Yoshihiro returned to Ezo after meeting with Hideyoshi, he gathered the Ainu from the east and the west and read to them in translation the Vermilion Seal Order investing the Kakizaki. He warned that if Ainu failed to observe the directives, Hideyoshi would send a military force of 100,000 warriors to crush the offenders. [1:23:41] Right, and so Hideyoshi, who wanted to center authority in Kyoto after the chaotic, you know, particularism of the Sengoku era, he would claim all rights to foreign trade. He'd solidify the Matsumae monopoly from the center in addition to investing them with formal political power. It was at this time that the Ainu formally entered the literary European record. That's what we said, you know, when the Jesuits first know about them. One other, we mentioned a few references before. There's another one when a Jesuit named Ignacio Moreira reported having met an Ainu guy accompanying the Kakizaki clan's delegation to Hideyoshi's palace in 1591. This is cool because he told, this guy, this Ainu person, told this Jesuit that he came from a place called Aino Moksori, which is probably Ainu Moshir, as rendered in Latin. [1:24:30] Amidst all of this, it's really important to note that after the Sakoku Order was instituted, the Ainu were one of the few domains that the Japanese had formal relations with, because, you know, even though they cut off all trade with the outside world, there were some little exceptions to this. Ezochi was conceived of as a foreign land, but that was of such paramount importance to Japan that they could carve out an exception for the isolation policy. Also, interestingly, at this time, the Japanese largely believed Hokkaido was connected to the Asian mainland. They didn't understand yet that it was an island that was simply proximate to other islands connected to near Asia. [1:25:08] But so let's talk about what exactly did this trade look like in this period when Japan supposedly had no foreign trade at all. As we mentioned, the Matsumae were able to secure a monopoly, which meant all trade was supposed to go through this one family and their delegates. Audiences called uimam conducted the trade, and the Ainu would go to the Fukuyama castle to offer tribute, receiving some kinds of gifts in return. This trade gave the Ainu finished products in exchange for natural resources. They became increasingly reliant on Japanese rice, pottery, salt, tobacco, sake, and iron. And in return, they gave the Japanese smoked fish, kelp, furs, sea cucumbers, and the like. By the 17th century, the Japanese had set up fisheries dependent on Ainu labor. At first, the Ainu were themselves engaging in long-distance trade, visiting other Ainu speakers in Sakhalin and the Nivkh peoples, but the Matsumae were able to box them in over time. [1:26:07] And so by 1644, the Ainu themselves were no longer seafarers. Connections between the Ainu and their relatives on other islands had been severed. The Matsumae then began to set up trading posts called Akinaiba in Ezochi, which is, you know, the Ainu parts of Hokkaido, and they coerced the Ainu to go with them rather than venturing abroad independently, solidifying their monopoly and, again, furthering the dependence of the Ainu on Japanese trade. This monopoly was directly sanctioned by the new shogun Tokugawa, who granted the following black seal to the family. He ordered that it would be unlawful for people from outside provinces to enter or exit the territories of the Ainu without consent of the Matsumae leaders. It would also be illegal for Japanese people to cross into Hokkaido for trade, but Ainu themselves did have the right to go to Japan if they wanted to. It also was strictly prohibited for Japanese people to inflict injustices upon the Ainu. [1:27:09] And if people act contrary to these edicts, they will be punished rigorously. So it's kind of interesting here. [1:27:14] It's like a, what's your kind of read on these stipulations, Sam? [1:27:20] Well, it reminds me a lot of settler-Native American relations, where on paper, there was a way that the settler traders were supposed to act with Native Americans, like they weren't really supposed to entice them with alcohol, for instance. They weren't supposed to give them weapons and things of that nature. But in practice, all of this was really going on. And in fact, Walker himself draws many parallels between the ways that American colonization proceeded and what the Matsumae were doing. He makes a direct comparison between the Massachusetts Bay Company and Matsumae operations, which basically gave them commercial monopolies over natural resources from foreign lands. [1:28:10] Right, right. And what you see in both the Americas and in Hokkaido here is that the development of trade with the Metropole really disrupts the traditional way of life of these people, eventually, initially, basically weaning them off of any kind of independent agriculture. And then the increased exploitation of natural resources also makes it harder for the Ainu to support themselves through hunting and gathering. They're really becoming increasingly dependent on this rice dole coming in from Japan, which really harmed their traditional way of life and made them completely politically dependent on their eventual colonizers. [1:28:47] The Ainu were then forced into this position of dependency. Other houses of Japan stayed afloat by lording over rice farming peasants, but Ezo wasn't really Japan. So the Ainu, they became dependent on the import of grain and rice imports to maintain a co-org surplus because so much of their produce was being traded away to the Japanese, and the chieftains needed to keep this trade going so that they could acquire the prestige goods needed to cement their power. Once again, very strong parallels to New England. So the Ainu, in this way, were forced into a position of dependency. The other houses of Japan traditionally stayed afloat by lording over rice farming peasants, but Ezo wasn't Japan, really. [1:29:30] Although the Ainu had been hunter-gatherers for centuries now, their ancestors had practiced agriculture on Honshu as well as in Hokkaido on a smaller scale. And there was really no inherent reason why they couldn't take it up again if they needed to. The climate of Hokkaido was different from most of Japan, as mentioned previously, but it wasn't really bad agricultural land. But because the Matsumae derived a lot of comparative advantage from providing scarce goods to the rest of Japan, it made much more sense to encourage other economic pursuits. Even Japanese settlers were encouraged to work at fisheries rather than taking up farming. So when the Ainu sporadically attempted to begin rice cultivation to remedy their dependency, they were prevented from doing so. Here's a. We've seen. Walker brings up many examples of the Ainu wanting to relearn how to farm. One shogun official sent in the 1780s to Ezo to examine the conditions produced a report full of really damning evidence against the Matsumae. [1:30:35] He reports that when one tribe successfully cultivated a plot of rice, the Matsumae sent officials to destroy the seedlings and forced the Ainu to pay tribute for their misstep. He also reports that one chieftain who he had spoken to asked the official for seeds and an explanation for how to cultivate them. He said that the Matsumae prevented the Ainu from learning this. It was also speculated that the Ainu were even prevented from engaging in their traditional small-scale agriculture to force them to come to the trading posts. It's really brutal stuff here to show them the way that these people are clearly being harmed, just you know, for this early, you know, basically capital accumulation. Really cold stuff. [1:31:16] And additionally, in addition to all of these problems, the traders backed by the Matsumae, the people responsible for all of this, were themselves very unscrupulous in their trade that the Ainu completely depended upon. [1:31:29] Walker writes that the Yoichi Ainu tribe lamented that rice bales that had once contained nearly 10 gallons now contained only four gallons. Similarly, they describe problems in the shellfish trade. If, for example, one string of shellfish is missing from a bundle, the Matsumae make us pay 20 strings of shellfish for the next year as interest. If we don't pay, our children are taken instead. This tribe explained that the Japanese trading practices made their lives particularly difficult. A similar report of 1670 told that in the old days, under the Lord Matsumae Yoshihiro, the Ainu received a large bale of rice for five bundles of dried salmon. But under the current policies, they only received a much smaller bale for the same five bundles. Because we are only Ainu, it does not matter whether we say yes or no, one Ainu man explained. And the Ainu were forced to trade at these rates. [1:32:22] The Ainu elders had lodged a complaint with officials, but were told that they were selfish for wanting better exchange rates from the merchants. [1:32:29] Yeah, and this wasn't the end of their problems either, because the Japanese also discovered that the streams of Hokkaido were full of gold and began mining operations to extract it from 1617 onwards. These gold mining sites would be created upriver from Ainu villages and they would disrupt the traditional salmon life cycles, which made fishing all the harder for the locals. The Jesuit Diego Carvalho, who visited Wajinchi, described how this process worked: quote, when they have decided on the mountain range in which, according to experts, there ought to be gold, friends and acquaintances get together and united as a body to purchase from the Lord of Matsumae so many ells, one ell being about 45 inches, of one of the rivers which must flow to the said range, and so many bars of gold, and that they need to pay these bars whether they find gold or not. [1:33:19] And when a great number of such groups come to the river, they divert the flow of the water along a different course and then dig into the sand which remains until they reach a living stone and rock beneath the riverbed. And in the sand lodged in the rents and fissures of the rock, it is found gold as fine as beach gravel. [1:33:36] So you can really see how this would be harmful to a people who really make a huge part of their livelihood from fishing. [1:33:45] And as time went on, the Ainu were coerced into working at fisheries in exchange for goods, really. It wasn't no longer a matter of currency anymore, even. They were just getting paid for their wares with finished goods at ridiculous inflated prices, relatively speaking. [1:34:02] It's kind of like a shittier version of the company store. [1:34:07] This description comes to us from the end of the 18th century, but here's what this trade would look like. Quote, When the fisherman completed one show representing 250 sea cucumbers, he brushed a black stripe on the arm of the Ainu trader. For each mark of the arm, the trader received one cup of sake at the trading post and incentive to gather more dried sea cucumber for the Nagasaki trade. For two show, or 500 sea cucumber, the Ainu received one tawara of rice, about four gallons, once again, from Walker. And this alcohol mention is really interesting because, again, that's a very strong parallel to Native Americans. [1:34:40] Right, right. [1:34:41] And really, all this to say that by the early, the late 17th and early 18th century, conditions had gotten very dire for the Ainu. They were not yet colonized in the way they would be in the 19th century, but there was clearly this very unfortunate relationship of dependency forced upon them by the Japanese. There was this awful legal middle ground of Hokkaido where it was not formally part of Japan, so Japanese laws and protections didn't really apply, but it was also completely tied in with the Japanese economy in ways that only harmed the native peoples. So obviously there was widespread dissatisfaction with what had happened to the Ainu lifestyle. [1:35:23] As we said, individual Ainu people recognized that life had been better in previous decades. So in the late 17th century, a group of Ainu people would decide to take matters into their own hands and lead a significant, probably the biggest charge against Japanese influence in Hokkaido in Japanese history. This would be a very important event in the history of the Ainu, and ultimately, this rebellion, which would be defeated, would pave the way for the complete colonization of the area 200 years later. This was Shakushain's revolt. [1:36:01] So, like Koshamain's rebellion before, Shakushain's war began as a relatively minor affair that quickly spiraled out of control. But the underlying causes were much more complex than meets the eye and quickly took on a much more different character. To quote Walker, once again, the war began when the Hae and the Shibuchari Ainu, the two groups involved, engaged in deadly fighting and largely stemmed from disputes over access to fisheries and fur-bearing animals, over contested borders among the Shibuchari River, and over lofty ambitions of certain chieftains. These border conflicts drew Fukuyama Castle and eventually the Edo Shogunate into fighting a war on the distant soils of Ezochi, and in the aftermath of the conflict, forced Matsumae officials to play a more direct role in Ainu affairs. Shakushain's war was seen as the watershed in the history of the Japanese conquest of Ezo. It was the last attempt by anything resembling a pan-Ainu alliance to expel militarily the Japanese from their homeland. [1:36:59] So, this conflict had its origins some years earlier, as Walker said. The Hae and the Shibuchari were neighbors, and a feud began between these two chiefdoms because of a killing in 1648. The Ainu had really strong delineations about who could hunt on which territory, as we mentioned at the top of the episode, but these weren't always respected. Chief Sentain of the Shibuchari disregarded them for many years, and he hunted and fished in Hae territory as he pleased. Sentain was too fearsome for anybody to call his bluff, but when he died and his son Kamokutain took over, the Hae took their revenge. Kamokutain was killed in a war a couple of years after he came to power, and Shakushain, his subordinate, who had actually committed the killing that began the war in the first place, took over. Shakushain would continue to wage war against the Hae until 1655, when the Matsumae clan finally stepped in and mediated a solution. [1:37:57] The Matsumae wanted stability because the war would disrupt commerce, and they made their living off that. They didn't want that to happen at all. But the peace was very tentative because the Hae and the Shibuchari would continue feuding even if it didn't come to blows, even if it didn't come to blows. The two chiefdoms would continue to hunt in each other's territory as if to provoke each other, but things really reached a fever pitch in 1666. First, Shakushain slighted the Hae chief Onibishi by refusing his request for a bear cub to be raised for the Iyomante ceremony, as the Hae had been unable to capture a bear cub that year. And then, in the winter of that same year, Shakushain was caught leading a hunting expedition on Hae territory and was rebuked. [1:38:44] Right, this really shows how important that bear ceremony is to the Ainu lifestyle. [1:38:48] And then, so in the summer of 1667, a relative of Onibishi captured a crane on the territory of Shakushain's subordinate. This would really be the final straw. Shakushain invented the man to his village to offer him sake, but instead, he was murdered by his younger brother for crossing into Shibuchari territory. Onibishi mobilized his men and was ready to pounce, but mediation by a local Japanese gold miner diffused the conflict for now, convincing Onibishi to collect blood money instead of seeking blood himself. Onibishi received only 11 gifts, though, not the 300 that he demanded. And so eventually, this Japanese mediation would actually make things worse. [1:39:30] Right, because of this affair, Shakushain began to view the Matsumae as allies of the Hae, and he refused to subordinate himself to either Japanese or the Hae. So, to this end, he constructed a fortress and dug in. Adding to the tension of this situation, the Ainu Yukars record that the gold miner in question had wreaked havoc on Shibuchari fisheries in the years leading up to this, which probably had some role in these disputes about hunting rights. Quote, Bunshirō and his miners had badly turned the Shibuchari River, preventing salmon from ascending the river to spawn. Local Ainu from Pepana, Ichipu, and Rupe Shipe, all in the Shibuchari area, found themselves with a dangerously limited supply of fish for the coming winter. Ainu chiefs protested but were treacherously murdered. The Yukar indicates that when Shakushain heard this, he launched an attack against Japanese, killing hundreds, many of them miners. [1:40:25] No doubt this story oversimplifies the origins of the conflict, but it is known that Shakushain's attitude towards the Japanese miners who disrupted his streams and allied with the Onibishi, with Onibishi, was less than congenial. [1:40:37] Right, and all this meant that 1668 would be a very bloody year for Hokkaido. Because when Matsumae ordered that Shakushain pay blood money again, this time he went on the offensive. When Onibishi was away on business, Shakushain killed two of Onibishi's brothers while they were farming. Onibishi took shelter in the home of his Japanese miner friend, the gold guy, the gold miner, but the Shibucha, but the Shibuchari shot him to death at the same time and launched an all-out war. The Hae were defeated in the field of battle and began to clamor for Matsumae help. But Matsumae officials responded that there was no precedent for supplying weapons to the Ainu, who, in this context, were formally characterized as peasants and therefore refused the request. [1:41:21] Despite their efforts, the Matsumae would nonetheless be drawn into war. In June and July of 1669, the Matsumae began to receive reports that the Japanese and their Ainu allies were being attacked at several sites. These two attacks reportedly caused 273 Japanese deaths. Shibuchari forces were quickly massing on Itomo within two weeks of Fukuyama Castle, and according to later Japanese chronicles, they sought to expel the Japanese altogether. Shakushain, the leader of this rebellion, called on other Ainu chieftains to slash their way to the capital of the Matsumae to expel all Japanese from Hokkaido once and for good. They believed that if they didn't do this, the Japanese planned to poison all of them. Matsumae officials, too, had talked of exterminating the Ainu, so that the Matsumae vassals and townspeople would not have to worry about them anymore. So clearly, just this was an incredibly tense time, really, just very, very violent with just incredibly high stakes in this conflict. [1:42:23] Word about the war reached the shogunate very quickly, and troops were actually dispatched from the center of Japan all the way to Hokkaido. Even though the Matsumae domain was not formally part of the Japanese Empire, because they were vassals of the shogun, they would get shogunate support nonetheless. It was reported that Shakushain was also making contact with Ainu on other islands like Sakhalin to join this war. This was a major concern because something happening around the same time was the Manchu invasion of China, the formation of the Qing Empire. People in Japan were suddenly a lot more wary of the possibility of these barbarian invasions from the north than they had been before. [1:43:05] Another really interesting parallel with the violent contacts between the Ainu and the Mongols centuries earlier. [1:43:12] Right, so in October 1669, after the shogun troops had been dispatched, Shakushain surrendered to the Matsumae. But he had caused too much trouble to be left alive. Shakushain and his generals were invited to a party to celebrate the peace settlement, only to be cut down. [1:43:30] Once again, if you're an Ainu chieftain, I really do not recommend going to a shindig run by the Japanese. It tends to not end very well. [1:43:39] Some traditions die very hard. [1:43:41] But anyway, the war brought much hardship to the Ainu, even those who weren't directly involved in the fighting. By this point, the Ainu were very thoroughly dependent on Japanese trade to remain fed, and the trade embargo that was instituted as a result of the war led many tribes to the brink of starvation. From this point onwards, the Matsumae realized that threatening to halt trade could be a weapon used against the Ainu. So after Shakushain's war, the Matsumae would formally create a boundary between the Wajinchi and the Ezochi. And the Wajinchi would continue to inch northward, and market relations would entangle more and more Ainu into dependence with the Matsumae, who were out to really secure their monopoly by any means necessary. Now, settlers would mostly be kept at bay for most of Hokkaido until the 19th century, but the quality of Ainu life really continued to decline, unfortunately. [1:44:41] Right. [1:44:41] And really, it's the aftermath of the failure of Shakushain's revolt that really makes Japanese conquest of the island, if not inevitable, much more likely to happen. Because after this period, the Ainu are no longer able to mount any kind of serious resistance to Japanese domination. I think this is why we should end this episode here with this failure, because it really marks a turning point in the history of the Ainu. I think that up until this point, the Ainu way of life and Ainu society really has been genuinely independent of the rest of Japan. But it is after this point, eventually leading to the direct colonization, in which the Ainu become essentially part of Japanese history, and I would say with very much disastrous results for their lifestyle. [1:45:31] Right. [1:45:32] Yeah. So that's it for this week. We're going to get much more into the later history and the following episode. [1:45:39] But yeah, wow, that was really a bummer to research, honestly. Parallels with American history really are quite striking. And it makes you realize that, you know, it's not because of American influence that this happened. I think it's really, if you look at it from kind of a materialist standpoint, it's that market relations compel people to be evil in a very mundane kind of way. These Japanese merchants were completely fine with destroying the Ainu way of life and fostering this really unpleasant dependency just because of like an incredibly meager bottom line. How much money do you think they could have been saving by giving the Ainu such worse compensation than they had given them 20 years before, right? It can't have been much, but they did it nonetheless. Yeah, they just realized that they could keep ratcheting. And now that the Ainu were totally dependent on them, they really had no means of fighting back. [1:46:33] Instead, they would just be given tons of alcohol to try to keep them complacent and just left to fend for themselves, making ultimately very meager wages as fishers for these luxury goods salesmen. [1:46:50] Right, right. And you know, there's whenever any kind of rebellion like this happens, there's always a lot of hand-wringing about whether or not it's acceptable for people like Shakushain to use any form of violent resistance against their occupiers. I think this is a classic example where the status quo was so quietly violent against the Ainu that if that the two ways to look at this are the Japanese gave the Ainu no choice but to resist violently, or at the very least, they offered the Ainu no humanity and should not have expected to be given any humanity in return. [1:47:27] Yeah, yeah, it's just really unfortunate, but it is what it is, ultimately. [1:47:32] Nah, no, and that's, you know, that's why it is heartening that in modern Japan, there is finally a turn toward the recognition of Ainu cultural dignity. But you gotta wonder, it's only because there is so little of an Ainu identity left that it's no longer a threat, right? That it's there's so few Ainu, and the fact that their language is now basically extinct, that only now can their culture be safely protected and promoted. [1:47:57] Yeah, right. I mean, that's, again, another parallel to what the American indigenous experience really. [1:48:05] No, and just, it's, it's very, yeah, it's, it's, it's, it's a really brutal history. The Ainu, like so many cultures, did not deserve this kind of treatment, but because of the absolutely brutal processes of economic development, they found themselves basically helpless, and people behaved completely amorally toward them in disastrous ways. And I think it's like, this is really just kind of an indictment of market relations in general, honestly. It just shows that when this kind of unequal exchange happens, and this is an unequal exchange that happens all over the world today, people suffer in terrible ways. And sometimes the only way out is a violent rebellion. And if that fails, things are probably going to get even worse. [1:48:53] Yeah, yeah. And oftentimes that violent rebellion is doomed to failure from the beginning because there's just very little chance that these people are going to have the means to overpower the oppressor in the first place. [1:49:09] Right, right. No, and I think that what's really so brutal about this, I think this might be what we should end on, is that it's clear from the stories about the rumors of poisoning and all that, that Shakushain believed that if his people did not strike back now, this would be their last chance and that they would basically be erased from history by the Japanese. And the unfortunate thing is that after this rebellion failed, it seems like he was proved correct. Although individual Ainu people seem to be doing better than they were doing 100 years ago, like we said, there are very few Ainu people left. Their culture, their identity has largely been erased, and largely as a cause, and this is a consequence of the direct colonization of the island, which was only possible after this rebellion had been broken. So I think that he was right, that this was their last chance and they lost it. [1:50:02] And now the Ainu people obviously still exist, and we shouldn't treat them as, you know, a group that has passed away into history. There's a lot of, there's a very unfortunate legacy of indigenous peoples being described as, you know, ghosts. This is not the case. But I think that things really would be a lot better off for the Ainu today if this rebellion had succeeded. [1:50:24] Yep. [1:50:24] And with that being said, if you happen to be an Ainu and you're listening to this episode, please get in touch. We'd love to hear from you. [1:50:31] Oh, absolutely. That would be incredible. We're hoping to get further into the kind of modern media representation of the Ainu in Japanese culture in the near future. I know that recently there's been a lot of interest in this very popular manga called Golden Kamuy, which is all about the colonization of Hokkaido. So it's been really exciting to kind of learn more about the role the Ainu have in the Japanese imagination today and the role of actual Ainu people in Japanese society. So really excited to learn more about modern Ainu people and share this with you guys. Again, if you guys like what you're listening to, please feel free to give us, you know, a couple dollars on Patreon. If you have any questions, any comments, shout us out. My DMs are open. We are always happy to hear. And I think with that, this has been Gladio Free Europe. [1:51:20] Thank you guys for bearing with us through our little delay. We are really excited to have a lot of really fun episodes coming up in coming weeks. We've been working on a lot of really fun stuff for you guys. All right. Take care. Bye-bye.