Gladio Free Europe, E96: Ármin Vámbéry and Hungarian Orientalism (with Turan Explorer) https://www.gladiofreeeurope.com/episodes/armin-vambery-and-hungarian-orientalism [0:00:15] Welcome back to Gladio Free Europe. I am your host, Liam, joined here as always by Russian Sam. [0:00:21] Hello, hello. [0:00:22] And once more by the incredible Turan Explorer, straight from the steppe. [0:00:27] Jó napot, how you guys doing? [0:00:29] Great. I am really excited to dive back into this really interesting topic. So let's just jump right in, continuing where we left off. [0:00:38] If you haven't heard our first episode on Turanism, I'd really recommend it. But to be incredibly brief here, the Hungarian language is now widely understood to be a member of the Uralic family, sometimes referred to as the Finno-Ugric family, which basically just means Finnish-Hungarian. Hungarian, as well as two tiny cousin languages spoken in Siberia, is only distantly related to Finnish. It also happens to have some very interesting grammatical similarities to Turkish and the other Turkic languages, as well as Mongolian. Linguists today believe that while Finnish and Hungarian certainly come from a common origin, probably spoken many thousands of years ago in Siberia, any similarity with Turkish is really a result of contact, not a common origin. So Finnish and Hungarian are believed to be this discrete group. Finnish and Hungarian and Turkish are not. However, in the early 20th century, this was very much not the case. [0:01:36] Many earlier generations of linguists, particularly in Hungary, believe that all of these languages came from a common Altaic or Turanian origin. This is no longer a well-supported theory, but it was very prominent in the early 20th century, not just in linguistics, but even in the realm of anthropology and nationalism. This kind of internecine debate about language families was bizarrely intensely important to the development of Hungarian nationalism, particularly after the failed revolution of 1848, which we discussed at length in our last episode. Because in this place and time, it was taken for granted that the origin of a language held some great secret to the origin of a nation and the, you know, the national soul. If it could be proven that Hungarian was in fact directly related to Turkish and Mongolian, then for a certain strand of Hungarian nationalists, it was believed that Hungarians should abandon many of the classically European attributes of their culture and return to the steppe. [0:02:43] Am I, is that, you know, am I on the right track, Turan? You're the expert here. [0:02:46] Absolutely. Yes, that's well put. [0:02:49] And in fact, before kind of the main course, we dive into the main guy that we're going to be talking about this episode. [0:02:54] Oh, yes. [0:02:55] I feel like there are two Turan Explorer adjacent figures who are worth mentioning. [0:03:00] Please. [0:03:01] We sort of touched on them just a little bit in the previous podcast, but the earliest guy to basically go out and try to find the steppe and someone, you know, who was related to the Hungarians was actually a figure in 1235 who left for the East in 1235 named Friar Julian or Friar Julianus. We really just have two documents talking about Friar Julian's travels, and there's a lot that you can speculate about those two documents. But basically, taking it all, you know, at face value, he went out to basically, you know, toward the Volga, the Volga region, and met some Tatars who told him that there were Hungarian speakers two days' route from where he was, two days' travel, but he doesn't specify in the letters, you know, in what direction. And he says that he encounters pagan Hungarians who could mutually speak the same language that he spoke. [0:03:52] He comes back, he reports that to he was a Dominican friar, and he goes out for a second time, and the people are totally decimated because that would have been they would have been destroyed by the very early, you know, Mongol invasion spreading westward. And what is more significant than Julian's recounting, if we can if we can believe it, of these Hungarian people is his description, either you know, seeing this devastation or talking to the various people he met along the way, eventually talking to rulers in Kiev. He recounts to Western Europe and gives some of the first sources of the Mongol invasions, that would, you know, that would ultimately come and hit Hungary pretty hard, of all places. [0:04:33] But so so he was the first of these explorers afterward, much later, actually, even before 1848, he there was a man named Sándor Kőrösi Csoma, who he was a Székely, as we mentioned in the last episode, and he went to Hungarian in Transylvania, exactly, exactly, a Hungarian Transylvanian. And he believed that basically he thought that the Hungarians were closest related related to the yellow Uyghurs. And his goal was to get to these Uyghurs and talk to the Uyghurs. He never actually gets that far. He wounds up, winds up in Tibet and becomes one of the first like Tibetologists. People consider him the founder of Tibetology as a field. Reads the first encyclopedias of Tibetan Buddhism, is probably one of the first to do that, and you know, writes one of the first Tibetan to Western languages dictionaries. [0:05:19] So interestingly, then jumping way into the future, Kőrösi Csoma's legacy, kind of tying in the past of Turanism and the present, in 1933, as Hungary and the Empire of Japan are aligned, Japan sends a delegation to Hungary to declare Kőrösi Csoma a bodhisattva. Really formally. This was as Hungary and Japan were fostering a lot of relationships. [0:05:43] Right. And we should mention here just kind of hammer home the different, very different angles Turanism has taken. That Hungarian-Japanese alliance was basically a predecessor to the Axis in World War II. [0:05:57] It was concurrent, yeah. [0:05:58] Uh-huh. Right. And I think that the Tibetan link is so interesting because I think that, you know, really in the broadest sense, Turanism is really just any Hungarian interest in Asia, right? Specifically, with the implication that learning something about Asia can teach you something about Hungary, because Hungarians are, in a sense, Asian. [0:06:15] We would go further and say that it's permutated to such a sense that it really is, I mean, it's an interest in anywhere in the world. There's Turanists who think that it's Mayans, that it's Quechua, that it's Egyptian, like we were talking about. Sumerian is a huge, zealous aspect of this. But yeah, it certainly starts with the look toward the East. But at this point, ancient aliens and Atlantis stuff, too. [0:06:41] Oh, yeah, no, absolutely. And it also, and this goes without saying, but even though Turanism has a very different attitude towards the East than other European nationalist tendencies, it's much more sympathetic to the East, which is very important, as we'll get into in the 20th century. Despite all that, it is fundamentally an Orientalist movement. It's really about this romanticized, idealized view of the East that kind of homogenizes very disparate Eastern cultures into one Orientalist blob, right? From like Tibet and Japan and China all the way down to Persia and the Middle East. They're all Turanians. [0:07:16] Yeah. [0:07:17] Right? And that's the thing is that there's this idea that all of those nations were Eastern in the same sense that the Hungarians were Eastern. As we mentioned, this was in many ways a reaction to the ongoing Western domination of Hungary by the German-speaking Catholic Habsburgs, who were believed, particularly after 1848, to represent everything the Hungarians were not. [0:07:41] Exactly. [0:07:41] Right. So as you said, with all these figures, many of these Orientalists from Hungary became some of the first Europeans to visit Asian countries, whether it's the era of Friar Julian, whether it's that explorer in Tibet. And as we're going to see in this episode, really focusing on the bulk of this episode, there was one figure in particular whose incredible journeys and probably even more impressive body of written work afterward in the decade, the many decades later of his long life, really attest to this very interesting Hungarian interest in the Orient. He was somebody who really put his money where his mouth was in truly attempting to kind of become an Easterner in a way that's very strange and a bit almost embarrassing and kind of odd and off-putting, but in ways that are interesting and really sets him apart from other Orientalists. This is the incomparable figure of Ármin Vámbéry, who I think is really a titan of the 19th century and one of the most Victorian of all the Victorians. [0:08:40] Exactly. The whole century distilled into one guy. [0:08:43] All right, so we briefly mentioned this guy back in October when we were doing our Transylvania episodes. We were talking about Bram Stoker's Dracula, which our friend Hernik Sworer also helped us with there. But Bram Stoker, he had his own helpful Hungarian, and that was precisely Arminius Vámbéry, who was his acquaintance. And probably the reason that Stoker's vampire was named after the actual Vlad Dracul of Transylvanian history rather than just remaining Count Vampire. [0:09:10] Right, right. So we don't want to overemphasize the link here because they weren't close friends. I think they just met once or twice. But Vámbéry was definitely an influence on Bram Stoker, particularly from his writings on Transylvania. And it's likely, but unproven that Vámbéry is the reason Dracula is named after the historical Dracula after all. [0:09:28] The character of Count Dracula. [0:09:30] Yeah, because the character was named Count Vampire until very late in the manuscript. It's pretty funny. Yeah. [0:09:36] Regardless, though, he's named in Dracula. And I believe of all the characters in Dracula, it's only Vámbéry, who, regardless what he told Bram Stoker, tells Van Helsing who Dracula is. [0:09:47] Yeah, that's true. [0:09:47] But it's just Vámbéry and Dracula, who are the only IRL historical figures in the book, I believe. [0:09:53] Yeah, because he's mentioned in the book as a friend of Van Helsing, the vampire hunter. You know, it's great. [0:09:59] My friend Arminius. My friend. [0:10:00] And we should mention that, you know, that little reference, that would have been kind of like a Victorian glup shitto, so to speak. Because very astute readers would recognize who my friend Arminius was a reference to, because Armin or Arminius Vámbéry was a relatively well-known figure in Victorian England. Not known as a Turanist, really, but known as a memoirist and diplomat, often in the service of the British Empire, because his wanderings in his youth, he led to these very widely read circulations of discussions of what life was like in Central Asia, which would become a very important asset for British foreign policy against the influence of Russia in Central Asia. [0:10:45] The Great Game. [0:10:46] Yes, the Great Game indeed. And what's kind of interesting, you know, which bring this back to Transylvania and Hungary in a sec for a second, is that Central Asia and Hungary were both places that were kind of in between the influence of the West and the influence of Russia because Central Asia was wedged between British interest in India and the great expanse of the Russian Tsardom in the north. And then, meanwhile, Hungary was right up against the Russian border while being controlled by the Habsburgs, who were very much kind of a traditional European power. [0:11:18] Very interesting subject here. And I think that what's really important to really keep in note for this whole episode is that all of the strange romantic nationalism of Turanism was heavily influenced by the political machinations of that time. And that a lot of times, you know, identities are shaped in opposition to somebody else. And that, like, as we've been saying, Turanism was very much made in opposition to the kind of European, the prevailing European identity of Hungary. [0:11:45] Exactly, exactly. [0:11:46] Yeah. [0:11:46] And lives kind of lockstep with all of that. [0:11:50] So Vámbéry was a really interesting figure. He was actually somewhat prominent in Victorian high society to the extent that he was a good personal friend of Prince Edward, eventually, you know, King Edward of the Edwardian era. And Edward was actually even the godfather of Vámbéry's son Rustam, who is named for the mythological Persian hero. And almost immediately after Edward became king, one of his first acts was naming Vámbéry to the Royal Victorian Order, a society whose other members included kings and emperors. Vámbéry was so prominent in Victorian London that it's actually somewhat surprising he never became a British citizen. Because despite spending a lot of time in Britain across his life, he always returned again and again to his native Austria, Hungary. [0:12:32] And he writes about his reason for doing that. You know, he says when he gets a taste of the British high society, he realizes, you know, it alienates him and it's, you know, just as uncomfortable to him as like living in poverty in Central Asia. So he even says that he realized he felt most at home in a place that was pretty much half East, half West, and returns to Hungary. [0:12:51] Yeah, that's great. And that's it. Vámbéry is just such an interesting figure. [0:12:54] We're going to get all into him. Let's just start from the beginning. I think that the most important thing about Vámbéry is that he had two incredible talents that would just define his life. He was one of the world's best language learners, just this immensely successful polyglot. And he was really, really good at wearing different masks. Very, you know, naturally enmeshing himself in local populations, whether it's, you know, the cafe society of Vienna, the elegant balls of London, or the oasis cities of Central Asia. And I think what's especially interesting is that he came from an incredibly humble background. Like you said, he came from this impoverished background of extreme marginalization and isolation. As Vámbéry was born into a very poor Jewish family in rural Slovakia, which at the time was, of course, part of Hungary. The town that he grew up in, you know, it's so like such a nowhere town. [0:13:47] Dunaszerdahely. In Hungarian, it means place in the middle of the Danube. [0:13:53] Yeah, and he really was dealt a poor hand as a kid because his father died when he was just an infant and his mother really struggled to make ends meet. She married a guy named Mr. Fleischmann, his stepfather, but he didn't really have much business acumen. And so they owned an inn that quickly went under. And then when this business went under, his family had to switch to a new trade, which I gotta say is like one of the most miserable old country kind of jobs I've ever heard of. Which was that his stepfather became a leech hunter. He went out into the swamp grabbing blood-sucking slugs from the mire to sell to country apothecaries looking to bleed people. [0:14:31] It sounds like a Nick Mullen bit. [0:14:33] Yeah. [0:14:33] Not like what the family did in the old country. [0:14:36] I know. And it's horrifying. And one of the earlier, like the first chapter of Vámbéry's autobiography called The Story of My Struggles, which we're sourcing this heavily from, he mentions how one time when he was a little kid, he woke up in the middle of the night to see that some of the leeches had wriggled out of their bag in the corner of their hut and had started sucking the blood through his toes. [0:14:58] God. [0:14:59] One of the few moments of like a bright, happy memory that he has is when he talks about at one point the leeches spilled and all the kids made like a game of collect of recollecting them. [0:15:10] Yeah. Man, and like, and then, yeah, it's like this, his memoir is just story after story of childhood misery. He grew up walking barefoot because his family was so poor with dirt floors. He had a ravenous appetite from his youth, but due to the poverty of his family, he almost never got his fill. So he was constantly haunted by hunger. Very, you know, Oliver Twist. His language is great. There's so much great writing here, but he specifically says, I often came face to face with the dreadful monster called hunger. His horrible grinning features have impressed themselves indelibly upon my memory. For hunger caused me to suffer equal pangs in my miserable lodgings in this town or among the sandhills of the steppes of Central Asia. [0:15:50] And an interesting thing about the differences in the English and Hungarian translations of his autobiography, you know, he was from like a very poor background, but he like emphasizes it much more in the English versions because they really, you know, loved like an Oliver Twist smile, rags to riches character. Which was like this is something that Russian Sam pointed out: is that the kind of the morals of his book is incredibly Victorian. He focuses so much on it. He emphasizes his own kind of moral strength, which would have really meant a lot to Victorian English readers in particular. [0:16:25] Yeah, like that's a very strong through line of the entire book where it's like, I was born into a hut, literally without a floor. I had leeches sucking my blood from when I was a young kid, and nevertheless, I persevered and I'm glad that happened to me because it made me even stronger. [0:16:40] Yeah. [0:16:41] Yeah, so Vámbéry, he was just so malnourished that one day he woke up with a sharp pain in his left leg and ultimately this leg just went lame. He would walk around with the crutch until his teenaged years when he decided that he would learn to walk without it based on, you know, this whole ethos of self-reliance. But he always had a very heavy limp. His mother, he attributed great wisdom to her despite everything, but she was illiterate and taken to all manners of superstition to try and cure the young Arminius. At one point, she sold Vámbéry to another woman, quote, in the hope that God would ward off the impending danger and be moved to clemency towards the possibly sinless new mother. And potions, herbs, and charms, they were a regular part of his childhood. The most shocking segment of this book is when she takes him to a folk healer who had Vámbéry steam in his lame foot for five days. [0:17:28] And then on the sixth day, he was pinned down and, quote, the peasant threw himself with all his weight upon my crippled knee, which formed almost a right angle. A terrible crash, and I knew no more. When I came to myself again, my poor weeping mother was on her knees beside me. She caressed me and gave me something to drink. The injured foot was now put between rough wooden splints and tightly bandaged. And so this guy told his mother that, like, the foot's gonna be normal when it's unbandaged, but lo and behold, that did not fix the problem at all. So he just got a pro-wrestling move done against his leg for nothing. [0:17:59] Oh god, that's hilarious. And like you said, it's just this whole book is a great look into Victorian English cultural norms in particular in the English translation. He takes great pains to emphasize how he overcame his disability through the strength of his garment. [0:18:13] And we should also point out too that he wasn't born Ármin Vámbéry. He was born Hermann Wamberger and Magyarized his name. And you know, he was very much, you know, he was from a Jewish background, but he very much considered himself to be Hungarian. And I think that that's kind of an important thing here that I think we touched upon this in our last episode, but that Jewish people in Hungary tended to be a lot more acculturated into the broader culture than you might have seen in Russia or Poland at this time. [0:18:40] Yeah, we're going to get into that later in the episode. [0:18:42] Yeah. [0:18:44] And yeah, so basically, so another thing that's kind of interesting about his experience as a Jewish kid was that he was the victim of constant anti-Semitic prejudice in many, many ways, but he seemed to believe that this kind of adversity, just like his lameness and just like this poverty, only made him stronger. And that he mentions the experience of anti-Semitic prejudice throughout the book as how it inured him to other forms of suspicion and prejudice he encountered many years later when he was traveling across Central Asia. [0:19:13] Exactly. Another interesting early life encounter for him is that his small village, which said the name literally just means, you know, place in the Danube, it was, it often hosted communities of traveling Romani people. And that seems like, this seems to really instill his interest in foreign cultures, as well as the kind of nomadic lifestyle that he knew was once common in Hungary in the Middle Ages, you know, when the Hungarian conquerors first came into the Pannonian basin, but was now limited basically to these incredibly marginalized, itinerant minorities. [0:19:44] Right? He says that, you know, they were his first introduction into the Orient. He calls them the brown children of the East. [0:19:50] Little cringeworthy. [0:19:52] Yes, yeah, he writes: The brown children of the East belonged to a tribe in Hungary known as the Wallachian Gypsies, a remarkable people, wilder and more lawless than the half-civilized tribes. They lived by stealing, fortune-telling, and tinkering, and were so hardened in the bitterest weather that they would camp in the open. [0:20:10] There's also an interesting kind of Romani ethnography thing because he's specifically talking about Wallachian gypsies and not, for example, like Romungro, who were more, you know, who were not from Wallachia and had itself kind of a Romungro and other, like Lovaro and other Hungarian Romani gypsies had, you know, a different and sort of assimilated role. [0:20:32] Yeah, and this is a little bit, you know, outside the bounds of this episode, but there are also very interesting linguistic divides among Romani people, you know, and that there's a specific Wallachian Romani language that is not the same as some other Romani languages. And then, of course, you've got all of the mixed languages, like there's like a Romani version of German, and then there's a kind of German-influenced version of Romani. It's really, it's kind of mind-boggling how much cultural diversity there is just among the Romani. But again, this kind of diversity is interesting because that is this really important factor of Central Asian life that is not really the case to the same extent in Western Europe, especially not in the British Isles. This constant intermingling of different languages as well as different religions. He, of course, as you mentioned, was Jewish in a Catholic country with notable Protestant and Eastern Orthodox communities. [0:21:20] So religious diversity was everywhere. And even though his family was very pious in their Judaism, when there's this kind of constant intermixing, you see a lot of strange commingling. For example, you know, after the pro-wrestling move on his foot didn't work, his mother actually took him to a Catholic priest to bless his weak legs. [0:21:38] Exactly. And then ultimately enrolls him in Catholic education as well. [0:21:42] Yeah, yeah, yeah. He had a very interesting relationship to both Judaism and Christianity. And of course, Islam, as we're gonna see. [0:21:48] Yeah, and just returning to the Victorian theme, Vámbéry, he had many negative things to say about his religious upbringing, as he viewed it, as being rooted in superstition and a very primitive orthopraxy, which had little understanding of the intellectual foundations of the faith. Vámbéry personally would convert to Calvinism as an adult for career purposes, but he was largely indifferent to religion until the end of his life when, interestingly enough, he somewhat randomly became a Baha'i. [0:22:12] Yeah, yeah. [0:22:13] So Vámbéry, he wasn't a fan of this upbringing, and so he had a very condescending attitude both to his faith and to the kinds of Islam practiced by lay people, which he saw as very similar to the kinds of Judaism that he was reared in. It was a correspondence that allowed him to humanize Muslims in a way that was rare among his contemporaries. [0:22:32] Right, yeah, he has this good quote here where he says: A religion which has to instruct its confessors in these minutest details, which prescribes how he must eat, drink, walk, stand, sleep, dress, and cleanse his body outwardly and inwardly, how to associate with women and how to comport himself during different natural occurrences. Such a religion necessarily exercises a profound influence upon the youthful mind. It absorbs him entirely, it captivates his senses and his thoughts. I found exactly the same thing in After Years Among the Muslim Youths of Turkey and Persia. There, as here, faith really manifests itself merely in outward appearances, in a ritual which is observed with the greatest exactitude, and is therefore not surprising that the young Jew, just like the young Muslim, when after years he begins to inquire into things for himself, breaks the fetters and becomes a free thinker. This total revolution of ideas may be explained as the natural result when two such widely different elements come into contact with each other. [0:23:26] Yeah, he as well, it's interesting because there was a whole cohort, most of them knew or were taught by Vámbéry, of Jewish Orientalists in Hungary, and some of whom were explicit Turanists, some of which weren't. And what's interesting is that almost all of them, at least like Goldziher and Germanus and Vámbéry as well, compare the like yeshiva system to madrasas, sort of like, you know, uniquely as such. It's kind of interesting. [0:23:51] Yeah. We're going to end this episode with kind of this really interesting kind of compare, look at the way that the kind of Turanist question approached Jewish people in very different ways. But I think that the fundamental thing here is that Hungarian nationalism had this self-conception of the Hungarian people as wanderers from a foreign origin that looked a little bit like the historic experience of the Jewish people. And as early as the high Middle Ages, it seems that Hungarian historians were imagining their own past with some influence by the story of Exodus in the Old Testament. [0:24:23] Yeah, all right. So Vámbéry, he very much looked down upon this kind of religious navel-gazing, but he also viewed it as creating the conditions that allowed for people to outgrow it. And this was just as true for Muslims as it was for Jews. We're going to get into this a bit more later, but Vámbéry, he was very much a cultural chauvinist, but he rejected racial chauvinism with vehemence, which was very rare among his contemporaries, which is one of his most positive attributes, I have to say. [0:24:48] He has one contemporary in particular who we're going to mention. He was a funny run-in with. Yeah. He also was a very strong critic of the idea that the language and the nation were intertwined. [0:24:59] That's so interesting because that idea seems so fundamental to Turanism. [0:25:03] You know, what's so interesting as well is that, and we might talk about it a little bit later, but the guys who, you know, won scientifically, the Finno-Ugrics, one of the biggest figures there, Pál Hunfalvy, not only was he extremely anti-Semitic and urged against the growth of the Jewish population in Hungary, but he also was vehemently a believer that the language and the nation are separated. So actually, it was originally, it was originally switched. It was the Finno-Ugrists, at least one of the major Finno-Ugrists who had that line of thought. [0:25:32] Huh, wow. [0:25:32] And yeah, so Vámbéry is, you know, he's attending a Christian school. [0:25:36] It's interesting, though, because there is, Adolf Ágai is one of the first major humorists in Hungary. He founded one of the biggest humor publications, Johnny Peppercorn. You know, it was really like a staple of like Budapest upper-class Jewish culture. It was really, really long-running humor magazine. He actually went to school at one point with Vámbéry. And it's interesting because Vámbéry writes about himself, you know, being a good student, but he just got distracted by all of this. But Agai seems to recount him as not being actually a good student. He had this prolific talent for languages, but according to one of his famous contemporary schools, he was not very good. [0:26:14] Right. And we should mention that, you know, this is that he's growing up here in the 1840s, right before the 1848 revolution. And this was basically, he would have been basically the first generation of Jewish kids in Hungary to grow up with this kind of secular or really just non-Jewish education. And only one in ten Jewish people would have had a secular or Christian education in this time in Hungary. This was really the beginning of what Russian Sam you've described as the foray of the Jewish people into liberal modernity, which would go on to be such an important part of Jewish history really up to the present. And that's why it's kind of interesting that he was not from a major city, he was from the sleepiest of small towns, which is somewhat, which in some ways is kind of not what you'd think of as a classical Jewish experience, but which represented Jewish life for many, many people in Central and Eastern Europe. [0:26:59] Yeah, so his mother sent him to a Protestant elementary school where he first picked up Latin. For anyone who's keeping track at this point, he would have spoken Hebrew, German, Slavic, as he calls it, and Hungarian. And now he's adding Latin to the mix. He was just a very prolific language learner from his youth to the point where he claimed that by 25, he could speak 25 languages, which I mean, I'm not sure about that, but he was definitely like... [0:27:22] Right, he's definitely a huge bluffer and bragger, but at the same time, it's clear from his memoirs that this guy could not have survived, whether in Hungary or in Central Asia, as we're gonna see, if he did not have these just supernatural abilities to acquire foreign languages and apparently, in many ways, speak about as well as a native. [0:27:39] So, the young Vámbéry, from the age of 10, he began to work as a language and Judaica tutor for a local minor proprietor who, in exchange for this, paid him as well as giving him room and board, which was very important to the very impoverished young Vámbéry. And because he lived for six months with this family, he was able to save up enough money to enroll himself in a more prestigious Catholic secondary school in the town at St. Georgen. He enrolled there after his bar mitzvah, and it was a huge culture shock for the young Vámbéry, who had been reared in provincial Orthodox Judaism and who now found himself having to adapt to these new surroundings. But he recalls that he took to it very well. He went to catechism very quickly and he gradually lost his old sense of religious inhibitions and taboos. [0:28:24] Like at one point, he mentions that he was so superstitious as a kid that he wouldn't even say the word cross. [0:28:29] Yeah. [0:28:30] Like to cross the street. [0:28:31] Yeah, yeah. [0:28:32] He's too Christian. [0:28:33] Yeah. But then he totally flipped here. And we should mention, though, this happened in spite of the fact that he experienced vicious anti-Semitism at St. Georgen, both from teachers and classmates and local townspeople. [0:28:45] Yeah. And his ability to feign belief in other religions came in very handy during his career, especially during his travels. [0:28:53] Right. And this kind of interest in religions was happening in spite of the fact that he was experiencing really horrible anti-Semitism from local Christians, including teachers and classmates, as well as people on the street. [0:29:05] Yeah, they called him Moshele. They called him Hirsch. They shouted Hep Hep Hep at him. A lot of stuff I actually don't know the context for, but I guess, yeah. [0:29:15] Yeah, you know, anyone who's read a little bit of early 19th century German history might know that hep-hep was this strange, mysterious, anti-Semitic rallying cry that anti-Semitic people in the post-Napoleonic era would shout. [0:29:28] It's actually not so mysterious. Like, basically, this was the call that German shepherds would say to their sheep and oxen and whatnot when they were putting them out to pasture, like, hep hep hep, go on. And like, in 1818, 1819, there was suddenly this massive wave of anti-Semitic students harassing Jews all over like Bavaria and those parts of Germany. It was specifically a reaction to Napoleonic liberalism, which emancipated Jews in Germany. Yeah, and so, like, the young Vámbéry, he was on the day that he met his second-year Catholic school teacher, he received a snide remark: like, well, Moshele, which is, you know, a name that was used to generalize Jews, why dost thou study? Would it not be better for thee to become a kosher butcher? So, in other words, like, why are you bothering with this intellectual pursuit? Why don't you just go and do what your people do, slaughtering animals and whatnot? [0:30:19] Right. And we should mention that this harassment did not end when the school bell rang because he mentioned, you know, the people shouting hep hep at him were random adults on the street. At one point, he even had stones thrown at him. And then, meanwhile, certain Jewish people around St. Georgen sort of saw him as a traitor for going to a Catholic school and, you know, in their mind, betraying the Jewish people. [0:30:38] Oh, and when he's much older, you know, writing in his 70s, you know, he even kind of makes a remark. He's like, we didn't have this whole Neolog thing back in my day. There were a bunch of, you know, mostly secularized Jews in Hungary. It feels like a little bit of kind of like old man, you know, like resentment a little bit, like how much it might have been easier for. [0:30:59] Yeah. [0:30:59] You know, like Neolog being like the Reform Judaism that began to become popular in like the 1840s, 1850s. [0:31:07] And also, just like, this was probably the most broke he had been in his life because the fellow Jews of St. Georgen were so skeptical of him. Like it was a tradition that Jewish families would feed students in Jewish seminaries, but because he was in the Christian school, at a certain point, like these people just stopped feeding him because they saw him as a renegade. So he remarks that like at this point, he was sometimes eating like two meals a week, maybe. [0:31:32] The whole like first fourth of his book is just trying to get a meal. [0:31:35] Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yes. [0:31:37] And I think, you know, to kind of psychoanalyze here, literally to survive, he had to adopt different cultural masks to basically curry favor from the various different ethnic and religious groups of the Habsburg Empire. And this would become incredibly valuable as he would travel across the Middle East and Central Asia as a young adult. It's the same kind of, you know, basically learning how to code switch and disguise yourself. [0:31:57] Yeah. [0:31:57] Right. [0:31:58] So in 1845, he became very tired of the small town provincialism and he decided to continue his education elsewhere. He visited Vienna for the first time, where he experienced all the marvels of the 19th century, like rail travel and puff pastries. In fact, he was so amazed by the latter that he didn't have enough cash left over for the last leg of his trip to Bratislava because he had spent it all on pastries. And he managed to beg for a few coins by impressing some Catholic travelers by asking them to pay for his train ticket in Latin. So it's sort of like Herzl at the Zionist conference famously said, Who among you can order a train ticket in Hebrew? Well, here, Vámbéry was able to get a train ticket in Latin, so he was very practically minded, as we can see. [0:32:39] Yeah, and so by his teenage years, he was still working as a tutor, but now in much more elite circles in Bratislava. Because, you know, Bratislava is right next to Vienna. It's a major city in its own right. And as a result of this new kind of cosmopolitan exposure, he began to study languages spoken even outside the Habsburg Empire, specifically Arabic and Turkish. [0:33:00] Right? And eventually studies Persian as well and talks all throughout his life about his deep, deep love of Persian literature. [0:33:06] Yeah. Yeah. So he spent many years doing that, just living as a tutor while studying languages on the side. And finally, in 1857, he decides he wants to go out to the east. When he started learning Turkish, it came to him that there were many similarities to Hungarian grammar, and that really piqued his interest and sort of sparked the passion that would animate the remainder of his life. When he decided he was going to do this, he wasn't able to get a passport for some time because, you know, he wasn't well connected at all, but he had made the acquaintance of a certain Baron József Eötvös, and the latter was able to help him to acquire this. Now, Eötvös, he was a very interesting figure. He was a Hungarian aristocrat and a very well-known liberal nationalist, which may sound like an oxymoron today, but it's a really important force in Europe in the middle of the 19th century. [0:33:58] And Eötvös, we're going to come back to him as a Jewish emancipator a bit later on, but now let's just remind our listeners where we left off the last episode. [0:34:08] Right, yeah, because just in very brief, you know, in 1848, there were these revolutions across Europe where they were nowhere more fierce than in Hungary, and Eötvös was one of these figures. Eventually, these revolutions would fail, especially in Hungary, largely due to the fact that non-Hungarian ethnic minorities, particularly Croats and Romanians, were very opposed to this liberal independence movement because they believed, not without reason, that independence for Hungary would have bad ramifications on non-Hungarians living in Hungary. And then, really, what was the nail in the coffin was that to the kind of shock of the mores of Europe, the embattled Austrian emperor actually invited the Russian Tsar to invade his own country to put down this rebellion. And this kind of occupation was very traumatizing for the Ukrainian national character, you could say, in a sense. It led to the Russians being described as the gendarme of Europe. [0:35:02] And also in the aftermath of this failed revolution, there were really horrible ramifications by local ethnic minorities and by the Habsburg state against Hungarians, as well as against Jewish people who largely supported these liberal revolutions. [0:35:17] Yeah. And Vámbéry, you know, I think that it's really important to point out, he becomes really radicalized by this. He talks about the pogrom that he experienced, you know, at the hands of, you know, I mean, he says the Slavs, you know, which is always, you know, maybe not always the favorite ethnic group in some of Vámbéry's writings. But, you know, he explicitly writes about how the ruling elite Magyars of Hungary are much more tolerant of religious minorities than the Slavs. And, you know, he writes about these kind of riots going on in Dunaszerdahely. And I think that it's important to say that it is directly because of this, at least in Vámbéry's own words, that he, after 1848, he's dejected with a number of other Jewish kids in this field. And they're watching the embattled and defeated 1848ers marching home. And this old peasant dramatically emerges and he says, one day the old Magyars will return from the east and bring us out of this misery. [0:36:10] And he says, you know, ever since then, I devoted myself to finding those old Magyars. [0:36:14] Exactly. And I think that to make bring this, you know, more personal, I think that we begin to see after 1848 this kind of personal transformation, one of several across his life, where he transferred, who basically transformed into essentially a, you know, an ethnic Hungarian, despite being from a Jewish background. He very much began to identify himself as a Hungarian person. And eventually he would, in the 1850s, make his first trip into the Ottoman Empire, where many Hungarian exiles had preceded him after 1848. [0:36:43] And Eötvös, his patron, encouraged him to advertise himself not as a Jewish person, but as a Hungarian, and to enmesh himself in the Hungarian community, not the very large Jewish community in Constantinople. [0:36:55] Of which he did. He spent a lot of time in the European quarter, but spent, I believe, six years in Istanbul with their total. A huge, huge portion of his life getting to know various pashas. He has this one, you know, he's generally a prudish guy, but he works as a language tutor for pashas and efendis. And he writes about at one point, you know, trying to get the women of the harem to this one harem to like him. And they're very hesitant at first. He escorts one to a dental appointment. You know, she has a toothache or something. And so is able to escort her. You know, they stop at a Hungarian friend for snacks and lunch and stuff. And apparently she had such a great time that, you know, over the course of the next, you know, several months, all of the other women started to have toothaches and asked to be escorted across. [0:37:41] At least according to his own words, he said, you know, it was very, very difficult for a man in his 20s to keep his eyes unaffixed from the fiery orbs of a beautiful Circassian. [0:37:51] That's hilarious. [0:37:52] Yeah. [0:37:52] And that kind of goes to show is that he, you know, as this natural chameleon, he used his charisma and his language skills to kind of shift seamlessly from the Hungarian community in Istanbul to the actual Turkish community. And that he became, he already was quite fluent in Turkish when he arrived. And because he knew so many languages, he really began to impress local Turkish Muslims. One of the things that he would do to make a name for himself was by performing Turkish poems and songs in these local coffee houses. And just like he'd done in St. Georgen and Bratislava, he once again became a language tutor. And so, you know, just as he'd previously transformed from a Jewish guy into a Hungarian guy, now he was an honorary Turk. He was dubbed Rashid Effendi by the Turks who knew him, and he made his way into the households of the Ottoman notables, chief among them the Pasha Mehmed Fuad, who was a really key figure in the reform era of Ottoman politics. [0:38:46] Yeah, and he also took to wearing a fez, which he would continue to do for the remainder of his life. He was just very Turkified. [0:38:52] He's elderly, he's wearing a fez, yeah. You know, and it's funny, he comes back after his trips to Central Asia, and he's not an instant celebrity. He thought that he would be, but I guess, you know, the culture in Hungary is just still so depressed, at least he says, you know, after 48, that, you know, nobody really celebrated his travels in Hungary. But he writes, as soon as he left for England, his Hungarian contemporaries immediately started talking smack behind his back, making fun of the fact that he came back and he was still wearing a fez. But he's like, but you see, my head needed to get used to the European hats again, and still wore a fez for the rest of his life because it was just his look. [0:39:29] Yeah, so Vámbéry, he's become a bit of a whipping boy ever since Edward Said wrote Orientalism. He's just sort of the quintessential example of someone who embodies the worst aspect of politically motivated European scholarship in the East. And the charge isn't entirely without merit, as he was a bit prone to exoticizing and portraying these peoples as barbarians sometimes. But in the East, Vámbéry also found much to admire compared to Europe. So for instance, he always had a chip on his shoulder about the European class system and the ways that the aristocrats were so high-minded about himself and considered themselves to be above the lowborn. So he wrote that the Oriental is quote particular about the nobility of blood only in the matter of his horses and sporting dogs. And like, I think that's not necessarily true. It just so happened that because he was a foreigner, he was like ranked in a different way than like a native Turk would have been. [0:40:23] But at the same time, like he was just right. [0:40:32] And I think, and this is a kind of common thing in 18th and 19th century Europe, this interest in foreign meritocracies believed to be superior to the European noble system. This is usually, you know, I think usually these people are looking at China when they do this, but Vámbéry very much did this, saw Middle Eastern societies, especially Iran, as some, if not egalitarian, more meritocratic. There was more social mobility for somebody of very low birth to rise up and become a vizier. [0:40:58] Yeah, exactly. Although he is very critical of the segregation of the sexes that he sees in Turkey because he thinks it makes the men like talk about sex too much, which he finds kind of vulgar. And he's also very critical of the religious fanaticism he encounters, which constantly reminds him of the anti-Semitism he experienced as a child. [0:41:19] But it's really so that's just before we move into Central Asia, which is mentioned. So really what sparks his interest in Central Asia, in addition to that encounter with an old Hungarian peasant as a teenager, was the fact that as he was learning Turkish, he was so naturally curious, he wanted to learn more about the other Turkic languages and even get his hands on any reading material he could about other languages believed at this time to be related to Turkish. For instance, Mongolian and Manchu. And so in his own words, Vámbéry, quote, found it advisable to retain this character of Efendi and visit the East as an Oriental. [0:41:55] And really, this in the late 1850s, early 1860s, this is where Vámbéry, as we know him, this great traveler, this larger-than-life Victorian, you know, wanderer, spy, diplomat, whoever he is, really comes into being. His, you know, the main thing that he embarks on that really, really makes his career from then on out. [0:42:15] Right. So he returns to Budapest, where he receives a university cash stipend for his work on a German Turkish dictionary and then sets right off back to the east. This time, he's determined to go much further than Istanbul and, in his mind, retracing the steps of his medieval Hungarian forebearers. And he took this offendi role so seriously that he decided to pass himself off full-time as an actual Turkish person. He kept the name Rashid, and he insisted that he was a dervish, you know, which those famous Sufi mystics who whirl around in their robes. [0:42:46] Although I don't think that he was of the whirling variety, I think that it was a different Sufi order that you were. So he was a okay. [0:42:54] He was a dervish who did not whirl. [0:42:56] I see. Okay, yeah. [0:42:58] Right. [0:42:58] Yes, yes, a stationary dervish. [0:43:00] Yeah, yeah. [0:43:01] So he decided that his first trip as Rashid should be to Tehran in north-central Iran. This was a journey that was well traveled by Turkish and Armenian merchants, but still pretty treacherous. And so with some financial support, as well as a letter of recommendation from the Ottoman court, he joined a trading caravan, I believe, of ethnic Armenians and began the journey to the border with Iran. So he traveled across the Armenian highlands on foot, because the only horses and donkeys were used to carry dry goods. He followed the mules up the mountain slopes, sleeping on bare rocks, woken only by rats sniffing at his toes. Probably, you know, a little bit too reminiscent of the leeches he encountered as a kid. He was really roughing it again, just like he'd done as a young boy. But eventually, despite these rough circumstances, his letter of recommendation from the Sublime Porte of the Ottoman Empire, as the government was called, gained him a lot of social credibility in elite circles in the Ottoman Empire and beyond. [0:43:56] He met the local governor of Erzurum, which is in Ottoman Armenia, and that's a very interesting city that had passed between Russian, Turkish, and Persian hands multiple times across the past 150 years. [0:44:08] There's a cool little anecdote here where he witnesses a very strange trial, like a legal, you know, dispute, where this local governor who received him claimed that one of his rings had been stolen from his bedchamber, and he knew that one of his seven household servants had to be the culprit. So a Muslim holy man was brought forward and said he knew how to find this thief. And he would do this with the use of a magic rooster. He took out a black rooster and said that whenever the real thief put his hand on this rooster, it would start to crow. And as soon as it began making noise, they would know who the true thief was. So all of these seven servants were told to put their hands forward and touch the feathers of this rooster. All seven of them would reach forward to the rooster. [0:44:54] And then, as soon as all the seven of them did this, the holy man told these men to hold out their hands. And Vámbéry saw that six of these men had sooty black hands, but one of them didn't. It turned out that actually this rooster had been rubbed in coal dust. It wasn't magic after all. But the fact that one of these men was too scared to actually touch it because he believed in the magic rooster, that meant he had to be the thief. [0:45:21] He recommends in the English version of My Struggles, he says that the London police need to adopt it. [0:45:30] Yeah. And just like he'd done when he was describing his early life in Slovakia, he took a lot of note of the diverse cultural and religious landscapes that he was encountering all across the Ottoman Empire and then again into Persia. So he met poor Armenian farmers who lived in caves, which is pretty, you know, that's really rough in it. And at one point, he actually spent the night along 20 cows in a stable carved into the bare rock of a hillface. But then as soon as they stepped outside of the caves, they would pass through the highlands haunted by Kurdish bandits. And he has this very self-aggrandizing moment where he describes how he became a very lion of strength and valor when he first had to pick up a pistol to defend this caravan from the Kurdish robbers. [0:46:10] It's like an anime hero monologue. It's really grand. Yeah. [0:46:15] Right. And then so he moves from Ottoman Armenia into Persia, which was actually, in a sense, enemy territory because the Ottomans had been rivals of the various dynasties of Iran for centuries. And a lot of local Shiites, who were probably Azeris, not Persians, they hated Vámbéry because he was passing himself off as a Sunni. So he really encountered for the first time this Sunni-Shia divide. And although I think that these days, Shiism is not really associated with extreme, zealous sectarianism. In his travels, maybe just because he was passing himself as a Sunni, he encountered a lot of Shia prejudice and seemed to have kind of bad feelings towards Shiites in general. [0:46:57] Yeah, he's got a very love-hate relationship with Iran. He really loves Persian culture and literature and language and, you know, the architecture, but he does not seem to have that favorable opinion of the fanatic Shia. [0:47:09] No, no, and I think, and we should mention that it's not because of any particular prejudice against Shiites. It's really just his low feelings toward religion. So he says here, it was religion, the product of divine inspiration and the supposed means for ennobling and raising mankind, which made me feel the baseness of humanity most acutely. And from my cradle to my old age, in Europe as well as Asia, among those highest cultures, as well as amidst the crudest barbarism, I found fanaticism and narrow-mindedness, malice and injustice emanating mostly from the religious people, and always on behalf of religion. [0:47:44] His enemy number one his whole life. Or maybe that was Russia. And then it was religious content. [0:47:50] Right. And then so while in, I think a good example of this, he had one very funny encounter with this kind of sectarianism while in Tabriz, where he fell in with a crowd of Shia religious singers also bound for Tehran. These guys were very rough travelers. They slept, they traveled all night sleeping in shifts. They tie themselves to their horses and sleep from the saddle. But then the more he began to knew these Shia singers, the more he began to realize they actually were not Shiites after all. [0:48:17] Yeah, he learns that they're Sunni and they're talking a lot of smack about the Shia behind their back. He sort of relates to that a bit. [0:48:25] Yeah, yeah, because they were charlatans. These guys were Sunnis who passed themselves off as Shias just to extort money out of the local Shia communities. And in their mind, this was really, you know, a way to get one over on the heretics. And also, he found out that some of them, some of these guys had previously done something even more underhanded, which was leading Shiites to the famous holy sites in Iraq, like the city of Karbala, but actually leading them to into a trap where fellow Sunnis would then, you know, jump out from behind the rocks and stick these guys up, you know, and rob them. And he was really kind of taken aback by this, it seems like, you know, realizing that like these people he was traveling with were just these like awful bandits. [0:49:08] Yeah. So, thanks to his letter from the Ottoman government, Vámbéry was able to be received as an honored guest by the religious group leaders of Tehran. And these guys tried to convert him from presumably Sunni, which he was passing himself off as, to Shia, and asked him all these kinds of Islamic theological questions. There were a few times that Vámbéry couldn't answer, and the Mullahs just took this as a way to say, Aha, we got you. You Sunnis don't even have an answer for that one. Not knowing that Vámbéry wasn't actually Sunni. He just wasn't very familiar with all these polemics. But he was good enough to pass himself off clearly. Now, Vámbéry, he was much less impressed with the European diplomats in Tehran, as they tended to have little interest in Persian culture. As far as I can tell, he kept up the Rashid persona even when he was speaking to these diplomats. [0:49:53] And so he was, you know, passing himself off as a dervish from Turkey and not Austro-Hungary. [0:49:58] Right, and one of these diplomats in particular was actually someone we hinted at earlier. Really a strange figure for him to encounter. It was the notorious race scientist Arthur de Gobineau, who pioneered the Aryan theories of Adolf Hitler and so many others in the interwar years leading to World War II. Turns out that Arthur de Gobineau was in fact a French attaché in Persia at this time. [0:50:25] Vámbéry doesn't really have much to say about Gobineau. However, it turns out that it seems that Gobineau, unlike Vámbéry, saw the indifference to rank in Persia as a bad thing. He rejected what he saw as this democratic character, and in particular, the indifference to skin color he noticed around the Persians. Because people in Iran of African or Indian descent, could rise up the social ranks just as much as a lighter-skinned Persian. [0:50:51] Any thoughts, Turan, on Gobineau and, you know, the ways that his whole Aryan stuff intersected or was rejected by Turanism? [0:50:59] Yeah, it's interesting. I can't think of, although I'm sure there may be some Turanists who explicitly refer to de Gobineau, although I'm sure later on in the movement there probably are. [0:51:09] Right. I know, as we'll see, some of these guys, they saw themselves explicitly as not the Aryans. The Aryans are the Germans and the Russians, and we're not them. [0:51:17] Yeah, but de Gobineau did write about Magyars and Osmanli Turks as being examples. You know, I've read what he says, and shocking, the inequality of human races is not a particularly coherent book. But, you know, he writes about the Magyars and say that, oh, people would use the example of Hungarians saying that Hungarians are, you know, the same language as Finns. This is very funny writing before Hungary became a smaller country. Says, oh, the Finns have mostly been in servitude throughout their entire existence, but the Magyars are one of the great conquering peoples of human history. And he's like, well, how could this be? Because they're, you know, the Magyars used to be yellow and they're white now. And we, we know, he makes this claim that the men of Saint István did not marry foreign wives, which is just patently untrue. But, you know, he's using them as an example or, you know, building like a straw man where it's like, well, don't you see that, you know, the Asian race can successfully conquer Europeans like they did in the case of the Hungarians. [0:52:21] But he, you know, ultimately cites cites theorists, not a Hungarian theorist, who says, who unequivocally, according to de Gobineau, proved that the Huns became the Székely and the Hungarians. And says that the Huns of Attila were referred to as the White Huns, which is also historically untrue. The White Huns were the Hephthalites in India. I've never heard those Huns, Attila's Huns called the White Huns. But he says that that means that they are white, which is funny. It was almost certainly a directional attribute. And says that a Germanic element permeated the Huns even in the time of Attila. And actually, the Hungarians, because they're the Huns, were always white. So even though there's this linguistic affinity with the slovenly and destitute Finns, like they are such successful conquerors because I guess they're whiter than Finns, which is also just like nonsense. [0:53:12] And that's, yeah, right. And that's what's so important, this kind of nationalism, even though so much of it seems so dogmatic, ethno-nationalism is always very flexible and suitable to any kind of political goal. It's like how, you know, Gobineau's inheritors, the Nazis, they would describe how some Slavic peoples were inferior Untermenschen, like the Russians, but other Slavic peoples, like the Bosnians, who just happened to be kind of friendly with the Nazis, they were actually, you know, temporarily embarrassed Aryans. [0:53:36] Of course. Uh-huh. [0:53:37] Right. You know, so we should mention, so, you know, while Gobineau really despised basically everything about Persia, Vámbéry really liked many aspects of the country. But he did a lot of kind of constructive criticism, especially in comparing Persia to the Ottoman Empire. This is something I think that some, you know, people who have not studied Middle Eastern history might not realize, but in the 19th century, the Ottoman Empire was significantly more sophisticated in its economy, government, and especially its military than the Persians. There was just a lot more centralization in all senses in the Ottoman Empire, despite the fact that it controlled much more territory than Iran. He described Iran as feeling a century behind that of Turkey and even further behind Austria-Hungary. The lack of any kind of economic connectedness from one part of Iran to another meant that if any new technology was introduced to Tehran, the capital, it had very little hope of spreading to the farther reaches of the country. [0:54:32] He called this a systematic want of system. And he got the impression, in addition, that Turkish intellectuals were much more open-minded than the Persians, possibly because he thought that Turkey had less of a homegrown intellectual tradition due to the historic reliance on Arab and Persian thought. This meant people in Istanbul, they were so used to absorbing foreign ideas from the East from Persian ideas, they would also just as easily absorb foreign ideas from the West. Then the Persians themselves were so proud of their great intellectual history from the ancient time of King Xerxes up through the Islamic Golden Age that the Persians were too proud to adopt any foreign ideas and thus were doomed to stagnate. That's his very condescending Orientalist attitude, but it doesn't really seem to be coming from a place of hatred. I think he really did seem to think that these were, you know, this was advice to Iran, and it was not a condemnation. [0:55:23] Yeah. And he hated the sectarianism. Like, that can't be understated enough. He really thought that there could only be basically future for the Muslim world to modernize if Shia and Sunni could get along. [0:55:35] Yeah. [0:55:35] Peace in the Middle East. [0:55:37] Yeah, exactly. Right. [0:55:39] And then, but now, in Tehran, things would really get interesting once he first had his encounter with people who were not Iranian at all. These were a group of Central Asian mystics on their way back from a pilgrimage to Mecca. And it turns out these guys had come all the way from Xinjiang, what he called Chinese Tartary. Their leader Bilal had visited Mecca twice and was actually the court imam to a Chinese Muslim official to the city of Aksu. These guys were probably Uyghurs. He does not identify them by name. Some of them might have been what we describe as Hui, who are ethnic Chinese Muslims. They were definitely from China, but culturally very distinct from most Chinese people. They were kind of a world of their own. And so, against the advice of his Persian hosts and all of the local Europeans, Vámbéry decided to join these Chinese pilgrims back to the innermost reaches of Central Asia, to cities possibly not visited by any European since the time of, you know, Friar Julian and the Silk Road under the Mongols. [0:56:39] But before Vámbéry left, he had one funny encounter with an Austro-Hungarian doctor who may or may not have seen through Vámbéry's disguise. This guy gave him a strange parting gift, which was cyanide capsules to swallow in case he was ever captured and facing imminent death by torture. [0:56:57] Spy suicide pills. I mean, like, not only was he a triple agent, but he also had like spy suicide pills. [0:57:05] Yeah, really hardcore stuff. [0:57:07] You know, he was plagued for his entire life by allegations of him being a British agent from pretty much this point. Although, like, the actual archival evidence that has been uncovered shows him being on British payroll from like the end of the 1880s, thereabouts. So he wasn't at that. It was 20 years after this. Yeah, so he wasn't. But he always liked to have an air of mystery around him and to imply that, you know, he was really hot shit. So yeah, this really fits that persona very well. [0:57:37] Right. And so he set off in the second leg of his journey with these rough and tumble Uyghur travelers going across the Alborz Mountains toward the Caspian Sea, and from there, the cold deserts of Central Asia. He was truly for the first time in the land of Turan. He said that in the daytime, it was pleasant, but the same temperatures as Hungary or Istanbul, but at night it was freezing cold. And the travelers insisted that the best way to distract from this terrible sensation of, you know, freezing to death was to sing as loud as you could. And he noted that some of these melodies in these Uyghur songs reminded him a little bit of Hungarian folk music. [0:58:14] Yeah, he sings about singing Hungarian folk songs too, and just nobody knew what he was saying. And they were singing Islamic religious songs, and it's a very cool vibe, it seems like. [0:58:23] Oh, definitely, yeah, yeah. No, truly, an all-men are brothers kind of language, right? And then, so, you know, we should mention his, he mentions in his first book, he describes his traveling companions in these Uyghur mystics. Some of them were former soldiers of the Chinese Qing Imperial Army. One man was an epileptic who thought that his condition was a divine blessing that brought him closer to Allah, which kind of reminds me of the Christian Pentecostals or the whirling dervishes, you know, this idea that a trance-like state is this divine experience. And then the most interesting of all of these companions was an old knife maker named Kerban, who was even more well-traveled than Vámbéry himself would ever be. Because this guy claimed that, in addition to having made this pilgrimage from western China all the way to Mecca, he had also previously traveled not just to Constantinople, but even to Calcutta in India by way of Tibet, which just is so incredible to imagine in a 19th-century context. [0:59:20] Basically, traveling like, you know, almost all of Asia, presumably on foot or possibly on camels. It's just crazy to think about. [0:59:26] Yeah, these guys had great calves. [0:59:28] Yeah, I'm sure they did. And they were perfect guides for Vámbéry. He rode with them, slept in their tents, ate their food. He mentions these people were so efficient and economical that they cooked their food in the same fat that they used from their candles. And, you know, during this experience, just as he felt himself turning Turk earlier, he now felt himself becoming a steppe nomad. He spent so much time on horseback that he suddenly began to feel unwieldy and ungainly when he was on foot. He felt his gait changing as so many hours on horseback, you know, actually changed the bend of his legs. [1:00:04] Yeah, and I'm sure that that must have been very freeing as a, you know, as someone who walked with a limp their entire life. [1:00:09] Yeah, yeah, no, totally, yeah. And so during this experience, as he goes through Central Asia, he much like Austria-Hungary, it's a kind of interesting place where it is at the same time cosmopolitan, but also very provincial. There are many different ethnic groups interacting with each other, and many people pass through this area. However, most residents live and die within a relatively close vicinity of their plate, of their, you know, hometown, their place of birth. Because of this, so a lot of the people he encountered had never met anybody from the Ottoman Empire, let alone from Europe. And the fact that he brought with him a seal from the court of the Ottoman Empire gave him incredible respectability among these Turkic tribes in what's now Turkmenistan, who shared a language, in a sense, and especially a religion with the Ottoman Empire, and not with the Persian Empire that ruled them. [1:01:04] And that's very important. [1:01:05] At one point, an old Turkic chieftain saw Vámbéry's seal from the Ottoman court and immediately offered to lead a Sunni jihad on his behalf against the Shiite Persians. And Vámbéry actually considered this. He writes, The thought flashed through my brain: stop, why not undertake this romantic exploit? All the way from Sharud, the Persian frontiers are exposed. 5,000 Turkomen can easily take the field against 10,000 Persians and more. And where will the Shah find so many soldiers in all a hurry? In Tehran, I shall find some adventurous Italian and French officers who will probably like to join me. In any case, an attack on the capital can be successfully accomplished. And who knows, I might myself possess the Persian throne, if only for a few days. [1:01:52] The white boy lusts for Paul Atreides. [1:01:54] Yes, no, exactly. And I would say you can see only in the example of Baron von Ungern-Sternberg how dangerous these kind of ideas could be in the wrong white boy Orientalist hands. [1:02:06] Yeah, who also had a Hungarian connection, too. [1:02:09] Yes, he did. Yeah, we're lucky that Vámbéry is a little bit, you know, too modest to try something as insane as that kind of filibuster scheme. [1:02:17] And so during all of his journeys, he eventually would reach all the way to the city of Khiva, which we're going to get to. But, you know, before he gets there, he had one brief run-in where with somebody who identified him not as a Turkish dervish, but as a European imposter. Because along the shores of the Caspian Sea, he crossed paths with an Afghan who had a run-in with the British army during their invasion of his country 20 years before. And at one point, Vámbéry overheard this man whispering in Persian to their caravan master. I bet you he is a Farang or a Russian spy. And with his pencil, he makes a note of all the mountains and valleys, all the streams and springs, so that the Russians can later on come into the land without a guide to rob you of your flocks and children. [1:03:04] In Khiva, thanks to the precautions of the Khan, the rack will do its part, and the red-hot iron will soon show what sort of metal he is made of. [1:03:13] Yeah, at this point, I think we should just explain the context of this because, for a while now, the rulers of this region were very paranoid about the Russians, especially, but European presence in general, because they just took these people to be mapping the territory for a future invasion force, as this man points out. So, like again, not unfounded, that's what happened, yeah. So, when Europeans would be exploit exposed in the region, they had a nasty habit of getting thrown into the dungeon and then executed, which happened to prominent British agents some 20 years before Vámbéry's own expedition. So, whenever he was like going up to all these courts and these cities to all these khans, this was very much in the back of his mind where it's like if you you know make a misstep, you could very easily find yourself executed and your head being stuffed full of straw and put on display. [1:04:17] Yeah, and his spy suicide pills come back up in this anecdote, don't they? [1:04:21] Yes, he very strongly considered secretly placing one of these poison pills in that man's food. He writes, I took the pill from the wadding of my cloak and held it for some time between my fingers close to the edge of the dish. The deadly silence of the night and the opium fumes which held this man under their spell seemed to favor my devilish scheme. But when in my distraction I gazed upwards and saw the brilliant shining canopy of heaven, the magic beauty of the stars overmastered me. The first rays of the rising moon fell upon me. I stayed my hand, ashamed of meditating a deed unworthy of a civilized man, and quickly hid the fateful pill again in the lining of my dervish cloak. Very dramatic. [1:05:07] Right. And then, so, following this Uyghur caravan, Vámbéry would eventually travel to the great cities of Bukhara and Samarkand, both of them in modern-day Uzbekistan. But I think his most exciting encounter would be in Khiva, which at the time was a really important Central Asian political center. Today, it's a city with fewer residents than Fort Myers, Florida. But in Vámbéry's time, this city actually was the seat of power over most of what's today considered the former Soviet republics of Central Asia. Most of Uzbekistan, most of Turkmenistan, as well as major chunks of Kazakhstan. And so, in his first book, he offers this great description of his audience with first a grand vizier and then the Khan of Khiva himself. [1:05:52] Yeah, a man who knew Khan, king, and sultan. [1:05:55] Yes, so in right, it's amazing. And he, I believe he even met the Austro-Hungarian emperor at one point, right? [1:06:01] Yes, uh-huh. Yeah, yeah, he recommended him to the right. [1:06:04] Vámbéry is the 19th century. It's amazing this was a real guy. [1:06:08] And when he's in Khiva, you know, he's a guest of Saeed Muhammad Ken or Muhammad Khan, who I think he was one of the last, well, obviously given the timing, of the Qungrat dynasty, Khans in charge of Khiva. And after starving for so long, I mean, really, most of his life, but especially on this trip, he suddenly is engorged with food. So much that it really kind of like repels him. Like he's he can hardly stomach how much food he's eating when he's a guest of the Khan. [1:06:43] Right, because he really sees, like, even though, you know, by the 19th century, the glory of the Silk Road was long gone, these oasis cities in Central Asia were quite prosperous due to trade with China and Russia, and particularly prosperous in comparison to the utter deprivation of the steppe and desert all around them. [1:07:00] Oh, yeah, I was just going to say, yeah, and he goes to Bukhara as well, which was the where the tomb of the founder of one of the biggest Sufi orders is. So this was more or less the whole crux of his clandestine reason for being in these places was that he wanted to go to, I believe, the Naqshband pilgrimage site there. Yeah. Yeah. [1:07:28] You know, what's funny is that even though, you know, the Sufis were very well respected among the Sunni nomads of Central Asia, the city of Bukhara was seen as kind of snooty, apparently. And so some people told him, like, you really want to go to Bukhara? They're just snobs up there. And he hated snobbery, so I get it. [1:07:43] Let me give a description of his first audience with the Khan of Khiva, because this is just so fun. This is what kind of makes the whole book, you know, so interesting to me. He writes, The crowd gave way for us on all sides, and it was a sort of great satisfaction to hear the women pointing to me, saying to one another, Behold the dervish from Constantinople, who is to give his blessings to our Khan. May God give ear to his words. I found the vizier in a hall surrounded by his officers, who accompanied every word of their lord with approving smiles. It was easy to distinguish by his brown complexion and his long, thick beard falling down to his breast, that he was of Persian origin. His clumsy dress and his great fur cap especially suited his rough features admirably. As he saw me approach, he spoke a few words laughingly to those around him. [1:08:29] I went straight up, saluted him with a serious expression of countenance, and assumed at once the place of honor in the company, belonging of right to the dervishes. I uttered the usual prayers, and after all, I uttered the usual prayers and added the amen with ordinary stroking of the beard, and then the customary civilities were interchanged with the vizier. The minister was desirous of showing his wit, and remarked that even dervishes in Constantinople were well educated and spoke Arabic, even though I had only made use of Istanbul Turkish. I then handed my printed pass from the Ottomans. On receiving this sign of paramount sovereignty, he kissed it reverently, rubbed it on his forehead, and then rose to place it in the hands of the Khan, and almost and returning almost immediately, told me to step into the hall of audience. A curtain was rolled up, and I saw before me Saeed's Muhammad Khan, Padishah of Kharezm, or as he would be styled in ordinary prose, the Khan of Khiva, on a dais, with his left arm supported upon a round silk velvet pillow and his right holding a golden scepter. [1:09:40] The Khan now began to question me respecting the object of my journey and the impression made upon me by the desert, the Turkomen, and Khiva. I replied that I had suffered much, but that my sufferings were now richly rewarded by the sight of the beauty of His Majesty. I thank Allah, I said, that I have been allowed to partake this high happiness and discern in this special favor of Kismet a good prognostic for my journey to come. [1:10:08] Very magical. It's so interesting, you know, to think then if you were a little Victorian child, or I guess, you know, like an educated Victorian adult reading this accounting. It's all very, very ethereal and fantasy-like. [1:10:27] Right. And again, because this guy came from like the lowest of low backgrounds. His family were poor Jewish leech hunters. And here he is being received by the great Khan, you know, the first European to visit the city in centuries. And again, not just, and on top of all that, he had a disability. [1:10:44] Yeah. He was lame. He continued, I think throughout this whole journey, he would use, he would still use a cane. I think he used a cane his entire life. [1:10:51] Yeah, there was actually a really great moment when he's brought before one of these khans. And again, they're generally very skeptical of him when they first meet him because they think that he might be a European interloper. So this guy, he asks him, oh, what are you doing walking all the way through this journey with that lame leg of yours? And he's just like, well, it didn't stop Tamerlane. And look where that got him. So yeah, he was just very quick on his feet and very ready to answer any kind of suspicion with quick jabs like that. He was also very good at reciting poetry, as we mentioned previously. And he would charm many people by just breaking out into a poem when the atmosphere was tense. [1:11:36] Yeah. Right, right. Although, you know, we do have to mention him with all these little epic clapback moments. This is his book, in his own words, you know, his own myth-making. [1:11:45] Okay. Yeah, but he did make it back alive. So clearly, he had a skill to him. [1:11:52] All right. So I think that's really as much as we can do with Vámbéry in the interest of time. But like I said, just an amazing figure. And I gotta say, Turan Explorer, thank you so much for putting this guy on our radar. I had never heard of him before this. And there's just so much, there's just so much fun stuff to get into with all of his books. [1:12:09] Yeah, the single most interesting person. You know, it's funny though, because there is a link between Vámbéry and our next topic because he, you know, in addition to all of this, the commentary later in his life about Russia, he is an essential figure in a lot of movements, but especially in Turanism in Hungary. [1:12:31] Right. And so let's just dive into that. [1:12:33] This is what this is all about. So by 1864, Vámbéry was back in Istanbul. From there, Budapest. His book, Travels in Central Asia, was initially published in German, but when it didn't make as much of a splash as he expected, he then went to London to arrange an English translation. And that's when it really took off. In addition to finding a lot of success in the British elite, he found himself basically really enjoying Britain and becoming as much of an Anglophile as he was a Turkophile. You know, so he would, I think, I believe he was still in his early 30s when he arrived in London, like he'd be 33, and would basically spend the next 50 years writing books in both German and English, and occasionally Hungarian on a variety of subjects: linguistics, history. He wrote multiple histories of Hungary for English and German audiences on Iran, especially, and of course, Central Asia, as well as linguistics and geopolitics. [1:13:30] Yeah. And his linguistic work about Hungarian is what caused a chain of events that I would say, in many ways, Hungarian Turanism might not exist today, at least not in the same shape if it was meant. If not for this, yeah. [1:13:43] Exactly. Because, you know, he by because in a sense, you know, if Hungary, if Hungarian Turanism is about bringing back together Hungary to the steppe, he was the first person to really do that since the time of like Friar Julian. [1:13:55] Yeah. You know, exactly. Yeah. [1:13:58] The thing is, he was incredibly intelligent, an obvious genius, you know, self-made man in many ways. But, you know, back and forth as like a scientist, so much of a Renaissance man that you can see why actual linguists would have had ire with him when he takes huge leaps and says that he believes Hungarian is a Turkic language, which caused a massive, I mean, like, really, it's a little corny, but it feels like rap battle style. Like, it's impossible to stress what, how heavy this was a subject among the Hungarian intelligentsia. [1:14:38] Yeah, because it was the Ugric-Turkic war. There was just widespread belief that all Central Asian languages had a common origin, but in that broader Altaic or Turanian umbrella, was Hungarian closer to Turkic or closer to Finnish? And we now know pretty decisively, it's almost it's close, it's part, it's you know, closer to Finnish. And the idea of this broader Altaic family is no longer widely believed. But it's what's interesting about Hungarian, as we mentioned in our last episode, despite having this origin with Finnish in Siberia, there was so much contact with Turkic-speaking peoples in the Middle Ages that Hungarian began to adopt some features of neighboring languages that Finnish, as not a neighbor of the Turkic languages, did not do. But despite all of that, you know, regardless of your stand on whether Hungarian was closer to Finnish or closer to Turkish, everybody agreed that this Asian origin of Hungarian was, at the very least, something of note and may have interesting nationalist and philosophical implications about both the past and the future of Hungary. [1:15:46] And so, near the end of his life, Vámbéry was one of many elite Hungarians who tried to synthesize all of these kind of eastward-looking ideas into a nationalist direction. This was, of course, the Budapest Turan Society, which really brings Turanism as we know it into Hungarian politics. [1:16:08] Yeah, at a point, you'll find almost every Hungarian prime minister during this period was a member of the Turanian Society. Particularly after World War I, where things really get hardcore. [1:16:22] Exactly. So, this we're looking at now pre-World War I, around like 1900. Vámbéry is an old man. He's like in his 70s now when this is happening. But these people, this new generation, are very much following him. The Turan Society's charter claimed: Our goal is the cultural and economic progress, confederation, flourishment of all Turanians, those being the Hungarian nation and all kindred European and Asian nations. Furthermore, the geographical, ethnographical, and economical research of the Asian continent, past and present, political and religious issues are excluded. [1:17:01] Yeah. And, you know, so many of these guys are so incredibly interesting. Yeah. Like, none quite as much as Vámbéry. I wish that we had 20 hours to go into the nitty-gritty details. But one funny thing about this sort of fault line that emerged was that all of the supporters of Vámbéry and his idea, which he eventually did revise and agree with the Finno-Ugric thesis, but most of the supporters were not a the two main proponents of the Finno-Ugric theory were Germans themselves who had moved to Hungary. So that's a little sus, at least in the mind of the Hungarians. But also, you know, they were boring old linguists. All the guys who were on Vámbéry's side were like cool, sexy explorers, artists, poets, theater patrons, collectors of all of this interesting, you know, art, guys who went on expeditions like Vámbéry as well. And each of them wound up, you know, going in a bunch of different directions. [1:17:55] Some of them wound up disagreeing with Turanism as it existed. Some of them wound up converting to Islam. You know, one guy, Gyula Germanus, became like an advisor to King Faisal. So many different directions that these guys go in. But it also becomes this huge and influential kind of political society in Hungary, sort of like a racially conscious Freemason lodge. [1:18:22] Right. No, and that's why I think it's, you know, the most unflattering way you can describe, you know, Turanism is that it's a lot, it's not dissimilar, honestly, looking at the outset from, you know, these, like you said, racially conscious men's clubs that, you know, in Germany would be the groups that became the Nazis and in America, were the second Ku Klux Klan that we discussed in our episode with our good friend Jern, who actually himself is of Hungarian descent. But really, I think, you know, Turanism did not have any kind of conclusions anywhere near as odious as the Nazis or the Klan. But we have to mention, it was a European nationalist movement. And, you know, European nationalism unavoidably goes into some horrible directions. You know, I think a lot of our listeners are probably sympathetic to the historic Irish nationalist project, but even Irish nationalists have oftentimes had some very horrific conclusions that, you know, they see as the logical end result of this nationalist ideology. [1:19:30] A good glimpse into this is the history of the Arrow Cross, the Hungarian Fascist Party's relationship with Turanism. Because at first, Ferenc Szálasi is such an avid Catholic that he's actually very off, very put off by it. And, you know, it was seen as like this very pagan thing. There were scandals. I mean, this explodes. It winds up not being only the Turanian society. It is hundreds of different organizations, including some cults who wind up getting in trouble. One of them, I believe, does actually sacrifice a white horse in like a Turanist ritual. Another one, it's funny, there was a rumor that they sacrificed a white horse. Then there were pictures that emerged of a facial circumcision basically performed on a newborn slashing its cheeks to mark it as a táltos, this newborn boy. It even gets written about in the New York Times, Hungarian pagans slash open a baby's face. [1:20:28] It turns out, actually, that the baby's face was never cut open. It actually just had raspberry jam smeared on it, like a photo op. But this was the Turanian monotheist church. You know, and it was really like the high point of this era. It wound up, you know, refugees of you want to say that, you know, after Hungary's communist period went to other countries, sort of still did this kind of esoteric occult religion, and then later would bring it back after 1989 to Hungary and start their own, you know, handful of like cults and New Age movements today. [1:21:02] Yeah. No, and that's, you know, this is this intersection of nationalism, of these secret societies, of esoteric beliefs. It's really interesting. This is part of why the interwar years are so interesting. There were a lot of really bad people who did a lot of very strange things. You know, it was a great time for villains, a real rogues gallery. And, you know, Turanism, I think, is generally, like we said, less odious than a lot of forms of Hungarian nationalism, but not always. It had this fundamental sympathy for the peoples of the East, which meant it was basically orthogonal to the dominant white supremacy of really every other form of European nationalism at this time. However, you don't want to overemphasize that, especially because many Turanists, as we're about to see, had very supremacist beliefs of their own, often in different directions, not always against the same targets, but all stemming from the idea that Hungarians had a unique historic path that set them apart from others. [1:22:00] I think really. Yeah. Eventually. Yeah. Eventually, returning to the Arrow Cross, Ferenc Szálasi does become a supporter of Turanism and in his biggest delusions of grandeur, thought that if he was running Hungary, because Hungary is so well situated to be this mediator between the East and the West, he could wind up being even more powerful than Hitler. Which is just very absurd. And this just kind of goes to show like kind of the extreme eccentricity of post-interwar ideologies. [1:22:34] But, you know, so we're saying interwar. [1:22:36] We got to describe what happened in Europe to make the pre-war period become the interwar period. [1:22:42] Bigger than the trauma of 1848 getting crushed was the division of Hungary as a result of the Treaty of Trianon. [1:22:53] Yeah, no, it was, yeah, it was just this shocking moment for Hungarians where after the defeat of the Austro-Hungarian Empire in World War I, something which some Hungarian nationalists thought would make Hungary more powerful as they were freed from their German Habsburg yoke instead resulted in a full 72% of Hungarian territory being chopped off, creating from whole cloth the modern day nations of Croatia, Slovakia, and giving the wealthy and very populous Transylvanian territories to Romania, who have held Transylvania up until the present. [1:23:34] Yeah. Exactly. This also means where we do a land acknowledgement for the territories lost to Trianon. [1:23:40] Yeah, basically, yeah. Because like, you know, whether or not you have any sympathy to Hungarians controlling non-Hungarian speaking territory, you know, because most of these territories were populated by ethnic minorities, it was still clearly this very traumatizing national event, especially because many of the peoples in these new countries were ethnic Hungarians. [1:24:01] Yeah. There were significant amounts of refugees who wound up in Hungary. It made it very difficult to deal with. You know, it made the post-war period of Hungary even more traumatic. And it also crucially transformed Hungary from being one of the most ethnically diverse countries in Europe to one of the singularly most ethnically homogenous countries. [1:24:26] Yes. And God, that is really, that's really where I think things start to go wrong for Hungary, I would say. That really might be it. And you know, to add insult to injury, the funniest thing about Trianon is that even though, you know, it was meant to, it was basically a response to Austrian aggression, essentially, despite that, a tiny sliver of Western Hungary was in fact given from Hungary to Austria, their former overlords. My tears are shaped like the Burgenland. [1:24:53] Yeah, no, that's it, man. And so, and look, so I think that, look, this, the trauma of Trianon, justified or not, however, you feel about, you know, the right of Hungary to have, to obtain Transylvania, whatever, regardless of your feelings on that, this was such a traumatizing event for Hungarians that it pushed them even harder in the whole we're not actually European direction. They felt so betrayed by the West, by the Treaty of Versailles, that they were increasingly interested in their Eastern origin, basically. [1:25:27] And so there's all these interesting figures that we can mention. One of these guys, right after World War I, who I think died in the immediate chaotic aftermath of the Treaty of Trianon, was Árpád Zempléni, this romantic nationalist poet who really saw Turanism as a rejection against European-ness at all. He said, I shall write against the malice and unrighteousness of the Aryans, that meeting Europeans. It hurts me that the peoples of Europe still regard us as a horde of intruding Mongol newcomers and the devil knows what else. The name Mongol does not hurt, but the slander against us does, as if they want to launch an extermination campaign following this campaign of words. They are also squeezing our Eastern racial kin in every way. They are persecuting and exterminating them. And when he says our Eastern kin, he means people in India, in Vietnam, Indonesia, victims of European colonialism in Asia. [1:26:27] Yeah, exactly. It's both sympathetic to colonialism, you know, other countries that might be getting chopped up and viewed as Eastern by the West, but also is one that oftentimes, not all of the Turanists, but a good many of them, saw Hungary as uniquely positioned to lead a liberated Asian world. [1:26:49] Which maybe that's all, you know, still ultimately colonial, just with a little more paprika on it. [1:26:55] Right, yeah, there were like different orientations on this question within the Turanist movement. Some of them had a very benevolent idea where it was like, our job is to help to uplift our brother Asians, where others were like, oh no, Hungary is explicitly going to become the leader of Asia. So we're going to have a so we're going to have a greater Turanian co-prosperity sphere, for lack of a better word. [1:27:20] And then there's just Turanism took so many directions because, you know, if it's based on an interest in the East, the East can mean anything you want it to be. It can be anti-Christian or it can be pro-Christian. The Turanist Fridius Rydo, I'm sure I'm saying that, I'm sorry, I'm pronouncing that terribly. He said that Christ, Buddha, and Confucius were all equally Asian thoughts that should be embraced by the Turanists, even though, you know, Confucianism and Christianity have really no historical interchange at all. They're so different in their origin. But to him, they're both Asian. [1:27:56] Yeah. [1:27:56] Uh-huh. You know, and a big, an important geopolitical rise, especially as you get closer to World War II, is this question of Japan. Japan was viewed as a model of people who retained their Asian roots, but were able to become extremely imperial. A lot of Hungarians during this time would have had strong opinions about the Japanese rule of Manchukuo, which is just wild, but you can find this all over Hungarian media at the time, supporting Japanese Manchuria and organizations like the Hungarian Nippon Society. [1:28:30] Yeah, and a bit closer to home, a lot of during the war, a lot of the more fascist-minded Turanians were fantasizing this idea of like carving out a Turanian Lebensraum out of the Soviet Union to create this sort of federation of different Altaic, Hungarian, whatever you want to call it, states that would, of course, be led by Big Brother Hungary. [1:28:58] Yeah, very Gunther-like kind of maps being coming to my mind. [1:29:02] Yeah, 100%. [1:29:04] Right, because you mentioned that, you know, there is this almost, there's this almost complete kind of network of Turkic or Hungarian speaking groups from, you know, Central Asia all across Russia to Hungary. And we mentioned the groups like the Bashkirs and the Tatars in our previous episode. Even though linguists no longer believe there's a genuine linguistic common origin there, at this time, it was understood that the Tatars of Crimea and Kazan were the natural brothers of the Hungarians. [1:29:34] Yeah. In fact, modern genetic studies of the very early conquering Magyars see ultimately usually the most affinity with modern-day Bashkiria, lending us to believe that maybe Julian did find Hungarian speakers there. And although they weren't totally eradicated, they might have become Turkified after the Mongols. [1:29:53] Right, because that's something you see time and time again in Central Asia: that a new conquering group comes in, often just probably a small group of people, but they manage to impose their language on the population. But in the process, their language kind of changes in response to this, you know, this quick, rap, this rapid language acquisition, which is why you begin to see this kind of linguistic convergence of so many languages. Because when you get Turkic speakers learning to speak Hungarian very quickly, or Hungarian speakers learning to speak Turkic very quickly, that the grammars are going to start to mix together. [1:30:29] Yeah. Exactly. And then, you know, you have modern Hungarian, which has plenty of German and Slavic loanwords, you know, just as much at this point, you know, as anything else, but put into a Hungarian vocabulary. [1:30:41] So we should mention that it's, I think it's most likely that, you know, when the first Hungarians came into the Pannonian Basin, most of the people living there, who would be the bulk of the ancestors of modern Hungarians, probably spoke Slavic languages. And then you had all of these German migrants in the high Middle Ages. We mentioned in our Transylvania episode, where, you know, most of the townspeople in Transylvania, which is very far from Germany, were ethnic Germans who traveled all the way from, I believe, the Luxembourg region in westernmost. [1:31:12] They were called Saxons, but they were not Saxon. [1:31:14] Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. They were mistakenly called Saxons. They traveled through Western Germany all the way to Eastern Hungary and what's now Romania. It's really interesting. [1:31:22] Yeah. You know, so many of these characters, the László Almásy, who was the star, you know, the main character in The English Patient, who, you know, in real life was likely a gay Iron Cross recipient pilot. He was the son of a major Turanist explorer and himself actually says he found a lost tribe of Hungarians in Sudan, which I've heard about this. And I know there's like some question if it's real or not, if there ever actually was a Hungarian population relocated by the Ottomans. What do you think? [1:32:01] I at first didn't think that it was true. I made a TikTok video about it asking if it was true because I saw mostly English and mostly Hungarian sources that all seem to repeat the same stuff of those, you know, several different trips where Hungarians have gone, you know, and said that, but it was a lot of copy and paste. And following a lot of these Turanist-like charlatans, I try to take a lot of that with a grain of salt. However, I'll say I made this video and, you know, on TikTok and it did fairly well. And I said in it, if you're Sudanese or Egyptian and you know anything about this, please can you let me know in the comments? And at the very least, I've had quite a few Sudanese people say, my mom is Magyarab or my uncle knows this Magyarab guy. [1:32:44] That's awesome. [1:32:45] That really changed my opinion about it. I need to do follow-ups and probably interview someone at some point. [1:32:50] That's great. [1:32:51] That changed my opinion about it. I think there's at least some connection. [1:32:55] Right. But yeah, all these other guys. Onwards to African Turan. [1:33:01] And that's what I think is kind of the most interesting thing about this whole kind of Turanist experiment. Just like that kind of connection there with Sudan, there is this grain of truth to Turanism, which is that even in the pre-modern era, travel and contact between very far-flung cultures was common and, in a sense, constant. The migration of the Hungarian speakers from Siberia to Central Asia to Hungary is really remarkable. Just as the travel of that knife salesman that Vámbéry mentions, you know, from Xinjiang to Calcutta to Mecca to Constantinople is incredible. And that's why I think that, you know, the most positive aspects of Turanism are the kind of all men are brothers implications of many Turanists. That despite distinctions of religion, culture, skin color, there is much that we can learn from these different far-flung peoples about ourselves, about our past, and of course, about our future. [1:34:01] And, you know, speaking of brothers, I will say the fourth ever World Boy Scout Jamboree took place in Hungary, and its emblems were Hunor and Magor and the White Stag. Because one of the biggest countries to adopt the world scouting movement was Hungary under Pál Teleki, who wound up running the Turanian Society. He was an avid Turanist, an avid supporter, avid supporter of the Boy Scouts, spread it to Hungary and other countries. The fourth Jamboree was actually held in Horthy's Palace, who himself had a very much love-hate relationship with Turan. You know, he didn't want to, he didn't want to alienate Catholic normal Christians, you know, in the country by being too Turanian. But he had a train car named Turan and definitely entertained that discourse a good bit. [1:34:52] It's great that you bring up Horthy, because I think that, you know, we've talked about the kind of the nice cuddly side of Turanism, the all men are brothers version. But we should mention that in the interwar context, in this nationalist context, Turanism typically took a less universalist approach. It was not all men are brothers. It was some men are brothers, which is often very dangerous. And that's why I'd love to kind of ask you if you could describe briefly the relationship that Turanism had in the interwar era with the extreme right, which was incredibly prominent in Hungary after Trianon. [1:35:33] Yeah. Yeah, because, you know, as we can see, like it, you know, many of the very early Turanists were either of Jewish descent or were liberals, you know, by all senses in Hungarian society. Not just Vámbéry, but also Gyula Germanus, Ignác Goldziher, you know, people who wound up kind of distancing themselves ultimately from Turanism as it became more anti-Semitic. But we also have major figures in the Hungarian women's liberation movement. Two of the biggest female Turanists, Jonji Bekashi, who ultimately started the belief that Hungarians were from Atlantis, and Ida Bobula, who wound up moving to South Carolina. She became an Atlantic writer, was still basically a liberal feminist throughout her life, but also strongly believed Hungarian was Sumerian and was one of the biggest writers and ultimately like really alienated herself after leaving Hungary to do so. But you have ultimately many major anti-Semitic politicians who start leading the, including Pál Teleki, who is sometimes considered this character who tried to keep Hungary out of World War II. [1:36:43] He said he stopped the German invasion of Poland, even if it meant blowing up Hungarian railways. He wound up accepting a huge portion of Polish refugees. He was early on in his career philo-Semitic, but became very anti-Semitic, passed many of the first anti-Semitic laws post-World War I. And there's a really great anecdote about Laszlo Turmeze, who his birth name was Mihalovic. He was a Slavic, like many Hungarians, totally Hungarian, but with a Slavic last name. And at a point, I believe it wasn't under Teleki, it was Czalnucki, he changes his name from Mihalovic to Turmeze. And he's writing a letter and he's like, now I want to be clear, this organization is so discriminatory against people who have Slavic last names when I am every bit as pure Hungarian as the rest of you. In fact, I've gone to the Budapest Anthropological Society and they measured my skull. [1:37:47] We got news for you. I'm pure Hungarian, man. So now I've changed my last name. I want to let you know to stop discriminating against people with Slavic last names and please get the organization back to what we've been wanting you to do the whole time: banned Jews and Freemasons. [1:38:03] Yeah, and that's when you get to the really nasty manifestations of Turanism. Especially, I think, the idea of Turanism as an anti-communist and anti-Semitic movement. These two ideas went together in the minds of many interwar European nationalists in ways I think Americans don't really recognize all the time. It didn't help that in Hungary, there was a failed communist revolution we discussed way back when that was led by a guy who happened to be, unfortunately, of Jewish descent, Béla Kun, who was widely hated by Hungarian reactionaries and supplanted by that dictator, Miklos Horthy, the guy with the train called the Turan. [1:38:45] Yeah, exactly. You know, and we're at a very interesting place because Turanism spawned many of these movements. I love the TikTok videos that I make because it turns me into a lightning rod for the most insane Hungarians on the internet. And, you know, I get this all the time. And a couple really funny ones that I've gotten are people who they believe in ideologies that are branched out of Turanism, though the less scientific, more esoteric Turanism that talks about Hungarians having always been in the Carpathian basin and using it as sort of like an ethnic kind of revanchist thing. But I've had people telling me Turanism actually, it's been a Jewish plot the entire time to make us think we even came from somewhere else and haven't always been here. See Ármin Vámbéry, the Jewish father of Turanism. So it's kind of come full circle to now, you know, and granted, you've still got very far-right anti-Semites. [1:39:45] You know, it's such a heterogeneous movement of people who are often saying the same thing. But that's a very interesting kind of fringe of this belief as well. [1:39:56] And that brings us to this last section here. All thanks to Russian Sam, the research that you've done kind of about the historical relationship between Jewish-Hungarians and Turanism. It's a very complicated and oftentimes contradictory relationship, as the Turanist movement included many professed anti-Semites, as well as many Jewish people, like Vámbéry. And I think that an important thing to note here, just on the surface, is that a fundamental thing about Turanism, which, as you mentioned, was the object of ire by those guys, by Steit Group, was the fact that it talks about this foreign origin of Hungarians as wanderers from the East. And this idea of wanderers from the East from outside of Europe felt familiar to many Jewish people. And as we mentioned, the historical experience of Hungarians was probably described in terms lifted from the book of Exodus. [1:40:52] Right. So let's get into the specifically Jewish component of this story. A very important thing to understand about the Austro-Hungarian Jews is that there were a lot of them, and they continued to grow both in absolute and relative numbers all through the 19th century. Albert Lindemann in his book Esau's Tears brings this into perspective. Jews would grow from being 1% of the population at the turn of the 19th century to over 4% at the turn of the 20th. In 1910, there were 911,000 Jews in Hungary out of a population of 21 million. So while the overall population of Hungary grew by 125% between 1787 and 1910, Jews had grown by over 1,000%. [1:41:36] This was the result of both immigration and natural population growth. So the revolutionaries of 1848, they passed a legislation for the legal emancipation of the Jews, but this would be very short-lived. It literally lasted only two weeks, as it was rolled back by the Russian intervention. So it wouldn't, in fact, be until 1867 that the Jews of Austro-Hungary were emancipated for good. [1:41:59] Right, I forgot to mention that, you know, the Russian Tsardom was basically the most essential anti-Semitic state of Hitler. [1:42:06] Right. [1:42:06] It also is important or interesting to point out. I believe the three biggest synagogues in Europe are all either in Hungary or former Hungarian territory, in Budapest, Szeged, and Subotica in Serbia. [1:42:19] Right. So József Eötvös, who was the education minister in 1848, we mentioned him earlier in the episode. And then again, from 1869 to 71. [1:42:28] As a patron of Vámbéry. [1:42:30] Yeah, exactly. He had been an early proponent of Jewish emancipation, and the Hungarian liberal reformers had a very strong pro-Jewish orientation on the whole. This was the result of both of their liberal ideals as well as practical exigencies. Now, the peasant anti-Semitism, which would more accurately be called anti-Judaism at this point, was a very strong force among peoples like the Slovaks and Romanians, and to a lesser extent, the Germans. The Hungarians did not tend to be nearly as anti-Semitic, according to the recollections of Vámbéry and others of his generations. Quoting once again from his story of my struggles, quote, the real Magyars, the ruling element of the country, more chivalrously inclined and of marked indifference to religious affairs, had always shown themselves kinder and more tolerant to Jews. But all the more disgraceful was the behavior of the Slavs. And in spite of my reputation as a good scholar, I was often exposed to the wanton behavior of passing Christians in the street of St. [1:43:24] Georgen, had stones thrown at me and was greeted with the insulting sheremache, hep, hep, hep, and other such similar titles. [1:43:50] Frankly, peasant superstitions about other religions. [1:43:53] Right. And as such, Jews began to undergo a Magyarization process and had very strong sympathies for the revolution under the logic of the enemy of my enemy is my friend. And many in the Hungarian intelligentsia felt likewise. And another dynamic to understand of the Hungary of this period is that Hungarians were becoming relatively smaller part of the population all through the 19th century. By World War I, they were only half of the population of Hungary. And many viewed the rapidly Magyarizing Jews as a way to shore up the Hungarian population, especially on the fringes of the empire, like Vámbéry's native Slovakia. So Jewish intellectuals from the 1840s onwards began to write about how benign Hungarian rule had been to their community, especially when compared to other European kingdoms. Now, figures like Rabbi Lipót Löw had emphasized that the kings of Hungary were always well disposed to the Jews. [1:44:51] While in the 1850s, when the ethos changed, Rabbi Ede Horn, who would later serve as the Secretary of State in 1875, argued that the Hungarian people as a whole were friends of the Jews. Miklós Konrád, in his paper, Narrating the Hungarian Jewish National Past, the Khazar Theory and the Integrationist Jewish Scientific Discourse, traces the history of Hungarian Jewish thinking on this question. One particularly fascinating strain of thought was that, quote, both Hungarians and Jews had been chosen by God to achieve a specific historic mission, the spread of pure monotheism in the case of the Jews and the spread of freedom in the case of Hungarians. And eventually, as Turanist thought became a major part of the intellectual milieu, some Jewish thinkers took the shared history of Hungarians and Jews a step further. What if, rather than being two distinct peoples with a shared destiny, the Hungarians and the Jews were in fact direct relatives? [1:45:48] This move meant that the Hungarian Jews were actually rooted in the Hungarian land rather than being Jews who had become Hungarian by historical accident. [1:45:57] Right. Okay, and so, you know, we mentioned in our previous episode and a little bit here that there was once this great steppe empire, Turkic speaking, not Hungarian speaking, known as the Khazars, who had some kind of relationship to the early Hungarians. They were either the overlords or the allies of the Hungarians. The most interesting thing about the Khazars, besides their Hungarian relationship, is the fact that they were to some extent Jewish. This is a very hotly debated topic. Historians have gone back and forth for over a century now, but it seems pretty conclusive that the Khazar elite in the early Middle Ages converted to Judaism as a way to have these intermediate relations with Muslims to the East and Christians to the West. Basically, unprecedented in the medieval record, there is no other case of any kind of kingdom adopting Judaism. And the fact that the Khazars so quickly disappeared led to a lot of speculation about what could have happened to the Khazars. [1:47:01] They were kind of this 13th lost tribe of Israel, in a sense. [1:47:05] Right. So in 1884, Rabbi Samuel Kohn published his History of the Jews in Hungary, where he devoted several chapters to the Khazar theory of Ashkenazi Jewish origin. Now, according to this theory, the Jews of Eastern Europe were in fact the descendants of the Khazars. And when the Hungarians passed through the area, a group of the Khazars referred to as the Khabars in the Hungarian Chronicles threw in their lot with the newcomers, revolted against their overlords, and settled in Pannonia with the Hungarian people. So according to the thought of the time, the Khazars and the Hungarians already would have had common origins all the way back in the East, back in Turan. But the Khazars got a head start in moving westward. And then these two branches of Turan peoples were reunited and fused their destiny in this way in the 9th century. So with this shared pedigree, Konrád writes, quote, on the one hand, Kohn's Khazar theory aimed at establishing a thousand-year continuity of the Jewish presence in Hungary. [1:48:03] On the other hand, its aim was to prove that the Jewish presence in Hungary had its origin in people who were not Jews by their ethnic background, their race, but only by their religious faith. Accordingly, their descendants, i.e. at least part of the Jewish population of 19th century Hungary, could not be defined by ethnic or racial criteria. [1:48:20] And I think also there's kind of, there's this, there's this great tragedy of Khazar scholarship here, which was the fact that the idea that modern Jewish people in Europe, people are descended from Khazars. First off, it's not believed to be true anymore. Nobody really, there's really no credible evidence to suggest this in the era of genetic testing. It's pretty obvious that Jewish people have their origins in the ancient Israelite peoples of the Near East. That's basically undisputable at this point. But what's interesting is that in the 19th century, this idea was initially mostly supported by Jewish thinkers supporting some kind of assimilationist theories in Europe. But then by the 20th century, in modern times, the Khazar theory is basically entirely the purview of anti-Semites these days. I feel like when you Google the word Khazar these days, what mostly is going to come up is black Hebrew-Israelite stuff. [1:49:13] Because those guys really love describing Ashkenazi Jewish people as Khazars because they believe themselves to be the real Jews. [1:49:20] Another group that you could compare to Turanists, you know? [1:49:24] Yeah, you totally can, yeah. Another kind of strange, yeah, nationalist sort of group. So that's like there's this kind of tragedy. I think that, you know, the Khazars are such an interesting historical people. And even if they're not ancestral to Ashkenazi Jews, they're incredibly interesting. And I think it's this real tragedy that this remarkable history has been appropriated by people with such odious beliefs. [1:49:45] Right. So the centrality of Jews to Hungarian history was championed by these intellectuals in this way. So some Jewish thinkers credited the Jews with their know-how. And some of these intellectuals went so far as crediting the Jews with the know-how that allowed their Hungarian cousins to develop a state. And others took it even a step further to credit the Khazarian Jews for the Christianization of the Magyars by introducing them to the Abrahamic faith in the first place. [1:50:16] Yeah, and I know this one, that theory is not really without merit because some historians have described a process called monotheization, in that the quick introduction of Christian, Jewish, and Muslim ideas to Central Asia and in the Western steppe at the same time probably led to a lot of Turkic-speaking peoples getting kind of confused, mixed ideas about a monotheistic God from three different directions. So I don't think it's that hard to believe that Jewish peoples traveling through Central Asia, of which we know there were quite a few in the early Middle Ages, might have had some contributions in the ideas of God that would become Hungarian Christianity. [1:50:56] Yeah. Although you'll have Turanists today saying that actually European Christianity is itself a Jewish conspiracy created by the rabbi Saul Paul, and that actually the native pagan faith of the Hungarians is true Christianity. Usually the implication that it's Nestorian Christianity. [1:51:14] Yeah. Or of course, and that overlaps a lot with Nazi anti-Christianity among some Nazis. Yeah. [1:51:22] These ideas of Khazar origins of the Jews were a cornerstone of Hungarian Jewish discourse all the way into the Holocaust. And Hungarians were much more concerned about Magyar demographic superiority on the whole. And because of this, the racial anti-Semitism that was gaining ground in Germany from the 1870s onwards and then later Europe writ large had very limited traction. In fact, its growth in Hungary was actively hampered by the fact that it was seen as a foreign ideology. [1:51:54] Right. And again, we should remember that, you know, after 1848, 1867, and 1919, there was this kind of distrust of all things German. [1:52:01] Yeah, exactly. So in 1883, there was an attempt to bring this into Hungary. The Count Istóczy founded the National Anti-Semitic Party, which won 13 seats in the diet and attempted to pass anti-Jewish legislation, but they failed to get anything done, and the party collapsed a few years later. Hungarian authorities looked down on such talk and they viewed it as destabilizing. A Hungarian Minister of Culture was very blunt about this, saying, Anti-Semitism serves only as a pretext to undermine the foundations of the social order. Riots began with Herzog or Itzig, that is characteristic Jewish names in Hungary, and lead to Prince Esterházy. [1:52:42] So, in other words, by stirring the pot, you're undermining the very foundations of Hungary, both the actual power relations as well as the Magyar demographic superiority over the other ethnicities. [1:52:59] Right. So, returning to the central figure of this episode, Vámbéry himself, he didn't really wade into the Khazar theory of Jewish origins, as far as I could tell, based on the available English language literature. But of course, I can't read Hungarian. So, Turan Explorer, if you have found anything to the contrary, please do let us know. [1:53:21] Yeah, he wrote about the Khazars and his history of Hungary, but I don't think that he ever makes as extensive a connection between the sort of Jewish nature of the Khazars, which he does mention, and a Hungarian development. It's not the same as these kinds of gestures that were being made in magazines like Egyenlőség, where a lot of these other rabbis have been written. I will say, though, it is important, especially if we're talking about Ármin Vámbéry and his relationship with his Jewish identity and his relationship with other movements. Not only was he a pivotal figure in early Turanism, and also Baha'i, which is a whole other thing, but he was also played a role, a small role, but an interesting one in early Zionism. He knew and was greatly admired by fellow Hungarian Tivadar Herzl or Theodore Herzl, who asked Vámbéry to arrange a meeting with the sultan of the Ottoman Empire to basically get a deal and found Israel. [1:54:27] And Vámbéry raises this money and gives it to this group that can make this connection. This is much, much later in his life. But they basically take his money and run. So I think that that's all he ever does. When he speaks publicly, there's a moment where there's a huge Jewish exodus out of Russia because of the spate of pogroms, I think in like 1906 or 1907. Yes, and he writes and he writes in actually, I think the New York Times, he says ultimately it's inadvisable for them to go to Palestine because it would just be, you know, it would irritate. So, you know, he was never an outspoken Zionist, but he was, you know, making moves behind the scene to lead to things. I think ultimately, Vámbéry just liked to be associated with successful political movements. And had he lived a few decades longer, you know, he might have been, you know, Herzl says, you know, you've written so many great things. [1:55:29] You know, you've gone on all these travels. May the last chapter of your book be, and how I created a homeland for the Jewish people. And, you know, chances are, had he actually lived to that point, he probably would have promoted himself in such a way. [1:55:43] Although I know that Herzl also complained that this man doesn't know if he is a Jew, an Englishman, or a Turkish. [1:55:52] Yeah, I feel like, you know, I think that as far as politics, he was very pro-British because just because he liked the British from because of reasons of personal affinity, he also just kind of had this idea of this very kind of like, you know, why can't we all just get along, man? Kind of attitude. Yeah. Yeah. [1:56:07] And we don't really touch on this, but like being anti-Russia was like the major plank of his politics all throughout his career to the point where he has like all these sort of Moscow Mitch moments where he's like calling his detractors like Russian agents and whatnot. He was just very alarmist about the advance of Russia in Central Asia and what he viewed as this barbaric state that hasn't been touched by the Enlightenment in the same way as Britain would be coming in and hampering the development of all these peoples in Central Asia with whom he had such a deep affinity. So he was just constantly writing in the British journals of the time, raising the alarm about the ongoing Russian conquest in the region. And nobody really paid him much attention. In fact, for a very long time, he was dismissed as a crank. Like, oh, this isn't really happening. [1:57:02] But then when Samarkand and Bukhara and Khiva, they fall to the Russians, suddenly this guy comes out seeming like a prophet of sorts. [1:57:10] And crucially, the Russians are the ones who crushed 1848, which was one of the most radicalizing moments in his life. In fact, he says when he returns to Tehran, he speaks to the Russian embassy, who are really interested in what he has to say. They want to kind of like recruit him sort of as an asset. And I think that he, you know, something like he openly tells them, yes, well, how do you feel about me hating Russia, having just political vendetta against Russia? And they're like, no, don't do that. In fact, his writings wound up very popular in Kazakhstan. And it was heavily censored by the Russians during that time period. So they did not like him. [1:57:50] Yes. [1:57:50] All right. Well, we are, yeah, yeah. I think we're just about wrapping this up. You know, it's been a while, but this has been such a great discussion. I really just have kind of one big question. It's a big one. I was warning you. That I kind of want to end with. [1:58:03] So we talked so much about the ways, the close relationship with Jewish Hungarians in this kind of Turanist project and really in Hungarian nationalism more broadly, all the way back to 1848, perhaps earlier. And that it seems like it seems like in the 19th century, relationships between Jewish Hungarians and Christian Hungarians were really some of the warmest in Europe, more so than in Germany, which was generally more economically developed, and certainly more so than Russia to the east, where these kind of peasant superstitions reigned supreme. And where Vámbéry's hated Tsar was, you know, persecuting Jewish people in ways that were shocking even to the vaguely anti-Semitic Christians of Western Europe. It was just considered this real crisis. And from where tons of Jews were immigrating into Hungary. Really, my question for you, which might be outside your above your pay grade, but basically, how did Hungary and the Hungarian National Project transformed from one that was probably the most philosemitic in Europe, one of the only nationalist projects that included a huge number of Jewish people in contrast to, say, German or Polish nationalism. [1:59:16] How do we get from that situation to basically the current situation of Hungarian politics, in which Hungary is probably the only country in Europe today where political anti-Semitism remains a strong force? [1:59:32] Yeah, one of them for sure. [1:59:34] Yeah, I don't want to let, like, you know, Poland off the hook here too much, or Russia, or Ukraine. But right. [1:59:41] Well, to ask Viktor Orban, you know, someone, and there are a million ways to answer this question. I feel like you could build a case for a number of different. This is a series of books, this whole question, you know, to answer. [1:59:51] Yeah. Uh-huh. [1:59:53] Viktor Orban was once asked about Hungarian anti-Semitism. And of course, you know, he first dismisses that because Hungary is a huge ally of Israel. There was talk, you know, last year that Netanyahu might flee to Hungary because Netanyahu and Orban are just very close personal friends. But Orban sort of gives this recounting of Hungarian history. In the kingdom of Hungary, Hungarians, Magyars, ethnic Magyars, were under 50%. And they entered a strategic alliance with Jews to put them over 50%. And this worked extremely well for the country until one man, Béla Kun, the leader of the Hungarian, you know, the second successful, just for a brief time, communist revolution in history, Béla Kun, who himself was born Bela Cohen, but he Magyarized his name himself to Kun, which translates to Kuhn in Hungarian. [2:00:54] Humorous. [2:00:55] Yeah, but this kind of shows his kind of furnace link, even in the communist movement. [2:00:59] Right. [2:01:03] So, you know, ultimately, like, you know, that is at least looking at it from an Orbanist perspective, why Hungary became anti-Semitic, trying to find an excuse for that. But you could also say, you know, Hungary transformed from a Christian state that spoke Latin, that, you know, interestingly, like Christianity was the unifying force of the state, but somehow that also created this climate where Jews could thrive too, to a super ethnic state. And ironically, that made the Hungarian ethnicity become so much more exclusionary over time, even as it was seeking to pull in Japanese people, Turks, all of them. So like, you know, so Orban sees it as that, you know, Hungarians relied upon the Jewish people and then they stabbed Hungary in the back. You know, it's this classic anti-Semitic canard. But I think, if anything, it's more that it's kind of more like, you know, it's the opposite. [2:01:55] It's that they relied on Jewish people, but then once they lost their Slovak and Romanian minorities, they no longer relied on Jewish people. So Hungarians stabbed the Jews in the back. The Jewish people were now the most visible minority, not the Slovaks. [2:02:10] Yeah, exactly. Yeah. [2:02:13] And then, you know, now that so much of Hungary's population isn't there anymore, you know, it's a lot of Roma, although interestingly, you know, there's a big Fidesz contingent of Roma because much like Horthy, you know, Orban sort of sits in the middle of good Western Christian conservatism and the freaky Turanist stuff. But the parties further to the right of Orban are much, are even more anti-Semitic, even more anti-Ziganist. You know, so a lot of people see Orban as just kind of like the straight and narrow that, you know, it's racist, but it's not as like, you know, Fidesz aren't doing the same kind of paramilitary demonstrations in Romani communities that some of the further right are. In fact, ironically, one of the first female members of European parliament who is Romani is a Fidesz politician. [2:03:04] Oh, wow. [2:03:04] Because the other, the even more extreme conservatives are even worse. [2:03:08] Yeah. [2:03:08] Exactly. [2:03:08] So here's kind of one last question. And again, this also can be a full up sort of book. But what how much Turanism is alive today in Hungary? You've been to Hungary. You speak Hungarian. Is the, I know that your family had people who had a strong influence of Hungarian beliefs. Is the idea that the true soul of Hungary is not along the Danube, it is in fact, you know, far east in Turan. What kind of everyday influence does this have on Hungarian thought and Hungarian politics? Is this entirely the purview of the extreme right? Or do regular, non-crazy, non-evil people believe these kinds of ideas today too? [2:03:50] Yeah, it's transformed into so many things, things that don't view itself as Turanism. But if you look at the history of some of the people who broke away, you know, are totally part of that intellectual legacy. And it is mostly the far right. You know, though I will say there are various different artistic movements, like, for example, Hungarofuturism, you know, which sort of sees Afro-futurism as an artistic model, who tried to sort of reclaim a lot of these Turanist symbols. [2:04:20] It truly is Hungarian Wakanda. [2:04:23] Yeah, exactly. Exactly. Although it's transformed into so many different things, I will say the most zealous people are the followers of Ferenc Badiny Jós. Who actually, I believe, you know, I point out that he's anti-Semitic because he writes virulently anti-Semitic stuff. And his defenders will always be in my comments pointing out that he is that he was half Jewish. And, you know, which I believe is true. But he, you know, basically, you know, propagated the idea that European Christianity is a Jewish conspiracy. And these are definitely the people who are, I'd say, the most zealous, but there are also other New Age movements, táltos organizations, you know, most of which are just like old ladies, not always like guys, you know, marching with tiki torches. [2:05:11] Yeah, it's New Age-ers finding a new post-Soviet neopaganism, not Nazi neopaganism. So there are like progressive Turanists today. It's not just an ultra-nationalist thing. [2:05:24] Progressive is even still kind of a stretch. But there are people, you know, here's the thing: most Hungarians don't know anything about this. I will say most Hungarians my age, because in the communist period, many of these Turanists fled Hungary. A lot of them went to Argentina, like Ferenc Badiny Jós. There was a huge organization or, you know, a milieu of Hungarians in Argentina who thought they were Sumerian, you know, and would like form these kinds of like social clubs and things. But the vast majority of Hungarians, you know, if you look at a map of whether you have more European affinity, national affinity, or regional affinity, I believe Budapest is the only, you know, when these kinds of surveys are done, the only like district that it's mostly European because there is such an urban reaction against the Hungarian right that it's so famous for further to the right as well. [2:06:21] Yeah, but most Hungarians don't know much about this, or if they know about it, it's just kind of an obscure thing. It was reintroduced in these ways in 1989, but it's a lot of older people. I will say there is a huge event and watch this space because I'm going to be going to it. And I'm trying to make as much content as possible. They have created founders of Jobbik, in fact, the ultra-right organization, created this Great Kurultáj where they invite delegations from all around the world. They're South Koreans, Japanese, Kazakhs, Kyrgyz, all of these various people, you know, from Turkey, of course, Turkish Ciprihat, who come and they do horseback, bow and arrow stuff. It's this huge event that is basically half an international Turanist gathering, half a Renaissance fair. It has shifted over the years and started to entertain more like legitimate scientific and anthropological stuff, but it very much has this roots in this, you know, political revival of Turanism. [2:07:21] So I'm very interested to take it all in. I've never been, but I'm going to go. [2:07:24] Stay safe. You might have to bring some, you know, cyanide capsules just in case. [2:07:30] Exactly. [2:07:31] All right. Thank you, Turan Explorer. This has been so great. You know, I just wish there was like another podcast or a TikTok channel where I could learn more about this subject. [2:07:42] Yeah. Well, I've heard of one called Turan Explorer, a TikTok channel and a podcast. And I'm on Twitter as well, you know, covering all of this, using it as kind of a springboard to look at other topics because it is both, you know, ethnic chauvinism, but also a kind of twisted embrace of multiculturalism. And it goes everywhere. And it's a brand springboard. And that's it. [2:08:06] It was this mass movement with like puck, you know, everyday support. And I believe we didn't get a chance to mention this, but you said that there were in the interwar years, there were so many people trying to register the name Turan in their business that the patent office had to put a stop to that. [2:08:20] Exactly. Yeah. [2:08:22] There was this, it was a strange period where everyday Hungarians really believed they were Mongolian steppe nomads due to the historical accident of their language, which is just so interesting. And that's, you know, we could go forever. I think that Hungary is a country that Americans tend to not think very much about at all. But I think it is just such an interesting little window into so many different types of movements and ideologies across the 19th and 20th centuries in ways I just think are so interesting. I think even if you have no interest in ever visiting Hungary, Hungarian history is really unique in some ways in Europe, while at the same time, giving you the window into so many trends that are common not throughout Europe, but really all throughout the world. The development of nationalism and communism. All this stuff is just so, so interesting. [2:09:13] And so I got to say, man, thank you so much for giving so much of your time and expertise. We've got like, what, three hours now of Turan content at least? [2:09:21] Yeah. Whole more steppe we could explore, I'm sure. [2:09:24] Oh, absolutely. No, because the thing, dude, the steppe is endless. You know, the grasslands of Turan go forever. And under every blade, you'll find something new. It's just such an incredible topic. [2:09:36] Very gladio-coded. [2:09:38] Oh, yeah. All right. Well, any closing words, either, you guys, because this is great. [2:09:44] Viszontlátásra. I'll see you again. [2:09:46] All right. All the links are going to be in the show description. So if you guys are going to check out Turan Explorer's in his own platforms, and I highly recommend you do, you know where to look.