Gladio Free Europe, E103: History of the Zombie https://www.gladiofreeeurope.com/episodes/history-of-the-zombie [0:00:14] Hello and welcome to Gladio Free Europe. I am here with my terrifying co-host Russian Sam. [0:00:21] Hello, hello. [0:00:23] We are back now with our fourth Halloween episode, bringing our listeners once again through the history of one of the most popular horror creatures of all time. We've previously described the golem, vampires, the history of Transylvania, even dragons. Now, we are of course going to walk through the really remarkable history of the zombie and what our interest in that creature might say about Americans more broadly. But while I was planning this episode, I thought that it might be fun to whip up one of the most iconic cocktails of all time. Because of course, the zombie means something much different to a bartender than it does to a horror aficionado. The Drink the Zombie debuted at the famous Don the Beachcomber Tiki Bar in 1934. But when I looked up a recipe, I realized that unfortunately, this one drink was a little bit outside my budget and far outside my mixological capacities. [0:01:24] Because to make a zombie, you need three types of rum, a dash of lime juice, some grapefruit juice, cinnamon syrup, grenadine, a little bit of bitters, and two obscure foreign liqueurs, falernum from Barbados and Pernod from France. Just assembling all of that would be really difficult and does require a pretty sophisticated bartender. And I think that a drink this complicated, with such disparate ingredients sourced from so many places, really has to have something going for it to get the widespread acceptance that it had. And I think it's amazing, therefore, that the zombie is so ubiquitous. It's a wholly 20th-century invention, but it has antecedents stretching back much farther in alcoholic history. And despite being associated with the tiki craze of the 30s, 40s, and 50s, the zombie is deathless. You can still get one at any beach bar. If you can't tell where I'm going with this, the zombie cocktail is exactly like the zombie of contemporary fiction. [0:02:26] It is a creature that is very, very distinctly American and of our modern post-war American moment. However, all of the ingredients of the zombie reach so far back into many different past societies, coming together in something that could not exist in really any other place in time. And what's so unique about the zombie is that unlike any other fictional creature in the Western imagination, the zombie derives the bulk of its inspiration from a pretty unlikely source, the folk religion of Haiti, voodoo, which has been the object of fascination and revulsion by outsiders for more than 200 years. But at the same time, many aspects of the modern zombie have nothing to do with Haitian religion, instead having their roots in the European macabre, in ancient stories of ghosts and revenants, risen corpses coming back to complete their unfinished business. So in this way, the zombie is a nightmare blend of half a dozen different peoples mixed together in the cocktail shaker of the Americas. [0:03:29] But before we can go into the history of the zombie, we do have to remind our audience that we do have a Patreon. And while we might not be able to raise anybody from the dead and compel them to do our bidding, we can, hopefully, compel some of our listeners to give us a few dollars to keep this podcast going. All right, but with that out of the way, please, Russian Sam, take us away. [0:03:51] In light of the fact that Halloween was just around the corner, we've been talking a lot about spooky stuff and various creatures, and we haven't brought something really interesting to my attention lately, which is that modern horror really skewed our perceptions of mythological creatures. So where today people have a very clear delineation of what constitutes a dwarf versus an elf versus a ghost versus a vampire. Traditionally, this really wasn't the case at all. Words denoting such concepts, even when they are found in historic sources, often blur the lines considerably. [0:04:24] Right, right. All these contemporary categories are creations of modern romantic genre fiction. They don't necessarily reflect categories that existed in the past. And many times you have these overlapping concepts from various different mythological sources that survive in modern culture as very different kinds of ideas. And zombies are a perfect example. [0:04:45] Right, so we got into this a bit in episode 22, Shadow of the Vampire, which talks about the vampires and how in these regions of Eastern Europe whence the vampire springs, their antecedents were often interchangeable with creatures we would more closely associate with werewolves, witches, or even zombies. And so you guys probably know what a zombie is without me having to describe it in depth because the image is just so iconic within our Western culture. Just to give a quick definition, the zombie is a remnant. It's a corpse that's reanimated with its mental capacities being totally destroyed. Its movements are jolted, and in most cases, it has a hunger for the flesh of the living. And this is a later addition, but being a zombie is also transmissible through this pathway. So this exact combination of features is very modern, but it has many antecedents because for as long as people have existed, the finality of death did not sit well with us. [0:05:44] People from across cultures grappled with the idea and most came to the conclusion that the dead were not truly gone, and that if their spirits were disturbed sufficiently by some misdeed of the living or through some usually malevolent magic, they may return to the realm of the living as either a spirit or maybe even in their previous corporeal form. Stories of these physical returnees were widespread in the past across both Europe and the Middle East, as well as even very far beyond. [0:06:13] The earliest reference we know of to the undead is in fact the epic of Gilgamesh, which I didn't think we'd be referencing two episodes in a row. In Gilgamesh, the goddess Ishtar threatens to raise armies of the dead from the earth and sic them upon the living. [0:06:28] Now, if we travel a few thousand years and a few thousand miles away, pre-Christian Scandinavians believed in the draugr, corpses risen from their barrows due to some great vendetta, like making the first couple hours of Skyrim really unpleasant. We mentioned last year in our Transylvania series that early Balkan vampires looked a lot like modern zombies, as Sam alluded to. Lord Byron, who helped popularize the vampire in the story that was mostly written by John Polidori, was convinced that there was a link to Arab folktales about ghouls, which were flesh-eating, undead creatures who might be our clearest analog to the modern Hollywood idea of the zombie. Our friend and co-producer Abram, who played a big role in planning this episode, pointed out that there's no good reason why Frankenstein isn't considered a zombie too. Because if you think about it, he is, after all, a person brought to life after death, often depicted in some kind of state of visible decay. [0:07:24] And in the 1931 film adaptation by Universal, which was such a big hit, it really helped create the modern horror genre, the monster is entirely mindless and shambles around like a stiff corpse. The next year, Universal put out the mummy, which is about an undead creature which walks the same way, perpetuating a lot of these same tropes about the risen dead that we now see in zombies. [0:07:48] All right, but let's talk about the zombie proper, which can really be traced to the Caribbean and even further back to Western and Central Africa. At the height of the transatlantic slave trade, when tens of thousands of enslaved Africans were herded onto ships yearly, they did not come with just the clothes on their back. Before they became slaves, they had been people with their own distinct languages, cultures, and religious beliefs. And so, even as the slaver regime attempted to deracinate these peoples and to strip them of their humanity, and in turn to turn them into zombies of sort for labor, these guides would continue to inform who they were in the Americas. And so, they carried with them these ideas which would hold sway over their descendants even hundreds of years later. The word zombie itself probably has Bantu origins, specifically from the area stretching from Gabon to Angola, thereabouts. [0:08:38] And in these languages, one finds words like nzumbi, nvumbi, nzombi, and zumbi. For speakers of these languages, I apologize for my pronunciation. But like basically, the gist is that these words are linked to death. They mean things like corpse, a disembodied soul, or even a remnant. And there is an interesting connection here to something else we've talked about a fair bit. When Christian missionaries began preaching to the Kikongo speakers, they needed a word for God. Missionaries would often draw on the traditions of the locals to make inroads when preaching. We saw this in our Christianity in Japan episodes 74 and 75: that the Jesuits originally chose to render the Christian god to their Japanese flock as Dainichi, the great sun, one of the leading Buddhas of Japanese Buddhism. In the Congo, though, this god became Nzambi. [0:09:31] And communities of African slaves brought traditional religious concepts and deities from their homeland to the New World. So you start to see this kind of joining of influences from Africa and from Europe. Religious systems from different parts of Africa gained adherence from peoples whose ancestors may have never practiced them, as different distinct African cultures from different parts of the continent began to blend together after being forced into horrifically close proximity in the conditions of the slave ships and the plantations. Across the colonial period, the disparate religious traditions of West and Central Africa began to blend together into something new and more cohesive, shaped by the shared experience of slavery and blackness. In some cases, neighboring non-black peoples even took on some of these practices as well. As late as the 20th century, for instance, Louisiana Voodoo was adhered to by many white people in New Orleans. [0:10:23] And Santeria today is practiced by really the entire breadth of the Cuban population. You don't have to be black to go to a Santero. However, all of these religions are distinctly African-derived, although they do bring in some many distinct Christian elements as well. For the most part, people who practice Afro-Caribbean religions see themselves as Christian and believe that their African-derived beliefs are wholly compatible with Christianity, although sometimes Christian authorities disagree. In many specific cases, African deities are syncretized with Catholic saints. This is why Cuban Santeria, a really good analogue for Haitian and Louisiana voodoo, literally means the path of the saints, as its adherents interpret the Yoruba gods in their religion as Catholic saints, subordinate often to a figure analogous to the one Christian god. Among Haitian voodoo practitioners, the gods are known as the Loa, but they're always believed to be subordinate to Bon Dieu, which is in French good god, which they see as kind of their interpretation of the Christian god. [0:11:30] So moving forward into the early 19th century, we begin to see the word zombie first enter English language accounts in ways that have really nothing at all to do with the modern conception of a zombie creature. The first is in an 1819 history of Brazil that references a much older 17th century African slave rebel named Zumbi, who is spelled in by this English writer as Z-O-M-B-I. A lot of histories, you know, cultural histories of the zombie will say that this guy in Brazil somehow has a connection to the modern zombie creature. That's not true. It's really a coincidence. These are totally different concepts derived from the same source. [0:12:12] Right, because again, this word also means divinity. [0:12:16] Exactly, exactly. And following that, in 1826, we dug up a strange piece of short fiction published in a Washington, D.C. newspaper called the Generous Carib. And so, this strange short story is this kind of idealized romantic account of a young man in an unnamed Caribbean island of unclear ethnicity. We're not sure if he's black or Native American, but regardless, in this little story, he worships a pantheon of gods described as the zombies. It's really a weird story. [0:12:49] Yeah, so the generous Carib, you can look it up. And what's I think very revealing about this place and time and this attitude towards the kind of people who believed in these zombie deities is that this short story is immediately followed by a wanted poster for a runaway slave in the newspaper. [0:13:07] Yeah, that's not great. [0:13:09] So, yeah, while the broader concept of zombie is found across the African diaspora, the zombie, as we know today, is uniquely Haitian. It's derived from the religious tradition of voodoo or voodon. Voodoo is used to describe the syncretic African religions in Haiti, the Dominican Republic, Trinidad, and Louisiana, where in that last example, it was probably introduced by Haitians who were forcibly brought to New Orleans by French planters fleeing the revolution of Toussaint Louverture. And so, voodoo blended with older African-American religious traditions across the US, and communities of slaves practiced variations of voodoo, often called hoodoo, as far north as Missouri. And these names have all been traced back to the word vodun, meaning idol, which is the name of a religious system from the Atlantic coast of Togo and Benin. And so, Haitian voodoo, which is actually spelled V-O-D-O-U, was not suppressed to the same extent as other slave religions because of the fact that the Haitians freed themselves from slavery at the dawn of the 19th century. [0:14:14] So, while some Haitian Catholics see voodoo as heretical, and some upper-class Haitians have found it embarrassing, the religion has really survived any attempted repression and developed its own holy sites. It is full of pilgrimage paths, initiation rituals, and even an organized priesthood. And so, while voodoo is traditionally associated with the lower classes, many Haitians from all social strata have turned to the priests and priestesses, often called houngans and mambos, for advice or faith healing in times of need. And what's most important about these holy people, according to practitioners of voodoo, is their ability to channel the power of the West African gods into their own bodies. This kind of possession is a major focus of Haitian folk religion, often compared to being ridden as a horse, where the practitioner is the horse and the gods, the loa, are the riders. Most important voodoo ceremonies in Haiti center around at least one spirit possession. [0:15:15] And in these possessions, an experienced houngan or mambo, that's priest or priestess, will enter an ecstatic trance, speaking in tongues as they perceive the spirit of the loa within them. Once possessed, this holy person will then use the power of the loa to provide blessings or guidance to others. So, historically, this sort of spirit possession has been taken seriously by all levels of Haitian society. So, during the 19th century, when class divisions between the urban rich and the rural poor were extremely broad, the only time a Haitian peasant could enter the homes of the rich was if he or she was possessed by the soul of a loa. And the soul in question is typically described as a zombie. [0:15:55] Right, right. And so, this is kind of important: is that you know, the word zombie in its initial sense does not originally mean a creature, it really means the soul that is possessing a body, usually in most cases, a living human body, the body of an experienced voodoo practitioner. Modern anthropologists trying to differentiate the undead creature from this word for soul will use the term astral zombie to describe the spiritual half of a human being. Because in the voodoo religion, which is very similar to Christian theology, there is a distinct separation from a soul and a physical body, the inferior, fallible flesh. In another parallel with Christian ideas of miracles and magic, Haitian voodoo is split into two categories: the holy and the profane. If a good houngan or mambo can practice benign voodoo, then a witch or a sorcerer can practice bad voodoo. [0:16:52] And in the Haitian Creole language, the word for such a practitioner of wicked voodoo is a bokor. So, a bokor is someone who can channel the power of the loa, but only towards selfish or malicious ends. A bokor may offer his services to curse someone's rival and love or to strike down an enemy with disease. They also heavily practice spirit possession, but uniquely, this sometimes entails the forced possession of another person. This is the curse of the zombie. So, at least since the middle of the 19th century and possibly even before, though the bokors had been feared for their ability to revive a recent corpse and to compel them to do their bidding, while the flesh of the zombie is alive and not decomposing like its modern depictions often frame it, they will lack an astral zombie of their own. And so, they are an empty vessel for the willpower of the Bokor. [0:17:44] In this way, the Haitian zombie might be close to the golems of Jewish folklore, which we discussed back in our earlier Halloween episode on episode 57. [0:17:53] Yeah, yeah, because that's the fundamental thing with traditional folkloric zombies: they are corpses, but they are very freshly dead corpses. So freshly dead that they can be resurrected without any visible, you know, differentiation of the flesh from a living person. They're not rotting. They are an empty human body from which the soul has fled and now which a new soul, a new astral zombie, can be projected inside. And so, in a way, it's kind of this like. [0:18:22] And I wouldn't necessarily call it a corpse just because this was something that people actually did for the record. And these people were very much alive. [0:18:30] Yes, no, no, so we should say we should get into this. Yes, that you know, there is kind of some evidence for historic zombies that seem to have existed that were very much not undead. They were people likely in altered states. Zombies are believed to be dead within the context of Haitian folklore. In many cases, people who claim to be bokors will say that they have risen a zombie by digging up a corpse that was buried the day before. So certain aspects of the zombie are definitely fictitious, but zombies are widely believed in within Haiti, within, you know, the context of Haitian voodoo. Not everybody who practices voodoo believes that zombies are real. That's something that some practitioners think is like, you know, a little beyond the pale. But it is this very interesting, enduring element of Haitian spiritual culture. [0:19:17] And so in the 1970s, the Haitian historian Maximilien Laroche examined the role and the origins of the zombie within the Haitian imagination, suggesting, which is now a pretty popular concept, that the zombie could be an echo of the horrific legacy of slavery. Laroche writes that the trauma of slavery, the transition from Africa to Haiti, and the experience of colonial oppression have clearly led Africans who have become Haitians to readjust their conception of the living dead, to see it not only from the metaphysical perspective that they had in Africa, but from the economic, social, and political perspective that Haitians now have. Within Haiti, voodoo practitioners who believe in zombies tend to reject any kind of metaphorical origin theory instead preferring supernatural explanations. One popular theory elaborated upon by the anthropologist Elizabeth McAlister is that the first zombie was in fact Jesus Christ. Soldiers who were guarding the tomb of Christ after his death witnessed the magic used by God in the resurrection, in which God poured his own astral zombie into the corpse of Jesus. [0:20:25] These Roman soldiers carried these secrets to West Africa and from there, their descendants brought these secrets to Haiti, the secrets of how to project one's own soul into the empty vessel of a corpse. I think that this kind of folklore is interesting because it shows how many voodoo practitioners really want their beliefs to be completely compatible with Christian conceptions of the Trinity and all that. And I think it shows that for most voodoo practitioners, they see their religion as the not something contrary to Christianity, but as in fact the correct, full interpretation of Christianity and everybody else is incomplete. [0:21:04] Right. And this interest in the zombie has been an interest for Western anthropologists for a century at this point. [0:21:12] It really began with the author called William Seabrook, who we're going to get into later on in this episode. But another very interesting example is the African-American author Zora Neale Hurston, who is more often known for her science fiction stories, but who was in reality a very prolific anthropologist. And so she wrote an entire book back in the 1930s based on her travels in Haiti and Jamaica and her work with these traditional Afro-Syncretic religions. On her travels to Haiti, she met a woman named Felicia Félix-Mentor, who claimed to have been a zombie who had died and was resurrected some 20 years earlier around 1907. While doctors insisted that her skeletal records did not match and that she was not the dead woman in question, Hurston speculated that some kind of poison could have been used to induce a state of near-death and perhaps even increase suggestibility, which would allow the poisoner to force their will on the victim. [0:22:11] And 50 years later, the Canadian anthropologist Wade Davis decided to put this theory to the test, making the case that zombies, in fact, really existed in his book, The Serpent and the Rainbow. Following in the footsteps of Zora Neale Hurston, Davis spent a long time in Haiti and also met a man who claimed to have been a zombie. Clairvius Narcisse put forward that he had died in the 1960s before being immediately resurrected as a zombie by a wicked Bokor who forced him to toil on his sugar plantation as a modern-day slave. He was unable to return to his family until 16 years later, after the Bokor had died and this curse had worn off. Although Wade Davis was unable to verify whether or not this story was actually true and see what kind of physical, mental, or chemical transformation Narcisse had undergone, he speculated that Narcisse may have been given a complicated poison based on locally available puffer fish venom and deadly nightshade to induce death and suggestibility. [0:23:11] In other words, this man was given a real zombie cocktail to drink. So while the book The Serpent and the Rainbow was a huge success and adapted into a 1988 horror movie with really nothing to do with the original text, anthropologists and doctors are not fully convinced that this kind of poison can actually exist. It's totally conjecture, and I think that, you know, there's really no way to know unless somebody is brave enough to try this poison themselves. Gladio Free Europe cannot, in good conscience, encourage any of our listeners to attempt their own zombification. But if you do happen to pull this off, please let us know and please spare our brains. [0:23:50] All right, but whether or not zombies are real is ultimately irrelevant to the zombies of contemporary fiction, which are very much not real, for now at least. So to understand how an obscure aspect of Afro-Caribbean folklore could have become a stock horror creature along the lines of witches and werewolves, we need to look at the deeper history of American-Haitian relations. [0:24:12] Yeah, because really, since day one, the relationship of the United States toward the nation of Haiti has been one marked at the best of times by distrust and at the worst of times by violent subjugation. There's this general pall of curiosity and fear toward Haiti because it is such an exception in the history of the Western Hemisphere. It is, of course, the first Black Republic. It is the only state to have been formed due to a successful mass slave revolt. This was also a slave revolt marked by significant violence and retaliation, which does leave a complicated legacy on Haiti's early history. The example of the Haitian Revolution terrified slaveholders on the American continent and across Latin America, leading to immediate hostility and a long-term economic blockade and imposition of a major debt regime upon the island. This means that Haiti has been in many ways uniquely isolated, despite being so close to other Caribbean nations and really just a couple days' boat ride away from the United States. [0:25:20] This isolation has led to this impression, which in some ways is true, in some ways is not, that Haiti is uniquely African, more so than other Caribbean islands where most residents are of African descent. This perception has led to both disproportionate interest and suspicion of the Haitian religion voodoo, which is often understood to be just an example of West African religions imported to the New World. [0:25:48] I think that in practice, Haitian voodoo is something that's very uniquely Haitian. I think that the comparisons to West African practices are not often as strong as some people believe. So many different African and European traditions came together in Haiti that I think that Haitian voodoo is really, it's this uniquely Haitian practice. And due to this perception that Haiti is uniquely African, certain aspects of Haitian religion have been the object of a great deal of exotic fascination. And no aspect of voodoo is more famous than the zombie. [0:26:23] Right. So although the zombie wouldn't enter American culture until the 20th century, which was the beginning of the 20-year occupation of Haiti by American Marines, but other aspects of voodoo, in particular the most macabre aspects of it, made their way into the Anglo imagination through sensationalist news reports, which dated back as far as the Haitian Revolution itself. [0:26:46] Technically, the revolution, which was the most successful slave revolt in history, happened before voodoo, as we know it, truly existed. Most Haitians in the late 18th century were still born in Africa, and they practiced the various religions of their homelands, which included Islam. But these religions were beginning to interact with one another as well as with French Catholicism. And so a new syncretistic tradition born out of slavery could have an enormous impact on Haiti's history and on the revolution itself. [0:27:16] Right, because the revolution is generally understood to have been proclaimed at a 1791 meeting at Bois Caïman, the Crocodile Woods. This kind of meeting was illegal due to the black code passed a century prior that banned any public gathering of slaves. But hundreds of Haitians risked violent retribution to defy this law and hear the words of two black mystics gathered there in the woods: Dutty Boukman and Cécile Fatiman. Dutty Boukman was a man born in West Africa, but brought by English slavers to Jamaica. English-speaking slaves or slave owners gave him the nickname Bookman due to his literacy, which might have indicated an educated Muslim background. Because any literacy was seen as subversive among slaves, his English masters sold him off to Haiti. We mentioned in our episodes on King Philip's War that slavery in the Caribbean was incredibly deadly. This is why Native American slaves were often sent there as a punishment. [0:28:11] Haiti was probably the worst place any slave could expect to be sent. Dutty Boukman's Jamaican owner believed that by sending him to such a deadly island, this would break his spirit and destroy any revolutionary potential he might have had. And the slave owner could not have been more wrong. Cécile Fatiman, on the other hand, comes from a very different background. She was the daughter of a wealthy white father who claimed that he had been a Corsican prince, but after his death, she and her black mother were sold to another plantation where she surely encountered many other slaves of different religious and cultural backgrounds. She eventually became some kind of spiritual leader in her own right, what we would now term as a mambo or a voodoo priestess. She and Boukman were the first generation of Haitians who were developing a new religious system alongside the official Catholicism. [0:28:57] According to one onlooker, the white physician Antoine Delmas, these two mystics sacrificed a black pig as an offering to a quote, all-powerful spirit, and then dipped their fingers in the blood and dabbed the foreheads of the people attending, sort of like Catholics do on Ash Wednesday. In a pattern that we're going to see again and again in anti-colonial revolts, the slaves attending believed that the sacrificed pig's blood rendered them invincible. Delmas was an opponent of the French Revolution and a staunch Catholic. He was convinced that this ceremony was a mock inversion of the Christian mass and that the all-powerful spirit in question was in fact Satan. As stories of the revolution spread to the United States, American slave owners were terrified that the same kind of revolt could happen here. A narrative began to develop that we see in extreme right-wing circles all the way up to this day, that the Haitians made a deal with the devil to free themselves from slavery, because there was no other explanation for the great violation of the supposed natural racial order. [0:29:54] Right, and as the Haitian Revolution became increasingly violent, U.S. newspapers widely circulated sensationalistic stories of massacres by black Haitians of white, while omitting any stories of white Haitians massacring blacks. And I mean, just these stories contained like as we said, Haiti was remarkably violent, even for a Caribbean slave society. And the kinds of punishment that were employed there by the white slave owners were just horrific. They were just torturing these people to death on the regular. And so naturally, like when it came time to free themselves, the slaves were out for vengeance because they were living under truly unfathomable conditions. And so like this white brutality that had been inflicted upon them, they proceeded to inflict on their former enslavers. [0:30:43] Yeah, and so what happened was that, you know, there was very little reliable information coming out of Haiti, but there were white people fleeing pretty serious violence inflicted by the blacks. And so white slave owners in the U.S. knew that their worst fears were coming true in Haiti, but there was such little reliable information that there was a lot of room to sensationalize and to speculate on the occult practices of Haitians, these imagined African pagan practices that might be existing on the island. So for instance, three months after the ceremony of Bois Caïman, Dutty Boukman was killed by French troops and his head was paraded around on a pike. This did not make the American papers. But what did make the papers were apocryphal stories of slaves putting on their own pikes the heads of white children. In this era, in the early 19th century, these specific stereotypes of voodoo, like our current associations about zombies and voodoo dolls and witch doctors, didn't really exist yet. [0:31:43] Because again, voodoo itself didn't really exist. It was still coming together. [0:31:48] But then, after the chaos of the revolution settled down, American interest in Haiti began to fade. But then, shortly after the Civil War, there was a new lured fascination reigniting about Haiti, which in a roundabout way is reflected in all modern zombie media. Because maybe two generations after the Haitian Revolution, there were new horror stories coming out of Haiti. Sensationalistic tales of cannibalism. Cannibalism is really the ultimate taboo in most cultures, including in Haiti and the Haitians' ancestral West African homelands. And so, although the zombies in Haitian folklore were not believed to eat flesh or brains, recent scholarship has tried to link the cannibalistic tendencies of Hollywood zombies to colonial era African folklore. By the 17th and 18th centuries, the peoples of Atlantic Africa had experienced generations of enslavement, yet knew nothing about where their countrymen were sent once they were kidnapped. So, from Senegal to the Congo, stories circulated of kidnapped slaves being cannibalized by whites and their bones ground down to make gunpowder. [0:32:51] These stories apparently caused many kidnapped Africans to commit suicide rather than submit to slavery. Additionally, there were regular allegations of cannibalism, which are very common in West Africa. Rival monarchs would often accuse each other of eating human flesh to justify local wars, particularly wars fought by Muslims against pagans. Now, some degree of real-life cannibalism certainly did exist in pre-modern West Africa, but the sources are quite scarce. However, in the neighboring Congo Basin, cannibalism was relatively widespread. A group of mercenary warriors known as the Imbangala practiced both witchcraft and cannibalism in an effort to terrify their many, many enemies. They worked at times for the Portuguese slave traders, which meant that on some occasions, fears of cannibalism in the slave trade were justified. These warriors followed complicated legal codes, which allowed for the consumption of human flesh, something which was banned by the Congolese kingdoms, which they fought for and against at various times. [0:33:50] Right, and so Congolese slaves continued to be killed and harvested for cannibalistic purposes until the modern era, but we should emphasize that cannibalism in this context was never about nutrition, it was always about this deliberate taboo violation. The consumption of human flesh in the society was a cruel exercise of power and domination, the complete subjugation of the slave. And in this sense, we can compare it to the possession of the zombie by the bokor. This conception of cannibalism as an insulting transgression was brought by those who survived the Middle Passage to the Americas and may be reflected in modern zombie lore. Additionally, independent of zombies, cannibalism was a central part of the Afro-Caribbean imagination. We should mention that a generation before the arrival of slaves, the Spanish cited alleged cannibalism by indigenous Caribbean peoples as a pretext to colonize those islands. These claims actually gave us the word cannibal, which is derived in a roundabout way from the Carib people, like in that 1826 story, The Generous Carib. [0:34:51] The Caribs were the same native tribe who gave us the name Caribbean. This means that by the 18th century, both white and black residents of the Caribbean greatly feared cannibalism, but knew that they were living on islands where cannibalism was at least believed to have once been widespread. This meant that the idea of cannibalism was never too distant to everyday Caribbean people, and it is thus not too surprising that sensationalistic claims of cannibalism would crop up every so often. [0:35:20] This is precisely what happened in 1864 when the nation of Haiti was gripped by a cannibal panic. Eight men and women were accused of cannibalism and then publicly executed for the charge of killing and eating a 12-year-old girl as part of a voodoo ceremony. Cannibalism is not a traditional part of voodoo, which is why there was such outcry among the Haitians. Although, symbolically, cannibalism does play a role, as we'll get into in a bit. [0:35:45] But yeah, so the British diplomat Spencer St. John believed that these rumors were true wholeheartedly, and in his report back to the London press, he did no favors for Europe's impression of Haiti, particularly of Haitian voodoo. According to St. John, who knew none of the people involved and was writing some 30 years after the fact, a brother and sister named Congo and Jeanne Pellé sought to upend their misery and poverty by making a great sacrifice to the loa. While a voodoo sacrifice is usually a chicken or a goat, the Pellés had grander ambitions. They chose to sacrifice a, quote, goat without horns, that is, a human. They allegedly killed their own 12-year-old niece named Clarice with the help of local voodoo priests who would join the Pellés as six other people publicly executed for the crime of sorcery, a crime which, shortly after the trial, was officially added to the penal code. [0:36:37] Historians today are split about whether or not these allegations were true or were fabricated by Catholic elites as part of a pretext for the suppression of traditional religion. No reliable information survives about the case. All we know is that it resulted in the execution of those eight people. It's likely not a coincidence that happened under the presidency of Fabre Geffrard, who is a staunch Catholic moralist. His predecessor, the Emperor Faustin Soulouque, had openly supported Haitian folk religion, and Geffrard, the new president, sought to radically reverse course. This human sacrifice trial was therefore a perfect pretext for Geffrard's crackdown on voodoo. Whether or not this cannibalism charge was genuine or the result of a cynical conspiracy, the public spectacle of this mass execution really brought actually the worst outcome to the Catholic elite of Haiti. Because rather than celebrating Haiti's leaders for suppressing cannibalism, white onlookers like Spencer St. [0:37:35] John began to think of Haiti as a nation of cannibals. A fear that may continue to shape outside stereotypes of the country, at least implicitly, all the way up to the present. [0:37:46] You know, as, you know, tragically, the fear-mongering about Haitian people is certainly not gone away. Yeah, and so even though Haiti is but a short ride away from the United States by boat, its political and economic isolation, largely a consequence of a cunning blockade of the Jefferson era, meant that Haiti is in some ways far more foreign than neighboring Cuba or Jamaica. Americans thought little about Haiti in the 19th century, except for during slave revolts and a few periods when annexing the Caribbean was very briefly entertained. First, briefly around 1866, the Johnson presidency considered annexing Saint-Domingue, which is today the Dominican Republic, to create a sort of black colony of sorts in the Caribbean. But such dreams did not end with the Johnson presidency. In 1891, the Secretary of State James G. Blaine, the man from Maine himself, took a more serious interest in Haiti. During a political dispute between two rival Haitian politicians and their factions, one contender named Florville Hippolyte asked the Americans for support with the condition that the American Navy could lease a tiny island as a coaling station. [0:38:56] When Hippolyte won, he realized that the public outcry against conceding territory to the Americans would be catastrophic. He reneged on the promise, leading the American Navy to send a squad of gunships to intimidate the island. When the Haitian government did not budge, the Americans blinked first and sailed back humiliated by a tiny, plucky country whose residents most white Americans believed to be inferior to themselves. American newspaper reports from the era after this were very, very bitter. The New York Times described the Haitians as semi-barbaric, and a Utah paper very colorfully described voodoo cannibalism. But this Blaine episode was just the start of U.S. imperial designs on the country. 23 years later, Woodrow Wilson's administration noted a trickle of German immigrant merchants into Haiti, fearing that this could be the camel's nose of German imperialism in the Western Hemisphere. Because this was a very unstable period of Haitian politics, the 1910s, the U.S. [0:39:53] feared that an inevitable political crisis, like the one involving Florville Hippolyte described earlier, could be used as a pretext for the German Empire to send troops to Haiti to restore order. But of course, only America is allowed to do that. So in 1914, the U.S. struck first. American Marines invaded Haiti with the stated goal of maintaining order before the Germans could. Financial institutions were seized by the Marines, resulting in the assassination by angry Haitians of the collaborator Haitian president and the subsequent imposition of martial law by the U.S. The full-blown American occupation of Haiti lasted for 19 years, during which time a string of dictators were imposed over the public. Poor farmers were forced by these American puppet politicians to labor for free on public works projects. A medieval style corvée system, which many Haitians believed as a new form of slavery introduced by a new form of white colonizer. [0:40:51] Not the French planter, but the American soldier and financier. Haitian workers rose up against this American system, fighting multiple guerrilla campaigns against U.S. troops and the Comprador Haitian gendarmes. During this period, respect for voodoo began to grow as it became a clear symbol for Haitian resistance. And also during this period, the American interest in voodoo grew as well. [0:41:16] So as we hopefully made clear, Americans were very long conscious of the Black Republic, which was only a short swim away from their borders. There was a sporadic interest in the affairs of the country, especially the most titillating aspects of their religion and culture, continuously. So given the long-standing American presence in the country, the Americans in the 1920s were more interested than ever. There was much money to be made by enterprising writers willing to sink their feet into the Haitian mud. So travelogues about Haiti and its culture were published left and right. But the one most widely remembered today is titled The Magic Island. William Seabrook was an extremely interesting man. Although he wrote some 50 years before Hunter S. Thompson coined the term, he was undoubtedly an early prototype of a Gonzo journalist. As a listless son of the Lost Generation, after completing a tour of duty in France where he was awarded the Croix de Guerre, Seabrook took off to explore the lesser traveled parts of the world in a quest to learn what goes on there. [0:42:12] He lived among the Bedouins and the Kurds for several months, during which time he converted to Islam. But after a while, Seabrook grew weary, for he knew that he needed an absolutely legendary white boy conversion arc if he hoped to make a name for himself. He found such an opportunity in Haiti as he set out on a quest to be initiated into Haitian voodoo. [0:42:31] Right, and his interest was complicated because, you know, he did have this genuine interest in Haitian voodoo, but he also was very much interested in the dollar and knew that he could thrill his audiences with stories of lurid Haitian ceremonies. But on the other hand, he was reticent to include any outright falsehoods in his work. And this actually cost him a lot of money. Seabrook was offered a syndicated deal for his coverage of Haitian voodoo for $15,000, which is about $300K in modern money, but he refused, saying that the changes these publishers demanded meant that, quote, everything between the lines changed color or evaporated. Some modern critics, looking back on his book, The Magic Island, see Seabrook's work as an exoticizing piece of pseudo-fiction which dabbles in racism against the Haitian people and legitimizes the U.S. occupation. Although the book did have illustrations which are very racialized, Seabrook was a lot more of a complicated guy than you know, just this belligerent bigot. [0:43:31] His works were indeed full of these kind of orientalizing stereotypes, not too far off of what you might see in a Conan the Barbarian story from around the same era. But Seabrook was remarkably tolerant for the 1920s. He went at great lengths to depict voodoo as a religion just like any other, writing that voodoo in Haiti is as profound and vitally alive a religion as Christianity was in its beginnings and in the early Middle Ages, when miracles and mystical illuminations were common everyday occurrences. Voodoo is primarily and basically a form of worship, and that its magic, its sorcery, its witchcraft is only a secondary, collateral, sometimes sinisterly twisted byproduct of voodoo as a faith, precisely as the same thing was true in Catholic medieval Europe. [0:44:17] Seabrook landed in Haiti in 1928, and shortly after this, he makes the acquaintance of a local young man named Louis, who sort of worked himself into Seabrook's employ and who was his in into the voodoo hierarchy of the Haitian countryside, which held firm to its traditional beliefs even when they were devout attendees of the Catholic Church. But time after time, Seabrook ran into problems. Even before the American intervention, Haiti was a really deeply bifurcated society. Historically, the Haitian government was controlled by the Creole elite of the country, who had significant French heritage, and these people really positioned themselves as the aristocracy of Haiti, trying very hard to align themselves with European culture. In the course of this, they took a very strong stance against the syncretized voodoo beliefs of the Haitian peasantry, who, as a rule, had much more African ancestry. Seabrook had a lot of trouble breaking into these religious societies, which were so used to operating under a government which treated them with hostility. [0:45:15] Seabrook was warned time and time again by editors that he would have trouble being present for voodoo ceremonies as a white American, seeing as the ceremonies were formally criminalized and he was a consummate outsider. One passage is really amusing if you've interacted with Haitian Americans before. Quote: The trail led me through the deep ravines in which the sun never shone, thence winding slowly up the edge of the sheer cliff to the door of a little man with a wisened face, a famous little man, a sort of voodoo hermit saint, who could have wisely taught me all that I wished to know and more. But he sneered at my sincerity and said, There is no such thing as voodoo. It is a silly lie invented by you whites to injure us. [0:45:54] Yeah, yeah. So as a Tony Soprano might say, what do you mean? There's no such thing as the voodoo. [0:45:59] Exactly. [0:45:59] And I mean, I just found this so funny because I grew up around Haitians and Liam, I believe you also did. And I mean, this is just very typical. [0:46:07] Oh, yeah, well, you know, yes, because I think it's because there's such a history of exoticization that, you know, some people who might grow up with these practices are embarrassed by the way they've been distorted by the media and, you know, and they might not want to discuss these with outsiders. So it's kind of easier to say this stuff doesn't exist than to try to differentiate the real existing voodoo practices from the kind of Hollywood stereotypes we're talking about today. They sort of, you know, want to put their best face forward and argue that, like, oh, you know, that stuff is just fake. Don't worry about it. It has nothing to do with us. And I mean, it often does have nothing to do with them. [0:46:40] Like, it's interesting, because on the one hand, many of these people, they would never actually practice voodoo, but they are like terrified of it. [0:46:47] Right. And Seabrook, for our purposes, was thankfully not a very polite or considerate guy. He refused to take no for an answer, and he wanted to know more and more about the religion of the people in Haiti he was living among. So thanks to his intimate links with Louis, his informant, he was able to earn the trust of locals well enough to have himself formally initiated into Haitian religion. Finally, his contacts led him into the island's highlands, where he met Maman Célie and Papa Theodore, a married couple who were the priests, Nama Loa and Papa Loa, of a local voodoo hounfort, or temple. Because the less explicitly Christian forms of voodoo were at this time criminal, joining this group was not an easy feat. So let's get into the ways that voodoo is very much a syncretic Catholic religion, just like Santeria in Cuba. [0:47:35] We discussed in earlier episodes the ways that the Catholic Church spread across Europe centuries before this. However, even though that really almost the entire mass of Europe, except for a small Jewish minority, became Christian, the people who became Christian were not tabulae rasa. Their prior religious heritage continued to be felt in folk beliefs in various ways. We've discussed this in our episodes on Christmas, the ways it may or may not be pagan. Similarly, the Jesuits operating in 16th century Japan found that their congregants mixed Catholicism with their previous Buddhism, just to cover all their bases. We talked about Dainichi already. In all of these cases, people began to practice a form of Christianity that was not entirely separable from beliefs that existed before their conversion. And while outsiders might see this as a corrupt form of Christianity, to these people themselves, this was what Christianity is supposed to be. [0:48:28] It's this correct synthesis of different valid systems brought together into something better and stronger. So today in Haiti, most Haitians attend either Catholic or Pentecostal church services, but many don't believe this as mutually exclusionary with their commitment to voodoo. They don't see a contradiction between going to Mass on Sunday and appeasing the older African gods that are now revered as the Loa in voodoo. Seabrook gives a great example of what this kind of syncretism looked like in practice. Another episode was told me in gentle, humorous despair by a tolerant old Breton priest who had lived in Haiti for 20 years and loved the peasants, despite the fact that he knows he has never been able to wean them completely from their ancient gods. One of his rural chapels was by the seashore, and parishioners from neighboring little islands came to monthly mass in their crude-sailed fishing boats. [0:49:20] One morning, as the bell was ringing, with the church already half-filled, he saw outside the coral reefs a boat crammed with black people coming to worship. What good Catholics he seemed to have made of them. But a few hundred yards from the shore, outside the reef, they became completely becalmed. A few moments later on the boat, there was a mighty blowing of conch shells, the thumping of a drum, a shrill chant arose. They were making voodoo incantations to Papa Agwe, begging him to send a wind that would blow them in to Christian communion. [0:49:47] Yeah, and Christianity was incorporated into voodoo as well. These African gods didn't emerge from their encounter with the church unscathed. These gods, or the loa, could be more properly called angels or divinities in the service of Bondye or Le Grand Maitre, like the great master. [0:50:06] Right, and then again Bondye is just a Haitian creole for bon dieu. [0:50:10] Yeah, exactly. And so in voodoo theology, Bondye created the world and the divinities, but he stepped away from the terrestrial affairs of the mortals, leaving these matters to his helpers whom the voodoo practitioners addressed. Just like in folk Catholicism, different loa are appealed to for different purposes, and the loa are even referred to as saints sometimes. Some biblical figures were directly integrated into voodoo. Mary became Erzulie. Saint Peter and Papa Legba were merged into one, as were Damballa and Moses. Some have argued that this was sort of a dissimulation that the enslaved adopted to hide their true faith from their masters. But even if this was the origin of the syncretism we see today, by now these are really sincerely held religious beliefs in their own right. [0:50:59] And also, one just little detail that I think is kind of interesting is that unlike in the kind of syncretism that you saw in Europe, as far as I know, a lot of times the syncretism in voodoo is kind of cross-gender, where a female saint will be associated with a male West African god, or vice versa. It's a kind of interesting little inversion there. [0:51:16] Yeah, yeah, it's just fascinating. [0:51:17] Yeah, I kind of, you know, I'm speculating a little bit here, but I also kind of wonder if part of it is the idea that, you know, these are the same figures, but they have different characteristics. There's like a male version of, you know, Shango, and also a female version, which might be Saint Barbara. [0:51:31] But going back to Seabrook, using his ties to Maman Célie, Seabrook was able to first observe a voodoo ritual at, like we said, a hounfort, which is like, you know, a voodoo altar. And he was then initiated in the religion himself. These parts of the book become a bit more questionable because he begins to describe the religious practices he was encountering in a very exoticizing tone, really writing for, you know, to entertain the reader more so than to inform. But he also takes pains to insist that, like we said, voodoo is a religion like any other. Seabrook watched as the locals made an offering to the Loa with the soundtrack of drums that are so central to voodoo practice. It's been argued that the word voodoo itself might actually have been once first used to describe a drumming practice in these ceremonies. The ceremony was packed with music, chants, and dancing, and a select few participants were seized with the spirit of the loa. [0:52:27] They were the horse being ridden. You know, just as a kind of cross-cultural comparison here, think about how evangelical Pentecostals react when they believe to be touched by the Holy Spirit. You see the same speaking in tongues, you know, the famous holy rolling. I gotta wonder if maybe it's not a coincidence that Pentecostals have made a lot of successful penetration into Haiti. But so, eventually, Seabrook describes the mass sacrifice of goats. Animal sacrifice is a pretty regular part of voodoo practice, and there's an element of symbolic human sacrifice Seabrook returns to time and time again. In a process paralleling the binding of Isaac in Genesis, the practitioners would sacrifice goats in place of a human sacrifice. They would say that, you know, this goat would represent the sacrifice of a man. Following the completion of this ceremony, the worshippers ran off into the forest to apparently have an orgy. [0:53:20] Seabrook's tone here becomes incredibly horny. Like, you know, he knows what he's trying to do here with what he's writing, but he really is committed to maintaining his stance on humanizing Haiti by drawing direct comparisons with these voodoo practitioners and his American readers back home. He writes, What after all were they doing here in these final scenes when formal ritual had ended that was so different from the things which occur in our own fashionable nightclubs? Except that they were doing it with the sanction of their gods and doing it more successfully. Savage rhythm, alcohol, and sex excitement. Yet there was an essential difference, for here was a mysterious, something superadded. Lasciviousness became lust, which is a cleaner thing. And neurotic excitement became authentic ecstasy, the divine frenzy of the ancients. And so, after the ceremony was over, Seabrook continued to linger in the village as he watched Maman Célie practicing her trade until finally it would be his turn to be initiated into the faith. [0:54:14] In the lead-up to the initiation, he was given a special charm and said the following prayer over it: quote, May Papa Legba, Damballa, Erzulie, and the serpent protect me from misrepresenting these people and give me power to write honestly of their mysterious religion. All living faiths are sacred. So, Seabrook described his initiation in great detail. It's really interesting stuff and very titillating as usual, and it really successfully conveys this sense of being face to face with a great unknown, which had great power. It really touched him to his core, and he emerged from the experience, a believer in the importance of such primal faith to the health of the soul. He wrote, quote, codes of rational ethics and human brotherly love are useful, but they do not touch the thing underneath. Let religion have bloody sacrifices, yes, even human sacrifices, if thus our souls may be kept alive. [0:55:04] I'd say maybe scroll down a little bit there, Liam. [0:55:08] And I mean, it's also entertaining to note that in his later years, Seabrook claimed to have eaten human flesh. This guy was really a bit touched in the head. There's a lot going on in his biography, but yeah. [0:55:24] It really is, you know, this is like the first great anthropological account of voodoo. Well, by the way, it's frustrating for scholars because almost like a medieval text, it's, you know, it's not really an academic account. Just like, you know, a medieval writer, he has very different interests that modern scholars might have. He is certainly not objective in any sense, does not attempt to be, but he has interesting observations that provide really important information, including really great details about the ways that Catholicism and voodoo are totally inseparable in Haiti. To give one example, describing this voodoo priest, as he arose and beckoned me to kneel at last before the altar, there was absolute silence. He was voodoo of the voodoo, but as he laid his hands upon my head, it was neither in Creole that he spoke, nor French, nor even the almost forgotten languages of Old Guinea. [0:56:18] I heard, as in a dream, low, clear, and deep, as the voices of old men rarely are, In nomine patris, et filii, et spiritus sanctis. Amen. [0:56:29] That rules. [0:56:31] Jesus. Yeah. [0:56:32] But all right, now we are getting to the part you're all waiting for. Because although Seabrook's book is worth a read in its entirety, there's one thing that really makes it stand out, and that is the earliest in-depth depiction of zombies as we know them. The chapter, Dead Men Working in the Canefields, might be the book's most shocking, as Seabrook talks in length about the many superstitions of the Haitian peasantry. Curses, wishes, vampires, werewolves, and of course, the walking dead. Here's how Seabrook defines them. It seemed, or so I had been so assured by black people more credulous than Polynice, that while the zombie came from the grave, it was neither a ghost nor yet a person who had been raised like Lazarus from the dead. The zombie, they say, is a soulless human corpse, still dead, but taken from the grave and endowed by sorcery with a mechanical semblance of life. [0:57:23] It is a dead body which is made to walk and act and move as if it were alive. People who have the power to do this go to a fresh grave, dig up the body before it has time to rot, galvanize it to movement, and then make of it a servant or slave, occasionally for the commission of some crime, more often simply as a drudge around the inhabitants of the farm, sending it to dull-heavy tasks and beating it like a dumb beast if it slackens. Note that one line about how the body has not yet had time to rot, because that is a huge aesthetic difference from modern Hollywood zombies. [0:57:56] Yeah, absolutely. So, as this passage makes clear, Seabrook had one local friend named Polynice who was usually very rationalist. He sort of dismissed these stories of like vampires and witches and all that stuff out of hand. So, when Seabrook asked him for clarification about the zombies he had heard so much about, he expected to hear the same jaded, rationalist outlook. Not so. Polynice took this much more seriously than he had expected. Polynice responded, Superstition, but I assure you that this of which you speak now is not a matter of superstition. Alas, these things and other evil practices connected with the dead exist. They exist to an extent that you whites do not dream of, although evidences are everywhere under your eyes. Why do you suppose that even the poorest peasants, when they can, bury their dead beneath solid tombs of masonry? Why do they bury them so often in their own yards close to the doorway? [0:58:45] Why so often do you see a tomb or grave set close beside a busy road or a footpath where people are always passing? It is to assure the poor, unhappy dead such protection as we can. And so Polynice offered to take Seabrook to see some zombies and Seabrook agrees. These zombies were mindless bodies performing hard labor, and one HASCO plantation had such individuals working in the cane fields. Seabrook was overwhelmed with anticipation until Polynice finally took him to visit the field by night and found absolutely nothing. But he would have an encounter soon enough. One day by chance, they passed the same way, and there they were. The zombies were working the field. Quote: My first impression of the three supposed zombies who continued dumbly at work was that there was something about them unnatural and strange. They were plodding like brutes, like automatons. Without stooping down, I could not fully see their faces, which were bent expressionless over their work. [0:59:38] Polynice touched one of them on the shoulder, motioned him to get up. Obediently, like an animal, he slowly stood erect. And what I saw then, coupled with what I had heard previously, or despite it, came as a rather sickening shock. The eyes were the worst. It was not my imagination. They were in truth like the eyes of a dead man. Not blind, but staring, unfocused, unseeing. The whole face, for that matter, was bad enough. It was vacant, as if there was nothing behind it. It seemed not only expressionless, but incapable of expression. I had seen so much previously in Haiti that was outside ordinary normal experience that for a flash of a hot second, I had a sickening, almost panicky lapse, which I thought, or rather felt, quote, Great God, maybe this stuff really is true. And if it is true, it is rather awful, for it upsets everything. [1:00:25] Yeah, and that one paragraph had more of an influence on the perception of Haiti than I would, I think, the rest of the pages in this book combined. Because I think that one paragraph is why the Magic Island was such a major bestseller and would become a really defining part of American horror media in ways I'm sure Seabrook never could have anticipated. [1:00:45] Yeah, so Seabrook attempted to speak to the zombies, but they just stared back vacantly. They were laboring under the supervision of an overseer, and when he attempted to ask her questions about what he had seen, she hit him with a stern, quote, Negroes' affairs are not for whites. The practice was notorious enough that it was even prescribed in the Haitian Penal Code. Article 249 of the penal code reads, quote, also shall be qualified as attempted murder, the employment which may be made against any person of substances which, without causing actual death, produce a lethargic coma, more or less prolonged. If, after the administering of such substances, the person has been buried, the act shall be considered murder, no matter what result follows. And we mentioned previously that there are, you know, a fair number of arguments saying that this is really a biochemical phenomenon, that you know, they use pufferfish poison to put these people in a coma, and then after the burial, they just go and dig them up. [1:01:40] And basically, this chapter also gives an account of a Bokor who kept a whole colony of zombie slaves, basically, and the conditions that they had to be kept in. They were fed this completely nutritionless gruel. They were like, the big thing in the story is that they're not allowed to eat salt because if they eat salt, then they're going to become conscious again. And so, I mean, it just sounds to me, frankly, like these people are being purposefully malnourished and given some kind of other drug which would make them really pliant and willing to follow the command of whatever is told to them. And so, it seems like some people just were stuck in this terrifying condition for many years before they were finally able to escape. [1:02:23] Yeah, and it's kind of exactly, I think, honestly, I would argue that the question of whether or not zombies do exist is something that people in Haiti and foreign anthropologists are basically split on. What's clear is that there is certainly a widespread belief that being turned into a zombie is a very real threat. The question is basically: is it something that happens to someone who has genuinely died, or is it like we said this, you know, chemical medical process? Some people completely dismiss any stories of zombification totally out of hand. But, like we said, is that you know, people in Haiti generally believe this to the extent that the modern constitution, like we said, has a provision basically banning the medical creation of a zombie. I think it kind of brings us to this really great quote that I think really kind of sums up Seabrook's entire attitude, which is that if you spent many years in Haiti, you would have a very hard time to fit this American reasoning into some of the things you encountered here. [1:03:18] Yeah. All right, so let's get into the zombie invasion of America that followed the publication. [1:03:25] Right, because so, yes, because you know, this book, The Magic Island, led to this flurry of interest in voodoo across the United States, all across pop culture. Voodoo starts to appear in movies, in plays, in jazz songs, and sometimes zombies appear as well. The zombie was really introduced to widespread audiences by Victor Halperin's 1932 film White Zombie, which is, you know, lifted in some aspects directly from accounts described by Seabrook. But in other ways, it's just another kind of, you know, fun early 30s spooky horror movie. I think it's worth a watch, but I know you, Russian Sam, were much less impressed. [1:04:05] Yeah, no, I'm really not a fan. Just to explain how Hollywood worked in those days, back in the 20s and 30s and 40s, movies often ran as double features, which is where we get the term B-list movie. The B-list movies were something that the studios wanted to pump out on the cheap without too much fuss about the quality of the product because the A-list material was what the audiences were really anxious to see. So horror movies in the 30s and 40s were almost entirely B-list movies. And sometimes, despite the limitations, these movies really shine onto themselves. But unfortunately, I think White Zombie is not one such movie. The plot, it's really simple. There's a jealous plantation owner named Charles, who falls in love with Madeline, a young American woman who spends the night at his plantation along with her fiancé, Neil. In a fit of lust, Charles goes to Murder Legendre, great name, played by that wonderful guy. [1:04:59] Should clarify, this guy's first name is Murder, and he is played by none other than Bela Lugosi. [1:05:06] Yeah, and so he's Legendre, he's this really powerful sorcerer who runs a sugar mill manned by zombies. Charles goes to him and asks him to make Madeline his wife. And she told Legendre gives Charles a substance, which he uses to put her into a coma, and then after the funeral, he resuscitates her as a mindless zombie. She is a mere shell of her former self. Charles really can't bear to see her in this state and begins to have second thoughts. At which point, Murder zombifies him too. But ultimately, the day is saved when Neil shows up and pushes Legendre off a cliff, breaking the fiancée out of her stupor and saving her. And so they lived happily ever after. Yada, yada, yada. Really, not a great movie, far from it. But the vibe of the film is pretty creepy at times, and it does include a fair bit of anthropological detail as reflected in Seabrook's writings. [1:05:57] No, it was also came out just a year after Dracula, I believe, and it's really kind of riffing on the whole Dracula premise. Like you have this, you know, blonde white woman who's kind of enslaved by this guy played by Bela Lugosi. It's really just the Dracula formula all over again, moved from Victorian London into Haiti. But I guess I think it's worth watching, but it's certainly in no sense an accurate depiction of Seabrook's text and really has nothing to do with actual Haitian voodoo. [1:06:25] Yeah, I just found it really impressive that they were able to make a movie about Haitian zombies and show only a handful of black zombies on screen. Like, literally, only the mill worker zombies are black. Otherwise, it seems like Legendre zombified basically every other white person that he found on Haiti. [1:06:42] Yeah. Right, right. But regardless of how good of a movie White Zombie is, it did really cement the zombie in popular consciousness. [1:06:51] And like we said, you know, was part of this broader voodoo craze that lasted until like the 60s. In the run-up to this episode, Abram went through the archives and found that the words zombie and voodoo were used relatively widely in American newspapers and American films across the 30s, especially after the release of White Zombie. Six other 1930s films used the word zombie in their dialogue, and at least 10 others reference voodoo, including some horror movies like Dracula's Daughter, this forgotten pre-code vampire flick with kind of shocking lesbian themes. But yeah, we're getting a little far afield here. We should mention that both words voodoo and zombie were used in joking derogatory ways that you still hear today. Voodoo was used to mean nonsense, and zombie was used to mean anyone who doesn't have a mind of their own. It's worse than horrible because a zombie has no will of his own. [1:07:42] You see them sometimes walking around blindly with dead eyes, following orders, not knowing what they do, not caring. You mean like Democrats? [1:07:52] That's Bob Hope in the 1940 film The Ghostbreakers. And so after the release of White Zombie in 32, there were other imitators which were produced with even less artistic merit. Sometimes with a nod to the Caribbean, but sometimes not at all. In 1936, Boris Karloff, who was already famous for playing the title role in Frankenstein a few years before that, starred as the reanimated corpse in The Walking Dead. His character is brought back to life through science, not magic, and the word zombie is never used in the film. But the New York Times review that year described Karloff as, quote, an impressive zombie, showing that at this point the term had become a byword for any kind of undead creature. In that same year, the movie Revolt of the Zombies was released. And it just goes to show how quickly the zombie was just divorced from the Caribbean. [1:08:41] Because, yeah, yeah, no, this one, it just takes place in Cambodia. So, yeah, which is, yeah, about as far from the Caribbean as you can get, you know. [1:08:49] Although, I guess, you know, from this, you know, exoticizing Hollywood perspective, they're both these unknowable tropical locations. So, I'm sure that in a way, Cambodia and Haiti are somewhat interchangeable in that mindset. [1:09:01] Yeah, and so the zombie as a concept, just like the zombies of folklore, was stripped of its past attachments and lumbered on without care. [1:09:08] There were a few other zombie movies after that. Pretty much all of them were garbage until finally Hollywood got its shit together and produced one Returning to the Caribbean, which I think is worth watching on its own merit rather than just an excruciating excursion through film history. [1:09:23] Right, because in 1943, RKO released Jacques Tourneur's I Walked with a Zombie, written by the Weimar filmmaker Curt Siodmak. Just like White Zombie, this movie's central zombie character is a white woman, but that's basically where the similarities end. Because while White Zombie takes place in a world populated with poorly written stock characters who act as a delivery vehicle for bug-eyed zombies, Tourneur's film puts you smack dab in the middle of a family drama, which led to the zombification of the zombie in question, who is the wife of this American-educated planter who lives on this Caribbean island. It's a really good movie. There's very explicit references to colonialism and slavery that would have been pretty rare, I think, in 1943. [1:10:07] Yeah, there's a pretty funny line, like right at the beginning of the movie, where this nurse who gets hired to take care of this zombified woman, she's riding in a carriage driven by a black man, and he's just telling her about how, oh, you know, they brought our ancestors on ships over here. And she's like, well, you know, it could be worse. This place is pretty nice. And you're just like, well, if you say so, ma'am, you know. [1:10:32] I know, yeah, yeah, I know. It's really dark. Like, there's one line where at one point early in the film, the main character, who's a white Canadian woman, she hears somebody crying. And it turns out that it's because a baby is being born. And in this island, they explain, life is so hard that people cry at every birth and laugh at every funeral. That's just how tough it is, you know, due to the legacy of slavery on this island. [1:10:57] Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Like, I don't want to spoil the plot too much just because I think this movie actually is worth watching. [1:11:03] Yeah, it's quite good. But it's right. Like, it's really good. They put a lot of effort into like, you know, portraying actual ceremonies. Whereas in White Zombie, you literally just have a funeral that lasts for like a minute. Right. And that's why, you know, this was not billed as an adaptation of the Magic Island the way that White Zombie was. But I think it's much closer to the spirit of Seabrook's account. [1:11:25] Oh, absolutely. It's an imperfect and subjective view of Haitian practice that in some ways is very garbled and exoticizing, but does make an attempt to portray this ceremony that seems authentic. And it is certainly a very sympathetic portrayal of these views. But however, as we see time and time again with this podcast, critics at the time were not necessarily impressed. Yeah, like in particular, the New York Times just seemed to hire the most deep-cutting haters around because they were not impressed with this movie at all. They wrote, quote, if the Hays Office feels it has a duty to protect the morals of moviegoers by protesting the use of such expressions as hell and damn in purposeful dramas like In Which We Serve and We Are the Marines, then how much more important is its duty to safeguard the youth of the land from the sort of stuff and nonsense that their minds will absorb from viewing I Walked with a Zombie? [1:12:17] And yeah, so both these zombie movies, I think, are totally fundamental to understand how zombies became part of American horror fiction, but they still don't really look like the zombies we see on TV today. [1:12:29] Like we said, they are not decaying, and importantly, they do not eat other humans. They are missing the ingredient of cannibalism that we've already described being present in other ways in the folklore of the Caribbean. It's difficult to know exactly when zombies first started eating flesh or brains, because as far as we can tell, in no film from the 30s or 40s is a zombie a cannibal. I did a little bit of digging, and from what I can tell, the idea that zombies eat living humans was invented out of whole cloth from a source that you don't really hear much about today, but clearly has had great influence on pop culture. These are horror comic books. Because, you know, while comic books might be inseparable from superheroes today, the rise of the superhero is mostly a consequence of the 1954 Comics Code, which banned depictions of violence and sexuality. [1:13:24] Before the Comics Code, but after World War II, was this golden age of gruesome, brutal comics, as comics in the late 40s and early 50s drew most of their stories from crime, romance, and horror. Horror comics are mostly forgotten today, although one series, Tales from the Crypt, does have a lasting legacy thanks to its 80s TV adaptation. Tales from the Crypt and most other horror comics were put out by the premiere imprint of the 50s, EC Comics, which hilariously stood for Educational Comics. Their stories drew from diverse macabre stories, often mixing sex and violence in ways that are still pretty shocking and tasteless even today. EC Comics were the target of the international comic book panic of the mid-50s, but before the comics code was passed, they would become very widely read across the US by Americans of all ages and would prove a huge inspiration for later horror storytellers. [1:14:20] Their covers were particularly lurid, often providing early jobs for now-prominent illustrators like Frank Frazetta. Frazetta's favorite subject in his brief tenure as an EC Comics illustrator was the rotting, dripping zombie. And so, in these comics, you're going to find how most of the modern-day zombie tropes were already there some 15 years before Night of the Living Dead came out, which was, you know, when zombies really took off. Yeah, so especially like the kind of the rotting zombie that we understand today, the infectious zombie, not the voodoo zombie. [1:14:55] Yeah, Liam dug up one story from 1953, which was titled The Corpse That Came to Dinner, which shockingly appears to be a reference to a Christmas movie that we discussed in episode 62, The Man Who Came to Dinner. [1:15:08] Right, because in this comic, a hideous corpse rises from the grave and tracks down a woman he once loved, only to find out that she's now married to another man. He threatens to eat their flesh, but then decides it'll be better to just squat in their home and annoy them. In kind of a, you know, parody reference to that movie, that Christmas movie. So he just, you know, he just tries to harass this couple for a few weeks, but eventually, the woman's new husband buys a bottle of voodoo poison to paralyze him. They toss him in a coffin and bury him back into his grave. But then, in the very last panel, we have the shocking twist. This zombie was, in fact, a regular guy wearing gross makeup, just trying to give this couple a scare. And now he's just been buried alive. Talk about a bad Tuesday. [1:15:55] Yeah. [1:15:56] I know, yeah. It really seems like, you know, most of the horror comics of the 50s were about zombies. And I think that part of it is just because the decay factor was so shocking to audiences. This was the kind of thing that really had never been depicted visually in mainstream media before. A rotting corpse with its face, you know, visibly obscured by decay with worms and slime. You know, I think that these comics were so taken up by the terror aspects of the gore and the cannibalism that they kind of left the voodoo stuff behind. And they replaced these voodoo elements of Seabrook's zombies, the zombies of I Walked with a Zombie, with instead elements from vampire lore. This is where we really see the connection with zombies and early medieval revenant stories. You know, the risen corpses here to prey upon the living. Because starting in the 50s, these comics begin to be able to infect humans with a bite, just like a vampire, which would be something that's, you know, totally alien to Caribbean folklore. [1:17:00] And I also kind of wonder if the reason why these zombies became so grisly is because, unlike Hollywood, comics writers before the comics code didn't have to worry about any censorship. They could show something that was disgusting and graphic in ways that would not be legally or really financially feasible to do in a movie. You know, because it's just much cheaper to create a disgusting, shambling corpse with colored pencils and pen than with special effects. Zombie comics are also this really interesting missing link because there weren't that many zombie movies in the 50s. There were a tiny handful of voodoo themed movies that featured zombies, but these were really just recycles rip-offs of White Zombie and I Walked with a Zombie. There were a couple others that tried to modernize the concept by involving zombies reanimated with science, like the creature with the atom brain. But we already saw this with Boris Karloff's The Walking Dead in 36. [1:17:55] After the Comics Code of 54 made it much harder to publish these really gruesome stories, zombies seemed to be dead and buried. But thanks to the efforts of some enterprising young filmmakers a decade later, these undead monstrosities would rise from their grave yet. [1:18:11] Yeah, because George Romero, with some $5,000 in his pocket to make an entire movie, set out to make what ultimately became Night of the Living Dead, released in 1968. This is probably the most important zombie movie of all times, and it really created an entire genre unto itself. The zombie apocalypse that we're so familiar with. Romero's creatures are entirely indebted to 1950s horror comics and have little in common with the Caribbean zombies that we've been talking about this episode. He actually took great pains not to use the word zombie at all in the film script, although the rest of the production team didn't get the memo because the ghouls are listed as zombies in the credits, and the film was explicitly marketed as a zombie movie. [1:18:54] Yeah, and since you had not seen Night of the Living Dead until this episode, Sam. [1:18:58] Yeah, no, I just saw it to prepare for this episode, and I mean, like, I'm very, very impressed. Like I said, this was basically a hobbyist project where they were shooting on a shoestring budget. And like, you know, they got a bunch of yokels to play the zombies because everyone was just so excited at the idea of like all these film students coming to their little podunk town to make a movie. And yeah, yeah, so they just staggered right on screen for them, and so they became immortalized as zombies. And it's just an interesting movie because unintentionally, it sort of also became a commentary on racial relations in the 1960s. [1:19:38] Absolutely, yeah. Yeah, because the main character is African-American, and then you know, I think it's probably fine to spoil a movie from 1968. At the end of the film, after surviving the, you know, first zombie apocalypse put on screen, he is killed by a white vigilante mob who possibly think he's a zombie himself. [1:19:58] Yeah, and I mean, it's just a really fascinating story all along because this character that he plays, he's really the main character of the movie. He wasn't written as a black man at all. So, this would have been the first example of color-blind Hollywood casting where they get a black man to play the lead without any special reference to the fact that he's black. [1:20:19] No, that's why I think it's so interesting, you know, because, like, you know, because zombies as we know them are totally connected to the experience of you know, black racialization of you know the creation of race under white supremacy. So, that's why it's like I don't think that Romero was doing this intentionally, especially because he tried so hard to differentiate his creatures, he called them ghouls, from voodoo zombies. But you do see these really strange kind of thematic links, and even beyond the racial element, I think that the reasons why zombies are so scary in Night of the Living Dead do reflect the common fears of zombies in the original Haitian voodoo variety as well. Largely the fact that any one person could become a zombie themselves. You could experience this life beyond death in which you have completely surrendered your own soul and are compelled by some greater force far beyond your own capabilities. [1:21:13] You know, it could be that you are, it doesn't matter whether you are being ridden like a horse by an evil bokur or if some terrible disease has rendered you into an animal. In any case, your soul is gone, but your body is not allowed to rest. And even though zombies obviously do not exist, certainly not in the Romero sense, I think that they really do tap into all of these societal fears. A lot has been written about the ways that modern zombie stories, especially the kinds of zombie movies that became really popular in the 2000s, might reflect fears of disease or climate apocalypse. [1:21:47] Yeah, classically 28 Days Later. Like, you gotta watch that one if you haven't seen it. It's just an incredible movie onto its own, right? It's one of the first appearances of God, what's his face? [1:22:00] Cillian. [1:22:01] Yeah, yeah, Cillian Murphy. Yeah, definitely. [1:22:03] No, no, and he's so he's gaunt enough. He could have played a zombie in the 40s pretty well. But yeah, I think that there is something that's, I think, is almost relatable about a zombie in a way that a vampire is not. And I think that this is why they are kind of the most popular modern horror creature. They're so visually arresting, especially now that they're always depicted in decay. But I think that they remind us about our own mortality, as well as the fragility of modern society and the fragility of our own ego, of our own will. I think that there is this fear that we could somehow be compelled by an addiction, a disease, just a very strong emotion to do something that we think we could never do, and that we would lose control the way the zombie does. [1:22:53] Yeah, and I mean, just going back to the labor element, which again is usually lost in modern zombie stories, but it's a very, very present element in the original zombie mythology. [1:23:06] It's like if we're gonna go looking back at our previous Halloween episodes, we did one on the golem two years ago now, and you know, that's sort of a very similar concept where you have this creature that's brought onto this earth to perform tasks of labor, really unable to express its own will. And in that episode, I drew parallels between, you know, these golems and large language models or other attempts to use so-called AI to replicate human labor. But I mean, like, a really interesting thing to consider is sort of like the zombie elements of these large language models, which are, of course, dependent on massive amounts of tagging and cataloging by people in places like the Philippines or Kenya or whatever, where, you know, you sort of have this sort of zombified labor go into all of these large language models to do the training. [1:24:07] And so ultimately, like these people's acts of labor are now like sort of providing the fuel for these machines to pump out their little piece of shit poems or whatever people are using them for Twitter click page, etc. [1:24:22] No, no, absolutely. And then from the perspective of, you know, of the user, I think that interacting with an AI, with an LLM, does kind of feel like it's this, you know, this soulless replication of a human form, not unlike either a golem or a zombie. You know, it's that it's, it's, or, you know, we're bringing this back to what we said, you know, in a sense, Frankenstein is the first zombie as this monster stitched together by joining together the flesh of different people. That that's exactly how a language learning model reproduces human speech. It just hacks apart real speech produced by actual humans and reconstructs them and reanimates them by joining them together into this undead synthesis of speech. [1:25:03] Yeah, yeah. So again, we are living in the age of the golem and we are living in the age of the zombie. But at least we have the consolation of knowing that we're getting, you know, some entertaining media out of this concept at least. And I mean, zombies aren't going as strong as they were before. Like in the mid-2010s, you know, you had The Walking Dead. Game of Thrones is basically a zombie series, if you think about it. [1:25:31] It is. No, I think that we are due for either a zombie comeback or a new creature on the horizon. And I'm curious, you know, what it's going to be. Maybe you're onto something, Sam, in that, you know, some kind of AI zombie is going to be the next big thing. Because I think you're completely right. You know, the way that it's, you know, human labor is forced to exist indefinitely. And I think that's the kind of thing that Western audiences can't yet conceive of as being relatable to their own labor, even though I think this kind of zombification is coming for all workers eventually. And yeah, so I think that maybe it's going to take the next great zombie movie to make Americans realize that their labor might be next, you know, and that, you know, under capitalism, there never can be eternal rest. [1:26:17] The arc of capitalism is long, but it ends with all of us becoming zombies. [1:26:21] Yes. And on that lovely note, I would say thank you to our listeners for joining us on this trip through the long and twisted history of the zombie, you know, from West Africa to George Romero and beyond. And yeah, we hope you guys enjoyed and we hope you are having a happy Halloween. And we hope you don't get bitten by a zombie because, yeesh, not great. [1:26:48] Yeah. [1:26:49] All right, have a great one. Bye.