Gladio Free Europe, E110: The Commune of Zoar (with Jern) https://www.gladiofreeeurope.com/episodes/the-commune-of-zoar [0:00:17] Welcome back to Gladio Free Europe. I am Liam, going here today with a special, very fun, one-on-one chat with one of our oldest and best collaborators and friends. We are joined by Jern, our man from Akron. How are you doing? [0:00:35] Doing good. Thank you. It's good to be back talking about Ohio history for much too long. [0:00:43] Yes, we are back with the one and only Ohio expert with yet another incredible and incredibly detailed look at the history of really one of the most interesting states. And I would say possibly the most American of all the states. [0:01:01] The most average American, I think, putting in all of the variations, smoothing it out into like one big, one big heart-shaped piece. [0:01:13] And yeah, yes. And, you know, if Ohio truly is the heart of America, I think that's because all of the various ideological currents in American history circulate through this heart. You know, we talked before about the rise and eventual fall of the Ku Klux Klan in Ohio, largely through the efforts of anti-Klan peoples, particularly among the Catholic community who rejected the kinds of, you know, supremacism of the Klan. Today, we are looking at another religious group in Ohio, a very different, much older group. These are the Zoarite Separatists, a German origin group who founded a utopian commune in Ohio known as Zoar. Before we get started in getting into any of this, just tell me, Jern, how did you first learn about Zoar? Is this something you guys grow up hearing about in Ohio? [0:02:12] This was... Zoar is really a very local part of like Northeast Ohio. I know quite a few people who have been there before and like visiting, but I hadn't actually heard of the town until I took my Ohio history class in college for my history degree. And so it was in that that I learned about a lot of the earlier history. And when we got into the Second Great Awakening and all of these communes all over America, we mentioned Zoar. So there was one day where I was like, oh, I want to go and visit some of these places we talked about in class. So I went to Gnadenhutten, Ohio, as well as Zoar. [0:02:56] Yes. Great name. [0:02:57] And got to tour around and realize, wow, this is one of my favorite places I've ever seen in this state. I got to learn more. [0:03:05] If you guys haven't heard two episodes prior, we were on with our friend Jackson talking about the American utopian tradition, basically from ancient Christianity up into modern times, and how there's this long trend in Christian thought about creating separatist colonies removed from society such that the believers in these communities can live a life free from worldly obligations and worldly sin. We talked mostly about how this religious idea eventually gave way to this secular Enlightenment utopian idea, best exemplified in the Indiana colony of New Harmony established by Robert Owen. Robert Owen was this forward-thinking industrialist who was right at the cutting edge of early industrial capitalism and then used those industrial principles of efficiency and organization to construct one of the first attempts at a post-capitalist society in New Harmony, Indiana. So, if you haven't listened to that episode, you totally should, because we go into great detail about a lot of the concepts that are going to be relevant here. [0:04:22] We gave an impression last episode that there was this linear trend from religious communes to secular communes, from the Shakers to New Harmony, to the Owenists. But that's a little bit off the mark because religious communes continued to exist, in fact, long after the experiment at New Harmony fell apart. And I think that the particular example of Zoar in Ohio is really illustrative of this whole religious sectarian utopian tradition. And it's also just a really fun story to get into, especially because unlike so many of these other communes we've described and we're going to describe in this episode, both religious and secular, the commune at Zoar was incredibly successful. New Harmony lasted for about a decade. Zoar lasted for 75 years. [0:05:21] When you visit Zoar today, driving down from the north following the canal, of course, in true Ohio fashion, you pass a lot of cornfields, rural houses, and then an auto body shop as you come to the town limit. You're greeted with a sign, and it says, Welcome to Zoar, founded 1817, site of America's most successful communal settlement, 1819 to 1898. Once you turn the bend at the sign, the town isn't that much more than a dozen small blocks neatly laid out with cabins, larger homes, and buildings that served as workshops, and then a park on the outskirts. The buildings are really well maintained. They're painted. They have signs that show their original construction dates and the years they were restored. And a lot of them are in the 90s and early 2000s. And the town is built surrounding this one large central block. It's a really, really beautiful garden of fruits, vegetables, herbs, and bright-colored flowers. [0:06:23] And it's all meticulously organized into their own sections and rows. And it all surrounds the stump of what used to be a giant spruce tree representing everlasting life. The 12 paths that sort of represent the 12 apostles and all of the different routes to reach heaven spread out from the center of the garden like rays of the sun. So to many of the people, the hundreds of people who lived here at this time for nearly a century, this garden was the center of their very own Eden. But the first question that comes up when you're approaching here and you see this sign: why is there this two-year gap between the town's founding and then the founding of the commune? You know, it implies that there wasn't a commune before and that would be correct. You know, they had to go through a process of deciding to do that. [0:07:21] So we're figuring out, you know, how did they come to Ohio in the first place? Why did they become a commune in those two years? Why was it so successful? And how did it end? [0:07:32] Yes, and all of those questions are going to be answered here. So, you know, sit back, strap in. This is going to be a big one and a really fun one as we go deep into perhaps the closest America ever got to a heavenly kingdom on earth. That being the commune of Zoar, named after a somewhat obscure biblical locale, but founded as a result of 300 years of Anabaptist and pietist agitation in Germany, now transplanted into the New World. [0:08:09] So I think if we really want to understand Zoar, we have to go way, way back to the start of the Protestant Reformation. We've discussed the Reformation many, many times on this podcast, especially in our last episode. But just for a quick recap here, it obviously all began due to the efforts of a certain Martin Luther, a young priest and monk who nailed his 95 theses onto the door of the Wittenberg church. Luther's idea of the Reformation is what's considered magisterial. It was mostly concerned with the deployment of earthly power by church authorities, particularly whether or not it was appropriate to sell indulgences. He had some theological disputes with the Catholic Church, but generally speaking, his arguments were more organizational, really, logistical. Other Protestants immediately emerged in the wake of Luther's protest, who had significantly more far-reaching ideas about theological reform. The most important of these would, of course, be the Calvinists, but even before the Calvinists began shaking things up, there were a group known as Anabaptists, from the Greek word meaning to baptize again. [0:09:30] Generally speaking, the main doctrine of Anabaptism is the belief that becoming a Christian should not be an automatic obligation of anybody born into a Christian society. Instead, to be a Christian is to make a covenant with God, which requires one to make significant sacrifices, abandoning much of the sinful mortal world. Therefore, the only person who can consciously enter this covenant is an adult. Anabaptists thus reject the notion of infant baptism, which was very central to the spiritual lives of all people in early modern Europe, especially when the infant mortality rate was so high. In 1535, about, I think, 17 years after the Reformation began, there were two prophets in the German city of Münster, Jan Matthys and Jan van Leiden, who led a violent revolt against the Holy Roman Empire and maybe even against the material world more broadly. The two Jans hoped to build a new kingdom of David in the German Rhineland, which would be such a beacon of piety and selfless living that God Himself would return to his children and wash away all sin. [0:10:51] It was an explicitly apocalyptic, revolutionary program. Unfortunately for the two Jans, neighboring princes had other plans. An invasion by the local Catholic bishop led to the first Jan being dismembered in front of his family and followers, and the second Jan was left to rot in an iron cage that still hangs from the Cathedral of Munster to this day. The Anabaptist movement, which was already illegal, was now almost completely eradicated within Germany. Anabaptism moved up into the Alps, where geography had always allowed religious dissidents to thrive, as well as down into the Netherlands, which was technically part of the Holy Roman Empire, but was quickly moving toward independence and was quickly becoming a real bastion for religious tolerance. A group in Switzerland, conveniently known as the Swiss Brethren, wrote the earliest formal tract on Anabaptist theology, known as the Schleitheim Confession. This insisted that baptism was a holy covenant with God, therefore could only happen to a willing and believing adult. [0:12:00] Those who have consciously repented, turned away from sin, amended their lives, and believed that Christ had died for their sins. The confession also insisted that true Christians should leave the world behind. There can be no fellowship with the wickedness of this earthly world. Therefore, there can be no participation in the organizations, works, church services, meetings, or civil affairs of those who live in contradiction to the commands of God. And this was central to another Anabaptist principle, which was non-violence. Because not only was violence rejected by Jesus in the Gospels, but the use of force, including the use of force to defend one's own life, was seen as an unnecessary attachment to the material world rather than to the world of God. So, just to clear something up, the Zoarites we're about to describe were not technically Anabaptists. However, the ideals of the Schleitheim Confession would be taken up by many different radical Protestant sects across the next several hundred years, including those at Zoar, as well as groups such as the Mennonites, the Quakers, both of whom we're going to discuss in more detail right up here. [0:13:14] Many of these groups did not identify themselves as Anabaptists, but I personally think if it walks like a duck and if it rejects infant baptism like a duck, then it's a duck. So, for this reason, historians often use the terms Anabaptist and Pietist as synonyms, even though these are different movements that emerged in different places at different times. For a quick crash course in a later Anabaptist history, up in the Italian Alps, a militant Protestant reformer named Michael Gaismair briefly turned the region of Tyrol into a utopian commune, not unlike Zoar just a few centuries earlier. After failing to convince the Doge of Venice to form an alliance with him against the Holy Roman Empire, Gaismair was ambushed and killed, but his followers remained outlaws and spread Anabaptist ideology throughout much of Central Europe, from Tyrol up into Moravia, the Czech Republic. A man named Jakob Hutter, who may have once been one of Gaismair's followers, preached complete nonviolence, even opposing self-defense against one's oppressors. [0:14:25] Expectedly, this led to the Hutterites, his followers, being kicked across Europe like a hacky sack for the next 400 years. Meanwhile, the Low Countries, which were always a hotbed of radical Protestant ideology, here Anabaptism was still going pretty strong. But in the wake of the failure of the Münster Revolution, Anabaptists began moving away from violence toward political quietism, church separatism, and sometimes even social isolation. And again, we talked about all of this in our previous episode on Utopian Communes. It's all coming back here. The transformation of Anabaptists from violent revolutionaries to pacifist farmers with funny beards is mostly the result of one man, Menno Simons, the namesake of the Mennonites. He was a former Catholic priest, just like Martin Luther, and he claimed to have once been so devoted to the obscurantist doctrine of the church that he never read the Bible until he was formally a priest, because he was worried that, you know, it wasn't proper for a lay person to study the scriptures and he might draw the wrong theological conclusions. [0:15:34] When the Reformation exploded in 1517, Menno saw many of his neighbors adopt radical Protestant beliefs like Anabaptism, for which some of them were actually executed as heretics. But when Menno flipped through the Bible to see what they had to say about the issue of infant baptism, he was shocked to say the Bible says nothing at all about that. His own Catholic Church was killing people over what he realized were trivial questions of ceremony and ritual, not important questions over the nature of God. This all became personal in 1535, when Menno learned that his own brother Peter had become an Anabaptist and took part in a violent assault on a monastery inspired by what was happening in Munster. When they failed to take this monastery, 90 men and women, including Menno's brother, were executed by church authorities. This caused Menno, now about 40 years old, to formally leave the Catholic Church and join the Anabaptists, but with the major asterisk that he condemned the kind of violence associated with Anabaptism. [0:16:41] He fled the Netherlands up into Holstein, at that time part of Denmark, and spent the next 25 years writing Dutch pamphlets on Anabaptist ideology that frustrated any attempts by either Catholics or Lutherans to stamp out this religious movement, and also pretty successfully and conclusively reoriented Anabaptism from revolution by the sword towards complete pacifism. After Menno died, his followers, the Mennonites, formed isolated agrarian communities in northeast Germany, at that time part of Prussia, and then moved on from Prussia to Russia. Eventually, many of them would settle in the Americas. Meanwhile, in the free cantons in Switzerland, Anabaptism was able to grow and prosper. One illiterate farmer named Jakob Ammann broke off from his Swiss brethren, partially over the question of how much of the material world would be rejected. Ammann's followers decided to reject pretty much all of the material world, and in the early 18th century, they formed probably the only ascetic utopian movement that still exists in America today. [0:17:50] These are the Amish. [0:17:53] Now, we're getting pretty close to the 19th century and the start of the Württemberg pietists, who would eventually found Zoar. But while we're on the point of the Amish, just curious, Jern, how much do you think the Amish can be considered a parallel with the Zoarites? Did they have similar ideas about clothing or technology? [0:18:17] The Zoarites wore really simple clothing, but I think a lot of that was the fact that they just made everything themselves. And as an economic point, they really stressed this kind of self-sufficiency. Their beliefs in the church were really more about running from like a church and state linked together that they thought was oppressive. [0:18:41] Oh, yes. And just a little side note here. We mentioned in our previous episode that the idea of separation of church and state, which today seems like a very secular principle, was really a deeply, a very important religious conviction in this era because many deeply religious Protestants feared that any worldly authority would corrupt the church. Therefore, church and state had to be separate. [0:19:07] And as far as technology went, they were actually quite modern as far as the 1800s went. You know, they had mills, they had an ironworks, you know, they mined their own iron, made it into pig iron. They had a tin shop, and they went out to big cities and bought modern conveniences like coffee shipped in and stuff like this. But one of the exceptions to this would be some of their farming practices. So, they had a reaper and a threshing machine in the 1870s, but they still went out of their way to harvest a lot of grain by hand. And they would take it, you know, with a cradle and then beat the chaff with a flail into their last days in the 1890s. But this was so that they could harvest the straw for the signature hats that was sort of a touristy selling point of them. [0:19:58] So, I guess it's you know, they would they might have had some elements of their lifestyle that was archaic, but it was really because of this idea about simplicity, not because they were deliberately trying to live like people in the past. [0:20:10] Yeah, exactly. [0:20:11] A lot of the the colors they used was done with a woad dye that they made into a blue that locals knew as Zoar blue. So that was a very familiar color to people in the area, yeah. [0:20:26] And so, so, were the Zoarites like immediately distinguishable from like Anglo-Americans around them? [0:20:31] Absolutely, yeah, they dressed like German farmers, they're the only people who have these like wide-brimmed straw hats. So they were they were definitely like a thing to see as a tourist. [0:20:44] So to kind of go back to the Anabaptist forerunners, just to kind of finish that off, basically, I would say, generally speaking, by around the year like 1600 or so, Anabaptism was around in many places, but only in these small communities, many of which would eventually migrate to the Americas, like the Amish, like the Mennonites. Everybody knew about Anabaptism, but it was still generally illegal in most places, so Anabaptists had to operate under the radar. They were a genuinely persecuted sect. They experienced a lot of pretty horrific hardship. And constantly, people who were identified as Anabaptists were put to death for their beliefs, often put to death in pretty horrible ways, just like we saw with Jan Matthys and Jan of Leyden. This meant that you began seeing this strong interest in martyrdom develop, because across the 16th, 17th, and 18th centuries, many Anabaptists really were killed for their beliefs. [0:21:48] Sometimes they were also killed for more political reasons, especially because they would always refuse to join the army in times of war. So there was a lot of, you know, a lot of conscientious objectors being killed for disobeying whatever government was trying to draft them. But again, like the persecution was real. And the one place in which this persecution did not really happen was in the Netherlands, this early hotbed of religious toleration. Instead, many Anabaptists in the Netherlands would publish detailed and gruesome tracts about the martyrdom of Anabaptists elsewhere. Probably the most famous of these was Dirk Willems. He was a Dutch guy in the 1560s who was arrested for his Anabaptist beliefs but broke out of jail. He trekked through the countryside on a freezing winter day to escape. And remember, this was during the Little Ice Age, one of the coldest periods in recorded history. [0:22:45] Dirk's prison guards chased him through the wilderness, but while crossing a frozen lake, one of his pursuers plunged through the ice. Dirk Willems could have kept running, but instead, he was so empathetic, he turned back to rescue this guy. And so after drawing himself off, this guard then took Dirk back to the jail and had him burned at the stake. I think most of us would say that in hindsight, Dirk Willems made the wrong call. You know, he could have just kept running and lived a long and happy life. But in the minds of many Anabaptists, living a long and happy life was absolutely not preferable to dying a martyr's death and entering the kingdom of heaven. Many of them really believed that the end of the world was close at hand, so it wasn't worth relying on any kinds of material attachments, including your life. [0:23:40] Additionally, many Anabaptists were aligned towards something called chiliasm. This is a belief popular in early Christianity that the end of the world would involve a literal kingdom of God returning. God would physically rule as king over earth, and his saintly elect followers, the only true Christians, would enjoy material rewards. The idea that being a good Christian could lead to these eternal material rewards was somewhat troubling to a lot of early Christians. So this idea, chiliasm, was generally ignored or suppressed by Catholics and mainline Protestants, but it was resurrected by the Anabaptists and is something that I think contributes a little bit to the pietists of Württemberg, who would eventually found Zoar. Any thoughts on the kind of apocalypticism element before we get into the Württemberg Separatists? [0:24:41] Yeah, as far as the Zoarites go, I don't think they really believed that much in like a physical kingdom of God coming down from heaven, and everyone will see God and He's going to tell everyone to be nice. And they saw the coming of this new world as really something that came within themselves and that they had to build themselves. But as these guys develop from being this Württemberg separatist group to becoming the Zoarites in America, they have a lot of prophecy that guides them. And this really becomes sort of a recurring theme in their history. A lot of sort of mystical signs from above. [0:25:32] All right, so let's get into the actual guys who had found Zoar themselves. [0:25:36] They came from the German state of Württemberg, which is roughly pretty contiguous with the German region of Swabia. And we're going to kind of use both of those as synonyms in this episode. Swabia is directly adjacent to Switzerland, which means that because Switzerland was such an Anabaptist and Calvinist hotbed for so many centuries, radical Protestant ideologies would often pretty quickly find their way into neighboring Swabia and Württemberg. Around the end of the 18th, beginning of the 19th century, there was a big resurgence of Anabaptist style thought in Swabia and Switzerland. This was, strictly speaking, pietism, which it was the term that these people used for themselves. It's very similar, pretty much identical to our purposes, for Anabaptism. It's just that these people did not consider themselves to be Anabaptists, despite the great similarity in beliefs. The upswing in pietism around 1800 coincided with this extremely turbulent period in European politics as the continent quaked in the aftermath of the French Revolution. [0:26:50] We touched on this recently in episode 105, but this episode and the ensuing regional wars brought the modern world right up to the doorstep of many rural isolated villages, including in the highest cantons of Switzerland and the most remote forest towns of Swabia. And the modern world rarely had the courtesy to knock before entering. Revolutionary Enlightenment values had a mixed reception in Switzerland and Swabia. Rural German-speaking peasants were pretty enthusiastic about the idea of individual liberties, but were skeptical of rationalism and often violently disdainful of secularism. They did, however, cherish the separation of church and state because there was a widespread fear that holy institutions would sully themselves by taking on worldly responsibilities. This is the opposite of the modern secular interest of the separation of church and state, in which we fear that the government would be corrupted by the church. It's kind of a funny little difference there. [0:27:53] One group of pietists in the Duchy of Württemberg and Swabia began circulating much older literature by the apocalyptic mystic Jakob Böhme, who wrote way back in the early 17th century during another brutal fracture point in world history, the Thirty Years' War. Just like John the Revelator, who wrote the book of Revelation a millennium and a half before him, Böhme preached about the coming end of the world, which would involve the construction of that heavenly kingdom on earth we've been talking about. These apocalyptic ideas have been at the core of Christian teachings since the days of Jesus himself, but the deadline for the end of the world tends to seem a lot sooner when you're living in times of great social transformation. This is exactly what was happening in the early 1600s in Germany, and this is what's happening now all across Europe in the 1790s through the 1810s, as the French Revolution boils over into a 20-year period of continental warfare from Belfast to Borodino. [0:28:55] But really, the spark to light the fire of these Württemberg pietists was not this guy in the 17th century. It was instead a much more obscure figure, a very young and semi-literate young farm woman named Barbara Grubermann, who had her own mystical visions about 200 years later. She experienced catatonic trances in which she felt no external stimulus, not even pain, and in which she had visions of heaven and hell and all the souls contained within. Just like Böhme and so many other German Protestants and mystics, Barbara Grubermann was hounded by church authorities and briefly imprisoned. After some of her supporters helped her break out of jail, she snuck out of Switzerland into Swabia, into the village of Rottenacker, which would be kind of the mothership for the Zoarite movement. Rottenacker was a Protestant enclave within a heavily Catholic part of Swabia, yet ruled over by the Duke of Württemberg, who was sometimes Lutheran, sometimes Catholic, depending on which member of this mixed religion family was ruling the duchy. [0:30:07] On paper, Grubermann was the domestic servant of a merchant family, the Hubers. One member of this family, Daniel Huber, would write these very touching poems about the persecution of pietists during this time. But even though she was employed as a servant, in practice, Barbara Grubermann was quickly becoming the spiritual leader of Rottenacker, edging out the local Lutheran pastor. Across the next decade, Barbara Grubermann began holding secret church services in private homes, including a smuggled-in organ that they brought, turning private homes into these sub rosa churches. She claimed at these meetings that God spoke to her directly, telling her that everybody, even Satan, could be saved one day, so long as they abandoned their attachment to material things and reject the corrupt Lutheran church, which in the minds of these pietists was really hardly any better than the Catholic Church. But in the early 19th century, rejecting the Lutheran Church was a pretty risky gamble. [0:31:19] In the kingdom of Württemberg, that was set up by Napoleon as he duchy becomes a kingdom. [0:31:27] Yes, exactly. [0:31:29] And so they had this state Lutheran church that was intertwined with the government. And part of that was you were required to be going to church. You had to go to the Lutheran church, and they would go and record like attendance sheets, like a teacher, and see who's not showing up. And so they start noticing that, you know, Barbara Grubermann and all of these followers of hers keep skipping church, and they find out, oh, they keep meeting in their houses. So this will not do. [0:32:02] You mentioned that Napoleon would invade Swabia and turn the Duchy of Württemberg into the somewhat larger kingdom of Württemberg. This would have some interesting implications here. I think the first one we should get into is the fact that a lot of these pietists, Barbara Grubermann's followers, they actually really liked Napoleon. Even though he was Catholic, even though he was a Jacobin, which was a very anti-religious movement, they saw Napoleon as delivering them from the sinful Duke of Württemberg, who is now a king. So many of her followers began wearing red, white, and blue uniforms in imitation of the French revolutionaries. But while the Jacobins wore the cockade of the French flag on their hats, the rebels at Rottenacker had their own badges with a seven-pointed star made out of thread, which was the star of Bethlehem guiding toward this coming kingdom of God. One other really funny thing that these guys start doing in this period is they transform the German language basically to be woker. [0:33:07] They abandoned the traditional German plural pronoun of Sie, instead calling everybody du, a more familiar pronoun, to signify social equality. This is exactly like how Quakers in England started calling everybody thou instead of you or thee. It was a sign of familiarity and friendship. Additionally, the Württemberg separatists refused to remove their caps in the presence of aristocrats and officials. This was a crime which led to public beatings in this semi-feudal society. [0:33:41] Yeah. [0:33:41] And we mentioned in our episode on Swiss history that there's a lot of funny implications around caps in German history. You know, oh, you know, one other funny thing about Napoleon is that small numbers of the separatists truly believed that Napoleon was the new King Cyrus or even possibly Jesus Christ returned on earth because they thought that who else would be allowing them to more easily practice their religion. So there was one pietist guy named his son Bonaparte and his daughter Josephine. You know, we're mostly talking about the pietists in the town of Rottenacker because those are the ones who would found Zoar, but this was a pretty widespread movement across the entire duchy-turned kingdom. We should mention that. They existed in dozens, dozens of towns. [0:34:27] Yeah, yeah. [0:34:28] And probably the most important of all of these guys was not Barbara Grubermann. Instead, it was George Rapp. If that name rings a bell, we mentioned in our previous episode that a group known as the Rappites or Harmonists were another German utopian group who came to America before the Zoarites and they founded the town of Harmony, Indiana, which would eventually be purchased, lock, stock, and barrel, by Robert Owen and transformed into New Harmony. But back in the early 19th century, before the Rappites left for America, they were accused of being traitors for sympathizing with the French enemy, leading to riots breaking out against Rappite teaching. George Rapp feared that his life was on the line, and so despite the fact that it was actually illegal to emigrate to America without permission, George Rapp led 700 of his followers to sneak across the border, eventually leaving Germany and the old world altogether for a new life in America as the Rappites or Harmonists. [0:35:33] But their departure meant that the sights of the king of Württemberg then moved to the next largest group of Pietist dissidents, who were, of course, the separatists at Rottenacker, the followers of Barbara Grubermann. So in 1803 and 1804, dozens of Pietists were arrested for alleged treason, many of them held for up to 20 years at the castle of Asperg, which yes is the namesake of a certain diagnosis today. While they were in prison at Asperg, separatist leaders were forced to dig a man-made lake on the king's nearby estate of Monrepos. He demanded that they build for him a stately pleasure garden, but because he didn't want the site of his land to be despoiled by filthy prisoners, they were forced to dig not during the day, but at night, including in the freezing winters in which many of these prisoners died. So in the minds and in the memories of these pietists, they were now exactly like the Hebrews captive in Egypt, forced to toil for the new Pharaoh. [0:36:35] But due to their doctrine of non-resistance, the pietists completely accepted this torment, declining any attempt to escape. Instead of crushing them, this kind of iron-fisted persecution strengthened the resolve of the Württemberg separatists. I think, if anything, this ramping persecution reinvigorated their belief that the end of the world was just beyond the horizon. Because a lot of these guys really did think the end of the world was coming in their lifetimes. This persecution also led to a lot more self-reliance as many people in the separatist community began supporting each other, especially with so many men locked away in jail. Many women had to take on male roles and pool their resources together just to avoid starvation. Strangely, the one person who apparently was not strengthened by this persecution was Barbara Grubermann herself, because she would completely disappear from the historical record during this period. But I know that before she disappeared, she did make a few final prophecies for her followers. [0:37:42] Yeah, there were several, and her prophecies were actually recorded in a book of prophecies that is part of like the Zoar historical records. But one of these from this time in the prison, she prophesies that her followers would go to America where they would have the freedom to worship as they choose, that they would recognize their leader when they saw him, and that they would band together in an organization that would become prosperous, which would only last as many years as a man's age. [0:38:18] Yeah, and that's exactly what would happen. It's pretty funny. I guess it would, you know, because it was what? It was a 75-year commune, probably pretty similar to the average life expectancy. [0:38:27] Yeah, it's kind of spooky how close she was to the money there. [0:38:33] Oh, also, one thing that I saw you dug up was that it was actually, it was when so many of these separatists were in prison that they formed their 12 pietist principles, which were not too dissimilar from the earlier Schleitheim confession of the Swiss Brethren Anabaptists. [0:38:53] Yeah, it's 12 principles, and we don't have to get into all of them. You know, there's basic stuff about the Trinity, the fall of mankind through Adam, and, you know, the redemption just coming through Christ. But the more particular things is, you know, they write down their refusal to give people like formal greetings. You know, everyone's in the informal du. And another really particular one is that they claimed, all intercourse of the sexes, except what is necessary to the perpetuation of the species, we hold to be sinful and contrary to the order and command of God. Complete virginity or entire cessation of sexual commerce is more commendable than marriage. [0:39:46] Yeah, and that's something that we didn't discuss in the last episode, but a lot of these guys were really into celibacy, even within marriage. And that's another kind of strange belief that you see in early Christianity as well. I think we briefly touched on, actually, we did briefly touch on it last episode because we mentioned that some of these groups, like the Cathars, would preach complete celibacy. And I think this kind of led to a lot of these heretical groups dying out perhaps earlier than they might have. And I guess, you know, we're moving ahead, very, we're jumping ahead here, but do you think this principle of celibacy, did that limit the Zoarites from growing? [0:40:27] Not really, because part of their development as like an economy and as a local government, they take in a lot of outsiders. Just any old German who's like down on their lot coming to Ohio could live there and be a probationary member, or they could be a tenant farmer working for them. They had a lot of options for people to come in from the outside. [0:40:52] You know, and I guess actually, I guess that's a great segue for the guy who eventually would become the leader that Barbara Grubermann prophesied. He would probably be a much more effective political leader than she was, just because he was able to keep the commune together for such a long time, but he was a somewhat unlikely leader. He himself was an outsider. He wasn't from Rottenacker. He was from another town a few days away. And he was this humble, lame-legged, itinerant craftsman who had worked a few different jobs. He was a pipe maker, he was a weaver, and he was a hymn writer who probably first came to attention because of the songs he wrote, which were explicitly pietistic and explicitly apocalyptic. He was one of the guys who strongly believed that the tribulation of the end times had already begun. He believed that the return of Jesus Christ would happen in just 30 years in 1836, in which Jesus would descend from heaven to inaugurate the kingdom of God. [0:41:55] And so slowly he began to become much more influential because so many other separatists were jailed at Asperg. Any thoughts about him before we kind of move on to the actual immigration? [0:42:06] Yeah, I find his like early history interesting. So he was originally trained as a weaver from his father in the sort of like guild trade system in his home of Merklingen. [0:42:19] The artisans. [0:42:20] Yes, he was a classic artisan. [0:42:22] We love those guys in this podcast. [0:42:23] Yes, and artisans, artisans will be coming up lots more. So he also briefly worked as a teacher for a couple years. And, you know, that kind of plays into him being this preacher and leader figure. So in 1804, he becomes a citizen of the city of Ulm, and he was registered as a master in the Weavers Guild. Later that year, his wife, coincidentally also named Barbara, no relation to Grubermann, dies and he is converted to separatism in this period. So he begins preaching in Ulm and he's harassed by a lot of local authorities while gaining some very loyal followers. His hometown of Merklingen was completely unreceptive to him. So all this is really small-scale, local in Ulm, and Bäumler wouldn't have any recorded history with the larger group based around Rottenacker until a decade later. [0:43:20] We should mention that in 1811, a few years after he came onto the scene, some of these separatists began sort of laying the groundwork for the later commune at Zoar by starting their own very short-lived commune in Württemberg itself. When the duchy became a kingdom, a lot of government positions were made redundant, so a lot of government buildings were vacated. Some separatists took over an abandoned government building and began living there as a commune, sharing all their property in imitation of how they believed the first Christians lived, in accordance with the book, The Acts of the Apostles. Around this time, they probably made contact with the Rappites who were now coming into America. Most likely, the guys who remained in Württemberg were hearing about the kind of utopian communal experiment of the Rappites in their towns of Economy and Harmony in Pennsylvania and Indiana. [0:44:17] Things were very difficult during the Napoleonic Wars, and things really came to a head at the end of this period in the infamous Year Without a Summer. This was in 1816 when the faraway Indonesian volcano of Mount Tambora exploded, shoving so much ash and dejecta into the sky that sunlight was basically completely suppressed, with huge ramifications on crop growth and therefore crop yields all across the world. Economic disaster hit the new kingdom of Württemberg, and it was suddenly really difficult to find work, especially because there were so many returning soldiers now that the wars had ended who were competing for agricultural jobs. This was never a good situation for any government, but the king of Württemberg, realizing that he had too many problems to deal with, relieved the ban on emigration to let these troublesome separatists leave the duchy, or sorry, leave the kingdom, therefore solving a political problem as well as this dealing with this economic problem of massive unemployment. [0:45:24] Now, the pietists, the separatists, whatever you want to call them, they were finally able to leave Germany and able to truly separate both from the Lutheran Church and from all worldly sinful society to found their own community. But before they left Germany, they tried one more attempt to start a commune in the old world. This was at the estate of Brandenburg, no connection to the state of Brandenburg in eastern Germany. This was an old castle owned by a member of the Fugger family. If that name rings the bell, these were the, this was a very old family of financiers who were very important in the early days of the Reformation. A group of pietists purchased this abandoned estate and came very close to using this land as the site of a new commune, similar to the one they tried to do in Rottenacker. However, the king refused to let the deal go through. [0:46:22] Do you know exactly why it didn't work? [0:46:24] Yeah, yeah. So what happened essentially is this estate goes up for sale and they get a straw purchaser, this guy from Ulm, actually, Christman of Ulm, who is a prosecutor. [0:46:38] Christman, interesting. [0:46:39] He goes, yes, yes, yes, with two ends. But he goes and buys this estate for them and lets them live. But they didn't really have the legal right officially to live there. So they're on this estate bought by Christman and they are petitioning to the king: hey, can you please let us live here? Hey, can you please let us live here? And they just get no response. One of their letters just gets ripped in two and sent back to them. They get their hopes up when the king at the time dies, but his son also does not respond to them. So at a certain point, they realize that we need to go and actually separate ourselves. [0:47:21] Yeah, yeah. And again, so we've been calling these guys separatists this whole episode because they separated from the Lutheran church. Now, just like the Rappites, they were separating from German society and really from civilization altogether. You know, one thing that I know you pointed out is that, so the Rappites, they would go to way out west into Indiana, which in the early 19th century was the Wild West. Indiana was somewhere that Europeans had never even heard of. [0:47:50] The wilderness. [0:47:51] You know, Ohio was remote enough. Indiana was crazy. It's even further west. For this reason, the Rappites didn't last very long in Indiana. They were uncomfortable being so far from any other settlements. The Owenists were less daunted, and so they took up this land. But the Zoar, but then after a few years, they also abandoned it. The Zoarites, however, they would have the most resolve of any of these guys because they would find this very remote part of Ohio to settle in and they would successfully settle there for the next 75 years. A lot of this would be due to the strong political savvy and charisma of Joseph Bäumler. But also an interesting element was the intervention of the Quakers, another one of these groups who don't have any direct theological connection with the Pietists, but are still kind of part of this Anabaptist Pietist tradition with a lot of similar ideas and similar goals. [0:48:58] Yeah, so with nowhere else in their home country left to run to, the Separatists finally make the decision to make the journey to America. And they had to do that with the help of some friends, the Society of Friends, that is. [0:49:12] Yes, because actually, although we associate the Quakers mostly with Britain and the United States, there were in fact some Quakers in Germany who quickly put them in contact with a British Quaker named William Allen, who organized a lot of the money to help send them to Philadelphia. Philadelphia and Pennsylvania more broadly were, of course, founded by Quakers about a century before the time of the Separatists. And so it was kind of a natural embarkation point for this community. William Allen was a Quaker philanthropist. There were a lot of these guys. And one of the causes he was involved with was actually New Lanark. If you remember from our previous episode on utopian communes, New Lanark was this experimental factory largely run by Robert Owen before he came to America and founded New Harmony. It was an experimental factory in Scotland using modern methods of efficiency with a big interest in quality of life improvements, giving the workers education for their children, dancing lessons, relatively humane hours, all that kind of stuff. [0:50:24] William Allen was an investor in New Lanark, and although he was a Quaker rather than an Anabaptist or a pietist, he identified the Württemberg Separatists as his own co-religionists. However, the differences in their ideology did become stark once they arrived in Pennsylvania. [0:50:45] Yeah, so the journey to America was very difficult and it had a lot of delays and detours that made food scarcity and disease a huge issue among the ship. Bäumler suddenly became really, really important to the group in this time because he had a deep knowledge of like pietist teachings, so he was able to preach to them and he was also a practicer of homeopathic medicine. [0:51:12] Yes, I'm curious. I know when I saw that in the book that we read, I'm very curious what that meant and how that helped here. [0:51:19] Yeah, I think there's a lot of diseases, honestly, in this time. That the best treatment you can do is just, you know, keep people feeling safe and secure and make sure they get a lot of fluids in them. And so if you're taking this, you know, like homeopathic medicine, which is just diluting everything in a bunch of water, like, sure, that'd probably help someone, some people. [0:51:44] After the journey, they landed in Pennsylvania, where they were initially housed by the Quakers in a philanthropic hospital where they were treated for the various illnesses they'd acquired on the journey. A guy named Thomas Cope, hilarious name, organized a community of, organized a committee of the Quakers to find jobs for all these German newcomers. [0:52:08] Yeah, so while all of these people are working for a few months trying to get themselves on their feet, the Quakers had also raised a bunch of money for them. Bäumler, without really consulting with the Quakers, but acting on behalf of the separatists, goes and buys 5,500 acres of land in the Ohio Valley along the Tuscarawas River from a Moravian land dealer. This same land was offered to the Rappites, who had already been in America, but they had rejected this offer previously. [0:52:47] Yeah, and just because this is so confusing here, just want a little quick clarification: Moravian here does not actually refer to somebody belonging, somebody from the Czech region of Moravia. It instead means somebody belonging to the Moravian church, a Protestant group that we discussed in our previous episode. [0:53:07] Yeah, lots and lots of different groups, sites, and eons, and all kinds. [0:53:15] Yes, yes. [0:53:16] Yeah, yeah. [0:53:18] And so, interestingly, the Rappites are coming here again because they had refused to buy that land before. You know, because the Rappites were not as successful as the Zoarites, I wonder if they should have tried this parcel of land instead of the land in Indiana. [0:53:33] It was good land. I mean, the Zoarites had a lot of success with it. [0:53:37] Yeah, yeah, no, as you know, you've been there. [0:53:39] Yeah, yeah. Yeah, and so I think it was $3 per acre, which I think was not cheap back in the 1810s money. But they had a payment plan that gave them 10 years to really get off their feet. The deed was solely in the name of Joseph Bäumler, who had recently anglicized his name as Bimeler, which I guess we'll call him the episode. And this land actually would remain solely in Bimeler's name until his death, like 30 years later. [0:54:10] So, however, I think that Bimeler's sole authority over the Zoarites before they came to Zoar was already raising alarm bells among some of their neighbors, especially the Quakers. I know that Thomas Cope was not too happy with Bimeler. [0:54:26] Yeah, so in his letters, he shares a lot of opinions about these separatists. One says, The committee began to entertain strong suspicions that Joseph Michael Bäumler had exercised an undue influence and command over the rest. He stated his determination to remove the whole in a body to the west of the Ohio so late in the season. He accused him later of being a despot. He called him an artful man and another Moses, which is a recurring theme in Bimeler's life. And by the 1820s, once they had already moved over, he started asking Cope to give him the entire sum of money that the London Quakers raised for them so he could build a mill. This was rejected, and the money was divided up between the separatists evenly. He also wrote that we found they entertained scruples respecting the eating of swine's flesh and had notions on the subject of worship with which we could not accord, and we were informed would not allow their members to marry, although their leaders denied the fact. [0:55:33] Why? [0:55:34] It's the celibacy, yeah, coming in again. Yeah, and this part about swine's flesh is pretty important. They did not eat pork. [0:55:44] Yeah, yeah, no, and that's something also you see a lot with radical Protestant groups is this big interest basically in Judaism. And I assume that has to be what's going on here. They're taking in elements of the old covenant that all other Christians had left behind. [0:55:58] Yeah, it's like in a way they kind of view themselves as like a new iteration of the ancient Hebrews. And they're like, you know, we suffered under this slavery to the king. [0:56:07] Yes, yes. No, and this is something that's kind of part of all Christianity is this idea that, you know, Christianity is this supersession of the Jewish covenant with God. It's the new covenant, the New Testament. But after the Reformation, a lot of these radical Protestant groups believe that no, no, to be a Christian, to sign this covenant with God, you have to do much more than just proclaiming yourself to be a Christian. You have to do adult baptism rather than infant baptism. And often you have to do things like adopt elements of Judaism, like sometimes abandoning pork and sometimes even adopting circumcision, which of course is very popular with American Christians today. [0:56:50] And so while all of this is happening, Cope still admitted: quote, most of them while here conducted themselves soberly and steadily. We are of the opinion that there are among them many innocent and valuable people. So, you know, while they still had these tensions, they were still pretty amicable. And so with the land that Bimeler went and purchased, the separatists started making their way in late 1817. [0:57:18] Yeah. [0:57:18] So I've got here, I've got a lot of letters and sources and stuff to read about this because Zoar is very well documented and there's just not been a lot of academic work written about this. [0:57:30] Yeah, no, and the cool thing is because, dude, you live right there. You're proximate to a lot of resources about Zoar that you were able to gather for this episode, which is really cool. [0:57:39] Yeah, and I've, you know, gotten to visit, talk to the historical society people to talk about their journey to Zoar, which is, you know, has a lot of religious connotations with the Exodus. [0:57:52] Yeah, no, so you know what? Let's, we haven't even gotten to that. Let's talk about what even is Zoar. We haven't even mentioned this. So obviously, Zoar is the name of this commune founded by these German separatists. It's a strange word. You might be able to recognize that it sounds kind of biblical. It's very, you know, it's very kind of exotic in the sounds. Zoar is Hebrew for small place. I'm not sure if anybody who was part of this community knew the etymological significance, but it does seem to kind of point to their ideas about simple living and humility. But more importantly, Zoar in the book of Genesis is this obscure location where the biblical patriarch Lot is sheltered after the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah. So, you know, by calling their separatist community Zoar, the implication there is that the rest of the world, whether Philadelphia or Württemberg, is Sodom and Gomorrah and may in fact soon be washed away in apocalyptic flames, just as Sodom and Gomorrah had been. [0:58:56] Yeah, and on the same theme, in their religious writings, they really love talking about Babylon, as many Christians of various types are wont to do. But yeah, the sort of influence of the outside world and this oppressive church is the great Babylon to them that is to be thrown down. And so they don't name the place Zoar until they arrive there. [0:59:21] And so I think we can go and talk now about what the trip there was like. If you want to read this, this is a section from the writings of Alexander Gunn, who is a man who's going to become very important in the end of the Zoar story. He was a wealthy outsider who knew the Zoarites in their last days. He spent a lot of time in the town and was very fond of the people there. And so he wrote down a conversation he had with one of the founding members, Michael Miller, about their migration from Philadelphia. Old Mike told me today of the time when he first came to Zoar. His father was left behind and sick. His mother, with her two children, Mike, age 12, and his younger sister, came on through the woods alone. The wagoner who carried them from Pittsburgh left them as agreed at Sandyville, three miles from here, then a wretched settlement of log huts in the woods. [1:00:15] It was a few days before Christmas, 1817. Old Mike told me how his mother sat down on a log and burst into tears. Far from home in a strange land, a trackless wilderness, no place to shelter her children. No wonder Mike says men were kinder in those days, for a man with a bushy beard and butternut-colored homespun clothes came up and asked her what the trouble was. She told him, and then he asked, Well, can you spin? And she said yes. So he offered her a home until she could get settled with her own people. And then old Mr. Roof, who was with the first party of families in 1817, said the first night in the beginning of December, they slept under a large oak tree near where the log church is today. The next day, they made a tent-like hut of poles covered with leaves and earth in which they burrowed. [1:01:05] The weather during December was fine, and they built nice cabins of logs. There, upon their arrival, they named the town Zoar, as a reference to Lot's shelter in Genesis. And then we have a quote from Jacob Sylvan, who was one of the original members who led the group in the end of its existence after Joseph Bimeler died. So he was reminiscing 30 years prior and said that throughout this year of 1818, there was as yet no communal sharing of goods, and each individual lived for himself. But it was found that this would not work, since there were destitute old people who were too poor to buy a little piece of land and too weak to feed themselves. Others, capable of work, were forced to work for the Americans in order to get by, and this impeded the work at home, which was not making headway. [1:01:53] So, you know, clearly that these guys are trying to separate from the material world, but they're still finding themselves being employed by American Protestants. Kind of kind of interesting. They're not able to actually separate as much as they wanted to. [1:02:05] The first person to suggest a community of goods, in German, eine Gütergemeinschaft, was Johannes Breymaier, who lived with the Rottenacker separatists and actually had spent 12 years imprisoned in Asperg Castle. He, along with Joseph Ackermann and August Huber, a member of that family that sheltered Barbara Grubermann way back, they drafted and signed the Articles of Agreement to officiate the process of holding their goods in common. Again, this is something we see over and over with these radical Protestant groups. This is something that they had briefly toyed with doing in Württemberg itself, all based on a couple lines in the New Testament about the first Christian apostles holding their goods in common. Joseph Bimeler, who remember had the sole title to this land, was initially not too happy with the idea of this early communism. But when he realized it's what the wider group desired, he acceded and allowed for Zoar to become yet another utopian commune, not just a regular town. [1:03:11] To pay for this land, the separatists were granted a contract by the local Ohio government to complete a section of the Ohio and Erie Canal, which would actually run straight through the town, or at least quite close to it, and fully integrate Zoar with the wider local community. And I just gotta say, I think that's a really funny contradiction here. These guys are doing whatever they can to separate from the sinful society of mortal men, yet they're finding themselves on this major trade route that would actually really benefit them financially. [1:03:43] Yeah, and so about this articles that they sign, we don't have to read all of them. There's like seven small sections, but the point about sharing, I think the wording is interesting. Each and every member does hereby renounce all and every right of ownership of his present and future movable and immovable property and leaves the same to the free disposition of the directors of the society elected by themselves. And so these directors of the society they're forming become the new government, essentially, and the people who can decide what to do with all of this capital that they've pooled. [1:04:25] So we can go in and flesh out what this early government looked like in Zoar. [1:04:30] Just like what we see with the government of New Harmony under Robert Owen, they separated their industry into different committees, each led by a trustee. There was the trustee of agriculture, the trustee of industry, and the trustee of livestock. I think a note here on practicality, I think it was smarter that they focused everything on food production and trade, because at New Harmony, it seems like a lot of their efforts were actually instead focused on education and literature, which is a very noble pursuit, but unfortunately, not as essential to actually running a surviving commune. I think it's no coincidence that Zoar would survive 75 years, New Harmony would survive just a couple. [1:05:13] Yeah, and on the note of this struggle to survive, after they put in these first articles together and start figuring out what did the trustees do, how do we organize this? In 1822, they enact a total enforcement of total celibacy. [1:05:31] Yes. [1:05:31] Men and women lived apart in separate houses. There's a house for the men, house for the women, and the children lived with the women. There was one female housekeeper for the men's houses, but besides this, they were totally separated. And this was because they were so poor. They need as many people as they can to be farming immediately, working on the canal. They can't afford to have any of their people taking care of young children. And so it was really only because of this practicality that they decide to enforce what was already part of their beliefs, right? You know, they said we believe it's better for men and women to be celibate, even if they're married. And so they sort of just took that to its full conclusion at this time out of complete necessity. [1:06:18] And then in 1824, they reorganized their government, which created a new three-person board of arbitration that would coordinate work between the three committees. Any purchase above $50 had to be approved by this new arbitration board. Bimeler, unsurprisingly, was the first one to be elected and held this position until his death. [1:06:40] It didn't have to be a board. It was like one to three people. And so Bimeler is the only person to ever hold this position. And when he died, they just got rid of it. So this is the Bimeler position. [1:06:52] Yeah. Yes. And just so there's no question about what his influence was. So he oversaw any major purchases in the town. He also was the cashier who handled all of the money. Every major transaction, therefore, any usage of funds had to be approved by him. And then, you know what? He even made himself the postmaster because why not? So, you know, so in a way, he really does feel like kind of a dictator, even more so than Robert Owen was, I would say. But you know what? I don't think the town was that opposed to this. You know, and like I can see why the Quakers were freaked out by how much influence Bimeler had, but it seems like he used his authority pretty effectively. So I don't think it's really worth, you know, wringing your hands about this guy behaving dictatorially in a small community 150 years ago. More than that. [1:07:45] Anything else you want to share about their government or their economy? [1:07:50] Yeah. So for as far as membership went, it was kind of interesting because you had to be age 21 for a man to be a member, but 18 for women. And it kind of had that, you know, the view of like girls maturing faster. [1:08:07] Yeah. [1:08:08] And also they had so many women that were just a part of their organization that like they had to give them rights. And so women could vote, even though no women were ever elected as a trustee of the society. [1:08:22] And then, you know, initially, men and women, of course, were also forced to be celibate. We mentioned that was a pretty big rule of the community, but only for the first seven years. Do you know why they abandoned celibacy? [1:08:34] Yeah, well, they finished the Zoar section of the canal in 1829. [1:08:40] Yes, yes, exactly. [1:08:41] And so marriages were resumed because they could afford to have people taking care of children instead of digging ditches. [1:08:48] Interesting. [1:08:49] And so that year, there were two marriages, and one of them was Bimeler marrying Dorothy Huber, the daughter of Stephen Huber, another separatist preacher from the German day. [1:09:02] Yes, yeah. And we've only kind of mentioned them obliquely, but the Huber family, they were essential at keeping the separatists together before their migration to Zoar. [1:09:11] And so they go through another sort of iteration of government in 1833. [1:09:17] Yeah, and so just to kind of make this clear now, this is so this is 1833. This is like, what, 17, 18 years after they first got there? So they've been established for a while. There are probably, you know, many children have been born by now in the community. There are people who know no life other than Zoar. [1:09:32] Yeah, like they had industry, you know, like into the early 20s. You know, they had like a remember. [1:09:38] And so this is already a significantly longer lifespan than New Harmony or many of these other communes we've talked about. So in 1833, their government changes and they redefined themselves as a corporation under Ohio law, now officially called the Society of Separatists of Zoar. And so this new constitution added more detail to the previous agreements. There was a new office, an agent general, which replaced the arbitrator role. Bimeler was elected to that position and held it for the rest of his life, of course. Trustees were elected for three-year terms and could be re-elected as many times as members of the society desired. A right of recall was specified for officers, but it was never used during the society's existence. A new group, the Standing Committee, was formed to arbitrate disputes, and these five men were elected for five-year terms and became a training ground for future trustees. [1:10:38] Joseph Bimeler was also elected to this office for the remainder of his life and held the titles of Agent General, cashier, and member of the standing committee all at the same time. [1:10:47] Yes, and don't forget postmaster. [1:10:48] You know, we talked last episode about how like these kind of communes resemble a lot of 19th and 20th century left-wing groups as well, like secular socialist groups. I gotta say, I think the obsession with committees has some resonance there. [1:11:02] Yeah, also like the directors kind of reminds you of like Napoleon's Directory, and then the standing committees is like, oh, it's just like a communist party. [1:11:11] Yeah. One thing, though, is that, you know, like, even if Bimeler might have been kind of a dictator, he doesn't seem to have been brutal in any sense. There is no evidence of any kind of abuse, as far as I can tell, either, you know, punishment or corruption, you know, abuse of his influence going on in Zoar at all. At one point, Zoar was visited by a guy we're going to discuss near the end of this episode in more detail named William Hinds, who was a guy himself a member of a utopian community who went around the country in the 1870s looking at various communes that still existed or had existed in the United States. So, this was long after the days of Bimeler. Bimeler had been dead for over 20 years by now, but the community managed to still hold together in the wake of his death. [1:11:59] And when he went to see what was going on in Zoar in the 1870s, they told him that they never had any principle of punishment, either in the days of Bimeler or after. Instead, if anybody disobeyed the regulations of the society, he was simply not allowed to attend their meetings anymore. And if he continued to disobey, then he would eventually be asked to leave. It doesn't seem like there was any kind of real oppression or punishment. [1:12:24] Yeah, like the most very common type of punishment in the days of Bimeler when he was leading these sermons, although part of the separatist thing is that they did not like saying that they had preachers or that they preached. Like they were completely against clergy. They met in houses. And Bimeler liked to call his sermons his Sunday discourses. And so these discourses are: this is their church. And so during these meetings, Bimeler could go and call out an offending member, ask them to sit in the front pew and talk about what they had done wrong to everybody. And this was called church discipline. So sort of using shame tactics instead of any kind of like harsh force. [1:13:17] Yeah, you know, I think we should say, though, is that it does seem like that the denizens of Zoar were pretty satisfied with what was going on. There was a principle that they could change their constitution with a supermajority vote, but in their entire 75-year history, this constitution was never changed once. [1:13:34] Yeah, and so now that we've covered sort of the government stuff, I'd like to get more into the development of their economy, which is really sort of the lifeblood of the town. [1:13:45] Yes, no, and I think that, and this is really essential to the whole Zoar story because almost every other American commune we've discussed really struggled to stay afloat. Often, like in the case of New Harmony and Nashoba, they went under very fast, largely for financial reasons. Instead, Zoar was very economically prosperous. They were so prosperous, they were lending money to their neighbors outside of the commune. And eventually, I think that their success is kind of what led to the commune dissolving. They were victims of their own prosperity, I would argue. So, because of their proximity to the Erie Canal, they were able to trade widely with the outside world, despite their whole idea being to separate from the outside world. They were very good at farming for whatever reason. They tended to have much better crop yields than their neighbors. Any idea why that might have been? [1:14:41] A lot of visitors to the town sort of remarked on how they had these really distinctly like German farming practices. And I don't know exactly what that entailed, but a big part of their success in agriculture was also the fact that the land that they were on used to be occupied by the Delaware people. And they would do these controlled burns along the Tuscarawas River. And so when the Zoarites arrive in 1817, they have a heavily wooded area, but these sort of river plains areas that had been maintained by the Delaware, and they had an incredible amount of nutrients from all of these burns that had been happening. So as soon as they arrive in 1817, they can just clear out the little bit of shrubbery and get farming immediately. They also, and so in the 1850s, like a typical year for farming, just as like an estimate for what they were growing throughout their history, they had 355 acres of wheat, 70 acres of corn, 219 acres of oats, 62 acres rye, 8 acres buckwheat, 21 acres barley, and 800 bushels of potatoes. [1:16:00] They also grew a bunch of flax, which is processed into cloth. They built a grain mill in 1822 and flour began being sold to outsiders. [1:16:09] Yeah, and as a long time RuneScape player, I know that harvesting flax is a great way to make a lot of money. Also, I love farming is that they also were really into apple products. And so they got a lot of attention for selling, of course, apple cider, which was like the drink of choice until the Civil War in America, but also dried apple chips, which I got to say sound awesome. [1:16:32] These little dried apple slices called snits. [1:16:34] I would love to, I would love to try some apple chips right now. [1:16:38] Yeah, I mean, I found that really funny because I'm familiar with those kinds of apple chips as a part of Amish country. Like that's something you get when you go out there and I get it. Yeah, and I'll get like an alcoholic cider. [1:16:51] Well, no, and again, like there's a lot of similarities here with the Amish, both culturally and theologically, you know, because like in addition to the whole fact that they're both basically part of this Anabaptist tradition, these guys were from Württemberg. The Amish were mostly from the same kind of area, Switzerland and southern Germany. And so a lot of cultural traditions were carried over. One of these actually was the famous like Amish barn raising, where they'll, you know, construct four walls first and then bring them all together. You mentioned that the people at Zoar were famous for being able to build a barn before breakfast. [1:17:24] Yes. [1:17:25] They had these, you know, these similar techniques. The famous Zoar garden you mentioned at the top of this episode was constructed about around 1827, about a decade after they got there, which was both this very beautiful public park, but also an actual productive garden where they grew a lot of fruits for consumption and sale, even with greenhouses, allowing them to have even some tropical and Mediterranean fruits like orange and lemon trees. [1:17:52] Yeah. [1:17:52] And you know, they had, of course, had a whole committee for animal husbandry. And I assume they were probably breeding and selling animals to outsiders as well because they had a huge amount of cattle, sheep. I think they had over a thousand sheep. You know, like they were really, they were really doing pretty well for themselves. [1:18:11] Yeah. And as far as animals went, the thing they really prized the most were the cows. They had 105 milk cows and they also had a lot of pigs also later in their history. [1:18:26] Now, even though they didn't eat pork. [1:18:28] Yes, they didn't eat pork and pigs started being raised once they opened the Zoar Hotel. And so pork was prepared for outsiders. They wouldn't touch it. But as we get into their very late history, a lot more members start eating pork as like as they drift away from their utopian origins, basically. Yeah. [1:18:51] They had very sophisticated methods of cattle rearing that were much more efficient than other farmers in this time or place that probably led to their prosperity. [1:19:00] Yeah, and here's a report from a visitor in 1832 talking about this dairy industry. Besides the great quantities of milk which are consumed daily in the community, partly with coffee, partly in other ways, there still remains so much left over that they're to prepare a kind of Swiss cheese from it, which likewise, for the most part, is consumed by the society. Almost every meal, they enjoy cottage cheese prepared in three different ways in addition to butter. Notwithstanding the considerable quantity of butter which is used in the different boarding houses and part for cooking, partly enjoyed on bread, every year several thousand pounds are put aside and shipped in small casks or vats weighing approximately 40 to 50 pounds on the canal to Cleveland and from there by way of Lake Erie to Buffalo to New York. In this way, the Society of Zoar is amply rewarded for the care which they take of their cattle, for they have plenty of butter and milk all throughout the year. [1:19:57] Yeah, I do gotta say, I think it's nice that these guys were really in their bag or whatever. They were very successful farmers, but they are completely negating their own goals here, it seems like. They're becoming totally dependent and reliant on trade with the sinful outside world. Do we have any idea if these guys recognize that contradiction? [1:20:20] I think the way that they saw it was more of the fact that they wanted to create their own industries and they wanted like that own work to be the basis of their living. So like even if they're selling stuff to outsiders, they're still producing this stuff themselves. And even if they didn't have the trade at the outside world, they could still grow enough food. What this outside money is bringing them is like an ability to buy conveniences like coffee and stuff from faraway places. And also allows them to pay outsiders to do labor for them. And there were enough outsiders around that they due to their proximity to the Erie Canal, they ended up building a tavern for canal travelers outside Zoar and even a hotel in 1833. [1:21:15] And I kind of wonder if this hotel and this increased connection with the outside world might have contributed to the 1834 cholera epidemic. [1:21:25] Yeah, and that is exactly what happened. So in 1834, a visitor to the canal tavern died. So this is someone who had been, you know, working up and down the Erie, and he drops dead in the tavern. His family comes to go and gather his body and his possessions. And this is immediately when the epidemic hits. It comes straight from the canal. And so 56 out of about the 300 residents died, including one of the founders, Johannes Breymaier, who was imprisoned in Asperg and suggested that the commune be built in the first place. 19 of the dead were under age two. So this was a huge, huge hit to the community. You know, like a sixth of them are dead. But because of these practices... [1:22:14] And because they'd done, unlike a lot of the other groups, they didn't struggle that much in their first few years. They had a really successful run, and then suddenly this just horrific disease epidemic. [1:22:26] Yeah, and but it was kind of hard for them to, I think, to acknowledge how insane this was for them because they had all of these beliefs about simplicity and not doing huge ceremonies. So when you know, when people were buried, they didn't put graves on the cemetery, you know, as all were equal in death. You know, their funerals were really simple, they were quick. They would just bury the person and go. And Bimeler in his Sunday discourses would just remark a little about the person. And these little remarks in his discourses would be saved by families, and that would be their version of obituaries. And so from Bimeler's discourse, Sunday night, August 17th, 1834, here's what he had to say about it. You, my friends, may well be excused from asking, but our text for today should be, since the frequent deaths of the past week remind us daily, that the object of our considerations during the last two discourses was this: that we should examine the state of our souls. [1:23:33] And this may very well be the most important and the most necessary today, also, since no man is sure what day or hour he may be called from this early life. So he goes back to this sort of, you know, the end times are near idea of you have to get your soul in order now. [1:23:52] And remember, so this was, yes, and also, this is 1834 now. We are getting really close to the 1836 date that some, not all, of the Zoarites believed would be the end of the world. I'm not sure how they reacted to this end of the world not happening in 1836. I'm not sure if in 1834 they still believed it, but I think that it's fair to say some element of apocalypticism was part of Zoar up until the end. [1:24:20] Yeah, I think part of this is the fact that in their beliefs, you know, their view of what the second coming would be and like the building of this kingdom of heaven on earth, a lot of this was internal. And so they believed that, you know, they were making these changes within themselves. And so I think in their view, by building Zoar, they kind of have inaugurated the second coming already. They are building heaven on earth and they had escaped the apocalypse in a way. [1:24:56] Yeah, no, that's fair. Yeah. Yeah. [1:24:58] And then the closest thing they had to an apocalypse, I guess, would be this cholera epidemic in the 1830s, but they weathered it. They kept going. [1:25:06] And one thing that's interesting is that after this cholera epidemic, they became more reliant, not less, on tenant farmers and hired hands from outside the community. I think some of them, you said you mentioned, stayed on as kind of probationary members of the commune. They were like kind of halfway in Zoar. [1:25:24] So they had a two-tier membership system. First class is the probationary member. So that's actually the lower one. And then second class is where you're like a full citizen member of Zoar. Yeah. So you have to go through this probationary period. You work for at least a year and then the trustees can decide if you are fit to join the society. But some people would work for years and years and never actually be admitted. And so some left from frustration. But there were also some people who stayed on as probationary members and just weren't interested in becoming like second-class full citizens of Zoar. And so they just liked staying how they were at. And these hired hands that become really important after the cholera epidemic. Another thing on this idea of them wrestling with like how integrated should we be with the outside world, they actually pay these hired hands half in cash, but half in credit at the Zoar store. [1:26:28] So like company scrip essentially allowed them to use their own products that they're making to pay people instead of having to be dependent on this cash from the outside world. As of 1834, where we're at, we can do a little review of their industry because Bimeler himself writes about it. [1:26:49] Yeah, no, and yes, yes. And this is something they didn't expect is that these guys weren't just farmers, like basically all of these other utopian colonies. In New Harmony, Robert Owen had tried and failed to set up industry. But these guys at Zoar actually did. These German hicks managed to pull off this autarkic industrial community where they had, let's see, they had a blast furnace, two different hotels, one woolen and one linen manufacturing establishment, two sawmills, one flour mill, one flax mill. They were just doing stuff all over the place. And then by the 1840s, they had their own iron foundries. They were doing like a Maoist Great Leap Forward stuff. They had actual functional backyard iron foundries. And this meant that all the tools they needed for the functioning of their society were produced on site. So that meant that most of what they traded with the outside world was, I guess, surplus, not essential goods. [1:27:49] Yeah. And one of the old historians of Zoar, who we'll talk about later, this guy who is named Nixon, no relation to that one. But he compared Zoar to like a medieval manor. So production was primarily for use and not for profit. Any excess was sold, but only if the needs of the community was met first. Manufactured items, furniture, tin wares, shoes were sold individually, not in bulk. So they would take orders from outsiders to go and like make some tin thing or some iron thing, but they weren't producing stuff in bulk and then selling it out on the market. They're doing specialized orders for people because these are artisans, they're craftsmen. This isn't. [1:28:34] Yes, yes. And so a lot of these people, like, you know, Barbara Grubermann did come from farming backgrounds, but many still were these common townspeople. They weren't peasants. They were independent craftsmen who had skills that would become really useful in this kind of community. [1:28:49] Yeah, exactly. [1:28:50] Moving forward into the later years of Zoar here, Bimeler would die in the 1850s, aged 75. But the community would manage to hold together for about 40 years after his death. Usually his death is seen as kind of the point where Zoar started to peter out, but it would take a really, really long time for that to happen. Another full generation. [1:29:14] It was kind of unclear how he died. I couldn't find out. I think he just died of being 75 in 1850. [1:29:20] Yeah, it's just old age. [1:29:22] Yeah, exactly. Uh-huh. So he's aware that the end is near, and he signs a will on his deathbed that gave away all property of his to the society and actually declared that all of the property that he had ever held had always belonged to the society of separatists. The current trustees, John Grossinger, Jacob Sylvan, and Jacob Ackerman, they were named executors of the will, and it was finally time to tabulate what did Bimeler actually own? What was being transferred to the society? And so the estate was tabulated out. And I can just read this out. The amount collected on book account, $5,200. Amount collected on notes and bills, $6,400. Proceeds on railroad stock, $1,300. Proceeds on state stock, $1,300. Interest on state stock, $300. Bank certificate, $12. [1:30:28] Because so much of the wealth of the community was in his name, I'm not sure if he was really directly benefiting from this wealth or if he was sharing it with the community. But it is kind of interesting that this guy claimed to be an advocate for plain living, like Bianish, was in fact probably one of the wealthier people in the entire United States in the 1850s. [1:30:46] Yeah, and there is sort of this conflict between them see some people seeing him as this dictator who is taking this wealth for himself and lording over all of these people. And you could get that impression if you're visiting the town at the time he was alive, because, you know, he walked with a limp, and so he was actually pulled around in a carriage most of the time. He lived in the biggest house in Zoar, but he also shared this with several other families. And this is where people would gather for his discourses. And so it kind of makes a bit of sense. [1:31:22] Okay, I just crunched the numbers. It looks like he's not as wealthy as we would have thought. His net worth would have been like a little under a million dollars today. So not super, super wealthy, but still a lot of money. [1:31:32] Yeah, and they have all of this productive capacity. And so they can make a lot more stuff than they could just, you know, otherwise go out and just buy with the money flowing out. [1:31:42] And so after his death, in addition to being one of the executors of his will, that guy, Jacob Sylvan, would collect a lot of Bimeler's discourses into this book that would kind of become the Bible for Zoar moving forward in the wake of Bimeler's death. It would be this, you know, collection of sermons that would allow his teachings to survive beyond him. He opens it with this introduction, saying that our loyal departed friend and brother in faith was appointed as the only appropriate and capable person for this position. Not only in his office, but at all times, he offered a worthy example to his little flock and himself practiced and personally experienced everything that he preached to others. But just as for all true servants and beloved of God, so here too, in full and even in excessive measure, this man found himself despised, ridiculed, maligned, and persecuted by Satan, the world, and the children of evil. [1:32:38] Most of all, he was maligned by the unfaithful and lapsed members who were sometimes present, which I assume is a nod to the people who are occasionally voted off the island and asked to leave Zoar. Sylvan continues, Bimeler followed his lord and King Jesus patiently and courageously, bearing this crown of thorns. No one ever saw him despondent, discouraged, or baffled in the midst of the myriad blows of fate that worked against him and our society. Like a good shepherd and hero, he stood before his little flock and protected them when hell's wolf wished to creep up and break in. In truth, one can say, he fulfilled with as much fidelity as it is possible for a human being the office and calling laid upon him by God himself. And so, in the wake of this death, there was a major power vacuum in the community of Zoar. [1:33:28] The town, sorry, the position of agent general was overseen, and the three trustees of the three committees continued to work independently, each keeping their own finances without somebody like Bimeler in charge of the entire community. [1:33:45] The town was still quite successful after his death, and they began using finance more than industry as an economic generator. They became money lenders, which I gotta say is so funny. You know, if you're trying to go as far as you can from the material world and you're just becoming a usurer, I kind of respect the hustle there. But they began loaning money to non-Zoarite farmers, to like, you know, Anglo farmers in the area, which they made a killing off of. You know, I think that so by 1872, this is 20 years after the death of Bimeler, they had like tens of thousands of dollars loaned out to surrounding farmers. And this turn towards financialization is something you see in agricultural communities across the middle and later 19th century in America. We've discussed this a little bit in the podcast before, but this financialization ultimately meant that subsistence farming, which was kind of the dream of the backwoods settler, was increasingly untenable as so many farmers found themselves at the wrong end of a debt trap. [1:34:53] Here in Zoar, these guys found themselves on the much better end of the debt trap. They were the creditors of the nearby struggling farmers, and this new situation of financialization only increased their wealth. [1:35:07] How did the Civil War affect Zoar in the 1860s? [1:35:10] So this period of financialization that we're talking about in Zoar really comes as a result of the Civil War. Because the Civil War goes and shapes the North and creates a lot of the economic engines that sort of put the industrial, like the Second Industrial Revolution, like into full motion. And so during the war, Ohio is really important for being a place where bankers and other people are loaning money to the government. And so a lot of these loans they do to Tuscarawas County, this is so that they can go and pay like returning soldiers. And another way that the Civil War affects them is socially, because, you know, as you remember, these guys are complete pacifists. They do not believe in fighting your enemy generally. You know, this is like the man in the 1500s who, you know, went and rescued his. [1:36:20] Yes, exactly. [1:36:21] Rescued his, you know, capturer from the frozen lake. [1:36:25] Yeah. Yeah. [1:36:26] And so as the Civil War comes, these guys realize that, you know, they abhor slavery because they essentially went through it in the Fortress Asperg when they were imprisoned and forced to do all of this labor. But they also don't believe in warfare. And so this issue ends up really dividing the town. [1:36:46] And we should also mention that, you know, they were obviously staunch unionists because even in addition to their objection to slavery, they were also German immigrants to Ohio, which made them basically the most stereotypical Republicans there could be in 1860. [1:37:01] Yeah, exactly. And so as soon as the modern Republican Party is formed and Lincoln gets involved, Zoar becomes wholly Republican for the rest of their existence. [1:37:11] Yeah. [1:37:12] And so theory. [1:37:13] Yeah, probably, I would assume still to this day. Yeah. [1:37:16] Yeah, definitely. Yeah, there was a Republican to the bad guy. [1:37:22] And so I know that there's one guy that you found named Simon Beuter, who described, who's a Zoarite, who described Zoarite attitudes toward the Civil War in his diary in the 1860s. [1:37:33] Yeah. So, January 1860. Congress has been in Washington for six weeks but cannot get organized. Seemingly all that appears certain is that slavery is a blot of shame that cannot be allowed to stay. June 1860. In both Europe and America, the fires of war are ready to burst into flames. The society of separatists at Zoar is faring no better than the others. Everyone finds fault with others, but not with oneself. So you start to see this sort of fracturing happening. January 1861. Only the sword appears capable of settling the dispute between North and South over the issue of slavery. The insanity of the slaveholders leaves no room for compromise, and the North is not going to give up any of its rights, nor should it. September 1861. Seven of our youth, some of them still underage lads, have allowed themselves to be recruited. This is in direct opposition to our principles and shows that they have not yet made their own. [1:38:36] Three of these volunteers were taken back because they had not reached the necessary age. One withdrew of his own accord, one took off, and there were two still in the army who came directly from our society. And so Christian Miller, who is likely the one that took off in this message, he used his army money to go to the commune of Economy. But he returned to Zoar in 1862. Yes, and at Economy, that was one of the ones founded by the Rappites, who also in 1862 and was labeled as probably a lost cause by trustee Jacob Sylvan. So eventually, in 1862, the Zoarites were approached by the Union government due to the ongoing draft. A letter was posted that said, the undersigned wish to let you know herewith that they intend soon to leave for Cleveland, Ohio, in order to enter the German regiment there. We would not have decided to take this step if it could have been avoided. [1:39:38] However, since there will be a lottery, we wish to enlist now. We know that it is contrary to the principles of the separatists to go to war. But now, but now in this present crisis, in order to contend for freedom and human rights, we feel it is our duty to unite the forces with those who, at the first call, sacrifice all, indeed, their most precious lives, in order to contend on behalf of those who cannot fight for posterity and for a free home. We await the approval or rejection of our appeal, signed with greatest amicability. [1:40:08] So, you know, here it's that they are acceding to the draft because they pretty nobly recognize that the cause of anti-slavery trumps their own personal feelings about nonviolence. And I think that's, you know, I think they do deserve some commendation for that. [1:40:23] Yeah, and this is something that you mostly saw with younger members because these are the people who were going and fighting in the first place. [1:40:30] Yeah. [1:40:31] There was still a very conservative strain in the town, like the older trustees and older members, they were completely against this. And they kept writing to the Ohio governor this letter titled, Reasons Why the Separatists Should Not Perform Any War Duties. So they're asking, please send these guys home. We don't want them there. But 12 to 24 Zoarites did end up joining the army. And that's depending on if you count hired laborers and their children, as well as people who just had close connections to the town in general and did a lot of business there. And so the lasting result of the war, it brings more questions to the town of how Americanized Zoar should be and these experiences of these young guys who saw the outside world. It began changing their views. The development of rail industry also brings more outsiders to Zoar. So by this time, the canal is basically not really in use. [1:41:27] A lot of the business coming from the outside is this new train that's going, and there is a Zoar station that they built, you know, a store adjacent to. [1:41:37] Yeah. So people were coming in from there. [1:41:39] Yes. [1:41:39] And so just kind of connecting back to what we mentioned earlier, this leads to a lot of outside interest in Zoar, including interest from other people connected to utopian communities. And I think that this is where we should bring in the Oneida community. This is so, this is kind of the evil twin of Zoar. It's in many ways the exact opposite. It's a very interesting community. It was less successful, though still very prosperous in its own way. Just like Zoar, it was led by this charismatic preacher. But instead of being a humble German hymn writer, this was a Yale theology student named John Humphrey Noyes, who would found the Oneida community. Oneida was one of many communities in the upstate New York region known as the Burned Over District. This was the same part of upstate New York where the Second Great Awakening had happened, then later where the Millerites, the Mormons, and even Cyrus Teed's Koreshanity had developed. [1:42:41] We discussed this way back in episode 58. It was called the Burned Over District because there had been so many successive religious revivals in this area. It was, you know, it was burned out. There was nothing left. Oneida, however, was an import. It was not founded there because John Humphrey Noyes began preaching in New England. While studying at Yale, he came to the strange conclusion that the end of the world as we know it had already happened. He believed Christ had already returned to Earth back around the year 70 AD, during the time of the destruction of Jerusalem and the Jewish temple by the Roman Empire. This meant that the end times had been going on for about 1800 years. Humans had to adjust their behavior accordingly. Because if we are already living in the end times, then our covenant with God is different than it might be had Jesus not yet returned. [1:43:37] So he began developing these very strange ideas, some of them quite socially progressive, including a strong belief in abolition and gender equality. He emerged as kind of an early Jim Jones figure, in that he was a charismatic preacher who gathered lots of followers, preached a pretty egalitarian doctrine, and of course collected many, often much younger, sexual partners. Noyes was obsessed with his various strange sexual ideas, including for a lot of advocacy for both male and female polygamy. He coined the term free love, which he quickly clarified was actually complex marriage, and he believed that all members of his community should be married to each other. Men and women should both have many spouses. In his idea, probably inspired by Plato's Republic, monogamy limited reproductive fitness by not allowing the most virtuous and most physically strong, or I guess he would say physically vital specimens to mate with each other, including if that meant mating with multiple partners. [1:44:49] He also had very creepy ideas about how young teenage boys should be paired up with widowed women to train them as sexual tutors. Of course. Meanwhile, young girls should be given as virginal wives to the most virtuous men in the community. And of course, the most virtuous of all of them was John Noyes himself, who had many very young women as his wives. He was also a very strong advocate for sex without reproduction, particularly through what he would consider the male retention of essence. Funnily enough, this was something also believed by Chinese Taoists many centuries earlier, now reinvented by this guy. Everybody else in America thought that the beliefs of the Oneida community were shocking and heretical. The reason they had to go to upstate New York is because they were first chased out of Vermont. I think an argument could be made that women in the Oneida community had more personal sexual and reproductive freedom than women living in traditional patriarchal marriages outside of it. [1:45:49] He recognized the principle of consent way earlier than most other people did, but just like with Joseph Smith or with David Koresh, many of his wives were really horrifically young. So after about 33 years of living as a commune, the Oneida community received a tip that they were being investigated by the United States government for statutory rape. Under the cover of night, John Noyes fled across the border to Canada and announced the end of complex marriage in Oneida. The entire community was thus dissolved, and they put their money into private accounts, which were then used to purchase a silverware factory. And amazingly, this company called Oneida Limited is in fact still one of the biggest silverware companies today. But the reason we're saying all this about Oneida is not just because they're strange and interesting. [1:46:43] It's because one member of the Oneida community, William Hinds, was sent as an emissary to visit and learn from other communes across America. In 1878, he collected all of his various observations in his book, American Communities, including brief sketches of his own cohort at Oneida, including other experimental colonies like the Shaker settlements, and, of course, Zoar. The first mention of Zoar by Hinds includes a compare and contrast exercise between them and the Rappites, who founded their own community of Economy before selling the land where Owens had built New Harmony. According to Hinds, the Zoar communists, much like the Rappites, whom they in many respects resemble, came to this country from old Württemberg, during which time was a veritable hotbed of religious radicalism. Both the followers of George Rapp and Joseph Bimeler were called separatists, but the latter were separatists in a double sense, renouncing allegiance to both church and state, considering that they together constituted the Great Babylon, which was to be thrown down as in the book of Revelation. [1:47:56] You know, and as a result of the attention given by Hinds to Zoar, a lot more English-speaking outsiders, as well as German immigrants, were really interested in joining the community. Do you know if many of them actually managed to successfully join Zoar? Because I feel like they were pretty hostile to converts. [1:48:16] Yeah, there were a few that ended up joining, but they did get just so many letters that they ended up having to make a standardized rejection letter that basically said, sorry, we're not taking any new people. Just trying to be as quick and curt as possible. But of the people who joined, they had a few different categories of applicants. You had Germans who had immigrated and were unhappy with America, as they saw, so they wanted to be around people speaking German. There were people motivated by religion who read the Hinds book, as well as another around this time that described Zoar, Charles Nordhoff's The Communistic Societies of the United States, and that was in 1875. [1:49:03] Yeah, because there was a lot of attention given to these guys, like especially not even non-Americans were very interested in these various American utopias. [1:49:11] Yeah, there were quite a few German writers who were interested in this kind of stuff. Yeah. You know, seeing like what are the Germans in America doing? These are some of the few people who are still speaking German, really. [1:49:24] What you mentioned about the standardized rejection letter due to having so many applicants, there was a similar kind of problem in Oneida before they were dissolved because so many sex perverts were just trying to join to get in on that, like the orgiastic action. And so I think one of the ways they scared off outsiders, just a little quick digression here, they had their own version of Maoist struggle sessions where every member of Oneida had to accept, had to listen to like self-criticism from the rest of the community, where people would just, you know, was, right, it wasn't self-criticism. It was like it was external criticism. And you would just let everybody in your community, who again, like all the every woman was legally your wife. Like they were, these were your people you had very intimate relations with, just talking about everything they hated about you. [1:50:10] And apparently this scared off many potential converts. [1:50:13] That's really reminiscent of the stories of a lot of the more recent cases of like troubled teen industry kind of stuff and like their culty practices. [1:50:28] Yeah, that's really interesting. Cultish trends coming all across American history. [1:50:33] On the contrary, of like the all of these sex perverts who wanted to go and join Oneida, Zoar had a problem of a lot of people that were like self-decribed, self-described socialists and communists and various free thinkers who wanted to join. But these people had no idea of the full religious history that these guys experienced in Germany. And so the Zoarites were really not receptive to these types because they just didn't share the history that brought them into being a commune in the first place. You also had in 1873, you know, a huge panic, you know, bank run, big economic crisis. And so a lot of people are down on their luck and are like, hey, I'd love to join the commune. And another group you had was current and former Shakers. These people, you know, had already lived in communes, but were unhappy with Shakerism for various reasons. [1:51:34] And so they just wanted a change in their commune life by going to Zoar. [1:51:38] Yeah, you know, and then the Shakers, the Shakers also had similar ideas about gender to the Zoarites. They were incredibly celibate. And again, this is why I was saying that Oneida is like the evil twin. Instead of extreme celibacy and gender segregation, you have gender egalitarianism with just constant sex. But yeah, but the Shakers, the Shakers were very celibate. And I think that I wonder if the modesty, but not full celibacy of Zoar is what attracted former Shakers. [1:52:09] Yeah, I think that might have been a big part of it because you had some families in Zoar who, you know, husband and wife who lived together. You know, they had kids together in the same house, but you also had other families that just completely lived separately still, like they did in the early days. [1:52:28] That's interesting. See, this is this, and this is a strange Christian idea that you should be celibate within marriage. It's obviously not a very popular idea, but it comes up every so often. [1:52:37] Yeah, and like on the idea of like family and like how children should be raised, you know, Zoar had these boarding schools where children would be sent. And the boarding school, you know, existed for a few decades in the early times of the commune. But, you know, children would be raised, taught about separatism, and they would do sort of like odd jobs as needed. A lot of this was like sort of home industry, you know, like spinning thread and stuff. But the directors, you know, these like trustees had like in loco parentis like legal rights. So they could act as a parent for like the benefit of the society. So they really embraced like raising, you know, raising children with the village instead of just the parents. [1:53:27] And that was a big thing with the Oneida also. It's based on this kind of platonic idea of like the community raising children based on whoever was the most fit to be a teacher or a parent, not just simply whoever was the biological parent. It's kind of funny that even though this is such a different origin, you do see some kind of similar ideas between these different kinds of utopian communities. [1:53:48] Yeah. And so at this time, you have a lot of tourists coming. You have people spending their holidays in Zoar. There's a lot of buildings that are regularly like rented out by outsiders. And so all of these people become more and more pervasive in the community. All these outsiders, they eat pork, and so more Zoarites start eating pork as well because it's, you know, it's served at the hotel. And so you have the world coming to Zoar, and eventually, towards the end, you have Zoar wanting to join the world. And so getting into what we were talking earlier about, you know, people from other countries interested in Zoar, I have a quote here from Karl Knortz, a German newspaper editor. [1:54:39] Yeah. [1:54:40] He was living in America and reporting, you know, for the Germans. What's going on across the ocean? If you want to read this quote. [1:54:48] Through this intercourse with strangers, the separatists are brought into contact with the outer world. And as they see only the favorable side of it, it incites in many of them a desire for independence. They begin to feel that in a communistic colony, the individual is absorbed by the world and must work for it. Therefore, many people who have grown up there leave their quiet, peaceful home to seek the happiness afar of which they are dreaming. Besides, the young people lack the religious faith of the earliest settlers. This wasn't just Knortz just assumed, like, you know, saying us off of vibes. We know statistically that by the 1890s, and again, it's amazing they lasted this long, like hardly anybody else lasted this long as a community, as an intentional community. But, anyways, by the 1890s, less than one-third of the people at Zoar attended church. [1:55:38] Yeah. [1:55:38] Which is crazy because this whole community was founded as a separatist colony of pietistic Protestants. But yeah, like it's hard to conceive of. [1:55:47] Yeah, and this is where you sort of get into the question of like, how necessary was Bimeler for the society continuing? Because clearly, you know, their economic model was doing well and they succeeded, you know, for decades after Bimeler was gone. But no one could really replicate how he preached. You know, when he got up to do a sermon, he said it himself, like, when I go up, when I go up to discuss the Bible, I do not know what I'm to talk about. You know, he said, the spirit work just speaks through me. And so he has this really like off-the-cuff way of doing things that it's really hard to replicate if you're not practicing. [1:56:36] Yeah, no, and that's doing this. [1:56:39] And so after his death, they're just circulating his, you know, published discourses that, you know, Sylvan had put together. [1:56:47] Yeah. [1:56:47] And then that guy, Simon Beuter, you mentioned earlier, he'd become one of the main preachers in Zoar by 1894 at the end of the community's existence. And he was corresponding with one of the remaining Rappites, a guy named John Duss. And he despaired in one of his letters, What is to become of us? The young ones are running away on a massive scale, leaving the old, the crippled, and the lame behind. Nobody wants to acknowledge what is going to happen. The faith has completely died, which is the worst thing that can happen to a society founded on God. The world cannot prevail much longer. And it appears that it has all been started with the communist societies because they are most of all in Satan's way, because they have introduced, even though imperfectly, what is necessary for the whole world. So here he's saying that, you know, we're falling apart because the world is conspiring against us. We're too virtuous. [1:57:39] We, you know, religious communistic colonies, we're so perfect that everybody wants to throw us down in, you know, because they're all following Satan's plan. [1:57:49] Yes, exactly. And a big part of how Satan is creeping into this community is through the introduction of money. [1:57:58] Cash. [1:57:59] Yes. [1:58:00] I mean, I gotta say, it's because, you know, it's funny. They've been prosperous and very, you know, involved in the outside economy since the beginning. I hate to say this is a classic example of get brainwashed of that thing. [1:58:11] Yes. Yeah. [1:58:13] And like the way they handled money was interesting because, you know, while all people's property was like deposited into the society, every person had their own tiny little locker. It was all of these lockers with like a glass door, tiny little things where people could put like cash and like small possessions like jewelry and stuff like this. And so as more and more people are coming into Zoar and staying at the hotel and renting even other buildings and making their holidays there, you have people who like send letters to Zoar like, hey, can you build a boat for like me and my daughter when we come here to vacation? So like more, more and more they're being directed by what outsiders want. And all of these people coming in are giving cash tips to people. And so this is how all of the citizens start accumulating more and more money in their little lockers that they have to keep it in. [1:59:13] Another thing you see a lot more is slacking. Nobody wants to work anymore. [1:59:20] Yeah, no one wants to work anymore. [1:59:22] And to get people to work for really important things that need done, graft becomes common. So, you know, give a bottle of wine to, you know, make someone go and, you know, like finish plowing or whatever if you really need it done. You know, it's kind of a sign of the Gilded Age. We are in the 1890s after all. This is how politics is done at the time. [1:59:47] So in the end, in a sort of poetic end, the person who finally called for abandoning the commune was the great-grandson of Joseph Bimeler, Levi Bimeler. He was the school teacher at the Zoar School in its last years and, you know, mirrored Joseph Bimeler because, you know, he was a teacher for a few years and was a teacher to the entire community for the rest of his life. But Levi begins publishing a newspaper out of the town print shop. They had a print shop, but they had never had a newspaper for the community. [2:00:26] Very surprising. [2:00:27] Yeah, I mean, I guess it was just so small and everyone knew everyone that you could just post a message over by the garden or something. But yeah, this is the first time we have a newspaper. And it gives it a weird name, the Nugitna, which is anti-gun. [2:00:45] Nugitna. [2:00:46] Yes, it is anti-gun spelled backwards. And that is a reference to Alexander Gunn, the guy we talked about earlier. [2:00:57] Yes. [2:00:58] This wealthy outsider. [2:00:59] Who knew old Mike? [2:01:00] Yeah, who knew old Mike, you know, one of the first settlers coming to Zoar as a kid. Gunn spent a lot of his summers in the town, and he was very, very close with the trustees. He was, you know, very loyal to the idea of them staying as a commune, even if a lot of these people are starting to lose these beliefs at this time. And so what I think he's getting at calling this newspaper like the anti-gun, the Nugitna, he's kind of placing Alexander Gunn as a representation of like the idealists of the society. You know, the people who want this thing to keep running as it has always been. And he, and so Levi doesn't really like that. And so the paper had small bits of town news, but was mostly created for Levi to insert a series of editorials arguing for the dissolution of the society. [2:02:00] And the paper was also sold to residents for 10 cents using this money that they're starting to accumulate everywhere. So it's already the people who are using money who are going to be buying this newspaper anyway. [2:02:14] Yeah, and so the first edition of the Nugitna begins with a quote from the Declaration of Independence saying that wherever any form of government becomes destructive for the ends for which it is instituted, it is the right of the governed to amend or abolish it. So here he's saying that destroying this harmonious commune is the same as, you know, independence from an empire. You know, the second edition continues on similar themes, asking, where is the spirit of love now? Where is the bond of peace and unity? Where are the planters and fosterers of the spirit? Gone forever. His solution, therefore, is dividing up the communal property between the various private bank accounts of all the members of the society. [2:03:00] Yeah, and so the third edition of this gets into the idea of equality, and he starts really laying into the idea of the trustees running everything in the town. He thought that it was very undemocratic and didn't make sense in the sort of modern age that they're in now. There was a fourth editorial written, but went unpublished. And in there, he claimed that communism was idealistic, but quote, deadens all push energy and ambition. So it's kind of unclear why he never published this. I don't know if this was sort of a belief that he was kind of waffling on. You know, maybe he was trying to create these arguments because he thought the society should be abolished, but he didn't really know how he felt about some of the particulars. [2:03:52] I think it's really interesting how evocative this is of later post-Soviet kind of stuff or late Soviet kind of stuff. You know, it's like this prefigures like 20th century anti-communism exactly. It's the same kinds of arguments and the same advocacy for selfishness for private property. [2:04:10] Yeah, it is really interesting. And I really would like to know more about Levi and like his early life because I'm kind of curious about like what what experiences growing up in the society would lead him to turn against this you know I think as someone who had the direct connection to the founders and you know knew all of these like really high ideals and history that they came from, I think he might have just been taken aback by seeing it in practice. And he was one of the people noting about this graft and loafing around, so he saw the inefficiencies happening. And so he just thought that, you know, the ideals that they built the society on just weren't being lived up to anymore. And so, you know, what's the point? [2:05:05] Yeah. And I think that, you know, a bigger issue also is, again, just like the Soviet Union, although there was a lot of private wealth held by the leaders of Zoar, the commune itself wasn't making as much money as it used to. And I think it's probably because of this constant graft. [2:05:20] And I think another part of it is just the fact that they were really good craftsmen. They were an integral part of the local economy. But that really changes once we're starting to approach the 20th century and we have these giant factories that are pumping out surplus. These guys can't really compete with that. And so their industries become less important in the local scene. And so they're relying more and more on the financialization that they're doing, you know, all of these small loans that they're giving out to local farmers. But that's not bringing in as much as it was. And so by 1898, two out of three of the trustees had figured that the society would become insolvent in a few years. And so it would be better to just divide up the property now. One of them was still against it, though. And so a resolution was drafted up proposing to do exactly that: divide up the property. [2:06:22] And in an instant, Barbara Grubermann's prophecy we had talked about earlier came true. And I'll repeat that. Her followers would go to America where they would have the freedom to worship as they choose, that they would recognize their leader when they saw him, and that they would band together in an organization that would become prosperous, which would last only as many years as a man's age. [2:06:46] 79 years, pretty decent lifetime. [2:06:49] Yeah, especially back then. [2:06:50] Yeah, yeah. No, she was completely right. And then so, yeah, so after 79 years, the properties of the town were auctioned off, and all the money held communally in Zoar was now divided between the members in shares. Members got a full share, probationary members got half, and any children who had done work were just given a flat $40 payout. Families were given a full or piece of a house and some farmland as well as $200 cash. People in certain special occupations got buildings suited for them, like, you know, the tinsmith getting the tin shop. They pretty successfully transformed this commune into a regular privately owned American town without the kinds of, you know, economic turbulence and destruction you saw in the dissolution of the USSR. But it is, honestly, it's the same process in miniature. It's the first time, it's the first time we're seeing a long-term socialist project be dissolved. [2:07:48] And I think, even though it's on such a small scale, it is an interesting illustration there. [2:07:52] Yeah, there is one story from that that really reminds me of this sort of like end of the Soviet Union days is the woman who ran the bakery was like so so proud when visitors came in and asked her, like, oh, where'd you get this carriage? And she goes, I bought it with my own money. And I'm so proud ever since like, wow, this really was mirrored like 100 years later. [2:08:21] The only one thing not auctioned out was the meeting house. This was originally, you know, this was their version of a church, kind of in the Quaker model. Levi Bimeler, you know, the great-grandson of Joseph Bimeler, he suggested they invite a Lutheran minister, which terrified older members of Zoar. Because remember, the whole reason this community was founded was because they believed Lutheranism was like the church of Satan. [2:08:45] They were doing with everything correct. [2:08:47] Yes, it was like the S. [2:08:49] So instead, they brought in somebody from the German evangelical church of Bolivar, named for the nearest, from the nearby town named after the Venezuelan leader. A lot of great American town names in this episode. [2:09:05] Oh, yeah. [2:09:06] Eventually, they formed the Zoar United Church of Christ, which I guess is not technically Lutheran, but probably much more mainline than the original Zoarites had been. [2:09:19] Yeah, and actually another just small tidbit about funny, funny town names in the area, mirroring how the Zoarites came in with the help of the Quakers. You know, they're going and lending money to Tuscarawas County, and the county seat is actually in New Philadelphia. [2:09:39] Oh, that's a great name. That's great. [2:09:42] So, this was the 1890s. [2:09:44] You know, Alexander Gunn, the enemy of Levi Bimeler, would die not long after Zoar died. But then in the 1920s, there was this renewed interest in Zoar about a little over 100 years after it first been built, as people in Ohio realized, wait, this is a really unusual part of local and national history. We ought to preserve this. So the Zoar Historical Society was founded within the lifetimes of many of the last Zoarites. And that, so former members began searching their own homes for various artifacts that they could use to collect to kind of commemorate this strange early communist experiment in the American Midwest. This is why so many of these documents and the speeches of Joseph Bimeler have been preserved. You know, if not for these last surviving Zoarites collecting their parents' and grandparents' papers, we probably wouldn't know who Barbara Grubermann was today. And she's the woman who got all this started. [2:10:41] Yeah, and part of this recording of history, a very, very important figure, Dr. Edgar B. Nixon. And yes, he did have a brother named Richard. These two, Edgar and Richard, were great-grandsons of Simon Beuter, you know, the Zoarite we had talked about earlier. And he wrote his doctoral dissertation about Zoar at the Ohio State in 1933. Edgar and Richard Nixon together gathered a collection of manuscripts from all over the town that were put into public access archives, and it's now called the Nixon Papers. [2:11:20] I gotta say, really funny. This is a very funny coincidence considering that the other Richard Nixon was himself a Quaker. [2:11:26] Yeah, exactly. [2:11:29] I wonder if Nixon is like kind of popular as a Quaker name. [2:11:34] I don't know, but maybe so, yeah, yeah. But these, so it's these sources that you know come together and become the basis for the book which guided most of this episode. It's really the only full academic book written on Zoar, and it is by the absolute goat, Kathleen M. Fernandez. Huge ups to her. Thank you so much. This episode would not be possible without you. She was the site manager for Zoar Village State Memorial from 1989 to 2004, and she wrote this book to have like a final narrative to present to visitors when they come asking, like, how'd these guys get here in the first place? What was it like? So, if you want to know more, get the book, read it. It's called Zoar, the Story of an Intentional Community by Kathleen Fernandez. [2:12:25] Right. And we discussed this in our last episode with Jackson, but I think part of why I'm so interested in these American utopias is because the entire American project is an intentional community. It's about people from the old world creating a new world in their image in ways they see fit, socially engineering new ways of living in ways that would not have been possible back home in Europe. Sometimes these are very positive developments, like commune, this kind of religious communism or attempts at secular socialistic living, like in New Harmony. It also involves new horrific systems of social hierarchy, like Atlantic slavery, which did not exist in Europe. I think that these guys, these communal groups, whether religious or secular, do seem to exemplify a lot of the most positive values of the entire American project. And so I think in some ways, Zoar, despite the fact that it was founded by these Germans, is one of the most American parts of America. [2:13:25] And I think that, you know, it definitely does say a lot about our history, just looking at this society and especially how eventually it fell. [2:13:32] Yeah, I think you see a lot of mirrors to how like the, you know, as their economy develops, the economy of the whole country is developing sort of in parallel because, you know, these guys were not rejecting, you know, new ways of doing things. They were changing as America changed and they wanted to be sort of a part of that national project, especially after the Civil War. [2:13:56] Yeah. Jern, thank you so much for coming back on the podcast and bringing us so much about Zoar. I knew nothing about this before you brought you mention it. I had seen like tiny references to it in books about other intentional communities, but I had no idea how successful and how interesting this was. I really had a lot of fun researching this and thank you so much for all the amazing research that you did putting this one together. Yeah, this is so great. [2:14:22] Thank you. It was really, really fun to be back writing. [2:14:25] Any closing thoughts here about Zoar or anything that you, Jern, would like to plug? [2:14:30] Yeah, I mean, one thing, if any of you ever do go to visit Zoar, one thing you will notice if you go and visit is that most of the town today is surrounded by this huge levee, like this big earthworks wall surrounding the town. That was actually built in the 40s, and that was because of flooding issues that they had had that was like risking the whole town being just swept away and all of this, you know, historical stuff completely lost. And, you know, they had a time where they were debating, like, do we just move the town to the top of the hill? But people weren't really happy with it. [2:15:13] It was like Patrick Very Patrick. [2:15:15] Yes, yes, exactly. But they eventually settle on just, you know, building this big earthen wall around the town. And so when you visit today, you get the impression that it was actually a lot smaller than it was. But they owned several miles of the countryside around that is now just for, you know, you have homes and suburbs and rural homes, but all of that was the Zoar countryside. [2:15:39] Yeah, like multiple mills. [2:15:41] Yeah, yeah, yeah. And the fact they had so many, like, so much like actual industry, they had like iron furnaces. They had to find on their land. Yeah, yeah. [2:15:49] No, it's, it, they were, they, dude, these guys were playing like Cities: Skylines and they were just killing. [2:15:54] Yeah. Yeah. It's really, really incredible. So if you get the chance, go visit Zoar. The people at the Historical Society are very nice. You can go in the Zoar store and go buy your merch. You know, they've got like Zoar-branded beer and ginger ale or whatever. But yeah, it's a great place. And they definitely need the monetary support that comes there, you know, to keep running. [2:16:21] Yes, yes. You can go and, yeah, you can, do they still sell apple crisps? Can you still buy schnitz there? [2:16:28] I believe so. They have a few different things that they sell, you know, like some pastries and whatever. I think a lot of it is like bought from the outside and just kind of, you know, sold for like snacks for people coming. But they do some festivals every, you know, a few months or so where they'll bring in some like food trucks or whatever. There's a lot of cool stuff to do out there. There's Civil War reenactors who will go and do some stuff out there. [2:16:56] Well, thank you, Jern, for all of this. And I hope all of our listeners will be inspired by the story of these brave Württemberg separatists. And now we'll know the dangers of what happens once you start accepting cash tips for your services in your commune. [2:17:15] Yes. Always remember, you know, stay true, throw down the Great Babylon. [2:17:22] Yes. Yes. [2:17:23] Because if we all work together, one day in our lifetimes, Babylon will fall. And we will build a new world, a new moral world. [2:17:34] That's right there. That's it.