Gladio Free Europe, E116: The Devil in America https://www.gladiofreeeurope.com/episodes/the-devil-in-america [0:00:15] Welcome back to Gladio Free Europe. I am here with Russian Sam. [0:00:19] Hello. We are taking a quick break from our exploration of Florida history to instead look at something equally chilly, that being the history of the devil in American folk culture. This is one of those episodes that's going to cover a lot of times and places, from ancient Rome and Judea up through 17th century Massachusetts and 1930s Appalachia. But I want to start a little closer to home with a time I think all of us remember pretty well. Summer 2020. Americans had been cooped up for weeks in a failed effort to stop the spread of COVID. Protests in Minneapolis over the murder of George Floyd were growing into a worldwide movement for racial justice and police reform. Everybody was getting into sourdough and Steely Dan, and the president of the United States shared a video by an influencer who believed that women's gynecological problems were caused by sex with demons. [0:01:17] This was a crazy time, so I can forgive you for forgetting this one little incident. But on June 22nd, President Trump and several members of his cabinet and family began sharing content from an alternative medical influencer named Stella Immanuel. A legitimate pediatrician and evangelical minister from Houston, Dr. Immanuel amassed a major YouTube following and about 100,000 Twitter followers during COVID lockdowns. She offered alternative diagnoses and treatments, warning against vaccines, which she believed included extraterrestrial alien DNA, and interpreted the condition of endometriosis as a symptom of demonic spiritual intercourse. In the following days, the global press and social media widely mocked Dr. Immanuel for her claims about demon sperm. Donald Trump stepped away from his previous endorsement. Onlookers in Europe and Canada were particularly confused how any educated person in the developed world, a doctor at that, could believe in demons and a literal personified devil. But in the weeks that followed, a small but brave number of American Christian publications came to her defense about these claims, insisting that this was actually rooted in standard evangelical belief. [0:02:33] For instance, Baptist News Global based Dr. Immanuel's demonology in ancient Christian tradition, as well as the modern-day practices of Pentecostal Christians in Africa. Noting that she was born in Cameroon and had studied in Nigeria, this outlet argued that she was reckoning with malevolent pre-Christian spirits that some of her patients or congregants had encountered. The author went so far as to celebrate these churches for not denying the existence of other gods, but instead acknowledging, in accordance with evangelical philosophy, the reality that pagan deities really exist within a Christian demonological framework. I am not trying to say that either Dr. Stella Immanuel or Baptist News Global reflects the views of many modern Christians. Pointy-tailed demons are not a popular topic in 21st century pulpits. But if we turn back the clock just a few generations to the period before mass media and compulsory education, this doctor's ideas about physical demonic interference were practically universal, especially outside more educated circles. [0:03:47] Going back further still, into the early modern period and Middle Ages, the most intelligent people in the Western world knew factually that demons existed and black magic was commonplace. They could prove this through scripture, through strange and distressing events with no natural explanation, and through the testimonies of those who said they'd really walked with Satan, really signed their names in the devil's book. These allegations of devil worship or diabolism often incorporated sophisticated legal and rhetorical techniques. To pre-modern subjects, the devil, Satan, Lucifer, or Old Scratch, was understood as a real and omnipresent antagonist. Not only a symptom of evil, but the inspiration for the most wicked and otherwise incomprehensible deeds possible. Satan interacted with regular folk in smaller ways too, beckoning towards sin and causing everyday misfortunes. The devil was a tempter and trickster who could be defeated through proper Christian prayer and good old American grit. [0:04:52] He was at the center of a spiritual geography that is to most of us today an alien planet. I want this episode to take us back into the minds of our ancestors and understand the implications of a world in which Satan exists. Especially because this perspective is often not taken to account in explaining pre-modern behaviors that today seem shocking or alien. [0:05:18] While venturing through the more distant reaches of Austria-Hungary in the 1880s, Scottish writer Emily Gerard learned from local Romanian speakers that Satan was a more present figure in the lives of Transylvanians than in the circles she knew back in Britain. Her travelogues, which inspired Bram Stoker's Dracula, mentioned that many features of the landscape were known as Devil's Mountain or Devil's Abyss, and that these people believed to be surrounded on all sides by a whole legion of evil spirits. She was amused by the tradition of placing burning coals on the doorstep to keep the devil from entering, and by stories of the Scholomance, a witch's school in which a select few locals, no more than 10 at a time, met with the devil directly to learn the secrets of magic. According to one friend of a friend story, a down-on-his-luck Romanian once went to the apothecary asking if it was true that he sold the devil in a little glass bottle. [0:06:12] He was so poor and desperate, and all his prayers had failed, so his only recourse was to turn to Satan. Both Gerard and Stoker understood these Transylvanian attitudes as primitive, oriental, maybe even a little bit un-Christian. But these same fears of literal and physical demons have thrived among the English-speaking public just a few decades before. And in select pockets like parts of Gerard's native Scotland and the American Appalachian Mountains, these beliefs were still quite vibrant into the 20th century, surviving in local folklore and folk song long after her death. Since the 17th century, Americans have likely thought about the devil more than anybody else in the Western world. The incident with Dr. Immanuel shows that some Americans still have a conception of Satan basically identical to that of their medieval ancestors. But more common is a conception of Satan that is a bit more metaphysical. The devil is omnipresent, but in more subtle ways. [0:07:14] This understanding of the devil as simply evil and temptation, rather than a specific spirit, stands up better to rationalist scrutiny and is less likely to cause any theological problems. But even this understanding of a metaphorical devil can be troubling. It gives an external supernatural explanation to acts of evil that we can otherwise not comprehend. This only exculpates actual human involvement. It's a way of modern people, especially modern Americans, to turn away from acts that shock us, especially acts committed by or against people who remind us of ourselves. The historian W. Scott Poole, who had examined the endurance of Satan in our culture, puts it bluntly: Many Americans have a, quote, extremely infantile view of evil, believing crimes like rape and murder to be the work of non-human entities and thus contrary to human nature. By externalizing violence in this way, we remove any culpability from ourselves and our society at large. [0:08:14] In various periods of American history, this supernatural answer to the question of evil, what we can call a diabolic worldview, had been used not only to explain violence, but to justify it. If non-Christian peoples are understood as collaborators with demonic forces, then it is much easier to put aside concerns for their lives and welfare. In the centuries since the colonial period, American society has not lost its habit of obsessing over tangible instances of violence to the in-group while ignoring or celebrating all that is committed against the out-group. 1960s television viewers paid much more attention to the Manson murders perpetrated by shaggy teenage counterculturalists than to the My Lai massacre committed by clean-cut American soldiers. Three centuries earlier, Puritan preacher Cotton Mather, best known for his involvement in the Salem witch trials, gleefully described the slaughter of the Pequot civilians as sending hundreds of heathens to hell. [0:09:02] Right, and so I don't think that the United States is uniquely violent. The genocidal violence of the American frontier isn't that far off from the great wars of 19th and 20th century Europe, the mass anti-communist massacres of Cold War Indonesia, and of course, ongoing campaigns of ethnic extermination in places like the Middle East. But there is a fascinating American tendency reaching far back into the 17th century in which we are totally unable to reckon with evil in our own midst. Killing on the road or in the tavern is understood as an awful tragedy, but one potentially explained by normal human vice and passion. A killing in the home, however, of a loved one or of an innocent exceeded the bounds of the normal. Such an evil must have its source outside the safety of family and the community, even outside the moral bounds of Christendom. A tragedy that cannot be explained by logic can thus instead be explained by Satan. [0:10:02] Many Christians today take a less literal view of the devil than their ancestors did. Per a recent Pew survey, while 74% of Americans believe in God, only 58% acknowledge any belief in Satan. Of that 58%, many of them don't envision a real devil with horns and a pitchfork, but instead, like we said, a metaphysical metaphor for evil and temptation. This wasn't the case historically. From the Roman period to the Middle Ages, up through the 19th and early 20th century, most European and American Christians understood the devil as a literal personified figure, the great tempter and the hidden hand behind all cruelty and wickedness. Adam and Eve ate from the tree of good and evil, not because of their own moral frailty, as is the traditional Jewish interpretation, but instead because of the intercession of a deceptive supernatural force contrary to the will of God. Serious Christian theology insists that because God is all-powerful, the work of the devil is still part of the Lord's unfathomable plan for the universe. [0:11:04] But in practice, I think the folk interpretation of Satan is more like a counter deity, a being that exists against and independent of the will of God, who but who can be defeated through prayer and piety. Sam, why don't you get into the weeds here and tell us about how Satan first emerged in our minds? [0:11:25] Yeah, well, it's if you are familiar with the Bible, you know that Satan isn't a whole cloth Christian invention. In fact, the Jews themselves talk about Satan. He's not really super present in the Bible, but we'll get to that. This understanding of Satan as an individual, intelligent figure whose will is contrary to that of God developed in the Jewish world at some point after the canonization of the Hebrew Bible, but before the emergence of Christianity. Most contemporary Jews, at least not Ashkenazi Jews, don't really believe in the devil, but this is really not the case historically, particularly during the Second Temple period. During this time, the land of Israel as well as the growing Jewish diaspora were strongly influenced by a succession of Persian, Greek, and Roman rulers. The influence of foreign religions on Judaism at this time has been hotly debated, especially given that it is in this period that we first begin to see the formation of a personified devil. [0:12:15] Various ideas began coalescing in the Second Temple Jewish circles that clearly prefigured the Christian understanding of Satan. This figure, known in the Old Testament as the accuser of God, not against God, was instead the great enemy of Yahweh and his creation, mankind. This same enemy was in fact the snake in the Garden of Eden. His supernatural abilities can be explained by the fact that Satan was an angel, albeit a fallen one, cast out of heaven either for refusing to bow before man, or more dramatically, for leading a failed revolt against the Almighty. So, to reiterate, all these currents of thought were originally part of Judaism in some form, although the Jewish world was so diverse that there's no way to know how widespread these ideas ever were. Over time, this so-called satanic package would lose its prominence in mainstream Judaism, but became a mainstream element of Christian theology, and especially of Christian folk belief. [0:13:04] The best evidence for the early Jewish development of Satan and his demonic hosts does not come from the Bible itself, but from various apocryphal texts composed between the Old and New Testaments. The mysterious books of Enoch and Jubilees, which are preserved only in the libraries of the Ethiopian church, describe angels and demons in more anthropomorphic terms than the Hebrew canon. Although these texts are not a major part of contemporary Judaism or Christianity, they're a great look at how the Christian devil came to be. The Life of Adam and Eve is another Jewish text which was produced around the same time as the emergent Christianity, or possibly a couple of centuries before that. It's still kind of fuzzy. But this book indicates an early belief in Satan as the Eden snake and that Satan had thus plagued humanity since the very early days. It's a very interesting book. [0:13:47] Have you had a chance to look over it, Liam? [0:13:50] A little bit. And I gotta say that this whole year I've been increasingly interested in Christian Apocrypha and Jewish Apocrypha, which we'll talk about a little bit more. Not just because in this case, they're so helpful at explaining conceptions that are present in religion, but not necessarily present in canonical scripture, but also, because a lot of these texts are very, very fun. [0:14:10] Yeah, yeah, yeah. This one was just really fascinating for me to read because this is, from what I understand, where the Quranic story comes from as well, where basically God created, yeah, yeah, because in the Quran, it says that God created man in his image, and all the angels bowed except for Satan. And as it turns out, this book of Adam and Eve has this exact same story. At one point, there's a cutaway, like, Satan, why are you messing with us? Adam and Eve say, and he's just like, oh, because God told me to bow before you, and I didn't want to because I'm a superior being. And yeah, it's just a very interesting book, still kind of digesting it theologically. Maybe I'll have more to say about it in a later episode. But suffice it to say, Jewish minds were very much thinking about Satan, not just the Satan of the book of Job, who was more just like a prosecutor, but the actual Satan who became the snake and all that stuff. [0:15:01] Yeah. And so by the time the Christian gospels were written, which was the late first century AD CE, Satan is clearly depicted as a specific malevolent spirit, a figure who tempts Jesus while he's in the desert after being baptized. Here, the devil shows Jesus all the kingdoms on earth and says they can all be his. Join me and we can rule the galaxy. I think this is a great scene because if Jesus saw all the kingdoms on earth, it means that canonically he knew about the Mayans and Han China. But medieval scholars like that passage because of the implication that the devil had these kingdoms to give away. The devil can only make this offer because per medieval theologians, he held real temporal power over the mortal world, perhaps more than God does. Later quotations from the epistles of Saint Paul were used to support this notion as well. [0:15:56] This idea that Satan rules the natural world is as far as I can tell a major departure from any Jewish theology, and it places Satan right at the center of the Christian moral universe in ways that the devil wasn't exactly in Judaism. Paul of Tarsus, in many ways the founder of Christianity, at least as a world religion, makes several references to Satan, describing him in the second letter to the Corinthians as a messenger of light, potentially connected thus to the devil's Latin epithet Lucifer, meaning lightbringer. The book of Revelation, one of the very last canonical texts to be written, understands Satan as fundamental to the Christian spiritual universe. The devil is connected not only to the serpent of Eden, but also to the great Leviathan. And as we mentioned back in episode 56, Revelation is central to the development of medieval conceptions of dragons as wicked beasts. [0:16:49] As Christianity spread across the Roman provinces and beyond, elements of ancient Jewish folklore interacted with the pagan worlds around them in really fascinating ways. This means that before we can get to this episode's actual subject, Satan in America, we first have to go deep into the dark woods of folklore to understand Satan in Europe. [0:17:09] Yeah, let's just talk about this medieval backdrop to satanic beliefs. Broadly speaking, the pre-modern European Christians saw all polytheistic belief systems as expressions of Satanism. The gods of India, West Africa, and Native Americans were understood to be real beings that actually influenced the world, albeit negatively. These were demons who were all part of Satan's legions. Additionally, Catholic missionaries in the 16th and 17th centuries noted similarities between various world religions and their own practices. They determined that these parallels, like the Buddhist use of prayer beads or the Aztec burning of incense, were in fact proof that Satan had guided these people towards a mockery of Christianity in the same way as the idea of the Black Sabbath would emerge as like a parody of the Christian communion. So this is part of a very old monotheistic tradition. The biblical Israelites interpreted the Philistine god Baal Zebub as the demon Beelzebub, who Christians think sometimes is and sometimes isn't the same as Satan. [0:18:04] In Exodus, Pharaoh's magicians are able to invoke powers of the Egyptian gods to turn their staffs into snakes, but being weaker than the one true god of Israel, they are defeated by the even snakier staff of Moses. The Greek and Roman adherents to Christianity, showing the typical zeal of the converted, very eagerly conflated their own pagan gods with the biblical Satan and his various demonic allies. This kind of syncretism is even present within the Bible itself. Revelation appears to describe the famous pagan altar of Pergamon as the seat of Satan. [0:18:33] Yeah, yeah, and just jumping on here, I've been told actually that to this day, some evangelical Christians insist on avoiding the real-life, actual, reconstructed Pergamon temple because they think that's where Satan lives. But before you laugh this off, remember that the altar of Pergamon today is held in Berlin. So there might be something to that. [0:18:50] Yeah, I mean, I've seen it. It definitely felt very satanic to me. [0:18:53] Big truth to you. [0:18:56] Another interesting pagan connection that I feel like would not be that intuitive is that early Christians were very eager to connect the devil with their ancestral nature god, Pan. Part of the connection is because Pan represented the natural worlds, which, as we've said, was sometimes interpreted as the realm of the devil. But the main reason for this link is that the books of Leviticus and Isaiah make references to obscure, potentially demonic, and probably goat-like creatures called se'irim. Hellenistic Jews and early Christians associated the se'irim with satyrs, prominent in Greek mythology. If satyrs are demons, then thus by the transitive property, the leader of the satyrs must be the leader of the demons. The leader of the demons is Satan. Satan is Pan. We, of course, see elements of satirical, literally, depictions in Christian art of Satan. This is where we get the hooves, the horns, all of that. [0:19:53] Some people think that Satan's pitchfork might be inherited from earlier depictions of Neptune. That one's a little bit more speculative. [0:20:02] Personally, I think the best example of how pagan deities shaped the Christian demonic is the word demon itself. This comes from a Greek concept for benevolent minor gods who guided mortals through life and inspired great works like the Philosophy of Socrates. The word demon was used in the first Greek translation of the Bible, the Septuagint, to describe various beings contrary to the God of Israel, including, like we saw with Beelzebub, rival gods of non-Jewish peoples. By equating pagan gods with the malevolent spirits of Jewish scripture, both Jews and Christians were able to reconcile their official monotheistic theology with popular cosmologies that allowed for the existence of evil spirits and supernatural powers. Everybody in the ancient world, whether they were Jewish or Christian or pagan, acknowledged that certain occurrences violated natural law. The Bible is full of miracles, but these were always attributed to the power of God, or much more rarely, to the lesser powers of demons or pagan deities. [0:21:02] Pagans, however, saw the world as governed by thousands of gods or lesser spirits, and they took for granted that normal people could perform acts of sorcery. The second century pagan philosopher Celsus bewildered that anybody paid much attention to Jesus walking on water or turning water into wine. Because these kinds of miracles happen every day. Come on. [0:21:24] Yeah, following the conversion of the Roman Empire to Christianity, the supernatural occurrences or abilities not associated with the one true God were increasingly associated with the devil. Instead, the Acts of the Apostles, which were probably written in the late first century, mentioned a figure named Simon Magus, who amazed the Samaritan people with feats of wonder and then tried to bribe the apostles into gaining even more magic powers. This is where the word simony comes from, fun fact, which is like the attempt to buy a post in the church. But anyway, to the author of Acts, the extent of this magic and its source wasn't considered important. But a fifth century text, the apocryphal Acts of Peter and Paul, turned this minor cameo character into a lengthy spiritual rival who stood against the apostles in a match refereed by none other than the Emperor Nero himself. This version is reminiscent of the Old Testament confrontation of Moses and the Egyptian priests, except here it's made explicit that any supernatural power not given by God is given by Satan. [0:22:19] Simon flies into the heavens like Superman, but only because a pair of Satan's demons have hoisted him up. Through invoking the power of the one true God, Saint Peter scares these demons into dropping Simon Magus, who then falls hard onto the Roman street, meaning a quick and messy end. But speaking of Nero, there's another apocryphal text from the late Roman period, which presents a really interesting look at the satanic syncretization of the pagan gods. The Gospel of Nicodemus, also known as the Acts of Pontius Pilate, begin with Jesus being brought before the infamous Roman governor. But as Jesus enters Pilate's hall, all the military standards held by the soldiers bow down before him. As Roman standards often included symbols of Mars and Jupiter, this could indicate that the pagan gods were acknowledging the superiority of Jesus and the God of Israel. But what's more interesting is the episode at the end of the gospel, where Jesus dies and is crucified and then descends into hell to save the souls of the damned. [0:23:13] Here he meets two figures: Satan and, amazingly, the Greek god Hades. At the end of the story, Jesus leads the souls of Adam and the Jewish patriarchs out of the infernal dungeon, but condemns Satan to be prisoner of Hades forever. [0:23:25] Yeah, no, I just love this because it just shows that, you know, in every sense, belief in a pagan god was reconcilable with Christian demonology. I think this is something that isn't discussed enough in the development of folklore around demons. It's so extreme that it might be a bit heretical, which I think maybe is why this text was not included in the canon of any surviving Christian movement, but it clearly shows how traces of belief in non-Christian and usually pre-Christian spirits survived into the monotheistic worldview. Demons were almost like an excuse to believe in the gods of your ancestors, except, you know, believing that they are now fully malevolent. Ancient Germanic-speaking peoples who settled the British Isles amid the fall of the Christian Roman Empire brought their own linguistic and cultural associations with the demonic. Interestingly, the word devil from the Greek diabolos appears to have entered proto-Germanic even before any of its speakers were Christian. [0:24:23] The Anglo-Saxons a few centuries later had their own words to describe a malevolent spirit. Fiend, which in Old English just means enemy. Unlike the Finns, who would call Satan by the name of their forgotten god Perkele, the newly Christian peoples of England did not associate the devil with any specific pagan deity. However, they did borrow the word hell from the gloomy underworld of ancient Germanic mythology, you know, cognate with Hades in the Greek. The narrative poem Christ and the Devil, written in the early Anglo-Saxon period, prefigures John Milton's Paradise Lost by a thousand years by depicting Satan in hell lamenting over his own suffering and weakness. To quote Satan, this is from Charles Kennedy's prose translation of the poem: Lo, once we knew great bliss before the face of God, and songs of praise in heaven in happier hours. Here in torment I must needs abide in bonds, nor ever for any better home, because of my insolent pride. [0:25:20] Per this poet, Satan is a truly pathetic creature, hated even by his own legions of demons. Then answer the foul fiends, black and sinful, chained in torment. Thou with thy lies didst teach us not to serve the Savior. To thee alone it seemed that thou hadst power over all things in heaven and earth, that thou were holy God, even the creator. Sorely we have suffered for thy lies. And just like in the Acts of Pontius Pilate, this story ends with Jesus descending into the underworld to carry out the harrowing of hell, humiliating the devil even further and casting him even into a deeper region of hell. This literature likely drew from a folkloric European tradition in which saints, angels, and Jesus himself carried out physical battles with Satan and his demons. Early medieval hagiographies contain traces of this, like the story in which Saint Columba defeats a sea monster in Scotland's Loch Ness. [0:26:18] Well, into the modern period, many European Christians, particularly in rural places, believed just as strongly in malicious forces as they did in the divine power of God. We have to remember that before contemporary rationalism, most people saw divine and demonic influence everywhere in their lives. This influence could often be very direct, through apparitions of angels or the Virgin Mary. It could also take the form of night visits by Satan himself. But both God and the devil often worked through human intermediaries who conveyed a touch of their power through their mortal disciples. Saints could perform great miracles in the name of God, and regular people could invoke holy power through prayer and benedictions. But the most wicked of the wicked were those humans who were so tempted by Satan that they not only performed his bidding through evil acts, but joined his service in a supernatural pact. [0:27:11] This idea of satanic pacts has precedence in pagan stories about humans aiding deities and vice versa, and some precedent in the New Testament as well, where Satan meets Jesus in the wilderness, offering worldly riches and power if he accepts his temptation. [0:27:24] But the first individual said to have signed his name in the devil's book was Theophilus of Adana, an Anatolian priest said to have been so jealous of a rival cleric that he used the help of a necromancer to commune with the devil himself. After conjuring Satan through the use of magic words, Theophilus then renounces Jesus and Mary, signing an infernal compact with his own blood. Satan then helps Theophilus become a bishop, at which point he repented, and then through the power of prayer and fasting, Theophilus is able to get out of the devil's service and burn the contract, at which point he also ascends to heaven. This story was widespread across the high medieval world in the form of saints' guides and theatrical performances. Theophilus and the Devil's pact was seen as a metaphor for satanic temptation, as well as a warning about real demonic contracts, as well as an influence on the story of Faust. [0:28:10] It should be noted. [0:28:11] Oh, absolutely. And also relevant to the movie we're going to be discussing in this episode. So keep that in mind. It all comes back from to Theophilus. [0:28:19] Yeah. [0:28:20] Yeah, exactly. Yeah. [0:28:20] So the signing of this contract became known as diabolism, or colloquially, witchcraft. And that's really where the trouble began. [0:28:28] Yeah, and so this is something we should get into that is often forgotten: is that the word witch in an English, early modern, and medieval Christian context has basically two definitions. The first is what we would understand, which is a person, usually but not always a woman, who possesses magical abilities. But the second definition, more important to our purposes, was a person who had gained such abilities through a pact with the devil. In the Anglo-Saxon period, witches were believed to exist and widely feared, at least by aristocratic and clerical elites. The laws of Alfred the Great mandate death for witches, drawing off of the infamous commandment of Exodus 22:18, do not suffer a witch to live. There isn't yet this specifically satanic connotation in King Alfred's laws, and there doesn't appear to be that connotation in the Old Testament context either. But across the later Middle Ages, as clerical authority became more rigid, witches of any kind were seen with intense scrutiny. [0:29:27] That second definition, the diabolical definition, a witch being somebody who had signed a pact with the devil, would eventually be elevated into one of the biggest social crises of the Catholic and later Protestant world. In the 13th and 14th centuries, as the first of several Catholic Inquisitions proceeded across Europe, clerical agents began investigating accusations of witchcraft with much more rigor than before. This was happening in the context of a newfound paranoia over heresies, like the Cathars and Waldensians we've previously mentioned on this show. We're going to see that spiritual threats of any kind always seem to lead to witch hunts of some kind. During this period, again, the high and late Middle Ages, suspected witches, heretics, Jews, and even the Knights Templar all faced accusations of devil worship and diabolical allegiance. Western Europeans often assumed all of these groups were working together in some way to undermine their Christian society. [0:30:22] I think that later on, anti-Semitic theories connecting Jewish people to communists and Freemasons ultimately derive from this same mode of thinking. As heretics were typically accused of devil worship and witchcraft, it came to be understood that any accused witch must therefore also be a heretic and a Satanist. Some medieval writers disputed this view that all witches were satanic witches. The English theologian Roger Bacon thought it was ludicrous to believe that any practice of folk magic indicated allegiance to the devil. Some writers distinguished between demonic magic and natural magic, whose source may not be godly but was still not diabolical. This view, however, was slammed by the Catalan Inquisitor Nicholas Eymerich, who asserted that any power not directly attributable to God is therefore the domain of Satan. No other supernatural forces exist. By his logic, every single witch was a devil worshipper, even if he or she didn't realize it. [0:31:23] This more hard-line view would gain popularity by the end of the Middle Ages and be codified a century after Eymerich in the notorious Malleus Maleficarum, written by paranoid monk Heinrich Kramer in 1486. This book, The Hammer of the Witches, advanced a misogynistic theory of female weakness and jealousy from the days of Eve onward and advocated for the burning at the stake of anyone convicted of witchcraft. Though condemned at the time by many churchmen as overzealous, things would change a couple generations after Kramer and after the protest of Martin Luther had cracked the Catholic world in half, leading to a revolution in theological freedom as well as previously unseen levels of Christian religious violence. The paranoia of the Reformation age caused both Catholics and Protestants to violently enforce doctrine within and without. Even before the bloodletting of the Thirty Years' War, which was in the broadest terms a sectarian conflict, tens of thousands of Christians were slaughtered by other Christians in the name of Christ. [0:32:27] This violence entails the suppression of radical Protestant reformers like the people of Munster. It entails the oppression of Protestants in France and Catholics in Ireland and England. And it entails, of course, the obsession with witchcraft that consumed Europe and America from the middle of the 16th to the beginning of the 18th century. [0:32:48] Yeah, we've discussed witch trials on the show previously. In episode 89, we went over the horrible story of Katharina Kepler, an elderly woman who was accused of sorcery to the shock of her son, the famous German astronomer Johannes Kepler. But this was practically a global phenomenon. Accusations ranging from relatively typical targets isolated an unpopular older woman like Frau Kepler, as well as the extremely powerful, like Scotland's 5th Earl of Bothwell, Francis Stewart, and 36 courtiers of King Louis XIV executed for sorcery and poisoning in the 1670s. What all early modern witchcraft accusations had in common is the allegation of Satanism. And I'm just going to add here: I think it's totally fair to say that witches do not exist. I mean, Liam, I'm sure you'll agree with me on this, right? [0:33:34] Yes, yeah. I will assert, I will say with a great degree of certainty here, magic is not real, and therefore any accusation of witchcraft is unfounded. But I think that even more unfounded than the belief in magic is the belief that anybody thought to be magical was a willing Satanist. I think this is completely ludicrous, and I think that some well-intentioned people accidentally give stock to these allegations of Satanism. And I'll explain why. So, pretty much everybody accused and convicted of witchcraft was a pious Christian, except for a small number who were instead pious Jews. So, I get kind of queasy when some modern writers, many of them with neo-pagan associations, insist that victims of the witch trials actually were witches of some kind. Because we need to remember that in this early modern context, a witch did not mean somebody in the woods who made little poultices out of herbs. [0:34:30] A witch was thought to be somebody who cavorts with the devil. This allegation was not only ruinous and deadly, it was a complete defamation of the spiritual character of the person accused. So, I think when people insist that there really were witch cults throughout history going back to pagan times, they're kind of, you know, spitting on the memory of these innocent people. Anyways, the idea that witches were satanic would be codified in the early modern witch trials, but has a lot of medieval antecedents. There's one really interesting case I want to get into, which is the 1324 trial of Irish noblewoman, Dame Alice Kyteler, because it's so early, but looks so similar to later witch allegations. Alice Kyteler, who is a Norman woman in Ireland, was accused of devil worship during a monetary dispute with her stepson. Dame Alice, who was in her 60s and very wealthy, was accused of a long list of lurid crimes. [0:35:25] She was said to have held magical meetings with men and women in crude imitation of Catholic ritual, burning candles not to invoke the beauty of God, but the wickedness of Satan. She sacrificed animals and physically cavorted with demons. She took for a lover a demon named Robin, who sometimes took the form of an animal and other times the form of an Ethiopian man. Although Dame Alice fled Ireland due to these allegations, her young servant Petronella was not so lucky. After confessing under torture, she was burned at the stake, like many other witches in later generations. As we previously saw with Saint Theophilus of Adana, even churchmen were not free of demonic possession. The 13th century monk Caesarius of Heisterbach described how all kinds of people, from knights to peasants down, were known to be possessed by demons. One particularly fun anecdote was a priest known for having the best singing voice in the Holy Roman Empire. [0:36:22] Upon hearing this man's voice, another priest realized that he was such a good singer, this was beyond the normal level of human ability. Instead, his voice was so good, it was perfect, and no human can be perfect. Therefore, this man must be possessed by a demon. So the second priest conducts an exorcism, at which point the musically gifted demon flees from the first priest's body, killing him instantly. A century after this, allegations of witchcraft and diabolism were made against the Spanish bishop Pedro de Luna, who during the Great Papal Schism named himself Pope Benedict XIII. He was just one pope of several during a time of rampant excommunications in the church. So it might not be surprising he was accused of the most wicked deeds known to Christendom, signing a diabolical pact. But even fully legitimate popes could not escape these allegations. Sylvester II, who ran the church around the year 1000, was widely believed to have had regular interactions with Satan. [0:37:20] After learning the secrets of black magic from a Muslim scholar in Spain, Pope Sylvester summoned a beautiful demon named Meridiana, who became his lover and his confidant until his death. I think it's relevant to note that nearly all these stories about Pope Sylvester come from the English monk William of Malmesbury, writing in the 12th century, when various popes had tense relations with the English kings. It's interesting that many of these stories have a contractual angle, going all the way back to Theophilus. We should note that medieval European life depended heavily on written contracts. There were many contractual disputes between lords and peasants, between towns and monasteries, and, like we saw, between popes and kings. Deals with the devil would inspire literary works for centuries. The most famous, as you mentioned, Sam, is the story of Faust, adapted into renowned plays by Christopher Marlowe and Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, centuries apart. [0:38:13] Marlowe's play was such a hit that some Puritans feared it was drawing crowds who didn't think Satanism was terrifying, but instead thought it was cool. There were even accusations that the actors Marlow had hired to play his devils were in fact not actors, but instead actual devils. I read the Marlow play, it's kind of fun. I have not read the Goethe play. Sam, are you more familiar? [0:38:37] Yeah, no, I haven't really read Faust yet. I mean, it's been on my list for years. I keep meaning to it. It's like the cornerstone of German literature. But yeah, it's just like hugely influential and it would have a really big impact on what the idea of like selling your soul to the devil would look like going forward. [0:38:56] So in both of these versions, Faust is an ambitious chemist who makes a pact with a devil named Mephistopheles to gain power, and in many versions, a complete scientific understanding of the secrets of the natural world. Originally intended as a warning against those who strayed from the Christian path, or even against those who sought to engage in diabolical behavior themselves, most modern interpretations see the Faust story as more of a warning against pride and ambition. As Goethe's Faust seeks to use his knowledge to create a utopian society, 19th and 20th century interpretations of the story often compared him to political idealists and social revolutionaries. All of these stories are based on rumors about the real life of Johann Faust, who was a German alchemist, astrologer, occultist, and early printer who lived during the time of Martin Luther and who was accused in his lifetime of necromancy and sodomy. [0:39:44] Very little is known of the historical Faust, except that he was an extremely controversial figure who also had some influence among the German aristocrats and even archbishops. I think we can probably compare him to his English contemporary John Dee, who was another elite occultist whose practices heavily overlapped with legal definitions of witchcraft. You know, both Faust and John Dee never faced any legal accusations of witchcraft. And although I have to wonder if that's only because of their proximity to power, which protected them. What I find especially interesting about the real-life Faust is the last attestation to him is that he was present at Münster during the bloody Anabaptist uprising we've discussed previously on this show. The extent of his involvement with the defenders of Munster are unknown, but given that there's no more references to him after this conflict in Munster, I think it's very possible he was killed there. [0:40:36] By the later 16th century, rumors and legends began to swirl about both his life and his death, claiming that he had used black magic to assist the Habsburg emperor's assault on Rome, that he was actually good friends and associates with Martin Luther and Philip Melanchthon, and that he had been killed when one of his alchemical experiments went explosively wrong. The most enduring of all these rumors, however, was that he sold his soul to the devil. One last funny detail about Faust that I wanted to mention, as late as the 1920s, people in West Virginia used the reference as great as the devil in Dr. Foster. It's now believed that this Dr. Foster is a garbled reference to the most famous satanic pact in Western literature. Perhaps distant memories of some English ancestor at an Elizabethan theater watching the Marlowe play. [0:41:28] So interestingly, in the first half of the 16th century, there was actually a downturn in number of accusations of witchcraft and diabolism in Europe, but this quickly rose again to new heights at the start of the 17th century. Martin Luther, who casually advocated for the burning of witches, also remarked that there weren't as many witches around now as there had been in his pre-Reformation childhood. This is potentially because in the immediate aftermath of Luther's cataclysmic revolt, Catholics and Protestants became too focused on dealing with out-and-de-open religious threats to deal with sub-rosa sects of devil worshipers. In addition, Protestants had some initial reservations about making use of texts like the Malleus Maleficarum, which was produced by a Catholic churchmen. But shortly after Luther's death, allegations of witchcraft and diabolism would explode across southern Germany, spreading by the late 16th century to France, England, Scotland, Sweden, and the Americas. [0:42:22] Yeah, and so various factors led to the rise of witchcraft allegations in the generations after Luther, including increased fears of secret internal heretics within one's own sect. Additionally, this period saw worsening weather conditions as a result of the Little Ice Age, this podcast's favorite climatic event. Steadily worsening crop yields over a period of decades might have been experienced not as a general downturn by farmers, but instead as specific hardships. A cow that didn't produce milk one year, or a crop of wheat that withered on the stalk. For people experiencing a precarious peasant livelihood, these apparently mundane problems could have life or death consequences. And with no readily available natural explanation, many people turned towards magic. Climate was just one of many changes in early modern Europe, however, because after the development of the printing press, which, as you mentioned, our friend Dr. Faust played a role, we began to see an explosion of literacy among European commoners. [0:43:26] There was new access to literature, especially in the form of broadsheet posters and chapbook pamphlets. While optimistic, Whiggish accounts of history often present expanding literacy as part of a straight line toward rationalism, in practice, unfettered access to information and misinformation, especially for-profit slop, allowed for a short-term increase in paranoid conspiracies, especially involving the demonic. Enterprising printers quickly realized that stories of wicked deeds were easy bestsellers. We mentioned before in the show that much of the infamy of Vlad the Impaler down to his famous nickname is probably related to the fact that he was active at the same time as the first ever newspapers were looking for bloody stories to print. These stories and songs about murder, witchcraft, and deals with the devil were widely circulated, both in the private libraries of the elite and the back streets of London, Nuremberg, and Paris. This literature often included hastily carved woodblock illustrations of witches and demons, like the one on this episode art. [0:44:34] They also included lurid rituals of sacrifice and sacrilege. Even before Christopher Marlowe wrote his play, many English readers knew about Faust from these various types of cheap pamphlets. This early modern information revolution also exposed Europeans to stories about the expanding rest of the world. Accounts of the exploration of Africa, Asia, and the Americas in particular were common subjects of popular literature. These texts, written by pious Christians and often by missionaries, were almost universally unflattering in their depiction of non-European religions. Written at the same time as the ongoing holy wars with the Ottoman Empire in the Balkans and their North African allies in the Mediterranean, European Christians saw themselves surrounded on all fronts by the heathen. Early modern writers, just like their medieval forebearers, assumed that Satan had to be leading the enemies of the church, regardless of whether this church was Catholic or Protestant. I think that the connection between Satan and non-European religions is the most under-discussed factor in the rise of early modern witch allegations, particularly in the Americas. [0:45:54] And now we're finally getting to our subject: Satan in America. [0:45:58] Oh, yes. Early generations of settlers in the New World, both in the Spanish, English, and in the French colonies, had direct and ongoing encounters with polytheistic belief systems, which they interpreted as devil worship. In some cases, genuinely shocking behaviors like human sacrifice and cannibalism reinforced medieval attitudes about what witches would do, bringing to mind earlier stories about witches like Alice Kyteler taking part in bloody rites. Allegations of diabolism were central to witch hunts, most famously in New England, but also in other colonies like Virginia, Bermuda, and Mexico. The underexplored Mexican Inquisition, part of the broader Spanish Inquisition, primarily targeted conversos. These were Mexican Catholics whose recent ancestors were Jewish. However, the Inquisition also involved allegations of black magic and diabolism, often connected to worship of indigenous Mexican deities. Demon worship was thus a less ludicrous charge in Mexico than it was back in Europe, because to colonial authorities, any adherence to traditional Mesoamerican religion was Satanism. [0:47:17] Peoples of known indigenous or Jewish descent were the most obvious targets, but in parallel to the New England witch trials, many of the accused were well-off children, supposedly of pure Christian stock. These were good boys and girls tempted by foreign satanic seduction. These allegations would be used to justify extreme violence against indigenous peoples. We see this as early as the time of Columbus, the very beginning of European colonialism. And these allegations were used again to justify the enslavement of supposed devil worshipers from Africa. As generations passed, these religious categories crystallized into colonial racial hierarchies, which arguably still reign to this day across the world. We should note that the association of foreignness and dark skin with the satanic was present even before colonialism began in earnest. Remember that Dame Alice Kyteler was said to have had a demonic consort in the shape of an African. Interestingly, Ireland itself was often associated with witchcraft and devil worship by mainland Europeans. [0:48:27] One medieval French adventure story from the 14th century describes the Baltic Crusades, in which a demonic axis of evil, Muslim Saracens, wild Irish, and Lithuanian pagans all fight against brave Christian soldiers. And this association of foreign gods with demons was central to witchcraft allegations in Puritan New England, which began just 20 years after the Pilgrims landed in Plymouth and had their peak in Salem and Andover in 1692. The Pilgrims, like other early European settlers, believed that the gods of the Native Americans really existed and that they were directly opposed to the establishment of an English Christian civilization in Massachusetts. [0:49:08] Yeah, and again, I just, we really have to, you know, I don't want to belabor this point, but I think it's so important for understanding the pre-modern worldview. Even though there was only one god, there were many other beings that could be construed as gods, but were really demons. I have to say, I didn't really internalize this until I began researching this episode, and I think this genuine belief in pagan spirits as demons does explain a lot about how early settlers rationalized the kind of violence they would enact. [0:49:40] Yeah, absolutely. So as early as the first years of contact, English explorers like John Smith and Edward Winslow described the traditional gods and spirits of New England as demons, in particular Hobbamock. We've spoken about Hobbamock in the previous episodes about the origins of Thanksgiving and civilization in New England. The Plymouth governor Winslow wrote that, quote, Another power they worship, whom they call Hobbamock, as far as we can conceive, is the devil, him they call upon to cure their wounds and diseases. This Hobbamock appears in sundry forms to them, in the shape of a man, a deer, a fawn, an eagle, etc., but most ordinarily as a snake. He appears not at all, but the chiefest and most judicious among them, though all of them strive to attain to that hellish height of honor. Later on, at least one woman who was accused of witchcraft in New England was accused of having taken Hobbamock as her lover when he took the guise of an Indian man. [0:50:37] Decades later, just before the Salem witch trials, prolific Puritan theologian Cotton Mather would claim that Satan himself visited a nighttime meeting of Indian sachems and convinced these chiefs, them being his loyal worshippers, to attack the English colonies and rid his country of the troublesome Christians. And these days, New England Puritans are about as strongly associated with witchcraft as they are with turkeys and pumpkin pie. To an extent, this is unfair because New England witch trials were part of a broader trend in Christianity stretching from Peru to Poland. But given the relatively small population of colonial Massachusetts Bay and Connecticut, New England actually saw a very high rate of accusations per capita and a somewhat higher rate of executions and convictions, particularly during the Salem events of 1692 and 1693. [0:51:29] Before we get into Salem, I just want to add a little side note. There's something I've been soapboxing on for a while here. There has been lots of popular speculation about the famous pointed witch hat. I would like to point out a very obvious factor that has been missed in many of the think pieces about where the witch hat comes from. This is that during the time that the Salem witch trials happened, pointy black hats were very common in Britain and America. Because witches were understood as women for various sexist reasons, women's fashion was codified as witches' fashion. That is why there is the pointed witch hat in every Halloween depiction today. So the Salem witch trials are one of the most famous and well-studied events in American history. The only stories about 17th century America that are more well-known are the First Thanksgiving and Pocahontas. [0:52:22] But colonial New England was an extremely unusual society, as we've described in the past on this show. It was a carefully planned and carefully policed, would-be utopian society of extreme English Protestants transplanted onto an alien soil. Despite the threats of the natural environment and the tense relationships with indigenous peoples like the Wampanoag, this so-called city on a hill quickly developed into a large and prosperous society with the highest rates of literacy and possibly the highest standard of living of anywhere on earth in the 17th century. The many internal and external divisions in New England society meant that the witch trials touched on many pre-existing crises of gender, class, theology, and settler colonialism. All of these facets are extremely important in understanding why the first allegations of Satanism and possession were made, why these allegations were taken seriously, and why nearly 150 people in New England were hanged and pressed to death. [0:53:26] And I'm sure that all of these factors, to some extent, played a role in why the witch trials happened. But I think that a lot of analyses, by focusing so much on the material or social or even biomedical causes, in the case of ergot poisoning, lose sight of the stated ideology and stated motivations of the people involved. This is to say, the people at Salem truly, really believed they were haunted by the devil. Acting through his loyal witches, whom he had tempted and deceived, the Prince of Darkness set his sights on a society he believed to be the most holy on earth, thus the most threatening to his power. Let's hear it again from Cotton Mather, who wrote, The New Englanders are a people of God settled in those which were once the devil's territories. It may easily be supposed that the devil was exceedingly disturbed when he perceived such a people here accomplishing the promise of old made unto the blessed Jesus. [0:54:29] The devil, thus irritated, immediately tried all sorts of methods to overturn this poor plantation. I believe that never were more satanical devices used for the unsettling of any people under the sun than what have been employed for the extirpation of the vine which God has here planted. These satanical devices, Cotton Mather means, included internal threats, like sin and heresy and witchcraft. It was understood that these peoples were in league with the devil to undermine the most perfect society on earth. Everyday troubles, like butter that went sour or beer that didn't ferment, could be chalked up to eldritch interference. Mather continues, whereupon there have been endured such mischievous consequences upon the bodies and estates of the neighborhood as could not be accounted for. Yea, that at prodigious witch meetings, the wretches have proceeded so far as to concert and consult methods of rooting out the Christian religion from this country, and setting up instead a more gross diabolism than ever this world saw before. [0:55:51] And yet it will be a thing little short of a miracle, if so, in spread a business as this, the devil should not get in some of his juggles to confound the discovery of all the rest. The historian Mary Beth Norton published a recent and very acclaimed account of the Salem witch trials called In the Devil's Snare, which does a great job of really exploring the psychology of the accusers, in particular by connecting the spiritual turmoil within Salem to the constant physical violence outside English settlements with Native Americans. I think it's remarkable that in the many centuries of analysis of the witch trials, few scholars have thought to note that the town of Salem was heavily populated with refugees from Maine whose homes were destroyed in King Philip's War. Then again in 1690, immediately prior to witchcraft allegations, a new conflict emerged described as the Second Indian War, in which native Abenaki and French Canadian militias came down into Maine and New Hampshire, killing hundreds of English subjects and taking dozens more hostage. [0:57:06] The shock of this invasion and the ensuing hostage crisis radicalized the settler society of colonial New England. These deeply religious colonists, who already believed it was their God-given right to claim the land they saw as a new Jerusalem, became more sensitive to any perceived threats to their stability and more open to violent solutions of maintaining internal control. These men took seriously claims of witchcraft made by young girls and women that they might have otherwise discarded and had less compunctions about killing alleged witches, most of whom were women from socially marginalized backgrounds. The gender point is, of course, extremely important in understanding witchcraft allegations, both in early modern New England or medieval Europe. Many of the allegations involved fears of Puritan domestic tranquility being upset by the devil. As seen in medieval allegations, many women were charged with sexual offenses, up to and including sex with demons and the production of offspring from this demon sperm. [0:58:17] There is clearly a major element here of men fearing women's reproductive power. Puritan society had extremely strict controls over marriage and reproduction for men as well as women. Ideas of demonic reproduction could have been a sublimated response to fears of illicit sex within the community. One of the women hanged for witchcraft, Sarah Good, had caused scandal by marrying her indentured servant, a man named Daniel. This might have been connected to concern over interracial marriage and cohabitation, which was sometimes punished with forcible annulment and beatings and was formally banned in the decade after the trials. Witches in New England were often charged with infanticide, which was actually a very real problem in a society that offered little opportunities and lots of punishment to unmarried mothers. Women who found themselves pregnant by men they couldn't marry were incentivized to rid themselves of any evidence of this affair by whatever means they had at their disposal. [0:59:20] In one particularly horrible case from 1670, a free black woman named Zippora was accused of murdering a baby she had out of wedlock, which she insisted was in fact stillborn. While she was acquitted on these charges, this case scandalized Massachusetts and heightened fears about women's abilities to control their own reproduction. This brings to mind a somewhat later colonial folktale, which I think has a lot of possibly the most far-reaching influence of any folk story about Satan. This is the Jersey Devil story. In most of these versions, a woman named Mrs. Leeds or Mrs. Shrouds, who had already given birth to 12 children, found herself pregnant again against her own wishes with baby number 13. In an active rebellion against patriarchal gender norms, Mrs. Leeds cursed her husband and their unborn child, wishing it would be born as a devil. Nine months later, she delivered a monstrous infant with wings and hooves and a face like a horse, which flew into the New Jersey Pine Barrens where it has remained ever since. [1:00:33] Stories about this flying creature would recur across the 18th and 19th centuries, including a famous sighting supposedly by Joseph Bonaparte, brother of Emperor Napoleon. After being exiled to America, Joseph purchased a large New Jersey estate. While hunting on one cold winter day, he saw hoof marks in the snow that suddenly ended, as if whatever beast had made them leapt into the sky and never came back down. Then, overhead, he saw a huge flying beast with flapping wings and the head of a horse. [1:01:08] Yeah, it's true. That was me. [1:01:10] It might be relevant to note that around the same time as the Salem witch trials and when the Jersey Devil story was formulated, civil magistrates in Germany investigated at least one case of a woman giving birth to a crow, which then flew out of her body and into the woods. This was not only taken seriously, but considered definite proof that the poor woman involved was a witch. You know, while we're on the subject of sexual and reproductive magic, there's one last story that's too bizarre not to mention, which is that New Englanders sometimes accused each other of using black magic to interfere with a man's sexual potency, either to cause erectile dysfunction or to cure it. When a man named John Foskett was feuding with his neighbor John Fausall, Foskett claimed that whenever Mr. and Mrs. Fausall went to bed, the devil would appear in their bedchamber and cause Mr. [1:02:06] Fausal's member to rise. [1:02:08] Which I gotta say, you know, it's a 17th century Viagra through the power of black magic. [1:02:14] So as we can see, gender, race, and sex all played a role in the development of the Salem witch trials, but we also should mention the role of religious dissidents within colonial New England, especially Quakers and also so-called antinomians like Anne Hutchinson. Prior to settling in America, Puritans had offered much more space to women preachers than the established Church of England had done. But once Puritans established their own church and their own communities, they clamped down on women's abilities to preach the gospel. Women thus found more freedom outside the Puritan church and instead in movements like the Quakers and the Antinomians. Relative blindness towards both gender and race separated the Quakers from other colonial Christians and opened them up to allegations of devil worship and witchcraft. The Quaker and antinomian belief that everybody could receive revelations from God was a major threat to Puritan church leadership. [1:03:11] It was thought that such supposed revelations could actually be some form of communion with the devil. I think it's very important to note that several of the accused Salem witches came from Quaker backgrounds, as all Quakers were seen as potential witches. [1:03:28] Yeah, so several other accused witches were enslaved, most famously Tituba, who was a woman of ambiguous origin who was thought to have inducted white Christian children into pagan devil worship from her Caribbean homeland. This aspect of seduction of good young Christians by a foreign other is very common across time and space, which reveals a lot of both racial and domestic anxieties. The presence of African and indigenous slaves in Puritan homes, of male servants seducing the daughters of their employers, of women who defied expectations of marriage and motherhood, and even of agricultural or culinary mishaps, all of these were crises of normalcy in a society that greatly valued stability and conformity. We should keep in mind that New England settlers were very prosperous and much healthier and better fed than their cousins back in Britain. They believed themselves to be uniquely pious and uniquely well governed. They were vigilant of any imagined threats to their settler colonial wild garden. [1:04:28] And in some ways, this was a precursor to the stability and abundance of the 20th century suburbia. [1:04:33] Yeah, and so I would argue that even beyond these Salem events, the uniquely new world institutions of settler colonialism and chattel slavery led to a greater deal of supernatural paranoia than was present in Europe. Religious systems like those of the Aztecs and the Wampanoags were understood as literal devil worship. Therefore, the demonic was thought to be much stronger in lands where such beliefs prospered. If Satan had lurked even in Eden, a literal paradise, then no people anywhere were safe from his temptation. And if no powers existed beyond the powers of heaven and the powers of Satan, Any people who rejected the Christian God in favor of another deity were thus, in their ignorance, worshiping the devil. So, in short, early Americans appear to have been more preoccupied with Satan than their British forebears, probably due to their proximity to indigenous and African belief systems misconstrued as devil worship, as well as the more central role of the Protestant church in America than in Britain, and the isolation and paranoia inherent to frontier life. [1:05:45] The modern horror film The Witch, which I would guess basically all our listeners have seen, understands all of these factors brilliantly. Writer-director Robert Eggers shows a Puritan family beset by a horrific and relatable tragedy. The loss of a child, exclusion from community, and the failure of their crops. These English colonists are unfamiliar with and terrified by the American landscape. Although Indians only appear in a single shot at the start of the movie, the family understands themselves to be unwelcome in a pagan land where Christ holds no power. Heathen devils rule here, present in the woods and in the spoiled milk and even in the eyes of the family's shaggy black goat. In the end, the family's teenage daughter, a young and apple-cheeked Anya Taylor-Joy, figures: if you can't beat him, join him. The film ends with her signing her name in the devil's book and taking part in the naked night flight of the witch's Sabbath. [1:06:45] Salem did not mark the end of the witch panic in the English-speaking world, but the ensuing decades saw a very rapid shift in both legal and theological attitudes toward diabolism. Possibly due to embarrassment over the overreach in the Salem allegations, which actually warranted an official government apology in the early 18th century, preachers in Britain and America began moving away from witchcraft and diabolical interference in their sermons by the early 1700s. This shift was actually noted and condemned by the famous Methodist preacher John Wesley, who insisted that giving up witchcraft is giving up the Bible. On the ground, local magistrates became less interested in prosecuting alleged witches across the early 18th century. However, local bumpkins, who missed the memo that witches were passe, took matters into their own hands. Two British women, Anne Izzard and half-hanged Mary Headley, were attacked by angry mobs on suspicions of black magic. [1:07:51] Mary Headley was hoisted up on a noose to the point of near strangulation. But in this instance, without any legal sanction, the violent villagers found themselves, not the supposed witches, the ones facing legal jeopardy. A generation later, the First Great Awakening, in which John Wesley played a leading role, took a much more individualistic view of salvation and damnation. In America in particular, preachers like Jonathan Edwards and Gilbert Tennent revived interest in the literal role of Satan in everyday life, no longer requiring witches as intermediaries. Tennent in particular identified alleged victims of possession and insisted that his detractors in the Anglican church must themselves be guided by devils. The first great awakening and the second was the beginning of a very slow and very development position in American society in which a religious society, mostly in the hinterland, became its own subculture, even more Protestant than the rest of an otherwise Protestant country. [1:08:59] A coalition was formed in the 18th and 19th centuries of Ivy League divinity students and backcountry preachers, a new faithful that largely avoided urban America and whose sermonizing often led to eye rolls from everyday folk, even in the countryside. As the 18th century progressed, these believers, most of them Methodists and Baptists, felt increasingly alienated by Enlightenment circles and despised the deists. Although many were fervent supporters of the American Revolution, believing that victory over Britain proved God's favor to America, his new Jerusalem, these people were skeptical of the attitudes and the priorities of the early American Republic. Unhappily split between the Federalist and the Democratic Republican camps, these fire and brimstone preachers saw the election of 1800 as a contest between the great Satan, Thomas Jefferson, and the little Satan, John Adams. Yale President Timothy Dwight, who we recently mentioned due to his interest in Hawaii, believed that America was riddled with demonic cults operating in the name of Enlightenment. [1:10:14] One of the first conspiracy theorists to invoke the Illuminati, he believed that banned group of Bavarian intellectuals had spurred the revolution in France, causing a domino effect that would put deists and atheists in power across Europe and America. Like many kindred spirits, Timothy Dwight thought the Freemasons were involved in this satanic conspiracy as well, apparently to the shock and discomfort of the sitting Freemason-in-Chief, President George Washington. Dwight's reputation was not really tarnished by these claims, but they weren't taken seriously by American-educated circles. After Thomas Jefferson's success in the election of 1800 and the ensuing long period of dominance by his Democratic-Republican Party, interest faded in supposed Jacobin devils manipulating America. But the concept of satanic conspiracy and satanic temptation remained prominent anywhere these kinds of powerful, fiery sermons were popular, such as the mountains of northern New England, upstate New York, and all the way down the spine of the Appalachians. [1:11:23] Moving into the 19th century, by this period, Satan had mostly retreated from political discourse, really only emerging in periods of shocking violence, like the Civil War and the assassination of Abraham Lincoln. But outside the well-built brownstones of coastal writers and scholars, rural Americans kept up a strong interest and fear of the devil. We see this in visual art, with little wooden and zinc figurines of Satan made as a constant reminder of the temptation to sin, or the New England quilting pattern of the devil's puzzle said to keep demons away from coming in the night. The Huntington Library in Los Angeles recently displayed some very charming pieces of decorative ironwork, like little stove decorations and bootjacks, forged by 19th century artisans into tiny stick-figure Satans. In so many ways, the devil was everywhere, not only in the psychology of early Americans, but even in their material culture. [1:12:19] I think these artistic motifs do reflect a real belief in supernatural entities all throughout the 19th century. One famous example is in 1820s, Tennessee, when the Bell family of frontier slave owners claimed to be plagued by an invisible spirit, widely interpreted as a witch or a demon. The entire family, as well as their slaves, reporting disturbing apparitions day and night, such as strange black dogs walking around the estate or hanging corpses of young girls. Teenage daughter Betsy Bell claimed that this so-called Bell Witch was scratching and slapping her, pulling her hair, bringing to mind the testimonies of the girls supposedly possessed at Salem. The Bell Witch episode ended with the death of Father John Bell, caused by a series of violent seizures attributed to this haunting. This story was widely circulated in print across the 19th century, with later embellishments including that the Bells had built their home over an Indian burial ground, or that even General Andrew Jackson was haunted by this being. [1:13:28] But the strongest evidence for the diabolical worldview of 19th-century Americans, who we should remember, were mostly isolated farmers living simple and oftentimes precarious existences, is recorded in music. Per the great folklorist Alan Lomax, early America saw the devil as a real and living personage. Rocks in New England were scarred by his hoofprints as he carried off maidens, screaming and howling, over the hills, or came after the men who sold their souls to him in return for money or success. A mountain woman tells of the last moments of her mean old husband. I know he were going because all the dogs from fur and nigh come around and howled. But plain as day, come down yon side of the mountain, I seen the devil coming. He were riding a coal black cart, driving a coal black oxen. The cart come down to the door and we stopped. [1:14:22] When it come, it come empty. But when it went away, it had a big black ball in it. My husband's soul. [1:14:31] Yeah, European settlers on the American frontier brought with them a bunch of folk traditions stretching countless generations into the past. Most American folk songs, in particular narrative ballads, come from early modern or medieval antecedents. This means that there are often New World and Old World versions of the same song. These songs are best preserved in the Appalachians, probably due to the long period of relative isolation. Appalachian folk songs are generally derived from English and Scottish roots and usually have modern-day counterparts in Britain. But the American versions tend to differ greatly, not just in their modal and minor-key melodies and the plucky banjo accompaniment, but also in lyrics and, weirdly, in theology. This is because many traditional British folk songs incorporate some belief, or at least the lingering interest, in elves or fairies. Some of these songs have American counterparts, but what's really fascinating to us is that England's more whimsical supernatural beings are often swapped out for the most malevolent of spirits, Satan himself. [1:15:37] A common trickster motif is seen in Riddles Wisely Expounded, the first of a famous list of ballads collected by pioneering folklorist Francis James Child. In this song, a conniving male figure, often an elf, traps some innocent, typically a young woman, only letting her go if she can answer his riddles. The American equivalent strips away any seductive element and replaces the pointy ears with pointy horns. Alan Lomax collected an Appalachian version called The Devil's Nine Questions, performed by a singer named Texas Gladden. While this motif usually ends with the innocent singer defeating the devil, another popular song, The Farmer's Cursed Wife, involves an unhappy woman who was dragged down to hell by Satan after she refused to submit to her husband. But after being sent to her eternal torment, she is no less independent and strongarms her way to escaping from hell. 1950s folk singer Jean Ritchie has a version with an explicit feminist twist because when, quote, two little devils come a rattling their chains, she hauled back her cudgel and knocked them out their brains. [1:17:12] The song concludes with the note, Oh, the women are so much better than the men. When they go to hell, they get sent back again. This song might be derived from a folklore tradition known as Jack Tales, prominent in Scotland, England, and early America, in which a young man outsmarts the trickster figure. The most famous story in this tradition is, of course, Jack and the Beanstalk, which really needs no elaboration. One example more relevant to the story and to the spooky season upon us are the Irish stories of Jack-O'Lantern, namesake of the carved pumpkin. Supposedly, the devil came upon a known drunkard named Stingy Jack and tempted him to buy a drink by transforming himself into a silver coin, with which his would-be victim could buy a glass or five of whiskey. However, Jack had a crucifix in his pocket, which prevented the devil from leaving his numismatic shape. [1:18:02] When this man died and went to hell, he was just as troublesome towards the devil. Satan got tired of Jack and sent him back to Earth as a ghost, giving him a lantern carved from a tuned turnip to guide his way between the spirit realm and the mortal plane every Halloween. [1:18:18] Yeah, and so you know, the Roud Folk Song Index, which is a sweeping catalog of American, British, and Irish folk music, has collected more than a thousand songs about the devil. Many of these pieces can be traced to the 17th century or earlier, when the diabolical worldview was basically universal in the English-speaking world. Dangers of Satan would recur in American lyrics and American mythology across the 19th and 20th centuries, not only in the mountains of Appalachia, but in the lowlands below. Southern ministers, both black and white, tended to discuss the devil with much more fervor than their northern counterparts. African-American gospel singers frequently warned about Satan. One song first recorded in 1927 reminds us that God is my father, Jesus is my brother, but the devil's no relation at all. Many preachers in the 20s and 30s worried that while their congregants might spend their Sunday mornings in the pews, they passed their Saturday nights in the juke joint, listening to the blues, often considered the devil's music due to its association with sex and alcohol. [1:19:23] Immortal guitarist Robert Johnson transformed American music forever in just 27 short years. He was so skilled on the fretboard that stories developed, probably after his death, that he'd met the devil on the crossroads on a Mississippi night. Johnson sold his soul to be a master at the guitar. Speaking of Satan and strings, we would be remiss if we did not mention the association of the devil with fiddling. We've all heard Charlie Daniels' The Devil Went Down to Georgia, one of at least a tiny few charting hits to feature a violin solo. But this tradition goes back much further, at least as far back as the 1830s, when Niccolo Paganini gave a performance so furious and so fiery, it was rumored Satan himself must be guiding the bow. Similar Robert Johnson-type stories were projected backwards in time toward the earlier musician Giuseppe Tartini, who made his own Faustian pact to perform his athletic sonata in G minor, known to later audiences as the Devil's Trill Sonata. [1:21:13] Musicologist Mai Kawabata writes that the demonic association with the violin probably goes back to the Middle Ages. The rock stars and blues men of their day, medieval viol players, were notorious seducers. Because bowed instruments entered Europe through the East from the Byzantine lands, there might have been some element of foreignness. One popular American fiddle tune is called The Devil's Dream, said to have been taught to its composer by Satan himself. This corresponds with English and Irish stories about melodies being whispered by the fairies. In at least one case in Scotland, a young woman accused of witchcraft was said to have actually attempted to beat the devil at a music contest. Tragically, unlike Johnny in The Devil Went Down to Georgia, this young woman ends up being accused and condemned of witchcraft. We don't know whether or not she won the contest. While mainstream belief in a personified Satan faded in educated and literary circles across the 19th century, Satan remained alive in pop culture and letters. [1:22:26] A famous example is Nathaniel Hawthorne's short story, Young Goodman Brown, in which an idealistic Puritan witnesses a satanic witch's Sabbath. The devil declares this congregation, Goodman Brown's own neighbors, as his sinful children. This night it shall be granted to you to know their secret deeds, how hoary bearded elders of the church have whispered wanton words to the young maids of their household, how many a woman, eager for widow's weeds, has given her husband a drink at bedtime and let him sleep his last in her bosom, how beardless youths have made haste to inherit their father's wealth, how fair damsels have dug little graves in the garden and bidden me the sole guest to an infant funeral. When Goodman Brown returns to his village, he can't abide this hypocrisy by his Puritan neighbors and ends up questioning his faith due to what he saw. He lives a long life, but Hawthorne writes, they carved no hopeful verse upon his tombstone, for his dying hour was gloom. [1:23:29] Personally, I think this story could maybe be interpreted as a critique of traditional Christian views of Satan and of sin. If we demand complete stainless morality from our community, a perfection that none but God can meet, we find ourselves unable to love and forgive those around us. Forgiveness is, of course, central to the preaching of Christianity per the New Testament. I do think this is what Hawthorne was getting at. A very different take on Satan can be seen in another fun story. Stephen Vincent Benét's The Devil and Daniel Webster, written in 1836 and set a century prior, drawing on the rich folkloric traditions of New England. Sam, you were the one who encouraged me to watch this, and I really want to thank you for it. Please give us your thoughts on the movie. [1:24:24] Yeah, well, it's a classic. I just came upon it totally by accident during the time when we were prepping for The Legend of Sierra Madre, and I was just looking up all these films that Walter Huston, who plays the father, who plays the old miner in that movie that he starred in. And he plays Satan in this one. So I just started watching it and it was very interesting. And then I got to a certain point where there's the trial between the devil trying to claim this guy's soul. And it turns out, oh, wait, this is very familiar. This is like something The Simpsons parodied in one of the Treehouse of Horror episodes. Yeah, and so in that way, I was already familiar with this American classic. [1:25:11] Yeah, yeah. So if you hadn't seen it, the movie, which is 1941, written just five years after the short story, it follows strapping young farmer Jabez Stone, who, faced with hard times, turns his back on his pious New England family to make a seemingly lucrative deal with the devil, Old Scratch, played by a rakish, mustachioed, and of course, fiddle-playing Walter Huston. Scratch promises great rewards that ultimately lead Jabez Stone to ruin, including the assistance of an enticing French maid played by Simone Simon, better known as the star of the movie, Cat People. Watch it if you haven't. After alienating his wife and his mother and potentially forfeiting the soul of his young son, Jabez Stone persuades famed American lawyer Daniel Webster to take his case. Echoing a famous tweet about that Charlie Daniels song: the presence of the demonic in this film is not a metaphor for sin. [1:26:10] Webster's challenge is not part of any cautionary tale about pride. Instead, he really can beat the devil, giving a happy ending to Jabez Stone and his family and basically everybody except the audience. Because in the most famous fourth wall break in American cinema, in the last shot of the movie, Satan cheats straight to the camera and knows that any one of us might be his next victim. [1:26:37] Yeah, yeah, so it's really a fantastic movie. And like, especially after I read the story, I was just thinking about how subversive it really was. It's like they added a lot of stuff to this movie to really flesh it out. And the story is just like sort of yada yada yadas Jabez Stone's time as someone who signed a deal with Satan. But here, like, we see like his corruption in his soul as he like becomes like he goes from a hardworking yeoman farmer really living the ideal artisan life who's like very thoughtful and attentive of his neighbors' needs to someone who really becomes a capitalist and is writing all these contracts that screw over his neighbors and by the end of it is just like totally hated by everyone. And I was just like trying to figure out if that was you know intentional. And as it turns out, it kind of was. [1:27:38] The director, although he didn't have any like, as far as I know, he didn't have any concrete political affiliations. He was, nevertheless, like someone who was accused of being a communist. And he wasn't outright banned like the other people who were forced before the House of Un-American Activities was, but he was sort of graylisted. And that sort of pushed him to move back to Germany from whence he had immigrated. But yeah, there's a lot of really fun stuff we were hitting on when we were discussing the making of this episode. For instance, the fact that Jabez Stone seems to have the same initials as Joseph Smith and similarly was involved in treasure hunting and all these kinds of things. And like, yes. Like, I don't know, Liam. I just like, like, I haven't been able to find any evidence that this was intentional on the part of Benét or anyone else, but I just cannot erase this parallel from my mind. [1:28:42] What do you think? [1:28:43] It's very, I know, it's very interesting, man. No, I know. Well, you know, look, on the subject of, I don't know, Mormonism and American religion, we want to end this one by moving from the 1940s in this movie through the later 20th and early 21st century and to see the ways that Satan in various forms survives in our discourse. So, as an I don't know about you, Sam, but as an elementary school in the Bush era, I knew several kids who were not allowed to watch the Harry Potter movies because witches were real. I knew kids who couldn't celebrate Halloween because that was the devil's birthday. For any non-Americans listening, these are not standard or particularly common beliefs in America, but they are ideas that are taught in certain churches, mostly evangelical and Baptist congregations. Not very common, but common enough. This is to say that enough of a belief in a literal Satan has persisted in America that sometimes satanic panics do indeed still occur. [1:29:55] Beginning in the early 1980s, there was a resurgence of satanic concerns on the political right. Huge numbers of otherwise normal American Christians froze with terror at the thought that young people, including potentially their own children, were being seduced into devil worship by rock music, horror movies, and tabletop role-playing games. In some cases, these young deviants then turned to violence, killing their siblings or parents as some part of devilish delusion induced by some electronic Tituba. During this infamous episode, thousands of people in the United States and beyond were accused of involvement in violent supernatural organizations. The most famous of these incidents involved the McMartin Preschool in Southern California. Except for one possible incident of a cult cartel violence in Mexico, no murderous demon-worshiping cult was ever proven to really exist. I would argue that the obsession with paranormal ritual interfered with actual abuse allegations, particularly the abuse of children by trusted adults. [1:31:05] In 1988, television host Geraldo Rivera baselessly suggested that so much human sacrifice was happening in America that children were now being conceived specifically for this purpose. While Geraldo would walk back this claim in the 90s, by which point America's lurid fever had dropped, this period is a good reminder that Satan and Satanism continued to inspire fear and action among Americans into the information age. However, unlike the witch trials of the Middle Ages and the early modern period, this modern satanic panic did not usually involve belief in literal diabolism. Few, if any, of the people agitating against these supposed demonic cults believed that anybody had signed a real pact with the devil. If a literal Satan was invoked at all during this panic, it was argued that Satan's abstract plan involves alienating children from their parents and guiding their hands toward brutal ritualized violence. It would not be until decades after these allegations were made that supernatural demonology would re-emerge in fringe online circles, both among alternative spiritualists and hardline evangelical Christians. [1:32:22] This brings us back to Dr. Stella Immanuel in 2020 and her theories about demon sperm. I think the satanic panic and the involved fears of human sacrifice and ritual abuse had more to do with the long backlash to 1960s counterculture than anything else. Recurrent nightmares of the Manson family haunted straight-laced Americans. The reactionary tenor of the Ronald Reagan presidency bolstered fears of the other and galvanized conservatives into turning paranoid suspicions into legal allegations. Since 9-11 and the ensuing rise of nativist reaction, small but significant numbers of Christian conservatives have insisted the devil is working hard to undermine America through the gay rights movement, through terrorist attacks and mass shootings, even through the economic rise of atheistic China. While these figures like Dr. Immanuel are very fringe, I think some more metaphorical aspects of the diabolical worldview survive in modern discussions of unspeakable acts. Satan no longer lurks behind every rock or in the stables among our goats, but we still believe that evil is something distinct from normal human behavior. [1:33:41] It's comforting to believe that the devil made a father abuse his own child, and not that such violence can often happen under the auspices of the nuclear family. We would rather believe that Americans and Europeans support far-right policies due to foreign interference than due to decades of simmering prejudice paired with economic alienation. The alternative leaves us like young Goodman Brown, disgusted with the knowledge that all of our neighbors are worthless sinners. To quote again from W. Scott Poole: Moral evil is writ large in the story of the human experience. The suffering and meaningless death inflicted by the human tendency to destroy, maim, rape, and plunder is a central theme running through the history of every civilization on earth. While every major religious tradition has celebrated values of compassion, benevolence, and mercy, the societies that gave birth to these ideas have been built on mounds of corpses. [1:34:45] Rather than thinking through the complexities of the problem of evil, why we practice aggression or violence, or why suffering seems imposed on others, even when human agency is absent, the human tendency is simply to declare the other as evil. The image of the devil in human history has provided the simplest answer to the problem of evil in all its forms. How is it that human beings capable of acts of self-sacrifice and moral magnificence are also able to perpetrate the greatest of horrors? One answer has been the power of an evil dark force that has helped corrupt us from the beginning of time. A devil that embodies all of our aggression and rage without any of our capacity for moral imagination. I think Poole's description not only summarizes literal diabolism, but also the more metaphysical ideas about the devil which survive in our discourse. It's easy to see why Satan was invented thousands of years ago by Iron Age farmers trying to understand the horrors and hardships of everyday life. [1:35:52] But the belief that Satan is real, either as literal and monstrous, or abstract and pernicious, frustrates our understanding of humanity at its worst. If we can't understand this, our own basest impulses and abilities to enact horrible harm on others, I don't think we have much hope for raising us to our best. Personally, I'm optimistic that one day we may be able to beat the devil like Daniel Webster did. But this can't happen until we exorcise him completely from our worldview, no matter what that implies about ourselves. I know that's kind of scary, but hey, that is what Halloween is all about. All right, thank you. I hope everybody listening has a very happy Halloween and stay safe from the devil. [1:36:44] Yeah, yeah, don't be making any pacts. It's not good for yourself.