Gladio Free Europe, E120: Historical Jesus https://www.gladiofreeeurope.com/episodes/historical-jesus [0:00:13] Welcome back to Gladio Free Europe. I am Liam, joined here by Russian Sam. [0:00:17] Hello, hello. [0:00:18] As well as our great good friend Grace Cathedral Park. [0:00:22] Hello. [0:00:23] And here, we're trying to do something very special on this podcast. Seeing if we can summarize 2,000 years of religious doctrine in less than two hours. Alright, let's get started. This is going to be a big one. It's a long time coming. We hope you all enjoy. 2,000 years ago, a carpenter was put to death in the hinterlands of the Roman Empire. He died on a cross. This was an instrument of both execution and torture intended to humiliate its victims in their final hours and shame them before all their friends and relations. It was used particularly on those who were thought to have upset the order of Roman society. At the time, the circumstances of this carpenter's life and his death were not considered exceptional. Nobody thought to record a single word about him while he was alive. Outside of a very small circle of close friends and supporters, nothing was written about him within living memory as well. [0:01:19] But in the century after his death, stories about this carpenter began to spread, first told by those who had once walked with him on his ministry, as well as his closest relations. It came to be believed that he was not a typical man, but a remarkable Jewish teacher so wise and so holy that he could perform miraculous acts just like the prophets of old. What's more, his death was unlike any other death in human history. Very soon after he had died, these supporters began to believe that their teacher had come back from the dead through divine intervention. God had blessed him with eternal life, something he had not given to any human since the creation of Adam and Eve. This man's followers believed that they had a duty to share this good news that a new era of history had begun. This divine exaltation was seen as evidence that their teacher, Jesus of Nazareth, was Christ, the anointed Messiah. [0:02:22] He would return in glory to take part in the coming judgment in which the righteous would too be exalted and the wicked condemned. As these teachings spread across the Aramaic and Greek-speaking worlds, among Jews and Gentiles alike, this small sect would grow into a new religion, overtaking the Judaism that birthed it, as well as the entire pagan world of the ancient Mediterranean. Just 300 years after this carpenter was nailed to a cross, the children of the men who swung the hammer would believe that truly this man was the Son of God. But who was Jesus really? What is actually known about the ancient individual whose life and death would become the state religion of the entire Roman Empire, and from there, the basis of the largest religion in history? In 1991, biblical scholar John Meier described the problem of this historical Jesus as one of the greatest puzzles of modern religious scholarship. [0:03:23] Whatever can be recovered from such efforts will always remain a scientific construct, and that this academic search can provide only a theoretical abstraction, does not and cannot coincide with the full reality of Jesus of Nazareth, as he actually lived and worked in Palestine during the first century of our era. However, on this podcast, we don't think any such search is futile. Because through the use of modern research methods, more sophisticated textual analysis, and innovations in archaeology, we can have a broader understanding of the origins of Christianity and the figure around which this entire movement is centered. Historian and one-time clergyman Diarmaid MacCulloch has said that at the end of the day, Christianity is a personality cult, a religion of billions centered around the life of one. Followers of this one individual would exalt him to a greater extent than any other leader of any other world religion. [0:04:20] Jesus would be hailed first as a Messiah, then as the Son of God, and ultimately as God himself. The Christian religion has shaped every aspect of Western civilization, and it had profound impacts on many other parts of the world as well. I don't think we can even discuss the Western world in any meaningful sense prior to the rise of this religion. Understanding the figure at the center of this movement is thus of paramount importance not only to Christians, but to scholars of humanities across the board. There can be no doubt that we have today a better understanding of who Jesus really was than we did at any time since the first or second centuries. Some Christians would scoff at this, insisting that the Bible and religious tradition already tells us enough. Evangelical Protestants in particular tend to be very hostile towards historical and archaeological investigations into the life of Jesus and the apostles. [0:05:07] But critical biblical scholarship is not an anti-religious endeavor by any means. John Meier himself was a Roman Catholic priest, directly celebrated by Pope John Paul II for his academic accomplishments. Meier believed that secular scholarship, fully independent of the weight of later tradition, was necessary for pious Christians to better understand their own religion. He is not the only Catholic clergyman to take an interest in the rationalist study of Jesus and the Bible. Other scholars who personally hold religious convictions believe that while their academic methods cannot prove the reality of supernatural events that they believe to be true, this kind of research can make real the cultural and social world in which Jesus and the apostles lived. This line of inquiry, what groundbreaking scholar Albert Schweitzer termed the quest for the historical Jesus, is thus of paramount importance to historians, to theologians, and to many members of the public, both Christian and non-Christian alike. [0:05:54] Jesus is the most written-about figure in world history, and books written about Jesus from a secular perspective are extremely common. Some of these books, despite their popularity, make claims that are not supported by any kind of academic consensus. Dan Brown's The Da Vinci Code comes to mind, as well as other related works. [0:06:10] Yeah, you know, and so I'll just say, you know, popular discussions of Jesus and his existence can be very fun. And I have to say, personally, as somebody who was not raised in a religious background, that was really my first entry into this whole line of study. I took a little bit of New Testament classes in college. I had a great professor who I'm going to mention here. And I was kind of shocked that my lay understanding of Christianity, which was informed from popular culture as well as from the kind of counter-narrative of stuff like the Da Vinci Code, was really very far from the current scholarly consensus. And that led to a long interest in the composition of the Bible and particularly development of Christianity, which I really got into most particularly over the past couple of years. Any of you guys who follow me on Twitter will see that I post about these kinds of topics pretty often. [0:07:07] Jackson, I wanted to ask: what exactly got you into early religious history? Because I know that you have kind of a different personal background than I do. [0:07:15] Yeah, so I was going to say that unlike you both, I went to Catholic school from basically when I started going to school until high school. So I received, as part of elementary and middle school education, I had to do religion classes. And obviously they teach you about the gospels and they teach you like the narrative, but they also teach you about a lot of the theology. I was kind of a like rebellious and kind of shitty Reddit atheist as a middle schooler. And so I was like, no, fuck off. This is wrong. But then as I got kind of older, I was like, okay, well, maybe the theology stuff is not like the truth, but the actual like stories of the Bible and like, especially of the New Testament, are still interesting. And there must be sort of like more to it than just like a Catholic education will tell you. [0:08:07] And so I kind of got into it for that way because like I read the Bible when I was in middle school. And like, so these are sort of, they're stories that like have a lot of, they were sort of drilled into me very deeply as like a child. And so the New Testament stuff for me is sort of, I also have a lot of the surprise when I read something that is counter to like the popular conception of the New Testament or to like Jesus as he was, like as he was like on earth. I also am sort of interested in it because it really does sort of put these really formative and like, I guess, identity forming sort of moments of the past. It puts them into a very new perspective that is kind of interesting to explore because it's like, oh, when I was a kid, I thought this way, but like, oh, it's actually this way. [0:08:52] Like, there's something that is really interesting about sort of uncovering this, not necessarily like the lies or whatever, or like the falsehoods of this early education, but just to like understand the complexity of it is really interesting to me and it's what got me into it. [0:09:07] Yeah, absolutely. And even if it's not the capital T truth, it is a truth. Like, this is something that influences the worldview of what, 2 billion people at this point. It just has to be grappled with. [0:09:17] Yeah, and I think that even if you are not personally Christian, or even if you don't have a, you don't think that theology seems interesting, I think that understanding standard Christian views about Jesus does help explain a lot of elements about European history, even our art and music, and I think just kind of, you know, broadens your understanding of human culture in a way. But we want to talk about how all of that began, beginning with the concept of the historical Jesus, the real individual at the core of this religion, as you're saying, Sam, of two billion people. And I do want to emphasize here that it is, in fact, the life of a real person that this all comes from. Because despite what many people on the internet like to say, it is extremely unlikely that the figure of Jesus of Nazareth is wholly fictitious. [0:10:08] I think that actually this is a nice place to start just to get this out of the way. Before we even get into reconstructing who Jesus could have been, I want to explain why we know that there was a Jesus at all. Because for centuries now, there has been a persistent body of literature, basically an entire genre, often referred to as mythicism, which purports that there was, in fact, no historical Jesus at all. [0:10:36] Yeah, so at least since the 18th century, there was a group of people called deists, into whom we're going to dive a little bit greater, who proposed that Jesus was a myth in total. From a Christian perspective, this is the ultimate iconoclasm, because all scripture and worship that Christian civilization is built upon is a complete fabrication. This position is very popular on the internet, largely among people who are very critical of Christianity, even if they are understandably so, because although we like to think that we live in an enlightened society, religious beliefs are still very strong in American culture and politics, sometimes in very detrimental ways. So, according to this line of reason, if Jesus never existed whatsoever, then the entire system of oppression could be revealed to be built on a foundation of sand and destroyed in total. But unfortunately, this argument is fundamentally untenable. [0:11:23] Mythicists are correct that we do not have any early first-hand accounts of the people who knew Jesus, but this is the norm for all individuals in antiquity. Even the lives of extremely significant Greek and Roman politicians, figures much more famous in their own time than Jesus, are often known from sources which were recorded decades, if not centuries later. Both Christians and mythicists often do not realize how little information is available about any given ancient individual and how much we need to rely on texts written by people who did not know these figures and often have significant biases for or against them. [0:11:54] Right, so let's look at Spartacus, who, much like Jesus, is a figure who was brutally crucified for destabilizing the social order of the Roman state only about a century earlier. The earliest references we have to the life of Spartacus were not recorded until decades after his death by Plutarch and Livy and Sallust. Additionally, these sources are more fragmentary than the earliest biblical texts about Jesus, and no less biased against their subject than the early Roman references to Jesus. But nobody, whether in academia or on the internet, would seriously doubt that Spartacus existed. I think another figure we've discussed on this podcast before might be an even better comparison. Johann Faust was a real historical figure, a controversial alchemist with close ties to the German aristocracy and some high-ranking members of the Catholic Church. Yet, Faust was charged in his own lifetime of sodomy and necromancy. Unlike Jesus, we have surviving references to this figure made when he was alive. [0:12:53] But the actual historical record of Johann Faust has very little bearing on the Dr. Faustus of myth. Faust today is much more of a literary character than a historical personage. Not the alchemist accused of being gay and doing crimes, but the brilliant scholar who made a pact with the devil to learn all knowledge that remained beyond his reach. While historians today are able to separate this Faustian fact from fiction, within just a few decades of Faust's death, fabulous stories about his contact with devils had circulated wildly and eventually totally replaced any historical memory of the actual guy. I want to note that the gap in time between the life of Faust and the publication of these first mythical stories, in German, the Faustbücher, is pretty similar to the difference in time between the death of Jesus and the composition of our earliest gospel, the Gospel of Mark. [0:13:47] Just like the stories of Faust, Mark turns Jesus into a supernatural figure who performed acts that rationalist methods cannot prove to be possible. He was even in contact with demons. While these sources are thus extremely unreliable, the presence of corroborating references in other material means we can assert with a very high degree of confidence that Jesus, just like Faust, really existed. But the Christ of the Gospels and the Dr. Faustus of literature should be understood as mythological constructions created by legendary elaborations upon a real individual's life. This happened through stories being told and retold over several decades by individuals with extremely passionate religious convictions, but not necessarily any close contact with the figures involved. Okay, and before we get into the life of Jesus proper, I do want to bring up one last point, which is the ongoing scholarly struggle between minimalism and maximalism. I just want to note, getting started here, that there are broadly two big poles in contemporary study of the life of the historical Jesus: those who believe that Christian writings tell us very little about the real guy, and those who believe they tell us quite a lot. [0:15:00] So, the letters of Paul of Tarsus, as well as the four canonical gospels, are our earliest known Christian texts. They were composed across a wide period, beginning with Paul around 50 CE, about 20 years after Jesus died, and continuing until around 100 or 110 CE with the composition of the final canonical gospel, the Gospel of John. As we see with the example of Faust, in just a few decades, a lot of really wild claims can circulate and gain currency. Thus, exactly how much credence we should give these early Christian writings is a major preoccupation of biblical scholars. I would argue that the primary work of this whole, you know, section of academia is parsing through surviving Christian writings, including those that were not accepted into the biblical canon, the Apocrypha, to determine what exactly we can really know about Jesus and early ideas about him. Scholars known as minimalists believe that what we can truly know about Jesus is very little. [0:16:02] In fact, it's not much more than what we've said in this episode's introduction, that he was killed upon a cross and had a following. But most experts in the 21st century would disagree. They argue that actually, Christian writings would not have circulated among early believers if they were purely fictitious. These so-called maximalist scholars use careful study of surviving materials to see which stories or motifs could potentially be reliable. Two criteria in particular are used in analyzing Christian sources to see what material might actually attest to the real life of the historical Jesus. Sam, why don't you get into what these two big criteria are? [0:16:42] The big one is multiple attestation, which means do two different early writers make the same claim. For example, interactions between Jesus and John the Baptist are recorded in all four Gospels. John's existence is further corroborated by the writings of Josephus. Thus, most scholars, except for some hardline minimalists, believe that it's most likely that these two historic figures did have some kind of association. Jesus may very well have been a follower of John prior to beginning his own ministry. In contrast, many aspects of modern Christian doctrine are only attested in a single source, including some very major concepts. Probably most of all is the notion that Jesus is God. This idea is fundamental to essentially all of the Christian movements today, but it is not present in the earliest of the three Gospels, and it is not in our earliest Christian source, the writings of Paul. Instead, the notion that Jesus is God, co-equal with the Heavenly Father, comes from the Gospel of John, the last of the four canonical gospels to be composed and the most mystical in its Christology, meaning that it's spiritual construction of Jesus. [0:17:41] Bart Ehrman believes that the fact that this claim only exists in a single source is enough to dismiss it as a later invention, probably by an early Christian community whose views of Jesus were much more heavenly than the other believers. This is because if Jesus really went around saying he was God, you would think that at least one other person would mention this. Christian apologists thus try to find indirect examples of Jesus' divinity in earlier texts, but scholars are completely unconvinced because this claim is not multiply attested in different sources. We reconstruct that all or most Christians before the time of the Gospel of John did not teach that Jesus was God. The other big test of Christian writings is the criterion of embarrassment, also called the criterion of dissimilarity. Scholars tend to believe that any episodes around the life of Jesus that seem surprising or unusual, or any quotes that do not jibe with contemporary Christian teachings are especially likely to be authentic. [0:18:32] This is because if something is embarrassing by modern religious standards or dissimilar from the modern theology, it was probably only included and preserved because the gospel authors were insistent that this really happened. Bringing this back to John the Baptist, many scholars have noted Jesus actually appears subordinate to John in the episode of the baptism, as Jesus is the one who is being baptized. John has some kind of beatific power over him. This is not really in accordance with the exalted image of Jesus that the Gospels were trying to portray. Another example is Jesus' view of the apocalypse. Nearly all scholars, even those who are quite minimalist, believe that Jesus thought the end was coming very soon. A major piece of evidence here is language attributed to Jesus, particularly in the Gospels of Matthew and Luke, in which he tells his followers that they will, quote, not taste death before they see the kingdom of God. [0:19:18] In other words, that it would happen within their lifetime. [0:19:20] Yeah, and so these two criteria, you know, the criterion of multiple attestation and the criterion of embarrassment, are really useful in trying to see whether or not there's any kind of historical value we can glean from an ancient text. But minimalist scholars think that this actually might not be enough. Because, you know, regarding multiple attestation, even if two texts might both repeat a claim, that doesn't mean that the source they got it from is necessarily true. It's generally believed that the Christian gospels were only written after about 40 years of oral transmission concerning the life of Jesus. Again, bringing back the example of Faust, we can see how a 40-year-long game of telephone can allow a lot of very wild claims to speculate. And regarding the criterion of embarrassment, scholars point out that this is based on our mental model of what we think early Christians would have believed. [0:20:14] We simply don't know enough about the spiritual and psychological worlds of the first Jesus followers to really know what exactly they would have considered embarrassing. Additionally, as we're going to see with the genealogy of Jesus and Joseph, the concerning the Davidic line, it's possible that some Christians included gestures towards ideas that they did not personally believe, but they know their audience wanted to hear. [0:20:41] Lots of potential compromises across the development of Christian Orthodoxy. Very interesting subject. [0:20:48] Since the middle of the 20th century, I think the tide has turned decisively in favor of the maximalists and against the more skeptical minimalism. Close analysis of the language and interdependence of biblical texts has convinced most, but not all academics that our surviving biblical library contains at least some reliable information about the life of Jesus. In addition, carbon dating has confirmed that the earliest scraps of the biblical manuscripts date no later than the second century. This consensus around dating fully disproves earlier mythicist arguments that the books of the New Testament were composed by the Catholic Church. Instead, we know certainly that these texts were written by Greek-speaking Christians long before Christianity was adopted by the Roman Empire and before there was a Catholic Church in the sense we understand. These texts were instead written by ancient Middle Eastern Christians who were not likely to have been true disciples of Jesus, but may very well have been acquainted with people who had once known Jesus or at least known somebody who had. [0:21:54] We thus have a game of telephone that is still quite problematic, but is no more than a century or a century and a half long. I personally believe this is a short enough of a period of time to preserve valuable and reliable biographical information, but it's extremely difficult to know what pieces of information are valid and which are not. A full account of Jesus' scholarship would require an entire podcast series, not a single episode. What we want to do here is instead of giving an entire account of every aspect of the life of Jesus and the scholarship therein, we want to give a gladio-style account of the matter, briefly charting the history of secular inquiry into the life of Jesus and then situating the real historical carpenter into his ancient Judean context. We would also strongly recommend everybody tune in to our previous episode on the notorious King Herod just to see how turbulent of a world this boy from Nazareth was born into. [0:22:55] Additionally, if anybody would like to contribute our own 30 pieces of silver, I would now remind you that we do also have a Patreon. All right, Sam, tell us about the earliest Christian references to the life of Jesus, both in the Gospels and beyond. [0:23:12] Yeah, well, the trouble is that we're not exactly sure when the first accounts of Jesus' life were committed to writing, but it's likely that this happened at the edge of living memory of him. Early followers of Jesus, most notably the disciple Peter, also known as Cephas or Simon, spread oral stories of his life, death, and supposed miraculous rebirth across Judea. Within just a few years after this early missionary activity began, the entire Jesus movement came to be spearheaded by Paul, an educated Greek Jew who had not known Jesus but who joined the movement after some kind of vision. Early sources attest that Peter and Paul disagreed on important matters, including on the role of non-Jewish Gentiles within the coming kingdom. Largely as a way of setting the record straight, followers of Jesus in the first century began writing down their accounts of Jesus and his significance. [0:23:57] Of the first generation of Jesus' followers, only the writings of Paul survive. This is troubling as Paul did not know Jesus, and moreover, Paul says very little about the life or even teachings of Jesus in his letters. What matters instead is the spiritual significance of Jesus' miraculous resurrection. It's extremely difficult to perceive what Paul believed about Jesus' life, and it's basically impossible to discern what other Jesus followers would have believed. But these lost oral traditions, particularly those circulating for decades in the middle of the first century, likely formed the core of contemporary Christian narrative. And so after Paul died around 60 or 70 CE, our earliest surviving biographical account was produced. This was the Gospel of Mark. Proponents of a two-source theory argue that around the same time, a second lost text was made, which may have been mostly comprised of the sayings of Jesus. These two sources, as well as additional material from the oral tradition, give us the Gospel of Matthew and the Gospel of Luke. [0:24:51] Other oral stories, likely dating back to this earlier period, are attested outside of the Bible, in the writings of the early church fathers, in the apocryphal gospels that were not included in the modern Bible, and even in traditions outside of Christianity. A story about the child Jesus bringing clay birds to life was so widely circulated that it even made its way into the Quran. By the end of the first century, Christianity was a somewhat well-established religion with churches across the entire Eastern Mediterranean as well as in the city of Rome itself. It's probably by this point, largely due to the efforts of the Hellenistic Jew Paul, the religion was more Greek than Jewish. Most Christians came to the religion from a pagan background, and pagan ideas about divinity may have begun to influence the conception of Jesus as the Son of God, like Romulus or Hercules. [0:25:34] We can say with more confidence that Greek philosophical concepts began to crystallize in the movement around this point. Many Hellenistic Jews, including Paul, interpreted their religion with the assistance of pagan philosophers such as Plato. The Platonic theory of forms clearly contributed to a new understanding of the mortal soul and the oneness of God. These ideas are clearly present in the book of John, the last of the four canonical gospels, and the most mystical in its portrayal of Jesus. [0:25:58] Yeah, so we're going to return to the Gospels time and time again, and we're going to mention the ways that they portray each a somewhat different portrayal of Jesus. But these four Gospels, as well as many non-canonical texts, came to be widely circulated across the Christian world, even outside the Roman Empire, in the second and third century. After the end of the third century, which was particularly tumultuous for Rome, Christianity was surprisingly proclaimed the official religion by the Emperor Constantine. Then, in 325, the famous Council of Nicaea codified the four Gospels, the letters of Paul, and some other writings into what we today call the New Testament. Some scholars debate the actual significance of the Council of Nicaea, but it did codify what was previously termed proto-Orthodox Christianity into an official sect. Christians of this sect were eventually given legal authority to marginalize other Christian movements that were also quite widespread across the Roman world and led to what we understand Christian Orthodoxy to be today. [0:27:04] Across the 1600 years after the Council of Nicaea, generations upon generations of Christian writers, many of them cloistered monks, would carefully study canonical Christian writings and attempt to reconcile its internal diversity as well as the many apparent contradictions across the biblical canon. This is because although the Council of Nicaea presented the New Testament as the one word of God, this divinely inspired manuscript, it is what scholars call multivocal. Many different individuals contributed to the compilation of the Old Testament and the New Testament. Every one of these individuals would have had a somewhat different perspective on divinity than the other writers. Due to these various inconsistencies concerning, for instance, the genealogy of Jesus, the place of birth of Jesus, this led to many seemingly improbable developments in Christian tradition that sought to reconcile the internal diversity of the Gospels. We see within Christian tradition major proclamations about Jesus and his followers that are present nowhere in the Gospels, but might be a way of explaining away certain inconsistencies. [0:28:16] One example is the idea that Mary, mother of Jesus, was not only a virgin upon the birth of her son, but was in fact a virgin for his entire life. Another one of these major proclamations is the notion that the Gospels of Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John were indeed written by Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John. This comes from close inference based on the text of the Gospels, but in fact, each of these books was written anonymously, and few serious scholars attribute their authorship to those individuals today. The humanist movement of the 15th century and the Protestant Reformation of the 16th century led to a new scrutiny over the authenticity of certain presuppositions of Christian tradition, as well as challenging both the monopoly and the authenticity of the Latin Bible used by the Catholic Church. After all, the Bible had originally been written in Hebrew and Greek. [0:29:04] During the 18th-century Enlightenment, there were many new developments in rationalist thought deriving from the humanist movement, which led to more significant aspects of Christianity being brought into question, including one of the basic assumptions of Nicene Christianity, deriving from the Gospel of John. That being the assumption that Jesus is in fact God. The first person to question Jesus' divinity outright from a specifically rationalist Enlightenment lens was Hermann Samuel Reimarus. He was a Hamburger born in 1694, and he was the first scholar brave enough to apply contemporary historical methods to the life of Jesus and to come to the conclusion that Jesus was not in fact the Son of God, but rather a specifically Jewish apocalyptic prophet whose message was later transformed by the apostles to create a new religion. Reimarus was essentially a deist. We mentioned these guys earlier, but in brief, these were people who held that God was real and the ultimate source of the universe, but he was not the god of organized religion. [0:29:57] A common analogy you'll hear of is God as clockmaker, which is to say that God meticulously put together all the gears and mechanism that make the universe tick. He created the laws of the world and its physical matter, but beyond that, his involvement was minimal. God stepped away from it from his creation and let the clock go on ticking. Hence, there is no divine intervention in our realm or anything else in that matter. Miracles are impossible because God cannot overpower the laws that he established. This is the ultimate Enlightenment idea, applying the reason and logic of the human intellect to make sense of the world. If you can't prove it through rational inquiry, it's not real. They logically held that God must exist as the first mover, for something cannot come out of nothing, but aside from that, they were unhappy with religion as a damper on the human intellect. [0:30:40] Reimarus, like many men of his class, was born into a Lutheran pastoral family, his mother hailing from the Hamburg bourgeoisie. He studied at the Hamburg Academic Gymnasium, and upon graduation, he left his city to study theology, philosophy, and oriental languages in some of Germany's best universities. After a decade of study and travel, he returned to Hamburg to become the teacher of Oriental languages at his high school, a position that he would hold for the remainder of his life. While teaching, he would also publish his philosophical and religious works, but he didn't publish everything. The most explosive of his works on Jesus was, quote, an apology for, or some words in defense of, reasoning worshipers of God. This would not come to light until after his death, and in his own lifetime, it was only given to close friends. Excerpts of it were first published after Lessing published them under the title Fragments of an Anonymous Writer from Wolfenbüttel, just because these claims were so explosive that Reimarus didn't want his family to be impacted by the fact that he was just pulling at these threads. [0:31:39] Yeah, and we should remember that, you know, this is in the 18th century when, you know, the kingdom of Prussia, or whatever state he would have been living in would have had an official state church that he probably would have been obligated to be a member of. [0:31:49] Yeah, exactly. Yeah, so Reimarus was insistent that Jesus sought the creation of a worldly kingdom and hence was an explicit political opponent of both Rome as well as the collaborationist priesthood of the temple who did Rome's bidding. Jesus was not a miracle worker and would be astonished to find out that his followers founded a new religion. He also picked apart contradictions in the various gospels and denied the resurrection. It's really a massive work. It's like 1500 pages. It wouldn't be published in full until like 1981, I believe, just because there wasn't enough interest in reading the whole thing. [0:32:20] That's crazy. [0:32:20] Yeah, no, people were just reading the Lessing bits and they're like, eh, that's enough, I guess. This guy, he was kind of a prolific aura farmer. The favorite thing I found out about him is that 10 days before his death, he invited his friends over for dinner and told him that this would be his last supper. [0:32:38] Yeah, and so basically, so Reimarus is so important because he's the one who really started this entire line of inquiry. He is really the first biblical scholar as we would understand it today. And immediately following his life and his very aura-filled death with his Last Supper, many other scholars in the 18th and 19th century took on the mantle of secular Jesus scholarship. I think the most famous of these is actually Thomas Jefferson, who in fact had his own redacted version of the New Testament that basically took out all of the magical stuff. Many of the scholars following Reimarus actually believed pretty strongly that the individual miracles described in the gospel had happened. They didn't want to think that somebody would have made that up. That would have been dishonest. Instead, many 18th and early 19th century scholars suggested that these supernatural happenings as recorded in the gospels were actually rational, everyday occurrences that had been misunderstood. [0:33:38] Most famously, the progressive Lutheran theologian Heinrich Paulus in the early 19th century denied the resurrection, but not the resurrection narrative, arguing that actually Jesus had fainted or swooned upon the cross. His ensuing recovery was later misinterpreted by his followers as a death and resurrection. Presumably spooked by this near-death encounter, Jesus then ceased preaching, but his followers continued on the message. Again, this was a very popular scholarly pursuit in the 18th and 19th century, and all of these basic counts would then be compiled at the beginning of the 20th century in the famous doctor and amateur theologian Albert Schweitzer's book, The Quest for the Historical Jesus. Schweitzer criticized previous generations of scholars for giving too much credibility to these individual narratives preserved in the Gospels, as they had been written long after Jesus died. He also encouraged scholars to focus more on the apocalyptic nature of Jesus' message. [0:34:43] And just to underscore this point here, scholars really emphasize that Jesus had a more apocalyptic worldview than most Christians today. Eschatology, you know, belief in the end of the world, is still a part of mainstream Christian belief, but seems to have been a major preoccupation of the historical Jesus and earliest generations of followers. We really need to understand early Christian writings in this light, and especially we need to use this context to understand what the historical Jesus might have been talking about. So, after Albert Schweitzer, New Testament scholarship trended actually in a more minimalist direction. Part of this was because other scholars began to look very seriously at connections between Christian theology and pagan religious motifs, which put some other people off of the whole endeavor. Scholars interested in these cross-cultural connections often were very cavalier about analyzing the New Testament as myths in the context of often Greek and Roman mythology. [0:35:47] One of the most famous people of this school was the late Victorian scholar James George Frazer. His work was very important to the field of biblical studies in developing a more mythical, less literal interpretation of events in the Bible and understanding how these so-called mythemes could have very important meaning, even if they do not record factual interpretation. But some other scholars in the mythic school brought biblical scholarship in an unexpected and somewhat unpleasant direction in the early 20th century. Some of these writers, notably Arthur Drews of Germany, argued that the Jesus movement was based around a wholly fictional deity derived not from Judaism, but from pagan Greek and Roman religion. Drews was a German nationalist and somewhat of a racialist who believed that the supposed superiority of the Germans was held back by their adherence to the foreign Christian religion. Although, unlike most of his nationalist contemporaries, Drews was not anti-Semitic. [0:36:49] His work informed later Nazi interpretations of Christianity that sought to remove it from its Jewish origin altogether. Many followers of Arthur Drews developed theories that Jesus was entirely non-Jewish and, despite living his life in the ancient Near East, was a European Aryan. Others used the presence of non-Jews in Galilee, a region sometimes nicknamed Galilee of the Gentiles, to suggest that Jesus came from some unknown, unattested European tribe. One of these claims, which still persists in racial circles today, insisted that Galilee, a name attested as far back as the early Egyptian New Kingdom, really has something to do with the Celtic Gauls. So Jesus was thus somehow not Jewish, but actually an early Frenchman. [0:37:38] Yeah, and I would just add that like the unfortunate association of mythicism about Jesus Christ, especially in Germany, kind of has a like long history. Leftistly inclined listeners are probably familiar. Well, obviously they're familiar with Karl Marx, but they might be familiar with his sort of mentor when he was a doctoral student named Bruno Bauer, who was really one of the first people to put forward a comprehensive explanation of Christianity as like wholly mythical, as like almost entirely made up. And Bruno Bauer did not believe in the historicity of Jesus. And Bauer is sort of most famous for today, I would think, his sort of anti-Semitic, sort of nationalist turn towards the end of his life. And anyone who's ever read The German Ideology or On the Jewish Question by Karl Marx, are kind of familiar with Bauer's sort of bad late-in-life turn. But he this sort of late-in-life turn was sort of maybe not wholly, but at least part of a consequence of his sort of German nationalist interest in Jesus mythicism. [0:38:44] Yeah, and I think there's clearly this anxiety that many anti-Semites had with the fact that this religion, so central to their understanding of European civilization and its supposed superiority, was derived in basically every way from forms of ancient Judaism. And so, you know, previous generations of Christians were very anti-Semitic for theological scriptural reasons. Later anti-Semites had more of a racialist view, and they thus tried to expunge any Jewishness from Christianity altogether. They felt like they had no need to use the scriptural basis for anti-Semitism, they could use skull shapes instead. [0:39:24] Yeah, there's a great, really pithy expression: Was der Jude glaubt, ist einerlei, in dem Blute liegt die Schweinerei. It's like, what the Jew believes is of no regard. It's in the blood that the masses. [0:39:36] Yeah, this transition from religious anti-Semitism toward racial anti-Semitism, which would not have really made sense even to medieval anti-Semites. So we should mention, though, that just at the same time as these odious racialist schools of biblical study were developing, other scholars, both in the German and English-speaking worlds, who were generally disinterested in reconstructing the life of Jesus, did make major breakthroughs in the study of early Christianity. So, because during this more minimalist period, we begin to see increased scholarship, not of Jesus, but of the writings of his first followers, including closer study of the Christian Gospels. During the early 20th century, we begin to see the development of the now predominant theory, the two-source theory, that the two Christian Gospels, Matthew and Luke, both draw from a now lost source known as Q, from the German Quelle. Then, in the aftermath of the Second World War, two enormous archaeological finds would have profound implications on New Testament scholarship. [0:40:40] The first was the uncovery of the Nag Hammadi documents in southern Egypt, giving us new insight into Gnostic movements in early Christianity. And the other was the development of the Dead Sea Scrolls in the Qumran Caves of the West Bank. These were early Jewish texts roughly contemporaneous with the time of Jesus, apparently from a sect known as the Essenes, which gave a lot of really important contextual information into the Jewish world that Jesus would have been born into, as well as the Jewish world of figures like Josephus, King Herod, and many non-Christians of this time. Both of these archaeological discoveries really led to a huge resurgence of interest in New Testament scholarship in the middle of the 20th century, establishing the current fields of biblical critical study. Links between biblical scholarship and the fields of classicism, Jewish studies, and of course archaeology have also allowed scholars to paint a clearer picture of the world that Jesus of Nazareth would have been born into. [0:41:39] John Meier's five-volume work, A Marginal Jew, written I think between 1991 and 2016, it's like 5,000 pages, is probably the most significant collection of texts in this tradition. It's certainly the largest. Other scholars in this contemporary tradition who we want to shout out here are Paula Fredriksen, Dale Allison, Amy-Jill Levine, Robyn Walsh, and Bart Ehrman. The last of these figures is kind of a public intellectual who has done a great job bringing this kind of scholarship to the public, just as we're hoping to do with a much narrower, more online, weirder audience with this episode. And I also want to shout out Dr. Robyn Walsh in particular because she happens to be my former professor, and she really was my greatest guide into this entire world of biblical scholarship and really ancient texts more broadly. I had very little understanding of Christianity when I took her class, and even my understanding of the Greek world was just massively expanded by having her as a teacher. [0:42:34] All right, so here is the big question: what we're really doing this whole podcast to explore: what do we actually know about the life of Jesus? And unfortunately, before we can even begin answering this question, we need to look at the existing evidence. Before we go through the Gospels in order, I want to ask Jackson, because you grew up in a Catholic background, what were your thoughts on how the different gospels differed from each other when you were younger? [0:43:02] Yeah, so obviously, when you are sort of in religious education as a child, they really stress the similarity of the gospels, right? They try and sort of syncretize them, which is understandable and kind of natural. Like, it's kind of what you have to do because they are very different from one another. But when I would, when I was reading the Bible as like a middle schooler, I kind of liked Luke the most because he has the most stuff and like the most stuff happens in Luke. It's sort of the most comprehensive. I thought Mark was kind of boring and like nothing happened, and Matthew was also just kind of boring. Having gone back to some of them, it's really obvious now, and the scholarship has talked about this a lot, that they are very different from one another, and they're arguably trying to do like very different things from one another. [0:43:49] They're not written with the same intent like you're often taught. [0:43:52] Yeah, have you ever like in your peak Reddit atheist phase, have you ever like tried to point out the contradictions that exist between them about fundamental details? And did you ever get like a good answer to why, you know, they have different ancestries, why they have different birthplaces, why they have a different narrative about the fleeing to Egypt, etc. [0:44:11] So Catholic school is not quite the, they don't quite try to do some of like the evangelical things where they're like, oh, well, first he did this and then he did this, and then something else happened so that they could all be true at the same time. They're not quite as forthright about like the sort of implications of them. And they're a little more sort of liable to just be like, I don't know. Like it seems like they're kind of getting at like a broader truth. Like maybe one thing happened, maybe something else happened. We don't really know. So but I do remember occasionally asking my religion teacher who I hated being like, oh yeah, well, what about this? And him just being like, I don't know, kid, I'm just here so I can get paid. [0:44:57] Well, so let's go through them. I will say, I think honestly, anybody who has any strong interest in history, I think, should at least read the four Gospels and the Acts of the Apostles because they're very fascinating. And I think it can be kind of tedious to read the first three in particular because there is so much overlap that it does feel quite repetitive. You know, one of the phrases used for the first three Gospels is the synoptic gospels because they can be, you know, they can be seen together synoptic, given that they really have, it's the exact same story, basically in the exact same structure. The fourth Gospel of John is something different altogether. But even among the synoptics, there are some really fascinating differences. So I'm just going to go through pretty quickly to explain all four. So, Mark is the shortest and is pretty universally understood to be the earliest of the Gospels. [0:45:46] It contains nothing of the birth or genealogy of Jesus, yet it's full of really rich information regarding his ministry, you know, his public teachings across the Holy Land. Apparently, aimed at an audience unfamiliar either with Judaism or any teachings of Jesus, and written in plain, accessible Greek, the Gospel of Mark is a fast-paced narrative account of what Jesus said, how his sayings relate to Old Testament prophecy, and the ways that this ministry led to Jesus' death and rebirth. Just as Mark does not include a Nativity narrative, even the resurrection here is only actually just implied. Later scholars, apparently embarrassed by this, added in an appearance of the risen Jesus to avoid potential theological dissonance between Mark and the three later Gospels. However, scholars again pretty universally agree that the ending of Mark was inserted after the fact. The best evidence of this is that there are two different new endings of Mark in different texts, depending on the manuscript you're reading. [0:46:45] Mark was then built upon by the twin Gospels of Matthew and Luke, two longer and more eloquent biographical accounts that describe the entire life of Jesus in much greater detail. The Nativity story associated with Christmas is about 70% from Matthew and 30% from Luke. We discussed Matthew's portrayal of the Judean King Herod in our last episode. Despite being quite similar in content and style, and despite both being thought to derive from a lost source known as Q, Matthew and Luke differ greatly in their approach and attitude toward Judaism. The Gospel of Matthew expresses in no uncertain terms that Jewish Christians must maintain the Jewish law, just as the sect of the Pharisees do. Luke, however, is cooler on both Judaism and the Jewish people, and much more interested in the ambiguous concept of the Holy Spirit, which might have its roots more in Greek thought than in Judaism. [0:47:40] This Holy Spirit has an even more prominent appearance in the sequel to Luke and my favorite of all early Christian writings, the Acts of the Apostles. As we'll get into later in this episode, it is a fascinating and invaluable source of early Christianity, kind of an official party history about the movement, mostly under the leadership of Paul of Tarsus and how it first spread across the Greek-speaking world. And like we said, the fourth gospel, the Gospel of John, is the most unusual. Only here does Jesus proclaim himself to be God. Before Abraham was, I am. In addition to its greatest divergences in theology, this gospel contains the least overlap with the preceding three in its content. Here, Jesus is less interested in teaching than in proclaiming his existence as both the Son of God and a co-equal to God, whose birth and death and resurrection will herald the end of the world as we know it. [0:48:34] The author of John is also bitterly opposed not only to the Jewish temple hierarchy and the rival sect of the Jewish Pharisees, but uses derogatory language toward all Jewish people. Again, only in John do we hear that the Jews killed Jesus, not certain Jewish critics brought Jesus before a Roman tribunal. The authorship of all four of these gospels is a matter of great dispute, but essentially no serious scholar argues that they were indeed written by the apostolic figures for which they are now named. This naming happened long after the texts were composed through, as we mentioned, somewhat arbitrary interpolations about the text. Additionally, many religious Christians accept that this naming should not be taken for granted. In fact, the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops now asserts that the Gospels were anonymous. Drawing from the world of secular scholarship, the bishops also maintain that Mark, not Matthew, was the first to be written and likely influenced Luke along with the lost hypothetical Q source. [0:49:37] Scholars believe today that while the individual identities of the Gospel writers may never be known, we can make educated guesses about the geographic and demographic background of their writers as well as their audience. As mentioned, Mark assumes that his audience is unfamiliar with Jewish practice. This means that not only was Mark writing for Gentiles, but he may have specifically been writing for Gentiles living in areas when there were very few Jewish people around them. By contrast, Matthew is adamant that Jewish said Christians need to follow every aspect of the Jewish law, at least if they are Christians of Jewish background. This puts him at odds with some other early Christians, including Paul of Tarsus, and also makes it likely that the author of Matthew was a Jew writing for an audience of Jews. Luke is often assumed to have been written by a Greek Gentile, but this is largely based on circumstantial evidence around his knowledge of Greek geography. [0:50:28] The identity of John's author is a matter of fierce debate. Its anti-Jewish stance, which clearly contributed to later murderous anti-Semitism, has led many scholars to see John as an obvious racial polemic against the Jews by a Gentile. However, others think this hostility could instead reflect the bitterness of a Jewish author who failed to convert his own community and may have been exiled as a heretic. Special attention is paid to a line in John where Jesus warns his followers, they will put you out of the synagogue. In fact, the time is coming when anyone who kills you will think they are offering a service to God. It's very possible that this is coming from the author's own personal experience during the short period of time in which non-Christian Jews had the upper hand over the early Jesus movement. Biblical scholar Paula Fredriksen believes that actually all four writers of the Gospels were probably of a Jewish background. [0:51:24] This is because she argues their deep understanding of Jewish religion would be extremely unusual for Gentiles of that time. Other scholars disagree, insisting that no real Jew would misinterpret the Old Testament as blatantly as, let's say, the author of Matthew, who misreads a word meaning young woman to be instead virgin, or the author of John, who, by elevating Jesus to the position of God the Father, apparently denies the Jewish conception of monotheism altogether. Personally, I don't think we can really know the background of these authors simply based on what they believed. And I certainly don't think that, you know, no person of a Jewish background would have disagreed with Jewish theology. I think, you know, even today, there is a huge amount of disagreements among Judaism as just as there is in any religion. But I think this question of authorship brings us to a related question. [0:52:18] And this is, was every gospel originally composed by and for a specific ancient sect? For instance, were Matthew and Luke used as the sole authority by a Jewish Christian and a Gentile Christian sect, respectively? A lot of older scholarship says yes. Each gospel was associated with a specific sect, but contemporary expert Dr. Robyn Walsh, again my former professor, says no. Instead, the gospels need to be understood as authorial works by individual interpreters. She hazards that overemphasis on projecting an ethnic background to individual authors assumes that Greek people and Jewish people must have all thought and wrote in culturally specific ways. In fact, some early Christians appear instead to have been working very hard to dissolve ethnic distinctions among the faithful. As Paul tells us in Galatians, there is neither Jew nor Greek, neither slave nor free, nor is there male nor female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus. [0:53:22] Paul himself is the most important figure in the spread of Christianity. He is occasionally considered more significant to world history than Jesus himself, because it was Paul who spent his life in ways nobody had really done before, trying to spread this religion across the entire known world, essentially. However, despite Paul's large body of surviving writings, he tells us essentially nothing about the man Jesus who he believed had saved the world. This is this fascinating paradox. His essays are entirely focused around who Jesus is and what Jesus means to believers, but the life of Jesus is not a major subject at all. Paul never mentions Jesus' parents by name or any of the apostles besides Peter and James, brother of Jesus. He tells us very little about what Jesus actually preached. What really matters is the theological significance of his sacrificial death. Of particular importance to Paul is the notion that the death and resurrection of Jesus marked the salvation of sin for all humans. [0:54:24] Another source we should mention here are the apocryphal gospels. These are a large body of works written by Christians, but for various reasons were not included in the Christian canon after the Council of Nicaea. These can be really important in understanding early ideas about Jesus. However, they're not necessarily great sources for the life of Jesus. This is because all of the known apocryphal gospels were written after the canonical gospels appear to have been composed. There's some speculation that the Nag Hammadi texts, the Gnostic library which contributed heavily to the resurgence of Jesus scholarship in the 20th century, some scholars once believed this might have been written at the same time as the canonical gospels. But now it's thought that the Gospel of Thomas, the earliest known Nag Hammadi text, was in fact written after the Gospel of John. We should mention also writings outside Christianity altogether, in particular, Josephus and Tacitus. [0:55:26] Though scholars have long been racked with anxiety that passages by these authors could have been later interpolations by dishonest Christians, the great Jewish writer Josephus and the great Roman writer Tacitus both contain references to figures that appear to be Jesus, written less than a century after his death. Josephus' account, known as the Testimonium Flavianum, doesn't tell us much, but its existence is enough to corroborate that Jesus existed, that he died at a cross, and that he had a brother. Tacitus tells us even less, but again, it confirms the crucifixion and mentions that Christians were persecuted under the Emperor Nero. I think that this again is enough to really dismiss mythicism altogether, but it's also such a small extra-biblical corpus that there's very little that we can know for certain if we are to take a hardline minimalist stance. But again, beginning in the later 20th century, there was a turn away from the most minimalist of scholarship. [0:56:31] A landmark event in contemporary biblical studies was the 1985 academic summit known as the Jesus Seminar. At this conference, several dozen academics debated which aspects of the life of Jesus, known from gospel accounts and external sources like Josephus, could be considered historical fact. The seminar came to agree upon a neat summary of what can be said with the highest degree of certainty about Jesus. They agreed that he was a Jewish teacher living in Roman Galilee who preached an apocalyptic message that caused him to run afoul with religious and civil authorities and for which he was crucified by the Roman state. After his death, a movement including his brother James emerged to spread his teachings. This was essentially the same description about Jesus from the beginning of this episode. It is also a description that not only scholars, but basically all believing Christians would agree with. The only potentially contentious point here is the argument that Jesus was an apocalyptic teacher. [0:57:35] But internal textual evidence in the letters of Paul and the Gospels, as well as external context about Second Temple Judaism and preachers in this Jewish context, means that the apocalyptic element is also pretty hard for scholars to deny today. Okay, so with all of this out of the way, we can now get into the fun stuff here about the life of Jesus. This is going to be the gospel according to Gladio, our official take on who Jesus actually was. I'm going to say here that much like the Bible, this podcast is not univocal. I and Russian Sam and Jackson all have various disagreements. So if you guys want to object with anything I'm about to say, please by all means do. But each of us is going to give our account based on the preponderance of evidence in the past century of scholarship. We're going to go from Jesus' birth right up through his life and death, and then explore what we can reconstruct about his afterlife. [0:58:33] That is to say, the origins of Christianity and the emergence of Jesus as a divine being. So in keeping with this winter season, we gotta start with Christmas, and we gotta start by saying we have no actual idea when Jesus was born. It is just as likely to have been December 25th as it is to have been April 1st, August 17th, or any other day. Before settling on this specific Christmas date, some Roman Christians actually believed he had been born in March. We've discussed the possibility of pagan celebration on this dating previously on the podcast, but regardless, none of these proposed dates has any basis in scriptural evidence. Nothing in or outside the Bible gives us any idea of when Jesus was born. His place of birth is similarly contentious. Some scholars find it credible that he was born in the town of Bethlehem in southern Judea, while others maintain he was born in Nazareth, a smaller village in northern Galilee, where he was raised and began his ministry. [0:59:38] In her recent book, Boy Jesus, Joan E. Taylor argues that it was not uncommon for Judeans, possibly those from towns such as Bethlehem, to migrate up to the provinces, including Galilee, during the time of King Herod. We should again recall from our last episode that Herod's great construction projects saw tektons, including those with illustrious Jewish pedigrees like Joseph, to be shuffled all around his entire kingdom for these building projects. [1:00:08] Yeah, and I think it's interesting that something that is sort of confounding to a lot of scholars about this sort of narrative of Jesus' birth is that in Luke, and I think in Matthew as well, but definitely in Luke, there's mention of a census being taken by the Romans. [1:00:25] Yes. [1:00:26] There's census being taken by the Romans that required everybody to go, not to their hometown, but to like the hometown of their ancestor to be counted. And this census is entirely fictitious. Like there's no record of it ever happening, and there's no record of anything like this happening throughout the Roman period. So it is interesting to note that the census is basically invented to put Jesus in Bethlehem so that he can be, he can fulfill like Old Testament prophecy, and it probably didn't actually happen. [1:00:59] Yeah, you know, and speaking of Old Testament prophecy, we're going to talk about the figure of the Messiah, but there is this idea that the Messiah had something to do with the life of King David, the legendary king of the Old Testament. One of the many things King David did was hold the census. And I've seen it suggested that that might be partially why Luke put in this narrative. We should also mention, you know, that, of course, in the beginning was the word, the word here being the proper noun Jesus. Let's talk about Jesus' name. Most of our listeners probably already know that in his place and time, he would have been known in the synagogue as Yeshua, that being the Hebrew equivalent to an English name, which is most often rendered not as Jesus, but as Joshua. Up in the Galilean hinterlands, Yeshua may have been pronounced closer to Yeshu or even Esho, as later Aramaic speakers would say it. [1:01:51] Joshua was a name with notable religious significance in this place in time. In the Hebrew Bible, he was the militant folk hero who followed Moses and brought down the walls of Jericho in the ancient conquest of the promised land. Centuries later, Christians of mostly non-Jewish background would see Jesus as a man leading his own people to a new kind of promised land, the coming kingdom of God. As a more divine view of Jesus developed, it was even believed that his birth, now of course celebrated at Christmas, heralded the beginning of a new age in human history, Anno Domini. I think that the most significant question around the birth of Jesus has to be who his parents are, only because this has so much theological importance today. I am going to make kind of a bold claim here and say that based on all of the evidence at our disposal, both internal to the Bible and outside of it, I think Jesus had an unremarkable birth to unremarkable parents. [1:02:50] I do not find it convincing that there was any miracle, any surprise, or any scandal around his birth. Jesus was born to Mary, a married woman, who I don't think was believed to have been a virgin. Her husband, Joseph, would thus have been his biological father. There are several reasons why I believe this. First, it appears that the virgin birth narrative only enters the Christian story as a kind of backwards way of justifying the idea that he was the son of God. Because, you know, if you want to really convince somebody that somebody's father is God, then you have to first remove any possibility that their real father is a human. Thus, you know, Mary was a perpetual virgin. However, scholars agree that Jesus did not consider himself to be the son of God in his lifetime. If this story thus developed after his death, there is basically zero chance that Mary would have been considered a virgin. [1:03:48] Additionally, under the influence of Greek and Roman mythology, as well as the divine status of the Roman Empire, some Christians, likely of pagan background themselves, began to interpret Jesus in the context of a classical demigod. We need to mention that at the same time that this was happening, some Jewish Christians, namely the sect of the Ebionites, didn't believe that Jesus was the Son of God. By contrast, as God was not human and completely indivisible, they didn't believe that he could have had a son, let alone that this son could too be God and co-equal with the Father. Our earliest Christian source, Paul, who was of course Jewish, describes Jesus as being descended from the flesh from the line of David and through the Spirit from God. I think therefore that the earliest Christians, including Paul, understood Jesus to be favored or adopted by God in a metaphorical spiritual sense. [1:04:47] Across the first century, this came to be taken literally. But Paul did not believe Jesus to be either God or the Son of God. The Gospel of Mark presents Jesus to apparently have been adopted by God at his baptism. This was succeeded in Matthew and Luke with the virgin birth narrative, and eventually in John with the narrative that Jesus was not only the Son of God born to a virgin, but also God Himself. I also want to return to Paul's claim that Jesus was descended from the flesh from David because this corroborates the later Gospel of Matthew asserting that Joseph was a descendant of David. Paul never mentions either Joseph or Mary by name, but I personally think that if Matthew and Paul both record this Davidic narrative, Jesus probably was believed to have been a true biological Davidic descendant. Furthermore, I suspect that Joseph's genealogy from David is only included in Matthew, again, the most Jewish of all the Gospels, because many early Jewish followers of Jesus believed that descent from King David was essential to the claim to be the Messiah. [1:06:06] We're going to see exactly what the Messiah meant later on in this episode, but this is all to say. Contradictory and competing oral traditions and theologies were circulating across the first century. Many of these traditions were preserved in our multivocal gospel account. The survival of the narrative of Joseph's paternity of Jesus in Jewish Christian circles in later antiquity also seems to corroborate that earlier Jewish Christians would have believed that Jesus was not in fact the Son of God, but instead the Son of Joseph. Therefore, Mary as well would not have been a virgin. Before we move on to Jesus' adult life, there is another counter-argument to mention. I have to ask Jackson, are you familiar with the Pantera theory? And I'm not talking about the band. [1:06:53] I was going to say, I'm familiar with Pantera the band, but I also am familiar with the Pantera theory. Yes, this was sort of, this is one of those, like, one of those Wikipedia pages you like read when you're like 13 or like 12, and it like kind of blows your mind. It's like kind of scary because you're like, oh my God, there's like, there's, there's so much out there, and it like undermines like all that I know about the world. So yeah, I came across this, I think, when I was a little younger. So basically, it's this theory that some scholars, including James Tabor, who's a very good academic, they take seriously. And this is the argument that Jesus was not the Son of God, but he was the illegitimate child of a Roman soldier named Pantera. [1:07:35] I find this unconvincing because it's entirely rooted in anti-Christian polemic texts written at a greater remove from the life of Jesus than any of our canonical gospels. So I just don't think we really need to give this much credibility given how late it is. Second, scholars no longer believe that Roman troops were a regular presence in Judea. We need to remember that Jesus was born in Galilee, which was ruled over by one of the children of Herod the Great. It was a territory run essentially then by a Jewish collaborator government. Even in Judea, which was a separate province from Galilee, there would have only been a Roman presence, at least a Roman military presence, during certain potentially tumultuous moments, such as the high holidays. Rural Jewish women, therefore, likely would never see a Roman soldier any time in their lives. This doesn't mean that an affair or an act of sexual violence was not possible, but I don't think it is a probable explanation for any particular conception. [1:08:39] This also leads to my third point against the Pantera theory. Nowhere in early Christian writing is Jesus alluded to be of illegitimate birth. Ancient Judea was a violently patriarchal society. Unwed mothers were treated with extreme scorn. Children born to adulterous unions were marked with a lifelong stigma that basically precluded them from any public religious life. I would conjecture that a scandalous birth would have had such a profound impact on the life of the historical Jesus that it would have necessarily been mentioned in early Christian writings. It's also possible that this stigma would have been strong enough to prevent Jesus from becoming a respected teacher at all. Moving on from his birth to his early life, what can you say about the childhood of Jesus, Sam? And please don't say that he spent it in India or England. [1:09:34] Yeah, well, unfortunately, we know pretty much nothing, at least from the Gospels. We have some apocryphal accounts that are kind of weird. There's that bit about him bringing clay birds to life. There's a bit where he's just playing with a kid and he just pushes him off a roof because he pissed him off and then brings him back to life. But yeah, nothing in the gospel itself. We know he was probably circumcised, and just judging from the number of relics that we have of Jesus' foreskins, you know, there was a lot of material there, allegedly. But the individual stories were likely made up after the fact, probably in accordance with the tropes of Greek biographies. These biographies, which were often written about emperors or philosophers, were written under the assumption that childhood was a predictor for adult behavior. So Greek historians did not always find it problematic to invent childhood episodes that illustrated the exceptional character of their subject. [1:10:27] So, for example, with the biographies of Alexander the Great, we have this one great story when a delegation comes from Persia into the court of his father, and he's like seven, eight years old. Instead of just, you know, playing with the guy's horse or whatever, he's just asking him geographical questions to show that this is someone who's going to grow up to become a great military leader. A similar story here. So, the gospel accounts of the Christ-child debating scholars in the temple were written for the same reason as the apocryphal accounts of Jesus killing a childhood friend and bringing him back from the dead, or again, fashioning birds out of clay. We can compare this to much later medieval folklore, such as the cherry tree carol, a 15th-century Christmas song in which Jesus, still in his mother's womb, commands a tree to lower its branches so that Mary can pick its fruit. [1:11:09] I also would like us to consider another apocryphal story involving a child and another cherry tree. The story of George Washington confessing to his father that he mischievously misused an axe was not written because it was ever believed to be true. Instead, in the great neoclassical fashion, early 19th-century author Mason Locke Weems invented this anecdote because he thought it was morally true. [1:11:30] Yeah, I think this whole concept of moral truth is really important to understanding how the New Testament was written, and honestly, probably how the Old Testament was written too. That, you know, miracles such as Jesus' ability to walk on water began to circulate as myths that were understood consciously or unconsciously, to illustrate the significance of the people involved. Just as Jesus was a refuge to his disciple Peter on a stormy sea, Christ can be a spiritual refuge to worshipers struggling with the turmoil of life. Just as Jesus provided physical nourishment to his thousands of supporters in ancient times by, you know, creating loaves and fishes, Christ provides spiritual nourishment to billions of believers today. And we should mention that while Jesus' day trade was apparently carpentry or construction, as he and his father Joseph are referred to in Greek as tektons, his true calling was to be a teacher, specifically a teacher of religious wisdom. [1:12:26] Figures along these lines were clearly quite common in the ancient Jewish world, including both John the Baptist as well as the Pharisees, who were Jewish teachers with wide support among common people in the countryside. Jesus, John the Baptist, and the Pharisees all held a similar apocalyptic worldview. Jesus and the Pharisees both condemned the temple establishment in Jerusalem, associated with the sect of the Sadducees, and they believed God would soon make things right and restore Israel to its ancient biblical glory. Apocalyptic Jews also encouraged people to lead more pious lives in preparation for this coming judgment. Repent, for the end is near. [1:13:07] Yeah, so it appears that the immersion in water as part of a purifying ritual was practiced by some peoples in ancient Judea, not only John the Baptist. The most famous baptizers of this period were the Essenes, a group that we've mentioned several times now on the podcast. These men and probably women were a fascinating Jewish ascetic sect that separated themselves from the rest of Judean society because they believed that mainstream Judaism was simply too worldly for anyone to properly follow God's commandments. In a practice remarkably similar to Christian monks of later centuries, the Essenes took to the desert in isolated communities where they would study and practice the Jewish law without distraction. Additionally, this left them free from the influence of worldly kings considered to be of dubious legitimacy, such as the priestly dynasty, the Herodian kings, and in particular the pagan Romans. The Essenes also had an apocalyptic worldview. [1:14:00] They believed that the spiritual mission of the Jewish people demanded repentance of sin and ritual purification through baptism in preparation for God's kingdom. The famous Dead Sea Scrolls, which are associated with the camps of Qumran, are also strongly associated with the Essene sect. These texts are of great importance to religious scholars as well as to contemporary Jews and Christians because they give us our clearest look at the form of popular religious practice and belief in the Second Temple era of Judaism. They are essentially the oldest surviving Jewish documents and confirm that the Hebrew Bible used by people in the Second Temple era was roughly the same Bible used by Jews and Christians today. Although the Essenes were a sect apart from mainstream Judaism, their library is our best guide for understanding what a Jewish teacher in the Second Temple era might have believed. Jesus is referred to in the Gospels as a rabbi. [1:14:52] This is in fact the earliest citation of any individual being referred to with that title. Jesus was living before rabbinical Judaism emerged. He was not a rabbi in the contemporary sense. So for instance, he would not appear to have undergone any kind of ordination or even formal training. How much education he actually had is also completely up for debate. Scholars are not even sure whether the historical Jesus could read and write. I believe that his apparent knowledge of the Old Testament scriptures means that he likely had studied them and thus was presumably fluent in Hebrew as well as in his native Aramaic. But due to the efforts of figures like John and the Pharisees in bringing the religious teachings to the provinces, we should not assume that an illiterate man would have been ignorant of Judaism. Looking ahead to European Christianity, we can find multiple cases of illiterate farmers not only being highly devout, but even leading religious movements. [1:15:44] Swiss Anabaptist Jakob Ammann, for whom the Amish get their name, established one of the most enduring sects in modern history despite being unable to either read or write. [1:15:54] One little thing I want to add here also is that we should remember that Second Temple Judaism was centered around the temple, which we discussed in length in our Herod episode. This was a physical location in the capital city of Jerusalem, very far from where the vast majority of Jewish people lived, both in Judea and in the diaspora. So there was a lot of interest in trying to establish some form of Jewish practice where people could be good Jews without being able or having to visit the temple physically. And I think that this kind of like, you know, provincial aspect is important in understanding the ministry of Jesus, as well as the Pharisees, the Essenes, and John the Baptist, who all operated outside of Jerusalem primarily. [1:16:39] Yeah, another title that was often applied to Jesus is preacher. Like rabbi, this would mean something different in first-century Jewish context than it would in a Christian context today. Jesus, like John the Baptist, was a deeply religious individual who felt called to share his spiritual convictions with others. If he's closest to any kind of contemporary preacher, he would not be a professional minister giving a weekly Sunday sermon, but instead the kind of street preacher you might see in Times Square or at the entrance of a crowded shopping mall, desperately trying to convince disinterested masses that the end was near. And ancient Judea was positively teeming with these guys. There's a great bit in Life of Brian where there's just a whole square of these guys just yelling at each other. And that's basically Life of Brian is actually kind of like, it kind of gives you like a decent picture of some of this stuff. [1:17:28] It's not bad if you want to, as a result, that one because it's great comedy and also surprisingly historically accurate in a lot of ways. [1:17:42] Yeah, yeah. And we should also mention that the English word preacher is usually used as a gloss for a couple different concepts. One of them being the Greek kerux, which in the first century meant herald or messenger. Although this is fascinating, in centuries earlier, including the writings of Homer, it actually meant a royal slave. Today, the word preacher is also often used to mean the Latin term pastor. That's a borrowing from, and that itself is a Latin translation of the Greek term poimen and the Hebrew term ro'eh. All three of these words mean shepherd. In the Old Testament, shepherds were strongly associated with the supposedly nomadic existence of the Hebrew people prior to the establishment of the sedentary kingdom of Israel. Sheepgrazing would certainly have been a major economic activity across the ancient Near East. For this reason, the image of the shepherd tending to his flock was a poignant metaphor. [1:18:45] God describes the people of Israel as his flock in the book of the prophet Jeremiah. Then, in the New Testament Gospel of John, Jesus describes himself as a shepherd, very possibly in a deliberate allusion to prophetic scripture. There is an additional, more violent layer to this sheep metaphor. In several of the Gospels, Jesus is also compared to a sacrificial lamb. This was meant to invoke temple rituals around the holiday of Passover, as well as the story in Genesis of the binding of Isaac. Just as the patriarch Abraham was called upon to sacrifice his son Isaac in place of a lamb to secure his initial covenant with God, writers of the New Testament saw Jesus as the ultimate sacrifice, killed to inaugurate a new covenant. God's last-minute fake out in Genesis, in which he commands Abraham to actually spare the life of Isaac, might have informed the very early Christian belief that Jesus was saved from death. [1:19:48] The sacrifice of Jesus, this Lamb of God, was seen by early Christians to be so totalizing that it signaled two great and cosmic changes, both the salvation of past sins as well as the approaching end of the world. So let's really get deep into apocalypticism here, because again, this is one of the major focuses of Christian scholarship, going at least as far back as Albert Schweitzer. And I guess as far even before that to Reimarus, because apocalypse in a second temple Jewish context doesn't simply mean a belief that the world is going to end. Apocalypticism is a concept influenced to some extent from Persian Zoroastrianism, suggesting that evil exists in the world because God in his almighty power has chosen to allow it to exist. It was understood that through prophetic vision, in Greek apokalypsis, God communicated that the existence of this evil was a test for his human creations, and in particular, his chosen tribe, the Hebrew nation. [1:21:00] In accordance with this divine plan, God would soon end this period of turmoil by directly intervening in worldly affairs. Israel would be liberated from her pagan oppressors. The Gentiles would accept the authority of the one true God. And God would then judge all of humanity, both the righteous and the sinners, based on their behavior during this period. Apocalypticism was not necessarily the official position of Judaism in this time and appears to have been discouraged to some extent by the reigning sect, the Sadducees. But apocalyptic beliefs were very widespread among everyday people, possibly just because they gave a nice explanation for why there is so much suffering under the watch of an all-powerful God. Per Josephus, the masses, especially outside Jerusalem, strongly adhered to the teachings of the Pharisees and had warm feelings toward John the Baptist as well. While we don't know if Jesus ever had a comparably large following in his lifetime, his audience probably would have already been familiar with this kind of apocalyptic message before they'd ever heard of him. [1:22:12] Across the 20th century, many scholars have drawn parallels between the Pharisees and the Jesus movement. This might come as a surprise to many Christians, because in the New Testament, the Pharisees are portrayed as the hypocritical enemies of Christ. Many Christians also make the mistake of conflating the Pharisees with the establishment of the temple in Jerusalem, who would have in fact most likely been Sadducees. In fact, both the Jesus movement and the Pharisees opposed the Sadducees for being Roman collaborators and had many important theological disagreements as well. The historical Jesus surely had some kind of beef with the Pharisees, although we know that certain individual Pharisees, such as Nicodemus and possibly Joseph of Arimathea, had supported him during his ministry. He disagreed with the Pharisees, though, on one huge point: this is the existence and identity of the awaited Messiah. As we're going to get into, it's very likely that Jesus himself believed that he was the Messiah and thus essential to God's coming plan for the end of the world. [1:23:31] But there were other more subtle divergences between the Jesus movement and the Pharisees that we can infer and see from the Gospels. Jesus accused his Pharisaic rivals as being hypocrites. They said the correct thing, but didn't follow through with it. Per the Gospel of Matthew, Jesus tells his followers to adhere to the Jewish law even more strictly than the Pharisees do, and perform piety without fanfare. Literally, in the case of his claim that the Pharisees would blow a trumpet to announce they were giving alms to the poor. Jesus argued that instead, a pious Jew ought to throw away the trumpet and give everything to the poor. Pharisees, as followers of the Hebrew Bible, argued that proper fair retribution was an eye for an eye rather than a death for an eye. Jesus went further, saying that one should be even more merciful and turned the other cheek. [1:24:26] Thus, once we get past the huge issue of the identity of the Messiah, Pharisees and the Jesus movement were probably more alike than apart. The Gospels' harsh diatribe against the Pharisees could possibly be because of what we would call the narcissism of small differences. And also because, in the century after Jesus' death, the Pharisees and the Jesus movement would be pulled in increasingly oppositional directions. The Pharisees would eventually develop into the tradition of modern rabbinical Judaism. Anti-Pharisaic language from the Gospels would thus inform the next 2,000 years of Christian anti-Judaism. Just like the portrayal of Jesus in Matthew, the Pharisees believed that more fervent adherence to the Jewish law was necessary to save the people of Israel from God's coming wrath. They believed this wrath would be associated with what Christians call the universal resurrection. All people who had ever died, both Greek and Jew, would be brought back from the dead to life in bodily form to await this final judgment. [1:25:36] God's mercy and God's wrath thus would come even for those who had died thousands of years before. This Pharisaic belief most likely informed early Christian ideas about the resurrection of Jesus. God had raised his exalted herald from the dead in anticipation of the coming resurrection of all his children. So the vast majority of biblical scholars agree that Jesus preached his apocalyptic message both because such a message is present in Christian writings, which we can call internal evidence, and also because of the external evidence that these apocalyptic currents were very mainstream in Second Temple Judaism. Bart Ehrman's book, Jesus, Apocalyptic Prophet of a New Millennium, argues that because Jesus believed God's judgment was imminent, all of his teachings need to be understood in the context of this coming end of the world. When Jesus says to forsake belongings and forsake divisions of gender and ethnicity, he was advocating for a full turn away from the material world and a complete focus on spiritual well-being. [1:26:44] He even goes so far as to saying you might have to abandon your family in pursuit of, you know, the true moral path. Jesus was thus not arguing for any kind of social revolution or trying to create a long-term new moral world. As Bart Ehrman puts it, Jesus did not see his teachings as social instructions for the long haul because he didn't believe there was going to be a long haul. God is coming and he's coming soon. Moving on to geography. Jesus most likely preached his message across the province of Judea and the neighboring region of Galilee, which of course was his home. We don't know exactly where Jesus was born, but he was certainly strongly associated with Galilee and the small hamlet of Nazareth. As we mentioned, Galilee had a mixed population of both Jews and Gentiles. It was close to the Greek colony of Sepphoris, where he very probably may have worked as a tekton, as well as a community known as the Decapolis. [1:27:49] This was a set of 10 towns in Syria and Palestine of a predominantly Greek ethnic origin that were kind of past the Mediterranean coast, deeper into the Near East. Yeah, we should also mention that these were kind of the boonies. So, like, just any kind of person who would have come from there would have been looked down upon from people from more settled towns like Jerusalem, just because, like, oh, what's this guy from like the shithole doing telling us that he's the son of God or whatever, you know? Yes, no, and there's this great line in the book of John where somebody, I think one of the disciples asks another, they're doubting Jesus, and one of them says, nothing good comes from Nazareth. It was like, you know, it really was, you know, it was the boonies. It was this frontier region. It had, I think we should have a mixed population, which might have meant its religion was seen as somewhat suspect. [1:28:44] And also, it was, in a sense, kind of a subjugated territory. Galilee had always been part of the broader Jewish world and had a Jewish population probably going back many, many centuries. But it had been recently brought into the political fold of the Jewish kingdom by the conquest of the Hasmonean dynasty and then by the great economic investments of King Herod. After Herod's death, Galilee and Judea were both made into Roman provinces, but left under the direct administration of Herod's sons, both of whom were Judean, not Galilean. And, but that being said, you know, Jesus was not, did not spend his entire life in Galilee. We aren't even totally certain he was born in Galilee, and he was certainly a very mobile person. Jesus is so mobile in the Gospels that some scholars have suggested the people who wrote them could not have been from the Near East. [1:29:40] They must have been writing in Greece or Italy, because they describe Jesus going from one part of Judea to someplace in Galilee, then going into Syria with such speed that would be unlikely for somebody actually familiar with that terrain. However, other scholars think this is just an attempt to say that Jesus was so committed to spreading his gospel, he was moving incredibly fast over basically the entire neighborhood of, you know, the ancient Near East. We know that Jesus was not preaching alone. He certainly had a core group of followers. The fact that multiple writers, including Josephus and Paul, attest direct contact or knowledge with Jesus' followers, namely his brother James, confirm that this following existed. It is probable that Jesus described his followers as the 12 apostles, especially because this number was specifically chosen as an allusion to the 12 tribes of Israel. Christian writings, however, disagree over who these 12 apostles were. [1:30:41] We honestly can assume there were only 12, especially because there were different accounts of the apostles in the different texts. Christian Orthodoxy holds this is because certain apostles were known by different names across their lifetime. We do know that, you know, Peter was also known as Simon and Cephas, so maybe that's the case for the rest of them as well. I think it's more likely that it was known that Jesus had 12 important apostles, but he might have had others as well. And by the time that the gospel accounts were written, people had forgotten who exactly these 12 were. It's also possible, this is just wild speculation here, that Jesus might have brought together different groups of 12 individuals at different times and said, you are my 12 apostles, just because he wanted to preserve that association with the tribes of Israel. I don't know. [1:31:37] For what it's worth, when I was in Catholic school, I was always taught that the apostles were the 12 and that all the rest of Jesus' followers were the disciples. [1:31:50] Although interesting. [1:31:52] But that doesn't necessarily work perfectly because the apostles are also referred to as the disciples and people who aren't part of the 12 get inducted into the apostlehood later on. So it's not a perfect solution. [1:32:07] Yes, in Acts, yeah, my favorite factoid is after Judas offs himself, they just like appoint a new guy, so there's still 12 of them. [1:32:15] Yes, yes, that's Barnabas, yeah. No, but also you're right that there are other figures that seem to be important to Jesus' ministry in the New Testament that are not listed as disciples. You know, like you said, like, you know, there's Lazarus, there's Zebedee, and there's many women who are prominent members of the ministry, most famously Mary Magdalene, but also, you know, Mary of Bethany, who are never included as disciples, but probably do attest to real figures who are, yeah, yeah, this broader following. [1:32:47] Yeah, exactly. [1:32:49] So moving on to Jesus' ministry. Unlike 18th century rationalists, I am unaware of any scholars today who argue that certain miraculous episodes of the ministry, like you know, creating bread, turning water into wine, walking on water, actually happened through ordinary means. I think that you know people have left that line of argument, that kind of rationalist line of argument behind. However, they do spend a lot of attention analyzing his words, not his deeds. This means that the teachings and parables of Jesus' ministry are of profound interest to modern academics. Scholars who are not hardline minimalists believe that many of his teachings, indeed specific words and phrases, might be authentic to the real historical Jesus. Bart Ehrman also suggests that some quotations of Jesus might have inspired mythic episodes in the Gospels. He brings up the story of Peter in the Garden of Gethsemane, cutting off the ear of a Sadducee, and says that this whole story might have been entirely invented to provide the setting for a pre-existing quotation that Jesus says in this episode. [1:34:05] Those who live by the sword will die by the sword. We unfortunately do not have time to analyze all of Jesus' biblical sayings. That would require this episode being even longer than it already is. Entire careers have been dedicated to that pursuit. But we need to emphasize that Jesus' teachings were intended to expand upon rather than to deny the law of the Hebrew Bible. They were thus directed toward Jews, not the entire world, although Jesus might have had contact with intrigued Gentiles and probably thought this coming kingdom, the kingdom of God, would be of equal importance to all sons of Noah, not only the sons of Abraham. Again, these teachings would have been instructions for individuals seeking to enter the kingdom of heaven. This does not mean going through the pearly gates when you die. Instead, this was going to be a heavenly kingdom on earth. [1:34:59] God comes down from up on high to judge the world and decide who gets detention and who gets the pizza party. Apocalyptic Jews often thought this would really be a physical kingdom with physical pleasures. Living people and the resurrected dead would be rewarded for all their righteousness with riches and rewards. Maybe not pizza per se, but probably some kind of flatbread would be involved. Although these teachings are not emphasized in most modern Christian churches, apocalypticism is still part of Christian Orthodoxy. Very early, no later than the decade immediately following Jesus' death, Christians began to see Jesus' very existence as a key element in this coming trial. His teachings would provide the roadmap toward a better future. Not necessarily a fairer, more moral future, but an apocalyptic future in which we would see, as the herald angels sing it, God and sinners reconciled. Truly a complete transformation of the world as we understand it. [1:36:06] The end of the world, in a sense. [1:36:09] Yeah, and so I think it's really important to mention that, like you said, the main thrust of Jesus' teaching is this sort of physical kingdom of God. And not only is this sort of central to Jesus' teaching, it's actually prob, it is in the Bible the first thing that he says. It's the first thing that he's chronologically recorded as saying. He says, the time is fulfilled and the kingdom of God is at hand. Repent and believe in the gospel. And like we've said, the at-hand part is meant to be very imminent. Not even a matter of years, but probably a matter of days, if not at most weeks, or maybe months from when Jesus eventually ends his ministry. He probably believed that he would be able to see it. [1:37:05] What is he like? Truly, truly, I say to you, you will not taste death. This generation shall not pass from the earth before the kingdom of God comes. [1:37:13] Yes. [1:37:15] Like, for example, Bart Ehrman says, or he thinks that Jesus told his disciples at the Last Supper that he would not drink wine with them until he drank it in the kingdom of God. He thinks that he probably meant that literally. That the kingdom of God was going to happen so soon that the next time he drank wine would be physically in the kingdom of God. And something worth mentioning is that Jesus, the historical Jesus probably thought that the kingdom of God would come about through the mechanism of the Son of Man. The Son of Man is a figure that is in some of the Old Testament prophecies, especially the one by Daniel, that was, per Jesus, imminently returning to judge the living and the dead. Basically, every modern Christian believes that the Son of Man is meant to be Jesus and that Jesus meant to have himself be the Son of man. [1:38:15] And it's possible that he meant that, especially towards the end of his ministry. But scholars, like again, like Bart Ehrman, do not believe that, at least at first, Jesus thought himself to be the Son of Man. Jesus' sayings where he appears to reference himself as the Son of Man are less plausibly authentic than the ones where Jesus refers to the Son of Man as some sort of coming other figure. So it's likely that he meant himself to be some sort of forerunner to Jesus. [1:38:42] Yeah, and again, so we're going to talk about the Son of Man and the Messiah in this context. This is something that Christians usually use as synonyms. Even some biblical scholars use these terms as synonymous because there is a lot of overlap there. But it does seem like in this context, these were different ideas. Jesus seemed to think that the Son of Man was coming, but he very well may have argued the Messiah was already here. [1:39:09] Exactly. Like, it's sort of a convoluted mechanism, but that seemed to be what he believed. [1:39:14] Yeah. And also, this kind of must bring to mind here something that Paula Fredriksen says, which is that the historical Jesus stands with his back to us. He was preaching and speaking toward a completely foreign audience, foreign to both modern Christians and modern biblical scholars. And so a lot of this is going to be really confusing. We're not from this guy's civilization. And this is all reconstructed. Like, you know, there's so much that we can't understand, and there's so much that might seem kind of surprising. I think that's something that Christian apologists do to be smug about is they say, oh, actually, I think I know a lot about Jesus. I know him very well. And I personally do not believe that is an honest argument somebody can make. He was from too foreign of a cultural context to really be considered familiar. [1:40:04] Exactly. And on this note, Jesus's teaching and like his moral teachings were pretty foreign and pretty radical for his, even for his audience, let alone for like modern listeners, right? So he seemingly preached a complete upending of both the spiritual order, but also the social order, right? So the famous quote being obviously that the first would be last and the last would be first. The historical Jesus probably preached that those who were suffering either under oppression or illness or spiritual inadequacy or in service of others would be restored their suffering tenfold in the kingdom. And those who were rich and rich in spirit would be made to serve the newly restored sufferers. And again, this isn't metaphorical. He probably meant this literally, that like people who were suffering would have those sufferings avenged by the people who made them suffer. To this end, Jesus probably asked his followers to be radically humble, right? [1:41:11] Spending all their time in service of the poor and the downtrodden, and to give up all that they had, even the bonds of family and friendship, to ensure their place among the meek who would inherit the earth. Right? And Jesus's message is, in that light, is incredibly disconcerting, right? Because he's not only sort of a preacher of social tumult, but he's also asking his followers to abandon everything in their life, like literally everything. [1:41:45] Yes. Yeah, and I think there's one great example of how, you know, like how scripture gets misinterpreted by tradition here. One of in Matthew, there's this really interesting line where he says, you must be like little children if you wish to enter the kingdom of God. And the way contemporary Christians tend to understand this, at least, you know, evangelical Protestants, is saying, oh, you know, because children are so nice. They can't hate anyone. Children just are, they're just loving and benevolent. No, when it says little children, this means you will not have rights. You will not be seen as a legally protected individual. You should be completely under the authority of this mission, just as a little child in our feudal, you know, in our ancient society is under the authority of their father and has no rights unto themselves. [1:42:34] Right. And on that topic of sort of childhood and family, Jesus is in the Gospels basically tells his followers to give up on their family to join the movement. And that's often like explained away, like, oh, you know, like, we'll all sort of be one big family in sort of Christendom. But like, no, he probably actually meant that like literally, like radically anti-family. [1:43:00] Yeah. [1:43:00] That you were, you were supposed to give up on your family, that you were supposed to give up on the people who kept you sort of on this current earth and to join his movement, right? Like it, it, it, it was a sort of it was kind of a culty message, right? It is, it comes off way cultier than we sort of see him usually, because he really is sort of like a, he's asking you to make very radical sacrifices. [1:43:28] I want to think back to what we talked about in our episodes about communes and, you know, in magic, and you know, utopian communities. And there was this idea that the first Christians had this communal existence. We're not entirely sure if this is true, but I think it is clear that the Jesus movement had this understanding that, you know, not only should we humble ourselves, but we should celebrate the humble. We should dissolve hierarchies of material wealth, hierarchies of gender, and really love all as our brothers and sisters. And I think this was a very radical and very benevolent social message, especially for the time. But I also think that it's a social message that only needs to be understood in the context of this coming apocalypse. You know, we don't know if he would have believed that there would have been such humility if these people were then glorified by the kingdom of God. [1:44:24] Yeah, exactly. And I think that Jesus's ethical teachings are with that in mind, right? Like he's not asking people to be kind to one another or to be humble or to forgive their enemies just because it's like instrumentally good or it's like morally good. He's saying that like this is how things will be in the kingdom. And if you want to have the good end of the kingdom, you probably should be as humble and as meek as possible because there is going to be this sort of radical overturning, right? Like, so because the people who are at the bottom are going to be at the top, you should probably put yourself as close to the bottom as possible so that you get as much out of the kingdom, right? [1:45:07] Yeah. [1:45:08] And another thing, too, is that not only did he think that you should sort of live up to the various sort of commendable moral things that he said for his followers to do in the gospels for that reason, but he also seemingly thought that there was some moral necessity to embody the kingdom of heaven before it reached the earth, right? To make oneself ready for the kingdom of God. Probably because he thought it would be an actual kingdom that you would actually have to live in. So you should probably like get, you should probably acquaint yourself with how you're going to have to live after the sort of Son of Man comes back and judges the living and the dead, right? So he, when he says in the Gospels that the kingdom of heaven is within you, it kind of also means that like, yeah, like you're going to have to live there. [1:46:05] So like we should probably embody it like as much as possible before it comes so that we're ready once it does come. [1:46:11] Yeah. [1:46:12] I think that with all this in mind, something that is really interesting about Christianity that isn't often given to it is that Jesus is both a way more understandable and legible figure to us than he's usually given credit for, but he's also way weirder and he's kind of sinister in this way, right? Like, like Jesus's message is pretty similar to like other millenarian movements that people are probably familiar with, right? Like the Children's Crusade or like the Millerites. [1:46:46] Yeah. [1:46:46] These are all things that we're pretty familiar with. And it seems like Jesus in his context would have been understood that way, right? Like that he was a utopian who thought that a utopian society was coming, right? And it would be one that people could live in, and it would be one that would be good, right? But he also, like, he also demanded like sacrifices, like we said, that were so vast and so deep that it is kind of sinister. Like, it reminds us of the cults of like the later 20th century that, you know, that exercised insane levels of control over their followers and sometimes ended very poorly, right? So it's not really any wonder that Jesus, his teachings received so much skepticism, and it's kind of not really any wonder that once he got closer, seemingly to the actual power structures of religious Judaism in Judea, that it started to face some level of repression. [1:47:52] Yeah. And you can certainly see why the message of Jesus concerning this coming apocalypse would have been troubling both to Jewish authorities, but especially to the Romans. Because even though most scholars do not think that Jesus preached or was involved in really any kind of violence, again, you know, Bart Ehrman goes so far as to deny that Peter ever cut off someone's ear in the Garden of Gethsemane. Despite that, there was not probably a violent element, the idea that a preacher is going around saying, pretty soon God is going to come and kick these Romans out, the Romans are going to worry about that and think that that might be a call to action. And I think that we'll talk about this in a minute, but I do think that it's this context of the apocalyptic message in which Jesus probably was convicted by the Roman state. [1:48:46] And the fact that his, that his practice, that his ministry was so totalizing and demanded so much of his followers, certainly might have scared Roman authorities into thinking, you know, what are these people going to do if we don't put a stop to them? How far are they going to take this? [1:49:02] Exactly. [1:49:04] You know, moving on to one last point about rhetoric before we finish talking about the ministry of Jesus, Jesus famously used parables to illustrate his various points, usually about the coming apocalypse. Some of these parables may actually be historic, no way to know. They could be later inventions. Recent scholarship, though, particularly by Candida Moss, has pointed out that the use of parables in the Greek and Roman worlds was actually most often associated with slaves. She draws intriguing parallels between the portrayal of Jesus in the Greek Gospels and the most famous parable maker in the Greek world, who is the legendary slave Aesop. The authors of the Gospels might have invented these parables to show the humility of Jesus, thus comparing him to a slave. Candida Moss also raises the possibility that enslaved scribes themselves, who would have physically written down the gospels dictated by wealthier Christian writers, might have also influenced what we know about the sayings and parables of Jesus. [1:50:11] At the very least, this interesting parallel between Jesus and Aesop is the kind of, you know, broader Greek context that contemporary scholars are very interested in, but didn't get too much attention really before the 20th and 21st century. So now let's move on from what Jesus taught to who he was, or at least who he claimed to be. As alluded earlier, it does not seem likely that he claimed to be divine. That is only present in the Gospel of John. The claim that he was the son of God is present in the other Gospels, but I am also skeptical that he ever claimed this of himself. You know, fatherhood by God is only really metaphorical in the writings of Paul and seems to be kind of an adoptive title in Mark. I think, therefore, that if our earliest writings do not show him as the literal son of God, he did not believe himself to be this. [1:51:10] However, Jesus might have called himself the Messiah. The book of Daniel, an apocalyptic text hugely influential on Second Temple Judaism, describes how God's apocalypse will involve worldly power being given to a kingly Israelite. This figure, an apparently human son of man, will rule over the nations while his heavenly father, the heavenly father of all mankind, begins his judgment. We've mentioned before how it seems that Jesus, when mentioning the son of man in third person, was not referring to himself. But early in Christian tradition, because Jesus possibly did refer to himself as the Messiah, these two figures were conflated. Even before the time of Jesus, there likely was a lot of overlap. The Son of Man in Daniel seems very similar to the prophetic idea that the Messiah will be this conquering hero to overturn the misfortunes of the Jewish nation. Stories of the Messiah are rooted in other ancient Jewish prophecies of coming glory, as well as folk memories of powerful kings like David and even the righteous pagan ruler King Cyrus, who had ended the Babylonian captivity of the Jewish priesthood. [1:52:33] After the establishment of the Hasmonean kingdom by the Jewish Maccabees and the subsequent re-encroachment of pagan influence under the Romans and King Herod, more and more Jews hoped that a heroic Messiah would liberate their nation. This kingly figure, like the Maccabees, would drive out the tyrannical Gentiles. He would be more holy than the Maccabees, however, closer to the ancient and legendary King David. He would likely be a descendant of King David, and, like the ancient kings, he would be anointed with holy oil. The Greek word for anointed is Christ. After some years of Jesus' ministry, during which time he may have referred to himself as the Messiah, he was arrested by Jewish authorities in the capital city of Jerusalem and then handed over to the Roman officials for trial and eventual execution. Jesus was found guilty of charges that are not known with any certainty. Strikingly, the Bible never says upon what accusation Jesus was convicted. [1:53:43] However, according to the Gospel of Luke, Jesus was asked by the Roman prefect Pontius Pilate if he claimed to be the king of the Jews. He did not deny this accusation. It thus seems that Jesus was crucified for pretending to be or asserting that he was the king of the Jews, as was written mockingly upon the cross. Bart Ehrman argues that this crucifixion was in fact directly response to Jesus' own claim that he was the Messiah. Because the Messiah was considered a kingly figure, the Romans misunderstood this claim and thought that Jesus was attempting to overthrow the Roman state by force of arms. They understood him to be a royal pretender. We mentioned several of these in the time of King Herod in our previous episode. There was a history of Jewish people saying they were going to be the next king. Usually they were members of the Herodian or Hasmonean line, not, you know, itinerant preachers from Galilee. [1:54:48] But in any case, this messianic claim may be what led Jesus to be tried, convicted, and executed in a brutal, torturous manner, most often reserved for figures like Jesus or like Spartacus, who had attempted to overthrow the social order of the Roman Empire. [1:55:09] Yeah, and like you said, crucifixion, considered among the worst means of execution in the Roman world. I don't know about you guys, but growing up, I didn't really understand how someone was supposed to die on the cross. Like, I figured that he was nailed to the cross and he kind of died to some mixture of blood loss, exposure, and then he got stabbed in the side with a spear. But the truth is actually way more horrifying. The body is positioned when you're crucified such that all your weight bears down on you, and the nails like stop you from being able to breathe because of it. And the only way you can breathe is to basically hold yourself up on the nails. And eventually, the mixture of pain, dehydration, and exposure makes it so you basically just give up on trying to hold yourself up to breathe and you just asphyxiate. [1:56:02] It's fucking, it's horrifying. It's nasty work. How did they figure this out? It's insane. It's truly. [1:56:10] Well, yeah, and I think there, other people did too. I believe that, like, there were crucifixions in feudal Japan. You know, like, people are nasty, man. People are really good at finding terrible ways to hurt each other. You know, and so a big point of disagreement among scholars across the past few decades is what probably happened to the body of the historical Jesus after his death. The New Testament asserts that he was placed in a tomb by a wealthy sympathizer among the Judean elite, possibly a Pharisee named Joseph of Arimathea. Later folk tradition also asserts that Joseph of Arimathea had some strange connection to Britain, which I think is extremely improbable and no one really, no scholar takes seriously. The entire premise of Joseph of Arimathea paying for a tomb has been problematized by some scholars, including again Bart Ehrman, who thinks that a formal tomb would have been expensive and unlikely for this figure. [1:57:10] He believes it more probable that Jesus, essentially considered a petty criminal by Rome, would have been thrown into some kind of mass grave, very possibly after a period of public decomposition. Again, one of the most punishing aspects of crucifixion is that even after their death, humiliation would continue by the body's deliberate exposure to the elements, food for scavenging birds. Writings from across the Roman world show a strong association with crucifixion victims and crows. It's thus highly probable that Jesus was denied a proper burial. The story about the tomb was invented after the fact to explain how his body had been still intact to, you know, ahead of the bodily resurrection, similarly to how the virgin birth story was likely invented after the fact to explain how Jesus' father could only have been God. Contrary to Ehrman's argument about Jesus being left on the cross before being thrown in a mass grave, Josephus does mention a case in which some Jews were allowed to properly bury a man who was crucified by the Romans. [1:58:24] However, some scholars today argue that Josephus only mentions this anecdote because it was an exception to the usual horrifying rule. While this might be getting beyond the life of Jesus, I think the brutal circumstances of his death likely explain why many, probably most Jews at this time, were unconvinced that he was the Messiah. Not only was the Messiah not meant to die, he was not meant to die in such a humiliating fashion. In the wake of the death of Jesus, his scattered followers had to shape Jewish messianic expectations, one which would eventually become the expectations of a new religion. Another point I want to get to here is that the model of the Messiah as present in Second Temple Judaism is so different from the idea of somebody who is tortured and killed on a cross, who essentially thus has lost any, you know, attempted campaign at glory, that there's such a divergence there that I think that it's possible that the best evidence for Jesus having claimed to have been the Messiah in his own lifetime is that it's unlikely that somebody who was defeated and killed in such a public manner could have been considered the Messiah if he had not claimed to be so in his lifetime. [1:59:46] Because unlike what some Christians believe today, nowhere in Jewish scripture does it say the Messiah is going to suffer and die. Language about suffering in Jewish scripture is never used in the context of messianic prophecy. Instead, after the historical Jesus really did suffer and die, Christians went back into Jewish texts and later reshaped certain passages to be about the Messiah, especially the book of Isaiah, even though that is not actually the intended consequence. Jackson, before we move on to the beginnings of Christianity, any thoughts more on the betrayal of Jesus and the crucifixion? [2:00:30] Yeah, I think specifically the betrayal, it seems like betrayal is probably historical, right? It's mentioned that he's betrayed by one of his close disciples, so a lot of scholars think that that probably wouldn't have been included if it hadn't happened because it's really embarrassing. When are your day ones switch up on you? That's pretty embarrassing. So, the actual betrayer, Judas Iscariot, is kind of an interesting topic in his own regard because everything we've said about how hard it is to know anything about Jesus is a hundred times more true for Judas, right? He's only in the Gospels, and he's basically only there to betray Jesus. He's also in some Apocrypha where he has some wild things that happen to him, but we won't get into that now. Yeah. As to why he betrayed Jesus, some argue that Judas was interested in like actual violent revolution against the Romans of the type that the later Jewish group known as the Sicarii would employ in the Jewish revolt. [2:01:36] Iscariot is basically a nonsense word, or at least one that we don't have the definition of, and its resemblance to Sicarii would kind of clear that up, and it would also give us some reason for why Judas betrayed Jesus, right? Because he thought that Jesus was going to incite some sort of rebellion against the Romans, and they came to Jerusalem, and Judas was like, We're going to do it now, right? And then Jesus was like, Yeah, that's not really what this is all about. And Judas felt, you know, spurned and betrayed him. It's also possible that he just did what the gospels say, which is betray him for money. It's kind of unsatisfying, but that kind of stuff happens all the time, and we kind of can't know. [2:02:17] Yeah, no, I think there's no chance we'll really ever know anything more about Judas, particularly. [2:02:23] Yeah, one thing that always got to me is just how laughably small the sum of money he betrays him for is. It's 30 pieces of silver. I think I read at some point that's like a couple of months' wages, maybe, for like a skilled laborer. And yeah, like, I don't know, just thinking about that always made me think like maybe there was something deeper going on. Like, I mean, you could always take like the Martin Scorsese Last Temptation of Christ line, where, you know, it was a setup, Jesus wanted to die, and he needed one of his followers to do that. But also, that's just very biblically, like, it's a huge heresy, you know? Like, they were literally firebombing movie theaters in France when that movie came out because Catholic extremists were not a fan of that. [2:03:06] And I think also, kind of, just keeping this more rooted in like a, you know, like a standard Christian perspective, I think also there's this interpretation that it was not a lot of money, but this shows how we are tempted by material possessions to sin, even if it's worth a lifetime in hell. I don't think the people who wrote the Gospels believed in the concept of a lifetime in hell, but this is how this was used, you know, by later Christian interpreters. I think one other point that we should mention about Judas is that Bart Ehrman supposes that it might be that what Jesus had, that what Judas specifically had betrayed was the fact that Jesus was claiming to be the Messiah. This was some kind of internal secret among his following. He wasn't going around publicly declaring himself to be the Messiah, but he was saying that I believe I am the Messiah. [2:03:59] My existence is going to cause the Romans to fall apart. I'm going to be proclaimed some new kind of kingly figure. I'm going to restore Judea to its ancient glory. Then God is going to physically come back. The Son of Man is going to become with him, and we're all going to get incredible rewards. Judas didn't want to wait that long and just took the reward now. [2:04:24] Yeah. [2:04:24] And one other point I want to mention before we move on to the emergence of Christianity is the figure of Pilate is kind of strange. I think the Gospels are almost weirdly pro-Roman, especially the Gospel of John. And this, when I say pro-Roman, it's that Pilate is seen, is depicted as a more reasonable guy than the Jewish authorities or the Pharisees are. I think that this might, this could potentially reflect the cultural bias of some of the authors who were writing for a Roman audience and wanted to portray a specific Roman as a good person. Basically, every other individual Roman, as far as I can tell, is also portrayed favorably. There's Cornelius the centurion, there's the centurion with the sick servant, there's even the centurion who declares truly this man is the son of God. So there's this kind of oddly pro-Roman stance in the New Testament, even though it appears that the entire thrust of the gospel would be we're getting these damn pagan Romans out of here. [2:05:32] So it's very kind of this strange tension there. I think it seems that over time, the guilt or the blame over Jesus' death was moved from the Romans toward the Jewish people. And every single text from Mark up to John and through the Apocrypha gets increasingly pro-Roman and anti-Jewish. Eventually, the Byzantines would go so far as to name Pilate as a saint, which I think is just, you know, absurd. Later apocryphal stories would say that Pilate converted to Christianity and tried to make Nero a Christian, but none of that is present in the canonical gospels at all. I also think that over time, Christian anti-Judaism during the composition of the Gospels became basically less about individual Jewish people opposed to Jesus, and then by the time of the Gospel of John, more about the Jewish people writ large. There's one mention, there's one line in the book of Matthew, which has been used to justify Christian anti-Judaism and later violent anti-Semitism. [2:06:55] And this is when a Jewish crowd says, curse be upon us and our children after they witnessed the horrible crucifixion of Jesus. People now wonder if that line, curse be upon us and our children, does not mean to refer to all of the Jewish people after every generation until the end of time. Instead, it literally means that generation of Jewish people and their immediate children. This might be the actual meaning here because the author of Matthew would have recently witnessed the destruction of the temple in Jerusalem by the Romans. This horrific misfortune, which had profound consequences on Judaism, might have been understood as a literal punishment for the generation after the Jews who were blamed for the death of Jesus. Okay, so now I think we do need to move on to the end of this episode, which is the birth of Christianity as a movement distinct from the Jewish following of Jesus. [2:08:03] So, again, to reiterate all of this, sometime around 30 to 33 CE, Jesus died. He was killed by Roman authorities in a particularly brutal way and probably disposed of somewhat unceremoniously. Jesus' apostles, as we are told by Mark, all fled the city in the wake of his arrest, abandoning their teacher and rabbi in his time of need. All of the Gospels also assert that during this time, Peter, probably the most important of the followers of Jesus, denied him three times when asked if he knew Jesus. The disciples only reconvened in Jerusalem after all the heat had died down. It appears that in this time, Jesus did not stay dead for long, at least in the memories of his followers, because stories of resurrection quickly began to spread among the believers. It was said that Jesus had died, but then later rose from the dead, and that he appeared to various followers in different ways to reveal that he had returned from the dead. [2:09:19] It was kind of a Victorian-era joke that the religion of Christianity had very little to do with the actual man of Jesus of Nazareth. I wouldn't go so far as to say this, but I do think it's true that only with the first resurrection testimonies can we say that Christianity, the religion, begins in earnest. We will never know who exactly started the idea that Jesus had returned from the dead. Early Christians were relatively good at writing down the sayings and deeds of Jesus of the Apostles, but we get very little about the actual beginnings of their religion. All the Gospels say is that a group of women, usually involving Mary Magdalene, came to the tomb to find that this body had disappeared. And in some accounts, they are told by an angel that Jesus had been resurrected. Paul and the Acts of the Apostles both tell us that Jesus instead appeared before these women to a vision to his male apostles, first to Peter, then to the rest of the 12. [2:10:22] I'm kind of curious, like, what do you guys think is the most likely account of how stories of the resurrection first began to circulate? [2:10:31] I kind of personally believe that this is just kind of a classic, like, when prophecy fails situation, right? Like, same thing that happened with the Millerites and how their Great Disappointment. [2:10:41] Exactly. [2:10:42] Like, there are people who are still descended from the Millerites that are still kicking today. And I think a similar thing happened then. I think that Jesus had kind of whipped up his followers and amped them up for the coming of the Son of Man. And then basically, they were forced to watch their teacher be tortured and killed. And they, as happens in some of these instances, they basically just refused to believe that that had happened. They tried to come up with some alternate explanation, and they probably just kept it sort of kicking in that way, right? It's probably not likely that any of them even saw him get taken down from the cross. It's probably, they probably didn't see his dead body, right? The apostles are supposed to have fled after he was captured. I think it's possible that through a mixture of sort of when prophecy fails and through a mixture of just the persuasive power of belief, somebody just had a dream or they thought they saw Jesus or they thought they had heard him talking to them and they basically just ran. [2:11:45] Yeah, no, and some psychologists claim that, you know, visions of this kind are especially common in periods of grief and are even more common in periods of grief associated with guilt. If you think that you should have been there for someone in their dying moments, you are more likely to have some kind of, you know, I guess, abnormal vision of yeah, yeah, that's definitely a plausible explanation. [2:12:12] Another one that I'm interested in, although it's like very cynical, and I'm not sure like if it's fair to ascribe that degree of cynicism to Jesus and his followers, but I could also very much see this being a situation of like, okay, so he's dead, right? But what's stopping us from like glorifying his name and saying like, oh, he rose from the dead? Let's just, you know, do a we are Charlie Kirk type situation and say there are a billion Jesuses now. [2:12:40] Yeah. Well, it's also strange because as far as I can tell, there was never any case of a martyr being exalted in this way, at least in, you know, the Greek or Roman and the Jewish worlds. Martyrdom was an important concept, but there wasn't a case where someone's death was seen as this great sacrifice. But it seems that very early, probably before Paul comes onto the scene, and we'll get to Paul in a second, there is this idea that the resurrection was sacrificial and that it had something to do with the salvation of the world, probably with the forgiveness of sin. Eventually, no matter what happened, it seems that people who accepted this story of the resurrection found themselves to basically be the first Christians. They were still Jewish. They were not in any sense non-Jew, you know, they were not breaking away from Judaism yet, but they were now forming a movement that had theological beliefs that I think are more different from standard Judaism than, like, let's say the Pharisees were from the Sadducees. [2:13:47] This was a more, I don't want to say heretical, but a more divergent Jewish movement that was eventually going to become something that was basically distinct from Judaism altogether. Anything you want to share about, you know, the early days of Christianity, either Sam or Jackson? [2:14:08] Yeah, I think something that gets talked about in the Acts of the Apostles is that you really do see this transition from the Jesus movement, right? This movement of this teacher named Jesus, which was apocalyptic, millenarian, it was based around the teachings of Jesus of Nazareth. In Acts of the Apostles, Paul starts to refer to it as the way, right? Which is a very like sort of, it's like an aura-filled, sort of legible, legibly modern thing to call your religion. But like, it does become like its own thing, right? It becomes the way, right? A religion based around the teachings of Jesus, but also based around the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus. And there starts to become pretty quickly a community of people who follow this way, right? They're not just members of this Jesus movement that listen to what Jesus has to say, but they follow the way, right? [2:15:11] His way to the kingdom of God, which at this point they still believe to be imminent, but they believe to be slightly less imminent than Jesus thought. And so the early followers of the way, right, we don't really know much about them, right? The Acts of the Apostles talks a little bit about the early Christian community, right? And this is kind of why I find Acts to be so interesting: Acts is sort of a history of the religion of Christianity after Jesus' death, right? And it's really, like we said earlier, like a history of a movement, right? It's really fun for anyone who has ever been in like a small political or cultural organization to read that's like an insular and minoritarian one because it's very much about like it's very much about like the history of factions that arise and then get sort of quieted through sort of not really clear means right it very much reads go ahead anyone familiar with left-wing politics is going to find a lot resonant about the acts of the apostles and really honestly early christian church history more broadly and i don't care if it's hacked to say this there are very fascinating structural similarities between the history of left-wing movements and the history of of christianity and i i think like you know the the obvious parallel with the Acts of the apostles is the the famous text, the history of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union, which was this official movement history meant to describe the Russian Revolution and the rise of Joseph Stalin in extremely sanitized, favorable terms to the leaders involved. [2:17:00] I think there are some very strong parallels here. [2:17:03] Yeah, no, I mean, they were holistically calling each other revisionists all the time, all these different quiddle sects. [2:17:10] Yeah, no, and like there were 250 years of basically like thunderdome theological turmoil from the death of Jesus up until the you know the adoption of Christianity as the state religion under Constantine. And like just there was just so much conflict during that time that some people have even suggested could have involved actual physical violence between early Christian supporters. That's totally speculative, but there was so much violent rhetoric flying around. It is very possible that this violence could have been physical at times. [2:17:44] Yeah, yeah, you mentioned a great theory that Paul actually died in one of these conflicts. [2:17:50] Yeah, no, and that is this. This is pure speculation, but it's, you know, you never know. They never say how Paul dies. They never say how Peter dies. You gotta wonder. [2:17:59] Right? So, like, take for example, there's this character in the Acts before actually Paul becomes a Christian named Simon Magus. He has so much like non-canonical lore about him that you could do in another whole episode on him. He's thought to be like the founder of Gnosticism. He's thought to be like the founder of like witchcraft. Like he's, he's a very, he's a very interesting figure. But in Acts, Simon Magus is described as a guy who does magic, seemingly through the power of God. Like he's a cool guy at first. Then he converts to Christianity, but then he gets mad when the apostles send other people to convert the Samaritans because he is a Samaritan. He tries to buy the power of benediction from the apostles, like give them money so that he can bestow God's grace on people. And then he is cast out of the Jesus movement. [2:18:52] He is shunned from the way. And he becomes the first heretic. And there's extra biblical tradition that holds that he like dies trying to fly. Like Peter basically shoots him out of the sky and he breaks his legs and he dies, right? So like we said, anyone who's ever tried to join like the successor to like an anime club and like nobody talks about like who started the anime club and like what broke it up is probably pretty familiar with like this kind of figure. [2:19:20] 100%. [2:19:21] Another figure that I find fascinating is the first martyr, Stephen. He's this young guy who gives a speech and then he dies. And I think that you kind of, again, by sort of by the criterion of embarrassment, the fact that he is only known for his death makes me think there probably was this young guy who joined the movement and then unexpectedly was killed by religious opponents. And that really freaked out the early Jesus movement and they ended up enshrining him as a martyr because after Jesus, he was the first person anybody had heard of who was killed just for what he believed. [2:19:53] Right. And so as to like what this actual community of early Christians believed, right? It's it's told there, the Acts tells us that they lived communally, like, right? Like, they lived in something kind of like a utopian commune where all things were held in common and everything was sort of divided according to need. Like we said, it's not really believed that they thought Jesus was wholly divine at this point. It's possible that they didn't even believe he was the Son of God, nor even really that his death had done anything but signify that they were living in the end times and that the Son of Man would return, you know, imminently. It's probable that people who saw the early Christians, maybe even the Christians themselves, did not consider themselves to be something separate from normal Judaism of the Pharisaical type, as they probably continued to keep the Mosaic law. [2:20:47] The keeping of the Mosaic law would only sort of become controversial and not become a central tenet of the way when a Hellenized Jew who had previously persecuted Christians by his own admission converted to Christianity. That being Saul, who eventually became Paul. [2:21:09] Yeah, yeah. Paul is just one of my favorite figures in human history. In so many ways, he feels like a very modern guy transplanted into this ancient context, both in his personality and in his kind of profile as this like educated diaspora kid torn between his Greek cultural background and his Jewish ethnic heritage, who apparently was educated in both Greek and Jewish traditions. He also was a total outsider. He was not Judean. He was not one of the followers of Jesus. Yet, simply because of his clout and the force of his personality, he was able to take over the Jesus movement from the actual disciples. And people believed him. It's amazing that he pulled that off. [2:21:55] No, I always marvel at the fact that he basically just was an outsider and an outsider who would hurt the movement, seemingly. And he basically just said, Yeah, Jesus appeared to me. And like people took that at its word. [2:22:11] Like people, people were like, Oh, I personally think this has to speak to his abilities. I think he was really, really good at convincing people to join this movement. He probably was good at like raising money. He was able to establish at least a half dozen permanent church communities across the Greek-speaking world of both Jewish and Gentile congregants, which like you can't do that unless you're really good at it. And I think that people might have just tolerated his outsideness simply because he was so useful to the movement and really helped bring it together and keep it together. [2:22:49] If we want to keep the metaphor going that acts as sort of like the history of the Communist Party, right? [2:22:55] Yeah. [2:22:55] Paul is Stalin. He is a guy who isn't really super important at the beginning. He's not the guy who really lays down the doctrine. He's just kind of there, but he's really effective. He knows how to get it done. And because, you know, after the initial sort of ecstatic burst of energy that creates the movement sort of goes away, they have to get a consolidator in there. And Paul is kind of like Stalin in that he is a pretty, like, like we said, if the sort of doctrinal disputes got violent, you know, not averse to violence, but an incredibly good consolidator, someone who is able to take this sort of these disparate sort of ideological precepts and mold them into something that maybe doesn't really actually resemble the original thought, but definitely can survive and maybe even be exported after the initial phase. [2:23:56] Yes, and so I think a big thing with Paul here is that he was, as mentioned, he was educated to some extent. He had connections to upper-class Greek circles, including Greek Gentile circles across modern-day Turkey and other parts of the Mediterranean as well, but mostly, mostly Anatolia, Asia Minor. He was really good at explaining Jewish Christian theology in ways that Gentiles could understand, probably because he had this Greek philosophical education to some extent. And he was so good at this that over the centuries, people have suggested, sometimes seriously, sometimes facetiously, that Christianity should be considered the religion of Paul more than the religion of Jesus, as it was really Paul who began exporting this movement out of Judea. And really, even within Judea, seems to have brought it together into a more cohesive project. Many concepts that we now consider to be bedrock Christian beliefs, such as the sacrifice of Jesus for the redemption of sin, belief in the resurrection as a necessary condition for salvation, and as well as some degree of divinity, are first attested in Paul. [2:25:13] Over time, these ideas would become more central and would become present in the gospels. Divinity, for instance, we see from Jesus being going from being a godlike figure to being a demigod figure to being God himself across the course of the four canonical gospels. Once Paul had managed to somehow take control of the movement in the Near East, you know, other early cities, in addition to Judea, there were early Christian communities in Antioch, especially and other parts of the Near East. After Paul had consolidated his power in the Near East, he began his work proselytizing to Greeks and other Gentiles across the Eastern Mediterranean. It's very possible that some of his theological conceptions were inspired by his earlier exposure to Greek philosophy, such as the idea that the resurrection of Jesus was some kind of blood sacrifice for mankind's sins. There is a debate about to what extent Paul had a philosophical education. [2:26:19] He certainly had a formal Jewish education, which other apostles might not have had. But scholars such as Richard Seaford assert that Paul makes several direct allusions to Greek literature that only a formally educated person would have made. For instance, he appears to reference the play The Bacchae, as well as the Greek poet Aratus. Moving on to philosophy, it's again hard to know which specific Greek philosophers Paul had read, but connections are often drawn with Plato and the Middle Platonists, who would have had a profound influence on the later Christian doctrine of Gnosticism. We don't have time to talk about Gnosticism in full in this episode, but the Gnostic doctrine was so early in Christian history that it was likely a development that began during or shortly after Paul's lifetime. Indeed, many of the sayings of Paul fit in with the Gnostic worldview that Jesus had come to destroy the imperfect mortal world and usher in a plane of perfection. [2:27:24] I think that Paul's personal spiritual beliefs prior to his conversion probably included some Platonic ideas which later contributed to Gnosticism. I think it's also possible that Paul was more interested in the death than the life of Jesus because Paul thought that Jesus was this kind of savior figure who could usher in the perfect Platonic world described not in the Jewish gospels or the Jewish texts, but in Platonic writing. But again, this is totally speculative here. I just think that you can't deny that there was some influence of Plato on early Christianity. We just don't really know what exactly Paul was reading. Scholars have also suggested that Paul might have been influenced by the Greek schools of Stoicism and Cynicism. All we can say is that he was likely a man of some Greek education as well as Jewish education and likely had exposure to elements of Hellenic philosophy that other followers of Jesus didn't have. [2:28:31] Yeah, and Paul was also a partisan of an interpretation of Jesus' teachings that would have been very controversial to the early Christians, that Jesus' sacrifice ended the necessity for the Mosaic Law. Circumcision was hard enough of a sell when it's done at birth and was basically, a non-starter for Gentile converts. And so, Paul's theology was very heavily informed by this reality. He quarreled with the so-called Judaizing Christians, people like Peter, who thought that the Mosaic Law was as important a part of Jesus' teaching on the imminence of the kingdom, and through a series of factional struggles, he was able to achieve at least some level of leadership over the then still small Jesus movement. For what it's worth, Acts seems to depict Christianity's broadening appeal with Gentiles around the time that these doctrinal issues started to arise. Although it's thought by some scholars that the Jesus movement's base was still diasporic communities of Jews throughout the Mediterranean, so it's hard to say if Paul really won these disputes, and if he did, to what extent Acts is playing it up in hindsight. [2:29:28] To keep up the metaphor here, there are really deep shades of Stalin's relatively modest position as the general secretary, helping him to make doctrinally controversial socialism in one country the order of the day for all the world's communist parties. So, Paul probably died before the Jewish revolt would essentially destroy organized Judaism and catapult the descendants of the Pharisees into control of Judaism. But not long after his death, the destruction of said Judaism in the war plowed up fertile soil for the growth of Christianity into a major religion. It's worth remembering, though, that at this stage, Christianity was still very much the way and not the Christianity that we are familiar with. It's not thought that Jesus' synonymity with God or his virgin birth were commonly held beliefs among the Christians, and the existence of Jewish influence on the church, coexisting with the Pauline Gentile-friendly Christianity, was probably widespread. [2:30:25] But the way had already diverged greatly from its roots. Gone was the message of Jesus of Nazareth, an apocalyptic preacher who prophesied the overturning of the earthly and ghostly status quo in an apocalyptic coming of the Son of Man to usher in the worldly kingdom of God. In its place was the Jesus movement, the way, Christianity, the religion about that apocalyptic preacher's message of love and forgiveness and humility, as well as non-conformity with the sinful world, and that apocalyptic preacher's sacrifice of his blood and his body to redeem the sins of all the believers and the redemption that proved that his message of the coming kingdom was still at hand and possibly proof of divinity. [2:31:06] Right. And I think, again, this is why Paul is, if not the most important figure in Christianity, certainly the second most after Jesus, because his interpretation and his mission to the Gentiles would totally alter the trajectory of the Jesus movement and probably be the biggest factor in its growth and endurance into what is now today the world's largest religion. I think regarding relations between Jews and Gentiles, I think that Paul himself was probably writing in a time in which Christianity was still predominantly Jewish, but becoming increasingly Gentile. And Paul was never in any sense turning away from Judaism. He believed he was sharing this Jewish revelatory knowledge with non-Jews because if God was the Lord of all people, then even non-Jews should be welcomed into this coming kingdom of God. Paul did not believe that Gentiles had to keep up the Jewish law. I don't think this is because Paul was himself against the Jewish law. [2:32:19] I think this was because he believed Jews and non-Jews had separate, distinct relationships with God. Very possibly, in the very near future, when God came back, all distinctions between Jews and non-Jews would be erased, and this point would become moot. Because God did not come back in Paul's lifetime or in the lifetime of his followers since, divisions instead between Jews and non-Jews sharpened, leading, of course, to centuries of anti-Semitism in the medium and long term, and in the shorter term, leading to the split away of Christianity from Judaism altogether. Around the time of the Council of Nicaea and a little bit after, there was lingering distrust of Jewish Christians within Christian churches, as it was thought that their continuing adherence to the Jewish law was somehow non-Christian. I don't think Paul would have wanted that at all, but by the 4th and 5th century, when Christianity was now overwhelmingly a Gentile religion and a Gentile religion favored by the once pagan Romans, I think that you can see how the Jewish roots of Christianity would thus be degraded. [2:33:45] This is again when we begin to see polemic references against Jewish Christian sects like the Ebionites, who maintained that Jesus was the son of Joseph rather than the Son of God. I personally think the theology of these Jewish Christian sects is probably closer to the original views of the first Christians and the historical Jesus, but we will really never know for sure. We can only presuppose based on logic and context. That basically wraps it up. To conclude now, Jackson and Russian Sam, what are your kind of closing thoughts here on why you think the study of the historical Jesus matters and what implications this might have on not just on Christianity, but really on our knowledge of civilization more broadly? [2:34:38] Well, I think it's just very important for a couple of reasons. There's, of course, the civilizational angle. Again, all of Western civilization, and I'm using a very broad definition here, sort of based on the idea of this figure. And if we want to truly know what this world is about, we just need to get to the root of this and figure out what his deal was. But more importantly, and maybe more saliently, just the story of Paul. You know, it's just such an incredible story. There are a lot of really great nuggets of wisdom in there for anyone who's actively trying to build a movement. You got to be Paul Maxing. You got to be studying the Gospels. You got to, you know, you got to be defeating your opponents in magical battles. Just, you know, go out there. You can just do things. [2:35:31] Yeah, and I kind of in that vein, like, I think that it is. If you were a Christian, I don't think that, you know, I don't think that anything here should, like, a sufficiently sophisticated Christianity, I don't think, is necessarily incompatible with the things that we've said today, right? Like, I think that a lot of biblical studies gets trashed by people who are believers because they think that it is telling them that they're wrong or like that there's some falseness at the root of Christianity. And I think that they do a good job of being like, well, no, that's not true. Like, if you think that there is still something to be gained here, and there's nothing wrong with thinking that there's some sort of deeper sort of religious truth to Christianity or Christian practice, right? I think that every biblical scholar would say that. But it does mean that you can't believe in sort of jot-and-tittle conservatism. [2:36:33] Like, you can't, you can't, you have to abandon that, right? You can't, that, if under the sway of all this, you can't really be a fundamentalist, right? You can't have a rigid and unbending interpretation of the Bible, right? So I think it's important in that regard, because I mean, not to get too topical, but like, you know, you see a lot of that these days, and it's important to remember that, you know, I think that there is a lot on the side of not acting like that, right? There's a lot on the side of not thinking that way. There's a lot of facts supporting that. But also, and something that I think is really interesting about this is that when you take the historical Jesus and you think about what he thought, and then you look at Christianity today and what Christians today think, they're way different from each other, right? [2:37:20] They are almost unrecognizable, right? Maybe Paul is the founder of Christianity because they really might as well not, they have very little to do with each other. I don't have nothing to do with each other, but very little. But I think that it kind of teaches us a lot about history, right? Because you can't know what's going to happen, right? No one can ever know what is going to happen in history, right? Jesus thought that he knew what was going to happen. The historical Jesus thought that the end of the world was imminent. That didn't end up happening. But Jesus of Nazareth also didn't know that he would have more than a billion people that claimed to be his followers in 2026, right? He had no way of knowing that. And I think that if that teaches us anything, it's that the various movements of world change, or rather, if that teaches us anything, it's that like the various movements of world change that shook the world in the 19th and 20th centuries, you never really can tell what shape any movement like that is going to take or how far it will end up from where it started. [2:38:36] And that in the future, despite how far we think we see into it, it's always going to surprise us, right? There's always going to be something that we can't see today that may surprise people in the present, right? So I think that the Jesus movement's history just sort of keeps, it begs us to keep that in mind, right? That we can't. [2:38:57] And I think it's fascinating that even though, you know, if you look at Jesus as the Messiah, from the traditional Jewish interpretation based on intertestamental texts and the various prophetic texts, Jesus looks nothing like the Messiah. He absolutely did not liberate Israel. He absolutely did not kick out the pagans. He did not restore his kingdom to its glory. He failed. He was killed in a humiliating fashion upon the cross. His own followers deserted him. But if you take a broader look, Jesus, in a sense, absolutely did conquer the Romans. Like, you know, 300 years later, like I said, like the descendants of the same people who killed him were then professing that he was their savior. And I think, like, you know, absolutely nobody in the Roman world would have seen this coming. The entire rise of Christianity is probably the most significant imperial blowback ever in history. [2:39:59] And it is a good reminder that even though we think that we have the right theories to know what exactly is going to happen, you're absolutely right that there are no prophets. Nobody can see the future. And that, you know, truly nothing is predetermined. [2:40:17] So true. [2:40:18] All right. Well, on that happy note, I think this has been one of our best. I hope our listeners enjoy this long account of one of the most fascinating figures in history. [2:40:29] Yeah, now let's see what all the rest of us can do to, you know, bring God's kingdom back to earth and have that heavenly pizza party. Because I think we deserve it. Remember, the kingdom of heaven is within you. [2:40:40] Yes, all right. All right. Well, this is Gladio Free Europe signing off. All right. Bye-bye.