Gladio Free Europe, E123: The Birth of Arthur https://www.gladiofreeeurope.com/episodes/the-birth-of-arthur [0:00:18] Shortly before his death, in the year 1189, King Henry II of England directed his bishops upon a quest. They were to dig up the churchyards of their cathedrals and abbeys in search of the remains of his predecessor. By this point, Henry Fitz Empress was the effective hegemon of Western Europe, peerless among rival kings and the most formidable monarch in Christendom since Charlemagne. Of the kings of Britain, none could claim to have been greater than he, with one exception. For the past 50 years, stories had been widely shared of the glorious knights of the ancient past. In the 5th and the 6th century, the very dawn of the medieval era, the great men of Britain were more valiant and more chivalrous than those alive in the 12th century. Gathered at a great round table, these men exemplified both the virtues of Christendom and the lost glories of the Roman Empire. [0:01:26] Under the reign of one king, the power of Britain would sweep much of the known world, just as it would again centuries later in Henry's day. But despite its greatness, this kingdom would be betrayed from within. Britain would fall to the pagan Saxons, sweeping the land with a dark night of barbarism. But its ruler, it was said, did not die. Instead, he slept at a place called Avalon, and like Christ, would one day rise again. This is why, following King Henry's orders, a team led by Abbot Henry de Sully broke through the hallowed soil of Glastonbury Abbey in 1191, consecrated by the Saxon saint Dunstan hundreds of years prior. This was because in the days even before Dunstan, this land, a hill over a foggy plain, was said to have been called Ynys Afallach, Island of the Apples. If Abbot de Sully was to be believed, this place was Avalon. [0:02:33] As his men dug through the graves, through layers upon layers of the dead, they came upon something remarkable. According to contemporaneous writer Gerald of Wales, underneath the soil were the ancient bones of a man and a woman, whose body still contained a lock of golden hair. Though Gerald was deeply contemptuous of the local people and their beliefs, what he described next was shocking and, in his words, miraculous. The men lifted up from the grave a stone slab, and affixed to this slab was a cross of lead. Written upon the cross was the following inscription, translated from Latin. Here in the Isle of Avalon lies buried the renowned King Arthur with Guinevere, his second wife. The apparent discovery of King Arthur's tomb at Glastonbury was one of the most significant archaeological finds of the Middle Ages. Gerald's report of this dig would generate almost as much medieval excitement and modern anxiety as alleged Christian relics like the Holy Lance or the Shroud of Turin. [0:03:38] But King Arthur was not a biblical figure, nor was he a saint. He was, it was thought, a historical figure, a king and commander so great and a Christian so great that he was worthy of admiration rarely granted to any mortal man. By the 1190s, Western Europeans were obsessed with King Arthur, not only in England and Wales, but also in France and the Holy Roman Empire, and even as far afield as Italy and Spain. Yet a century prior, none of these people outside of Wales and the French region of Brittany would have heard of Arthur at all. The reasons for the shift was something very novel by the standards of the Middle Ages. King Arthur had become so celebrated so quickly because he was the most beloved character of medieval pop culture. Beginning in the long reign of Henry II and continuing at least as late as that of his descendant, Henry VII, stories of Arthur would form the core of a vernacular fiction, a genre and an industry which heretofore did not exist. [0:04:36] This was known as a chivalric romance. [0:04:39] Right, and so this episode of Gladio Free Europe is going to explore the emergence of the entire Arthurian tradition, perhaps the most famous and most interesting aspect of all medieval vernacular culture. So much of this is around the genre of the romance, a new genre of fiction that didn't exist until the High Middle Ages and would really dominate medieval literature basically until the end of the Middle Ages. So just to get this straight, romance in this context refers more to adventure than love, although to medieval readers, these ideas were actually very closely entwined. The origins of the word romance are somewhat obscure, but people living in France in the early Middle Ages described their own vernacular language as Romance, a term which identified them with their Roman heritage while also distinguishing their speech from the high Latin of the church. We can compare this French usage with the name Romansh, the Romance language of Eastern Switzerland still spoken today. [0:05:45] By the time of Henry II, the word Romance or Romance came to mean stories written in this vernacular language, and this is the language that we would today call Old French. But it didn't just mean any vernacular story. A romance was a story dealing with concerns and interests of medieval people, and in particular, the landed aristocracy, the knights and barons who held land and who fought for a living. The romance was a new literary genre, and it was arguably the first popular fiction in Western Europe since the time of the Romans, at least the first to circulate in written form. These stories, which were often written in verse, would be hugely indebted to classical poetry, especially Virgil's Aeneid, and many romances were in fact adaptations of Greek and Roman texts. Others still were modern stories based around ancient Mediterranean heroes, sometimes mythological figures like Perseus, other times historical figures like Julius Caesar. [0:06:52] But there were two other major influences on the medieval Romance tradition. First, there were a small body of earlier poems about the Frankish Emperor Charlemagne and his warriors. The most notable of these is, of course, The Song of Roland, a piece produced in the late 11th century about a fight against the Basques turned into a fight against Muslims. The other literary influence here would be greater than that of the Romans, greater than the works centered around Charlemagne, but is also much more difficult to understand. I'm talking about the vast body of oral stories, particularly those told or sung by Celtic language-speaking bards, which had radiated out of the island of Britain since the earliest centuries of the Middle Ages, the very period when King Arthur would have ruled. These stories, though not recorded until many centuries later in written form, would become the primary literary basis for the Arthurian canon that would eventually take over all of Britain and eventually spread across much of the medieval world. [0:08:07] As you can see by our episode length, Arthuriana is a massive subject. Our previous episode on Beowulf dealt with a single epic poem. This episode will explore dozens. An entire literary tradition which flourished for over 300 years and drew from stories that were older still. Stories which may have once been told about real kings and real warriors, recorded as faint echoes in fantastical literature even today. Like Camelot, the literary corpus about King Arthur is vast and crenellated. You can spend years examining all of the various aspects and interpretations of this canon. This is partially because there's just so much material to discover. Arthuriana absolutely dominated the high and late Middle Ages. After the massive success of some 12th century writers, particularly Geoffrey of Monmouth and Chrétien de Troyes, Arthurian romance became Europe's foremost genre of popular literature. Stories of King Arthur and his court exploded across Europe, most prominently in France and Britain, but to a significant extent in Germany and Italy as well. [0:09:20] Smaller numbers of Arthurian works, particularly romances, survive in Old Norse, Spanish, Yiddish, and Hebrew. Recent scholarship has suggested that these stories may have also influenced heroic narratives in the Arabic-speaking world, particularly in the Iberian kingdom of Granada. While we cannot say that King Arthur was ever bigger than Jesus, as the great majority of medieval texts were still devotional in nature, these chivalric romance stories would comprise a full majority of vernacular literature in the Middle Ages. These texts were so influential that by the 13th and 14th centuries, many knights and aristocrats themselves fully took to heart the values and aesthetics of these fictional stories. King Edward III of England was said to proclaim quests to the various knights in his hall and created the Order of the Garter largely on the Arthurian model. His son Edward the Black Prince was considered to be rivaled in chivalry only by the ancient knights of the round table. [0:10:24] People took these stories extremely seriously, which makes sense considering there was very little other popular literature around. [0:10:34] Right. A recent statistical analysis argued that our surviving Arthurian canon is probably only a minority of all the adventure stories composed in this period. Tragically, these chivalric works were considered frivolous by contemporaries and especially by early modern people. After the Age of Knights and Castles came to an end, Europeans had little interest in copying and preserving the chivalric romances unless they had notable historical, religious, or nationalistic implications. So, clearly, a huge amount of Arthurian romances were written, and this episode will explore only a small number of stones in this massive literary castle. But size isn't everything, there is another reason why King Arthur remains the object of such enduring fascination. Through nearly, though nearly all of our sources come from 1150 or later, the period in which they are set is the late 5th or early 6th century. This is one of the most obscure and most pivotal moments of European history. [0:11:28] This was the collapse of the Roman world and the rise of the medieval. Within Britain specifically, we see the emergence of Germanic-speaking kingdoms across much of the island and the beginning of a process of displacement of Celtic languages into the rocky western reaches, places like Wales and Cornwall and Cumbria. These Celtic-speaking peoples, often called the Romano-Britons, were directly continuous with the period of Roman imperial control over the island. Although the Roman Empire had apparently stopped defending Britain around 410, resulting in a disastrous power vacuum, its residents maintained a strong sense of Roman identity, closely tied to their Christian religion and their use of Latin as a religious and literary language. [0:12:06] Yeah, and most of our listeners probably know that while King Arthur is a British hero, he's not an English one. His enemies, as far back as the earliest references, are pagan Saxons, progenitors of the later English. Although English people would come to embrace Arthur as perhaps their greatest national hero, his earliest fans would be Celtic speakers. Welsh, Breton, Cornish, as well as a bit later on, French speakers. It is actually due to the work of these French poets that King Arthur stories spread outside the Celtic world and into the aristocratic courts of Western European aristocrats. Over time, these Arthurian romances would be grouped together with each other, as well as other renditions of Welsh and Breton legends, most famously the tale of Tristan and Isolde. Together, this collection would be called the Matter of Britain. The phrase could maybe be more accurately translated as the subject of Britain, and it comes to us from French. [0:13:13] Again, it was the French, not the English or even the Welsh, who really popularized Story of Arthur and Camelot in the high and late Middle Ages. Some of these writers, like Wace, were Normans living in England. Others, like Chrétien, were Frenchmen living in France, but who had close professional or personal ties with the English realm and the English court. Even Thomas Malory, the last great writer of Arthurian romance, felt compelled to give his English language biography a very French name. His book, Le Morte d'Arthur, was the first to codify the previous 800 years or so of Arthurian references into a single narrative. Aptly named, the publication of Le Morte d'Arthur basically marks the end of the medieval Arthurian tradition and the end of chivalric romance more broadly. A century after its composition, a certain Miguel de Cervantes would embark on his own epic, which would skew and skewer our perception of knights and castles forevermore. [0:14:21] This Thomas Malory was himself a knight and apparently a very bad one. His text reflects his own experiences with chivalry and the failure of knights like himself to live up to the expected values of armed men of high birth. After its 1485 publication by early printer William Caxton, Le Morte d'Arthur was an immediate hit. It would be reprinted all throughout the 16th century, including by one of the best-named printers of all history, Wynkyn de Worde. Due to these republications, Le Morte d'Arthur became one of the most widely read works of fictions in Tudor-era England, retaining much more relevance than earlier Arthurian texts. Malory's book is a great introduction to the tropes in the settings of Arthuriana, but I'd argue his dry prose and stiff characterization don't do service to the entire Romance tradition. [0:15:20] Yeah. [0:15:20] Its gravity and solemnity would strongly inform later takes on the Arthurian legend. For instance, the 19th century writings of Alfred Tennyson or the late Victorian paintings of the pre-Raphaelites. More recently, the 1981 film Excalibur by John Boorman is almost entirely based on Le Morte d'Arthur. If you are not familiar with Arthurian tropes and characters at all, the movie's a pretty good introduction to the most basic themes and figures. [0:15:49] It's the most chrome movie I've ever seen. [0:15:51] It is extremely shiny, yes. But Excalibur is so reliant on Malory that it's everything that makes his work beautiful and also everything that makes his work dull. It's one of those movies that I think is actually much better consumed in GIF form than as motion picture. So, you know, I really want to emphasize here that other earlier writers of Arthurian stories, those before Malory, most especially the great 12th century poet Chrétien de Troyes, brought a lot more color and a lot more self-awareness and fun and whimsy and playfulness to this lost world of post-Roman Britain. But Malory's book would have a much greater influence than any of those French stories because it was one of the first English books to be mass-produced. Due to its very early printing and reprinting, it almost seems like the late 15th century version to a game that everybody has just because it comes pre-installed in your Xbox. [0:16:52] By the 16th century, after the period of chivalric romance had basically come to an end, those earlier medieval stories, most of which were French, stopped being copied. Malory's Le Morte d'Arthur became nearly the only Arthurian text readily accessible to English readers. Even in the English tradition, famous stories like Gawain and the Green Knight had to be rediscovered in the 19th century. There was another text that was widely circulated after the period of Thomas Malory, but it wasn't a romance. This was the Historia Regum Britanniae, a fantastical 12th-century history of Britain that begins with the settlement of the island by refugees of the Trojan War and contains the earliest detailed biography of King Arthur. This book, The Historia, kind of bookends the Arthurian tradition just as much as Malory does. This episode of Gladio Free Europe is going to explore the birth of this tradition to see how campfire stories about a sixth-century warlord turned into medieval tales of a lost chivalrous king. [0:18:05] We are going to go chronologically from the origins of this medieval British folklore through the creation of the Historia Regnum Britanniae and the rise of the romances, up until the end of the European Arthurian tradition and its afterlife. It is no coincidence that poets and storytellers became much less interested in Arthur by the early 16th century, just as knights were losing their military prominence, as the printed pamphlet replaced the illuminated manuscript, and as high medieval values of chivalry and courtly love gave way to new early modern concerns about the individual's relationship to God, to morality, and to the state. [0:18:50] Yes. I'm also going to say there are two big pieces of Arthurian lore we're basically going to sidestep here, because they're such big topics of discussion and we really cannot contain them in this episode. These are the character of Merlin and the image of the Holy Grail. We're going to touch on both, but we might have to come back to these in a future episode. There's just so much to get into. [0:19:17] Yeah. All right. Well, without further ado, let's get into it. For many centuries, King Arthur was considered to be a completely historical figure. Even today, many books and documentaries insist that they haven't covered the truth of the real man who inspired the legendary king. But here's the thing: nobody truly knows if there was a real man behind the stories. There's not a single contemporary or near-contemporary source attesting to Arthur's existence. But remember, this is also true of nearly every other figure from this time and place. If King Arthur really existed, he would have lived at some point in the late 5th or early 6th centuries. This period was one of the most turbulent of European and especially British history. It was the closest we had to a true Dark Age. Only a handful of works from this place and time survive, most notably the writings of Saint Patrick and another saint named Gildas, whose impassioned ramble on the ruin and conquest of Britain is the only first-hand account on the collapse of Romano-British civilization and attacks by barbarians. [0:20:17] Both of these works we've met, we've read at various points in the podcast. I believe the Gildas one was episode 14, so go back and listen to that. It's been five years. [0:20:28] Shocking. [0:20:29] But anyway, that's true. [0:20:31] Yeah. Neither of these works mention Arthur at all, although Gildas' work would form the basis of later medieval reconstructions of Arthur's world. The lack of any mention of Arthur in Gildas is enough for some scholars to say that he is a purely fictional character. Others believe that a real man named Arthur could have been one of several historical figures from post-Roman Britain who all came together to inspire the folklore king. The main historic figure brought up was Ambrosius Aurelianus, a general mentioned by Gildas as one of the only righteous men in Britain's most desperate moment. Another was Riothamus, a figure mentioned by the Byzantine historian Jordanes, who led an army of Britons in defense of the Empire. Riothamus didn't fight in Britain, but actually in Gaul. It's been suggested that an overseas expedition like this may have inspired stories of King Arthur fighting on the continent. [0:21:19] We will never know, of course, but I think it's more likely than not that at least some historic memory of the chaos of these centuries caused the British people to search their history and their folktales for an inspirational hero. [0:21:31] Yeah, and so of course this hero would come to be known as Arthur, and that's a name that appears most likely to derive from the Latin Artorius, as Arthur is referred to by this name in various early accounts. Since the 1920s, a Roman general named Lucius Artorius Castus has also been suggested as a possible inspiration for King Arthur. Personally, I think this is completely nonsense, because this Artorius Castus lived in the 2nd century, long before the 6th century of the historic King Arthur. He also had only a passing association, if any, with the island of Britain. I think that is a pure coincidence, but you know, it shows that this name was in use in the Latin-speaking world. The name Artorius may also have been used as the Latinization of a Celtic name that sounded a bit similar. We don't exactly know what the original name would have been, but it most likely began with the word Arth, meaning bear. [0:22:35] Again, this is hypothetical. We don't know what this early Celtic Arthur type name could have been. We have no references to anybody being named Arthur until after King Arthur's stories, but this shows how we can reconstruct the story. [0:22:48] Yeah, well, we do have the Arthur stone. [0:22:50] Oh, yes, yes. We'll get to that. Yes. Okay. Let me say we don't have any specific literary references to somebody named Arthur. [0:23:00] I just want to add here, because it's a very funny coincidence, that if the name does indeed refer to a bear trying to say that, you know, this king could have been as fierce as a bear or something like that, this would make him, this would give him an interesting similarity to Beowulf, the Geatish hero of our last episode, who in fact would have lived at the exact same time and also had a name referring to bears. We were saying before if anyone has ever tried to argue that Beowulf and King Arthur were in fact the same person, I have never seen that argued, but it honestly is not that much more implausible than many other theories about King Arthur. But okay, let's get to the brass tacks here of the round table. What do we actually know about the potentially historic, or at least the early folkloric King Arthur? [0:23:53] And unfortunately, we have exactly one early source that mentions King Arthur. And although tantalizing, this early source tells us nothing except his name. The Welsh narrative poem Y Gododdin, probably composed around 100 and 200 years after the historic Arthur would have lived, tells us about a different hero named Gwawrddur, who fed black ravens on the rampart of a fortress. Though he was no Arthur, among the powerful ones in battle in the front rank, Gwawrddur was a palisade. And that's it. That little poetic stanza from the Welsh is the entirety of our early references to Arthur. When I say early, I'm using that term pretty liberally. I mean, within the lifetime of somebody who could have possibly known a very old person, who could have known another person who had met Arthur. And this passage doesn't even say he was a king, just that he was valiant in battle. [0:24:58] Because there are no other references to any prior figure named Arthur, historians are pretty confident that this poem in Y Gododdin is a reference to the same figure as the later Arthur we know from folklore and literature. Centuries would pass before these later references begin. Then in the 9th and 10th centuries, we have two Welsh chronicles that express exactly who this Arthur guy was. According to the Historia Brittonum and the Annales Cambriae, or Annals of Wales, Arthur was a soldier and a commander, a miles and a dux bellorum, who fought the pagan Saxons while bearing the image of the cross. Note that he is still not a king. Both of these sources also suggest that Arthur's greatest victory was at the Battle of Badon, a fight first mentioned by our contemporary source Gildas, who remember doesn't mention anything about a guy named Arthur being present. Now, 400 years after Gildas, we are told that Arthur's power and piety won the day. [0:26:07] The Annals of Wales give us a specific date to Arthur's activities. Badon was fought in 516 AD. This is a really cool detail because, as a funny coincidence, this happens to be the same year that a group of Danes plundered Frankish territory on the continent. As we mentioned last episode, this Danish raid is used to date the text of Beowulf, or rather the story of Beowulf, to that same era, around, you know, early 6th century. We have very few other references to Arthur after the 10th century, but before the 12th century. But there's nothing. You know, the entire Anglo-Saxon literary tradition, for instance, the tradition by the supposed enemies of Arthur, contains nothing about this guy. Everything we have is from the Welsh. Saintly hagiographies, though, are a little bit relevant here only because the plot points and the tone of some of these texts seem to inspire later Arthurian romances. [0:27:07] It has been thought that some of these saints' lives could contain coded information about the real Arthur. I think that's very implausible. I think that rather the similarities you see between the hagiographies and the romances are because hagiographies were basically the only popular literature available before the emergence of the romance. As a specific example here, this is very strange, but it has been argued that the figure of Merlin in Welsh Myrddin sounds a little bit like the name Martin. So stories of the saint Martin of Tours from France might have actually influenced Merlin's magical powers. Again, this just shows the dominance of the hagiography on the medieval mind. There's one last interesting detail from these early references, which can be used both for and against Arthur's existence. So, again, we don't have any evidence of somebody specifically named Arthur before the 6th century, except maybe an inscription we'll get to later. [0:28:12] Yes. [0:28:12] The clearest reference we have is to a guy with a similar name, an Irish prince named Artuir. This Artuir would have died at the very end of the 6th century. He's mentioned in the 7th century in the life of Saint Columba. If this man, known from hagiography, really existed, it is hypothetically possible that he had some connection to the real King Arthur, if there was one. I think more plausibly, he could have been named after a recent figure whose reputation was so renowned that it had spread out of southwest Britain into Scotland and Ireland. Again, I don't know if this says in either direction whether or not there was a real King Arthur, but I think it's possible that the existence of a guy named Artuir at the end of the 6th century shows that the folkloric figure of King Arthur had already begun to spread quite widely in just a century. [0:29:15] Yeah, and I mean, we don't have to tell you guys, there are just mountains of Arthuriana coming out even this year, where these various writers try to stake out the claim of the historic King Arthur and try to glean out facts from much less fanciful accounts, which were written by writers of romances who were not trying to faithfully describe their past. But we don't think that we should get into these arguments because there's just so little evidence in either direction. Instead, Liam and I want us to look at who King Arthur could have been, and then we will see how this 6th century warlord was transformed into the High Middle Ages' most chivalric king. [0:29:55] Yes. So, let's make something clear. If Arthur had been around the 6th century, he absolutely would not have been the ruler of a great stone castle, holding court at a round table with his knights in shining armor. All the cultural and aesthetic trappings of the High Middle Ages and the chivalric values expressed so passionately in later Arthurian romance did not yet exist. This means that medieval Arthurian literature is very deeply anachronistic. A particularly egregious example is how Arthur and his knights are often described as battling Muslims in the Holy Land, even though they would have lived a century before Islam even existed. Now, whether or not this was deliberate is a matter of debate among scholars. It probably goes without saying that there's no reason to believe anybody else at his court was actually associated with the real Arthur. But while some figures, like Merlin, are based on possibly real but unrelated individuals, others, like Guinevere, Gawain, Galahad, and Lancelot are all purely fictitious. [0:30:56] These are products of high medieval chronicles and romances, but a small number are hypothesized to come from another source. 20th century scholars like J.R.R. Tolkien noted that some certain figures of the Arthurian canon, like Lancelot and Guinevere, appear to be very Latinate and courtly, reflecting the values of the Roman Empire which survived in later medieval works. Other figures like Morgan le Fay, who live outside of Camelot in the woods and grottos, hearken towards an older, more mysterious, perhaps more Celtic past. While we're not convinced that the argument of Morgan le Fay being based on an Irish goddess named Morrigan, we think that the broad thrust of this argument is correct, that there are many folkloric elements that went into baking the Arthurian cake that we eat these days. [0:31:47] Yes, yeah, and that's because Arthurian stories are a witness to the turbulent history of Britain, preserving many elements of the folklore of its various inhabitants, Christian and pagan alike, from the ancient Britons to the Romans to the Saxons and eventually the French. It's fascinating that Arthurian stories are so central to British folklore because the period these stories are set in is one of the most obscure in British history. We've discussed previously on the show how while we can debate how severe and how rapid the collapse of the Roman Empire was in continental Europe, the island of Britain experienced a disastrous and horrific decline as it drifted outside of Roman control. The traditional narrative presented a classic case of barbarian despoliation. Here is how an 18th or 19th century historian would put it. And don't you dare clip this out of context and try to say I'm arguing this genuinely. [0:32:48] No, Liam actually does believe this for directly. [0:32:50] No, not true, not true. So what they would have said in like 1840 is: immediately after 410 AD, the Saxons, remorseless veterans of a Germanic warrior culture, invaded a helpless island of Celtic Britons recently enlightened by Rome. These Britons tried in vain to protect their Christian civilization from the illiterate pagans who then slaughtered and raped their way across the island, eradicating all the Celts, except those who escaped to the highlands of Wales in the west and Scotland in the north. These Anglo-Saxons thus became the ancestors of the English, a Teutonic race fundamentally different from the Celts of the Highlands, whose unique determination would allow them to build a civilization and an empire far exceeding the Celts and even greater than the Romans. By proving their superiority through right of conquest, English speakers had won the right to rule over Celtic speakers, which meant the Welsh and the Scots and the Irish are not allowed to complain. [0:33:48] Long-term Gladio listeners already know this is not in any sense an accurate picture of the early Middle Ages. We've brought up the Anglo-Saxon migration repeatedly because it's one of the most complex and unusual events in all of European history. But due to the lack of contemporaneous sources, early historians, meaning 19th-century historians, who did not have access to modern archaeological techniques, had to reconstruct what happened using very fragmentary and unreliable literary sources. In reality, there was not a great conquest of the island by rampaging Saxons. Instead, the Celtic-speaking lowlands of Britain became the Germanic-speaking England through a complex process of accommodation and assimilation. While the migration of Anglo-Saxons was very rapid from a historical standpoint, it wasn't necessarily perceptible in a human timeframe. Britons of late antiquity absolutely suffered horrific violence. Some of this violence was indeed committed by the forebears of the English. But archaeology and archaeogenetics indicate that this was more of a story of shifting identities than shifting peoples. [0:35:05] It was not a case of widespread massacre and replacement. Certain Anglo-Saxon polities may have, in fact, been formed through the co-option of existing Romano-British states. Great attention has been paid to the fact that the early kings of Wessex, literally the West Saxons, had Celtic names. The Kingdom of Kent also derives its name from earlier Roman and Celtic sources. We cannot assume that the political takeover by elite Angles and Saxons happened at the same time or for the same reasons as the spread of the Old English language. For instance, we know that numbers of Germanic speakers were hired prior to the Roman withdrawal of 410. They were hired to defend the island of Britain from internal and external threats and were posted as far north as Hadrian's Wall. In the south, fortifications along the English Channel came to be known as the Saxon Shore due to their defensive purpose in protecting Britain from early sea raiders from Saxony, ancestors of the people who would make England English. [0:36:14] But long before any major Saxon settlement began, some Roman troops manning that Saxon shore were apparently of Saxon descent themselves. Well, the Saxons who settled Britain, the, you know, barbarian plunderers, were often assumed to be contrary to Roman civilization. Roman trade and service in the Roman military was extremely widespread among Germanic-speaking peoples, especially these Saxons who lived right across the Roman frontier. Many of the people invading Britain were probably veterans of Roman service themselves, especially because the Roman Empire survived longer on the continent than it did in Britain. It's very possible that there were more Roman veterans attacking Britain in the 5th century than there were defending it. [0:37:06] Yeah. A major narrative violation. [0:37:09] Yeah, so while there were indeed many, many raids carried out by Germanic speakers in this period, as well as by the Irish and Picts from the West and North, respectively, the archaeological as well as literary evidence indicates some peaceful movement of Saxons as mercenaries for and not against various British warlords. They may have been offered lands recently vacated by peoples moving to the continent. It's highly possible that these mercenaries, once they had been invited, became the core of a military elite that came to control the lowlands, not through violent conquest, but through wealth accumulation, as well as through political marriages with the local British nobility. None of this would indicate that these things were all sunshine and roses in the 5th and 6th centuries. In fact, this period saw some of the least sunshine and fewest roses in centuries. By all accounts, Glyfen post-Roman Britain was absolutely miserable. [0:38:00] And while the Saxons didn't cause this, they did not improve the situation one bit. If you would like to learn more about the situation and the period, check out our second Pirenne episode where we went deep into post-Roman Britain. But anyway, following the enigmatic departure of Roman troops in 410, the island of Britain fell into disaster and disarray. Basic aspects of Roman society and economy could not be maintained at all. The people who had lived there for centuries in Mediterranean-style villas and towns now migrated to ancient, easily defensible hill forts built by their Iron Age ancestors. Literacy and knowledge of Latin eroded, roads went unpaved, Hadrian's Wall was torn apart for its stones, some of which would be used to build the very abbey where Bede taught, and many, many more things. [0:38:48] Famously, they lost a pottery wheel somehow. So, in other words, they just spent centuries making pottery by hand, which is absolutely miserable. [0:38:58] Yeah. Now, and cunt. Yeah, I'm chosen. [0:39:01] We didn't say who Bede is. [0:39:02] Bede, that's the Anglo-Saxon historian who gives us the names, you know, Angles, Saxons, and Jutes. He's our best source on the early Anglo-Saxon migration. And although he's an incredible writer, he does not give us much in the way of historic reliability. It's very hard to know what he said is factual and what is allegorical. [0:39:24] Yeah, he wrote the Ecclesiastical History of Britain. That's considered one of the first sources. Go read that if you're interested in this stuff, I guess. But anyway, he's also a calendar nerd, which is not a type of guy you see that often. [0:39:37] Yeah, I could go on about calendar nerds for a while, honestly, just because it's so central, but that would be a distraction from this topic. This is going to be long enough, so let's, yeah. Okay, so in contrast to the slow transformation from mercantile bureaucracy to agrarian landlordism that we see in the continent, again, this was described by the historian Henri Pirenne, who we've discussed in the past. Britain, unlike the continent, lost its complex Roman economy with violent rapidity. As the great modern historian Guy Halsall puts it, an old woman born in the middle of the 4th century would have entered a world of long-distance trade, a heavily monetized economy, a world of towns with the old Roman urban facilities, of elite, stone-built, tile-roofed villas, with under-floor heating. But she would have left a world without towns or villas, or any organized specialized crafts and industry, where the economy was local and small-scale, relying upon barter and gift rather than coinage, and where people universally lived in thatched-roofed timber buildings. [0:40:49] If she was extremely old and lived until the 6th century, her life would have gotten bleaker, not better. By the 6th century, as we mentioned, basic technologies like the potter's wheel and tiled roofs had vanished altogether. International trade was severely restricted, and non-luxury imports basically vanish. At the same time that fewer and fewer new goods were entering the island, older goods were increasingly reused. This is especially grim because it suggests that people lacked the skills to replace even basic items needed for everyday life. More people were likely employed in agriculture rather than skilled trades. Yet, at the same time, the rapid regrowth of forest suggests that less land was under cultivation. And then we have the terrible volcanic winter of 536, when average temperatures dropped several degrees in Britain. According to the archaeologist Deborah Shepard, this was enough to shrink the growing season by up to 30 days. [0:41:57] This means that marginal farmland, like the rocky soils of much of northern and western Britain, suddenly became useless for farming. Huge swaths of territory either returned to wilderness or were now used for the grazing of cattle. All of this indicates a shrinking population and the long-term adaptation to a more meagre standard of living. It was in this period of collapse that many Britonic-speaking refugees, presumably those of some economic means, sailed across the English Channel to northwest Gaul, to the place that soon came to be known as Brittany, or Little Britain. Some of you may not be aware that the reason we say Great Britain is not because we love the Beatles and jellied eels, but it's to differentiate it from this part of France. [0:42:44] Yes. [0:42:45] It is entirely possible that due to this settlement or even colonization, as it's sometimes called, more people may have left Britain in the 5th and 6th century than entered it. Modern-day historians like Guy Halsall make it exceedingly clear that the Anglo-Saxons did not cause the fall of Roman Britain. Instead, they became the conquerors of a world that was already in ruins. People who did enter Britain in this period would not have been living large. Except for a small number of chieftains or warrior aristocrats, these Germanic-speaking newcomers would have shared much of the same misery as the Celtic-speaking natives. But from the perspective of an Anglo-Saxon in this period, Britain would have had a more hospitable climate than the places they were leaving behind. Again, the winter of 536 was nightmarish. It essentially wiped out all human habitation in northern Norway, causing major population pressures in the rest of Scandinavia and the broader North Sea world, very possibly creating a series of a chain of events that eventually lead to the Viking Age centuries later. [0:43:58] Well, back to the fifth and sixth centuries, the parts of Britain that have the highest amount of Germanic-speaking settlement, mostly along the eastern coast, would actually be some of the poorest and most lightly populated parts of the island. While it's easy to blame the Anglo-Saxons for this poverty, it's more probable that the places they settled were up for grabs, as they'd already been largely depopulated following the Roman withdrawal and the mass exodus to the continent. Not every part of Britain, however, was as bleak as the rest. In eastern Britain, the Kingdom of Kent, traditionally believed to have been founded by the Jutish people of Denmark, now appears to have been largely continuous with the government of the Romano-British client kingdom it supplanted. Kent was probably one of the first areas of Germanic-speaking settlement. Archaeologists now believe that it maintained strong political ties with the realm of the Merovingian Franks directly across the channel. [0:45:03] By the 6th century, Kent was the most prosperous and the most densely populated Germanic-speaking polity in Britain. It would become in the 7th century the launchpad for the Pope's reassertion of Catholic influence at Canterbury. Kent is also where we'd have the first evidence of written laws in Anglo-Saxon Britain. But if we want to find a real beacon of civilization in this darkest of dark ages, we should look actually not in southeastern Britain, but into the southwest. Places that today are the counties of Cornwall and Devonshire and Somerset. This area of Britain, which like Kent is very accessible to foreign ships, is highly significant both to archaeologists of early medieval Britain and to scholars of Arthurian literature. Two early medieval sites in particular deserve our attention: Cadbury and Tintagel. [0:45:55] Yeah, these days, if someone were to mention Cadbury, you would probably think of the chocolate eggs, but it's one of the oldest continually occupied places in all of Britain, apparently beginning as a small farming village way back in the Neolithic, before being enclosed in a Bronze Age hillfort, even before the arrival of the Celtic languages. By the time Romans arrived around 2,000 years ago, Cadbury had been eagerly adopted by the Celtic Britons as a military, economic, and religious site, one of the oppida that had been the primary social unit of the Celtic world. The hill fort, or castle, survived a fire that might have occurred during the Roman invasion or some decades afterward during the famous revolt of Boudicca. During the Roman period, Cadbury seems to have been mostly depopulated, but not disused, as it was the site of a popular pagan temple. Then, in the 5th century, following the collapse of Roman society, Cadbury once again swelled with residents. [0:46:51] Its inhabitants may have retreated to the security of the hillfort to protect themselves from attack by Irishmen from the west and Saxons from the east. It's also possible that worsening economic and climate conditions caused people formerly living in far-flung settlements to concentrate in places where work and resources could be shared. Cadbury was one of the few places in the post-Roman Britain where trade goods from the Mediterranean remained fairly widely accessible. It had been speculated that the size, prosperity, and the well-maintained fortifications of Cadbury indicate that Cadbury Castle could have been the seat of a powerful early monarch. Very possibly one of the figures who inspired the stories of King Arthur. What is certainly true is that a thousand years after Arthur would have lived and died, local farmers in Somerset were convinced that this now ruined fort had been the great Camelot. While this is certainly wishful thinking, some historians and archaeologists have used this folklore to conjecture that this may have been the real Camelot, even in the 21st century. [0:47:53] And before we dismiss this, I think we should add that the name Cadbury may derive from a nearby river called, wait for it, the Cam. [0:48:01] Yes, but even more fascinating than Cadbury is the site at Tintagel, an even more dramatic hill fort built on a rocky promontory on the north coast of Cornwall, just across the water from Wales. Tintagel is explicitly described as the site of King Arthur's magical conception in the works of Geoffrey of Monmouth, later expanded upon by writers like Thomas Malory. This castle is thought to have been the seat of the kings of Dumnonia, a Brittonic-speaking polity that flourished at the same time as the Kingdom of Kent, but had even stronger continental ties, particularly with the closely related Breton peoples of Gaul. Although by the early 6th century, it might be more appropriate to call Gaul France. Tintagel also contained a notable amount of pottery from North Africa. This was a highly valued trade good that was basically inaccessible everywhere else on the island. Discoveries of coins from Byzantium and from the Gothic kingdoms of the Mediterranean show that people were likely visiting Tintagel from quite far afield, during a time when extremely few people from developed parts really had any interest in Britain at all. [0:49:12] But these coins and potsherds are not what makes Tintagel a big deal to Arthurian scholars. In 1998, the site generated headlines worldwide when archaeologists discovered a rock, apparently from the 6th century, engraved with the name Artognou. The meaning here is not entirely well known, but it could mean something like bear knowledge. It might be a noun, but given the context, it's more likely a personal name, one which corresponds to Arthur. A small number of scholars think this is enough to declare that King Arthur was a real guy and he ruled at Tintagel. I don't think we can assume that much, but what this rock does confirm is that there probably were people named Arthur in this place and time. I think this does make a historic argument a little bit more plausible, because if this name was actually used in southern Britain, it puts to bed some of the more fanciful claims about the emergence of the Arthurian legend. [0:50:15] For instance, the exotic suggestion that the historic King Arthur could have been a Sarmatian nomad from Eastern Europe, or that he in fact was the same person as that Irish prince named Artuir, who was later conflated with Arthur. Anyways, unfortunately for the romantics among us, it is not possible to connect any of these sites to a historic King Arthur. And again, we don't know if there was, in fact, an Arthur or if he was purely legendary. But both Cadbury and Tintagel demonstrate that southwestern Britain, the area around modern Cornwall, would have been more commercially and possibly culturally confident than the rest of Celtic Britain after 410. It appears that the overall population of southwestern Britain actually increased during this period, the opposite of everywhere else. This might explain why the earliest references to King Arthur strongly emphasize southwestern locales. So, again, you mentioned how we have some early references to King Arthur in the 9th and 10th century, then we don't have a lot until the 12th century. [0:51:31] There's sort of another dark age here in terms of the way that Arthurian stories were spread across Europe. It seems that in the 10th and 11th century, before Arthurian stories begin to be written in earnest, they are transmitted orally by Celtic-speaking bards, the figures you mentioned at the top of this episode. This would have been happening during a time of transition in Britain and France. The shift from the early to the High Middle Ages. The most important event here in Britain is, of course, the Norman conquest of 1066. In France, the new Capetian dynasty slowly begins to increase its power across the kingdom and develops a sophisticated court culture. Although France would politically be very weak at the start of the High Middle Ages, it was culturally very strong as a legacy to the great glory of Charlemagne centuries earlier. French-speaking aristocrats had a huge amount of cultural influence all across Western Europe. [0:52:34] After the Norman Conquest, you saw individual French speakers joining the courts of people in Wales and Ireland and Scotland, spreading French culture and French, or at least continental ideas such as chivalry, quite far afield. This is to say that by the 11th century, when we see the High Middle Ages in earnest, we're beginning to see a social structure and a new set of ideologies distinct from those of the early Middle Ages. This leads to new ideas and new aesthetic concepts that would become strongly associated with King Arthur, specifically chivalry and knighthood, which did not exist in the time that these stories are set. In fact, many of the early Welsh stories about King Arthur, which were written in the 12th and 13th century, harken back to a time before knighthood existed. Instead, King Arthur is described as ruling a hall, not a castle, and instead of being surrounded by knights, he simply has his men. [0:53:42] Yes. [0:53:43] Right, so up until the start of the High Medieval Period, stories of King Arthur continue to circulate throughout the Celtic-speaking world. We have very scant references to Arthur and his men, mostly from Latin language texts produced in Wales, in addition to the sources we mentioned earlier. One additional source produced around 1100 is The Life of Saint Carannog. This mentions King Arthur as a ruler in southwest Britain who employs the saints' help to slay a dragon. This is probably the first reference we have to Arthur being a king rather than a general, and is also probably the earliest tale of dragon slaying in the Arthurian canon. Now that we've established the context of the Arthurian romance, let's get into the themes and cycles that make it up, the particles, if you will, of the Matter of Britain. Because here we find the most fascinating element of the entire King Arthur mythos. [0:54:35] The characteristics that set the stories like Gawain and the Green Knight, as well as The Quest for the Grail, apart from the Carolingian chivalric romances set in France. What we find in stories of Arthur are folkloric traces of a lost British world. The stories are set in the most obscure period of recorded history on the island and harken back even further into the mythological past. Arthurian writers like Chrétien and Malory, without even knowing it, were engaging in a British storytelling tradition which dates back not just before the Normans or the Saxons, but possibly into the deep Celtic past, prior even to the arrival of Julius Caesar on Albion's shores. And let's make something clear. We don't think that there's any historic value, ipso facto, in the stories of King Arthur. Not a single surviving reference is within 200 years of his supposed life, and the full narrative works were not written until 500 years after his death. [0:55:29] But these stories do preserve medieval attitudes towards the past as well as very old narrative elements, particularly the idea that past glories are greater than those in the present. And in this sense, we think that the Matter of Britain is roughly comparable to the subject of our last episode, Beowulf, because in addition to reflecting views about the past, the Arthurian romances clearly reveal a strong popular interest in chivalry and underscore the overwhelming influence of Christian piety as well as the reverence medieval people held for pre-Christian Greeks and Romans. [0:56:04] Yeah, and just to kind of clarify this argument, what we're saying here is that, you know, Beowulf is an Anglo-Saxon text from the Christian era, which reflects the Anglo-Saxon attitude toward their pre-Christian ancestors. [0:56:18] Yes. [0:56:18] Chivalric romance, this is later high medieval literature that reflects the later Christian understanding of history. You know, the attitude toward the Britons of King Arthur, but also the attitude of the Greek, toward the Greeks and the Romans. References to Greece and Rome are surprisingly common in medieval Arthurian literature, and it was genuinely a widely held belief that chivalry was not a new idea, but actually came from Rome. We're going to mention this idea of the nine worthies later on, but figures like King Arthur were often understood as part of a heroic context with Julius Caesar and Hector, for instance. [0:56:59] Yeah, yeah. And just in general, the Arthuriana needs to be understood as one of the many facets where the medievals would look upon the past and just project their own realities onto it because that's what they took for granted. And I mean, knighthood, as Liam said, is quite recent. Another thing that I found interesting was jousting, which is what we really associate with knighthood, wasn't invented until the 14th century or something like that. But Arthur and the boys are always going jousting in Chrétien's stories, at least. [0:57:38] Yeah. Yeah, no, it's funny. They joust in a purely martial sense. They charge each other with lances, but it's explicitly with the intent to kill. It's not for sport. Okay, so high medieval stories of King Arthur featured a cast of characters, including figures we've mentioned before, like Guinevere, the Knights of the Round Table. And even though the broad strokes here primarily come from Welsh and Breton mythology, Arthuriana really comes into being with the addition of these high medieval French elements. Parallel to the rise of Arthurian literature, French poets developed their own body of stories, The Matter of France, set a little bit after the days of Arthur in the time of Charlemagne. The most famous of these pieces, the first of these pieces, is that one, The Song of Roland, mentioned before. We can see many apparent influences of the Matter of France, the stories often described as the chanson de geste, onto the matter of Britain. [0:58:40] In these French tales, Charlemagne is a widely beloved and virtuous king, surrounded by a collection of nearly but not entirely spotless disciples. Clearly, also drawing some structural influence from Christian stories of Jesus and the Apostles, Charlemagne is not only shown as an indomitable warrior king, but also a moral paragon that readers ought to emulate. His 12 companions of the palace, from where we get the word paladin, were essentially knights in want of a round table. Charlemagne himself is not immediately distinguishable in his character from King Arthur. These two literary traditions will develop in parallel, both influencing each other. And both Charlemagne and Arthur were generally considered to be of equal historicity in this period. However, certain individual narratives, like Geoffrey of Monmouth's fanciful history, were met with some doubt by the most skeptical medieval readers. But at least as late as the time of Thomas Malory, many writers and readers of Arthurian romance insisted that every detail of these stories were stuck deep in a bedrock of truth. [0:59:58] Yes. [0:59:58] Malory himself mentions casually that the church where Arthur was crowned was not that current chapel in London, but the one that once stood in its place. However, Malory also greatly undermines his own historic credibility at the very end of his narrative, where he tells us that in the final battle between Arthur and Mordred, they were blasting each other with guns in the sixth century. [1:00:22] Listen, you know, like maybe they invented them early or something. Like, this is King Arthur we're talking about, you know. [1:00:29] All right, that's true. [1:00:30] Yes, that's true. [1:00:31] Okay. Well, regardless of whether or not early guns were used at the Battle of Camlann, many other writers surely knew that they were not relating factual history. They knew they were turning popular myths and received wisdom into a story that they thought was morally true, not true in a literal sense. I think we have to bring up the saints' life here again, because the stories of King Arthur and his loyal knights are again functionally similar to the relationship between Jesus Christ and his disciples in early Christian literature. They were also similar in their morally instructive nature. Some writers of Arthurian romance were in fact priests and often courtly chaplains hired to instruct the children of aristocrats in a proper Christian life. Often this involved ideas about the material world and the use of power, ideas we now consider chivalry. Even though these stories were often completely fantastical, medieval readers understood them to be paradoxically both invented and true. [1:01:42] This is because we have to emphasize, medieval people did not live in a rationalist world. They had an attitude toward truth that is extremely alien to us today. Writers of both saints' lives, who invented stories of flying monks and monks who could bring the dead to life and monks who could be in two places at once, knew in a sense they were making this up. But they thought it was fine to do so because it was in, it was to illustrate a moral point about the holiness of these figures that was not in doubt. We mentioned previously how Saint Columba was said to have encountered a fearsome sea dragon while preaching to the Picts at Loch Ness. Some hagiographies openly admit to conjuring up these anecdotes from their own minds, but they justified it by saying: if these men and women were so holy, surely they could have done these things. [1:02:41] And in a world where monsters were generally believed to exist, who else but a saint of great power would be likely to encounter and defeat one? [1:02:50] Right, and returning to Camelot, romances served a similar social and ideological role to the lives of the saints, because in addition to being read for enjoyment, these tales were morally instructive. Some medieval writers, like the Norman poet Wace, told tales of knights just as eagerly as stories of saints. There is rarely much stylistic difference between them, except that courtly romance was more typically written in verse than prose and involved some theme of love or seduction. These stories are, after all, the origin of the modern word romance. Romances typically, though not always, celebrated a kind of love that was passionate and overwhelming, but ultimately quite chaste. The lovers in these stories could not marry, as in the case of Lancelot and Queen Guinevere, or less frequently, involved a couple married to each other, such as the case of Erec and Enide. Adulterous love was paradoxically understood to be more pure, as it was love for its own sake and not marred by the concerns of property and propriety that had marked marital love as practiced in this period. [1:03:54] A lover like Lancelot had nothing and everything to lose by pining after a woman like Guinevere. A physical affair would risk social ruin and perhaps even death to the people involved. And yet, lovers in a purely emotional affair could pursue their passions to the extreme. In the works of Chrétien de Troyes, we think he's the greatest of the Arthurian storytellers. Lancelot is so overwhelmed by the beauty of the married Queen Guinevere that he immediately contemplates suicide. [1:04:23] I mean, I've been there. [1:04:25] And after they part, he stands atop the battlements watching her disappear across the horizon. He wonders why he shouldn't jump right there, so that his eyes never again have to look up to something that isn't Guinevere. [1:04:38] I mean, yeah, I mean, who among us, you know? [1:04:44] Closely related to the idea of courtly love is the idea of chivalry. And, you know, chivalry is a word that's also used today, but I'd argue that the contemporary usage of chivalry is as different from the medieval usage as in the word romance. Chivalry is a very interesting concept to historians because unlike something like feudalism or Romanitas, it is a concept that was widely used and widely discussed by the people in the time it's used to, you know, it's applied to. So chivalry literally means the way of the horse, referring to mounted combat, and it emerged as a rough moral code adhered to in theory by members of the propertied class. After the fall of the Western Roman Empire and the disintegration of the imperial military structure, Europe essentially fell under a centuries-long period of military rule. The so-called barbarian kingdoms of early medieval Europe commanded land and people through physical force. [1:05:44] The rich were those who owned swords and horses in a society where ownership of a sword and a horse was one of the only ways to become rich. Again, if Henri Pirenne is to be believed, this kind of warlordism did not begin as early as the Visigoths or as early as the Merovingian Franks, but instead later, after the slow transformation away from urban commerce and Roman-style taxation on the continent. Instead, per Pirenne, this system, which some call feudalism, developed during the time of the later Carolingian Franks. As these people, in the 8th century, not the 7th and the 6th, began to derive their income and authority, not from issuing currency or from tax and commerce, but instead from managing agricultural estates, from deriving tribute and tithes for massive peasantry, and from the force of arms. [1:06:45] Right, yeah, so chivalry was a code of honor that these armed aristocrats were supposed to adhere to, and unlike the warrior ethos that we find in Homer's Iliad or in the Norse sagas, the great emphasis of chivalry is on restraint and mercy, particularly the showing of mercy to women and to peasants, as well as other people outside of the great aristocratic gang war of medieval Europe. Chivalry was closely tied to the peace and truce of God, a papal initiative from the early Middle Ages meant to limit the constant bloodshed among the high-born men at arms. And again, the idea that civilians are not fair game was not inherent to other value systems in other places and times. So the Greeks and the Romans, for example, were rarely bothered by the most extreme abuses of slaves and barbarians in warfare. Chivalry was specific to the Christian beliefs of medieval Western Europeans, though we shouldn't suggest that this merciful attitude was inherent or limited to Christianity. [1:07:42] And so the greatest weakness of medieval Christian morality was that its obligations typically only extended to Christian believers. So this meant in practice that crusading knights in the Middle East and in the Baltics, and even in France and Greece, raped and slaughtered with abandon when they encountered peoples who were not Christian, or not the right kind of Christian, even. And massacres along these lines still occurred when Catholics were fighting Catholics. I think we should see chivalry as an attempt to bring order and harmony in an extremely violent society. It was an attempt to domesticate these men at arms. It was because they were living in a society in which violence was an expected duty and often a pastime of the elite. I would argue that the expansion of the state in the early modern period is really what killed chivalry, as this transformation disempowered the aristocracy and replaced knightly retinues with professional armies of commoners. [1:08:38] Later on, centuries after this shift had been complete, some European artists and writers would become nostalgic for what they imagined was a simpler medieval time. The chivalric romance, and in particular the Arthurian romance, would be rediscovered as part of this broader 19th-century identity crisis. We are going to get into that. [1:08:58] Right. And so, you know, from a purely historical or anthropological standpoint, this means that chivalric romances are a really cool look at a system of values not really shared by people today, but a system that is common to other honor codes across world history. [1:09:15] Yeah, no, I mean, yeah, I was just telling Liam about this earlier, and I've just always found it so interesting that so many different cultures across the world that had no contact with each other tended to develop very similar codes of conduct with, you know, how you behave when you accept guests, like, you know, how you can expect to be treated when you're a guest. It's all very important in a world where there are basically zero institutions. This was like, basically, they invented this idea of like honor and hospitality because without it, the entire world would have been a big PvP zone and everyone would be killing each other, which was very, very harmful to staying alive, let's say. So, in other words, if you live in a context, and this could be, you know, this could be in ancient Arabia among the Bedouins, or it could be in medieval Georgia among the Svan, or it could be in any place among any number of people. [1:10:27] You see a guest, you offer them food, drink, a place to sleep. They sleep at your place, and then next morning they go off and go into the world. And often, it doesn't matter who this person is. They could literally be your nemesis. They could be someone that you absolutely just want to die. But nevertheless, if they come to you and say, hey, I need a place to stay for tonight, you are supposed to, according to the honor code, squash that beef for at least that night, feed them, offer them drink. And then, you know, hopefully the next day after they've left, you'll encounter yourself again and you can die gloriously on the field of battle. But yeah, you weren't supposed to do that. I was also thinking recently about Lawrence of Arabia. He recalls how, you know, he was in Arabia over there. He was working with the Hashemites. [1:11:24] He was working with Hussein and Faisal. And basically, right before, like literally a week before the Arab revolt was set to pop off, two of the pashas of the triumvirate of the Ottoman Empire showed up in Medina to inspect the army of the Hashemites because they figured that these troops would be used to fight against the British, not abet them. And, you know, this was a huge deal for many, for some of the people among King Faisal who knew that he was going to, you know, that he was going to be up in arms against these people in literally a week. So some people went to him and said, hey, you know, we're about to fight these guys on the battlefield. Like, this is basically a decapitation strike. We would get rid of the command of this army. And then it would be like shooting fish in a barrel to kill the rest of the army. [1:12:19] And Faisal, who was very much native to these traditions, said, No, we can't do that. That's not an honorable thing. If we kill these people here, that's going to absolutely destroy my reputation. So we're going to have to, you know, let them spend the night and go away and then meet them on the field of battle as is proper. So, yeah, basically, this is, you know, this is what it's all about: maintaining one's honor in the face of a terrible world. [1:12:49] Yeah, no, that's the thing. I think chivalry, it's this particular high medieval Western European expression of a kind of honor code that you see all over the world, especially in societies where large numbers of people are expected to perform violence as part of their life, where you don't have professional armies. Instead, many people, usually adult men, are trained in arms and expected to use arms to advance their own interests and defend their interests. I think that if you want to look at what makes chivalry particular to various honor codes, it's the specific way that mercy is emphasized. And, you know, this is clearly meant to reconcile Christian morality with the everyday requirements of a medieval world. I think, you know, in this way, we can kind of compare chivalry with the ways that Buddhist warriors in Japan and Southeast Asia had to figure out how they can use violence and also believing in a religion that is oftentimes somewhat pacifistic. [1:13:54] A big element of chivalry in particular that we should mention is the idea that women are off limits. It is never appropriate to commit violence against a woman, and women ought to be protected. This is an extremely strong principle in the poems of Chrétien de Troyes that we're going to talk about. For instance, one of the poems begins because a woman is slapped, and that this makes the knight Erec have to go on this quest. And I think in practice, women were not treated well in chivalric society at all. This was an ideal that really did not meet the actual behavior, particularly behavior of knights. We're going to see with the life of Thomas Malory that real knights were often as far as you could get from the knights of chivalric literature. But there was this attempt here. And I think the idea that the most important thing a knight can do is protect women and pine after women, but not necessarily actually consummate that love. [1:14:56] That's really central and particular to the Western European chivalric tradition. And it explains why, you know, the word romance came to mean what it means today. Okay, so let's get into how these romances actually began to be written. So again, just to really read right here, we have this period of oral transmission by Celtic-speaking poets and bards. Of this period, we know basically nothing, just that one of the stories, or at least one of the figures these bards spoke about, was King Arthur. He is trans he goes first from being a post-Roman general, then to being a mythical kind of hunter figure. Some early Welsh sources describe him as hunting boars with a dog, and that eventually by the High Middle Ages, he is understood as an ideal king. These stories would have been mostly told in Wales, but also in Cornwall, and especially again the French region of Brittany, which had been settled by people from Britain centuries before. [1:15:58] They were all part of a Celtic or Britonic cultural continuum. The Bretons of northwest France were acutely aware of their heritage, essentially as refugees, forced from Britain's green and pleasant land by Saxon pirates from across the sea. Both the Bretons and the Welsh had good reasons for dreaming of a heroic leader who had defended them in their greatest time of need and could perhaps one day fight for them again, restoring to them their beloved country. So, you know, actually, it's in Brittany, not in Britain, that the name Arthur rather than Artuir or Artognou first emerges. It seems that every Arthur is named after the legendary King Arthur. So the emergence of Arthur as a given name clearly reflects the circulations of stories about this guy. Some of these stories were again clearly based on very ancient traditions. One Victorian scholar, John Rhys, boldly argued that King Arthur was actually the conflation of two different figures: a real historic warchief who battled the Saxons in the 6th century, as well as a pagan Celtic god, also called Arthur. [1:17:12] Nobody believes this today. There is no evidence for a pre-Christian deity named Arthur. But John Rhys was unable to think of any other explanation why deeply religious medieval writers such as Chrétien, whose name literally means Christian, would preserve in their stories elements that he thought were so clearly pre-Christian. I think this is part of the great mystery and question of Arthurian stories. The fact that Christian elements and Roman elements and various continental influences exist in relative harmony with this older Celtic layer. So we've talked about the interest of Arthur in Wales and in France, but interest in England doesn't seem to begin until after 1066, when the island was conquered by French-speaking Normans. We should note that many of the knights accompanying the Normans on their conquest were of Breton origin. The new King William awarded notable land grants to Bretons in his service. This means for a small moment, some really did retake parts of Britain, just as they were doing so underneath the Normans. [1:18:31] The Breton presence in Norman England was limited. We're probably looking at just a few hundred to a few thousand individuals, but due to their high status within the broader Anglo-Norman elite, tiny traces of Breton culture appear to have seeped into England during this period. The best example is that the name Alan isn't attested in England before two Breton brothers, somehow both named Alan, accompanied William on his conquest. The name Arthur is also not attested in Britain until this time. Stories of King Arthur would likely have been told across the Norman English realm, as well as the sizable Norman holdings in France, primarily by Welsh and Breton itinerant storytellers. We can surmise with some confidence that these bards were the first to develop the mythology that connected King Arthur to pre-existing figures such as Merlin, who appears to have been based on a more menacing legendary bard known as Myrddin the Wild, who again was given the powers apparently once attributed to Saint Martin. [1:19:35] Yes. [1:19:36] I will remind our listeners that in our episode on Druidry, we mentioned how the medieval Irish saw bards and druids as comparably magical professions. This might explain the development of Merlin here, who we really might have to do a whole episode on, because there's really a lot to get into in Merlin. [1:19:52] Yeah, yeah, well, where was our magic? [1:19:54] Yeah. So, Arthur re-emerges from the waters of oblivion around the year 1150 with the works of Geoffrey of Monmouth. He is our first named Arthurian author of any note. Geoffrey, or as he calls himself, Galfridus Arturus, was a cleric living in Norman-ruled Wales, possibly in one of those parts of Wales under the rule of Breton lords. Geoffrey describes himself once as British, which probably means he was of Welsh or perhaps Breton origin, but he was a native French speaker who completed his life's work in the Latinate world of the Catholic Church. Geoffrey claimed to have spoken the ancient British language, and that he used an ancient book of British history to base his chronicle. Both of these claims seem to have been, at best, huge exaggerations. An offhand comment describing British and Welsh as separate languages suggests that Geoffrey probably had no knowledge of Celtic dialects, despite his claim of British origin. [1:20:59] Otherwise, he would have known that the ancient Britons essentially spoke Welsh. Also, the book he claimed to have used as his source is not mentioned by any other writer. Geoffrey was well ingratiated into the upper classes of Norman England and probably taught at Oxford, which may be where he began writing his most famous text, the Historia Regnum Britanniae, History of the Kings of Britain. Geoffrey clearly read the Sermon of Gildas, from where he gets his rough outline of the collapse of Roman Britain, and he also certainly read the Anglo-Saxon writer Bede, who was the first to write about the wicked British king Vortigern and his association with the barbarian brothers, Hengist and Horsa, who brought the Saxons to Britain. Geoffrey also read the Welsh Historia Brittonum, one of those two 9th and 10th century Welsh sources that mentions King Arthur. This Welsh but Latin language source includes a story about the tyrant Vortigern meeting a young boy, who revealed two dragons hiding underneath the king's tower. [1:22:01] The story, which would become the origin of the Welsh flag, would be greatly elaborated upon by Geoffrey of Monmouth. He would connect this story to the figure of Merlin and he'd give it a new prophetic meaning we'll describe shortly. So again, we see lots of discrete influences going into Geoffrey's work. This makes it less plausible that he based his account on some ancient lost text. And again, no Welsh writers ever claimed to have access to such a book. I think it is most probable that Geoffrey brought together a lot of pre-existing sources and then, due to his great and creative imagination, made up the rest, either to entertain himself or to aggrandize his Norman patrons, who had taken the island less than 100 years prior and were eager to gain new legitimacy, especially among the defiant Welsh people. [1:22:56] Yeah, while we were planning this episode, Liam and I were just joking around how this guy just would have been the medieval George R.R. Martin, and we just lost the context for that. So we just... [1:23:05] Yeah, yeah, he's a world builder. [1:23:06] Yeah. [1:23:07] And many other elements of Geoffrey's chronicles are very clearly sourced from Greek, Roman, or biblical stories. So the entire opening section, in which a man named Brutus flees the ruins of Troy to settle in Britain, is just a riff on Virgil's Aeneid. The famous story of King Arthur's Conception, in which Uther seduces his vassal's beautiful wife, Igraine, and then has this vassal killed, is surely inspired by the Old Testament account of David and Bathsheba. Geoffrey also recycles his own stories. British kings named Locrinus and Vortigern each fall for the wiles of a German princess, and after marrying this foreign lady, lead their country into ruin. And despite the presence of fantastical giants and dragons, the constant adulation of martial valor, as well as the stories of aristocratic love affairs gone awry, Geoffrey's writings were not romances. Rather than being a work of fiction written to amuse the writer and the reader, this is a purportedly factual chronicle, and one which was taken seriously, at least as late as the Tudor period. [1:24:08] It's written in prose rather than verse, and it does not linger very long on any individual hero, as we would expect a romance to do. In addition to not being a romance, the Historia Regnum Britanniae isn't even Arthurian. The section about Merlin and Uther and Arthur is the most famous part of Geoffrey's account, and it comes near the end. King Arthur is placed in the broader context of kings who brought either glory or ruin to the Isle of Britain. Other figures described at length before him include Brutus of Troy, but also the famous King Leir, King Cole, very possibly the origin of the nursery rhyme, and then notable Roman commanders like Julius Caesar and Constantine the Great. A different Constantine, an imperial pretender mostly attested in the writings of Gildas, is presented as the rightful British king and also Arthur's grandfather. Plenty of figures listed here definitely existed and were known from Gildas or Bede or the earlier Roman sources. [1:25:05] But Geoffrey arranges these scattered references into a mostly coherent series of events. He also greatly expands on the lives of pre-existing historical or literary figures, especially those like Merlin and Vortigern and Arthur himself, who would become primary characters in the later Arthurian canon. Several of Geoffrey's anecdotes, like that of a young boy seeing two dragons, were based on Welsh or Breton oral traditions and attested in earlier written sources. But Geoffrey appears to be the first person to link King Arthur with Merlin, previously known as Myrddin the Bard. He may have changed the spelling to avoid resemblance with the French word merde, meaning shit, and he was the first to describe Arthur in writing with any amount of detail. [1:25:54] Right, right. And again, so yo, so Geoffrey of Monmouth, he doesn't invent King Arthur at all. Although some of his story tropes are present earlier, for instance, in the Welsh Historia Brittonum. [1:26:05] Yes. But we don't really get Arthur in any color until we get Geoffrey of Monmouth. And it is now pretty widely understood that Geoffrey of Monmouth's account predates Welsh language narrative accounts of King Arthur. We do have Welsh Arthurian stories, especially in the Mabinogion, but these come after Geoffrey, as well as after the development of the French romance tradition. One thing that's funny in Geoffrey's account is that the first like two-thirds are pretty dry history. You get some color and some excitement in the section about Brutus of Troy. There's a very cool moment where he explores a ruined city and he finds an abandoned temple where the goddess tells him that he's going to settle on the island of Britain. It's cool stuff. A lot of it's cribbed from Virgil's Aeneid, but it's kind of cool. Then it goes, there's a big, very dry description of this king and that king and this king, various failed invasions of Britons, of Britain by foreign, various exotic foreign leaders. [1:27:04] At one point, the Huns try to conquer Britain. But then, near the end of the book, once we get to the generation before Arthur, the narrative begins to take on a more human pace, and it's less of a chronicle, more of a story. It's very possible that this part of the narrative is Geoffrey recalling a story that he had once heard from an old bard around the hearth, you know, during his childhood, either in Wales or in Brittany. We don't really know his origin particularly. We begin to learn much about Arthur's relatives in this section of the book, especially his father, Uther Pendragon, and his uncle Aurelianus, a figure borrowed from Gildas's Ambrosius Aurelianus. We here have our first account of Arthur's mystical and deceptive conception. This is a creepy story where King Uther uses Merlin's magic to transform himself into the figure of the husband of a woman he loves, thus conceiving his son King Arthur through deceptive rape. [1:28:12] Many elements of Arthur's life mentioned by Geoffrey would become standard parts of the Arthurian canon, including his conception. They'd be expanded upon by writers as late as Thomas Malory. There are also some stories included in later Arthurian romances that are not super well known today because they don't really match the modern image of King Arthur. One of these, for instance, is Arthur's battle with a Spanish giant at the famous Mont Saint-Michel. King Arthur actually doesn't do a lot of battling in the stories that we're used to. He usually is more of a peripheral figure. His knights do all the fighting. Also, in Geoffrey's account, Arthur invades the Roman Empire and brings huge amounts of Western Europe under his subjugation. This is not the kind of thing you see in a lot of King Arthur stories, especially modern adaptations. So Geoffrey ends his tale of Arthur's reign not with the king's death, but instead with his mysterious remark that he went to the Isle of Avalon to be cured of his wounds. [1:29:15] We know from the contemporary historian William of Malmesbury that by the time Geoffrey wrote this, some Welsh and Breton people strongly believed that Arthur would soon rise from the dead and drive the English out of England. While many of these stories were surely products of Geoffrey's imagination, he tells us that stories of Arthur were very well known in his own time, the mid-12th century. I think that he heard these stories from Bretons or Welshmen, perhaps in the Welsh language, perhaps in French, and that that inspired his own history. And really what he did was bringing these stories from the Welsh world into the broader world of the French-speaking upper classes of Europe. [1:30:04] Yes. [1:30:05] He thus would bring Britain's greatest king to the forefront of Western Europeans' aristocratic imagination. We don't really know what was going on in his head, obviously, but one presupposition might be that by relating or inventing this fanciful history, Geoffrey was trying to explain to a pan-European audience that British history is just as deep and just as turbulent as that of the ancient Mediterranean. So he constantly pegs his events to the chronology of the Old Testament or episodes in Roman history. Usually something like such and such British king ruled over this part of the island at the same time that King David killed Goliath. The Brits were presented as kin to the Romans, as well as the joint heirs to a glorious legacy of ancient Troy. Geoffrey explains that Britain was so important to the ancient world that the Romans actually invaded only after much earlier incursions by the Huns and then by the Scythians, who, Geoffrey insists, are the ancestors of the Picts. [1:31:03] The most famous Gaul who sacked Rome, a chieftain known as Brennus, was actually a Briton. Emperor Constantine, most famous for proclaiming Christianity as the state religion of the empire, was actually half British. Geoffrey even insists that Britain became predominantly Christian long before Constantine was born, implying that Britain was in fact the world's first Christian majority land. [1:31:24] Right, and so like basically all medieval Arthurian works, this account is deeply Christian in its values and allusions. I think that we have to emphasize the role of religion in medieval fiction because it's something that many modern readers of medieval romance don't expect when they go in. We should remember that he was, after all, a priest, and there are biblical references all throughout. The Saxon king Hengist is compared to the wicked king Agag of Amalek in the Old Testament. Although at the same time as this, you know, this Christian element is present, some pagans in Geoffrey's chronicle are treated with unexpected respect. Brutus of Troy and his sons were seen as virtuous men, as was Julius Caesar. I think that we can see this chronicle as an attempt to reconcile Christian ideology with the imagined glory and virtue of a pre-Christian past. Some modern writers have suggested that Geoffrey is kind of prefiguring the idea of nationalism by emphasizing Britishness as something that exists independent of religion, as we first see the glory of the Britons before they are Christian, then we see the glory of the Britons after they are Christian. [1:32:39] I think the only wrinkle in this understanding is that I don't think Geoffrey's idea of Britishness is necessarily an ethnic one, because, you know, his idea of Britishness seems to be more about habitation on the island than descent. Otherwise, I don't think the English people and the Normans would have accepted his chronicle so eagerly. Moving on to the relationship between Christianity and the pagan Roman past. Writers following Geoffrey, particularly writers of romances, would take pains to link the virtues of the Christian knights of Camelot to the heroes of classical antiquity. Again, they often suggest that the principle of chivalry was not new, but instead came from Rome. There are many political implications of Geoffrey's chronicle as well. You know, we could spend an hour talking about all of the ways that Normans at the time could have used this text to their advantage. But there's one particular story that I want to get into. [1:33:43] This is the tale of Merlin and the two dragons. We discussed this one way back in episode 60 on legendary ancestry claims. But according to Geoffrey of Monmouth, the wicked King Vortigern invited Saxon mercenaries to Britain to fight his wars, only to be overthrown by these same barbarian interlopers and sent running to the hills of Wales. Vortigern ordered the construction of a great tower to defend his remaining lands, but it kept collapsing under its own weight. After consulting with his magicians, King Vortigern resolved to perform a human sacrifice. He would consecrate his tower with the blood of a child with no father. Eventually, his soldiers apprehended a boy born to a princess who had been made pregnant by a disembodied demon. This boy's name was Merlin. Vortigern was about to kill this kid when Merlin spoke out and said the real reason the tower kept collapsing would be revealed if they dig underneath its foundations. [1:34:47] There, beneath the stones, two dragons slept. Vortigern had his men dig underneath the foundations of the tower, and lo and behold, two creatures, a red dragon and a white. After awakening, the two began to battle each other with their flaming breath. The white dragon seemed to be winning, pushing the red to the coast of a pond. But then the red one struck back with vicious force. Merlin explains to Vortigern that this is a direct political allegory. The white dragon signifies the Saxons whom you invited over. The red denotes the British nation, which shall be oppressed by the white. Therefore shall its mountains be leveled as the valleys, and the rivers of the valleys shall run with blood. The exercise of religion shall be destroyed, and the churches laid open to ruin. But at last the oppressed shall prevail and oppose the cruelty of foreigners. So what does this mean in a 12th century context? [1:35:43] We have to remember that he wrote this text in dedication to the Norman king Henry I, the son of William the Conqueror. William was supported in his invasion by a significant number of Breton knights, men whose national mythology lamented their exile at the hands of the pagan Saxons centuries before. So Geoffrey here is very clearly saying that although King William and his son Henry were French-speaking foreigners in England, they were actually redeeming Britain, saving the island from an even more rapacious class of conquerors who made the land their own previously. [1:36:16] Right, right. So, in other words, we're seeing these extremely foreign conquering elites using this old imagery to say, actually, we are true Britons. Even though we may not ourselves be of the blood of Brutus of Troy, we are part of this nation, whereas these Saxons are not. And we, the Normans, will drive these Saxons out. [1:36:37] Yeah, and so Geoffrey links the line of King Arthur to the line of King William with another interesting literary invention. He claims that when Uther Pendragon, who was again the father of Arthur, first came to prominence, a great comet shone over Britain and Ireland and Gaul. This comet signified the glory of his coming rule and the coming defeat of a Saxon army. Every medieval reader would be reminded of Halley's Comet, which hung in the sky in 1066, overlooking the defeat of another generation of Saxons by the Normans. While much or most of this mythology, what we would today call world building, was clearly invented by Geoffrey himself, he sourced some of his ideas from much earlier legends. And not only the classical legends of Greece and Rome, but also the more indigenous tales told by the Britonic peoples who had existed before. But regardless of whether or not he spoke Welsh, Geoffrey was indebted to the Bardic oral tradition, which kept the tales of Arthur alive from the 6th century up until the Norman conquest. [1:37:44] All right, and I think this is a pretty good place to leave off now, now that we've seen how this whole tradition developed. And when Gladio comes back, we'll see what exactly the later high medieval tradition of King Arthur looks like and how Camelot really comes into its own through the incredible work of my favorite medieval writer, Chrétien de Troyes.