Gladio Free Europe, E126: Homer and the Hittites P. 2 (with Alexander Thatcher) https://www.gladiofreeeurope.com/episodes/homer-and-the-hittites-p-2 [0:00:19] And we are back with another episode of Gladio Free Europe, joined once again by Russian Sam and our very special guest, Alexander Thatcher. Alex, I believe you have just returned from your own form of Aegean Odyssey, isn't that correct? [0:00:34] Yeah, so I was in Thessaloniki for about a week and a half, which is nice. I got even more of a sunburn. I had easy extra foot work for about 11 days, which is always appreciated. [0:00:47] Yes, yes, after being in Turkey, yeah. Well, very nice. So if anyone has not listened to the first part of this series, I would strongly encourage you to do so. We had a great discussion last time all about the Bronze Age Mediterranean with an emphasis on the great empire of the Hittites, which would have been the greatest state in the northeastern Mediterranean in this period. And that's particularly relevant to our purposes here because the period of Hittite domination in this part of the world is exactly the period apparently being remembered in the works of Homer. For a very quick recap here, the Hittites were an Anatolian Indo-European speaking society with very strong connections to Mesopotamia and the Levant in the east, as well as some fascinating links to the Aegean coast of Western Anatolia and of course Greece. And again, they spoke an Indo-European language, but the exact origins of this language and how it arrived in the Hittite homeland of the Anatolian highlands is really a matter of intense debate. [0:01:59] It seems increasingly likely that the Hittite language developed not on the Eurasian steppe alongside other Indo-European languages, but instead in the Caucasus Mountains. The rest of the Indo-European languages, all of those except the Anatolian branch, would have developed and spread separately out of what is today Russia and Ukraine. The Hittite language, which is our earliest documented Indo-European language, is very well attested due to the many thousands of texts discovered at the Hittite capital of Hattusa, as well as smaller numbers of inscriptions from their territories in Syria and other parts of the Near East. But it seems that the vast majority of Hittite subjects did not indeed speak the Hittite language. Rather, this empire was a loose network of different cities and tribes and peoples speaking many different languages, including the indigenous language Hattic, the closely related Luwian of the Anatolian coast, the Hurrian language spoken in the Taurus and Caucasus mountains, and as well as several Semitic languages such as Ugaritic and Akkadian. [0:03:15] It also seems increasingly likely that on the far western coast of Anatolia, at least some of the Hittite subjects spoke some form of Mycenaean Greek. So this Hittite empire would have been a vast crescent stretching from the Aegean islands in the west down across Anatolia up to the Caucasus, even reaching Upper Mesopotamia, and then curving down to parts of the Levant, especially northern Syria. Certain provinces, particularly in Syria, operated as basically independent states ruled by close relatives of the Hittite king, traditionally one of his sons. Other territories were more tributary, and the exact relationship between subject populations and the Hittite king still is not very well understood. What we do know is that there were apparently no formal imperial institutions. Instead, this was a highly personalized monarchy, maybe comparable to the monarchies of early medieval Europe. This required the king to be peripatetic or constantly mobile across his empire. [0:04:32] This required a very complex alliance system, especially marriage alliances between the Hittite king and the various daughters of subject peoples. It also required constant royal violence, keeping all of these various subject territories in line and also dealing with potential matters of succession. One of the great crises of the Hittite world happened in the 15th century BC. The general Suppiluliuma simultaneously battled rebels known as the Kaskians from the Caucasus Mountains in the east, at the same time as a coalition of Western Anatolian peoples known as the Arzawans or Assuwa. This Western revolt included the participation of the city of Wilusa in far northwestern Anatolia and may have involved some mercenaries from Mycenaean Greece. Suppiluliuma used his glory to launch himself to kingship, but the problem of these western territories did not go away, as we know from later correspondences. One mysterious figure known as Piyamaradu, some kind of rebel or bandit, gave the Hittites significant trouble in the western borderlands of their empire. [0:05:51] He may have employed the service of some Greek-speaking mercenaries. Before we move on even further into Hittite links with the Greek-speaking world, I know, Alex, you wanted to get into something about Hittite religion, a kind of a very infamous element of that religion, which we touched on last episode, but you wanted to go a little bit deeper into due to its potential links to other cultures within the Indo-European world. [0:06:25] Right. So, last, like, the famous, like, if someone knows something about Hittites, they maybe know the joke about how, like, you know, in Hittite religious law, you can, if you engage in zoophilia, you are put to death, with the exception, of course, of horses and mules. [0:06:45] Yes. [0:06:46] But of course. Which is, you know, everyone agrees, perfectly reasonable distinction here, like completely normal morality. But, like, you said then that the distinction was: if you do this, then you cannot become a priest. [0:07:03] Yes. Yes, you can never approach the king. You can never be employed in the royal household, which, and the royal household was the seat of government. [0:07:14] But when I found interesting about that is that is an idea of ritual contamination, right? So it's the idea. [0:07:22] Yes. [0:07:23] This is something that exists in your world. or at least at some kind of symbolic level. The idea that a man and a horse can be joined dustly. It's like it's an idea that is somewhere out there that you kind of have to legislate around or deal with, even at a hypothetical level. [0:07:44] Yes. No, and so in our episode on Druidry, I think that was earlier this year, we mentioned that the kind of somewhat infamous British scholar, a Welsh scholar, Gerald of Wales, who was in the employ of the Normans, he claimed that Irish kings did such a ritual to justify their sovereignty. I think this probably happened. I find it unlikely that this specific claim could entirely be slander, especially as you're about to describe, there are other analogues, not only among the Irish and the Hittites, for this kind of bizarre, disgusting ritual. [0:08:20] Yeah, so it looks like in the Vedas, so in kind of like the earliest scriptures of Hinduism, there's a prayer, there's a very early prayer called the Ashvamedha, which is a specific, it's quite complicated, but by the time we have it in the Vedas, it looks like what's going on is that there's some kind of at some point, there's an idea of a symbolic, almost like festive idea of a possibility of a local queen having some kind of like imitation mock conjunction with a horse. And that the specific ritual is a justification of political power, right? So I actually read like the earliest version of the prayer, and the version of the prayer starts with an invocation of the earliest Vedic gods, and then it ends with like, we will have success in our rule because of this. We shall rule like a stallion, is basically the idea, right? [0:09:31] Yeah, yeah, the horse is this, you know, symbol of masculine power. The king is in a very physical way takes the place of a stallion. [0:09:41] Yeah. But the more I thought about this, the more interesting it is. Because like, we know the Mitanni are doing something, have elements of the Mitanni religion are at least influenced by yes. [0:09:56] No, and again, just to recap, as we mentioned in the previous episode, the Mitannians were a kingdom in Syria that appear to have had basically a Hindu ruling class, presumably from somewhere in Afghanistan, India, or Pakistan. This is very, how this happened is very mysterious, but it is basically without, beyond doubt, that the gods worshipped by the ruling elite of this kingdom were cognate with the Hindu gods. [0:10:28] Yeah. So what I think it's hype, like, I think what we might have evidence here of is some kind of specific religious taboo around Mitannis who are like these, like, possibly, I don't want to use the word Aryan, but that's probably the most effective word here. These like Aryan Mitanni warriors who are that would have been a genuine, a genuine autonym in that society. [0:10:52] Yeah, by that time, probably, right? [0:10:55] And I think maybe that's what we're looking at. We're looking at some kind of like religious taboo about the king being in direct contact with Mitanni notables at that level, or possibly an idea that Mitanni people who have engaged in this cannot, you know, can't become priests from the Hittites. [0:11:19] Yeah, no, no, that is extremely. So, what you're saying is that the specific stipulation in the legal code that the Hittite king could not interact with somebody who had had sex with a horse may have been some kind of basically colonial policy dealing with the interactions of the now subjugated Mitannian people of Syria, who may have had very strange, from our perspective, ideas about horses. And this is also quite interesting because, as you know, obviously, the Mitannian ruling class as well as the ruling class of the Hittites, they both spoke related Indo-European languages that would have been separated by thousands of years in the origin of their languages and also thousands of miles as the linguistic forebears of the Mitannians. They would have had a very kind of circuitous migration pattern from Russia-Ukraine through Central Asia, down into India, Iran, up to Syria. So there would have been huge differences separating these two societies, yet some fundamental ancient ancestral similarities, primarily in language, but also possibly in their attitudes about horses. [0:12:38] Here's what I find interesting. I think it's possible this is a distinction between the Hittites and the other Indo-European people. Yes, that it was that they're the ones who do that with horses. We don't. [0:12:49] Yeah, and that is that is extremely possible. And that, you know, this idea of this kind of idea that the Hittite king would serve different peoples in different ways, I think this does seem to match what we see in Hittite religious prayer, the prayers, which are often in multiple languages, apparently showing how the king had to perform potentially different religious services for his different subjects. And I think that in a society without a real formal national government, as we understand it today, the king necessarily must adapt himself in dealing with various subject populations, whether it's emphasizing his similarities with them or possibly in this case, distinguishing his religious practices and taboos from those of subject peoples. [0:13:44] Right. So there's a Hittite kind of like mourning ritual for their kings, which often gets compared to the funeral of Patroclus and the Iliad. And they're quite similar in a bunch of ways, but it looks like there is some kind of like poor Hittite conflation of the horse and rulership. But it kind of looks like it's not quite as intense and not quite as like visceral or like Vosh adjacent as this kind of older core Indo-European like imitation zoophilia like like I hypothetically like I like I don't think this yeah I think like I got really into reading about Hittite religion and something that I find interesting about it is that there a lot of the literature seems to think there's this like Indo-European level that's the same as all the other religions that is like overlaid on top of Anatolia and the Caucasus. [0:14:51] But I kind of wonder if like if we go by the Lazaridis and Reich model, if what we're seeing is more just like this one Caucasian element that would eventually go north and become a common Indo-European kind of religious structure. But for the Hittites, it just kind of stays in the Caucasus and it moves over into Anatolia. So we're dealing with like, I wonder if we're dealing religiously with something that's already distinct before like the Aryan, the Aryans break off and go east or before the Proto-Greeks come through the Balkans. [0:15:30] Yeah, no, absolutely possible. And I think also what's interesting about the Hittites is that, you know, as we're going to see in this episode, just like so many other peoples of the ancient world, they had influences in all directions. So there is this deep, most ancient ancestral era, this connection with the steppe, with, you know, the ancestors of the Greeks and the ancestors of the Aryan peoples of India and Iran. But there's also, of course, their Eastern connections to Mesopotamia. And one thing we're going to see in this episode is it seems increasingly likely that certain Mesopotamian and other Near Eastern religious ideas could have traveled through the Hittite world and eventually ended up in the Greek world, as recorded in certain passages in Homer's Iliad and the Odyssey. You know, the Odyssey in particular is discussed much more right now in our current moment than it was this time a year ago, primarily due to Christopher Nolan's recent movie. [0:16:39] I know that you recently reread The Odyssey, Alex. And any new insights this time? [0:16:47] So I hadn't read it since middle school, somewhat embarrassingly. I just finished Emily Wilson's translation, which was the famous premise that ruined the Odyssey. I enjoyed it. I'm much more of an Iliad person for obvious reasons, you know, the connections to Anatolia. [0:17:08] Oh, yes, let's see. [0:17:09] It's an interesting, it's a very interesting translation. I did the audiobook, and Claire Danes does a wonderful audio performance on it. It is very odd because so much, I mean, people, you know, right-wingers made fun of this, but so much of the Odyssey is guest friendship and hospitality. [0:17:27] Yeah. That's the actual core of the story because they're like they're they're notables moving around, right and in a in a world where there's not like Airbnb, they have to have some kind of like reciprocal notion of of guest friendship just in order to have any kind of mobility yes so like a huge amount of the Odyssey is just is just the rules of guest friendship and like what yeah like what what happens to you if you disobey this the punishments the the the the the the rewards hypothetically of like of like properly maintaining all of this like it is very interesting but it's it's not it's not what I expected and this is a huge part of of the recent film and I think to a greater extent than other adaptations I've seen yeah as you intimated a lot of right-wingers on the internet are are really mad at the existence of this film largely due to you know aesthetic casting choices you know they they tilted windmills over this film hoping in vain that it will fail financially and you know punish the figures involved and I think a lot of this flailing is kind of increasingly embarrassing from these guys global chud revolution Christopher Nolan now sits atop a throne of chud skulls like basically that's what's happened with the culture right like he's like porn like lord like Critical Drinker's gone right like the whole thing's ridiculous like everyone knows it's our age of chud just collapsing that's okay I already I already had that as the art as the as the Substack post title like I'm not exaggerating I I'm like I'm like three three three sections already into that but like, I'm literally, that's basically what I'm saying, right? [0:19:18] I mean, it's like it's this interesting moment. I think, and what's so funny about it to me is that it's the Bronze Age, right? It's this weird little like circle of like Bronze Age Mindset being destroyed by the Bronze Age. [0:19:31] For listeners, this is a reference to an infamous right-wing blogger, basically, who is always purporting to be an advocate of Bronze Age values, which just so nicely happened to line up with his modern-day political grievances. Let's get into the film here, just briefly. Because, you know, it's fine. I thought it's not my favorite. It has very little effort to be faithful either to the text of the Odyssey or to the archaeological context that it's portraying. But I think it's basically fine. I don't think that historical accuracy or literary fidelity needs to be the great preoccupation of the filmmaker. [0:20:16] I will say it's very funny that Emily Wilson herself is not a fan of the film because of its portrayal of the values. [0:20:24] No, she's having a very amusing meltdown. Yeah, yeah. [0:20:29] And I totally get you. As she is a translator of the Odyssey, I fully understand why she would be offended at the ways that the complex morality and themes of the Odyssey are turned into basically like a Jason Bourne PTSD type of story. [0:20:45] Emily Wilson is a poet. I'm not like maligning her having a visceral negative reaction to what is essentially an adaptation of her work. Like I, I, I, I, I, like, I, her translation, I enjoyed it a lot. Like, I think a part of it is Claire Danes' performance in the audiobook, but it's very impressive. [0:21:06] Yeah, no, and she's also argued that it kind of the nastier aspects of some of these characters, particularly Odysseus himself, are sanded down to be more palatable for a modern American audience. So, like, you know, the slaughter of the slave women after Odysseus returns home is reduced to the implied killing of Mia Goth's character, which isn't even seen on screen. [0:21:26] Yeah, I could see that. But also, like, the PTSD is already in there in the Odyssey. Like, it just is. People have been writing about this for 50 years. I mean, there's a specific scene in book eight, I think it is, where Odysseus is, I think it's with Nausicaa. I'm not going to be able to remember the name of this people. They're like, I think they're not fully human somehow. They're like, they're nautical people, Phaeacians or something like this. I'm not sure about this title, but like this bard is recalling Odysseus' accomplishments, and Odysseus has the specific comparison that he starts crying like a Trojan woman, right? Like his tears are like there's this heroic recollection of the story and what's happening to him, reads like a flashback. But that's just what it is. And something I found very funny about the kind of Chud rejection of Odysseus' complexity and his trauma is that I don't know how many of these people know like actual military veterans. [0:22:41] Like just to think about like Graham Platner simultaneously pleading the military and making fun of it, but also being really weird and proud of it at certain moments. Like, this is a type of guy. Like, I keep thinking of like Nikos Kazantzakis, Zorba the Greek. Like, there's this, Zorba is proud of the fact that he was like an anti-Ottoman partisan in Crete, that he warred against the Turks for all the years. But he also, like, freaks out at one point because, like, he has like someone says something like besmirching Turkish honor. He's like, no, they were good soldiers. Like, what are you talking about? [0:23:18] Yeah, I know. And that very much, that attitude, right there, that is the whole Greek perspective on the Trojans. [0:23:25] That is fascinating. Because that is exactly. Yeah. [0:23:28] Wow. [0:23:29] I mean, Zorba is like, he's this very Greek figure because he's like, he's very charming, right? That's a huge part of him. Like, he dances, he goes in and out. But he's also kind of like not super dependable, a little violent. Like, I think it is this kind of like very Aegean character at a fundamental level that's still like recognizable in the fiction of the region. [0:23:49] Yeah, and I think in particular, certain Greek heroes, like, you know, Odysseus and Theseus are kind of tricky in a way, especially Odysseus, you know, that I think makes them a little bit more interesting, you know, complicated, if you can forgive me for using that word. More so than, I would say more so than somebody like Gilgamesh, who is a fascinating character, but doesn't have as much going on internally. And I think in a funny way, the fact that Odysseus lies constantly, this makes him almost kind of an anti-hero from our point of view, not to mention, and not to mention his killing of innocent people, whether these are the civilians of Troy or the slave women of him and his wife Penelope when he returns. [0:24:34] Well, Adorno has this famous essay in like 1944 where he argues that Odysseus is like everything good and bad about the Enlightenment, right? Like he's just like proto-bourgeois kind of like man of reason and of like self-limitation who's able to like break through a lot of the like pre-enlightenment social norms. [0:25:04] He's constantly venturing to foreign lands and also ends up always killing the people who live there. [0:25:09] I mean, he's also like, he's more of a merchant, right? I mean, like, Achilles is this kind of like very Balkan, like individualistic warrior. Like, one of the reasons I hate the 2004 movie Troy so much is that it gets the history, it gets the actual trajectory of the history completely wrong. Because in Troy, there's this like Achaean Greek kind of like emerging superstate that's going to like destroy Troy. And Achilles is this like emo bad boy who just wants to be by himself. But so the idea there is that there's this like telos, there's this like movement of history towards a Mycenaean superstate. And like Achilles, Achilles is the future, right? Achilles is the like lone Balkan warrior who moves with like a band, who is like outside of state structures, who has to be like cajoled into fighting. Like this is right before the Dark Age. [0:26:10] So like Achilles is the future far more than that's true. [0:26:13] Yeah, that's really fascinating. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. No, and even in the, I think in the Bronze Age, you know, the Mycenaean world would have been most likely even more informal than the Hittite Empire. This, like, the diff, there would have been not really any fundamental difference between the government of a small Bronze Age kingdom and the way like a mafia racket operates. It would have been this hierarchy of violence and patronage, that, you know, people are physically coerced, physically and economically coerced, and that the actual coercive power of all of these figures is very limited. There probably isn't really that much in terms of absolute difference between these kings and their subjects. They are ruling on very minimal margins. And we'll get into this at the end of the episode, but I think that is part of why the Bronze Age world, especially in Greece, collapsed so quickly. [0:27:12] So, okay, so let's actually, before we move on from the film, The Odyssey, we have to talk about the most infamous line in the film, which we've already alluded to at several times, but it's when Odysseus says outright, our Age of Bronze is collapsing. And that's a really corny line, in context or without it. But what I will say in defense of Nolan's script is that it is not entirely impossible to imagine in Homer's account, somebody like Odysseus could have self-identified as living in the Bronze Age. This was because before the term Bronze Age was revived by 19th century archaeologists, it was used by Homer's contemporary, Hesiod, in the Theogony, where he describes human history in five ages, those being gold, silver, heroic, bronze, and iron. Hesiod identified himself as living in the Iron Age, just as later archaeologists would place him. The contemporary archaeological scheme, though, isn't full, while it recalls Hesiod, it's not, it has another obvious literal implication, that being the Bronze Age primarily involved metallurgy using bronze, which is made through the use of precious rare tin, but can be smelted at a lower point, whereas iron uses a very common ore, but requires a much higher smoke point, requiring less international trade, but more local economic extraction, both of the iron ore itself, as well as chopping down a lot more trees to build much hotter fires. [0:29:00] So, you know, so I will defend that one line there, even if it's very corny. [0:29:04] I think the idea that people in the Bronze Age didn't know that bronze was important is ridiculous. [0:29:11] Yeah, yeah, absolutely. Especially like a man who's a lot of literature over the past 20 years has explicitly compared the desire for tin in the production of bronze as something like the 20th century and 21st century oil crises. [0:29:27] Yeah, and like even mythologically, like we have very limited understanding of the Hittites, the Hittites' own understanding of the origin of the cosmos. But the thing that shows up twice is a copper knife. Like a copper knife separates, I think it's the sky from the earth. That's like the initial act. And the idea there is that like the entire world that they understand it is made through a copper tool, right? I mean, it's there. It's something they, it's a part of how they understood the world. [0:29:59] And, you know, so the film itself has very little to do with the Bronze Age in its aesthetics or even in its social dynamics depicted there. It's drawing much heavily off of the, more heavily off of the classical world that would be, that would come after Homer, not the Bronze Age world that would come before Homer. I didn't hate the visual design. It's very modernist, which I think, you know, which is a deliberate kind of touch. [0:30:25] You know, when the first screenshots came out, everyone complained that Agamemnon looked too much like Batman. But then when they saw the film, I think it works. I think the idea that that's an accident is really silly. Christopher Nolan made three Batman movies that are about the global war on terror. And then he makes an Odyssey about how the Global War on Terror destroyed everything. I mean, that's in the text. Also, just like, so I was one of the people who was complaining about the design of the Odyssey on Twitter. Like, I had a bunch of tweets go viral in the early days. But then I saw the actual sacking of Troy during a trailer as a trailer before Avatar 3. And within a minute, I kind of knew I was in trouble. This is an actual bit I had on Twitter for several months at this point. [0:31:18] And then like I was just really into that specific first 30 seconds of that scene of what I was watching. And I said, like, as the scene kind of kept going forward, I just liked it more and more. And I was just like, on Twitter, it's where there is like, okay, Chris Nolan knows what he's doing. [0:31:35] Yeah, yeah, no, you know, the city of Troy, in particular, which is the set they constructed. There's, I think you suggested there might even be an influence from like Turkish modernist architecture from the Kemalist period. [0:31:47] Yeah, so it, what it reminds me of is something called Second National Architectural Style, which is kind of like the localized Anatolian version of strict classicism, which is usually associated with Nazi architecture. But it's like it's it's like a form of like it's kind of is fallen adjacent sometimes, but it's it's it's you know, it's it's it's it's more Central European. It's used in like central Longkin, like the Çankaya Palace is built in that style, Anıtkabir is kind of built in that style. I mean, like the moment I saw Troy, I was like, you know, okay, this is cool, I can see what he's doing. [0:32:24] Yeah, and I think the Troy set also had some resonances with Frank Lloyd Wright, honestly, especially the Hollyhock House in Los Angeles. It has these crenellations that are kind of Mayan-inspired that seem that seem to show up in the film. I think the most interesting locations, which you were the first person I saw point this out, are that a lot of locations are not sets but are actual locales in the Aegean. They do not date back to the ancient Greek period, especially not to the Greek Bronze Age, but instead from medieval Greece. There's, I think it's a medieval Venetian fortification is used as the palace of Ithaca. [0:33:01] It really works. I made this point, but it kind of felt like people don't realize that most of Greece is not like if Greece is not like Santorini. Like it looks more like Albania or the Caucasus as well at the time. It's a very mountainous country. And so, like, it and the music, in The Odyssey, also, like, they use this Albanian flute that kind of sounds a little bit like the Armenian duduk to me, but I know the duduk much better. [0:33:30] I was thinking that, yeah, no, because I live in a very Armenian area, so I'm very familiar with the Armenian flute music, and yeah, I definitely, yeah. [0:33:37] It's kind of got a cool vibe of like mountainous Greece, which is not something you really see in movies, yeah. Like, you see, like coasts, if you see Greece at all, you see, like beaches, but that's not Greece, Greece is like hills and mountains and trees and stuff for the most part. [0:33:54] Yeah, so we've talked a lot about the depiction of the city of Troy in the film, and as well as you know, to an extent in the literature of the Iliad and the Odyssey. Sam, let's get into what we actually know about the site of Troy. You know, we should mention also before we do this that an older name for the city in Greek would have been Ilios, hence the Iliad, the story of Ilios. But in Mycenaean Greek, when there was still the digamma, the W, it would have been pronounced Wilios. This is extremely similar to the Wilusa of Hittite records, which has also been identified with the archaeological site of Troy, first discovered by Heinrich Schliemann. [0:34:39] Yeah, so we know a fair bit about the archaeological history of Troy, but unfortunately, we know practically nothing about the Wilusans from the contemporary literary sources. There are, of course, a number of records of the city taking part in the revolt of the Arzawa or the Asua, and it was also referred to by the Hittites as Taruisa. But through the archaeological efforts of the notorious Heinrich Schliemann, as well as the careful analysis of Hittite texts, we have a much better idea of how the people of Wilusa related to their Hittite masters, as well as the nearby seafaring peoples of the Aegean. This being, of course, the Mycenaean Greeks. In Homer's Iliad and in the Odyssey, we're obviously in Troy, but these were written about 500 years after Troy had been destroyed. So some scholars are quite skeptical that these texts can be used to reconstruct any particular details about the life of the real historic Wilusa. [0:35:37] Right, and so the thing is that, you know, like Wilusa was destroyed, but this is not enough to say that the Trojan War actually happened, or even that its destruction had anything to do with the Greek people across the Aegean. [0:35:51] Yeah, yeah. So the Trojan court of the Iliad looks very similar to what we know about the Hittite court of Hattusa. The literary Troy is a walled city, just like the Trojan Citadel, wherein King Priam lives with his many wives and many sons and daughters, like Hector and Paris and Cassandra, as well as the spouses and children of these children, like Andromache and Helen of Troy. Hector clearly is presented as the designated heir with specific military authority. There's one particularly gnarly moment in the Iliad concerning the prospective son-in-law. One Anatolian aristocrat offers himself up to Priam's service to win the hand of the Trojan princess Cassandra before being speared by the Greek Idomeneus, who then cruelly mocks the dying man by saying something along the lines of, how's that for a wedding present? And all this very strongly resembled the family dynamics of the Hittite court. [0:36:45] This was likely not a coincidence. Two theories have been suggested here. The first one is that the Iliad is drawing from the tropes of a now lost body of Anatolian epic poetry and thus reflects the norms of the Hittite capital. But the other explanation, which we find more likely, is that the real-life Trojan court was organized along similar lines to the Hittite court. So Wilusa was, after all, a piece of the Hittite world, even if the Wilusans seem to have worked hard to change that. As we will see with the Greek Greek palace of Mycenae, the Hittites exhibited a significant regional influence. It's very likely that the attitudes about kingship laid down by the Labarna, which was how the Hittites called their kings, would influence the behavior of kings in rival or subject realms like Wilusa. [0:37:31] Yeah, and so it's interesting how the Hittites were this great empire, but they were fully operated out of a single citadel, this relatively small city in which the king and his royal, his large royal family with his many wives and many children, would have been socially segregated from the rest of the public, especially public who had had sex with horses. But we see a parallel here with other Bronze Age fortifications and these citadels, both on the edges of the Hittite world in Wilusa, which was a city that was subject to the Hittites, but constantly in revolt. We also see this, a similar situation with the cities of Mycenaean Greece, where there is this large citadel in which the king lives with a very large household, and political life is derived, you know, radiates out of this fortified settlement. And so, you know, due to the archaeological works of Schliemann and later more careful scholars, we can see additional archaeological parallels with the Homeric narrative of the Trojan War. [0:38:47] Schliemann's Troy was destroyed around 1180 BC, which is completely contemporaneous with the famous Bronze Age collapse. This was an event all across the Eastern Mediterranean in which nearly every urban civilization collapsed or experienced some kind of major power shift or some form of decline. The Hittites probably collapsed harder than anybody else in this period, although the Mycenaean Greeks would give them run for their money. Some structures in this layer of Troy, the burned layer, Troy 7b, show some signs of deliberate burning. This happened at the same time when many Greek palaces in the Mycenaean world, including Mycenae itself, were also sacked and burned. It is highly possible there could be some direct link between the apparent destruction of Troy or Wilusa and the destruction of nearby Greek sites like Mycenae, but we don't know exactly what the causal relationship is. Of course, in the Iliad, the king of Mycenae, Agamemnon, leads the Trojan War on behalf of his brother Menelaus, which eventually causes the sack and destruction of the city of Troy and the near-full eradication of the Trojan race. [0:40:20] But the archaeological situation is much more complex than what is presented in Homer. And again, we have to remember: Homer was writing about these potentially historic events 500 years after they had happened. And during most of these 500 years, the Greeks would have been wholly illiterate as the Bronze Age collapse saw the disappearance of the Bronze Age Linear B writing system. This is alluded to in Christopher Nolan's Odyssey, which I thought was kind of, you know, an interesting touch when they say that the deeds of Troy are going to have to be sung rather than written. So let's go into the various layers of Troy. Chronologically, from the deepest to the shallowest, oldest to youngest. Troy layers one to three were largely destroyed by Schliemann in his efforts to find the rest of the site. However, we should note that Troy II, an early Bronze Age site constructed as early as 2500 BC, way earlier than anything we're discussing with the Hittites, already appeared to have been an organized town with sophisticated stone and mudbrick walls, as well as evidence with trade all across the Mediterranean and beyond. [0:41:38] This Troy II from the early Bronze Age contained gems originating in Anatolia and India, as well as amber from the distant Baltic Sea, which was highly desired in the ancient world. The entire existence of this early urban Troy II shows that by the late Bronze Age, Troy 7b already would have been an ancient town well over a thousand years old, which likely had recovered from multiple destructions previously. So moving on to the younger layers, we have a few more layers showing increased connections with the Middle Bronze Age world, especially the Minoan civilization of Crete, and then we get to Troy 6 and Troy 7. These sites were major settlements with walled citadels just like the Hittite capital of Hattusa, as well as the Greek settlements at Mycenae and Pylos. It seems increasingly likely that Troy 7, particularly Troy 7b, is the Troy of the Trojan War, the one remembered by the works of Homer, as well as the Hittite accounts of Wilusa. [0:42:47] The 20th century archaeologist Carl Blegen was one of the first to ponder whether Troy 6, the previous layer, was destroyed by an earthquake or by warfare. Since Blegen's time, it seems increasingly likely that natural disasters, especially earthquakes, which are very common in the Mediterranean, could have had an under-described effect on the collapse of civilizations. It's not that earthquakes themselves can necessarily cause a city to collapse, but it's that when times are hard economically or politically, it is less easy for the survivors of an earthquake to muster up the manpower and the resources to rebuild after a natural destruction event. Following the destruction of Troy 6, the city was rebuilt, even grander than before. But then, as mentioned, around 1180 BC, the new site, Troy 7, was also reduced to ruin. Again, traditionally, the destruction of Troy 7 was associated with the Trojan War. There is, in fact, minimal evidence for an earlier layer, Troy 7A, having some potentially violent destruction, I believe, due to the presence of arrowheads. [0:44:07] Troy 7B was actually destroyed in ways much more severe than Troy 7A. But there is not the same violent evidence. This may suggest that while there was social ability to rebuild the site at Troy 6, creating Troy 7, after Troy 7 was destroyed, the local residents no longer had the skills or the money or the willpower to rebuild. And instead, the site would basically fall into permanent ruin, and the residents of the region of Wilusa, later known as the Troad, would instead find different settlements. Alex, I know that you know a bit about the Luwian language. This would have been spoken all across the Mediterranean coast of Anatolia. It seems like Luwian was probably the primary language of the city of Wilusa. Do you know much about what exactly separates Luwian from the Hittite, the related Hittite language? [0:45:12] I think most of the Anatolian languages are pretty closely related. I tried to go through some of the literature on them. I don't think there's like, off the top of my head, I don't know the major distinctions between them, but I mean, Luwian does kind of become more, like we talked about this in the last episode, it does become more important as the empire kind of goes forward, right? It becomes a more common language. [0:45:40] Yeah, this it seems that it was more widely spoken in the Hittite Empire than Hittite itself, and this led to Luwian having an increasingly important role over time. We also see this increasing geographic spread over time, where Luwian begins in southern Anatolia, and then these Luwian inscriptions move westward. And also, we should mention these are hieroglyphic inscriptions, no relation to the hieroglyphics of Egypt, but it was a hieroglyphic system, not a phonetic system. [0:46:09] That's different from the cuneiform. [0:46:11] Yes, exactly. So, again, and this just shows the very complex linguistic situation of the Hittite world. They would have had multiple languages and multiple writing systems simultaneously. We see Luwian hieroglyphics spread from southern Anatolia, like the region of Cilicia, basically, westward toward the Aegean coast, eventually to the far northwest at the city of Troy. There's not really any way to know if this represents the spread of the spoken language or simply the spread of a writing system. I think it's personally most likely that Luwian was the primary spoken language at Troy. It wasn't simply a written language, and that, you know, the entire Anatolian coast probably spoke something like Luwian. But there may have also been other languages spoken at Troy. Obviously, foreigners, such as travelers from Egypt into Syria, would have been speaking their own languages. There may have been some knowledge of the Hittite language, which probably would have had to be learned as a second language. [0:47:14] Probably was not similar enough to Luwian to have been fully intelligible. There also may have been some Greek speakers living in Troy. And to what extent is very hard to know. [0:47:29] I wanted to point this out. Sorry, just to interrupt for a second. I think it's also possible there were still pre-Indo-European languages. There's the Tyrrhenian language Lemnian, which is not that far off the coast. [0:47:41] Yes. [0:47:42] And even in the classical period, there's references to Pelasgians and Eteocretans. So it's possible this is a very dynamic linguistic environment in Troy. [0:47:53] Yeah. And, you know, it seems very likely that because these cities or citadels, often, might be a better way to understand them, because these were regional economic centers, people from all over would constantly be traveling to these cities as merchants, often as slaves, or as hired mercenaries. And the best evidence we have for Greek speakers in the city of Wilusa is this latter category. One of the most interesting correspondences that references the Greeks, who in the Hittite texts are known as the Ahhiyawans, is the Milawata letter. And Milawata may be the etymological origin of the later Greek city of Miletus. This letter says that the city of Milawata contained within it some people from Wilusa who were agitating against Hittite rule. It mentions a fearsome individual named Piyamaradu, who we alluded to earlier, some bandit or rebel who was stirring up trouble all across the Hittite Anatolian highlands. [0:49:03] This figure occurs in several other letters, suggesting that he was apparently a pretty major player who was considered illegitimate by the Hittites. He was some kind of warlord contesting the authority of the Hittite king, and it appears that he had support from the people of Wilusa, and he may have possibly been from Wilusa himself. It has been suggested that the name Piyamaradu can be connected to both King Priam of the Iliad as well as his son, Paris. Paris, however, has an even more fascinating resonance with Hittite texts. That being one of the most interesting Hittite texts of all, which I think has particular relevance to our guest here, that being the Alaksandu letter. This letter is the earliest known instance of the Greek name Alexander, and it seems to link this name with a king of Wilusa. [0:50:07] I think it's the first known attestation of a European name that's still in use. Like my name is like the oldest Europe, like currently in Europe name. [0:50:19] That's pretty cool. And what we should also say going in is that, you know, anyone who's not read Homer, Alexander is the alternate name given to the Trojan hero Paris, whose affair or marriage with Helen of Troy is what causes this whole thing. [0:50:36] And I find that interesting because I've always wondered, like, a lot of Greek names feel very appropriate, like, too appropriate. Like, you wonder sometimes, if there was a culture of like inventing names for someone past a certain point, or like, like, people started using poetic names. It's like Native American names, right? Like, like, maybe they had some kind of like poetic names. But if Alexandros, I think it means like defender of men, right? Like, that's the origin of it, but he also starts the war. That's the problem with the problem. [0:51:07] In the Iliad, you know, Hector is constantly hectoring Paris for not defending his kinsmen enough. Because, you know, like he said, there are moments, so Paris does take to the battlefield on many occasions, but there are certain moments in which he would rather be hanging out with his, you know, bride, Helen of Troy. And also when Paris does fight, he is primarily an archer, which is seen as somewhat unmanly by Greek writers. [0:51:33] But there's also, it seems Eastern as well, right? I mean, it's like, even at this point, it feels un-Greek. [0:51:42] Yeah, yeah. Well, okay, so this Alaksandu letter begins by saying that once upon a time, the Labarna, my forebear, had subdued the entire land of Arzawa and the entire land of Wilusa. Later, the land of Arzawa waged war for that reason. However, I know, since the event lies far back in the past, no king of the land of Hattusa from which the land of Wilusa had seceded. Yet even if the land of Wilusa had seceded from the land of Hattusa, close ties of friendship were maintained from a distance with the kings of the land of Hattusa and the envoys sent regularly to them. So this shows that, you know, from this letter sent by the Hittite king to King Alaksandu of Wilusa, Wilusa by this point, it had slipped outside of Hittite political control, but there was strong interest in maintaining links between the Hittite Empire and this western province. [0:52:41] How exactly Wilusa escaped the political grasp of the Hittite Empire will probably never be known, but this text does show that Wilusa was a contested ground. It was largely under the influence and at certain times under the direct control of the Hittites, but was also very strongly influenced by the Aegean world of the Mycenaean Greeks. Scholars are very interested in the name Alaksandu and the potential link between this king and the legendary Prince Paris or Alexander. It's especially perplexing because, again, this is apparently a Greek name, not a local Anatolian name. Presumably, this king would have been of Greek origin or at least some kind of Greek affiliation. Is it possible, therefore, that by the late Bronze Age, could the final city of Wilusa, Troy 7b, have in fact ruled by Greek people? We don't really, there's really no way to know, but it is highly possible that some Greek political elite could have taken over the city of Wilusa prior to its destruction, especially because we see a parallel on the island of Crete, which where the Minoan civilization apparently becomes folded in to the Mycenaean Greek world, very possibly through some kind of conquest, or at least some form of elite takeover. [0:54:24] The name problem still perplexes scholars. The recent classicist Mary Bachvarova suggested that the Homeric tradition of Paris having the second name Alexander could be a reference to a real tradition in which kings of Wilusa were known by both a Greek name and an Anatolian name, because again, the name Paris may be of Anatolian origin. I find this kind of surprising though, because the name Alaksandu, which is apparently Greek, is only known from the letter from the Hittite king, who was himself Anatolian. If these two, if there was a king who went by both the name Alaksandu and the name Paris, you would expect fellow Anatolians to refer to him by his Anatolian name. So I'm not really sure what's going on here. The main evidence that Bachvarova gives for this dual name tradition is that much later kings of Anatolia in the classical period would sometimes go by a Greek name and a Lydian name, or a Greek name and a Persian name. [0:55:28] But I'm not sure if we can project this tradition as far back as the Bronze Age. All right, so let's move on now to looking more closely at Mycenaean Greece. These people, the peoples of the Aegean, were known by the Hittites as the Ahhiyawa, which directly corresponds to the Greek name Achaea. Any readers of the Iliad will know that Achaean is Homer's most common epithet for the Greeks. He describes the aggressors of the Trojan War as Greeks or Hellenes only twice, possibly just to reference the Myrmidon tribe of Achilles, not all the Greeks as we understand them today. Instead, by Homer's time, Achaean was apparently the catch-all ethnic term, which even referenced the people of Crete, many of whom may not have yet spoken the Greek language at this period. But what exactly did Ahhiyawa, the Hittite term, mean? The Hittites used it simultaneously to refer to all Greek speakers, as well as a specific individual Greek kingdom, situated around the site of Mycenae, but possibly also ruling areas of western Anatolia, including the city of Miletus. [0:56:45] The Bronze Age site of Mycenae is, of course, the namesake of the Mycenaean Greeks, and it was first identified by Western travelers in the 18th century and then excavated by the very same Heinrich Schliemann who discovered Troy. Mycenae is the kingdom of Agamemnon in the works of Homer, sometimes conflated with the city of Argos right next door. Because Agamemnon and his brother Menelaus led the legendary attack on Troy, Homer describes his heroes as Argives, and almost as often as he calls them Achaean. Schliemann's excavations at Mycenae confirmed that it was indeed a major royal center, one of those massive royal complexes around which the entire local economy was oriented. The palace, which probably housed hundreds of residents, was elevated around the surrounding city and enclosed by a massive wall of unmortared stone, later described as Cyclopean because Greeks of the classical age thought that only a monstrous cyclops could lift such huge blocks. [0:57:51] The structure of Mycenae, with its citadel elevated above the town, has fascinating parallels with the much larger and more well-fortified Hittite capital of Hattusa. In addition, the famous gate of the Mycenaean palace is capped with a relief of two lions around a pillar. This has really fascinating similarities with the massive gate of Hattusa, built with similar masonry techniques, but featuring a much larger, fully three-dimensional relief of two lions guarding the gate. So, it very well may be that this association with lions and kingship is something that spread out of the Hittite world into nearby Mycenaean Greece. Let's talk about palace economies because this is something that gets quite a lot of attention in discussions of the Bronze Age world, particularly because it is so different from the later Greek economies of the classical age. Sam, what do you know about the palace economy? [0:58:54] It's a very interesting form of political economy. Basically, it's based around this idea that the royal residences being settlements, which often contained hundreds or thousands of residents within the primary citadel, as well as thousands more in the outlying regions. This is also a fascinating parallel with medieval Europe and the contrast with the highly urban nature of classical Greece. So, the owners of these Mycenaean palaces appear to have been warrior kings of sorts who derived their legitimacy through command of arms as well as the control of the redistributive economy. Because the palace was the main economic center, commoners would rely on goods sold or given out by kings. And like the Hittite kings, these were peripatetic or mobile, ruling on horseback as they traversed their kingdom on simple roads. However, unlike the Hittite kings, every Mycenaean ruler likely had a very small domain, possibly smaller than an American county. [0:59:50] Yeah, and just to interrupt here for a second, I gotta say, Alex, you might appreciate this. Something about the Mycenaean world, given the fact that it's all about these personal homes as opposed to the cities of the classical world or of, you know, the Levant in Mesopotamia, something about this palace economy, it feels very McMansion to me, very America B. [1:00:12] If our listeners are familiar with me, I was literally about to say this. It feels very boat dealer. [1:00:17] Yeah, no, one of, so, you know, so America B is a term that I came up with a couple years ago that's gotten kind of big on Twitter recently. I, one of my tweets like a year ago, was I basically said that, like, you know, Texas is becoming a palace economy, like, you know, Mycenaean Greece. And some people were annoyed when I said that because they didn't see these large homes as redistributive centers. But Au contraire, every major McMansion owned by, you know, a boat dealer is going to necessarily employ significant numbers of people, whether as home cleaners, as lawn guys, the pool boy, not to mention all of the DoorDash drivers. In a sense, I think that these homes still are a kind of economic distribution center, even if not to the same extent as the, you know, the Mycenaean palaces. It seems that this distribution, both through employment and enslavement, as well as patronage, is a big part of how these Mycenaean petty kings gained their influence. [1:01:22] This palatial system, I kind of wanted to talk about the origins of it. So the Mycenaean Greeks are kind of a more classic Indo-European people. They break off of the Yamnaya civilization. Sorry, the Yamnaya. [1:01:36] Yes, and just again, just to pause here, you're describing the fact that the Greeks were to settle, were descended from, their language came from the steppe, whereas the Indo-European Hittite and Luwian languages no longer appear to have come from the steppe. Instead, they developed in the nearby Caucasus and then moved from the Caucasus into Anatolia. [1:01:59] Or perhaps they came from like some part of the Volga that was like closer to the steppe, but they never had quite the same steppe influence as the other Indo-Europeans. [1:02:07] Yes. [1:02:08] But the Mycenaean Greeks, they come out of the, I think it's called the Helladic culture. So there's what it's called Helladic II. [1:02:15] Yeah. [1:02:16] Where there looks like there's this migration of the Yamnaya or catacomb culture-derived Indo-Europeans into Mycenaean Greece. But this gets quite complicated because it looks like what happens is that they get the idea or the core concepts of the palatial system from the Minoans. [1:02:38] Yes. [1:02:38] Or maybe from a non-Indo-European speaking people of the region because the Minoans have a complex palatial economy before the Mycenaeans come in. And the Mycenaean Mycenaean and later Greek political terminology is interesting because there's a layer of non-Indo-European terminology there, which stands out. [1:03:03] Yes. Yeah, no, and so the yeah, I'm glad you brought this up because this is something that David Anthony, the archaeologist, discusses how some of the words used in ancient Greek, basically associated with civilization, as we understand it, with urban life, with masonry, with settled living, as well as certain place names, don't seem to be of Indo-European origin. So either these were introduced by the Minoans from Troy, I'm trying to see the Minoans from Crete, or they could have been introduced by local native peoples who lived in Greece before the Mycenaean Greeks, before their language arrived. Funnily enough, until relatively late in the 20th century, it was actually thought that the Mycenaean Greeks did not themselves speak Greek. [1:03:53] No, sorry, I just wanted to bring this up because it's important for the horrible shitstorm on Twitter on the physical appearance of the ancient Greeks. [1:04:04] So the Mycenaeans are all black and Chinese. [1:04:08] Exactly. [1:04:08] All Korean. Like every single one of them. Korean is market and soul on a Tuesday afternoon. Achilles' real name was Achille. [1:04:21] No, but so Mycenaean Greeks are like 85%, 90% local for the most part. And the 10, 15% is Yamnaya-derived. And Yamnaya Indo-Europeans probably don't have a lot of the stereotypical marker of what it means to look European. So they probably didn't have these modern day racial right-wingers idolized the ancient Proto-Indo-Europeans, but the both culturally and phenotypically, the earliest Indo-Europeans did not match their ideal. Like, if you ever want to see what a Yamnaya looks like, go to like rural Dagestan or like a Ossetian cultural gathering in like Piafu. [1:05:14] Yeah, yeah, they would not match this supposed Nordic ideal that these guys idolize. [1:05:20] Yeah, and so like we are dealing with the people who are like physically like closer to Jason Mantzoukas than they are to like Brad Pitt. [1:05:30] Yeah, yeah. No, and again, and this is also why these guys are so offended by the casting of like, you know, like two black actors in like pretty small roles in Nolan's film, but they seem to have no issue with Northwest European actors playing basically everybody else. [1:05:46] Something I find specifically funny about this is Patel, the actor who plays like the kind of the second, the second man, Odysseus. If you render his face in marble, including his beard and hair, he would look quite Greek, just like realistically. I mean, there's all this like right, there's all this like right-wing hysteria on like specifically South Asians. And they just focused on this guy when like you look at him and he like the skin color and like maybe the cheekbones are like identified as South Asian, but he looks closer than like Brad Pitt. [1:06:23] Yeah, yeah. Well, yeah, it's reconnecting the story of the Odyssey with the archaeology or the archaeology of Mycenaean Greece. It seems quite clear that most of the heroes of the Iliad and the Odyssey are supposed to represent the kinds of petty kings who ruled the various palaces of Mycenaean Greece. Again, as mentioned, Agamemnon would have been the ruler of Mycenae itself, the greatest city possibly politically dominant in the Mycenaean world, which it might have had contacts in Anatolia as well. It seems that all of the most of the leaders of the Trojan War, like Nestor of Pylos, for instance, they're all described as kings of their own lands. They would have been kings of very tiny lands, but this kingship seems to imply some form of military obligation in the Trojan War. Each king brings his own ship and his own warrior retainers. Think about the mostly loyal crew of Odysseus or the fearsome Myrmidons who come to Troy with Achilles and Patroclus. [1:07:20] These are all recorded in the infamously boring catalogue of ships at the beginning of the Iliad. However, we should mention that, you know, you alluded to this, Sam, but it's most likely that the vast majority of people living within these Mycenaean palaces were not kings and their retainers, but instead the masses of slaves and workers. Records from the city of Pylos show that thousands of slaves could have been employed at a single palace. If this was the case, it was probably an extremely unstable social situation in which these teeming oppressed masses were ruled over by a tiny warrior aristocracy who only had very tenuous coercive power over them through patronage, through the distribution of resources, and of course through violence. We have many documents from the Mycenaean Greeks themselves, which is an incredible historical resource. This is due to their literacy in the Linear B script, which is derived from the undeciphered Linear A of the Minoans, but to an even greater extent than with the Hittites. [1:08:24] These documents, while very fascinating in the economic data they provide, tell us very little about the beliefs and political structure and internal worlds of the Greeks in the Bronze Age. We do know that each Mycenaean palace would have been ruled by a king called wanax, yet not a single one of these is known by name from Mycenaean sources. We get some additional insights, not from these internal sources, but instead from foreign, particularly Hittite documents about these Mycenaeans. Most of these are from this cache of 26 documents known as the Ahhiyawa letters from the Hittite capital at Hattusa. One of them is from an Ahhiyawa king himself, which is fascinating. We actually get the perspective of a Bronze Age Greek person writing in the Hittite language, pleading to an unknown Hittite king for the return of Greek-speaking islands apparently conquered by the Hittite king generations before. This again proves that the Hittites and the Mycenaeans were in direct political conflict over territory, and the islands being referred to very well may have included the territory of Miletus, right off the coast of Anatolia. [1:09:43] Another one of these fascinating texts is the Tawagalawa letter. This document again mentions the mysterious Anatolian rebel Piyamaradu, and it is addressed directly to a king of the Ahhiyawa in the 13th century BC, probably about 75 years before the Bronze Age collapse. This letter suggests that the Ahhiyawans were supporting Piyamaradu somehow. But what's more interesting is that the Ahhiyawan king was closely involved with yet another outlaw, this being a man named Tawagalawa, who is one of the only Mycenaean individuals known by name. This also may have been the local Hittite pronunciation of the Greek name Eteocles. This may be the inspiration for the Homeric character of Menelaus, who again is the brother of the king of Mycenae, known to the Hittites as Ahiala. What scholars are most interested here in this letter is the direct links between the Greeks of Mycenae and the people of Wilusa. [1:10:52] This letter shows that the Hittites had previously battled the Greeks directly concerning the matter of Wilusa. Again, this goes, this suggests it is very possible that by the time of the Bronze Age collapse, the city of Wilusa or Troy was already Greek-speaking, or at least had a Greek-speaking elite. This is a really fascinating document, therefore, in understanding the actual political background to the events either invented or remembered by Homer 500 years later. In addition to this evidence of direct Greek involvement in Anatolian affairs, we also have lots, possibly more evidence, of influence in the opposite direction. Since the 19th century, historians have noted various parallels in content and theme between the works of Homer and Mesopotamian literature, in particular, the epic of Gilgamesh. Mary Bachvarova has demonstrated pretty convincingly that rather than coming directly from the Bronze Age to classical Greece, texts such as Gilgamesh were transmitted through Anatolian intermediaries, primarily through the Hittite Empire. [1:12:04] Texts written in Hittite, Luwian, or Hurrian recorded their own local Anatolian variants of the Gilgamesh story, as well as poetic accounts of the deeds of the Sumerian king Sargon of Akkad and other figures from deep in the Bronze Age past. These texts and several others show apparent influence on Greek literature and even belief. For one example, an otherwise entirely lost text known as the Wilusiad, apparently recounting the history or some story within the city of Troy, constantly uses the word high or lofty to describe the walls of Troy. This same phrase is found nowhere else in the Anatolian corpus, but does show up in Homer. It is very possible that when Homer describes the lofty walls of Troy, he is hearkening back to an Anatolian tradition from when Troy still existed. An even clearer parallel is the summoning sacrifice that Odysseus carries out to conjure up the spirits of the dead in the Odyssey. [1:13:07] This scene was depicted with surprising fidelity in Christopher Nolan's movie. Here, Odysseus sacrifices two animals and tosses them into a pit, causing their blood to mingle while he performs a complex ritual that involves pouring wine and milk and scattering barley. This is surprisingly similar to a Hurrian text known as Purification Ritual of the Former Gods, in which the reader is able to commune with an ancient overthrown pantheon of deities comparable to the Titans. This ritual looks exactly like what Odysseus does. The same kinds of sacrifices, the same kinds of spells, both in the invocation of these supernatural spirits. This to me suggests that certain Hittite ritual practices could have been adopted by the Greeks of the Aegean. I know you have some other thoughts, Alex, about the ways that Homeric depictions of sacrifice resonate with both Indo-European tradition and with ancient Near Eastern tradition. [1:14:10] Right. So the most famous example of this is probably, I think it's kind of like a general burial for Patroclus, right? [1:14:17] Yeah, yeah. [1:14:18] So the funeral pyre and the funeral games. I think the term is the erastes, like the love of Achilles. Like it's debated whether or not this is sexual. Maybe this is like a culture of like love, lover in classical Greece, but it's possible that that's a development after the Homeric period. And we can't really, we don't know how to project that onto the Bronze Age. It's very arcane. But the Patroclus is interesting because it looks kind of like an older Indo-European burial in a bunch of ways. Well, first off, I believe when Patroclus dies, his horses are, there's a specific moment where his horses like cry out in agony because Patroclus is dead. So again, there's the idea of like a man and a horse kind of being combined and this somehow resulting in rulership. [1:15:06] Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. These are the immortal horses of Achilles who weep when Patroclus dies. [1:15:11] Yeah, but then it gets interesting because his hunting dogs are killed to go with the image of the afterlife. And dogs are everywhere in the Eurasian. Dogs function as psychopomps in religion everywhere. [1:15:28] Yeah, yeah, yeah. Cerberus is the most the most famous example of Cerberus. [1:15:33] And then I believe there's two dogs in certain versions of the like Vedic or like a Hindu conception of the afterlife that are used as guides between lives. And the most interesting thing I found is I think at a Zoroastrian funeral, they still use dogs sometimes. Or like we have this idea of like a classic Zoroastrian belief of a dog. I believe the oldest examples we have of a Turkic, Turkic burial customs involve dogs as well. And this, like, not to get Borman and like compare Native American religious beliefs to Eurasian religious beliefs, but it looks like there is some kind of dog as psychopomp idea that is quite common in Native American religious beliefs. [1:16:18] Yeah, I believe going down into Mesopotamia. And this is getting into like, you know, totally wild conjecture here, but I know that some serious, some serious scholars have suggested that this could this be a belief brought down from the ancient North Eurasians, who you mentioned in the last episode are now understood to be ancestral both to the peoples of the Eurasian steppe as well as to Native Americans. [1:16:43] Yeah, but Patroclus' funeral also includes, I believe it's four different horses that go with him. But there's also ten Trojan war captives. [1:16:53] Yeah, no, before this episode, we were discussing how, you know, again, some right-wingers, one of the ways they abuse the past is by suggesting that human sacrifice is something that non-European savages do, whether you're talking about the Aztecs or the Phoenicians, whereas good, proper Europeans would never do something like that. Yet, you know, the earliest European literature includes a straight-up human sacrifice. [1:17:15] Yeah. Agamemnon kills his daughter. [1:17:18] Iphigenia. [1:17:19] Yeah. How do you pronounce her name? [1:17:20] I think that's right, yeah. [1:17:22] And Achilles kills 10 Trojan captives for his burial. [1:17:26] Yes. [1:17:27] And then even the Romans, when the Romans were at war with Gaul, they conducted straight-up human sacrifice to bless their war. And not just that, but that's the origin of the gladiatorial games seems to be some kind of burial human sacrifice. [1:17:43] It very much is, yeah. [1:17:44] So I think something that's, I think it's kind of funny about the burial of Patroclus is I think they kind of, I think what possibly could be happening is this is like an older Kurgan, like it's a remnant of a much older Indo-European burial custom that we're seeing. But what they kept it in because it makes Achilles sound like a badass. Like that's kind of a very theory. Even though by Homer, so by Homer's time, people weren't doing human sacrifice anymore. But if you want to show that Achilles, Achilles is the like ne plus ultra greatest badass of all time. [1:18:17] That's funny. [1:18:18] That's the except by having him go to like a much older religious custom. [1:18:22] That's very, yeah, that is extremely plausible. And I think another issue with the other problem here raised by, not necessarily a problem, but an issue raised by discussions of sacrifice in Homer, whether these are human sacrifices or cattle sacrifices, are that while they have these Indo-European or even, you know, like these resonances that seem to be ancestral from the linguistic heritage of the Eurasian steppe and that influence on the Indo-European speaking peoples, they also have extremely strong parallels with Near Eastern sacrificial ritual. And I'm not sure if the Indo-Europeans and the Semitic-speaking peoples of the Near East separately developed very similar sacrifice traditions or if there was just constant feedback across the Bronze Age world. But regardless, there are these really fascinating parallels. We discussed, we hinted at Phoenician human sacrifice, a very notorious practice. But we know much more about ancient Israelite sacrifice of cattle. [1:19:25] And I think that the sacrifice of cattle by Nestor in the Odyssey and by Odysseus in the Iliad has extremely strong similarities with the sacrificial practices attested in the Old Testament. It's this highly ritualized practice. And I think that people really don't understand, modern readers do not understand how important sacrifice was to all ancient peoples, either ancient Israelites or ancient pagans. Sacrifices not only were a major civic and religious event, but much, possibly most or all of the meat consumed by people in the ancient world would have been ritually sacrificed. It was not common to ever eat a side of beef that was not in some sense holy. [1:20:09] I was thinking about this a lot and like I was trying to think of like what is it about a horse, right? Because we have this, the thing is that like the Trojan horse is just like one of the most iconic images in all of culture. It's just this, right? [1:20:23] Yeah. [1:20:24] This huge horse sculpture in the middle of the city. And what is it? And like you can make maybe it's an Indo-European thing. It's the idea of like contesting rulership or like kingship through the like shamanistic combination of man and horse, where the like Achaeans drop out of the horse and come out and destroy the city. Or like maybe it's a reference to like Poseidon, who's like Poseidon's probably king of the gods in the Mycenaean period. And he has this ancient connection to horses and to earthquakes. And then in Homer, Poseidon is basically co-equal to Zeus, it seems like. Zeus is described as the greatest of the gods, but he doesn't seem to have any actual power over Poseidon. And in Mycenaeans, like, I think it's usually believed that Mycenae, he's actual Lord of the gods in Mycenaean religion. I think that's the concept. Mycenaean really just looks a bit more like, unsurprisingly, like Anatolian or maybe even Minoan in some regards, because Zeus is not necessarily the center of it. [1:21:28] It's Poseidon and Potnia, the mistress. It's this Chthonic deity who's Lord of earthquakes, who feels a bit more Anatolian than anything else. To get back to the horse sacrifice, I think these are just kind of like images in our brain somewhere. Like I was trying to think of different places where like a white horse is involved in ritual sacrifice. And I kept thinking about Twin Peaks because like, if you guys watch Twin Peaks, there's the second season spoilers for a TV show that's 35 years old. But like there's the ritual murder of a character with a white horse hallucination at the beginning of it. There's just some kind of like weird, intense connection between the horse and sacrifice. There's the play Equus from the 1970s. That's like the biggest, the biggest like play of the British theater of the 19th century. [1:22:23] Yeah, and then revived with Daniel Radcliffe. [1:22:25] Yeah, yeah. Or like the episode of Hannibal, where the therapist cuts at people and horses. Like, there's just some kind of weird. [1:22:34] No, yeah, this is something I've thought about often is that, you know, so many religions across the world are obsessed with animals. And I feel like mammals in particular. Like, whether, you know, whether they're horses, cattle, wolves, bears, there's this idea of like humans desiring to take on the characteristics of animals that they think are cool, basically. You know, it's almost a bit of, I think it's, you know, this is not disrespectful here. It's kind of a juvenile practice. Like, you see, wow, bears are so big and so strong. I wish I could be like a bear. But it's such a fundamental belief that it makes sense that this is, you know, part of so many ancient and modern religions. [1:23:12] Yeah, I know. The furry has ancient roots. [1:23:14] Yes, indeed. And also, just, you know, back to the idea of international influence, it's extremely clear that syncretism, obviously, was a huge part of ancient religion. And it was something that almost was understood without even needing to be identified. So the Hittites had a complex system of syncretizing their local Anatolian gods, these Hittite or Hurrian gods, with the gods of Mesopotamia. So like, you know, the main Hittite god, Tarhunna, he was syncretized with the Semitic god Dagon, who I think might have also been syncretized with El at times. And then one Hittite goddess was associated with Ishtar or Astarte of the Near East. And even with the Greeks, we do see some kinds of this, you know, Oriental influence coming in at different periods. There's, of course, the very famous Asiatic or Orientalizing period of Archaic Greece, but even in the Bronze Age, perhaps even more strongly in the Bronze Age, you see these influences from Near Eastern peoples on Greek culture and religion, including the mighty Hittites next door. [1:24:27] So, you know, for instance, the Greeks understood their own god Dionysus to be of foreign origin, particularly Phrygian origin. The Phrygians, who we'll talk about next episode, lived in the same, the very same region of the Anatolian highlands that the Hittites would rule, except the Phrygians were there in the Iron Age, not in the earlier Bronze Age. However, this Eastern Phrygian origin of Dionysus is no longer understood, as the name of the wine god is actually one of the earliest theonyms recorded in Mycenaean texts. One of the tablets at Pylos includes a figure by that name. The fact that the name is attested so early makes it unlikely that this god actually came from the east. So it's very strange then that the Greeks attributed such an origin to their god. I think the most likely explanation is there were some differences in worship of Dionysus, the famous Dionysian mysteries, that separated this god from the others. [1:25:28] So they thought that he must have had a separate, possibly foreign origin. The reason they looked to Anatolia is because they understood that other elements of their religion had come from the East through Anatolia. The most obvious example is the lovely Aphrodite, who is now largely understood to be the local Aegean equivalent to the Semitic goddess Ishtar or Astarte. The name Aphrodite may even be a local Greek attempt to pronounce Astarte, or it could have come from a Phoenician word meaning most excellent. Aphrodite was also sometimes described as heavenly or Urania. This connected her to the Titan Uranus, who some Greeks saw as her father. But it's also very reminiscent of Astarte's title, Queen of the Heavens. At least one group of the Greeks, the people of the island of Kos, who maintained very close contact with the Levant, explicitly identified Aphrodite with Astarte. Meanwhile, in Cyprus, an island that slowly became Greek across the Bronze and Iron Age, here the pre-existing cult of Astarte would be transformed into the cult of Aphrodite after the conquest of Alexander the Great, and then again the Romans, as Greco-Roman influence begins to penetrate even the most remote corners of the Near East. [1:26:49] Basically, all worshipers of Astarte become worshippers of Aphrodite and Venus. [1:26:56] Yeah, and yeah, and I mean, you also have these pockets of seemingly Semitic-tinged belief all over the Greek-speaking world. So, for example, on the island of Samothrace, which is quite far from like Semitic lands, it's like basically off the coast of Thrace. They have a tradition of worshiping the Kabeiroi. The name is derived from the Semitic word for big. So, even at that distance, you had all these different cults cropping up. And I mean, this is really an interesting thing to consider, maybe worth doing an episode about at some point. When classics got solidified in the 19th century as a field of study, it had a very strong Chud undercurrent rooted in like the racial ideologies of the period, where they wanted to present this idea of the Greeks as sort of being truly exceptionalist, as having created their own culture, ex nihilo, without the influence of the people who were neighboring them, who were to a large extent Semitic. [1:27:56] And this had tie-in with the anti-Semitism of the period. So, of course, you had more Jewish scholars tend to poke holes in this, being like, hey, wait a minute, what about XYZ? So, I mean, this would continue to be a trend for a very while. It's kind of cyclical. Even today, there are, you know, racial right-wingers who want to assert that Greek culture either had nothing to do with the culture of the Near East and was, you know, wholly the product of white Europeans, or they even more shamelessly say actually the Greeks were influenced by the Near East. But that's because in this period, the Near East was truly wise. [1:28:33] Yeah, no, I mean, yeah, yeah, lots of very silly stuff happening, unfortunately. This often ties into like the worst kind of Indo-European scholarship. So, like, claims that they were like seven feet tall, or like it's quite funny. No, I'm serious. Like, I read that in a Substack post. Like, there are people who will, like, I'm never sure if they're joking, right? Because, like, some of these guys they will treat things as a bit, and it's kind of almost like a fool's errand to treat them as a bit or not. [1:29:02] Yeah, it's because the grain of truth here is that in certain circumstances in the Bronze Age, especially, there were certain times in which Indo-European speaking tribes were better fighters and possibly more physically robust than neighboring non-European speaking peoples. For instance, in like, you know, in the Carpathian region, that may have been what happened. [1:29:20] They had a better time. They had lactase persistence. [1:29:22] Yeah, because they had huge amounts of milk and cheese, which helped you get, you know, big muscles and bones. People extrapolate this to this racial supremacist fantasy. [1:29:32] Some of that was, it looks like some of that was genetic, but a part of it was just nutritional. I mean, that look at Lee, we're talking about, you know, why do horses and cows matter so much? Horses and cows are both directly involved in food production in really important ways. Like, you need both of them to live. I just find a lot of this frustrating sometimes because these are such like nuanced, complicated, beautiful cultures, and you try to create racial myths out of this. I mean, like, to be honest, if I'm being very honest about this, the left does this too sometimes, down into like Marxist conceptions of Edenic, kind of like pre-earliest communism, or even like David Graeber's book, which is like interesting sometimes, but also just gets into like anarcho-Kidian mythology in a lot of ways that are not really productive. Like, you can read into, you could be interested in Indo-European mythology and not too, but it's like an eternal struggle against Semitic night. [1:30:23] Oh, no, yes. Well, and that's it. It goes without saying that, like, you know, modern-day racist abuses of this scholarship have nothing to do with the actual content being presented. And I don't think that it's awful to suggest that modern-day abuses of history should somehow harm the history itself. I completely reject that idea. [1:30:42] It's quite funny, like, on Twitter, I barely talked about this for years because I didn't want people to know how interested I was in this. And then at some point, I just started tweeting about it, and people are like, oh, this isn't chud, right? It's also quite odd because ADNA research, like ancient DNA research, was like taboo in academia for quite some time. [1:30:59] Yeah, no, we mentioned this last episode, but you know, like the rise in archaeogenetics is relatively recent. It began basically in like the last 10 years. And yeah. [1:31:06] And like, you know, this is just like, it's a new way to view the world. And it doesn't have to have this like Chud Coke talk. [1:31:14] Yeah. A lot of these chuds think that the existence of archaeogenetics affirms all of their priors because there are a handful of cases in which certain late 20th century theories have basically been disproven. And sometimes the, you know, the modern account does have reminiscences with earlier, very, you know, cavalier 19th century theories about the migrations of the peoples and all that. So because of this, some right-wingers overextend their argument to suggest that genetics has vindicated them everywhere. But that really isn't the case at all. And again, looking at the Greeks, you're talking about how Greek people, although they spoke an Indo-European language, they did not derive the vast majority of their ancestry from the proto-Indo-Europeans of the Eurasian steppe. Instead, there was local continuity with the earlier Copper Age peoples of the Aegean. And again, so some of these religious, so some of these religious similarities we've been discussing, these trans-Mediterranean religious connections, they could have potentially predated the development of the Greek language. [1:32:21] Although I think it's more likely that what we're seeing here is proximate contact due to trade and mercenary service and all that. Let me just quickly, you know, this has gone for a while, but let me just bring up two quick examples of clear Near Eastern influence on Greek mythology. So we mentioned how Aphrodite. [1:32:39] Are you going to Apollo? Are you going to bring up Apollo? [1:32:42] Actually, I don't know when I'm not sure. Tell me what's the Apollo example. I don't know that one. [1:32:46] Well, Apollo is, I believe he's considered the defender of Troy. [1:32:50] Yes, very much so in the Iliad. [1:32:52] In the Iliad, his primarily, like, his domain is disease. [1:32:58] Yes, he plagues the very beginning of the Iliad. He plagues the Greeks with disease. [1:33:03] Yes. And he's also an archer. I joked on Twitter that he's almost more like Nurgle in the Iliad. Like, he's like this, like... [1:33:10] Yeah, this, the, the Mesopotamian death god. [1:33:12] Yeah, or the Warhammer 40K death god. [1:33:15] Oh, that, that one. Yeah, no, yeah. I think, I think, yeah, I think you, I think D&D also, Dungeons and Dragons also borrows this Mesopotamian figure. [1:33:23] He's a very different god. But we have, I believe, he's first attested in Anatolian records as some kind of like eccentric god of the West. And he's not even connected with the sun until quite late. Like in the Odyssey, when they talk about the sun god's cattle, that famous scene, I believe in the actual Odyssey, it's Helios. [1:33:41] It's Helios, yeah. It very much is Helios. Yeah, yeah. It's the Titan's cattle. It's not Apollo's cattle. So do you think that Apollo could you think Apollo could have been this like autochthonous god of Troy who then was adopted by the Greeks? [1:33:56] I think that's been suggested by some people. I'd have to, I think I read that in one of the books I read, but I'd have to go through it first of the preference. But that is also interesting because it does show a continuous evolution of a god, right? So you have a god that starts off as a defender of Troy, who's associated with the walls of Troy, who's associated with the Trojans, who maybe, I think he's called shining, but he's not necessarily associated with the sun in the Iliad. And then by the time of festival antiquity, he's quite, the process of him syncretizing with Helios is quite advanced. And by the Hellenistic period, he's like mixed in with all of the weird, like, syncretic sun gods that are emerging out of the. [1:34:38] No, and of course, yeah, Alexander the Great, of course, would identify himself with Apollo, right? Because Apollo became this like heroic god of young men, which is not how he's portrayed at all in the Iliad. Bringing this back to, you know, speaking to Anatolia and Wilusa and the Hittites and all that, Aphrodite very much was a goddess of the Hittite world, primarily not in Anatolia itself, but instead in Syria. But the Hittites did associate her with their own goddess, Shaushka. So this is kind of this Hurrian goddess worshipped by the Hittites, whom they associated with Astarte. There's this one Hurrian text used by the Hittites, the Song of Kumarbi, which includes a graphic theogony in which the primordial god Anu is overthrown by another god, Kumarbi. This usurper king of the gods bites off and swallows Anu's penis and testicles and then spits up his predecessor's semen onto a mountainside, causing another god to be born from the foaming fluid. [1:35:40] He then becomes pregnant with two other gods. Our listeners probably already recognize there are striking similarities here with Hesiod's theogony, in which the Titan Cronus castrates his father Uranus, after which the family jewels are thrown into the sea, and from the foam created therein, we get Aphrodite. A more obscure Greek poem written in Hellenistic Macedonia has even more striking similarities with the song of Kumarbi. Here, Zeus does the castrating, swallows Uranus' genitals, and then he becomes pregnant, just like Kumarbi. Either all religions have a natural tendency towards some kind of divine mpreg, or we can see here Anatolian influence on Greek mythology. Before I move on from religion, I also want to bring up one crazy anecdote, just crazy example that I can't believe is not more well known. The Greek god Adonis is clearly and certainly derived from the Semitic word Adonai, meaning lord, famously used in, you know, in Judaism today for the god of Israel, for the god of Judaism and Christianity. [1:36:44] Adonis may have actually entered the Greek pantheon as part of a package deal with Astarte. This is because Astarte, Aphrodite, had a divine consort who went by various names in Near Eastern pantheons. So this very much may be the origin of Adonis. [1:37:01] And he's associated with beauty. I mean, it makes perfect sense. [1:37:04] Yeah. [1:37:05] Okay, so now we've talked all about these connections with the Hittites and with the Mycenaeans and the implications here on Homer, but the world depicted by Homer in the Iliad and the Odyssey looks abroad in other ways as well. You know, there are mentions of Ethiopia in both texts, and we don't exactly know what Ethiopia meant to Homer if it was the same as the modern-day nation. But at the very least, the Greeks of Homer had clear interest in their connections to the outside world, not just to Anatolia. The Bronze Age Mycenaean Greeks clearly did have international contacts, perhaps most strongly with Egypt. The name Ahhiyawa is recorded in one Egyptian reference from the end of the 13th century, shortly before the entire Bronze Age system came crashing down. The inscription at the famous temple of Karnak, proclaimed by the pharaoh Merneptah, states that this king won a great victory against the tribal Libyans, who were aided by other barbarian tribes, northerners coming from all lands. [1:38:10] These northern tribes included the Sherden, the Sheklesh, the Ekwesh, and the Lukka. Some scholars will confidently state that these people, Sherden, Shekelesh, Ekwesh, and Lukka, are in fact Sardinians, Sicilians, Achaeans, and Lycians, those being a people, a tribal people from the southwest Anatolian region of Lycia. However, there isn't any context here beyond phonetic similarity. A later passage confuses things further. The Ekwesh, possibly the same as the Achaeans, were said to be circumcised, which one would not expect of Bronze Age Mycenaeans. I'm sure, you know, in fact, the later Greeks of the Hellenistic era famously scorned the Jewish practice of circumcision to the extent that this is basically why we have the holiday of Hanukkah today. But it is not impossible that some of these Ekwesh or Achaeans, these Bronze Age Greeks, could have been circumcised. This is because, again, cultural influence in the Bronze Age world went in all directions. [1:39:17] Not only did you have Near Eastern religious ideas coming into Greece, you also had Greek individuals coming into the Near East. Contemporary with the description of these potentially Greek Ekwesh recorded in Egyptian texts, we know from archaeology that some Achaeans settled along the Levantine coast. The Philistines, namesake of the modern land of Palestine, are now understood conclusively to have been partially descended from Greek-speaking migrants from the Aegean, possibly after a stopover on the island of Cyprus. Philistine pottery has undeniable Mycenaean links, and while it's true that pots are not people, genetic research indicates that people living in Iron Age Philistia did indeed have distinctly Aegean ancestry, as well as, of course, most of their ancestry being from local Canaanite peoples. Even the architecture of the Philistines has interesting correspondences with the palatial economy of the Aegean world. A small inscription at the Philistine city of Ekron might also include the Greek word potnia, meaning goddess. [1:40:28] All of this suggests that the Philistines, later immortalized in the Hebrew Bible, maintained a religious and cultural practice that mixed some aspects of Aegean material culture with Semitic language, Semitic religion, and possibly the Semitic practice of circumcision. This part is fully conjecture, but I think it may be possible that the reason why Egyptian texts describe the Ekwesh as being circumcised is that these people had not come straight from Greece, but instead were Ekwesh from the Levant. They were Philistines, who, though they were of Greek origin, had adopted local Near Eastern religious practices, including circumcision. [1:41:12] Aren't there suggesting that Goliath somehow has like a Mycenaean etymology as well? [1:41:17] I have not heard, I have not looked into that, but that absolutely could be possible. I know there are various attempts to connect the name Philistine or Peliset to various Greek terms. I'm not sure, you know, it sounds like glove of something. I'm not sure if it would be that in Greek, if the linguistic evidence suggests that. [1:41:33] And in the Old Testament, he's specifically being described as huge, right? Is he described as army? [1:41:39] No, I think it depends on the account. I think the height of Goliath actually has been debated. I think some, like Rabbinical commentaries, there were some oral structures saying he was like six foot seven or something. [1:41:49] Six seven, six, seven. [1:41:50] And others, he was like, you know, 12 feet tall. I think it was a scribal error. Scholars say that they somehow mixed up the numbers. They said he was such and such number of cubits, but a scribe at some point must have fudged it. But I don't remember the details, so I'm just gonna. [1:42:05] Yeah, well, either by accident or because it's a better story. It's a much more exciting story if David brings down a nine-foot-tall giant rather than a six-foot-seven giant. But it is interesting because it is the idea that the Philistines are somehow like. [1:42:20] Yes. Yeah, there is. And then, you know, the book of Samuel also has some brief physical description of the armor and weaponry used by, I think, Goliath, or at least some Philistines. And it has been, people have tried to argue, could this attest to the kind of Mycenaean armor that we see from, you know, from various Greek sites? Like, there's the famous panoply that's this huge suit of armor of banded bronze basically stapled together, these, you know, metal bands. Could that be the kind of bronze armor being described of the Philistines in the Old Testament? And the answer is maybe. It's hard to know. [1:43:04] That seems really unlikely for a bunch of reasons, but we'll get into that in the next episode, probably. [1:43:08] Okay. Well, you know, just to wrap this up, because we're at nearly two hours without pre-edit, let's talk about this is this is very tenuous, but it's fun. There's one other potential biblical reference to Mycenaean Greek activities in the Levant, and these activities would have probably come around the end of the Bronze Age, possibly coinciding with, possibly contributing to, the famous Bronze Age collapse. This is that we've mentioned how Homer constantly refers to the Greeks as Achaeans or Argives. There's also one third name that he uses, and that is the Danaeans. It has been conjectured since the 19th century that the Danaeans might have some link to a group in the Old Testament, that being the seafaring Israelite tribe of Dan. Initially, this theory was basically laughed off because it's fully based on phonetic similarity, and we really cannot trust that. Again, I should mention that we've been trying to explain the ways that the Ekwesh, the circumcised Ekwesh of the Egyptian records, we've been looking at the ways they could have been Achaeans. [1:44:19] It is perhaps even more likely that the Ekwesh described by the Egyptians were an otherwise unknown tribe with nothing to do with the Greeks at all. They simply had a phonetic similarity to the term Achaean. This very well may be the case with the Danaeans and the tribe of Dan. But this is complicated because in the 20th century, it was then discovered that another Egyptian inscription references yet another people known as the Denyen. It has been thought that these Denyen could relate either to the tribe of Dan from the Hebrew Bible or to the Danaeans of Homer. Unlike the case with the Philistines, there is no archaeological or archaeogenetic evidence linking this biblical tribe of Dan with any foreign culture. Indeed, the very existence of a tribe of Dan or any of the 12 tribes of Israel is highly contested. There is a site in modern-day Israel and Palestine known as Tel Dan, very close to the region of Philistia, which is traditionally associated with the biblical tribe of Dan. [1:45:32] It is very possible that the entire emergence of such a tribe came from this site, that Tel Dan was first. Recent excavations at Tel Dan show that there were indeed some strong connections with the world of the Aegean Greeks. There is not enough evidence to say that the tribe of Dan from the Bible were the same as the Danaeans of Homer and the same as the Denyen of Egyptian records, but it does seem that the Philistine world basically and the processes that created the Philistines also extended to the site of Tel Dan nearby. I think what this suggests is that international contacts in the ancient world were much deeper than what we really think we know at this point. We know for a fact that the Egyptians maintained strong economic and political links first with the Minoan people, who we're going to describe in our next episode, as well as the Mycenaeans. [1:46:34] Letters from the Hittites to the Egyptians suggest that the Mycenaeans or Ahhiyawa were so troublesome that economic embargoes were placed upon the Mycenaeans by the Hittites, possibly because of Mycenaean support for anti-Hittite rebels, such as, you know, Piyamaradu or Alaksandu of Wilusa. Even centuries before Homer, the Greeks were already an outward-looking people with fascinating international connections. These connections, as we'll see in our next episode, probably had something to do, or at least can help us understand the fall of the Bronze Age world and the rise of the Iron Age. Ultimately, the Greek world would survive far beyond that of the Hittites, despite the great might and influence of the Hittites in the late Bronze Age. Even though the works of Homer were written down so many centuries after the Hittites ceased to exist, I think they really can be a fascinating look at the cultural memory of this moment when the Greeks were an ambitious but small ethnic group living around the margins of greater societies such as the Hittite Empire or the Egyptian New Kingdom. [1:47:53] Before we wrap up, any thoughts from Alex and Sam about this entire topic and the Hittites and Homer? [1:48:01] We've talked about this a bit before the episode, but it really does feel like the Phoenicians and like the kind of like Semitic Levantines and the Greeks have just been connected throughout history in ways that we're still kind of untangling, right? There's a lot more evidence coming out these days of Carthaginian Greek links that we kind of like can infer from most facts of the history, but you know, these were people who mixed. These were people who were all over the Mediterranean together. [1:48:28] Yeah, no, very much so. And I think a lot of kind of you know normies, for lack of a better word, they have this intuitive understanding that there are very strong connections in culture and attitudes across the Mediterranean, you know, from Spain to Italy to Morocco to Palestine to Turkey. And these similarities can very much be overstated. Even similarities in cuisine are often overstated, but there's something to that argument. You know, the Mediterranean was, generally speaking, more of a channel of communication than a division. In the Bronze Age, we see this remarkably interconnected world that, with these far-reaching connections that would basically be severed for centuries after the Bronze Age collapse. And I think what's very interesting about the Greek angle here is that the Greeks are perhaps one of the only peoples of this time, maybe honestly, alongside the Persians, who would come out of the Bronze Age collapse in a much better position. [1:49:23] Even though they would lose their ancient writing system, they would develop a new, much more robust literary tradition. A literary tradition that would obviously change the world in ways that we are still dealing with. Again, I just think it's very fascinating that the earliest and perhaps most famous works of Greek literature attest to this fascinating and mysterious transition period associated with the collapse of empire, the collapse of an entire world system. Much of Christopher Nolan's film, The Odyssey, is about the ways that violence and the corruption of the soul leads to the fall of civilization. We're going to get into that in the next episode. But anyone listening, if you're somebody who's new to ancient studies, I really think you should read, at least skim through the works of Homer. The Iliad and the Odyssey are long and daunting, but they're very fascinating. From an archaeological to anthropological standpoint, there's so many cool little details that seem so alien and defy your preconceived notions about what ancient Greek life is like. [1:50:32] But then, from a literary standpoint, they're both very sophisticated, very beautiful texts. You know, both Alexander and I, we've talked about the scene at the end of the Iliad in which Priam, following the death of Hector, when Priam pleads at the feet of Achilles for the return of his son's body, and Achilles, looking at this old man, thinks to his own father back home in Greece. That's a very, very touching moment. And that there are these genuine emotional insights in the works of Homer that really help us understand that peoples in the deep past felt the exact same emotions that we do, and we're just as smart as we are. They might have had shocking differences in culture. For instance, they were fine with human sacrifice, as mentioned in certain cases. But, you know, people are people. And I think that this is something that Christopher Nolan does not do, is to emphasize the ways that different cultures can be aesthetically very different to ours and very different in their value systems, but still essentially the same in their emotions and motivations. [1:51:38] And I think that the original text of the Odyssey and the Iliad very much do show that. So I understand why translators like Emily Wilson aren't happy with the film. And I do think that, you know, whether or not you like Nolan's Odyssey, you ought to read the original. And I think that the Iliad in particular, it can be a lot to get through. It's very long. It's extremely repetitive. But when it's good, it really is very good. And it's just such a great window into this lost world of the Bronze Age. A world that, if we did not have the Iliad and the Odyssey, would be, I think, honestly, feel much less real to us. [1:52:19] I kind of wanted to get like, we'll talk about this more in the next episode, but just like, I feel like there's a real appetite for the classics on both the left and the right right now. And I think that's probably a good thing in a lot of ways. [1:52:31] Yeah, yeah. [1:52:32] I think people became way too comfortable with junk. That's just the reality of the situation. Like, they became way too comfortable with Marvel movies, with superhero Schlock in general. [1:52:47] Yeah. [1:52:47] There was just a cultural dumbing down throughout the entirety. I don't want you to west, but it did happen a little bit, just realistically. And like, I think going back to Homer, to even to Hesiod, to the foundations of the culture, to like the origins of world literature, there's something really engaging and fun about it. I think this is the way. [1:53:10] Yeah, right. And I can't wait for all the other Hollywood studios to, you know, for the arms race where everyone goes to races to make their version of the Aeneid and then an epic about Brutus of Troy settling Britain and becoming the ancestor of King Arthur. I can't wait. I want to see all this on the big screen. [1:53:26] Oh, God, it's going to be so terrible. [1:53:29] All right. Well, you know, thank you so much, Alex. Always a pleasure. You know, you're going to be coming back soon to finish this discussion, but I think this is, again, a really great talk. And thank you very much to Sam. All right. And have a great rest of your day to our audience. All right. Bye-bye.