Inside the Internet episode art

12

Inside the Internet

Pam

The Internet is what gives us power. It’s an energy field created by all

artificial things. It surrounds us. It penetrates us. It binds humanity

We talk about it by way of the National Geographic TV documentary

Inside the Internet: 50 Years of Life Online , which you can watch here.

Hosted by Liam,

Abram, and

Pam.

Transcript

About 15,600 wordsPlain text

TranscriptInside the Internet

Welcome, Pam

Back to April. Back to your podcast app. Just glad to hear of time. I'm Abram, and today I'm joined by Liam.

Hey!

And special guest Pam.

Hi.

A returning champ. And today we'll talk about the internet and recent history of the internet. And mostly like the history that concerns the average consumer. A people's history, if you will.

Inside the Internet

We're going to talk about that by way of this National Geographic TV documentary. It's called Inside the Internet: 50 Years of Life Online. Came out a couple years ago in 2019. It's not very good. It's like, you know, it's a TV documentary. It's like 47 minutes, an hour with commercials. It's on Hulu.

Yeah, it touches on a bunch of like topics like email, America Online, the Y2K bug, dot-com bubble, like Napster, social media, viral videos, online dating, online journalism, fake news, you know.

Yeah.

It definitely isn't really in the technical side at all, and it really kind of seems to be trying to teach people who have never known a world without the internet, basically how did all of this come into being.

Yeah, it's like a timeline of events, really.

Yeah.

Like it's very shallow.

Oh yeah.

Everything they talk about, you'll understand much better if you just read the Wikipedia entry for it. But obviously if you don't know the exact timeline, then you know having a timeline just telling you this happened, then this happened, this happened is like very helpful to like get you started.

Yeah, yeah.

And it's quite recent and so it has very like millennial now this news type of aesthetics and the way it presents information.

Moby, again

So to describe how shallow this is, this is something Pam talked about to me in the DMs and Liam, I don't know if you picked this up, but Moby is in this documentary.

Oh, yes.

If you don't watch documentaries, let me explain. Moby is like an electronic dance musician. He had like a couple of really good albums in the early 2000s. And in the past 15 years, Moby has been in about five or six documentaries each year. Always about things that do not remotely involve him or his career.

Well, kind of. I mean, he's like a vegan activist, so a lot of them are like that kind of documentaries. But also, if you want somebody, if you're making a documentary like this, like about the internet and the music industry and like how those two things intersect, like Moby's your guy, because he will come on in any documentary and talk about it. Like he was in that, like 10 years ago, he's in the documentary Press Pause Play, which is kind of like this one. It's just like about the internet and how the internet's changing like these industries. So yeah, he's a staple talking head of these kinds of documentaries.

Which is really a shame because he really might be the most off-putting man alive. He's like that guy at work who just always has an opinion on something. Just always butts in on whatever you're talking about.

Talking heads

Yeah, and like Liam just said, this is a documentary where it's basically just talking heads. Some actual industry people, but like a lot of celebrities as well.

Like the strangest guests. Randy Jackson, Martha Stewart, half of Public Enemy. And Mark Cuban.

There's a random porn star. Which they don't identify as a porn star. They just say like internet model.

Yeah, come on. You could be polite.

They actually, fun fact, they actually didn't even invite Moby. He was just there. He showed up.

He shows up to every documentary.

If you try to do a TV documentary, Moby materializes in your room.

Yeah.

That's actually the context of the famous Moby Natalie Portman photo.

Basically, they get all these celebrities and like talking heads and industry people and just do short interviews with each of them. And then you cut up those interviews and then sort like all the clips by topic.

Yeah.

And then you interstitch those clips with like archival footage or like stock footage.

Yeah.

And then you put on a voiceover narration over top to like weave all these things together. And that's the style of this documentary.

It's clear that the hardest working person in this production team was the booker.

Well, I would say the opposite. I would say the hardest working is the editor because the booker just like picked like easy targets like Moby or Mark Cuban. You know, people who love to talk but also have very little to say. But yeah, I mean, I guess the style is fine. I think if it's like very focused on a particular topic, the style of documentary can be effective. But when it's like a topic so broad, it's like 50 years of the internet, you're basically not learning anything.

Yeah, no, it reminds me of those like pre-produced YouTube things put out by Vox or NowThis, where they just have, you know, a guest talking in front of a white screen, very flat, very no frills about a specific topic. But like you said here, when these are people who have really nothing to say at all about the history of the internet, trying to cover a really, really broad topic, it just seems, like you said, a little bit shallow, a little hollow.

A shallow timeline

It also, it's kind of non-linear. It jumps around a lot in time and it kind of just hurts whatever point it's trying to make. Like when it randomly mentions Napster near the end, but it was already like in the 2010s.

Yeah, well, I guess, I guess, I think it's pretty chronological, but I think that's, to me, that's kind of more of the problem. That it's like, this happened at a specific time, then that happened at a specific time, but it doesn't really link anything.

Yeah. It jumps around a lot. It doesn't really flow well.

Yeah, it's not chronological because that's how you would think it would be, but it's sorted by topic. And the way that you sort the topics isn't necessarily the smartest way because, yeah, you know, they talk about BuzzFeed and this, and one of the founders of BuzzFeed is one of the people they interview. And that stuff, the BuzzFeed stuff, comes before they talk about Facebook, which comes before when they talk about Napster.

Yeah.

So it's BuzzFeed, then Facebook, then Napster, which is like reverse chronological orders.

Yeah.

And it's such a pop history kind of overview that they really focus on very kind of social media friendly issues. Like, oh, everyone knows the basics of the Y2K scare. Everyone knows the phrase fake news.

I have to say, it's very shallow. That's why I'll have a link in the description for this episode for like the video if you want to watch it. But I'm just going to say right now, like, don't bother watching it. Instead, what we're going to try to do is we're going to go through most of the topics in this documentary and just actually give you a much clearer picture of what things happened.

Yeah, sure.

The Y2K bug

I think we should probably just start off with the year 2000 problem, the Y2K bug. This is basically when the internet really becomes like a main focus in culture and your computers in general. So you guys are a little younger than I am. Do you have any recollection of this period in history?

Yeah, I remember.

I do not.

Oh, I remember. I just remember people freaking out and then, like, I mean, my family didn't do Doomsday or anything. They're like, I don't care. And I remember like watching the ball drop and people like being like, oh, is Y2K gonna happen? I don't know. A lot of these, I feel like a lot of these documentaries kind of overhype how nervous people were. Like, the news definitely did, but I don't, not a lot of people really went nuts over Y2K thinking maybe. By the time it was New Year's Eve, like, enough has been, was solved by software engineers that they're like, no, it's fine. You don't actually have to, like, freak out.

In the documentary, they have footage of one of the founders of AOL with the R&B artist Sisqo in Times Square for that ball drop, which was great.

Yeah, I feel like just the hype of the new millennium completely drowned out any fear of the Y2K problem.

Yeah.

That's true.

Yeah, yeah.

One thing I could add: so I do not have any memories of Y2K. I guess I'm a little bit younger than you, Pam, I think. But I do have memories of stumbling into my grandparents' basement and finding these massive 12-pound bags of dry peanuts that were lined up, stacked up. And it was because my grandpa was convinced that the world was going to end, so he spent hundreds of dollars on dry goods.

I think that was like a very big televangelist thing. Those kinds of like hucksters basically just hyping this up.

Oh, I can see that.

But yeah, as you say, like most average people were just like completely not bought into this because we basically fixed it.

I just think also at the time people didn't really understand what the bug was. So they're like, who cares that the dates are messed up?

How dates broke

Yeah, absolutely. So I'll try to explain it in the least technical way possible. You know, between the three of us, we have two computer science degrees, but I assume nobody listening to this has any kind of experience in that regard.

Yeah.

In the 70s and 80s, computers were really limited in space. Like back then, storage was measured in kilobytes. So, you know, kilo means thousand, so a thousand bytes. A byte is one character. So one letter or one number or one punctuation mark or one space, all that just takes up one byte. So a thousand-word essay with like no formatting, just plain text, is about 20 kilobytes, maybe a bit more. So, you know, a computer in the 70s and 80s could store like a hundred thousand word essays, you know, really, really limit space. So that means that programmers had to try to shave off as much unnecessary data as possible, just like to save space. And one of those things is just like shave off the date, like in a spreadsheet.

Oh.

Obviously, they weren't like storing essays. They were storing like spreadsheets and databases.

Yeah.

So, you know, they just shave off like the 19 and the date, just, you know, save space. And as years went on, space got bigger, like computers were up being upgraded. But the software that was written in the 70s was still being used like up until the 90s.

Of course.

And so still was shaving off those first two digits. And then, you know, year 2000 is approaching and like that's going to be a problem.

Because it's also like all those completely different pieces of software would like interpret the date. It's going to be completely different.

Like I remember in Windows 3, the date would roll over to 19:00. Because the system was hard-coded, so the first two would always be 19, and only the last two would increment. But the way like computers store like the sequence of letters and numbers, colon is the character immediately after 9. So after 99, instead of going 0, 0, it becomes colon 0, which like doesn't make sense. And also computers have to interpret numbers, and when you put a colon there, it's just going to break everything.

Well, I think it's hilarious how sh yeah, how short-sighted that was in general. And that that reminds me of when I was a kid in elementary school in like 2003, 2004, we had these planners they would give us every year, and the planners automat we had with like a calendar built in, and it automatically started with 19. So even though we were getting these planners in like 2003, the place to write the date had the letters 19 printed in because they assumed it would be only used in the 20th century.

Yeah, because I say like the software was written in the 70s, but the hardware was continually upgraded.

Don't a lot of operating systems still basically use those fundamentals from the 70s? No, I mean we've completely like fixed the Y2K problem, but okay, well because that's there's something I wanted to bring up which I'm sure both of you know about but I can wait.

The 2038 problem

It's something similar that I've heard is coming up on the horizon soon.

Oh the 2038 bug?

Yeah. Yes, because my understanding was that because we're still using software from the 70s, they're gonna run out of seconds. That's the way we store memory.

So that's because there's a thing like 32-bit. It basically just means like not to go too in depth about like how bit math works and stuff, but basically 32-bit just means we have a certain number, like certain set spaces to store something going up to 32-bits. So like basically 32-bit means you don't have as much space for whatever you're storing compared to 64-bit. And so eventually you have a rollover problem where if you have everything turned on, it's 111111. And say if it's like a number and you want to add something to it, then you have an overflow error because it goes back to zero. And so it's basically what's going to happen with dates, but we have so much time that's going to be fixed. So it's not a big problem.

Yeah, the 2038 problem specifically is in Unix, the way it calculates time is instead of a hard time stamp where it says like the year like 2021, it will count the number of seconds from January 1st, 1970, and that's how we'll store the date. We'll store a date as just the number of seconds since that period. And this is basically done because time is very sensitive for a lot of types of data. So, you know, if you store dates in like strings that way, and you have time zones, and you're trying to like share data between like two computers in like LA and New York, and the time zones are like different, that can really fuck things up.

Yeah, think of like, yeah, like train times, for example, or flights.

Yeah, so what they want to do is, okay, fuck that. We're not going to deal with like saying what time zone it is. We're just going to count the number of seconds from this period, and that's going to denote the time. But, you know, as Pam said, in the year 2038, we're going to roll over. So a 32-bit integer can only count up to a certain number. And then after that, it's going to roll over. But I think that's not going to be a serious problem because we have like 64-bit operating systems now.

Yeah.

And like those kinds of computers just aren't going to be used as much anymore by the year 2038. Plus, we also have like a decent amount of time left. So hopefully we'll fix it.

COBOL and machine code

Yeah.

If anything, they kind of briefly mentioned it in the documentary, but a more interesting point is that a lot of really old software, like for banks or the government and stuff, a lot of the base code is written in coding languages that no one uses anymore. So they had to, they say it, they had to get some people out of retirement because they were the only ones who knew how to code like COBOL and stuff. So I actually, you'll see on Reddit sometimes people being like, oh, you should learn this because they'll pay you so much money to do it, to code in it, even though it's so boring.

It's basically like one step above machine code. So machine code is literally like you tell the computer to like access this, you know, location in memory and do whatever manipulation or move it or whatever. You're literally moving like the memory itself.

Back in the 70s, would they have been writing in machine code itself or were they already using modern languages literally? Wow, okay.

Yeah, sometimes, yeah. It was so optimized to do that.

So fun fact, Roller Coaster Tycoon is actually written in assembly, which is machine code. So it's so optimized you could get it to run on so many different machines.

It's like if you were like a god building an animal and instead of you know looking at like an existing creature and modifying it to something new, you just had to go completely from the cellular level.

Yeah, like code now today is so abstracted, you don't have to worry about that because there's so many other ways we've optimized it. You don't have to concern yourself with it.

Yeah.

Why Y2K mattered

So, you know, by the year 2000, like computers and the internet weren't like in our face just yet, but they were fully integrated into the global financial system. So like in finance, you had like millions of transactions and money exchanges happening each day between all these businesses and banks and like financial institutions. And you need to have like an accurate time stamp for each one of them because the order that these transactions happen like matters a lot because you know like some people need to be paid before others. So in a situation where you have say three different systems telling each other. One says the year is 2000. Another says the year is 1900. Another says the year is just zero, that messes up everything. And because you know, we live in a capitalist country where like everything is done through commerce, through transactions that rely on this interconnected global information network.

If that network serves as the backbone society breaks down, everything else will eventually break down.

Of course.

So yeah, that is what the real scare of Y2K was: that these financial institutions would break.

Yeah.

They were the nukes.

The early 2000s internet

Let's talk about the previous decade, you know, the early 2000s, the era of AOL, MSN Messenger, you know, early gaming forums, like Something Awful, 4chan, that era. What are your memories of that era?

Oh, yeah, that was like for me as a 12-year-old, exploring new ground. I was so quickly interacting with so many different people, learning about so many different, you know, just things, both good and bad. I remember like every day just posting on forums, I would just learn some new aspect of like online arcana that today we totally take for granted. Like, what is slash fiction? Who is this particular band from the 70s? Why do I have to download WinRAR? Stuff like that.

Yeah, I was pretty online as a kid. And so, like, I remember a lot of dumb memes and websites and stuff.

Yeah.

When being online wasn't cool

What this documentary doesn't do though is like, and like I see Gen Z people not understanding this is just because you could go online doesn't mean it was like you said normal to be very online. And I remember when I was a kid, I knew like all these dumb internet memes and stuff. It was not cool to admit that you like went online a lot. Like people only really went online to check email or maybe go on Facebook or MySpace or something, but or to like go on iTunes. But to be like, yeah, I just got this meme from like 4chan or Something Awful or something. People would make fun of you. But like today, kids are so online that it's weird to not be online. But yeah, like they kind of act like YouTube. Yeah, it was like this big deal and like everyone was into YouTube, but no one was really fully plugged in until like the mid-2010s, I would say.

It was still a very nerdy thing to be into computers and going online, even in the 2000s.

Well, I think that right there is the biggest divide between like my group and your group and like the actual Gen Z people. The fact that like when I was in middle school, I spent more time on the computer than other kids. But like the amount of time I spent online in 2008 is, I think, like average for someone born in 2000.

Yeah.

I mean, also at the time, it was just like you had to physically be at a computer. You couldn't go on your phone.

That's true. No, yes.

Even though like iPhones, like Twitter and Tumblr apps and all that weren't really functional until like 2013.

Yeah. Yes.

No, I remember in when I was in high school, there was this one dude who was like this weird nerd, but he was the first person anybody knew who had a phone that could really use the internet in like 2010.

Yeah.

So this one, this nerdy dude, suddenly became like the coolest guy in my high school because people could like go on Facebook or whatever on his phone in 2010.

Yeah, it's kind of funny when, like, I don't really when I was a kid, I'd read a lot of fanfiction. That was like a very also, I feel like, quintessential, nerdy, online girl thing to do. But, I could tell, like, sometimes when I do read fan fiction, I can tell when it's written by a Zoomer. Because, say, if it's like something that's set in the 90s or like 2000s, they'll be like, oh, you went on your phone and looked up this or blah, blah, blah. And like, they don't understand you couldn't do that on phones yet. Even though, like, maybe they could connect to online, you would waste so much data. You get charged so much.

A different online world

It's funny because, like, these changes do happen quite incrementally, especially changes across the 2010s. But looking back, like, we are in a completely different online world than we used to be. I know that Kate Wagner, the McMansion Hell girl, has written a fair amount about this. Websites themselves are just a lot less prominent than they used to be. There's just been this totally unprecedented consolidation into specific social media platforms, which always have an app component, like Reddit, you know, like Twitter. And that the idea of like a nerdy kid on the computer is kind of disappearing because it's just the internet has become ubiquitous and it's become so personalized and portableized.

Yeah, it used to be where you couldn't be online in your bed trying to fall asleep. You have to get up and go to your computer.

Exactly. And I think that because the internet is so ubiquitous now and because it's also so individualized, there really is no more online culture per se. It used to be that if you were someone who used the internet in the early 2010s, you were part of this culturally specific group.

Yeah.

And I think that group is essentially dissolved. Like the old, you know, Something Awful people or the 4chan crowd.

Oh, yeah, like 4chan. Yeah, they'd freak out when like the news talked about them, but now it's like...

Twitter is like a distinct community still. To some extent, Reddit still is like has like certain stereotypes about it, but I don't think that specific community cultures really exist in the same way.

Yeah, it doesn't feel secret, it doesn't feel like a secret society.

That's totally it, yeah, yeah. Now, using a computer in 2011, you felt like you know, like you were the kids in the chess club who, like, even sure, you might not be that cool outside, but here it's just you, and you could, like, talk shit about the jocks. That's what it was like on, like, a forum.

That's why I think fandom Tumblr kind of understood this subconsciously. They'd, you know, be like, oh, logging onto Tumblr, it's like going to Hogwarts or something, you know, like you left your muggle life.

Oh, God.

Oh, God.

Remember those posts about, yeah, God. Remember the ones that were like, oh, I want to go to Tumblr University where this is the uniform?

Yeah, but now it's like kids today, their social life is so intertwined with online that it's like not even such a separate life to them that it just is.

The network effect

Yeah, okay, so I want to talk about that specifically. The fact that a separate life in sociology, well, sociology and economics, there's this thing called the network effect or like the opposite, which is the no network effect. Like if we look at how people communicated and coordinated in the early days of the internet and like cell phones and smartphones and shit, it had like very little effect, like you say, because you know you were like the oddball out. If you were online at that time, you were on your own. Obviously, you could go online and like go on Tumblr or go on a message board and like communicate with like basically anybody anywhere. It didn't really have any effect on your real life, like your offline life, because like no one you knew in school was using it, or like, nobody you knew at work, or whatever.

Yeah.

But as more people get connected and start using this network, like, social relations begin to change. Like a very simple example is how people like used to make plans before cell phones, right? Like, you'd say, I'll meet you at this place at this time, and we'll do this thing.

I cannot even comprehend that.

And now that people have cell phones, like people say, okay, I'll message you when I'm off work or something, right?

Oh, yeah.

Something I think of it all the time is like in the 70s, if you were gonna meet somebody and they don't show up, you just have to like assume they're dead, I guess. Like, what do you do?

Well, you go to a payphone.

You go to a payphone. It's just, it's crazy to me. Like, you can call them up at home and they might not be at home. Like, you know, they might be like lost on the way.

Yeah, you have to call around.

A big thing I've thought, yeah. Well, you know, actually, something I've thought about a little bit is the fact that, obviously, in certain, by a lot of parameters, life in the US is worse than it was a few decades ago. But in some other ways, like crime, it's a lot safer. And I have wondered if, like, increased communications technology has prevented people from getting murdered. If it's, you know, easier to call a ride home, if you're like, you know, it's easier to find out, like, maybe what areas are especially dangerous. If you can look up if the guy you're going on a date with has a criminal record. If you can just say, hey, message me when you get home.

Yeah.

And then you don't get a message when they get home. Like, you can immediately assume something happened and call the cops.

Yeah.

Or just as a deterrence, the fact that if you're going to mug someone or if you're a serial killer and you want to tie them up and stab them, they have a device in their pocket that can immediately record your identity and sends a distress signal.

You know, the reason like scheduling changed is because, you know, this is the network effect that I'm trying to say is, you know, because we can contact each other at any time. Things like that are basically completely changed, you know. And it's like somewhat insidious that this happened. Because obviously, you, Liam, you say, like, there are some good ways, but there's also some bad ways. Is that now this network, the internet, has completely integrated itself into society and we've become dependent on it. So just to give another example, in the early days of Facebook, you could like easily just make the choice to not have a Facebook account. Because like very few people I know are on it. It doesn't provide like any real utility because of that. So I'm just not going to use it. But if all my friends and family get on Facebook and it starts to become their main way of communicating with each other, my decision is no longer, do I want to have a Facebook account?

My decision is, do I want to communicate with my friends and family? And it's the same with like smartphones and the internet more broadly. 15 years ago was do I want a smartphone? Do I want to be online? Now it's do I want to participate in society?

Yeah, it's it's compulsive now.

Marketing and data

One thing that kind of annoyed me with the documentary is that they never really discuss how much marketing affects our online use. So they like they say the thing how in like the 90s and 2000s people are like oh stranger danger like don't put so much information about yourself online and now it's like total opposite people are just so open online but I mean a lot of that cultural shift is because marketers you know marketing companies they want to you know collect all this data about you know how people use their websites or whatever what ads they click on what they search whatever who they follow and that affects ad agencies they buy that information to then change how they advertise things and it's you know, obviously, then there's an incentive to make people overshare and want to keep being engaged with online and and interact and use it.

So, you know, I feel like it's also kind of interesting how they bring up Napster and how like musicians were arguing, like, well, who gets to own music and distribute it and blah, blah, blah. But, you know, one big issue that you kind of see coming up now, but not a lot of people talk about, is who, you know, why is it that a company can make all this money off of my data and, you know, what I post online, but it's something that's mine. And I don't get to say, like, you don't get to make money off of this or where's my share or whatever. It's just there's so much money to be made off of online. And that's what makes us so absorbed into it because people want us to be online and make money off of that.

The thing you're talking about is online advertising or like data brokers or even just like the mechanics of how a social media company works, like how Facebook works. They don't really touch on that in this documentary. And I guess it's because like the documentary just wants to have an overall positive view of the internet. And that's like a very negative view.

Yeah, it has no like ideology to it.

Yeah.

Yeah, it's like they even mention fake news, but it's like a single sentence. That's it.

Even that is like too much negativity.

iPods and iTunes

But yeah, I mean, do any of you guys have iPods? Because I never actually owned an iPod.

Oh, yeah. Oh, I don't know.

One of my most traumatic memories as a kid was when I went, when I took my iPod, which was mostly loaded with movies, onto a water ride at Disney World, and it was completely ruined forever.

Oh my god.

Come on, Liam. What did you think was going to happen?

When I was 11, I would only buy songs that I knew. So my iPod was like individual songs from like Harry Potter soundtracks that I thought were cool, and then individual songs I knew from Rock Band.

Oh, that's great. I mean, that is basically how you're supposed to use them. You know, obviously, the record labels got furious at the existence of people being able to get music off the internet. So, the compromise was they partnered with Apple with iTunes, and it was like, you can just buy a song for a dollar because that's really what people are fed up with. You know, like an album costs 15 bucks, and you might have only just liked two songs of the album.

Oh, yeah, that was the worst.

Oh, yeah, and then if you bought singles too, they'd have all those remixes and then make it expensive still to just buy the single.

The music industry

I saw this in the documentary too, is at a certain point, like half of CDs in like the world, I think, like had an AOL logo on them, and they were just giving that shit out for free. They were just like mailing free CDs to everybody.

I'm just give you an example of how extremely cheap a CD was to manufacture. Like, a single CD cost the record labels, like, I don't know, maybe like 50 cents to manufacture, but they were charging like 15 bucks for each of them.

Yeah, that's why people are just like, fuck this shit. I'm just gonna download the song I like for free off the internet.

One of the guys in the documentary talks about how before the internet, you need to get a record label to sign you to like get your music out there. Like, you couldn't just pull up onto a record store with like a stack of CDs and say, Hey, can you sell these for me?

There were no SoundCloud rappers.

Now, you can just upload your music and share it with anybody online like immediately. Whereas before, you had to go to the record label and they would go to the record stores and they would go to the radio stations. And you know, if the record labels weren't like into you, that's it.

Yeah, no, no, absolutely.

But yeah, I mean, I never owned an iPod, so I never really you were like listening to CD players like Shinji Ikari.

MP3 players and Zunes

No, I was I got the very cheapest MP3 player they go to the store.

Oh, wow!

Wow, yeah, you didn't have a Zune.

Oh, I did have a Zune. I got a Zune when they were like... So, Zunes were like $250 or something, like the same price as iPods. Microsoft gave up on them and just like slashed the price, so I got one for $100, and that is when I got like a real MP3 player for the first time. So yeah, I got the Bargain Bin MP3 player. It could only fit like maybe 20 songs in total, but you know, that was enough.

I remember I got this pretty nice speaker for my birthday when I was like 14 that I could plug my iPod into, but it didn't have an aux cable, which meant that no aux port at all, which meant that as soon as the technology evolved a little bit, not even to move away from ports, but just to change the port, it was totally unusable.

Finding music before streaming

I remember when the iPod and Zune and all that was coming out. I remember talking to my sister about it being like, oh, it's so stupid. Like I'm never going to get one, blah, blah, blah. And then a few years later, I got one, obviously, because it's so much more convenient. You had to have huge books to like keep your CDs in to carry them around. But I do kind of miss, I feel like there was a sweet spot where with iPods and everything before streaming, just at least having to find music online. And like this, like there used to be so many music communities online because you could just go on Spotify and search whatever. Yeah, you had to actually like at least, if it was a more underground artist, you had to find on certain websites where you could actually like download it or share it.

It was just a lot more like intimate to find music. And like when you did find something good, it felt so much more rewarding. It was just more exciting. And that's just one thing I don't like about streaming is that the like instant gratification and like the library itself feeling so overwhelming. It's almost as if like it's like when you're scrolling through cable and it's like there's so many channels that you don't know what to watch. I feel like that's what Spotify and everything is now, where like there's so much music now at our hands, at the tips of our hands that it's like that's it's not fun anymore to really discover music.

Last.fm

Yeah, absolutely. I mean, my way, I would go on Last.fm.

Oh, I loved Last.fm.

Well, it's great.

Well, no, I still, you know, this is embarrassing here, but I still do. I only use listen to music if I know I can scrobble it because I like knowing what I'm listening to.

Yeah, that was the fun feature about iTunes too.

Last.fm was basically like a social network for like music fans. So they had a lot of, you know, groups, which, you know, like basically discussion boards. And also, if you clicked on somebody's profile, it would show you like what they last listened to. But yeah, that was like how I found music. Is you know, if I see somebody like on there has like similar music tastes to me, I would just like scroll through like the music they listen to and then like try to find like a torrent for like that album and like listen to that.

Yeah, I had my Last.fm scrobble thing embedded in my LiveJournal profile. That was the cool thing to do.

The DIY web

Yeah, I just remember like 2000s and early 2010s internet. It just it had a little bit more of like a DIY feel to it. Like having to actually maybe code up a little bit of your profile on MySpace or something.

And I feel like Tumblr too. Yeah, and I think that's part of what makes TikTok click with a lot of people is that like you can really play around with how you edit your videos. And it's like for people who don't know how to do that with like regular software. Because compared to Instagram and stuff, like there are filters and everything, but it's pretty cut and dry with like you just post something. There's no real like customization. Like, that was one thing that always bothered me about the transition from MySpace to Facebook was that Facebook, you can't have a custom layout or profile song or anything. And, like, people definitely miss the over-customization. Like, people are so excited to customize stuff when online was first becoming a thing that I feel like the internet started to lose that a little bit.

DeviantArt

Speaking of online communities, the first online community I used to be in was DeviantArt. And if you don't know what DeviantArt is, so like Pam said, in the early 2000s, basically, any program, any app on your computer probably was able to be skinned. Like, I remember Winamp was like a big thing. Like, you could skin when you could just completely customize the look. And DeviantArt was started as a website for people to share their custom skins. And then eventually it became like this big thing, just like a general website for all kinds of artists. But, you know, the core community at the beginning of it was just people who wanted who liked customizing like Winamp or Windows Media Player and shit.

Forums and chat rooms

It was also, this is a period in time where basically every major website had a forum and a chat room. I was searching just stuff on CNN from like the year of 2001. And at that time, CNN also had a discussion board. And also like BBC, like all those like news websites. Basically every website had a discussion board and a chat room up until 2005, I guess.

Oh yeah, I loved looking lurking the forums of you know different bands that I listened to or like sometimes bands wouldn't even have an official forum so people would make like the unofficial fan forum and then like there are definitely the few forums that I'd lurk and like because I was too scared to post until I turned like, I don't know, I used to not really post until I turned like 20. I was just too scared to go online and post things really besides just like on Twitter with friends. But yeah, it's like I was reading this one Vice article how, like, there's so much just random online community like forum drama that's just lost to time because you know these websites are gone and it's communities online used to be maybe just like 20 people not like a whole like Twitter, like it's so big, it's such a you know huge web where you can say maybe left Twitter, but then like it really branches out into other parts of Twitter and it's you know, but to be on a forum where you can see the roster of you know who's actually online or who registered, it's pretty clear like who you're actually interacting with.

Lost archives

I said I was reading CNN 2001. The reason I was doing that is I was curious what people were saying about 9-11 as it happened. And a lot of it is archived on the web archive, but obviously like that part of CNN, they just got rid of that shit. They just threw that all away. So it's like you had this discussion board where like all these people were talking about like these major breaking events as they're happening. And they also had like this chat room where people discussing it, but there's no log of that. Like they just completely got rid of it.

Forum kids, bloggers and commenters

And I think that news article comment sections are really kind of a missing link for Twitter because they were this massive, you know, whole series of anonymous arenas where you could talk about whatever. And I really like was involved in that, but I would bet that a lot of like boomer conservatives who post on Twitter, I bet the more like internet savvy of them 10 years ago, 15 years ago were posting in like the CNN comments or whatever.

Yeah, a lot of older like Gen X types on like lib or even Left Twitter were frequent posters of the AV Club comments like 10 years ago.

You know, I've never thought about this, but no, I totally believe you. And but that makes me realize is that there are roughly three types of like, you know, veterans or whatever. There's the forum kids, which are especially big among like the kind of older millennial lefty Twitter comedy crowd, you know, like the Something Awful people. Then there are the bloggers who they now basically are the media class, people like Joy Reid, who have in many cases gotten really risen to substantial heights. And then there are the commenters, like you said, the people in the AV Club comments, the people who were and are still calling each other fuck nuggets and stuff like that.

You know who was a former forum poster in the early 2000s? A big forum guy, I believe Keith Ellison. And he got in trouble because it turned out that he was apparently posting on a forum where, like, I think Farrakhan himself was also a member or something.

Yeah, so many people I know from the internet are former goons or just like former 4chan people.

Of course. What does the DSA stand for?

Democrats of Something Awful.

Interesting.

Reddit and the death of forums

Yeah, it's weird how the closest thing to forum culture now is Reddit, which sucks because a lot of subreddits suck. And it's not the same as like, I mean, you could look up a band on Reddit and post on their subreddit or whatever, but it's not the same as like a forum or.

Well, I think that Reddit is probably a better site than it was 10 years ago.

Absolutely.

Because it's gotten so large. But the problem is that Reddit's growth has been entirely at the expense of like any other online community.

Yeah.

Like I was a really big forum guy when I was a kid. When I was in middle school in high school, I was really into that shit. But then, really, by the end of high school, which was also when I first got on Twitter just to lurk, that was already dying. By like 2013, most forums I posted on were much smaller than they used to be. And people that I knew from forums were now just on Tumblr or Twitter.

Yeah, that was the same for me as I mean, there were like a couple of big ones, like 4chan stayed big and kept getting bigger, but all these small gaming forums, basically they just went away because the real thing was, is these were like just amateur like run forums. Like it was just some guy who decided to like buy some server space and just every single forum had was run just by some dipshit. Some guy with a little bit of money who had no idea what he was doing. It was always like a 29 year old white dude who everybody hated, but you could never talk shit about him because he would just ban you.

Yeah, I mean that was literally 4chan.

Yeah, really what happened is eventually these forums die and the community remaining that kind of wants to like stick around, what they do is just say, let's just make something immediately. What can we make immediately? We can make a Facebook group or we can make like a subreddit or something.

Yeah, yeah.

Basically whenever a forum died, the community would run over to Reddit or Facebook or something like that. You know, eventually enough forums died that people weren't going to forums first. Like that wasn't their first experience.

That's true.

I guess an analog to that is that the three of us first met in what was essentially like a forum. And we don't interact on that specific area anymore on that platform, but we've kept in touch through Twitter.

Discord and satellites

You know, like chat rooms and amateur forums are basically gone. But yeah, like Slack, Discord, subreddits, they're basically the modern equivalent.

That's true. And yeah, I know a fair amount of guys a little bit younger than me who are in like 27 active Discord chats.

Yeah, the thing is, so people don't really realize this, but every small forum kind of had a similar culture to like a big forum that it was like a satellite of. So like a lot of gaming forums, they kind of had a very similar culture with Something Awful or a very similar culture to 4chan.

Yeah.

Most people posting on that small forum also posted on that big forum.

Slower posting

Yeah.

That reminds me of something else I think about a lot. Is I don't think Zoomers realize how much slower the rate of posting used to be on the internet years ago. Like, because you could be on Twitter all day and there's so much going on, but back in the day to go on a forum, like you would maybe check it for 20 minutes or something.

Yes.

Then go do something else and then check it again later to see who posted.

When you were in an argument in 2011, you would post your angry ass all caps post and then wait 25 minutes refreshing until the other person makes a reply.

Yeah, it would last days. The internet was like fixed to your computer at your desk and also even like late in 2000s. A lot of people had like dial-up modems so they couldn't like be on it constantly or just you know it's like a family computer.

Yeah or it was only at work or school.

Yeah.

Notifications

But really, really, what we're talking about is the fact that phones have notifications. So you just get an instant notification as soon as somebody replies to you.

Yeah.

Yeah.

Which I didn't exist before. Pam, you were saying how like social media companies were kind of trying to make us addicted to them. Like that is one way they do it. They just like spam you with notifications and just say, hey, somebody replied to your post.

Oh, yeah.

Or they'll just like they'll give you notifications for really dumb things, like, oh, you haven't got on in a while. Or, like, I hate how Instagram you can turn off where they won't send you notifications about someone going live, but when you're in the app, you can't turn off those notifications telling you someone went live. So, sometimes I'll be scrolling through Instagram and then I'll be clicking something like to view someone's story, but that's also where the notification shows up, and I'll accidentally tap that and go to someone's live, and it's like tricking you into clicking it.

Yeah, for me, it's like technically in Instagram, you can just turn off specific notifications. I don't want notifications about somebody liking my post or commenting or anything. I just want a notification if somebody messages me. So, that's the only one I have on. But in reality, is like I'm not gonna get any notifications at all. Like, I have to either turn them all on or turn them all off.

Oh, yeah.

Oh, what I hate is the little badge with the number. Like, Twitter, you can turn off notifications or like mute a DM or something, but it'll show still show up the little badge on the little envelope icon in the corner. So, like, you still compulsively want to go clear it and you click it to go clear it, and it gets you to stay on the app longer.

Twitter

I mean, like, Twitter is like a bad example because I'm pretty sure they're not making the app shitty on purpose. Like, I think they're just clueless, honestly.

I really think that Jack Dorsey believes he is part of some world-historic mission to connect, you know, the entire planet, but he just has no idea how to do it at all. Twitter is in an especially weird position because I would argue that basically every year, Twitter becomes more essential to global politics, communication, yeah, and economy than it ever has been before. But even as this is happening, the actual user base is shrinking, which I think is really interesting and kind of funny to think about.

Yeah, it's so weird to think about what like confidential information has gone on in Instagram DMs because journalists will use it to network and stuff or politicians. I mean, I assume like some smart ones are like, hey, let's move this conversation over to Signal, but plenty of them are just like, just get confidential documents like DM'd to them as a JPEG over Twitter.

Yeah.

Cyborgs

A thing I hear people in tech say a lot is that, you know, like technology has turned us into cyborgs, or specifically smartphones have turned us into cyborgs. You know, a cyborg in science fiction is like a person that's augmented with technology to boost human capability. Common thing is just like boost the brain, like boost cognitive abilities with like a neural implant, right? You know, it being science fiction, that's like a physical thing, like a physical thing in your brain. Like you look like the Borg from Star Trek. And that implant allows you to like pull up any kind of information like at will or like communicate with any other cyborg just like instantly. You know, obviously in real life, it doesn't look exactly like that, but it is like that. You know, we don't look like the Borg from Star Trek, but we do have smartphones in our physical person at all times with all those capabilities.

Like at a moment's notice, we can pull up any information from Google anytime. You know, we can like message anybody or like call anybody anywhere in the world at any time. Like our phones aren't like literally physically integrated into our bodies, but they might as well be at this point, right?

Yeah.

If you haven't seen Star Trek, the Borg, they're like physically dependent on those neural implants. And we are basically like that at this point.

Smartphones and memory

You know, there's been a bunch of like studies about this. Like, there's a University of Chicago one that gets passed around a lot online that I've seen. Basically, it says prolonged smartphone use reshapes our cognitive pathways to the point that we're reliant on smartphones. The fact that we have any information easily accessible at a moment's notice through the internet means we memorize a lot less than we would have like in previous generations.

Oh, yeah.

So, here's a simple test for like you two and whoever's listening: is don't look down, just look straight and just think, What are you wearing right now? Just like picture it, like picture it in as much detail as you can. Like, what are you wearing right now?

My current outfit.

If you have, like, if you had to draw it, could you like draw it in detail? Like, right now, I'm wearing like a like flannel.

Yeah.

And you know, like, I can picture in my head, but like, if I had to, like, list every single color in the flannel or like draw the exact pattern, maybe get close, but like, I could not do it fully, right?

Yeah.

I'm wearing some t-shirt with, like, a pattern in the back, and I just no chance. Like, I don't even know what it is. I couldn't tell you. I've worn this shirt hundreds of times, but like, I've barely commit any of the detail to memory. I was like, why is that? It's because, like, I don't need to, right? This information is always available to me. Like, I can always just look down and look at the shirt and know what it says, right? This is basically what having the internet does to everything. You know, like, on a subconscious level, we understand that because this information is going to be easily accessible to us at a moment's notice, we don't commit it to memory. We don't memorize things that we don't have to. The University of Chicago study basically lists the point says, like, smartphones affect memory recall. They impair the ability to learn new information, and they reduce cognitive capacity by being a distraction.

Like, if your phone's near you at all times, it becomes a distraction, so you're just like always concentrating less on what you're supposed to be doing just because you have your phone present. So, yeah, like scientifically proven that smartphones and specifically the internet access aspect of smartphones is making us dumber.

ChaCha and Google 411

Yeah, well, who remembers phone numbers anymore?

Oh, absolutely, yeah.

Remember, did you guys use Cha-Cha where you'd have to like text Cha-Cha or Google your question instead of having to go online on your phone?

I have no idea what that is.

There was another one that you could text.

Yeah, like before you could really go online on your phone and say go on Wikipedia or something, if you were like, oh, well, like, what year, like, who won the World Series 1984? You text Cha-Cha or Google and they tell you an answer instead of like it was 242-242.

Now I remember, yeah.

Yeah.

I remember people in my like high school would cheat on exams by texting a question to Cha-Cha for like two dollars.

Oh, it charged you?

Oh, it was two fucking bucks.

I thought it was like standard text rates for Google.

No, it's a paid service.

Yeah. It's maybe there's a different one, but I remember the number. It was like 242, 242 or something like that.

Maybe they were getting fleeced by a different company.

Yeah, I remember Google 411.

I'm Feeling Lucky

Now, here's a question. This is kind of a general internet question. I don't know if this is still a feature, but it's something that has perplexed me since I was a very small child. What's going on with I'm Feeling Lucky?

Oh, that was a thing where it would just link you to the very first result.

The first, right? Why would they do that? What's the what's I guess they still have it?

This was back from like the I guess early dial-up days where basically, every single page load, even just like loading the Google search results, would take like 30 seconds minimum.

Oh, yeah, it took forever.

Oh, okay.

So, if you just knew you just wanted the first result, just click I'm Feeling lucky and just direct you to that.

Okay, interesting. And they, yeah, that it's surprising they still keep that up. I wonder what the rationale is. Like, people who still have dial-up?

It's probably just a nerdy legacy thing.

Yeah, yeah.

For a long time, just clicking I'm Feeling Lucky just directed you to Wikipedia article for that thing. So, that's kind of why I always used it.

Old software

It is based on how many people are still using just incredibly old software and hardware, especially people, you know, in rural areas or whatever. I used to work, I had like a really basic IT job where I would do a lot of password resetting, and sometimes I would have to use Citrix to go onto their desktop. And so many people, either the software wouldn't work at all because their system was too old, or they'd be using like Windows XP in 2016.

Oh, yeah.

Offices can be the worst with that. There's like stories of really old database exploits that were patched in, like, say, the late 90s or early 2000s coming back because of these random companies that still never updated their databases.

God, that's hilarious.

Yeah.

Security weak spots

So, there's a question. So, we've talked a little bit about, you know, 2038. Now, we talked about these exploits. What do you guys think? Because you two both know quite a bit more about the computer than I do. What do you think are like the big weak spots in internet security or not even security so much? What are the possible things that can go wrong? What do you think is on the horizon?

You know, there was like the Stuxnet virus a few years back, which was like a very...

Okay, and you know, like, I'm very anti-Stuxnet, but I gotta say, like, Iran, they kind of caught you lacking. Like, well, why would you let your nuclear technology be connected to a global database like that?

Yeah, I mean, that was like a very specially crafted piece of technology. Take that out.

For anybody who doesn't know, it was a computer virus that was likely developed by Israel and the United States to take out the nuclear reactors in Iran.

I believe it was used for nuclear energy, right?

There was really no indication at all that there was any interest.

Yeah, yeah.

Can you even use nuclear reactors to build bombs? How would you do that?

I'm not sure on the science in that aspect. I don't think so, though.

Maybe that, like, the uranium runoff from a nuclear power plant can be used to manufacture nuclear weapons, but I don't think that's really how they're made.

Ransomware

Those kinds of viruses that just attack very specific targets. Like, most recently, a lot of hospitals are hit with like ransomware, and you know, you have to like pay this hacker, you know, this amount of Bitcoin, and they will unlock the server for you. And obviously, these are like critical systems, like medical records. That kind of attack is very common and also like very problematic.

Leaks and privacy

I just worry that there's gonna be this huge leak or like exploit or like honeypot type app where like people just collect a bunch of nudes from you know regular women. That's something too, like 10 years ago or whatever, there wasn't really like a thing where you'd send nudes to people. And I don't know, I just worry that there's like we kind of had that with celebrities getting their iCloud hacked and you know, their nudes leaked and stuff. But I just worry about how much like it's common now where people get their Snapchat or whatever Instagram hacked because people are trying to find if there's nudes on the account and then they'll like, you know, maybe like blackmail you or something. But I don't know. That's something I worry about.

That's why I'm surprised that like people do use Snapchat for porn. Because isn't that just like incredibly common to happen?

Yeah, I don't think people realize like how insecure it is to host whatever data or content you want on these other sites. And even if you say delete it off the app on your phone, who knows when it's ever deleted off their servers or like what's the real legality of them owning it? I know there's a huge controversy because Snapchat, like the owners and developers and stuff, they'll go through what's getting sent and they'll like see nudes and stuff and be like, oh, like this chick's hot or whatever. Because basically by using the app, you agree that they can use your content with whatever, you know, however they want to do it. So there's no real security.

Yes, isn't that the lesson that Chris D'Elia learned in a roundabout way?

Oh, yeah.

Encryption

I should probably explain why this works.

Sure.

There are end-to-end encrypted messaging services like WhatsApp or Signal. And what that means is it's encrypted both ends. So you send a message and then it's encrypted and then that stays encrypted on like WhatsApp servers. And then it's sent to the other person and then it's decrypted on their phone. So only those two phones can see that message. The downside of that is that, you know, if you just get like a new phone, you lose all your chat history basically. And there's like ways around that. Like WhatsApp has cloud saving. But, you know, that's why stuff like Twitter or Facebook or Instagram or whatever aren't end-to-end encrypted because they want you to be able to just like open up Chrome on your laptop, like sign into Instagram and see all your Instagram messages like easily. That's the thing with encrypted messengers: they're locked to a very specific phone.

So they're less convenient. And really, most people just want that convenience of being able to just look up their messages from like any device at any time.

Yeah.

So that's why they're not encrypted. But that also means that if somebody manages to figure out your password for like Instagram, they can just open up Chrome on their laptop, log into Instagram, and see all your messages, just like that.

Yeah.

Deleting your data

That also pisses me off that in the US we don't really have anything like a GDPR where if now in Europe it's pretty recent it's been out for a few years but they passed a law where like if you're deleting an account off a social media site and you want like them to totally wipe your records from their servers they have to do that if you if you select that so we don't really have anything like that in the US where if you delete your account from say Instagram they still can host all your data on their servers for indefinitely yeah and they also have like backups just like stored on the shelf somewhere yeah and they don't want to like take those backups off the shelf and like delete everything yeah that was an issue when i was in tech yeah yeah i i have no idea how this happens but one you know one issue now is that old image links get repurposed to different images and so there's been cases of recently cases of of porn appearing as embedded videos on random sites that didn't intend it to be oh that the vid.me thing that was like a recent story yeah it's hilarious this i can explain so you know on reddit there's a website called Imgur so if you want to just like host an image very quickly just upload on Imgur and like link it on reddit or like any other forum right somebody made a video version of that called vid.me.

And it was, yeah, basically just like a video version of Imgur. And it was very expensive. And the person just like shut it down. But like a few years later, somebody just bought that domain name. And then every single video that was embedded all over the internet for vid.me, basically in like old news articles, old forum posts, old Reddit posts, whatever, just was redirecting to this like new website. And the new website was a porn website. So you just had porn all over these old news articles that were embedding this video. And that's why people tend to prefer using big services that they know won't just go away like a few years from now.

Oh, yeah.

Who hosts the internet

A lot of websites actually use Amazon web services to host a lot of their media that you're uploading. So it's not even like they're hosting it directly. So that's another partner now or party getting involved with like who owns this data.

We know Amazon's great, so people don't realize this. Like Amazon, a third of the internet is run by Amazon. I think the second biggest one is like Microsoft and the third one is Google. I don't remember if it's still the case, but Snapchat is hosted on Google servers. So, you know, everything on Snapchat is hosted on Google.

Oh, interesting.

Everything on Tumblr is hosted on Amazon. Everything on Reddit is hosted on Amazon as well.

Yeah.

So yeah, think about that. Like even a third or fourth biggest social media app isn't even like hosting its own stuff.

It has to rely on a third party.

Snapchat's beach house

No, I think that Snapchat is just one of the funniest companies because like they're just still so huge, but it really is the last of the classic like guys in their garage kind of success story. Like I remember when Snapchat first blew up, their headquarters, what I think they still own, was a house. They had a house on the beach in LA, and that was their entire base of operations. And this was when they were already like a billion-plus valued company.

A lot of their offices were just condos in LA. And what they would do is they would keep the beds in the bedrooms because it wasn't zoned to be an office, it was zoned to be like a residential building.

So, if that's hilarious, they had to legally, yeah, it has to look like somebody's sleeping here. It can't look like you just turned this place into an office, yeah.

Online dating

Yeah, yeah, yeah. That's the huge thing. Basically, so many people's lives have just been completely transformed by online dating. Like, as we all know, like, I think I'm pretty sure an outright majority of couples now say they met online to some extent.

Yeah.

In this documentary, they interviewed the match.com guy who like started match.com in like I think the 90s, early 2000s.

Right, right, that was hilarious saying that he couldn't get a date just by using the local newspaper classifieds. So, he thought, what if I could link all of the newspaper classifieds onto one website?

Very few people bother with newspaper classifieds, and as few people also bother with like online dating back then. And it didn't really get big until Tinder in like 2012. The co-founder of Tinder is also in the documentary.

Yeah.

And he says he made Tinder because he had a lot of trouble meeting new people after he graduated from college, which is like a very common thing, obviously. After graduating college, it's pretty hard to make new friends, especially if you have to like move to a new city. So, Tinder comes out in 2012. And at that point, a lot of people have owned smartphones for like several years or just graduating college. And at that point, the internet killed a lot of places where people would just go to meet somebody.

Yeah.

Like music stores or bookstores, like that kind of thing. Just like hoping to see somebody who's like into the same kind of music they are. Or just like the kind of book that they're into, and just like approach them, you know, say, Hey, what's up?

Blockbuster and bookstores

I read this one article about Blockbuster: how a lot of the charm was that you'd have to go physically, you know, get a movie. And then, if you're like, oh, that movie is pretty good, you'd ask, Oh, what else do you recommend? And then people would just kind of hang out at Blockbuster and meet people that way.

Absolutely. I think that it's kind of like how forums gave way just to Reddit because what happened was that just in the sense that Reddit has so many people, such a fast speed of discussion, and such a wide variety of topics, the big box bookstores, or really the only one, Barnes & Noble, had such a massive selection that you could almost always find what you were looking for, at least for most readers. So, there was no need to go to like the local corner bookstore where you might know the name of the owner, but they would probably only have half of the kind of books you wanted to buy.

I couldn't see that. I mean, obviously, Borders went bankrupt, but that was more like mismanagement than like people buying Kindles, right?

Now that I think about it, it is interesting that Barnes & Noble might be the only company that has essentially no competition in its field. The only competition are the very, very few remaining independent bookstores. There was one I used to go to in Miami that closed, there's another one that is hanging on. But I feel like the only way bookstores hang on today, it's just like music stores. They really hammer home the community aspects. Every record store that still exists today is probably a major center for music in its city because they have events, they're a networking community for like local musicians and all that. And I think it's the same thing for independent bookstores. And I'm just gonna bring this back: any web forum that still exists today only exists because it was really, really able to offer something that Reddit and Twitter and Tumblr could not.

And that's why there are still a few forums left because they have a unique community and they're basically refusing to go along with the trend.

Against dating apps

I think I hate online dating. I think it really, I mean, especially, I guess, my age group with people who grew up relying on it more. I think it just really inhibits people's social skills. Honestly, it really isn't that hard to meet people in real life if you actually know how to talk to people. I mean, look at how many kids now, like, or even adults are like, oh, I'm too scared to, like, pick up the phone and like call delivery or something when, like, before the internet or when a lot of things are automated, that's like unheard of to be like, you're too scared to answer the phone. Like, there's some benefits, I guess. Like, if you're gay or something, it makes it easier to find people because it's harder to find people when you're gay or something. But then, also, like, the flip side to that is then there, you also sometimes have to worry about like fake accounts trying to out people or like just who's a creep online or who's a catfish or who's like whatever.

And then to talk to someone on a screen with texts, like to then meet them in person, it is very jarring and like a big step. So, I think that's why a lot of people, like, they'll go on dating apps, but not necessarily, like, actually pursue anyone. Because it, like, I'll go on dating apps, and sometimes I'm like, okay, like, do I really care about this person to now like designate time in my week to go see them? And then, what if it sucks? Because I don't actually know how they are in real life. And, like, compared to meeting someone organically, you know right off the bat, like, if you vibe with them or not, if there's chemistry. So, I just, I don't know, it sucks because I like watching a lot of 90s movies and stuff. And, and you know, like, you'll hear, like, oh, like, they went to a singles-only event or like whatever.

And I feel like you don't really see that anymore because we're so dependent on Tinder and OkCupid and everything that it's yeah, the culture of being single, it's just so dependent on being online that it sucks, and it's you know, people just don't know how to actually socialize.

Yeah, I think for me, the difficulty is that it's just hard to like start a conversation on a dating app versus just like you're in dating app mode. Whereas, like, if you're just trying to start a conversation, just like a random person, like I don't know, like you're just waiting in line somewhere and just kind of like talk to the person standing next to you to pass the time. It's like very easy, but you know, on like Tinder or Bumble or whatever, it just feels like there's nothing feeding into the conversation, yeah.

It almost feels like a job interview at times because then you'll ask filler questions, like, oh, like, where do you work or like whatever? Like, in the back of your head, you know that they could be talking or probably are talking to like five other people on the app or whatever, you know, like they just have a whole list of people that they're shuffling through. And it's like, like you said, if you met someone in real life, it's like there's more context to it that makes it less awkward.

Gender and the apps

Yeah, I mean, what you just said is like very gender-dependent. You know, the genders are such that men will swipe on anybody, and women will be very picky. So, you end up in a situation where like women will obviously have like maybe five, ten matches they have to like go through, whereas guys will probably only have like one at a time. For women, it makes like going through these messages a chore, you know, like going through work emails, or like yeah, whereas for guys, it's like puts a lot of pressure on them to just be like, Okay, this is my only shot at happiness, I can't fuck this up.

And I think it's also, I think, actually, at the same time, it's almost kind of like a feedback, a weird kind of feedback loop. I think that some guys actually don't put much investment into their messages because they know they're probably not gonna get anything. So, that's why some guys will say really shitty things or at least very like unhelpful, boring comments, which reinforces women who think, oh, like these guys aren't shit. I have to be really selective.

Yeah, online dating makes people like very unhappy because obviously, for women, when you have like that abundance of choice, it just like it feels like a chore and that makes you like unhappy with this experience. Whereas, if you're somebody who gets like no matches, that makes you unhappy because it's like shit, like nobody likes me.

A mostly negative experience

Yeah, I feel like a lot of stuff we've talked about so far is kind of skews positive, but I feel like internet dating is almost mostly negative.

Yeah, like it's positive in the sense that if you're the kind of person that doesn't really go out, if you're only going to go out to a bar to like hang out with friends and you're not interested in meeting strangers, then if you're that kind of person, it's very difficult to meet new people. Like, it's much easier to just meet people through an app. But the experience of trying to meet somebody on an app is as such that you might as well not have the experience at all because it's just so negative.

Yeah, I think it's like a it's this weird thing dilemma where like if you are good at Tinder and like socializing with random people, you don't really need Tinder because you're good at socializing with people in real life. So, like it kind of creates like a weird feedback loop where, like, then the people who aren't good at socializing go on Tinder, but then those are the dry conversations you have because, like, they just don't really have social skills. So, so that also just makes it very awkward. Because if you're like, are just a very outgoing person, like, you don't really need apps to meet people. And also, like, because we were saying earlier that it's there's nothing really there to like spark conversation, that makes it awkward. I think that's also why people joke, like, oh, their favorite dating app is Twitter or something. Because, like, on Twitter, you know, people are talking about whatever.

You see people's personalities more through it. And so, like, I guess that's why people like form crushes or whatever or DM slide. But Tinder, like, it doesn't really foster any reason for you to, like, actually highlight your interests or show your personality or, like, show how you actually like communicate with other people. It's just so sterilized in a way. Like, it is basically like the newspaper ads where you just list attributes about yourself and you hope you get someone interested, but that's not really how things work in real life.

Superficial apps

Yeah, and we haven't even touched on just like how incredibly superficial dating apps make everybody.

Yeah.

I mean, they don't say it, but the whole point of Tinder was for like one-night stands, not really for love, which it's kind of weird how they try to market themselves as like an OkCupid alternative because it really is. It's so bare bones that it's you're picking people based on aesthetics.

Yeah, I feel like that doesn't actually matter so much because there's other dating apps like Bumble is the dating app where like women respond first, and you have like really long profiles you can fill out.

And like Hinge is also the same way.

Hinge and segregation

You have like all these questions and hinge, Hinge is really weird. You know about the whole Friends of Friends thing they use for matching?

No, I haven't, I've never used it.

They I think they say they don't do it this way anymore. But Hinge's whole thing, they really pride themselves on having like the best matches, the most compatible. Like you're not just gonna match with some fuckboy or whatever. The way they did it traditionally, and maybe they still do, is they basically segregate their users effectively by class, race, age, social circle, because it's Facebook linked. And what they used to do was it would be based on friends of friends and friends of friends of friends. Even if you move to a new city, there's a really good chance that you're going to know a lot of people who have a distant connection to somebody else you know. And you'd be much more likely to meet those people or people who know those people, which again, effectively just leads to segregation, which I think was kind of the point.

Interesting.

Tinder and Grindr

You know, Hinge and Bumble basically feel just only slightly less superficial than Tinder.

Yeah.

Tinder is the most hookupy one of them, of the straight ones. Obviously, Grindr is basically just complete hookup.

Oh, yeah.

Fun fact. Tinder is like, if you're a gay man, Tinder is like when you don't want to hook up and you want a serious relationship.

Interesting. Oh, because the Grindr, yeah, of course, that's really funny.

Instagram as a resume

I mean, just to me, like, you say you can get a gauge of somebody's personality through Twitter. All the apps have, you can link your Instagram account or you can, like, Spotify, I guess.

You can.

Yeah, what Drake song they list.

Just interesting that, like, the only thing they will link is just a website where you post more photos for yourself.

Yeah.

Instagram basically is like a resume or LinkedIn for dating. Like, definitely, you can tell when someone curates their Instagram just because they want people they match with on dating apps to see it and be like, oh, like, they have such an interesting life or like they're so attractive.

Yeah, but I mean, like, DM slides are also very big on Instagram as well.

Yeah, but I mean, like, you can tell when someone curates their Instagram for dating rather than like showing their actual personality because it's your typical, like, oh, I go out with friends. Oh, here's me at the beach. Oh, I'm at the gym, you know, like things that would maybe impress a girl or something. I don't know, that's something I've noticed.

I mean, that's how I do my Instagram. I'm gonna be completely honest.

Yeah, because once you notice, like, oh, I linked my Instagram to Tinder, now they can see like my dumb posts. Maybe I should curate it better.

The death of the documentary

So, yeah, that was the documentary. It wasn't very good. Like I said, it was 47 minutes, so it's like an hour with commercials. And it's funny how, like, documentaries are basically just dead as an art form. You know, like documentaries used to be like a serious thing. Like, they used to be seriously discussed as like the Academy Award contenders for best documentary, right? Feature-length 90-minute documentaries, they would play in like theaters. You could buy them on like DVD or like, and that's basically just gone.

Yeah, there was that one, yeah, the last one I can think of was 2016 with a documentary the 13th, which was feature-length.

There are still some feature-linked documentaries, but they're all on streaming services, and they're they're a lot more kind of clickbaity, it seems like. Like, probably the biggest documentary recently were those two competing Fyre Fest documentaries.

You're you're forgetting one icon, one legend herself, Carole freaking Baskin.

Well, that was a series. Documentary TV shows are doing fine.

I think it's I think it actually might be a reflection of the fact that so much of media now is just TV. Yeah, the television format, especially on streaming, for whatever reason, is more marketable. Maybe it's because people like one-hour blocks, 40-minute blocks, instead of a two-hour, 90-minute documentary. The only documentary content now is TV, pretty much.

I disagree with that completely. I think the reason the feature-length documentary has gone away is because of YouTube, of like the Vice documentary, like the 40-minute Vice documentary. A lot of Vice documentaries are much better produced than the documentaries that I watched that would be in a theater. And they're just done much better and they're free on YouTube. So if there's going to be a documentary that's like has a lot of money put into it, a lot of money backing to it, it should be longer. Like it shouldn't just be YouTube length. It should be like a whole series like Tiger King.

Yeah.

It makes sense. You're not constrained anymore by TV or movie theaters. And like information is so accessible online anyways, like with Wikipedia and everything. To make a shorter documentary, it's like, well, the person could have just looked this up themselves. I mean, unless you have something actually interesting to say, but most documentaries don't.

This one is very shallow, but like, this is what documentaries were like 20 years ago. They were this level of content. I guess back when, you know, you had to go to the library and pull out an encyclopedia, and that was your way to access information. Something shallow like this was still like a lot of information that you didn't know.

Political documentaries

I can't think of the last like political documentary really to like be big. Because Michael Moore had his moment in the Bush era, but we're so hypersaturated with politics, that it's like, why even make a documentary?

Yeah, they're just that they don't really have.

You're right. That's probably it. Because the world is so political, they don't really have much of an impact. The last one that I saw in theaters for a class, actually, was Errol Morris, who's probably the most famous documentarian, maybe second after Michael Moore. He did The Thin Blue Line in the 80s. He did a documentary that was just like a two-hour interview with Steve Bannon, and it was really bad. It was just like, you know, him asking really basic questions of Steve Bannon. But they really tried to hype it up. It's like, oh, like a sit-down with the dark mastermind of the American right. But no one watched it because that's the kind of thing that like, like you said, because politics is everywhere, no one wants to go out of their way to go to a movie theater just to see a Republican speak when they can just look at the comments of any CNN post about Biden to see the same thing.

Yeah, or like YouTube people, you know, commentating on stuff or podcasts.

I mean, the only other political documentary I can think of is HyperNormalisation, which wasn't even that big of a hit.

I mean, I don't even like politics 50 years.

Celebrity documentaries

The last really good documentary that I watched and enjoyed was the Blackpink documentary on Netflix.

Oh, yeah, I like that one.

That's hilarious.

And before that, I watched the 6ix9ine documentary. I think that one was on Hulu. That was quite, that was okay.

Yeah, celeb documentaries are getting big.

I really hated the Britney documentary because it, like, it was so close to self-awareness. The whole thing was that it was this incredibly intensive, almost prying documentary about this woman's life. And then it kept having these asides about how, oh, and the media would never leave her alone. And never once did they acknowledge that they were completely, basically doing the exact same thing as the gossip mags 10 years ago. Just instead of like breathlessly reporting on her divorce and her and shaving her head, they're now breathlessly reporting on her legal battles.

Yeah, they're still using her as like a vehicle for content, a vehicle for page views.

Yeah, and then now Netflix wants to make one too.

A series, actually.

Yeah, it's like they also don't really hold anyone accountable. They never like have any specific journalists from the time come on and be like, why did you harass this girl?

I mean, there was the paparazzi guy, but yeah.

Predicting the future

I don't really have any closing thoughts I can think of. What's your final takeaway about this documentary and about how the internet has changed, really?

I'll predict the future. I think a lot of people are going to start trying to go off the grid now that like people are coming more aware of like privacy issues and stuff.

You think the cottagecore future is real?

To a degree, yeah. I mean, I think, especially now that like kids who were part of like mommy vloggers and stuff, seeing like, wow, like I was a child and I was posted online and like I never really got to like consent to that or anything. And just, I think a lot of Zoomers or younger generations are starting to have a bad taste in their mouth of the internet and they kind of like the surveillance and everything, they kind of, I think that's why they like cottagecore is like imagining a time when they weren't always feeling like they were under like a microscope with, you know, the internet and everything making them so interconnected.

I don't think people are going to step back from the internet or smartphones. I think what they're going to do is they're going to step back from social media.

Yeah, social media at least.

Probably use like WhatsApp or Signal or like, you know, those encrypted apps and share things like in a group DM, but not share things on like a public timeline, like an Instagram or Facebook timeline.

Yeah, something that doesn't involve their face so much because I know Zoomers now complain like they hate seeing themselves without filters and everything, that it gives them really weird and unique body dysmorphia.

I think that one interesting analog maybe is how, like, despite all like the hand-wringing by like, you know, trad guys online, statistically, young people today are basically like the least promiscuous generation in like 60 years.

Oh, yeah.

Sexually. And, you know, and I think that part of it is that it's like, in contrast with people who are young in the 60s and 70s, there's not really anything revolutionary about like sexual permissiveness these days. So it's like there's not the kind of like thrill about it. And I think in the same way, that the kind of thrill of the early internet, which has disappeared with every innovation, there's less and less thrill and excitement and wonder. I think that when the internet becomes fully mundane, and it pretty much is, people are much more likely to log off. And I think it's that as it becomes completely ubiquitous in the way that like modern dating is totally ubiquitous, then you might see people making a conscious choice, maybe not to log off entirely, but just to delete social media, maybe not even own a smartphone, and maybe just to make an effort to focus on elements of society that they believe have been lost because of the internet.

I don't think anyone's gonna actually, I don't think anyone's gonna actually be living in a cabin. No one's gonna be totally off the grid. I just think I could imagine some people in the near future deliberately reducing their online usage to pursue other pursuits.

Yeah, I mean, that was kind of like the start of lockdown. Like people got into baking and stuff.

Yeah, yeah, no, I totally agree. I know one of them, my kind of proto-lockdown, there was a hurricane in Miami a couple years ago and everything was shut down for a while. And I got really into like video games for the first time since I was a little kid. Like I played PC games sometimes, but I was for the first time ever, I was like, you know, really getting into like GameCube games. And like, I just, because of the internet, I had been wasting my time with, in other ways, I had forgotten that, like, oh shit, it's really fun to play an old Zelda game. And I think that that's kind of what I'm thinking of. It won't be any kind of disengagement with technology at large. It'll just be a conscious rejection by some people of basically the least cool aspects of online.

Yeah, it won't be a rejection of technology. It'll be a rejection of the feed.

Yeah, that's it. That's totally it.

Wrapping up

Yeah, yeah. And this was Gladio Free Europe. I'm Abram. I was joined by Liam and Pam, and we're going to sign off. See ya.

This episode on Spotify

The show is also on Apple Podcasts, Overcast, Pocket Casts, Podcast Addict, YouTube, RSS and Patreon.

More listening