King Philip's War and the End of Native Sovereignty episode art

91

King Philip's War and the End of Native Sovereignty

In 1675, the Puritan colonies in North America were fighting for their lives. A brilliant young commander named Metacomet assembled a Native American coalition that upended a half-century of colonialism, pushed the English back to the coast, and would come very close to obliterating settler life in New England.

In this episode of Gladio Free Europe, Liam and Russian Sam return to colonial New England to cover King Philip's War, a conflict that is little-known today, but provides one of the greatest "What Ifs" of American history. The psychological terror of Metacomet's revolt, and the brutal English reprisals that followed, would have enormous implications on the development of racial hierarchy and the expulsion of indigenous peoples. And while Metacomet was not even 40 when he was drawn and quartered by the English, he would live forever in the nightmares of the Puritans and the memories of Native Americans, as one of the greatest icons of resistance and rebellion this continent has seen.

Transcript

About 20,200 wordsPlain text

TranscriptKing Philip's War and the End of Native Sovereignty

King Philip's War

Hello and welcome to Gladio Free Europe. I am here with a really big one we've been working on for a very long time with the incomparable Russian Sam. How are you doing?

Good, good. Just still reeling from all this stuff because, jeez, what a story.

Yeah. We've been kind of laying the groundwork for this episode for about a year now because we are here to tell the story of King Philip's War. Possibly the single most important conflict in English North American history. One of those things that is part of such a far-reaching kind of butterfly effect chain of events, where if this one war goes differently, everything about the modern world would be unrecognizable. You probably only heard about this conflict briefly in high school history class. And if you remember anything, you just know that it was a somewhat interesting conflict about a charismatic young leader making a great push to protect his way of life. Ultimately, this great push would be a failure, and the invaders, the English, would win. You might have some understanding that this is also an important part of the prehistory of American society, because the total victory of the English over the so-called King Philip would have dire implications on his Wampanoag tribe, as well as the development of American society as a whole.

Many historians have connected the rigid racial categorization and hierarchy that separates the English-speaking colonies of North America from the Spanish-speaking colonies as a consequence of the brutality and distrust created by this war. But to really understand how this happened, we really have to go deep into the complexities of American society at this time. Because in 17th century New England, relations between the English and their neighboring indigenous nations were richly textured and complicated. They might defy some of our assumptions about how colonialism happened. Because before the war, all the peoples of New England, regardless of race or language or religion, were dependent upon one another for their safety and survival. By the end of this war, this would no longer be true. The English had become so powerful that they could construct a New England society for the English only. If we take a walk through the dark woods of the 17th century past, we can start to figure out how and why these things changed, why King Philip's War occurred as it did, why this war was so shockingly violent by the standards of the time, and why it helped shape the racially exclusionary and desperately paranoid society of colonial New England.

In other words, King Philip's War is the key to understanding how we get from the first Thanksgiving to the Boston Witch Trials, from one side of American colonialism to the other, and really to the development of a society that we are living in today.

From the Pequot War to Metacomet

Yeah, absolutely. So in the previous episode, we discussed the history of colonial New England after 1621 with a particular focus on the worsening relations between the colonists and the indigenous peoples across the 1630s. The peaceful coexistence that figures like Squanto, William Bradford, and Wampanoag Massasoit worked so hard to maintain exploded with the Pequot War, when the Wampanoag watched in horror as the Puritans, the Mohegans, and their Narragansett allies massacred and enslaved the hostile Pequot nation, introducing slavery into the Puritan colonies on a mass scale for the first time. And across the next 40 years, the expansion of English settlements and increased pressure over the slaves and natural resources would lead to slowly ramping up hostilities between the colonists and the indigenous people. Things would come to a head when the charismatic young man known as Metacomet assumed leadership of the Wampanoag after the death of his father and his brother, the Massasoit and Wamsutta, respectively.

Metacomet, whom the English called King Philip, realized that English expansion was making traditional ways of life unsustainable. And in so doing, he rallied together a huge coalition of Native nations. Not just the Wampanoag, but also the Narragansett, the distant Abenaki of Maine, and many others.

Right, and this is what separates it from the Pequot War we discussed in the last episode. It was a genuinely regional conflict involving many more people, comparable, I would say, in its scale and significance to something like the American Revolution or the Civil War, especially if you look at what percent of the population was killed on each side. This means that Metacomet's campaign of resistance and terror toward the colonists would be the greatest threat to American society as we know it that there would ever be. This is the closest Native Americans ever came to nipping colonialism in the bud. Ultimately, Metacomet was, of course, unsuccessful. The intensity of this war shattered hopes of long-term coexistence between the English and their neighbors, turning this relationship into one fundamentally defined by hierarchy and exclusion. Surviving indigenous peoples found themselves living for the first time in a settled world.

The mistreatment, displacement, and subjugation that followed King Philip's War would become the playbook for the later English and eventually United States expansion all the way to the Pacific. So again, this is why this war is so intriguing and I think so fundamental to understanding American society as it exists.

Yeah, but before we continue, I would just like to remind you guys that we are on Patreon. And although we don't pay well any of this content, because this is fundamentally a labor of love, we're just really into introducing these kinds of interesting stories to you guys. But if you feel like our hard labor is worth something to you, then please do check out our Patreon and pitch in a few bucks if you are so inclined.

Yes, we are very grateful for anything that you were able to give. It makes this a lot easier for us and we really appreciate it.

Yeah, we also accept wampum.

Yes, yes, please.

Wampum belts, anything, anything.

Yeah, gifts of corn and brandy and ale, whatever you like.

The colonies of New England

All right, now let's get into King Philip's War. This is a big story. It's a complicated story. There's going to be a lot of names to remember. So I'm really going to do my best to lay the names out early so everybody knows what we're talking about here. If you haven't listened to our last episode on the Pequot War, I'd really recommend that first because there's a lot of recurring characters. So New England at this time, this being the 1660s and 1670s, was organized into multiple colonies that don't entirely line up with modern state borders, but were united under both the monarchy of King Charles II as well as the New England Confederation. This collective defense pact formed after the Pequot War of the 1630s. Really, all throughout New England history, from really as soon as it was founded, Massachusetts Bay Colony was much larger than the other English colonies of New England, including the older colony of Plymouth, the one founded by the famous Pilgrims.

We should understand Massachusetts Bay as a dense cluster of farmsteads surrounding two pretty big port towns, Boston and Salem, while the other colony of Plymouth was a lot less dense and stretched mostly around the Cape Cod area.

Yeah, and we should just emphasize that these are two separate entities. They were founded on different charters and consequently they had very different internal governance as well as relations with their natives, although they're often conflated as one political unit in retrospect.

Definitely. And on that note, there were two other significant colonies here in Connecticut and Rhode Island, which were actually founded by defectors away from Massachusetts. There were always some tensions over that between people in Boston and people in Rhode Island and Connecticut, but ultimately at the end of the day, they would work together for a common colonial project. But we should keep in mind that, you know, both politically and geographically, the English colonies were not united. If you were traveling from one English colony to another, you would either have to go oversea because almost all English colonies were coastal or travel through Native American land. All overseas shipments of food, mail, or whatever were dependent on friendly relations with Native peoples living in between. And this was especially true for the most distant English settlements, because the Puritans had some very far-flung colonies out on the northern tip of Long Island, as well as up in New Hampshire and Maine, really far out there.

The native nations

On the indigenous side, Connecticut and western Massachusetts were dominated by the Mohegan tribe, a powerful nation that we spent a lot of time talking about in our last episode. They benefited greatly from the leadership of a really ambitious and capable sachem named Uncas, really a character who deserves much more attention, I think, in American, you know, the American popular imagination. And there were three closely related groups living to the east of the Mohegans. There were the Narragansetts of Rhode Island, the Massachusetts people, you can guess where they lived, and then the Wampanoag we mentioned earlier. These three groups spoke very close dialects of the Massachusetts language, part of the Algonquian language family. However, these three, the Narragansetts, the Massachusetts, and the Wampanoag, were historical rivals, with the Wampanoag generally maintaining the friendliest relations with the colonists. We got to mention also that the Wampanoags were the main group involved in King Philip's war against the colonists.

So this really was a significant break from the traditional relationship here. Additionally, there were some smaller tribes in the area. The tiny Niantic tribe hung onto a sliver of coast surrounded by English settlements in Rhode Island, while the Nipmucks lived in the forests of central Massachusetts. They were in a tight position, sandwiched between the Massachusetts colony and the Mohegans. Because the Massachusetts settlers and the Mohegans were pretty strong allies, they were feeling quite uneasy, and it might not be surprising that they were some of the first to join this war against the settlers. And there were two other indigenous peoples who would play an important role in the conflict, despite being geographically, culturally, and economically very distant from life in coastal New England. First of all, were the Mohawk, who were the fearsome easternmost branch of the Iroquois Confederation, or the Haudenosaunee, who dominated a huge expanse across New York, Vermont, and parts of Canada.

There were also the Abenaki, who were organized in loosely connected bands across New Hampshire and Maine. Unlike the neighboring peoples of the coast, these groups were not farmers. The Mohawks relied entirely on tribute and food from subjugated tribes and trade with the French Canadians, while the Abenaki were some of the last full-time hunter-gatherers in the region. Perhaps because they spent far less of their time farming, these two groups would prove to be some of the most dangerous warriors on either side of King Philip's war.

After the Pequot War

So let's pick up where we left off the last episode. We discussed the primary consequences of the Pequot War, namely the incorporation of hundreds of captive men, women, and children into New England society as slaves/indentured servants. Although they were assigned temporary conditions of servitude, making them closer to our understanding of indentured servants rather than slaves in the African model that would predominate shortly thereafter, the Puritans brutally exploited the captive Pequots and used a variety of systems of imprisonment and death to avoid freeing them, and often ordering their children to be enslaved into adulthood. Worst of all, they were free to sell these peoples to the slavers of the deadly sugar islands, particularly Barbados, when the contract was coming to its end.

Yeah, no, it's just brutal. So, really, really to emphasize this here: it's horrific. Somebody would be told they would only be a slave for 10 years, but then in their 10th year, when they thought they were about to be free, their master would then sell them to permanent slavery in the Caribbean, and really nobody made it back alive from that. It was a death sentence.

Yeah, absolutely. So, the war saw the obliteration of the Pequots as an independent nation, as nearly all members were enslaved by either the English or their Native American allies, particularly the Mohegans, who were at this point led by the Sachem Uncas, as we mentioned, and by the Narragansett. Additionally, the war allowed the English Puritans to push deeper and deeper into the interior of New England. While nearly all of the colonial towns and farms were on the coast, usually connected to each other only by water, white settlers were now moving into seized Pequot territory. Some Puritans were also invited by Uncas to settle within Mohegan territory. A document survives of a land deed signed by Uncas and some members of the new colony of Connecticut. Interestingly, although he was illiterate, he signed his name with a drawing of a broad-chested stick figure standing with his arms crossed.

This might have been a self-portrait.

Yeah, I love that. And I think that we're bringing up the Pequot War here because, you know, in the same way that World War I leads to World War II or the, you know, French and Indian War helps set the stage for the American Revolution, the Pequot War established the conditions necessary for King Philip's War in many ways. There was the expansion of slavery across New England for the first time. There was the growth of the Mohegans in the West and the English in the East of New England. And also, I think there was the brutal show of force against the defeated Pequots. They were massacred and they were subjugated in ways that didn't really happen in indigenous New England before the colonists got there. This was a real departure from the past and showed that war was taking a more total turn. Other Native American societies did have a tradition of widespread massacres and total war, but it doesn't seem that coastal New England was one of them.

It soon would be. Another consequence of the expansion of slavery was that there was this permanent demand for new slaves. We mentioned that the English would do a lot of sneaky tricks to get away from freeing their slaves after the set 10-year contracts expired after the Pequot War. However, many people still were freed. To satisfy the need, some people were brought in from Africa. We saw the beginning of African slavery in New England, as we discussed last episode. But also, but also there was a desire for more and more slaves to be captured from the hinterland. Technically, this wasn't really legal. English settlers weren't supposed to be going into the countryside to capture Indians to be slaves, especially because this would, you know, potentially lead to conflict between the English and whatever society these slaves came from. However, there was so much money in the slave trade that many people still did capture slaves illegally.

And many of the slave capturers were in fact Native American themselves, particularly they were Mohegans.

Slave raids and Miantonomo

Around the 1640s, about a decade after the Pequot War, a lot of relatives of Uncas, the great Sachem, started going into the countryside to capture people from other tribes, particularly the Narragansetts. The Narragansetts and the Mohegans were actually on the same side in the Pequot War. They were both allies of the colonists against the Pequots. But after the war, tensions would really increase, and eventually this conflict would go hot. And there was a very short but pretty significant war between the Narragansetts and the Mohegans. The English didn't take a side, but it probably involved more troops on each side than the previous Pequot War. It was led mostly by a Narragansett sachem named Miantonomo, who, much like King Philip a generation later, was this very skilled, charismatic young leader who realized that things were getting worse for his people and he had to act decisively to preserve his way of life.

He mustered together a pretty significant army to invade Mohegan territory because the Mohegans were capturing Narragansett as slaves. He knew this was unsustainable, his people couldn't stand this pressure, so the Mohegans had to be stopped. However, the Mohegans were able to push back the initial invasion force, and Miantonomo was captured. The English stepped in to broker a peace treaty between these two tribes. During the negotiations, Miantonomo, I've told you he's a brave guy, he managed to escape from Mohegan captivity, and, in the process, jump over a 40-foot waterfall to get away from them. Tragically, this was not enough to truly get away because within days, he was tracked down by Uncas's relatives, these slave hunters, and bludgeoned to death.

Yeah, we're gonna have a bit more on Miantonomo later on in the episode, so stay tuned, keep that name in your head.

His killing outraged the Narragansett, immediately blowing up any peace negotiations. Miantonomo's brother Pessacus and his son Canonchet rallied their army to attack the Mohegans once again, now aided by that small Niantic tribe that we mentioned earlier. In response, the English would intervene directly. They crossed into Niantic territory to defend their Mohegan allies. They captured the Niantic leader Ninigret and forced him to submit to English demands before moving into the Narragansett territories directly. In return for their assistance, Uncas gave more and more land to the English, while using his victory over the Narragansett to make the Mohegans the unquestioned Indian authority over inland New England.

Eliot, Cockenoe, and Sassamon

There would also be another major ongoing transformation of this part of the world, which was that the Puritans had finally gotten serious about their efforts to convert the native peoples to Christianity. There were major conversions happening in the Wampanoag and Massachusett tribes around the same time as this war, largely due to the efforts of a Puritan missionary named John Eliot and a young Montauk slave named Cockenoe. Eliot realized that Cockenoe spoke many of the local Algonquian languages, some which were intelligible and some which were not. And these languages included Wampanoag. We'll talk more about these guys in a second. Also, at the same time that Christianity was spreading through New England, so did disease. The first waves of smallpox and other epidemics passed through even before the pilgrims arrived in New England, but then by the 1660s, disease continued to ravage indigenous societies, even groups like the Abenaki, who had very little direct contact with the settlers.

As a result of both disease and raids by the English and the Mohegan slaveholders, many indigenous peoples left their traditional homes to migrate deeper into the countryside, farther from the English-dominated coast. They knew rightly that getting farther from the settlers would insulate them from disease as well as slave capture. However, the places these people were migrating to were not empty. They were the territories of the French-Canadian settlers and the Mohawks. This led to a lot of new hostilities across the entire region. The Mohawks were now much more keenly aware of political machinations in New England and realized that, you know, any kind of conflict to their east could have implications all the way out in their territory in Vermont and upstate New York and the Great Lakes.

Yeah, this is kind of like a billiard ball effect here, sort of like what happened in Neolithic Europe or later on when the Huns started to come into Europe and displaced all these Germanic tribes, which would push against the Romans and cause all sorts of problems, which contributed to the end of the empire ultimately.

Right. No, this is all this is a story of so many chain reactions totally spiraling out of control. But going back to New England, Christianity and disease often went hand in hand. Many of the local natives came to believe that the God of the English would protect them from the Englishman's diseases. It was also popular to convert to Christianity on one's deathbed, which often resulted in orphaned children being reared by English families. Quote, But now I must die. The God of the English is much angry with me and will destroy me. Yet my child shall live with the English and learn how to know their God when I am dead. One native man is reported to have said on his deathbed. These children would become hybridized links between the two very different worlds: one English and one Indian. And one of these children would act as a catalyzing force in the outbreak of this war.

This was John Sassamon. Sassamon was a Massachusetts who was born around 1620 when the English were just beginning to settle the land. When his family passed, he was raised in the home of John Calicut. This was the same man who, a few years later, would indenture or enslave, again, at this point, these categories weren't quite set in stone, Cockenoe, who would become John Eliot's translator. But Sassamon, having come among the English as a boy, participated in the Pequot War as a soldier and an interpreter on the English side, while Cockenoe would be taken in this war as a captive. Ultimately, however, the two men would not only live under one roof, but work towards one goal. John Eliot arrived in New England in 1631, a decade after the first Thanksgiving, and he became established as a preacher in the town of Roxbury pretty soon after. His interests were not limited to tending to his English congregation, as he saw it as his duty to spread the gospel among the original inhabitants of the land.

We should mention that he was pretty far from being a racial chauvinist. Many Puritans did not view the natives as inherently evil, but instead saw them as people being ignorant of the word of God, but not otherwise deficient. Eliot went so far as to write that they were Englishmen who were just as ignorant of God as the natives. Right, so for men like Eliot, therefore, Christianization did not necessarily imply anglification. To this end, he became one of the few Puritan men most interested in the local languages, and with men like Cockenoe and Sassamon at his side, he was able to master the language and bring the gospel to the natives in their own tongue. This was clearly unusual, as even the natives were surprised by the idea. To quote from his A True Relation of Our Beginnings with the Indians, while he was praying, one of his fellow Indians interrupted him and told him that he prayed in vain because Jesus Christ understood not what Indians speak in prayer.

He had been used to hear Englishmen pray and so could well enough understand them, but Indian language in prayer he thought he was not acquainted with, but was a stranger to it, and therefore could not understand them. His question, therefore, was whether Jesus Christ did understand or God did understand Indian prayers. Our answer summarily was, therefore, this: that Jesus Christ and God by him made all things and makes all men. And if he made Indian men, then he knows all Indian prayers also. So, back to Cockenoe. Presumably, under duress, he helped Eliot to translate at first a few basic biblical passages like the words prayer into Massachusetts languages. But across this process, Cockenoe either became genuinely interested in Christianity or recognized that Eliot could be a powerful ally. Because once his term of slavery expired, Cockenoe remained at Eliot's side as a preacher and a translator.

Together, they preached the gospel to the local tribes, especially the very numerous Wampanoag, and they would eventually translate the Bible into their language in their entirety. Eliot, Cockenoe, and Sassamon had great success at converting the Wampanoag and Massachusetts people. Planned communities for Christian natives were established within the bounds of English towns, including in Nantucket and Martha's Vineyard. It should be noted that both of these so-called praying towns were built on islands where the residents would be safe from any reprisals from other Indians who may have seen the converts as traitors. Eliot and his Indian accomplices would build 14 such towns in total. Men like Sassamon would also work as schoolmasters in said towns. Eventually, Eliot was so impressed with Sassamon that he arranged to give him a university education. He went to a little-known institution you might have heard of called Harvard. It's pretty interesting, of course, he was the first Native American graduate.

Eliot also worked to establish a printing press specifically for Massachusetts language texts. By 1663, in collaboration with Sassamon and a printer known as John Nesutan, two books of Psalms and the Bible would be printed in Massachusetts. This would be the first ever Bible printed in North America, before any English version. Until his death in 1690, Eliot worked tirelessly on the series he called his Indian Library, which included two dozen publications, including grammar books for Englishmen hoping to learn the language. A lot of resources were expended to this end. And according to Jill Lepore, the paper that was used to print just two editions of the Bible was more than the total amount used by the Cambridge Press since its inception in 1639, to the effect that there was one Massachusetts Bible for every two and a half Indians. There was a huge amount of Bibles in circulation.

And although supply clearly outpaced demand here, this didn't stop Eliot from dreaming big. And it certainly had a strong effect on spreading Christianity among the Native peoples. He really put his full might behind this effort, but for reasons unknown to history, Eliot and Sassamon had a falling out in the early 1660s. Intriguingly, Sassamon would actually leave the Christianized Indian world behind and become a full-time translator and scribe for the Wampanoag Sachems, while still privately retaining his Christian faith. And not just privately, he was also converting people, but he decided that he was going to live amongst his own people rather than being among the English primarily. So despite their successes with the Wampanoag in Massachusetts, the Puritans had much less success in converting the peoples to their West, including the Mohegan friends and the more hostile Niantics in Narragansett. When a white resident of Martha's Vineyard asked the Niantic Sachem Ninigret if he could convert his people, Ninigret told him, quote, go and make the English good first.

And side note, if you remember the icon from our indigenous New England episode, that sachem depicted in it, that's probably Ninigret. So very handsome fellow.

The death of Massasoit

Possibly the biggest factor precipitating the turn towards war in New England was actually the death of the Massasoit, a full 14 years before war broke out. Because when he died in 1661, the Massasoit departed from a markedly different world than the one he'd been born into. The Wampanoag people, by clinging tight to their English allies, were able to become some of the top native honchos in the region. And because of the explosive growth of the English colonies and their continued close personal relationships with figures like William Bradford and Edward Winslow, the Wampanoag were able to win the fealty of many tribes who'd previously been tied to their enemies. But these kinds of alliances between the Wampanoag and the English were in a sense based on the desperate circumstances that the early English were in. With every successive generation, there were more English people who felt much more secure to expand across New England and felt less reliant on assistance from the natives.

This meant that the Wampanoags found their status essentially dwindling. They were no longer as necessary. And while Plymouth continued to consider itself bound by agreements it made with the Massasoit, the much more vast and populous Massachusetts Bay colonists had an entirely different foundation and made no such agreement. John Winthrop, the leader of Massachusetts, famous for his City Upon a Hill speech, took on an altogether different view of the natives, viewing them as derelict and believing God to be squarely on the side of the English. Winslow and Bradford predeceased him by a few years in 1655 and 1657. And as the first generation drifted away, you know, the squanto Thanksgiving generation, new faces came to the fore. Settler leadership in New England largely remained in the hands of Puritan elites, but there were a lot of other people who came to the region under the charter of Massachusetts Bay Colony for less religious reasons and more economic reasons.

This meant that the composition of the settlers shifted away from persecuted religious dissenters and towards people whose primary interests were commercial. And figures like Winslow bemoaned these people as morally inferior. For the Wampanoag, the new leadership would be the Massasoit sons, Wamsutta and Metacomet, who we mentioned earlier. These would be known to the English by the monikers Alexander and Philip, named after Alexander the Great and his father, Philip the Great. It's pretty interesting.

Right, and these names alone show just how different the world of the sons was. They themselves asked the English for new names upon ascending to the sachemship, as it was customary for a sachem to take a new name upon ascending to the post. But the choice of names signaled just how much had changed. Both of the brothers were born in the 1630s when the English were no longer a bunch of raggedy religious exiles struggling to feed themselves, and their way of life came to infringe upon natives, even those who were their allies. At the core of the problem was that, first of all, the English had a very different political economy. They had a very different relationship to the land. And secondly, their numbers were growing at a very, very rapid rate. While most of the natives in the region practiced agriculture, it was nowhere near enough to sustain them exclusively.

Their diets were also heavily supplemented by hunting and fishing. But the English were not only converting land for agricultural use, they were also introducing livestock into the region, which put a great strain on local food systems, which were the lifeblood of the natives. This was apparent as early as the Pequot War, and in the aftermath, there were even more serious attempts to create a wider Indian alliance to expel the English.

Miantonomo's warning

One such attempt was recorded by Lion Gardiner, who settled in Long Island. Sometime around 1642, Miantonomo, the sachem of the Narragansett, who had allied himself to the English during the Pequot War, came to Long Island in an attempt to forge an alliance against the English. Now, now clearly disillusioned with his former allies. Miantonomo had a very acute sense of the problems posed by the English and the natives' incompatible way of life. Quote, We all Indians as the English are, and say brother to one another, so we must be one as they are, otherwise we shall all be gone shortly. For you know our fathers had plenty of deer and skins, our plains were full of deer, as were our woods and of turkeys, and our coves full of fish and fowl. But these English have gotten our land. They with scythes cut down the grass, and with axes fell the trees, and horses eat the grass, and their hogs spoil the clam banks, and we shall all be starved.

Therefore, it is best for you to do as we, for we are all sachems from east to west. Both the Mokakes and the Mohawks join with us, and we are resolved to fall upon them all at one appointed day.

Wow.

Yeah, so the sachem of the people to whom Miantonomo appealed told Gardiner of these plans, and the plot was foiled. Miantonomo would flee, and he would be taken prisoner a year later, as described above.

The war with the Mohegans, yeah, yeah.

Yeah, it should also be mentioned that this wasn't just about the Mohegans taking Narragansett slaves, it was also a result of tensions about the disposition of each nation's share in the spoils, peoples, and lands which they had acquired in the Pequot War.

Yeah, yeah.

But unfortunately for the natives, the problems that were diagnosed by Miantonomo would not die with him.

Wamsutta and Weetamoo

So, returning to the sons of the Massasoit, both of them were toddlers at the closing of the Pequot War, which permanently changed the tenor of English-indigenous relations, and they became acquainted with the English ways very early in their lives. In addition to the very different relationships they had with the land, the spread of slavery and Christianity led to new tensions across and within the tribes, while also connecting most New England nations more closely with the English and Wampanoag. The brothers grew up around native missionaries like Cockenoe and Sassamon. While neither became Christian, they became part of a newly cosmopolitan and somewhat bilingual elite. Metacomet wore European clothing and visited the rapidly growing port of Boston. In addition to being the sons of the Paramount Sachem, both Wamsutta and Metacomet had marriage ties to the other lesser Wampanoag Sachems, which secured their standing in New England society.

When Metacomet was a teenager, his older brother Wamsutta married a really intriguing woman named Weetamoo from the Pocasset sub-tribe. I think she's one of the most fascinating characters of this whole story. Her father was a chief named Corbitant, who we mentioned briefly last episode because he kidnapped Squanto back in 1621 and caused a conflict with the English. When Corbitant died, Weetamoo assumed leadership of the Pocasset, which seems to have been not that unrare for female leaders in this era. Shortly after this, around 1661, the Massasoit died as well, as we mentioned. This means that Weetamoo and her husband, Wamsutta, that being Metacomet's brother, had become the greatest power couple of 17th century New England. In kind of a Ferdinand and Isabella situation, this meant that there was this significant marriage pact connecting these two groups within the broader Wampanoag umbrella, really strengthening their power within their society and without.

Wamsutta's tenure would be very short, however, as he died in 1662. By this point, there were about 60 to 70,000 English settlers in the region, and there were only about half as many natives. The growing pressure meant that the sale of lands, which was so devastating to the natives' way of life, kept ratcheting onwards. This pressure and the consent-based nature of the sachemships would require extensive gift-giving, and this meant that the Wampanoag was increasingly pressured to accept European goods to keep themselves in good standing with their subordinates. So, this is a really volatile situation. You have Wamsutta and his wife, Weetamoo, with a lot of significant power in the region, but they find themselves increasingly locked in by the English. You can really see how this might boil over, right? How you're seeing the ingredients here for an organized resistance. Additionally, the consolidation of the Wampanoags by this political marriage allowed the Wampanoags to more easily check the power of the fearsome Mohegans, who were still led by Uncas, as well as the English colonists.

Metacomet probably helped his brother and his sister-in-law wage a small war against the Narragansett people, but this invoked the wrath of the Puritans because they ended up buying and selling land with English settlers without any kind of official approval. Worse still, the lands being bought and sold in question were under the authority of Weetamoo, and she became so frustrated by her husband's dealings that she appeals to the Plymouth General Court to prevent her husband from infringing on these lands. Really interesting stuff here, the way this, you know, domestic drama becomes political.

Right, and she was able to go to Plymouth because the treaties that the Wampanoag were tied to basically meant that they were unable to sell lands to other colonies without the consent of Plymouth.

Yeah.

So, because this was a violation of the old treaty, Wamsutta was put on trial by the Plymouth aldermen. But he did not come willingly, and Plymouth had to send armed men to arrest him and bring him to justice. But during the court process, he fell ill and was released, dying shortly thereafter. While his death ended the immediate crisis of the illegal land sales, the suspicious conditions surrounding Wamsutta's demise led to widespread speculation about poisoning. There was another reason to suspect foul play. There were also rumors that Wamsutta was conspiring with the Narragansett to make war against the English. We mentioned last episode that similar questions arose after Squanto's death. Metacomet himself came to believe that the English had poisoned his brother.

Metacomet takes power

And so, in 1662, just a year after the death of his father, and with his older brother now dead as well, Metacomet was thrust into power as the primary leader of the Wampanoag. The English called him King Philip at this point and recognized him as the most powerful sachem in the region after Uncas of the Mohegans. Metacomet reinforced his alliance with his brother's widow, the female sachem Weetamoo, by marrying her sister, Wootonekanuske. The next decade of his life is somewhat obscure, but Metacomet clearly began to sour on Christianity and the increasing influence of the English. Most likely, this animosity had an economic element because many Christian Indians left Metacomet's territory to live amongst the English in the praying towns established by John Eliot and Sassamon. This would have disrupted the power structure of indigenous societies and increased the manpower advantage that the Puritans already had. Eventually, Metacomet too felt the need to sell parcels of Wampanoag land to the English in exchange for increasingly necessary cash, to the dismay of many, even among the Wampanoag.

Cattle, fences, and land

Aside from the strains placed on him by the terms of these treaties, some settlers would also infringe on the rights of the Wampanoag clarified in such treaties. To quote from Silverman's This Land is Their Land, Indian resentment over these developments naturally extended from the colonists' growing unwillingness to abide by the spirit or letter of joint use agreements. Imagine the natives' frustration when they returned to spring fish runs to find the streams dammed up or fenced off, or cattle grazing on their planted fields, or wood they depended on for fuel and building materials cut down, or their dogs killed for threatening colonists' sheep. Such incidents mounted with every passing year without resolution. In 1663, a group of Englishmen in Taunton acknowledged that some of their townsmen had violated the long-practiced custom of tolerating Indians planting corn in the remote parts of their community to the Indians' great impoverishing.

The following year, Putameticom accused the English of Rehoboth felling his timber. Yet the greatest strain on joint use was the English livestock, or more specifically, the unwillingness of colonists to fence in their animals. Practically every year, complaints poured in from Plymouth from every corner of Wampanoag country about English cattle, horses, and pigs devouring their people's crops. Sometimes the animals even swarm around fences the Wampanoag built across peninsular necks of land to keep them out. When the Wampanoags killed the trespassing animals, or when their dogs attacked them, or livestock wandered into Indian deer traps, colonists sued for damages. It made Wampanoags wonder why the English valued Indian property so little, yet expected their own wandering four-legged property claims to carry such weight.

Right, and this is really familiar because, as we mentioned in our Ainu episode, the Japanese authorities would similarly play these kinds of games, but not only that, they would also actively impede the Ainu from adopting to Japanese ways of life. There was a similar dynamic at play here as well. When it became clear that the traditional native political economy was no longer feasible, natives would attempt to transition to a more English mode of living, including rearing livestock, but they were only frustrated in their attempts in this effort. To quote from Silverman again: the English refused to share pastureland and obstructed Indian competitors from selling pork on colonial markets, contrary to their admonitions that Indians should live in a so-called civilized manner. In 1669, the Rhode Island colony of Portsmouth even demanded Metacomet to remove pigs he had put to feed on the aptly named Hog Island, a literal stone's throw from the Sachem's village, arguing that he had already sold that exclusive right to the Englishman Richard Smith.

The plague of English beasts was so bad that John Eliot considered it to be one of the greatest obstacles to propagating Christianity, because it left Indians infuriated towards colonists and unwilling to live near towns. Yet, for some English, that was precisely the point. The more difficult it became for Wampanoags to share space with their colonial neighbors.

Swansea and disarmament

Right, and so for all these reasons above, Metacomet was increasingly frustrated with the demands made upon him and the Wampanoag by the English, including on several occasions the demand that all Wampanoag weapons should either be turned over to the English or at least shown for inspection. The town of Swansea in Plymouth was a hotspot of tensions to the point that even Metacomet could not accede. In the spring of that year, 1671, that is, he marched through the town with his warriors bearing arms. For this offense, he was called to the court in Plymouth, where he admitted that he was preparing to go to war with the Swansea community. He signed a treaty the following month where he agreed to disarm, but the conflict continued to simmer, and the matter was brought to the Massachusetts Bay authorities in Boston. These men ruled against him, and he was forced to pay Plymouth a fine.

And let's remember that town, Swansea, because it's about to become very important.

Right, and to add insult to injury, the land sold to the English was often used to build praying towns on the border between English and Wampanoag territory. Metacomet feared that this would lead to his own subjects defecting to areas of English control, and that his people would accept a stability of servitude to the English rather than maintaining their traditional lifestyle of their ancestors and their fealty to him. Obviously, the English were the real enemy here, but Metacomet blamed Christian Indians as well, particularly his old friend John Sassamon, the Harvard graduate who was now decidedly his enemy.

The murder of John Sassamon

Returning to Sassamon, in 1673, he settled on land that was once Wampanoag territory and built a meeting house there where he preached to Metacomet's subjects. In the course of his ministry, he heard rumors from the Wampanoag congregants that Metacomet was planning some kind of uprising against the English. In January of 1675, John Sassamon appeared to Plymouth Governor Josiah Winslow to report this. He was not taken seriously, however, because, quote, it had been an Indian original, and one can hardly believe them even when they speak the truth. There had been false alarms of Indian attacks for 50 years, after all, going back all the way to Squanto's days. But only a week later, John Sassamon disappeared. In February, his body was found preserved in a frozen river. Not long after this, a Native American witness said that he saw three Wampanoags drag Sassamon's body into the water to make it look as if he had drowned by accident.

These three men were brought before a jury in Plymouth, which was composed of two-thirds Englishmen and one-third Wampanoag. Sassamon was almost certainly murdered, but the trial revealed how fraught early modernity was and how rational inquiry continued to be infused with a supernatural tinge, which was given rationalist legitimacy. As Jill Lepore puts it in The Name of War, an unusual jury of 12 Englishmen and six of the most indifferentest, gravest, and sage Indians was impaneled to consider the evidence. First, there was Patuckson, the eyewitness who, unseen by those three that killed Sassamon, beheld all that they did to him and spake of it so that a praying Indian, William by name, heard of it and he forthwith revealed that he knew to the English. Both Patuckson and William had promptly testified at the trial. Second, there was the forensic evidence. Governor Winslow had ordered Sassamon's body dug up from its grave and commissioned a coroner's inquest to make inquiry how he came by his death.

And they found he'd been murdered, for his neck was broken by twisting his head round, which is the way Indians sometimes use when they practice murder. Also, his head was extremely swollen, and his body wounded in several parts of it. Testimony might have also been offered when the body was first taken out at the pond. No water issued out of it, which argued that the body was not drowned, but dead before it came into the water. Finally, there was supernatural evidence. The court ordered Tobias to approach Sassamon's dead body, and as he did, Sassamon's body fell bleeding afresh, as if it had been newly slain. This experiment was repeated, giving the same result, supplying an irrefutable testimony to the guilt of the accused.

Yeah, very interesting times.

Yeah, so yeah, like, you know, if logic would help you with your case, use magic.

Yeah, exactly. Now, the historian James Drake notes that because these Indian men were likely literate, they were probably Christians, and their addition to the jury might have seemed less like a display of goodwill and more like a display of bias. But it's important to keep in mind that the court process shows that the English and the Wampanoag were still living in a shared society, where appearances of good relations and coexistence were still necessary, despite the increasing overreach of the white settlers and the worsening prospects of the natives. After King Philip's War, such coexistence on equal terms fell to the wayside completely. Given Metacomet's past discontents with Sassamon and the knowledge that he had gone to speak with Winslow, it was believed that the killing was done at Metacomet's behest. But the court was unable to keep Metacomet for lack of evidence, leaving his subordinates to take the blow.

Nevertheless, the trial was viewed as a massive blow to native sovereignty. Recall that extradition of accused criminals was an article of the first treaty made with the Massasoit, but in practice, this was very fraught and not undertaken. Furthermore, this was not a crime perpetrated against an Englishman, but an Indian. Under the letter of the treaty, it was not permissible to try Metacomet for having killed someone he had jurisdiction over. Metacomet denied any wrongdoing and claimed that even if he had done the killing, there would be no need to cover it up since the murder would have been well within his rights. He had other complaints as well, namely on the unequal application of the law. Quote, If 20 honest Indians testify that an Englishman had done them wrong, it was as nothing. And if but one of the worst Indians testified against any Indian or their king when it pleased the English, that was sufficient.

And on June 8th, 1675, three Wampanoags accused of killing John Sassamon were taken to the gallows. The third of these men, Wampapaquan, did not die that day as the rope tore when he was hanged. He was told that his confession would secure clemency, and he accused the other two men of having done it while he watched. But this was no use, as when war broke out, this guy would be shot anyway.

The road to war

Metacomet viewed these executions as the straw that broke the camel's back, and he began to organize alliances with other sachems across New England in the lead up to these men's execution. There was a fundamental disagreement about whether the native leaders were sovereign in their own right or subject to colonial authorities, and it would now break out in all of its fiery wrath. Three days after the hanging, Josiah Winslow was informed by a resident of Swansea that the hostilities were brewing. Warriors were congregating in the area, and Wampanoag had sent their wives away to the Narragansett for safety. Recall that the Narragansett were the nation, the fear of whom had led Massasoit to embrace the Puritans as allies in the first place. Indian workers were quitting their English employers and going away. It was clear to all who listened that the colonists now tread in perilous waters.

John Easton, the Quaker deputy governor of Rhode Island, met with Metacomet hoping to prevent war. Easton wanted to arrange an arbitration by third parties to settle complaints without having to resort to arms, something that the Wampanoag were not opposed to in principle. Easton wrote, quote, They said they had been the first in doing good to the English, and the English the first in doing wrong. Said when the English first came, their king's father, that is the Massasoit, was as a great man and the English as little child. He constrained other Indians from wronging the English and gave them corn and showed them how to plant and was free to do them any good and had got them to have a hundred times more land than now the king has for his own people. Easton then recorded a long list of complaints registered by the Massasoit: how the Christian Indians destabilized the balance of power and double dealt with the colonists for their own benefit.

That the English had also poisoned Wamsutta, that being Metacomet's brother, and that the English were buying up too much land and leaving little for the Indians, who in idleness turned now to drunkenness from liquor brought by the English and became a further burden to native communities and a justification for fines, which forced further land sales. So really an awful situation for the Wampanoag people to be in. Easton agreed that these were valid complaints and came away from the meeting convinced that there was another way forward. The Wampanoag also agreed that the English were too numerous and they'd prefer that the English should do to them as they did when they were too strong for the English. However, on the return trip, Easton received a letter saying that Winslow intended to subjugate Metacomet by force of arms. There would be war. Back in Swansea, intimidating postures were exchanged until finally, on June 19th, the situation turned explicitly violent.

This began first as robberies and property destruction, since the natives wanted the English to draw first blood based on a prophecy of a powwow that the natives would lose otherwise. English soldiers led by William Bradford, that is the son of the William Bradford who had broken the treaty with the Massasoit in the first place, massed in the area. But nobody was killed until the 23rd, when a boy shot dead a Wampanoag, who was burning his family's farm. Nine settlers were killed the following day, and two mortally wounded in ambushes. By this point, most settlers had taken shelter in garrisons.

Swansea

So, at this point, you're probably wondering why Swansea was the flashpoint of this encounter. It was a very small town, some 40 miles away from Plymouth, in the vicinity of Mount Hope, that had been founded only a decade before. Montaup, on the southern tip of the peninsula, was the Wampanoag seat of power, at least from the time of the Massasoit. Swansea was just over a decade old and contained only 30 households. The local settlers, being so distant from Plymouth, depended on good relations with the Wampanoag. But despite this, the closeness of this community to the center of power and all that that's embarrassed in the current environment made them sort of a bridgehead for English colonialism.

The eclipse

In light of these events, troops were then dispatched from Boston, but their advance was paused by a sudden lunar eclipse blanketing New England in darkness. Quote, that night, that is June 27th, as a lunar eclipse forced the first two companies marching from Boston to pause near Dedham on the Neponset River, those men saw in the strange sky a black splotch shaped like an Indian scalp or bow. The men talked among themselves and agreed that this was a bad omen foretelling the wider war they feared. That is from Mandell's King Philip's War.

There's no way to know if the Wampanoags could predict this eclipse, but it clearly was an omen to expand the war. And we know that across the Great Lakes, the Huron people told some French missionaries that an eclipse was always a sign of war to come. It's easy to imagine the Wampanoag might have had this view as well. Drake points out that the initial attack on Swansea was a direct retaliation for the execution of the men who'd killed John Sassamon and was likely carried out by those men's relatives. The attacks after the eclipse were similarly small-scale, but more widespread across New England. We mentioned last episode that the New England tribes had a tradition of pretty limited warfare, tit-for-tat targeted killings that were usually resolved within a few weeks. This was shaping up to be a different kind of conflict, a more widespread conflict, which brought back memories of the destruction of the Pequot War.

Violence radiated outwards to the great chagrin of Massachusetts authorities as well as other colonial governments in the region, who felt that they might get dragged into a war if they played no part in sparking. Many English soldiers were poorly disciplined and prone to hostility against neutral and even friendly Native Americans. One of the company's called to arms was headed by a captain Samuel Moseley, a Jamaican privateer who had a reputation for violent outbursts against Indians. Such antics pushed away many potential allies into the arms of Metacomet's growing rebellion.

Guerrilla war

Right, so at this point, the colonists had massed some 350 soldiers in the vicinity of Swansea, as Winslow had hoped to deal the Wampanoag a decisive blow by capturing Metacomet and bringing the war to a quick conclusion. But these military units, who operated according to the European war doctrine that included orderly lines and marching in formation, etc., things of that nature, were pretty easy targets for the more decentralized guerrilla tactics of the natives, who emerged from and disappeared into the swamps with great ease. The problems posed by this approach were clear from the earliest day. Captain James Cudworth wrote that what we would today call counterinsurgency was difficult since, quote, for the issue of such design will be to pick off our men, and we shall never be able to obtain our end in this way, for they fly before us and from one swamp to another.

By the time that the English troops made it to the bottom of the Mount Hope Peninsula on June 30th, Montaup was abandoned. The Wampanoag had swam away in the dead of the night to take shelter among the Pocasset and the Sakonnet, most of whom were themselves not keen to participate in the war but opened their doors to their neighbors. The English followed in pursuit, leaving behind a trail of burned-out fields and dead elders in their wake, which forced these people, led by Wamsutta's former wife Weetamoo, to throw in their lot with Metacomet. Violence begat violence, and July saw many English settlements fall prey to the Indians' fury. After the burning of these Wampanoag villages by the English, Metacomet appears to have assumed direct control over the war. And we should note that up until this point, there's no reason to believe he was personally involved in these attacks on English farms.

King Philip's war was probably, in fact, not started by King Philip himself. But Metacomet was clearly a very skilled diplomat, and he quickly rallied Weetamoo, his former sister-in-law, to join the war, as well as the neighboring Nipmuck people of western Massachusetts. The activation of this alliance really alarmed the Mohegans, who were still at this point led by the elderly Uncas, who we talked about last episode.

Oh, wow.

Yeah, I know. He was probably like 80 at this point. So by July, a war on multiple fronts was now spreading across New England, because you have the Nipmucks in the west and the Wampanoags in the East. And now the Mohegans in the West are joining, you know, to fight for the English. It's a very complicated situation. Generally speaking, the tribes living nearest to the colonists were the ones fighting the colonists. They were the ones rebelling, whereas more distant tribes sought to maintain the balance of power by aiding the English. During all this, the English scrambled to secure the support of any nearby tribes, or at least intimidate them into staying neutral.

Wheeler's Surprise

In August, a few dozen Massachusetts Bay militia led by a Thomas Wheeler entered the territory of the Nipmucks, who they believed were still neutral. What Wheeler didn't know is that Metacomet had beaten him by just a few days and secured his own alliance with the Nipmucks. Realizing this alliance was still a secret, the Nipmuck Sachem Muttawmp told the English that he would be their friend and, in fact, promised to appear in Boston the following week to sign a treaty. However, as soon as the English turned back to their own territory, he began preparing an ambush. Muttawmp knew that to get out of Nipmuck territory, you had to cross through this very dangerous swamp, where the only stretch of solid ground was so thin that any group of men would have to walk single file. As soon as the English started walking through this pass, Nipmuck warriors emerged from the trees, showering the settlers with both musketballs and arrows.

Although only a handful of Englishmen were killed, this event, now known to history as Wheeler's Surprise, convinced the colonists that neighboring Indians could not be trusted, and that King Philip's war was not going to be rebellion fought by the Wampanoag alone.

The Narragansett dilemma

Right, so at this point, many Native Americans found themselves caught in the middle and increasingly distrusted by the English. Because the settlers had more guns and more men by the 1670s, coastal peoples like the Narragansett believed that successful resistance would be impossible and that they would be better off making a quick peace to restore the status quo. Now, interestingly, the Narragansett people approached Rhode Island leader Roger Williams to discuss the possibility of both of their people staying out of the war. Let the Wampanoags and the Massachusetts Bay colonists sort this one out. Williams responded that this may not be possible because all Englishmen were subject to King Charles and that an attack on one colony would be considered an attack on all English subjects. Meanwhile, in western Massachusetts, a series of isolated English settlements along the Connecticut River were now in enemy territory.

The Connecticut River towns

Local settlers like John Pynchon, who in fact is an ancestor of the writer Thomas Pynchon, as Liam found out, tried to maintain peace with the local Nipmuck and Wampanoag peoples. In frontier areas, peaceful coexistence was a necessity. But as Metacomet's warriors began to raid the Connecticut River farms, other settlers began to see all Indians as the enemy. Across the fall of 1675, nearly all settlements in western Massachusetts were being targeted by the Wampanoags and their allies, like the Nipmucks. By the time a Massachusetts army could reach the site of an attack, Metacomet's forces were already burning another village. The settlers' lack of detailed knowledge of the territory, particularly this far inland, made them unable to defend these lands that they'd colonized since the Pequot War. This meant that entire towns were destroyed by Metacomet's army, and the majority of the English population of inland New England would flee back to the coast.

By December, it appeared that the Wampanoag were winning King Philip's war pretty decisively. They had gotten the settlers on the back foot really for the first time since the pilgrims had arrived in New England 50 years earlier. In just a few months, there was this rapid change of circumstances. But Metacomet had his own problems to deal with, because although the Native American side had better leadership and a superior knowledge of the terrain, they were many fewer in number and far less well supplied. So a single decisive attack by the colonists could have terrible impact on the Wampanoag's ability to wage war. In other words, Metacomet had to get lucky every time, but the colonists only had to get lucky once.

The Great Swamp Fight

Accordingly, the tide would slowly begin to turn against Metacomet's army, perhaps beginning with the famous Great Swamp Fight. So this was a very interesting conflict actually fought by the Narragansetts, who had intended to stay out of the war up until this point. They had had an uneasy relationship with the settlers since the days of the first Thanksgiving, and felt slighted by the ways that the Puritans tended to favor their historic enemies in New England, like the Mohegans and, ironically, the Wampanoag, Metacomet's people. So, when the war broke out, the Narragansett sachem Canonchet initially refused to get involved. This made some sense because his forefather's decision to join a coalition war against the hated Pequots had caused both the Puritans and the Mohegans to become powerful enough to bully the Narragansetts in ways they couldn't before. However, due to their distrust and resentment of both the Puritans and the Mohegans, many Narragansetts discreetly supported Metacomet's war.

This meant that Wampanoag refugees were given shelter in Narragansett homes, like Sam mentioned. And the Puritans constantly accused the Narragansett of letting Wampanoag warriors hide out in their lands to stage ambushes on the English. Canonchet denied all of this vociferously, and in fact, signed a treaty with the Massachusetts Puritans insisting upon his neutrality. But the Plymouth Puritans, who were not party to this treaty, led an attack into neutral Narragansett territory to find Wampanoags they were sure were hiding there.

Big Nixon Cambodia vibes here.

Oh, yeah. Dragging this, you know, uninvolved third party into the war because you believe that they are sheltering the enemy.

Yeah, yeah, we're just doomed to keep repeating the same mistakes.

But anyway, not long before Christmas 1675, the colonists and their Mohegan allies crossed into the half-frozen swamp to a fortified village in what is today known as Kingstown, Rhode Island. In a repeat of the Mystic Massacre of the Pequot War some 40 years earlier, this village was burned by Governor Winslow, whose own father, Edward Winslow, was present at the first Thanksgiving and wrote one of the earliest sources about the pilgrims in Squanto, which we read from in the previous episode. Just like at Fort Mystic, hundreds of men, women, and children were burned alive. Survivors fled out of the fort and into the swamp, where many drowned, and others were pursued by Puritan forces and the Mohegans. Indian troops on the English side were apparently led by the great Mohegan sachem Uncas, who was by now over 80 years old. If one excludes the hundreds of civilian casualties, this so-called battle was far less of a decisive victory than Mystic, which ended the Pequot War.

The Narragansetts fought back hard and killed about as many English invaders as had died themselves.

Joshua Tefft

Intriguingly, at least one of the warriors on the Narragansett side was an English defector. A 30-year-old farmer named Josiah Tefft lived in Narragansett territory. His wife and father had recently died, which apparently caused him to become a man with little to lose. So when the Puritans attacked Narragansett town, he crossed behind enemy lines and shot at least five English troops before being captured.

Wow. Tefft.

Yeah. At first, Tefft insisted that he was innocent and that he hadn't fired any shots in the battle. But then he changed his story to say that he was forced to fight by Narragansett, who were holding him captive. But according to other native prisoners taken at the battle, he joined on his own volition and was an eager supporter of the anti-English cause.

I'm sure all of our listeners have at least one white boyfriend who is exactly like this. We just want to give him a shout out right now, real quick.

Yeah. Hopefully your friends will not suffer the same fate that Josiah Tefft suffered, which was to be hanged, drawn, and quartered by the English authorities. Interestingly, this was actually only one of a small handful of times this punishment was ever carried out in America for anyone. Pretty interesting.

We should mention, though, that as brutal as Tefft's execution was, his family was actually shown some clemency that would not be given to Native Americans. Because his young son, Peter, did not suffer the kind of intergenerational punishments typically inflicted upon the families of defeated Native Americans. Possibly due to public sympathy for his son, who is now an orphan, New England authorities actually overrode a law that should have prevented him from inheriting his father's land. So again, you're starting to see systems of kind of racial hierarchy take shape during the war, even though this guy was an enemy, just like the Native Americans. It's kind of interesting how this happens.

Schaghticoke and the Mohawks

Absolutely. To turn back to the Wampanoag, in the aftermath of the Great Swamp Fight, Metacomet led his troops to upstate New York to a village called Schaghticoke, established in Mohawk territory by New England natives who were fleeing warfare and disease on the coast. We mentioned that the Mohawk were uncomfortable with outsiders moving into their territory, and while they initially tolerated the founding of this village by New England refugees, things changed very quickly once the residents of Schaghticoke gave refuge to Metacomet's warriors. The Mohawks violently evicted the Wampanoags out of their village, killing hundreds in an attack that forced them back into New England territory.

Presumably because they didn't want the English to have a casus belli against them, I guess.

Yeah. So at this point, Metacomet's army was stuck between Scylla and Charybdis, with the Mohawks dominating in the New York forest and the English on the coast. Both of these peoples were more numerous than Metacomet's coalition and were generally better fighters. The English had an obvious technological advantage as well, while the Mohawks had been a military hegemon over the England Northeast for decades.

Right, but Metacomet was clearly an effective and inspiring leader despite all of these disadvantages. His army held together in the wake of this Mohawk attack, returning back to New England where they resumed their assaults on English farms.

Mary Rowlandson

We've got an incredible source here from a woman named Mary Rowlandson, whose farm was one of the places attacked by Metacomet's forces during the war. Her husband at the time was away, but she realized that while he was hunting Metacomet's forces, these forces instead found her at home. On the 10th of February came the Indians with great numbers. Their first coming was about sunrise. Hearing the noise of some guns, we looked out. Several houses were burning, with the smoke ascending to heaven. There were five persons taken in one house: the father and the mother and the suckling child, knocked on the head. The other two were taken and carried away alive. There were two others who, being out of the garrison upon some occasion, were set upon. One was knocked on the head, the other escaped. Another, who was running along, was shot and wounded and fell down.

He begged of them for his life, promising them money, but they would not hearken to him, but knocked him in the head, stripped him naked, and then split open his bowels. Another, seeing many of the Indians about his barn, ventured and went out, but was quickly shot down. There were three others belonging to the same garrison who were killed. The Indians getting up on the roof of the barn had advantage to shoot down upon them over their fortification. Thus, these murderous wretches went on, burning and destroying before them.

Right, and Mary Rowlandson, she hunkered down in her house, but as the Wampanoag attackers were unable to get inside, they instead used the tactic previously used by the English, which was setting the building on fire with all of its people inside. Quoting from her again, At length they came and beset our own house, and quickly it was the dolefulest day that had ever mine eyes saw. Some of the Indians got behind the hill, others into the barn, and others behind anything that could shelter them. From all which places they shot against the house, so that the bullets seemed to fly like hail, and quickly they wounded one man among us, then another, and then a third. About two hours, according to my observation in that amazing time, they had been about the house before they prevailed to fire it, which they did with flax and hemp, which they brought out of the barn, and there being no defense about the house, only two flankers at opposite corners and one of them not finished.

They fired it once more, and one ventured out and quenched it, but they quickly fired it again, and this took. Now is the dreadful hour come. Some in our home were fighting for their lives, others wallowing in their blood, the house on fire over their heads, and the bloody heathen ready to knock us on the head if we stirred out. And seeing no other option, Mary Rowlandson led her children out of the burning house, surrendering to the captivity of the Wampanoags. My eldest sister being yet in the house and seeing those woeful sights and hearing her son William was dead, she said, And Lord, let me die with him, which was no sooner said than she was struck with the bullet and fell down dead over the threshold. I hope she is reaping the fruit of her good labors, being faithful to the service of God in her place.

The Indians then laid hold of us, pulling me one way and the children another, and said, Come along with us. I told them they would kill me. They answered, If I were willing to go along with them, they would not hurt me.

So Rowlandson was now a captive of the enemy. Although she and her children were not directly harmed by the Wampanoag captors, they were forced with the warriors across the Nioangu wilderness. During this arduous journey, one of her children got sick and died. After this, she and her surviving children were placed in the custody of the sachem who would become the Weetamoo's new husband. Eventually, she was granted an audience with Metacomet himself. Fortunately, she didn't think it relevant to mention anything about his intentions or personality, instead, describing what it was like to smoke a peace pipe. Quote, There, one of them asked me why I wept. I could hardly tell what to say. If I answered, they would kill me. No, said he, none will hurt you. Then came one of them and gave me two spoonfuls of meal to comfort me, and another gave me half a pint of peas.

Then I went to see King Philip. He bade me to come in and sit down and asked whether I would smoke, a usual compliment nowadays among saints and sinners. But this no way suited me. For though I had formerly used tobacco, yet I had left it ever since I was first taken. It seems to be a bait the devil lays to make men lose their precious time. I remember with shame now how formerly, when I was taken two or three pipes, I was presently ready for another. Such a bewitching thing it is, but I thank God he has now given me power over it. Surely there are many who may be better employed than lying sucking a stinking tobacco pipe.

Yeah, so you heard it here first, folks. Tobacco addiction is the devil's handiwork, so you better kick that vaping habit.

Yeah. After this meeting, Metacomet actually began paying Mary Rowlandson to sew clothes for his family, and she traveled with him for about three months. Although she wasn't mistreated, it was a pretty traumatizing experience, as she constantly saw the corpses of both Indian and English warriors rotting in the forest. And she knew that at any moment, she and her two surviving children could be killed on a whim. She was also shocked to hear that many Native Americans thought things would get better if there weren't any more settlers around. She wrote, They mourned with their black faces for their own losses, yet triumphed and rejoiced in their inhumane and many times devilish cruelty to the English. They would boast of their victories, saying that in two hours' time they had destroyed such a captain and his company at such a place, and boast how many towns they had destroyed, and then scoff and say that they had done them a good turn to send them to heaven so soon.

Again, they would say this summer that they would knock all the rogues on the head or drive them into the sea or make them all fly the country. And I gotta say, I think that her perspective is kind of interesting here, because you know, you can't really blame this person for resenting people who have captured her, but I think that she might want to show some, I don't know, humility or perspective here. Like, the fact that she seems shocked that these people are resisting their colonization, I think is kind of funny to me. She was so wrapped up in her bubble, she didn't realize the ways these people might have resented the kind of hierarchies that had been mounting for the past 50 years. And this kind of reminds me, you know, back to our Ainu episode, the island of Hokkaido was in this terrible gray area, much like indigenous New Englanders before King Philip's War.

Because this was a situation where Japan dominated the northernmost island, yet Japanese law didn't actually apply. So the Ainu were not protected by law from any kind of colonial aggression, but the Japanese could not be held account by that same law because they were not technically in Japan. And this is kind of what we're seeing with the Wampanoag and all Native Americans in coastal New England, even the praying Indians who had accepted Christianity. Because even if you can't morally sanction the killing of Puritans by the Wampanoag, and I'm not saying you should, I think that you gotta sympathize with their feelings of desperation. And it's remarkable that Mary Rowlandson was so shocked at this perspective. And it's also remarkable that the English were so blindsided by this attack.

Yeah, and I mean, I'd say that, frankly, this might be even worse than what was being done to the Ainu, just because there were laws in place, there were treaties in place, and, you know, like these were supposed to apply, but nevertheless, the English courts almost never considered the native complaints to be valid at all.

Right. Right. And we're going to see after the war the way that the legal system was used to basically obstruct justice, not, you know, provide it.

Mm-hmm. Yeah.

So it's also notable that Mary Rowlandson and her children did not appear to have been abused because many later wars between white settlers and Native Americans in other parts of the country saw much more violent treatment of captives. If I had to guess, I'd say that this is because the New England indigenous tradition preferred to adopt captives into the tribe rather than harm them. So eventually the Rowlandson family would be ransomed back into white society and Mary Rowlandson would be reunited with her husband, although he died soon after the war. But nevertheless, she remarried and apparently lived happily for another 35 years.

Nine Men's Misery

We should mention, however, that torture did happen to male prisoners. A month after Mary Rowlandson was captured in Massachusetts, Narragansett warriors ambushed and killed dozens of militiamen from Plymouth, an army that actually included pro-English Wampanoags as well as white settlers. Nine captives were then brutally tortured and killed by the enemy. We don't actually know the circumstances of their death, but the settlers who found the nine corpses found it particularly shocking. A cluster of stones left to mark the grave came to be known as Nine Men's Misery, and it's considered the oldest war monument in the United States.

Massacres and the turning point

Right, although we don't want to give the impression that cruelty was unique to the indigenous side. Because beginning in 1676, around the time as the Lancaster raid on Mary Rowlandson's farm, inexperienced farmers in the Massachusetts militia began attacking Wampanoag and Narragansett villages essentially at random, regardless of any affiliation to Metacomet. Hundreds of Native American civilians were slaughtered by these settler mobs in what are essentially pogroms. Despite most of the victims being women and children, the Wampanoag fiercely fought back, actually killing many of their settler attackers, including a man named William Turner who had organized these attacks. And I'm editorializing here, but I think these kinds of massacres were the true turning point of English-Indigenous relations in New England. Because these attacks were so indiscriminate that it was clear that there would not be the same kind of future for independent Native American life anywhere near the English settlements.

The coexistence that marked the Squanto era was now completely unthinkable due to the radicalization of the English toward Native Americans during this war. As a consequence, Native Americans living near English settlements were faced with a brutal choice. Either you can enter into English custody as prisoners of war or flee to the northern woodlands free of English control. Both of these options were pretty unattractive. English custody could easily translate to a lifetime of enslavement. Meanwhile, the trek north left people vulnerable to attacks from hostile tribes, either from the pro-English Mohawks or from Metacomet's forces, who saw any unaligned Indians, and especially Christian Indians, as potential traitors.

The northern theater

But nevertheless, many Native peoples did make it to New Hampshire and Maine, which was the territory of Abenaki hunter-gatherers at this time. The Abenaki slowly waged their own conflict against small numbers of local English settlers, but like the settlers of the isolated Connecticut River Valley, these settlers were so few in number and so far from any English population centers that they were dependent on the Abenaki for trade and protection. The decision of the Abenaki to join the war on Metacomet's side was a disaster. Accordingly, the Northern Puritans were far more careful in their war with their neighbors and more eager to make peace. And interestingly, just as the Mohawks were longtime allies of the English settlers, the Abenaki had a particularly close relationship with the French. A young French nobleman named Saint-Castine was embedded with the Abenaki at this time to provide them with arms and teach European military tactics.

He married into numerous Abenaki families and seems to have eagerly adopted their way of life in the Maine wilderness. It seems that by the end of his life, some decades later, he was recognized as both the French baron and an Abenaki chief.

Which, again, I'm sure this guy would have listened to our podcast.

Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, there's actually a town named after this guy in Maine today, Castine. But I think the most interesting element of this northern theater, beyond, you know, the strange role of this French baron, was the fact that there were Indian raids not only by land, but also by sea. Because Abenaki warriors using both canoes and European-style boats attacked fishing settlements across the Maine coast, you know, getting off of their ships like Vikings to plunder the settlements, capturing and burning any settler ships that came across. And then later, at least one Indian ship, probably piloted by Abenakis, sailed all the way down to Boston Harbor, armed with a cannon. These guys horrified colonists by shooting at their homes from the sea, and although they never actually appeared to have caused any damage, just the presence of this bombarding Native American ship was this huge, you know, terrifying psychological factor for the colonists.

They never thought this would be possible.

Yeah, so consequently, most English settlers fled northern New England back into Massachusetts, which was an inverse of the refugee path taken by the Wampanoags and the Narragansetts who were trying to flee the fighting.

Richard Waldron

Few Englishmen remained in the woodlands, except for one group of militia led by a staunch Puritan named Richard Waldron, infamous even among the settlers for ordering the torture and humiliation of three Quaker women in New Hampshire. When these women were convicted of, quote, spreading the wicked errors of the Quakers, Waldron ordered them to be marched 80 miles through the freezing winter, stopping only to be whipped at every village on the path as a warning to other potential heretics. Eventually, another Puritan named Robert Pike convinced him to end this barbarism. Waldron was in his 60s when King Philip's War broke out, but he took to his new military role with great relish. Just as English settlers were fleeing south, he led his army north all the way to the Canadian Maritimes in search of the Wampanoags being sheltered by the Abenaki. He captured dozens of men, women, and children of both tribes as slaves and brought them back to Boston, where they would be sold off to Barbados, facing almost certain death in the sugar fields.

The tide turns

And during the same time, fighting in southern New England was reaching its most intense phase. A majority of English settlements far from the coast had been destroyed, captured, or evacuated, and nearly all mainland farms and towns in Rhode Island were abandoned as people fled to the actual island nearby. During all of this, English massacres of native towns continued unabated. And despite the Wampanoags suffering heavy losses of their own, Metacomet's army had punched a hole straight through the entire English colonial project. A year into the war, his warriors had killed thousands of settlers, about one in ten adult white men, and wiped out decades of English colonial expansion. The moral blow against assumptions of English and Christian superiority were incalculable. But despite the damage they could inflict, the indigenous side was running low on supplies. The planting season had been completely disrupted by the war, and trade with the more well-supplied English was now obviously out of the question.

And interestingly, despite being so far from Europe, the besieged Puritan settlers received occasional food shipments from the old country. And in fact, actually, a group of Dublin Protestants with family ties to New England organized a famous relief flotilla that arrived in August, known today as the Irish Donation.

But it was still very difficult for the English as well, just because all of these raids meant that they couldn't be out in the fields, naturally, because, you know, so this land basically went uncultivated for the duration of the war for like two years, basically. It was just not a great time for anyone involved at all. So, but nevertheless, the English were better supplied, and Metacomet, being aware of this, shifted from attacks to isolated country farms to more well-defended forts and towns, which he knew contained large food stores. But the native forces were much less experienced with those kinds of direct attacks. Not only did these attacks mostly fail, but large numbers of Wampanoags and Narragansetts were killed, including many Sachems.

The death of Weetamoo

A terrible moral blow occurred in August 1676. While on her way to lead a battle against an English town, Weetamoo drowned crossing a river. Her warriors likely saw this as a bad omen, because they abandoned the attack and left her body in the river. When Weetamoo's corpse floated down to the English town, the Puritans dragged her from the water and left her head on a pike to warn the others.

Yeah, and remember, Weetamoo was really Metacomet's most essential ally. She was his sister-in-law. They'd been together for about a decade at this point, and she was essential to keeping this Native American coalition together. And with her death, it appears that this coalition basically immediately began to unravel.

The death of Metacomet

And ultimately, the ending of King Philip's war would come much quicker than anybody expected, really without any kind of grand climax. Because despite the English having been brutally battered by this war, by August, they were now the ones who had been backed into a corner fighting for their lives. And I think this meant that they fought a bit harder, you know, and they also no longer were being drawn out into the countryside for ambushes. By bringing the war to the coast, Metacomet had unintentionally brought the war to the English's own turf, and it was a lot harder to displace them. He might be able to force the settlers to the coast, but he couldn't force them into the sea. And mixed teams of Mohegans, Praying Indians, and Plymouth militia chased the now starving Wampanoag forces across the burned towns of Massachusetts and Rhode Island. And within just two weeks of the death of Weetamoo, these men had the amazing luck to stumble onto a group of warriors led by Metacomet himself.

A Wampanoag preacher known to his people as Antaquon, whom the English called John Alderman, had once been a counselor of Metacomet and probably had inside information about his relatives's whereabouts. But after Antaquon's brother was killed by Metacomet for obscure reasons, possibly because he was a Christian, Antaquon switched sides and began to aid the English. And on August 12th, 1676, it was Antaquon who shot and killed Metacomet in an unceremonious ambush. Just like his sister-in-law, Weetamoo, Metacomet's head was left on a pike. His friends and children were captured soon after and sold into slavery in Barbados, at which point they disappear from history. By the end of August, the English had recovered most of their territory across New England, though it was now largely burned, and killed any remaining sachem from Metacomet's army they could get their hands on. Their Mohawk allies eagerly assisted in this fight, hunting down Narragansett warriors, including the sachem Pessacus we mentioned earlier.

By September, it was clear that the war had been won. New England was now truly the domain of the New English, and they no longer had any plans to share it with anybody else.

Right, sporadic attacks and raids would continue for another year or so, but nevertheless, this was very much isolated. There was no longer any kind of grand vision, and it was just put down very brutally.

Trials and enslavement

As soon as the fires were put out across Massachusetts and Rhode Island, trials were held for Indians suspected of direct or indirect involvement in King Philip's War. Hundreds of Wampanoags, Nipmucks, and Narragansett were accused of treason to the crown, a crown to which they had never consented to be subjects and whose protections were never granted. By treating the prisoners as traitors rather than enemies, the settlers had far more legal leeway to punish individual participants in the war. It's important to note that there was no peace treaty signed. There was no general amnesty to any who had surrendered. Basically, this meant that murder charges could be filed against any single, or in this case, treason charges, against any single participant in the war. It's a kind of unusual circumstance.

I'm not really sure where else you've seen this. I guess maybe after the U.S. Civil War, but then, of course, you know, with the end of Reconstruction, that was all totally half-assed.

Yeah, but I mean, even there, I don't think like a regular low-level Confederate soldier would have been put on trial after the conclusion of the war.

Even then, you're right. Yeah, this is really a really unique situation where it's basically the Puritans maintain this legal fiction that a war has not been fought and that any killing of a white settler in the course of the war was treated identically to as if it would have been like, you know, a murder during a bar fight.

Yeah, and so because of this, any Native Americans who were accused of killing settlers were hanged, while those accused of supporting the war in other ways were simply enslaved. We mentioned in the last episode that while slavery was once a temporary sentence in New England, by 1676 it had begun to morph into a permanent and hereditary racialized system that we now associate with the South. The burden of evidence required to enslave the accused traitors was very, very low, and some people were enslaved simply for being relatives of known warriors. While many New Englanders congratulated themselves on handling this war in a civilized matter and insisting upon trials, others recognized that this process was a sham.

Daniel Gookin and Deer Island

The most important of these figures was the Irish-born warrior Daniel Gookin. Gookin was an English missionary who had been the superintendent of the Praying Indians since 1656. During the course of the war, many natives had opted not to take up arms against the English, but they were nevertheless rounded up and sent away. The most notorious of these destinations was Deer Island in the Massachusetts Bay. Somewhere between 500 and 1,000 praying Indians would be sent there during the winter of 1675 and 6, consequently, ostensibly for their own safety against the hostility of both the native insurgents and the angry settlers. But in reality, this was a policy of internment. And like many other internment projects, this one had deadly results. Within a month of their deportation to the island, food shipments began to run dry and starvation became rampant as the natives had to subsist on meager clam banks.

Many would never have set foot on the mainland again, and by the time they were allowed to return to the mainland in June, over half of them had died and many more would die shortly thereafter from the sickness that had ravished their bodies.

Yeah, horrifying.

Daniel Gookin was among the Nipmuck when they received an ultimatum to surrender themselves and face deportation. In the run-up to the deadline, some 300 warriors on Metacomet's side entered the praying Indian town of Hassanamesit, among the last of the praying Indians to be deported, and took its unarmed residents hostage. The warriors strong-armed the residents of the town to join the resistance. As Gookin recounted in his account, which is called an historical account of the doings and sufferings of the Christian Indians in New England in the year 1675 to 1677, quote, the enemy's Indians wanted them to go quietly, then they would spare their lives, otherwise they would take away all their corn and then they would be famished. And further, they argued with them, if we do not kill you and you go to the English again, they will either force you all to some island as the Natick Indians are, where you will be in danger of being starved with cold and hunger, and most probably the end of all that would be being sent out of the country for slaves.

These kinds of arguments used by the enemy and our enemy and our friends' inability to defend themselves, together with the fear of hard measure from the English, whereof some of them had great experience. Upon these considerations, many of them were at last inclined in this strait of two evils to choose the least, as it to them appeared, and to accompany the enemy to their quarters under the promise of good usage and protection.

Right. And Gookin, as well as the missionary John Eliot, were the most vocal opponents of abuses inflicted upon the natives after the war, particularly upon Christian natives. And in the midst of a society braying for blood, this made them incredibly unpopular. One string of insults leveled against Gookin called him an Irish dog that was not faithful to his country, the son of a whore, a bitch, a rogue. God confound him, and God rot his soul. If I could meet him alone, I would pistol him. I wish my knife and scissors were in his heart. He is the devil's interpreter. If I could roast him alive, I would.

Yeah, yeah, this guy was really, really bad, clearly. He would be fined actually by the court because this was just too much. But it really goes to show that the mood was not at all pleasant.

Yeah, no, absolutely. That's the thing is that, you know, even when the war was over, there was a permanent sense of paranoia among the English settlers who no longer believed they could live safely among Native Americans. This is getting a little bit outside the scope of this episode, and I'm not really sure how strong the argument is, but a lot of people have tried to connect this post-war paranoia to the paranoia of the Boston witch trials about 20 years later. It's kind of interesting.

Yeah, who knows? Maybe we'll get back to that one, wink, wink.

We might have to put a pin on that one.

Segregation and the black codes

But to focus on 1676, we begin to see this general trend toward the segregation, marginalization, and expulsion of essentially all Native Americans from southern New England. Carveouts were allowed for certain groups like the Mohegans, who were longtime allies, as well as, of course, the thousands of slaves living among the English. But generally speaking, New England would become exclusively English, at least along the southern coast. We should mention that farther north, things were quite different because English settlements were about 50 years behind the curve. This meant that in places like New Hampshire and Maine, when the English settlers who had fled their farmsteads returned home, they realized they couldn't afford to upset the Abenaki anymore. So they actually agreed to a pretty unusual circumstance where white settlers in Maine and New Hampshire formally recognized the Abenaki as their overlords and agreed to pay them a tax and corn in exchange for protection.

And I think this is kind of funny because although the war was won pretty decisively by the English in the south, in the northern theater, the English kind of lost. It's just kind of funny how these things happen.

Yeah, yeah. It wouldn't be until King William's War in like 1689 that things would break out in hostilities again and the English would have a more fortuitous outcome in that one, I think. But anyway, natives who had stayed put and survived in the region after the war found themselves living under a very strict regime of restriction and cruelty. In 1677, as combat was drawing to a close, the General Court in Boston convened to pass new regulations on the life of Indians in the colonies. Many had their own ideas of what that would look like, and one set of proposals worth noting was written by Edmund Brown, who was a minister at Salisbury. He had been in the region for decades by this point, and he was thoroughly unimpressed by the Indians, believing that even the converted ones were duplicitous. He seemingly thought this because a convert stole a blanket from him at some point.

So man really kept a grudge. But the war turned his disdain into hatred, as shown by his genocidal proposal to the Boston General Court. In a letter written to them, he suggested first that diminishing their numbers, and this may be done in two ways: first, by the sword of coercive justice cutting them off by death that they apparently and very unjustly imbued in their hands with the blood of the English, and the second by transporting some others into transmarine parts. Additionally, Brown recommended, quote, their confinement to such places within prescribed limits beyond which to not go without peril for their lives and lest an English guard with them.

Right, yeah, it's kind of basically he's proposing the most brutal form of Native American reservations here. You know, these kind of Bantustans, essentially, where all New England Native Americans would be forced to live on. And the historian Margaret Newell compared these kinds of restrictions to the black codes that would be enforced on African Americans in the 18th and 19th century, even after slavery. These were these incredibly brutal laws that limited the freedom of movement of all black people, including free black people, with very similar tactics of control and surveillance. Ultimately, the Boston court would pull back from the most extreme of these regulations, but they still required that all Native Americans living within the bounds of the colony must resettle to one of the four official praying towns. These towns had to provide an annual list of their residents and could never host any Indian visiting from elsewhere.

Additionally, no Indian could enter an English town without permission, and the House of Deputies attempted to require all Native Americans to carry identifying papers at all times or risk the death penalty. Ultimately, a group of magistrates shot this down, possibly just because it would be too difficult to enforce.

Yeah, but nevertheless, it was clear which way the ratchet was turning, and it wasn't going to get any easier from here. According to the historian Jenny Hale Pulsipher, quote, by the beginning of the 18th century, popular animus against Indians was finally matched by legislation that codified divisions between English and Indians along race lines. In 1703, Indians were included with the growing black slave population in an order imposing a 9 p.m. curfew on English towns. A 1705 proposal would have banned blacks and Indians from intermarrying with the English. Only the protest of Samuel Sewall, who thought that such an act, quote, an oppression provoking to God, removed Indians from the act. In 1716, even Sewall could not prevent the enactment of a law under which Indian and black slaves were rated for taxation along with hogs and horses. In 1786, Indians' perceived distinction from the English was made explicit in legislation that succeeded in banning Indian-English intermarriage.

Crispus Attucks

Interestingly, intermarriage between Native Americans and African Americans was actually not prohibited, and this was relatively widespread as both groups were similarly racialized and forced onto the margins of English society, usually living on the edges of towns and working on the docks or as domestic servants. By the 18th century, we can find black New Englanders with identifiably Wampanoag or Narragansett names. The most famous of these is, of course, Crispus Attucks, usually considered the first casualty of the American Revolution. Although he's remembered as African-American today, his ancestors appear to have been both enslaved African Americans as well as enslaved Narragansetts captured during King Philip's War. And the name Attucks is in fact the Narragansett word for deer.

Owaneco and Samson Occom

But as the English reasserted power over New England, longtime allies like the Mohegans now found themselves subject to English authorities in ways that they did not expect. Their leader Uncas would live until his 90s, watching settlers encroach over lands that were once his. After his death, his son Owaneco sued the Connecticut authorities over some kind of shady land deal that had ceded large amounts of territories to the settlers. Owaneco was probably the first Native American leader to make a formal argument that the people were a sovereign nation equal to the English crown and not subject to it. He also made the bold move of directly addressing Queen Anne as his peer. After a two-year court battle, the royal governor actually agreed that Owaneco was correct and ruled in his favor. But across the 18th century, it was clear to the Mohegans that their military prowess was no longer useful in an English-dominated society.

They found themselves on a closer social footing to their subjugated Wampanoag enemies than to their one-time English allies. One Mohegan who hoped to eventually peacefully improve the civil rights of his people was the highly educated preacher Samson Occom, who brought the first great awakening to various Native American communities and toured Europe to raise money for native churches. But when Occom brought this money back to New England, it was swindled out of him by a white minister named Eleazar Wheelock, who used the funds to instead build the all-white Dartmouth College. Completely disillusioned with English society, Occom led a migration of Christian Indians out of New England and into the territory of their old enemies, the Iroquois. This kind of migration was a pretty radical choice. Clearly, Samson Occom and his followers believed that New England was no longer where Native Americans would survive.

Yeah.

Racism's New England roots

And we should mention that all of these trends of marginalization had been in place since the Pequot War in the 1630s. But really, it was King Philip's War in the 1670s that made these trends basically irreversible. The domination of white settlers over Indigenous people was here to stay and it was going to get worse. Because remember, you know, just a generation before, the Massachusetts Bay Company had a logo of a Native American with a speech bubble saying, come over and help us. Now there was no longer any pretense of living alongside or helping Native Americans. Even Native Americans who adopted Christianity, which was supposedly the mission of Massachusetts Bay, they were still victims of this same racialized oppression. The utopian project of a Puritan New England was now clearly for the English only, even though this had not necessarily been the case 30 years prior.

I think, therefore, you know, we can extrapolate enough to say that a lot of the development of racism in American history more broadly is in a way connected to the outcome of King Philip's War, because these colonies were so prominent in shaping the later civic tradition of the United States, especially because the literacy rates were so high in New England that they produced a lot more laws and much more sophisticated legal arguments than other places. New England laws quickly spread elsewhere, were adopted by people in neighboring areas, including laws involving race, intermarriage, similar kinds of practices.

Yeah, and again, the New England diaspora was vast in the early American project.

Totally, yeah. New Englanders basically founded Ohio, you know. There was a lot of influence of New Englanders in neighboring northeastern states like Pennsylvania and New York. And that's why I think that it's really interesting that King Philip's War is really not remembered today at all, because it really was this foundational moment in creating American society as it is today and really, I would say, shaping it significantly for the worst.

Yeah, absolutely.

Memory and Metamora

Although King Philip's War is hardly remembered today, it played an enormous role in the New English imaginary up until the 19th century. Literature abounded with lurid histories that established Metacomet's Revolt as the central trauma of the region. Mary Rowlandson's captivity narrative was part of a deluge of books which were published in the aftermath of the war, always from the English perspective and rarely giving credence to the underlying problems of indigenous exploitation which has caused the outburst of violence in the first place. But time inevitably softened these feelings of animosity and by the first half of the 19th century, New England saw a flourishing of sentimentalist literary accounts of the noble Indian, as exemplified by John Augustus Stone's play Metamora or James Fenimore Cooper's The Last of the Mohicans. The second of these was set during the French and Indian War of the 1760s and this book draws heavily from King Philip's War and confuses the Mohican people of upstate New York with the prominent Mohegans of Connecticut.

But at the same time as Native American life was being idealized somewhat condescendingly in New England, Indigenous peoples in other regions of the now independent United States faced the struggle of life or death. Andrew Jackson's presidency, spanning from 1824 to 1832, saw the question of the civilized tribes come to the fore as white settlers successfully fought to displace the Indians who had done the most to acculturate to the mores of white society. Many Americans rejected the suggestion that these nations should be oppressed and eradicated, and one of the most prominent advocates against this displacement was himself a New England Indian.

William Apess

William Apess was a Methodist minister from a mixed Pequot, English, and African background, and he claimed to be a descendant of Metacomet himself. He was one of the first Native American writers to publish in the United States, putting out a widely read autobiography titled A Son of the Forest, around the same time that Fenimore Cooper wrote The Last of the Mohicans. While Apess painted a vibrant picture of a living Native American society, rejecting Samson Occom's idea that such a thing was no longer possible in New England, his vision of Native American reality was anything but idealistic.

Right, because Apess detailed a miserable childhood of poverty and abuse, as his parents quickly separated and he came under the care of an alcoholic grandmother who then forced him into indentured service. He ran away as a teenager and joined the New York militia just in time to fight for the War of 1812 when he was 14. After the war, he returned to his family and started to reclaim his Pequot identity. It was then that he decided to pursue a career as a minister and a social activist. He settled down among the Wampanoag of Mashpee and became a voice for that community. The Mashpee at this time were managed by white overseers placed by Massachusetts authorities to deal with Indian affairs. These overseers were notoriously corrupt and wielded their power against the natives who had no recourse against them. Lands were taken from the Mashpee and they were arbitrarily forced into indentured labor, just as if it was the 17th century.

Apess became a voice for the community and was formally adopted into this tribe. And using a deeply Christian vocabulary, he excoriated the whites for their unceasing hostility against the natives, which he held to be in violation of these people's God-given rights. The hypocrisy of Massachusetts society when it came to Indian affairs deeply bothered him, and he wrote: As our brethren, the white men of Massachusetts have recently manifested much sympathy for the red men of the Cherokee Nation, who have suffered much from their white brethren, as it is contended by the state that our red brethren, the Cherokees, should be an independent people, having the privileges of white men, we, the red men of the Mashpee tribe, consider it a favorable time to speak. We are not free. We wish to be so as much as the red men of Georgia. How will the white men of Massachusetts ask favor for the red men of the South while the poor Mashpee red men, his neighbors, sigh in bondage?

Will not your white brothers of Georgia tell you to look at home and clear your own borders of oppression before you trouble them? Will you think of this? What would be the benevolence of Georgia? The red men think would be so in Massachusetts. You plead for the Cherokees. Will you not raise your voice for the red men of Mashpee? Yeah, so in this atmosphere of Indian removal fever, Apess was able to successfully wrest away rights from the overseers and return them to the Mashpee. But he had a very uneasy relationship with the tribe subsequently as a result of his lifelong struggle with alcoholism.

And I just thought it would be kind of funny to mention that a lot of the arguments that Apess made in favor of Indian sovereignty came down to the nullification crisis, which was a time when southerners led by John C. Calhoun were arguing that states had a right to nullify any federal legislation that they didn't agree with. So basically, Apess was taking that as a granted and extending that to these Native American nations who he presumed were sovereign unto themselves. It's just a very interesting thing and, you know, not a constellation of politics you would necessarily think of going together.

Yeah, yeah, nevertheless. Apess is very much a product of his time, but also a very interesting figure. And I think really the greatest reminder that although white settlers might have wanted to remove Native Americans from New England, they never actually were able to. And, you know, figures like Apess persisted. But what I think is especially interesting for our purposes here is that Apess was also, as we mentioned, a claimed descendant of Metacomet and a very active participant in the perpetuation of a new kind of historical legacy of King Philip's war. And he had a very different perspective on the war than any white settlers had.

Eulogy on King Philip

Right. In 1836, one of the last literary works he would produce, he gave a lecture called Eulogy on King Philip, which not only defended Metacomet's actions in the war, but compared him to George Washington as a freedom fighter for his people. The Wampanoags of Metacomet's time had left no written record of their experiences of the war, but Apess would attempt to recover their voices and to link the contemporary problems of Indian removal and sovereignty with the problems facing Metacomet's generation. He was suggesting a continuity, in other words. Quoting from it, he asked, Who is Philip? He was the descent of one of the most celebrated chiefs in the known world. For peace and universal benevolence toward all men, for injuries upon injuries, and the most daring robberies and barbarous deeds of death that were ever committed by the American pilgrims, were with patience and resignation born.

For injuries of much less magnitude, how the people called Christians slain their brethren, till they could sing like Samson. With the jawbone of an ass, we have slain our thousands and laid them in heaps. It will be well for us to lay those deeds and depredations committed by whites upon Indians before the civilized world, and then they can judge for themselves. How inhuman it was in those wretches, how they could go to enslave a free people and call it religion, is beyond the power of my imagination and outstrips the revelation of God's word. Oh, thou pretended hypocritical Christian, whoever thou art, to say it was the design of God and we should murder and slay one another because we have the power. Power was not given us to abuse one another, but a mere power delegated to us by the king in heaven, a weapon of defense against error and evil, and when abused, it will turn to our destruction.

Mark then the history of nations throughout the world.

Yeah, there is some irony in using Christian vocabulary to defend Philip's memory, given that Metacomet was very much opposed to the Christianization of Native American peoples. But like we said, Apess was a product of his time. This was the tool set he had as a Christian missionary in the 19th century. He then also proceeded to recount the history of New England, ironically recasting the white settlers as savages in the face of the noble Indians who had generously opened his lands to these newcomers. He inverts the oratory genre, one which many Americans use to glorify the deeds of their ancestors. And instead, Apess used it to shame these same English ancestors. He wrote, Let the children of the pilgrims blush, while the son of the forest drops a tear and groans over the fate of his murdered and departed fathers. He would say to the sons of the pilgrims, as Job said about his birthday, Let the day be dark, the 22nd day of December, 1622.

Let it be forgotten in your celebration, in your speeches, and by the burying of the rock your fathers first put their foot upon. For be it remembered, although the gospel is said to be glad tidings to all people, we poor Indians never have found those who brought it as messengers of mercy, but contrawise. We say, therefore, let every man of color wrap himself in mourning, for the 22nd of December and the 4th of July are days of mourning, not of joy. If you're wondering why he's mentioning the 22nd of December, that was because this was Forefather's Day, this now forgotten New England holiday we mentioned last year in our Thanksgiving episode.

Yeah, the other thing I find interesting is that he's here basically prefiguring Frederick Douglass's speech, What is the 4th of July to a slave, by saying that these dates are, you know, are signs of the tragedy that were inflicted upon these peoples rather than something that should be celebrated. And he ends this narration by extolling Metacomet's military prowess to the point of hyperbole, which was kind of the point of this, you know, genre of literature, where he says, Yay, he outdid the well-disciplined forces of Greece under the command of Philip, the Grecian emperor, for he never was enabled to lay such plans of allying the tribes of Earth together as Philip of Mount Hope did.

And just to explain here, he's directly comparing King Philip of the Wampanoag to King Philip of the Macedonians.

And then he continues, Even Napoleon patterned after him in collecting his forces and surprising his enemy. Washington, too, pursued many of Metacomet's plans in attacking the enemy and thereby enabled him to defeat his antagonists and conquer them. What then shall we say? Shall we not do right and say that King Philip, with his one talent, outstrips them all with their 10,000? No warrior of any age was ever known to pursue such plans as Philip did.

Yeah, I feel like that's a very ballsy move, just to say casually, oh yeah, Napoleon, you know, he was inspired by Philip and went down.

Yeah, yeah, you never know. And then he then continues to go on to list later atrocities committed against the Native Americans in the wake of King Philip's war and to highlight the hypocrisy of the Christians who failed to live up to the values of Christ. Apess has been called a Christian nationalist by a few people because he really wanted to expand the role of Christianity in the public sphere, especially over Native Americans who at this point were still very much hesitant to accept Christianity. But again, like, you know, that's this is the tool set this guy had. I think it's very clear that Apess's mind was in the right place, even if, you know, our modern secular values might not align with his.

Right.

Before we started recording this show, Liam actually pointed to the fact that a lot of the more secular types were basically slave owners, while these kinds of religious fanatics, for lack of a better term, were.

Yeah, that's kind of more of an 18th century thing. But yeah, around the time of the American Revolution, the general trend was that the more religious of the Founding Fathers tended to be the ones who were the most progressive on issues of race and class, whereas it was the most secular tended to be figures like Jefferson, who were basically these slave-owning elites who, with all their free time of not having to do any work, were able to engage in these scholarly pursuits and dabble in deism and secularism. It's this weird inversion of our association of political values today.

Yeah, and I mean, during the Civil War also, that was the dynamic you had going with the religious New England versus the South that wasn't particularly Christian until they suddenly discovered their faith when they started losing.

Yeah, yeah, we're kind of getting, you know, getting a little far afield here, but I think that, you know, this guy, Apess, who I had not heard of before, really interesting figure.

Metacomet Day

And one interesting aspect of his legacy was that King Philip or Metacomet survives very prominently in the cultural memory of Native Americans in New England today, because the white settlers were never able to permanently evict the Pequot, Mohegan, Wampanoag people from Massachusetts and Rhode Island. They're still living there today. And every August 12th, the Wampanoag of Massachusetts celebrate Metacomet Day in honor of King Philip's war, you know, in honor of this man who led the greatest effort to stop the gears of colonialism from turning.

Wrapping up

We're winding down here, but I just got to say, Russian Sam, you really did a great job digging up so much information for this episode. This is really such an important piece in American history, and it's a piece of our history that I think is really woefully underdiscussed and understudied outside of academic historians.

Yeah, yeah, absolutely. I just barely even remember this being covered in APUSH. And I mean, that's supposed to be the extensive one. We just got like literally a paragraph about it, and that was it. But yeah, this was really a foundational moment for the history of the American colonies, and it would really heavily shape what came afterwards.

100%, because the tragedy here is that, you know, despite everything that Apess would say about Metacomet's virtues as a leader, ultimately he would fail. And in the wake of this failure, the systems erected by the settlers would set America on a course of racial and social hierarchies that had not yet been so sharp and so formalized up until this point. So I think that whenever we think about the consequences of racism and colonialism, either in contemporary America or colonialism anywhere in the world, I think this conflict is a really good and brutal illustration of how these processes take shape. And in these circumstances of paranoia and desperation, it's really easy for a group with power to strip the humanity of the group without, you know, to see all of your enemies as potential combatants and to do unspeakably uncivilized things in defense of civilization. And I don't know, I just got to think that really the only thing we can do here to stop this from happening again and again is to, you know, work towards some kind of world where distinctions of property and power no longer exist.

Because otherwise, these wars are going to keep happening. People with guns and land are going to be able to terrorize those without. And maybe I'm just an optimist, but I got to think that as a species, we can do better than that, right?

Well, one would certainly hope so, although I'm not particularly optimistic at the moment, but who knows? A lot can change in a very short period of time.

Yeah. All right. Well, that's it for King Philip's War. This was a big one. And, you know, thank you to our listeners for, you know, your attention and your interest here. We've got some really good and less depressing episodes coming up, but I really do feel like this was an important one to get through. It really helps you understand American history in a different light. And I think that if you want to understand more about specifically New England history, this is an essential event to understand. It was foundational in establishing the psychology of later colonial New England. And I think, regardless of whether or not it directly influenced the Boston Witch Trials, I'm sorry, the Salem Witch trials, I think it's an incredibly important piece of context that usually goes unmentioned.

Yeah, so if you liked this episode, please let us know, send us comments, suggestions, and let us know if you guys want more early American history episodes going forward.

All right. And that's it. Thank you so much, Russian Sam, and I hope you guys enjoyed. Bye-bye.

This episode on Spotify

The show is also on Apple Podcasts, Overcast, Pocket Casts, Podcast Addict, YouTube, RSS and Patreon.

More listening