The Making of Modern Florida episode art

117

The Making of Modern Florida

Grace Cathedral Park

From 1880 to 1930, life on Earth was reshaped in ways previously inconceivable. Nowhere was this transformation more total than in Florida. In a single generation, a peninsula hardly charted since the days of Ponce de Leon was molded into a testing ground for new modes of living and capital accumulation. This episode of Gladio Free Europe drains the marshy mysteries of time to understand how Florida, once the most foreign of all the contiguous territories, became perhaps the most fundamentally American state of all.

Jackson (@GraceCathedralPark) returns to the show for a deep exploration of modern Florida history, running from the noble failures of Reconstruction up through the reassertion of Confederate control and the establishment of a new society, a unique and twisted marriage of northern venality with southern barbarity. Gilded Age robber-barons like Henry Flagler took to the waters for pleasure and for profit, turning the remote Sunshine State into a secret garden for the idle rich. Railroads soon connected Florida to the American mainland north and south, bringing both well-heeled investors and threadbare farmers down the peninsula. Poor whites in particular saw Florida as a beacon of the New South, where a man could make his fortune in land sales or the orange boom. But these newcomers had little interest in sharing their wealth with the African American residents of Florida, some of whose ancestors had been working the swampy soil since the Spanish era.

Florida after Reconstruction experienced some of the worst racial terror anywhere in the United States, with an exceptionally high rate of lynchings and episodes of mass violence at Ocoee and Rosewood, where white mobs ransacked black neighborhoods and murdered dozens upon dozens. Then the swamps, once a refuge for escaped slaves and Seminole Indians, were drained out to the sea, paved over to make room for America's newest feat of social engineering: the suburb.

By the Roaring '20s, Florida's economy primarily revolved around real estate and tourism. Middle-class Americans flocked to the new neighborhoods that sprawled across the ruined wetlands, many of which were designed for cars rather than people, and most of which were racially segregated. Meanwhile significant numbers of Cuban immigarnts migrated to the Gulf port of Tampa, turning a small fishing town into a cigar city that rivaled Havana.

Transformations along these lines happened across the United States, particularly in other Sun Belt regions such as Arizona and Southern California. But nowhere else were these changes so extreme, so rapid, and so destructive... not only to the natural landscape upon which these plains were laid, but on the residents pushed aside to built this petty-bourgeois fantasy. The state has been a theme park since decades before the Mouse spread his ears. In many ways, Florida is its own kind of twisted intentional community, and perhaps America's most successful utopian experiment.

Transcript

About 19,300 wordsPlain text

TranscriptThe Making of Modern Florida

Back to Florida

Welcome back to Gladio Free Europe. After a quick detour into America's satanic past, we are returning to perhaps the most devilish part of the United States of all. That is, of course, Florida, the sunshine state. I am here joined by Russian Sam, as well as our good friend Jackson, who really now is kind of our Florida correspondent.

Yes, our man in Jackson.

That's right.

Okay, so as a quick recap of the previous two episodes on Florida history, Florida was first contacted by Europeans in the early 16th century, even before the Spanish conquest of Mexico. This makes Florida in many ways the earliest or the oldest colonial holding in the United States, yet paradoxically, was really the last of the 50 states to be settled and developed along the lines of the rest of the country. In the 18th and 19th century, Florida would pass between various colonial hands, the last of whom, of course, would be the United States. While these flags were raised and lowered on various occasions, the real authority in the ground throughout much of this time were the Seminole peoples. These were an indigenous coalition of relative newcomers from the upland south who acclimated brilliantly to the Florida environment while also eagerly adopting various American technologies and fashions. But then in the early and mid-19th century, for various reasons all related to the attitudes and character of Andrew Jackson, the Seminole people were forcibly removed out of Florida.

Only a tiny number of Seminoles managed to survive, living in the Everglades essentially as guerrillas. In the years leading up to the Civil War, northern Florida would become an important center for the southern slave economy, as well as cattle grazing. Then, once the South seceded, Florida briefly emerged as the breadbasket of the Confederate states. Now, this episode, the conclusion to the Gladio Free Europe Florida trilogy, is going to pick up immediately after the Civil War, going up through to the development of the contemporary society of the Sunshine State in the 20s, 30s, 40s, and 50s. A society that is largely one of the suburb. My question for you, Jackson, which is kind of the whole question of this episode: how and why was Florida, in many ways the most foreign of all the contiguous states, incorporated into American culture and society?

Let's get into it.

Reconstruction in Florida

I guess that we gotta start with Reconstruction, right? You know, we talked about that a little bit at the end of last episode. I think that deserves a little bit more attention just going into how this state was brought into the broader American fold.

Revisionist narratives of Reconstruction insisted that after the Civil War, an unpopular Republican Party was imposed over an unwilling Southern majority. This narrative is nonsense. It was invented basically during the time of Reconstruction by Confederate revanchists, often known as Redeemers. These were generally white elites who disdained democracy, really in all forms, and more often than not, were members of the first Ku Klux Klan. Because Florida was about half black during the entire 19th century, the expansion of Reconstruction and the expansion of democracy meant that the Republican Party associated with African American civil rights and the Union cause would dominate Florida from the middle of the 1860s until the end of Reconstruction in the 1870s. During this period, Florida voters elected over 100 African-American candidates to statewide and federal office. One particularly notable Black Florida politician is Josiah T. Walls, a Union veteran from Virginia who came to Florida during the war and was then elected to represent the prosperous Alachua region in both the House and the Senate statewide.

One particularly notable example is Josiah T. Walls, a Black Union veteran from Virginia who came to Florida during the war and was then elected to represent the prosperous Alachua district in both the Florida House and the Florida Senate. Then in 1870, Josiah Walls was elected to the federal House of Representatives. In a move typical of Confederate holdouts, his Democratic opponent accused him of fraud. In 1872, he defended his seat against yet another former Confederate officer. This time, his opponent convinced Democrats in the House to actually nullify the results of this election. Walls was never seated. Undaunted by this underhanded defeat, he remained active in Florida politics throughout the end of Reconstruction, holding alternating terms as the mayor of Gainesville and the representative of the Alachua district before becoming professor at Florida's first historically black college. Another interesting but more obscure office holder was state Senator Egbert Sammis.

This guy was a free mixed-race farmer who I mostly want to mention here because his grandfather was Zephaniah Kingsley. If you guys remember from the beginning of last episode, Zephaniah Kingsley was an eccentric Quaker slave owner who paradoxically disavowed racism while holding dozens of African slaves, some of whom he also simultaneously married, apparently in imitation of a polygamist African king. His grandson Sammis went on to be named as the American consul to the newly formed Empire of Germany. As far as I know, this makes him the first black official to serve anywhere outside of Haiti and the Caribbean in American history. Reconstruction not only saw the political ascension of various black Republicans, but also the eager involvement of many whites, both some white Southerners as well as migrants from the North. And these groups were tarred by their white supremacist enemies as scalawags and carpetbaggers, respectively.

The scalawags, the carpetbaggers, and the many freedmen were responsible for organizing Florida into a true, albeit short-lived democracy, in which the huge population of newly freed black men could now vote and stand for office. Additionally, these groups developed the Florida economy in very significant ways, bringing new trade opportunities from northern cities into Florida ports, particularly Jacksonville and Pensacola, and even opening the first public schools in the Sunshine State. So, Jackson, my question for you here is: to what extent was the fear or the resentment of these supposed northern carpetbaggers, men said to be preying on the economically prostrate South? To what extent was there a real phenomenon of exploitation? To what extent was this just, you know, the loser's resentment? And how much of this might just be the inevitable result of mercantile capitalism expanding into the agrarian periphery?

Well, we'll get into this a little more as the episode goes on, but I do think it is worth pointing out that Florida was probably the most sort of interconnected with the North after the Civil War, right? Like a huge conglomeration of factors led to a lot of different Northerners taking an interest in Florida after the Civil War. So the idea that it was like an organized campaign of like Northerners coming in to take advantage of the, like, like you said, like the prostrate South does not really, I think, hold up to any historical scrutiny. And I think that I think that I think that what was happening, and as we'll see, sort of continued to happen as the 19th century wore on, was that Florida was just in a great position for the North to take a very deep interest in for a number of reasons.

And a lot of their sort of influence was obvious to people in Florida at the time. And as we'll talk about later, a lot of their influence was sort of not really aimed at overturning the social system of the Jim Crow South. And it was able to sort of comport itself to that reality a lot more easily than I think people would.

And so Florida is a weird state in so many ways, but I think just kind of laying the road work here for the rest of the episode, I think that you can almost see Florida as this Frankenstein creation of various systems and hierarchies and horrific traditions of prejudice all jammed together in a new kind of society that really didn't look exactly like anywhere else in the country.

Right, yeah. And I think it's important to point out that Reconstruction did last somewhat longer in Florida than in other parts of the South. It showed a lot more of the pattern of somewhere like South Carolina, where Reconstruction actually was able to, and like the civil rights of African Americans, was able to persist a lot longer than it did in other parts of the South, like in the Upper South and places that had sort of lower populations of former slaves.

Yes.

Because, yeah, go ahead.

Well, yeah, because they had to coexist because simply Florida was such a black state in this earlier period that there was basically no way for white settlers to exist without the cooperation of their black neighbors. By the early 20th century, that was less true. And really, as we're going to see in this episode, that's when Florida racism gets even worse and really reaches its nadir, not during the period of the first Ku Klux Klan, but in the 1920s, during the rise of the second Klan.

Exactly. And as we'll talk about, again, as we'll talk about as the episode goes on, the switch from a state where the population is majority in many places, a near majority in total, African American, to a population that is much whiter and as a result, is much more sort of invested in racial hierarchy. Those two things happen at basically the same time, right? So, the exodus of African Americans in the Great Migration and the influx of northern whites into Florida, those happen at almost the same time. So, Reconstruction basically, in sum, like Reconstruction actually lasts a little longer in Florida than in other places, just because these sort of these trends hadn't really started in the way that they had in other places yet.

Frederick deBary and the first tourists

So, it's in the 18th late 1870s and early 1880s that we begin to see the unraveling of Reconstruction, which was slower in Florida than in other parts of the South. It also saw another unexpected change that probably would have really bad effects on the lives of African Americans. And this is an unexpected change. This was that the warm subtropical climate of Florida, which was previously associated with death and disease, was now being seen instead as curative. This is to say, Florida was becoming much more attractive to white settlers. And probably the biggest factor here is the development of quinine, which dramatically reduced deaths by malaria. I think it's very interesting that this same factor also allowed for greater European and American colonial adventurism in Africa and Latin America. Events like the building of the Panama Canal and the occupation of Haiti, not to mention that Europeans scramble for Africa at the same time.

So much of this is because the mosquito, in a strange way, really was limiting white European expansion. Now, with the development of quinine, by the late 19th century, doctors across the United States had begun to prescribe fresh air, sunshine, and lower latitudes as a treatment for a variety of poorly understood diseases, tuberculosis in particular. Known for centuries as the captain of maladies, TB spread rapidly in cramped conditions like factories, tenements, or military barracks. While poor tuberculosis patients usually wasted away in highly contagious conditions, wealthier consumptives would board the new trains headed out west or take steamships down to the horse latitudes. Although now it seems that sunshine only has a very mild effect in combating tuberculosis due to the effects of vitamin D, this medical advice was so common that convalescents actually became not only the earliest medical tourists in American history, but probably the biggest group of Florida transplants in the years immediately following the Civil War.

By this period, the end of Reconstruction, Florida was still extremely wild. Probably 80% of the state looked exactly as it did in the days of Ponce de Leon, which is to say, endless swamps and impenetrable forests of cedar and saw palmetto and cypress. More and more towns were being built further down the peninsula, but these towns had very tiny populations. For instance, one of the largest settlements, Tampa, had 700 people in 1880. The population of central and southern Florida was so small in this period that wealthy convalescents and their relatives had a major influence on shaping the state's society and economy. For instance, German-born champagne magnate Frederick deBary made his fortune in New York, but after a tuberculosis outbreak killed his wife and left his daughter bedridden in 1871, he left the city for remote central Florida, purchasing land way up the St. Johns River in the tiny town of Enterprise near what is now Orlando.

deBary built a massive mansion that still stands to this day. Built and attended by workers, he shipped in from Manhattan. After his young daughter made a miraculous recovery, Frederick deBary muscled his way into taking over the local riverboat industry. These boats, which were predominantly staffed and piloted by local freedmen, brought thousands of settlers and tourists down the St. Johns River from Jacksonville. These deBary riverboats allowed for the birth of towns like Sanford and Orlando along or near the St. Johns River system. I think that, you know, this guy is not remembered very well today, but Frederick deBary really helped solidify the Florida vacation as an aspirational yet attainable luxury for Gilded Age Americans. Because in the 1870s and 1880s, just like today, retirees from across the several United States began to flock down south for a taste of the sun. When she was about 60 years old, Harriet Beecher Stowe, author of Uncle Tom's Cabin, purchased a home up the river from Jacksonville on the banks of the St. Johns.

Her home and her person would become kind of a local tourist attraction, as passengers on the deBary Riverboats would crowd the edge of the deck to catch a glimpse of the famous novelist on her front porch. But the biggest draw for river cruisers was hunting, as both recreation and occupation. Men and women alike would blast at any living creature they could spot on the shore. Exotic alligators were particularly prized by trophy hunters, but professionals would gun down entire flocks of birds, especially egrets, to pluck feathers that could adorn the hats of society ladies in New York or Chicago. By around 1880, the pine and cypress groves of Central Florida had already begun to be deprived of animal life. This sent the plume hunters deeper into the peninsula, eventually reaching the dark and swampy Everglades. Settlers realized that if properly drained and slashed and burned, marshy woodlands could be used to cultivate alien forests of European orange trees.

Russian Sam, why don't you tell us about the strange role of the orange in 19th century culture?

Orange fever

Yeah, well, oranges were quite the treat back in the day. You know, it was still something that you got from the Mediterranean. It's, you know, where we get the Jaffa oranges from. The bulk of oranges at that point were coming from Palestine. You know, it was only accessible in the form of marmalade jam, usually, just because that's what you can ship most easily, and fresh fruit obviously don't keep very well on ships. But the European and American gentry, they would build specialized greenhouses or orangeries to keep the delicate fruits safe from winter frosts in some parts of Europe. And southern planters especially had hoped to make citrus into new cotton, a cash crop grown through the labor of slaves. But even though Louisiana and Georgia can be sweltering in the summer, it only took a single overnight freeze to wipe out an entire year's orange crop.

Outdoors citrus production was thus not considered feasible in the South. But after the Civil War, as more and more settlers went west out to California and south down to Florida, they realized that they'd reached the orange zone, a climate suitable for growing citrus at scale. In years past, people had avoided Florida due to waves of deadly yellow fever, but now, orange fever was bringing thousands of settlers to the state year after year. From 1870 to 1890, the population of Florida doubled, which was a feat that would be accomplished again and again by a boom-and-bust cycle that would reappear many times in Florida history.

Yes.

Essentially, all of the landowners, including Frederick deBary and Harriet Beecher Stowe, had their own working orange groves. According to the historian Shana Klein, the author of Uncle Tom's Cabin even had her own export business, labeling crates of her home fruits with her name and the name of her town, Mandarin, Florida.

Yeah, I yeah, I actually grew up near Mandarin in Jacksonville. So, funny.

Oh, well, thank you for your service.

I love Mandarins.

Yes, of course.

Yeah, so poor farmers who were both landless whites and African-American freedmen came to Florida for their own slice of the meringue pie. The interracial nature of the orange groves and the riverboat economy so soon after the Civil War allowed former abolitionists like Harriet Beecher Stowe to hope that Florida would be able to transition from a slave and sharecropping regime into an egalitarian society of yeoman farmers. Harriet Beecher Stowe, who was herself from New England, encouraged northerners to move south not only for their health, but also to build a freer culture, part of the spirit of Reconstruction. She optimistically believed that white Floridians, both old crackers and newer migrants chasing the orange boom, would want to live in relative equality with black people in the interests of what she called, quote, the progress of Christian civilization. By the end of her life in 1896, the American South in Florida, in particular, would instead take a very different path.

But we're not quite there yet. For now, we can just relish in the optimism of the times. The orange trade was promising, prosperity, or at least stable employment regardless of color, and times were good. The only obstacle to the growth of the orange trade was the impenetrability of the Florida interior. There were essentially no roads south of Jacksonville, so very few people lived far from the coast or waterways like the St. John's River. But this would soon change.

And yeah, and just to kind of hone in on something here, Jackson, I think this right here, as we're seeing the beginning of northern interest in the Florida orange economy during this period of orange fever, this is a great illustration of the northern interest in Florida that you were mentioning. Florida was kind of this, you know, fallow ground that northern ideas about equality were believed to be able to be enacted more effectively than elsewhere in the South.

Yeah, exactly. And also, like, the citrus economy in particular, it's very emblematic of the post-Civil War agricultural economy because instead of growing crops that are made solely for industrial consumption, right? Like the cotton of the antebellum South, obviously, you can't eat cotton. All throughout the South, there was this sort of shift towards these crops that were edible, but also like cash crops, right? So in Georgia, obviously, we have the peanut was the sort of crop du jour. And in Florida, it was the orange. So I think it is significant that the shift after the Civil War was not away from commodity production, but it was instead honed towards commodity production that would be sort of useful in America for different purposes than merely just feeding like cotton mills, right? Like the growth of the citrus economy and the peanut economy in Georgia are both sort of emblematic of a society that is switching gears from a sort of earlier 19th century style of industrialization where the loom is really king to a later 19th and early 20th century form of industrialization, which is really built on access to previously sort of luxury-coded consumer goods that are also, you know, useful in reproduction of like a working class in the cities.

Yeah, yeah. So instead of having to eat marmalade from Jaffa oranges from the Ottoman Empire, you can eat fresh oranges made from the garden of your favorite author.

Exactly. Or even canned sort of citrus fruit. The Dole Company obviously becomes a big commodity at this point. So it basically retools from being made specifically for one industry, the textile industry, to being a commodity that can be used in a lot of different applications.

Henry Flagler's hotels

Yeah. And so not that long after Frederick deBary came to Florida and took over the, you know, riverboat economy, allowing people to much more easily navigate Florida by water, another wealthy New Yorker made his mark on the Sunshine State, and in particular, on its systems of transit. Henry Flagler, by this point, had already amassed a huge fortune as an oil man. As a partner of John D. Rockefeller, he was the acknowledged mastermind behind Standard Oil's scheme of horizontally integrating its way into a monopoly that dominated not only the petroleum industry, but about half of all elected officials in the United States. When Flagler's wife, Mary, became seriously ill with tuberculosis, he and his family sailed down to St. Augustine for the winter. But Florida initially made a poor impression on him. Too sick and too gray. St. Augustine only had one real hotel, and the sound of wet, infectious coughing was inescapable.

But Flagler could tell that this town's climate, proximity to the seashore, and romantic colonial history had the potential to make it something greater. Very soon after his wife succumbed to his tuberculosis infection, clearly not helped by the warm weather, Henry Flagler married her nurse, a much younger woman named Ida Shourds, who introduced her 50-something husband to leisure and nightlife, apparently for the first time in his life. Henry and Ida Flagler suddenly became regular fixtures at Newport, Rhode Island. Any fans of HBO's The Gilded Age will know this city as one of America's first tourist attractions. Wishing there could be a seaside resort with weather nice enough for swimming year-round, not only in the summer, Henry and his new wife returned to St. Augustine. Here, they set out to build a new hotel, not for invalids, but for lively young people, or at least lively young people and their rich older husbands going through a crisis.

So, opened in 1888 after three years of construction, the Ponce de Leon Hotel was designed by Brazilian architect John Merven Carrère, best known for his work on the New York Public Library. The Ponce de Leon was the first all-inclusive resort in the world, built in a fantastical Moorish Mediterranean style, surrounded by imported palm trees and a few native palmettos, and located just a block from the ocean. This would be the first of many hotels that Henry Flagler built along the Florida coast and is today part of the campus of Flagler College. Only one of these resort buildings still operates as a hotel today, the famous Breakers Hotel in Palm Beach, a town basically created by Flagler. But his efforts would have a permanent effect on the economic and social development of Florida, particularly because of the railroads he built all along the Atlantic coast. In accordance with land grant policies at this time, Flagler obtained an enormous chunk of the Florida shoreline completely for free.

Railroads and the Yamato colony

This land grant was 2 million acres of beachfront property. Just think about how much that will be wealth today. We might be talking trillions of dollars, that much real estate value. So we should mention though that even by 1880 standards, this was considered an obscene gift from the government. The federal government actually cut down this claim from 2 million acres to 200,000, still a huge amount of territory to build his train tracks. The Flagler Railroad and the associated Flagler Hotels became a major employer both for local residents as well as immigrants from Europe and the Caribbean. Homes were sold for just $1,500 a plot. That's $50,000 today. Flagler's model land company encouraged the migration of entire immigrant communities as residents. The most notable example is the Yamato colony of Japanese immigrants to South Florida around the turn of the century. Led by an NYU alum named Jo Sakai, no relation, dozens of families emigrated to what's today Boca Raton to grow pineapples.

Although the venture fell apart due to competition from Cuban pineapple growers, the site is now the location of the lovely Morikami Japanese garden. Henry Flagler was a master of civil engineering, hydraulic engineering, and social engineering. His hotels and settlements were strictly segregated on race and class lines. He deliberately used natural barriers to separate his wealthy northern transplants and hotel guests from the poor workers who made this luxury possible. The city of West Palm Beach only exists because Henry Flagler didn't want his own black employees living on Palm Beach Island. Instead, hundreds of Bahamian and African-American workers had to board rowboats before the break of dawn and paddle the width of Lake Worth Lagoon every day. Journalist Christopher Knowlton, whose book Bubble in the Sun is a pretty comprehensive account of the development of Florida across this period, describes how Henry Flagler turned the state into a hotel civilization.

South of Jacksonville, Florida was so little urbanized that each one of these massive resorts would become the economic and demographic center of gravity for the entire surrounding region. It almost brings to mind the kind of palatial economies of Bronze Age Greece. It's not the kind of society you associate with America. Regardless, elite society doyens like Mamie Fish of New York began to be spotted as often in Florida as in Manhattan, turning what had previously been one of the most podunk, god-forsaken states in the Union into the most talked about part of the United States.

Right, so for the most part, the Flagler resorts and later imitators were not open to the general public, but only to industrial capitalists and early celebrity tastemakers, as well as their coteries of servants and entourage of friends and admirers. Because these hotels were private, they allowed the strict decorum of 19th-century manners and morals to be relaxed. Men went around without ties for the first time in generation. Women could smoke and drink outdoors. These hotels had a reputation for romance, a place where young people from elite families could meet unsupervised, where robber barons could sneak away with their mistresses, or where would-be philanderers would meet young actresses or photography models normally outside of their cultural milieu. So by the end of the 19th century, especially as admission standards began to loosen, the Florida hotels developed a reputation for debauchery. Alcohol and sex were widely available to both male and female patrons, and the presence of pretty young women lounging on the pool was a big part of the draw.

Lots of parallels with modern Florida marketing here, especially the hotels in Miami Beach, as Liam grew up around and could testify to.

Yes. By the end of Henry Flagler's life in the early 1910s, Americans had developed this licentious obsession with bathing beauties. This is the image of young women in Edwardian onesies, which were at one time considered scandalously revealing. Famous filmmaker Mack Sennett hired hundreds of girls to star in beach-themed silent comedies, usually involving a hapless male protagonist surrounded by nameless young beauties in knee-length bathing suits, looking kind of like circus strongmen. The need to find more beauties and more beaches sent early film crews down to Florida. Bathing beauty films might have been artistically worthless, but led to more serious projects being shot all across the state. Jacksonville in particular had a brief moment as a genuine film capital rivaling Hollywood in the 1910s and early 20s. Directors and producers from Los Angeles and New York suddenly were major players in the local North Florida economy, using their clout to constantly shut down streets for filming and, in one apocryphal account, shouting fire at a crowd to produce a real-life stampede they could catch on film.

Florida's film industry

After World War I, local politicians began to oppose the influence of the film industry in Jacksonville, and this sent most of these film crews packing back to Hollywood. But throughout the 20s, Jacksonville remained the home of Norman Studios, which is notable as being one of the first production houses for African-American cinema. As South Florida began to be developed in the 1920s, the suburb Hialeah briefly also became a major shooting location, which is very funny to anyone who spent much time in Hialeah today. It doesn't exactly have a Hollywood vibe.

But neither does Jacksonville.

Yeah. No, it is interesting. You know, like these days, Florida is one of the least filmed locations in the United States. It's extremely expensive to live there and to film there, and there aren't really any good tax incentives like there are in Georgia or, you know, South Carolina now. But things were really different then. And it kind of shows, you know, like, you know, the idea that Jacksonville was a place with a lot of cachet. You think we could ever recapture that, Jackson?

Well, if if we if we follow the the GCP program, then one day we will. But I'm not having a lot of time.

We are going to build BYU for Owenism in Jacksonville.

Exactly. But an interesting point actually about the sort of decline of the Jacksonville film industry is that the local lore surrounding why the film industry left Jacksonville essentially makes it seem as if the residents of Jacksonville were kind of annoyed with the hustle and bustle that film production brought to the city. Like I know that a lot of the lore surrounding like why the film industry left the city has to do with citizens basically were at like town hall meetings and were like, hey, the film industry is shutting down all of our streets and it's sort of causing a huge ruckus in town and we don't really want that in our city. And so pass like a number of resolutions to make it harder for filmmaking to happen in Jacksonville. And that's really what led to a lot of the decline in the film industry there.

But I can't help but think that the fact that the film industry in Jacksonville was so heavily invested in creating movies starring and for African-American audiences. I can't help but think that that had a big part to play in the decline of the film industry in the town. Like, I think that the sort of association of the film industry with prosperous black middle class in Jacksonville had a lot to do with the decline in the film industry in the city. So we can basically thank racism for why Jacksonville is not Beverly Hills of 12 today.

Yeah. And again, this is going to be part of this episode and part of the story all across Florida down all the way to Miami. The increasing marginalization of black people in the early 20th century up through like the 20s, basically. You know, it's quite the, it's, you know, anyone with a Whiggish view of racial relations in America just needs to look at Florida to see that, in fact, things often can get much worse very quickly. On the subject of Miami, I want to get into now the early, early development of South Florida, even before Henry Flagler. Because we have to mention that when Flagler's railroads came onto the scene, there were no cities south of Sanford and Orlando with more than a small few hundred residents. We cannot emphasize enough that throughout this century, beyond Jacksonville and the Panhandle, Florida was basically depopulated. It was largely swamps and forests.

The Gulf Coast frontier

But slowly, after the Civil War, small numbers of hunters and homesteaders began to make their way down the peninsula. Along the way, they met older communities of New Englanders, Bahamians, and Cubans who fished along the coast, as well as the small remaining core of Seminoles who had successfully resisted the genocidal policies of the Jackson administration. So while this population was extremely small, there were some interesting southern Florida settlements deserving notice. Long before Miami existed, the only real urban centers in Peninsula, Florida were Tampa and Key West. These places are not thought to have much in common today. Tampa is a real metropolis if it's sometimes overlooked, whereas Key West is mostly really only known for bachelor parties and booze cruises. But in the 19th century, these two cities were Peninsula, Florida's primary ports on the Gulf of Mexico. Their proximity to the Caribbean made them increasingly significant shipping centers at the expense of Florida's older Gulf port, Pensacola, located way up on the panhandle.

Cuban Tampa and Key West

Shared proximity with the Antilles meant that Tampa and Key West were both heavily affected by political developments in Cuba, at this point still firmly a Spanish colony. In 1868, Cuban nationalists of all classes and all races heeded the famous call of Yara to resist Spanish imperialism. The ensuing conflict, known as the Ten Years' War, would end with a Spanish victory atop 200,000 corpses, about a third of them Cuban civilians. This failed revolution and its aftermath prefigured many later developments in Cuban politics, paving the way for the kind of guerrilla tactics used in the 1890s by revolutionaries like Jose Martí, and then in the 1950s by people like Fidel Castro and Che Guevara. But the most interesting part of these historical parallels is that the failed Cuban Revolution of 1868 produced a significant class of Cuban political exiles who not only held significant pressure in their communities, but were also able to exert pressure on the island of Cuba itself through sophisticated espionage tactics.

You had cells of Cuban Americans throughout the 19th century successfully agitating to overthrow the government of Cuba and even pressuring the American government to use military force to support insurgent activity or even invade outright. Very interesting parallels here with 20th century Florida, I have to say. But during the 19th century, about 100,000 Cubans moved to the United States, half of them to Florida, the rest to either New York or New Orleans. Tampa and Key West, as the only urban centers in southern Florida, were host to the most influential and politically active exile communities. These people supported themselves economically and often out-competed Anglo-merchants and tradesmen. Loyalist newspapers in Havana hated the Cuban diaspora, deriding them as pirates, an image that both Key West and Tampa would embrace with pride.

The most significant of all the Cuban immigrants to Florida during this period has to be Vicente Ybor. Ybor was a Spanish-born cigar impresario who fled the island after the government discovered that he was siphoning tobacco funds to fund the rebels. After successfully establishing a cigar factory in Key West, staffed by his fellow Cubans, Ybor then expanded to Tampa, a small city of only a thousand residents at this point, but still much bigger than any other city nearby. Tampa is fortuitously located at a great natural port and was also the terminus of a new railroad line built by one of Henry Flagler's rivals. In 1885, Ybor and several other cigar manufacturers worked together to establish a company town just outside Tampa, Ybor City, entirely built around cigar manufacture, owned and staffed largely by Cubans. Although Ybor's little colony only operated as an independent city for two years before failing and being folded into Tampa, its existence totally transformed the economy and culture not only of the Tampa Bay area, but Florida more broadly.

Cuban cultural influence was so strong in Tampa in the late 19th century that when thousands of Italians also came to work in the cigar trade, many of them assimilated not into American culture, but into Cuban culture. Bilingual newspapers were printed in the city, in Spanish and Italian. One Tampa periodical, La Gaceta, still publishes in those two languages to this day. The older Florida cracker residents of Tampa chafed against the swelling immigrant populations, in particularly because Cuban residents were often quite financially successful and very well organized politically. Inspired by the tactics of their guerrilla wars against Spain, Cuban workers constantly agitated for better pay against their employers. Over time, however, Anglo residents reluctantly embraced the city's Latin character, only because they realized this could be part of the romantic myth used to sell the city to investors. Just as Henry Flagler built his Ponce de León Hotel in old colonial St.

Augustine, real estate developers in Tampa and nearby Sarasota invented a fictitious Spanish history. This is why, to this day, the mascot of Tampa is the imaginary Cuban buccaneer Gasparilla, and why residents of Tampa insist that the Cuban sandwich was invented not in Havana or even Key West, but in Ybor City. Moving below Tampa, the southern Gulf Coast includes the areas of Naples and Fort Myers, as well as the Chokoloskee Bay and the 10,000 Islands. A major fishing source for the Calusa Indians for hundreds of years and still important to their Hispanic-speaking descendants during the Seminole Wars. These areas were practically uninhabited in the decades between the Seminole deportation and the extension of the railroads. However, small numbers of farmers, the first of whom were probably African-American, came down after the Civil War to grow sugarcane and oranges on the bay and in many of its islands.

Some merchants from the Keys began buying up much of the land in the area, including a family of Corsican descendants known as the Santinis. But by the 1890s, interest in southwest Florida grew as wealthy white Americans, mostly from the north, began to develop a passion for the pursuit that once made the Calusa kings of the Gulf saltwater fishing. In particular, the hunt for the so-called Silver King, a famous Tarpon. Fort Myers was an actual military fort just like Key West, and it was a Union enclave within the Confederate States of America. It was used as a recruiting station for escaped slaves and disaffected southern whites. Fort Myers was the site of one of the southernmost and smallest Civil War battles, and after the war, some members of the garrison formed a village that would grow into the modern-day city of Fort Myers. Many of the residents were of Cuban descent and maintained links to Key West.

But then by the 1880s and 90s, as interest grew in saltwater fishing, seasonal travelers came down to southwest Florida to spear tarpon, including Thomas Edison and his wife Mina. Many local crackers who knew the complex coast of islands and mangroves began working as guides around Fort Myers and the Chokoloskee Bay. One of the surly locals was Edgar Watson, a man connected in two of the most notorious unsolved murders in American history, including his own.

Edgar Watson, Florida outlaw

Right. So very little is known for certain about Edgar Artemas Watson, but he is one of the most interesting characters, I would say in all of Southwest Florida history, and maybe in American history more broadly. He was believed to have initially come to North Florida as a child, allegedly after having killed a man at nine years old, before going back up to the mainland to work as a ranchhand. Edgar Watson quickly fell into crime and is generally believed to have killed his landlord, who was the famous woman gunslinger Belle Starr, whose Oklahoma murder has never really been solved. After likely killing several other people in Oklahoma and Arkansas, Watson returned to Florida where he briefly attempted to go straight as a farmer, but he quickly was indicted for killing yet another man and then wounding a sheriff's deputy. At one point, he got into a knife fight with landowner Adolphus Santini, slitting his throat and almost killing him.

Despite all of these notches on his murderous belt, Edgar Watson assembled significant landholdings around the areas of Fort Myers and Everglade City, hiring lots of young single men, many of them Seminole or African-American, to till his soil. However, it was quickly realized that although many of these young men came to Edgar Watson's land to work, very few of them came off his land. Although this was never actually proven, it was widely believed that Edgar Watson was killing his own employees to avoid paying them. He was certainly responsible for the later murder of a family of white farmers who squatted on his land and refused to leave. After repeated requests and the inactivity of the local sheriff, Edgar Watson killed them to a man. For all of these reasons, Watson's infamy grew as a genuine mass murderer, one of the most brutal men of all of Florida, a stain on the very name of the Sunshine State.

It should thus be of little surprise that in October 1910, amid the chaos of a deadly hurricane, a mob of his neighbors confronted him at the steps of the local Smallwood trading post. Though details remain murky, the entire community of Everglade City pulled out their guns and blasted Edgar Watson to pieces before burying what was left of his body in a shallow grave. No charges would ever be filed in his death. Everglade City would remain a small shady town known for proclivity towards secrecy and smuggling until the present day. Speaking of smuggling, we are now moving from the Gulf Coast into the Atlantic coast of southern Florida onto Miami, a city with which I am personally very well acquainted and a city that stands apart from the rest of the country for various historical, geographic, and cultural reasons. With all due respect to Jacksonville, Jackson, Miami is at present the most significant city in the state, with 6.5 million people in its metro area.

This is double the current size of Tampa and makes Miami and its surroundings the sixth biggest city in the entire U.S. Miami famously boasts the largest Latino community of any U.S. city and also the world's biggest Jewish population after New York and Israel. And of course, we must also mention the populations of feral peacocks, chickens, and iguanas that make Miami so unlike any other American metropolis. But what I find most remarkable is how unlikely it is for this city to exist at all. It really all starts in 1894, surprisingly late for a major American metropolis, when a sudden freeze swept across Florida, instantly killing particularly vulnerable plants like pineapples and coconut trees, and destroying the profitable citrus industry overnight. In 1895, the very next year, before these groves could recover, another freeze swept across the state. Annual production of oranges plummeted from 5.6 million crates to just 150,000 crates, a 90% decline.

The great freezes

This one-two punch of 1894 and 1895 ended Florida's orange fever, spelling disaster not only for the orchard owners, but for the many people whose fortunes were tied up in some way to the fruit business. This included, of course, railroad magnate Henry Flagler, who began throwing millions of dollars in free seeds and farm equipment to entice his tenants to stay and rebuild rather than return to their homes in other states. However, this catastrophic freeze was not felt so harshly in the lower reaches of the peninsula, including the small hamlet of Miami, which in 1895 was an informal frontier community recently built around the older Bahamian settlement of Coconut Grove, as well as the Cape Florida Lighthouse. The most notable Miami residents at this time included Ralph Munroe, a naval commodore and yacht designer whose house, called the Barnacle, still survives, as well as elderly trading post operator William Brickell, who had previously lived in the White House as an aide to President Lincoln, and also Julia Tuttle, widowed landowner whose orange grove is one of the few spared in the freezes of 1894 and 95.

Julia Tuttle and the founding of Miami

According to legend, Julia Tuttle asked Mary Brickell, the Australian wife of Postmaster William, to send a flowering orange branch up to Henry Flagler's home in St. Augustine to show off the warmth and fecundity of her little town. Just a year later, Flagler's men were laying the groundwork for the Royal Palm Hotel, a new luxury resort overlooking Julia Tuttle's Little Grove. Within months, Flagler's Florida East Coast Railway was making regular service to Miami. Realizing that this rail connection would turn her town into a city, Julia Tuttle invested in her own hotel to rival Henry Flagler's. The small community voted then to incorporate their settlement into the city of Miami, only after Henry Flagler rejected the plan to name the city after himself. So there's a world where I'm telling everybody that I'm from a city called Flagler. I gotta say, Miami is a much better name. Julia Tuttle would not live until the 20th century, when Miami would grow from several hundred residents to several thousand, and also when Henry Flagler would extend his reach southward to Florida, where he built another hotel.

However, Julia Tuttle, as much as Henry Flagler, is really part of the development of the South Florida economy and is surely the reason why Miami, rather than say Fort Lauderdale, became the center of South Florida. After Julia Tuttle's death, Flagler became increasingly interested beyond Florida in Cuba and the Keys. The last of these he was determined to reach with the longest bridge ever constructed upon open water. Sam, please tell us about Henry Flagler's late-in-life bridge obsession.

So, at this time, Flagler, evidently a member of the trained community, in the sense we would recognize it today, had practically unlimited power over the Florida government. So, he faced no legal challenges to any of his private constructions or private affairs. When his wife Ida began developing a severe mental illness, he bribed his way into changing divorce laws so that he could easily dispose of her to marry a woman 38 years his junior. Therefore, his 155-mile railroad extension from Miami to Key West could immediately commence with no concern for regulation. He assembled a fleet of 123 boats to lay down the pilings and then train tracks. Christopher Knowlton argues that the only project comparable in scope and expense at this time was the Panama Canal. And we should note that both were largely built by black Bahamian workers who were a major portion of the southern Florida population.

And just like on the railroad, the conditions for the workers were miserable and extremely dangerous. They had no sophisticated equipment back then to track the weather, and in 1906, a hurricane ran through the construction site, which washed away 160 workers into the sea, of which only 49 managed to survive by clinging to the debris or swimming to shore. Another 50-odd men were killed by drowning or dynamite blasts across the next several years. The railroad was finally completed in 1912 after this series of mishaps. In what was probably his last public appearance, Henry Flagler took his train down the entire length of the track to Key West, where he met a joint delegation of U.S. and Cuban officials to celebrate the railroad. 82 years old and in very poor health, Flagler gave a quick speech listing his own accomplishments in the state of Florida. Before he arrived, quote, Palm Beach had three houses, two families, and an old bachelor.

Coconut Grove perhaps had three or four houses. Today, there is a very large population, filled with industrious and prosperous people, and thousands of comfortable homes exist where desolation existed only 25 years ago.

Right. And so when he died the next year, Flagler surely knew that his wealth, ill-begotten as it was, had turned Florida from a slice of swamp into a central node of American capitalism. What's more, his hotel civilization would become the blueprint for the next century of Florida development. Flagler realized the most precious resource in Florida was not its fertile soil or long growing season or even its abundant fishing waters. No, the most valuable resource was the idea of Florida. Henry Flagler sold the American elite on dreams of rest and relaxation just a train ride away where one could sip a tall glass of orange juice and watch the Atlantic sparkle under the boughs of a palm tree. Later generations of developers, men like the eccentric Carl Fisher, would bring this vision to the broader suburbanizing public. Per Christopher Knowlton, this hotel civilization would spread across the peninsula in the 20th century until it resembled something more like a civilization of suburbs.

Populists and Democrats

So now let's move on to 20th century Florida, where we're really seeing Florida as we understand it today begin to take shape. Henry Flagler's personal story of railroad and hotel speculation is in many ways indicative of the broader themes of late 19th and early 20th century Florida politics, the power of developers and speculators. With the end of Reconstruction in the 1880s, due to a mixture of intimidation, murder, and lack of zeal in its prosecution by the Grant administration, Florida drafted a new constitution and reverted to what it had been in the antebellum period, a one-party white supremacist state led by the Democrats. But in keeping with its unique position in American history, Florida's political system was not identical with the other Democratic partocracies of the Deep South. Please, Jackson, this is much more your turf than mine.

Sure, so for one thing, we talked about this earlier, but it's definitely true that the influx of Northerners that were looking for sun and surf brought their ideas with them, right? Harriet Beecher Stowe did not stop being an abolitionist when she set foot in Florida. This doesn't necessarily mean that there was a white block in favor of integration and civil rights necessarily, but it does mean that a lot of the issues that American politics shifted into after the end of Reconstruction reared their heads a little more significantly than elsewhere in the Deep South. Florida was a much more sort of recognizably American political situation than a lot of the other states in the Deep South were in the late 19th and early 20th century. So the main division in Florida's political landscape after the end of Reconstruction was between populist Democrats and your sort of establishment business Democrats, which is very much in keeping with the rest of the United States that were sort of more Democrat-leaning than Republican-leaning at this time.

It was definitely true in other southern states at the time, but it was probably next to maybe South Carolina, the most sort of the state where that was the truest, right? This sort of populist versus Democrat split or versus business-democrats split. So the first spate of Democrats brought in with the end of Reconstruction and the creation of the Jim Crow system in the state were basically fully in the pocket of rich landowners and business tycoons seeking to exploit and develop Florida's economy. And they greased the wheels of commerce to their benefit. The Gilded Age railroad construction projects of Henry Flagler were just some of the railroad speculation bonanzas handed out by the state government in the 1870s and 1880s.

Yeah, and just to add here, I think in our episode 101 on the American Bicentennial period, we talked about how this was known often as the Great Barbecue, in which government grants were just handed out like giant chunks of exactly.

And to that point, Florida looked a lot more like the underdeveloped states of the West than it did places like Mississippi or Alabama, right? Because the railroad bonanza giveaway barbecue was a lot more of a factor in the economy of the state than it was in those places.

And that's what I just got to add here. There are really interesting parallels with the development of Florida and the development of California, especially Southern California, which also had, of course, this orange industry, this Mediterranean obsession. But for mostly geographic reasons, I guess, and climate reasons, development took a much, was a much slower process in Florida.

However, just as in the western states, that generated a lot of populist backlash to the sort of railroad industrial government complex that basically governed the state. The populist movement that some former AP US history students may be familiar with, that populist backlash looked remarkably similar in its coalition in Florida as it did in places like the Great Plains or the rural Midwest. So you saw a lot of the same types of people in that sort of populist coalition. You saw small farmers, orange growers, and people who worked on those orange groves. They were really in favor of this sort of populist surge to regulate big business, to maybe defang big business, and to sort of break the power of railroad monopolies that really limited and really sort of controlled their ability to get their produce to the market.

Just curious, was this like an all-white movement? Because I know there were black populists in the 1880s and 90s. I'm curious if that was true in Florida too, or if that was more of a no, not really a southern phenomenon.

While the populist Democrats were, I think, a little more open to sort of collaboration with black people in the Midwest and in places like the Great Plains, in the South, and especially in places like Florida, it really did sort of resemble more of a sort of white supremacist project. Like it was sort of, it was, and indeed, we'll talk about this a little bit later, but it was rhetorically positioned as being against vested interests. And one of the vested interests in places like Florida was often sort of talked about as essentially the organized black vote that still existed in the state. They were basically sort of talked about as another sort of vested interest that needed to be combated. So while they were maybe more open to less sort of racist racism than maybe sort of bourbon Democrats and old plantation owners were, this was still a pretty racist movement, especially in comparison to the Midwest.

Yeah. And I also wonder, you know, we talked about this at the beginning of the episode, but this kind of reminds me about the ways that, you know, like supposed the supposed predations of the carpetbaggers, which they would have included here as anyone supporting the rights, the civil rights of black people. This is really just the normal expansion of capital, right? It's like how industry comes into primitive rural markets and various older allegiances are basically often dissolved, often leading to a backlash of people who are very vested in those kinds of allegiances. In this case, white supremacy.

Sort of a tangent, but I do kind of think this is why like American history and the history of places like Florida are so interesting, because we have these models of what capitalism entering a sort of economy does to the politics and the social system that it encounters. And a lot of these are sort of European models. And they get sort of tested in very interesting and very like weird ways by the sort of reality of America as like this place that has this sort of racial past, but it also has like very mixed and weird class pasts. So it is sort of like an interesting sort of test case where, yeah, the imposition of industrial capitalism, modernity that gets sort of metabolized into like social democracy in Europe, in America, it sort of takes a lot of weird and not always good sort of twists and turns into like these sort of strange dimensions.

Oh, yeah. Yeah, and I think it was Thomas Frank who talks about how there was this 20th century, later 20th century idea that the 1890s populist movement could basically be written off because it was racist. And he says, like, it is true that in the South, the populist movement was very racist. There's no way around that. But what this misses is that southern whites were just extremely racist in the South. This was not restricted to the populists. The Bourbon Democrats were even more racist. And even white Republicans were very happy to sell out black people to advance their own interests in this period. It was not specifically a populist problem.

To that end, the populist Democrats became a very serious force in the politics of the state in the late 19th century, in the 1880s and 1890s. And they were the famous sort of Grange movement that, again, students of APUS history maybe remember actually had branches in Florida. And indeed, one of their sort of famous sort of policy documents that they put out as a sort of summation of what they were about came out of a meeting in Ocala's called like the Ocala Declaration. So Florida in particular has a lot of roots and a lot of connections with that sort of prairie Midwest populist tradition. So they were a power in the state in the late 19th century and they were able to get a fair amount done through sort of negotiations with the more classical establishment business Democrats. They were able to get a number of state commissions together on things like health, which was particularly salient because of the sort of lingering effects of tropical diseases on settlers, but also commissions looking into railroads and railroad appropriations, railroad monopolies, and sort of the rates that railroads were allowed to charge for the shipping of their goods.

So I guess Henry Flagler was able to build as much as he wanted to, but they limited the amount of land he got forward.

Exactly, I guess. They were able to take it from 2 million down to 200,000. Eventually, in 1901, the Populist Democrats were able to get one of their own in the executive mansion in Tallahassee. None other than William S. Jennings, who, cousin of possibly the greatest what-if president of all time, and kind of a sort of unhealthy major obsession of mine. He was a cousin of William Jennings Bryan. He was actually his cousin. Yeah, parenthetically, Bryan, the great commoner, he was actually sort of himself really connected to the state. After he stopped running for president unsuccessfully, he basically retired into a role as like a real estate salesman for Florida property. He basically had a second late-in-life career as a like sort of vacation home salesman.

Many such cases. Yes.

Governor Sidney Catts

But from 1900 until basically the Depression, Florida's Democratic Party and the politics more broadly were more populist and open to government intervention than in much of the rest of the Deep South. And in many ways, they sort of presaged the progressive era of Wilson and the New Deal of Roosevelt. One figure in particular that I find incredibly fascinating and to be a really sort of emblematic figure of this reality and also just an incredible sort of Florida man was Governor Sidney Johnston Catts. Notable for being the only governor of Florida since 1868 to be neither a Democrat nor a Republican, Catts was a preacher and previously a lifelong Democrat. And in 1916, ran a primary campaign for the Democratic nomination for governor, where he basically utilized sort of modern campaigning techniques, including sort of whistle-stop tour of the state, where he would famously give speeches and then he would shoot his sort of two six shooters he kept with him into the air like Yosemite Sam.

And he would also sort of drove around the state in a Model T that had loudspeakers sort of attached to the top of it, imploring the listener to vote for Catts. Basically, due to like skullduggery and like graft, the Democratic establishment basically made it so that he lost a very narrow primary election for the Democratic nomination in what would be the first, but certainly not the last time that the Florida Supreme Court would step in to rig an election. Undeterred and determined to be governor, Catts ran as the candidate for the Prohibition Party in the general election. He was a deeply populist candidate who promised to fight big business and inaugurate many of the progressive reforms we now associate with modern government. He more than anything ran on the dual promise of prohibition of alcohol and anti-Catholic nativism, sort of another in the long line of American figures to sign the know-nothing apology form.

Catts, a Florida man's Florida man, managed to drive his Model T right into the executive mansion. Actually, literally, he drove the Model T to his inauguration ceremony, but he ultimately basically didn't accomplish anything. And in many ways, he kind of embodied sort of Florida's late 19th, early 20th political system after Reconstruction. He was hideously racist, even sort of by the day's standards. He was very kooky. He was very crazy. But he also sort of, against type, was interested in the creation of a sort of modern administrative state, the kind of thing that was a core part of the identity of later successful Democratic attempts at sort of state building like Wilson and eventually FDR. So, just an addendum, we talked about this a little bit, but while Florida's political system was sort of populist, it was also still like very much a white supremacist apartheid state where white supremacy was, if not like literally the law, it was at least de facto the law in the state.

The populist surge that brought the great commoner's cousin into Tallahassee was, at the end of the day, like we said, basically a movement of white people. And it can really best be understood as a movement of sort of the sort of cracker yeoman against big railroads and big landowners and big business. Most black Floridians at the time still lived the sort of classical imagination of the Jim Crow South, right? They lived as tenant farmers or they lived as wage laborers working for sort of reduced pay in segregated communities that were more or less unable to share in the development of sort of northern capitalism that after the Civil War brought.

Rosewood and Ocoee

Yeah. No, and it's clear that people today debate to what extent Florida is part of the South. In the 1910s and 20s, Florida was as southern as any other southern state with all of the horrors that that entails. During this period, Florida actually had the highest rate of lynchings per capita of any U.S. state. This is also happening during a period of Florida becoming basically more white and less black. We mentioned obviously the introduction of quinine, the spread of the orange boom. You also begin seeing many black people leaving the state of Florida, largely due to rising levels of horrific racial violence, especially in the early 1920s. So at Ocoee outside Orlando, anywhere between 12 and 80 black people were killed across two days in November, coinciding with the 1920 election. This occurred at the height of the Ku Klux Klan's resurgence after the release of D.W.

Griffith's Birth of a Nation and a nationwide wave of racial violence against black communities. Locally, these murders were fueled by resentment against the handful of prosperous black farmers who overcame Jim Crow by paying the odious poll tax, not only for themselves, but also by starting a fund to pay for their friends and neighbors who couldn't afford it. Despite following all of the rules laid out in this white supremacist society, these black residents of Ocoee were still barred from voting by white workers who simply didn't believe they had paid the tax. When two men involved in the poll fund showed up to insist that these people had really paid their poll tax and thus were eligible to vote, white residents flew into a frenzy. Led by a retired cop and active Klansman named Sam Salisbury, the white mob rioted and burned its way through the Black district of Ocoee, murdering at minimum a dozen people and forcing hundreds, over a quarter of the town's entire population, to flee for their lives.

The only arrests made out of this slaughter, which included hanging, gunfire, and burning, were in fact Estelle and Karitha Perry, two black women, wife and daughter of victim July Perry. Perry had managed to kill two white men in self-defense as they raided his home prior to killing him. An all-white grand jury said, We go on record being opposed to mob rule and deploring any semblance to lynch law, yet they refused to prosecute any of the men involved in perpetrating the lynchings. Dissatisfied with the bungled investigation by U.S. Attorney General A. Mitchell Palmer, notorious already for his heavy-handed anti-communist raids, members of the NAACP took matters into their own hands. Future Executive Secretary Walter White, who is of mixed descent and easily passed as a white man, visited Ocoee undercover. He found that local residents, believing they were speaking to a fellow Florida cracker, eagerly bragged about killing African Americans who attempted to vote.

White reported to the NAACP that at minimum, 30 people had been killed. He presented these findings to the U.S. Congress in 1921, part of an effort to support anti-lynching congressman Leonidas Dyer, whose efforts we discussed back in episode 83. However, Walter White was met with little interest from the mostly white congressmen and even abuse and disrespect from Southern representatives. However, if not for Walter White's investigation and testimony, it's very unlikely that this massacre, which may have had up to 83 victims, would be known at all. Even more notorious than Ocoee was the Rosewood Massacre, committed in 1923 in Levy County, named after 19th century congressman and slave owner David Levy Yulee, we've mentioned previously. Rosewood, taking its name from the coastal pine trees that were part of the economic bedrock of the Gulf of Mexico, was a primarily black logging town where some black residents enjoyed a degree of prosperity.

Just like in Ocoee, whites were threatened by this economic competition and resorted to extreme violence to enforce their power over the community. After a young white woman named Fanny Taylor alleged that a black man had beaten and robbed her, false rumors began to spread that she had been raped. Convinced that her attacker was a black prisoner who escaped from a local chain gang, we should mention, chain gangs were a major part of the Florida workforce, including on the railroads, a mob then seized and killed many innocent black people in the search for this suspected escaped convict. The white mob then went into the house of Sylvester Carrier, a local music teacher who was sheltering two dozen black residents in his home. After the mob accused Sylvester of gloating over the beating of Fanny Taylor, Sylvester grabbed a gun to defend himself. The mob then began shooting blindly into the house, killing Sylvester and many other people inside the home.

The ensuing rampage saw the entire destruction of the town of Rosewood. In their fury, the white supremacist mob even burned the white side of town. At least one black resident was forced to dig his own grave before being shot. Victims were shoved into mass graves by farming plows. The lack of investigation means that the death toll, at minimum 20 to 30 people, is never going to be properly known. I gotta say, you know, you learn about the Rosewood incident in high school in Florida, but it really is horrific. There's very little in contemporary American history that really seems like this. It looks like the kind of ethnic violence you're seeing in Europe around this time, the 20s and 30s.

Yeah, the only reason why I know about it is because they made a movie about it in the 90s that's quite good with Don Cheadle. Yeah, I recommend that. It's called Rosewood. And I mean, yeah, it's just very shocking just because this was a community that was, by all accounts, like prosperous and fairly well integrated. Like these people were being killed by their neighbors with whom they had fairly amicable relationships in most of the South. So it was just really, really shocking.

Yeah, yeah. No, and you know, so even, you know, by the time this was considered shocking, but there was no immediate action, it's possible that the backlash against Rosewood and Ocoee might have led to kind of the slow decline of lynchings across the 20s and 30s, but no compensation was ever paid to the victims until the 90s, seven years later, by which point nearly all of them were dead. And we also mentioned that, you know, Rosewood and Ocoee are the most shocking episodes of violence, which really I think could be understood as like genocidal hysteria. But there were smaller outbursts of violence against black Floridians regularly throughout this period, all across the peninsula. Racial animus in 1920s Florida was so extreme that at least one white man was a victim of anti-black prejudice. Spanish immigrant and bartender Manuel Cabeza was attacked by a lynch mob in 1921 for the offense of living with a black woman.

After shooting and killing one of his attackers, Cabeza was arrested. However, a mob then broke into the jail and dragged him through the streets of Key West, hanging him from a palm tree on Christmas Day. Then in 1929, Lebanese immigrant couple Nula and Hasna Romi were killed by a mob that included members of the local police. Though Christian and legally designated as white, they still found themselves victims of the extreme paranoia and racism of the Second Klan era. And this violence was occurring in the context of major demographic changes in Florida. White migration was happening at a very rapid pace at the same time as an exodus of black refugees. From 1890 to 1950, Florida shifted from being around 50% black to being 20% black. And as we mentioned at the top of this episode, this shift meant that racist whites no longer had to be accommodating of their black neighbors to ensure their own survival.

Jim Crow Florida

Conditions clearly worsened for black Floridians during this period from like 1890 to 1930. A complete and final reversal of the relative colorblindness of Florida's frontier days, which we discussed back in our first episode of this series. With a small handful of exceptions, economic bonanzas like the orange fever and the 1920s land boom that we'll get into offered prosperity only to whites. While many black workers found employment during these times as railroad workers or construction workers or as hotel and domestic staff, racist policies prevented much social advancement.

Can I add something to that? Yeah, so I think that maybe viewers are sort of viewers. I think that maybe listeners of this might be sort of familiar with the Tulsa massacre also in the 1920s.

Of course.

And it's kind of worth pointing out that not only was this sort of a nationwide phenomenon that occurred like basically throughout the 1920s, but that it really does sort of fit in with the sort of broader vibe of the late 1910s and early 1920s as like this really big crisis point both in the country and sort of globally, right? And because of these sort of tensions and these crises of especially World War I, but also, you know, the Spanish flu and then economic downturn after the end of World War I.

The Russian Revolution, the fear of Bolshevism.

Exactly. Yes, like the 1918, 1919 sort of anti-communist wave. Basically, like we were talking about earlier, about how American history sort of filters our expectations of the world into a completely new and oftentimes way worse sort of outcome. I think that you really can understand the things happening in Florida and nationwide really as this sort of American affide equivalent to things that are happening in Europe and happening throughout the world, just with this sort of really ugly, sort of racial aspect to it as well.

Yeah, yeah. And there was something else I know that you wanted to touch on, Jackson, that I find very interesting but don't know much about, which is how during this period, African Americans being totally excluded from white society pretty successfully managed to make a living outside it.

Zora Neale Hurston's Florida

Yeah, right. So listeners who have read Zora Neale Hurston, who was herself a resident of Florida, listeners who have read Their Eyes Were Watching God may be familiar with the town of Eatonville, which was a settlement in Orange County that was created at the end of the 19th century to be basically a black-only community, but not in the negative sense, right? It was created as a black-only community that would be run by black people, sort of with the improvement of their sort of social position in mind. It was founded in 1884 by a collective of black settlers who basically wanted to found a, and this is quote, a colony for colored people. And it became a small but significant area for black self-government through the late 19th and early 20th century. It's important to remember that the Jim Crow South was not a system where black people were wholly excluded from participating in civil society.

They were just excluded enough to where they wouldn't affect sort of the overall sort of outcome of state-wide politics, right? So Eatonville was this sort of oasis for black self-government and self-determination in this sort of sea of like white supremacy in Florida.

Yeah. And then on a smaller scale, you also see all of these black farmers south of Lake Okeechobee moving into the Everglades in the like around the turn of the century area, right around the same time that Miami was founded. And I think the Everglades element is also interesting because it kind of shows how Florida, the swamps of Florida, were still this place of refuge, just as they had been in the 16th century when freed slaves were coming down to Fort Mose.

Exactly. And it really does.

18th century, rather.

Yeah. It kind of puts a slightly darker sort of, already dark, but even more dark sort of lens on the sort of the draining of the Everglades and the sort of reclamation of swampland. Like that the region is sort of undeveloped, but because of its undevelopedness, it sort of exists as a refuge for sort of social outcasts that starts getting closed as the government encroaches. But I think there's worth remembering that, you know, we've talked a lot in this sort of limited series about how the like Florida is a place that people sort of project their hopes and dreams onto, right? Like we've talked about how it was the site of a bunch of intentional communities. We talked about how Henry Flagler really produced this vision of Florida as like, you know, dreamland, wonderland of vacationing and hotels and sort of leisure. That's also true for the black community that had lived there since the Spanish period, but you know, most sort of significantly since the introduction of American like plantation agriculture, right?

Florida, because it was so, it was still thought of in this sort of frontier sort of framework. It was still thought of as a very wild place. There were still places that had not been sort of touched by the encroachment of sort of white civil society. It was still seen by some black people as a place of refuge, right? Like a place where black people already lived because they lived in Florida and significant populations, but that also they could sort of move to and go to to basically build a new sort of frontier like home for black people in the wake of the sort of Jim Crow reestablishment of white supremacy in the state.

Yeah. And I think that this is especially interesting when you see that every Florida urban center was just extremely segregated. And this might not be surprising, you know, because it's a place in the South, but I think that a lot of people think that Miami was never part of the South and that it isn't the case at all. So probably the nicest part of Miami, Coral Gables, was so segregated in the 20s and 30s when it was founded that black residents were forced to carry day passes proving that they had expressed permission to visit. They couldn't live there. They could only be there for, you know, as workers. Meanwhile, in Miami, Bahamian immigrants had been part of the social fabric of the community since before it was even incorporated into a city. And then later, African Americans came down from all across the U.S. to work on the Flagler Railroad.

The land boom

But they just had really no way to advance politically and socially in the broader community except through working in very segregated and deprived black communities. I think the most interesting example of somebody who could kind of sort of break through all of this was a guy named Dana Dorsey. He was a railway worker born to freed slave parents from Georgia, and he very wisely invested in South Florida real estate around the time of World War I. He was Florida's first black millionaire, and he was briefly the owner of most of what would become Miami Beach, a barrier island off the coast of Miami proper. Dana Dorsey intended to turn Miami Beach into Florida's first integrated vacation spot because all of the Florida hotels were completely racially segregated at this time. But then in the brief recession of 1918 caused by the Spanish flu, Dana Dorsey was ruined.

He sold the land to showboating car salesman Carl G. Fisher, but did manage to invest what little he had left into the Miami neighborhood of Overtown. Overtown is an area that was once known as the Harlem of the South because of its relative prosperity and also the huge influence that it had in the jazz world. So Carl Fisher, do you know much about this guy, Jackson?

No, I do not.

Carl Fisher and Miami Beach

Carl Fisher, who reminds us a lot of Governor Catts, the Prohibition Party guy, he is dubiously considered the father of Miami Beach. Fisher was born in the Ku Klux Klan hotbed of Greensburg, Indiana, and first emerged in the public eye as part of the first generation of auto hot rodders. A man who lived fast every day of his life, Carl Fisher made a fortune as a car salesman and a mechanic in the early 20th century while competing on the weekends in local races and being one of the major figures behind the Indianapolis 500. Notoriously reckless, these races had no safety precautions. In at least one occasion, a spectator was splattered by a car spinning out of control. I think this is very illustrative for the rest of Carl Fisher's career. A master of marketing, he first gained national attention by lifting a car up into the sky by a hot air balloon to spread the word about his business.

Fisher was a reprobate womanizer with a penchant for very young girls. He married his wife Jane when she was 15 and he was 35 and already engaged to another woman. During their honeymoon, a river cruise down the Mississippi, he abandoned his underage bride to carouse for several days through the brothels of New Orleans. Despite all of this, they remained married for 17 years, which upon their divorce was longer than she had been alive before her marriage. During World War I, Carl Fisher made his way down to the still pretty tiny city of Miami and took particularly notice of the barely developed island of Miami Beach just across the shore. He oversaw the construction of the first rickety one-lane bridge connecting the island to the mainland, and then bought out African-American landowner Dana Dorsey. He transformed this island into a racially segregated playground for well-heeled vacationers. Desiring to attract a younger and wider audience than the older Flagler hotels, Fisher continued his use of great stunts involving hot air balloons and animals, particularly two live elephants, to draw investors to his development projects and land sales.

He leaned very hard into the bathing beauties trend, arranging photo shoots of scantily clad women, including his wife Jane, to lure men to Miami. Famously an advocate of the automobile, he also ensured that Miami Beach and the mainland would be dominated not by public transit, but by the private automobile. This initially led to catastrophe, as the spread of cars outpaced the growth of the roads, causing South Florida to have never before seen levels of congestion. In the 1920s, this is going to have a catastrophic effect. But here, in the you know 1910s, early 20s, Fisher's antics contributed to a population explosion across South Florida and the entire state. Around the same time as Miami's expansion, the slightly older hotel colony of Palm Beach was growing into the biggest winter shelters for wealthy northerners. The most important figure associated with Palm Beach in the 20s has to be Addison Mizner, if you've heard of this guy, Jackson.

Addison Mizner and Boca Raton

He was this larger-than-life, literally, Klondike prospector, turned self-taught architect. 6'2, 300 pounds, and as close to openly gay as you could be in the jazz age, he cut a very wide shadow across the development of Palm Beach. Following the example of Henry Flagler and John Carrère, Mizner had a sophisticated understanding of Spanish, Italian, and North African architecture, which helped give South Florida its distinctive Mediterranean look. The most famous of all his various constructions is a 1927 waterfront home built for the Post cereal heiress and now known for other reasons, that is, Mar-a-Lago. Addison Mizner ingratiated himself with all of the wealthy northerners wintering in Florida, including many early filmmakers, as well as renowned songwriter Irving Berlin. Irving Berlin was a major investor in the town of Boca Raton, which largely only exists due to Mizner's initiative, but his eyes were even bigger than his stomach. He was unable to execute the great plans he drew for the city, which he thought would rival both Palm Beach and Miami.

Boca Raton is a perfectly nice town today, but most of its population comes from a later wave of migrants, many of them retirees in the 60s, 70s, and 80s. The initial plan for Palm Beach was basically a bust due to the events of 1926 that we're about to get into. In the 50s, long after the architect had died, his friend Irving Berlin wrote a never-produced musical based on the life of Addison Mizner, as well as his brother Wilson, a notorious opium dealer and womanizer. Later, in 2003, this would become the basis for Stephen Sondheim's musical Road Show, which is kind of the main reason I know about Mizner. But this is all to say that across the teens and the 20s, many land speculators hoped to achieve the same wealth and success of Carl Fisher, some of them recording, some of them resorting to the same kinds of attention-grabbing tactics.

Coral Gables

Coral Gables, Florida, only exists through the efforts of another segregationist visionary, George Merrick, responsible for those African-American day passes. A more sophisticated planner than Carl Fisher, he turned cropfields and orange groves outside Miami into the genuine beautiful suburb of Coral Gables, replete with Mediterranean architecture and various villages built in other foreign styles like Chinese and Dutch, often including homes designed by Addison Mizner. Initially envisioned as a car-free town, possibly as a middle finger to Carl Fisher, Coral Gables still has iron hitching posts for horses all around its downtown boulevards. Another notable developer we should mention was five-foot-tall David Davis, who after a failed stint in the Jacksonville film industry, moved from Tampa to Miami, where he made a modest fortune in real estate. Impressed by the activities of Carl Fisher, including Carl Fisher's major initiative of wetland draining, David Davis spent millions of dollars dredging the Tampa Bay coastline to pile up sand and concrete into entirely new landmasses ready for suburban development.

Tampa, which had already grown due to the cigar boom of the Ybor City days, was now beginning to grow even more rapidly in the 20s. White Protestant settlers from the South and the Midwest eagerly moved into David Davis's new suburbs, diluting the pre-existing Latin Catholic Cuban character that the city had had in the early 20th century. Down the coast, the nearby town of Sarasota organized similar dredging efforts. This city was previously best known as the home of the Ringling Brothers Circus Tycoons, and later began to attract prosperous investors and visiting baseball teams, some of whom have been coming down for spring training for over a century. Probably unique among any Florida town, Sarasota in the 20s also became the home of a small mennonite community, whose thousands of descendants still live in the Sarasota area today. But then in 1926, all of this came crashing down, and more literally than you'd think.

The bust and the 1926 hurricane

Just 10 days into the new year, a retired Danish schooner intended for use as a floating hotel and casino sank in Biscayne Bay, blocking all access of goods by sea and requiring any transit to be rerouted onto the already congested roads and railways. You know, traffic is bad today, but in the era before refrigerator trucking and the interstate highway system, this led to major logistical bottlenecks. Miami and surrounding communities faced an existential crisis as necessary goods could not be shipped down the peninsula in time. Milk and meat arrived spoiled. Cow's feed was moldy, causing actual starvation among the cattle population. Restrictions placed on what goods could be sent by rail totally halted Miami construction, causing many enterprising developers to smuggle in bricks and rebar underneath sacks of flour or heads of lettuce. But as bad as things already are in Miami, things are only going to get worse.

Because on September 18th, 1926, a yet unnamed Category 4 hurricane slammed into Miami, destroying thousands of homes and construction sites in progress, including Henry Flagler's Royal Palm Hotel and the first campus of the University of Miami. The next year, the school's football team would be renamed the Miami Hurricanes. The beautiful Vizcaya, the great palace built off the Miami shore by James and Charles Deering, barely survived due to its sturdy stone construction. Although tropical storms are now a well-known aspect of life in Miami, the first-generation investors were completely spooked by this weather event, possibly showing better foresight about climate than today's oceanfront developers. This means that after the initial rebuilding effort, there really wasn't any interest in new grand hotels or skyscrapers. Carl Fisher was ruined, his third wife left him, the billboards in New York were all papered over, and the Florida land boom had come to an end.

Miami would remain an important city for the next few decades, but it would actually be a surprisingly small town until the 50s. In the 30s and 40s, Miami was smaller than either Jacksonville or Tampa St. Pete. Something I'm sure that Jackson is very proud of. As suburban growth slowed down, Miami would revert back to the hotel culture of the Flagler years. Hospitality became its primary industry, you know, and Miami Beach in particular would become famous for small Art Deco hotels built during this period. Miami was actually relatively insulated by the Great Depression, only because by 1929, so many local banks and businesses had already been ruined in the 1926 land bubble. The city gained international attention in 1933 when President Franklin Roosevelt visited Miami alongside Chicago Mayor Anton Cermak. A young diminutive anarchist named Giuseppe Zangara took this occasion to shoot at both the president and the mayor, striking and killing the latter.

Zangara and Cermak

While Zangara had hoped to inspire a revolution against monarchs and capitalists and presidents everywhere, locally in Florida, the reaction to the assassination was yet another period of increased nativism and open participation by Miami police in the Ku Klux Klan. Klansmen in Miami were not only hostile to blacks, but really anybody who was not white and Christian. This means that even though Miami Beach is a famously Jewish area today, in the 20s and 30s, Jewish residents were informally barred from neighborhoods and hotels outside the bottom tip of the island, in line with the racist visions of Carl Fisher. At least one Miami Beach hotel infamously advertised: always a view, never a Jew. Despite institutionalized prejudice, Jewish families continued to move into the area, including the founders of iconic South Beach restaurant, Joe's Stone Crab, as well as many of the developers of those famous Art Deco hotels on Ocean Drive.

So ironically, anti-Semitic policies excluding Jewish residents actually helped concentrate capital investment in South Beach, turning it into the most desirable part of the island and making Miami, the broader Miami area, an international vacation hub. Conspicuous consumption blossomed across the 1920s, leading to a sudden interest in travel. Whereas in the days of Frederick deBary and Henry Flagler, Florida vacations were only available to the rich. Now, now the ever-stretching railroad tracks and ever-fattening wallets allowed middle-class Americans to see the sunshine state. The weather was a particular draw. Carl Fisher's publicity man, Steve Hannagan, put a famous billboard one winter in Times Square, saying, It's June in Miami. But there was something else that could be found in Florida just as easily as sunshine. That is alcohol. Sam, why don't you tell us about Florida and Miami during the Prohibition era?

Yeah, so learning about this from you was really crazy because I just didn't know any of this history. But really, Prohibition didn't defeat America's glut for liquor, but it completely transformed the country's relationship to drinking. Because spirits had to be produced in secret or smuggled across the border, this led to a rise in Appalachian moonshine production and also a huge interest in Canadian whiskey, as well as, for our purposes, most important, Cuban rum.

Yes. Just to add here, this is to say, prohibition is the reason we put little tropical umbrellas in our drinks. Only reason.

Prohibition and rum runners

Yeah, so true. Yeah, so all of this led to a noticeable boost in tourism, which turned Cuba into a major destination for international travel, as well as fueling the growth of the Key West and Miami. Yeah, the first of these areas was so close to Havana that it once again became a major hub for crime and smuggling, just as it had been a century prior in the days of the wreckers and pirates. Although many of these figures were associated with brutal gangs, most notably Al Capone's Chicago Syndicate, some rum runners had achieved legendary status in Florida. The most romantic of these figures must be the beautiful young dance instructor Marie Waite, nicknamed Spanish Marie for her Mexican heritage. Marie, along with her husband Charlie, commanded at least a dozen high-speed smuggling boats before she was 25 years old. Like many other rum runners, Marie oversaw nighttime voyages from Havana to Key West and vice versa, bringing illicit alcohol to thirsty revelers in Florida in all 48 states.

After her husband was killed in a Coast Guard shootout, she continued their operation solo while caring for several small children, using the secret radio frequency to communicate with smuggling hubs across Florida and the Caribbean. After the U.S. military cracked her code, she was arrested, but after her arraignment, she fled the country and successfully evaded any prosecution for her smuggling operations.

Yeah, another kind of fun link here is that in 1927, the famous airline Pan American, you know, Pan Am, began its first flight, which was a puddle jumper, from Havana to Key West. So I am not alleging that Pan Am flights were used for rum running. However, the timeline is pretty interesting. And in addition, several individual Pan Am pilots were arrested for moonlighting with their private planes as smugglers. So I think it's kind of easy to connect the dots here with Pan Am. During this time, Al Capone and his brother Ralph Capone, who I gotta say, I love that name, Ralph Capone.

Ralph Capone.

Yeah, they pioneered airspace smuggling initially through flights over the Great Lakes from Canada to Chicago and quickly had over two dozen planes sneaking whiskey in from Canada and rum in from Cuba. Miami openly prospered from prohibition during this time. Very interesting parallels with the later cocaine era in the 80s. Nicknamed the leakiest city in America, cheap saloons and high-end hotels alike made only a token attempt to observe the Volstead Act. Supposedly, limousines would line up at the docks to meet every ship coming in from Cuba or the Bahamas, so wealthy Miamians could get their liquor straight from the source. In 1921, a wealthy snowbird was arrested at Henry Flagler's Royal Palm Hotel for the possession of approximately 50 cases of liquor, from which 90 bottles were produced as evidence at his trial. Despite all of this, he was acquitted of all charges in five minutes. One New York street preacher, possibly inspired by seeing all of Carl Fisher's billboards, declared that if anyone wants to go to hell in a hurry, they should head to Miami.

Al Capone and the Tampa mob

Because Miami was central to Al Capone's operations, he spent a lot of time in the city. His criminal enterprise surely contributed to the city's economic growth. He was arrested many times in Miami on various criminal charges, including at one point accepting a million dollars in cash for a liquor deal. But the infamously slippery Scarface was acquitted every single time. In 1930, he was formally banned from the city of Miami, yet 10 years later, while dying of neurosyphilis, Al Capone was released from Alcatraz and returned to South Florida, electing to spend his final delirious years in Miami Beach. Apocryphally, his brain was so rotted by this disease that by the end of his life, he was seen fishing in his swimming pool. The Prohibition era saw the beginning of major transnational links between American gangsters and Cuban elites. But what I find really interesting is that a surprising and cool center of all of this were actually those multi-ethnic cigar floors in Tampa, which we mentioned before, where Italian and Cuban immigrants would spend all day long in close proximity, learning each other's languages, setting up joint business ventures, and forming criminal organizations.

Sicilian-born gangsters Ignacio Antinori and Santo Traficante, clearly the best name of any gangster ever, formed rival street gangs in 1920s Tampa, making most of their money initially off of the bolitas, or little balls, a traditional Cuban lottery that had spread to Florida. They transitioned to the Cuban rum trade, but then after the end of Prohibition, they needed to find other ways to keep up their income. Ignacio Antinori visited the French Riviera and Corsica, where he worked with local banditi to turn Tampa into North America's premier opium smuggling destination, which it would remain until he was killed by an unknown gunman in 1940. True to his name, Santo Traficante, meanwhile, made huge amounts of money by smuggling drugs, this time from Latin America rather than the Mediterranean. He used his wealth to establish new casinos in 1930s Havana, often with investment from major New York gangsters, most famously Lucky Luciano.

The Tampa mob thus laid the foundation for later, more significant links between American gangsters and American intelligence operatives within the Cuban government. In 1960, Santo's more famous son, Tampa-born Santo Traficante Jr., would be implicated in a CIA plot to assassinate Fidel Castro. But that is beyond the scope of this episode. After the end of Prohibition, you began to see some interesting changes in Miami's tourism and drinking culture. One interesting change is that live music was banned in hotels, which led, which was related to the shift away from major hotels such as the Royal Palm, destroyed in the 1926 hurricane, to the smaller, more intimate Art Deco hotels of Miami Beach. Because music could not be played in these hotels, you begin seeing the rise of nightclubs in the 30s and 40s. Many of these nightclubs had specific exotic themes. They might be Italian-themed, at least one of them was South Seas-themed, prefiguring the later tiki movement.

The first tiki bars

Many of them, however, perhaps the plurality, were Latin-themed and embraced the rum-running legacy of the 1920s. I think this is very fun because it shows that as early as the 30s and 40s, Miami is embracing its own criminal past, commercializing its heritage of smuggling, just like you see today with, you know, Miami Vice aesthetics and, you know, in all of the vaporwave stuff. So, you know, this is all to say, you know, Florida in many ways has always been Florida. But so, returning to the hurricane of 1926, this storm destroyed not only many man-made structures, but also flooded the crop fields and knocked over thousands of young fruit trees. You know, the orange industry cannot catch a break. We're going to see, then in 1929, there was another catastrophic shock here, because the Mediterranean fruit fly, one of the most destructive of all agricultural pests, infected 75% of the entire Florida citrus crop.

Draining the Everglades

Entire groves had to be burned to stop the spread. This devastated the Florida economy in the short term, causing high unemployment even before the Great Depression. It also, however, opened millions of acres of farmland up to suburban development. During and after World War II, these suburbs expanded in waves around Miami, Jacksonville, and Tampa. And quickly, these post-war suburbs overtook the urban centers in both area and population. This suburban sprawl, very similar to what was developing in New York and California, quickly went past agricultural greenfield, instead moving into the surrounding swamp. The Everglades have been used for agriculture for decades, but the spread of the suburbs saw a much larger scale of environmental erosion. As early as the 1920s, pioneering environmentalist Marjory Stoneman Douglas petitioned to save the Everglades from development and overhunting by turning the entire region into a national park. Stoneman Douglas and gardener Ernest Coe spent much of the 30s and 40s lobbying to preserve the Everglades from the encroaching suburbs.

In 1947, the administration of Harry S. Truman agreed to preserve the Everglades just weeks after the publication of Marjory Stoneman Douglas' landmark work, River of Grass. It is remarkable that so much of the Everglades was preserved. However, we gotta keep in mind that by 1947, the vast majority of the Florida wetlands had already been drained. As early as the days of Henry Flagler, federal and state governments were working ceaselessly with local landowners on massive public works projects in Florida. Bridges, roads, and canals all built with the intention of lubricating domestic and international trade. In the early 19th century, these kinds of projects had been termed internal improvements, although the most famous of all of these was dug 4,000 miles south of the U.S. in Panama. All these improvements, which included wetland reclamations and drainages, were popular with both the factions that vied for control in Florida's political system during the Flagler days.

Jackson, what can you share about this?

Yeah, so the draining of the Everglades was pretty popular with both factions because there was something that both kind of saw as an opportunity there, right? So establishment business Democrats looked to expanding commercial ties of at first railroads and then tourism and then eventually sort of land speculation. They saw that as an ample opportunity to make a bunch of money. But the populace also saw it in a sort of classical American Democrat way as an easy way to expand and to get more land in the hands of Florida's cracker yeomanry, right? It was seen as...

Yeah, it all goes back to Jefferson.

Yes, exactly. It was seen as essentially a new, and we've hammered this point home a couple times, a new frontier that could be sort of parceled out and given to the sort of small holders of Florida, right? So the wetland reclamation was basically the biggest issue of late 19th century, early 20th century Florida politics. And the overwhelming majority of the Florida government's sort of focus at the time was on facilitating, planning, and actually executing these sort of wetland reclamation projects.

Yeah, and you know, I think this really bookends the legacy of the 19th century Democratic Party in Florida. Because at the start of the century, you have the illegal conquest of Florida by Andrew Jackson, later founder of the Democratic Party. Then, under his presidency, you see the violent removal of the Seminole people out of Florida during the Seminole Wars. And then, 80 years later, you're seeing the homeland of the Seminole people be literally destroyed, completely altered to make way for white settlement, for this yeoman expansion. And I think there's a little bit of the yeoman dream in the suburbs, you know?

Oh, 100%. Many people have talked about that, but it really is sort of like the final instantiation of that idea.

Yeah. So between 1905 and 1925, Florida Governor Napoleon Broward and land magnate Barron Collier oversaw major drainage efforts, digging canals to drain Florida's ecologically unparalleled wetland ecosystem out into the sea. For their efforts, each of these men got a South Florida county named after him. Although this drainage was initially intended to spread farmland, that you know, the rural yeomanry, a long period of drought coinciding with the Dust Bowl of the Plains, ruined much of the topsoil on the now dried-up former swampland. This caused wildfires to sweep through central and southern Florida across the 30s. Had the Everglades not been partially restored in the 40s, this reckless drainage probably would have turned South Florida's tropical landscape into a lifeless mudflat. There's one other project we have to mention here. Another what-if in Florida history that I think deserves a little bit of attention here, which is that in the 1930s, the administration of Franklin Roosevelt planned a project even more ambitious than what his cousin Teddy had dug in Panama.

This would be a 100-mile-long canal from the Gulf of Mexico all the way to the St. Johns River. This would allow ships to sail straight from the Atlantic into the Gulf without having to round the peninsula, by truly cutting Florida in half. If anybody's ever seen that Bugs Bunny GIF, we almost did it.

God.

From 1933 to 1935, New Deal funds were authorized for crews of workers to slash their way through miles and miles of Florida forests, requisitioning and even destroying farms and homes along the way of this planned canal. These crews altered the route of the St. Johns River, digging their way through the dirt and limestone out of their start point near Palatka, Florida. Meanwhile, on the Gulf end of the Proposed Canal, residents of the tiny village of Yankeetown, I love that name, hoped that they would soon become one of the biggest ports in the USA. But then in 1936, Republican opposition in the House and the Senate halted this project. And although this was not known at the time, it would never really be completed. Across the 50s, 60s, and 70s, token efforts were made to continue the Trans-Florida Canal, but the financial and environmental cost made it unfeasible.

Due to the efforts of early environmentalist Marjorie Harris Carr, not to be confused with Marjory Stoneman Douglas, the project was officially canceled in the 1990s. Today, a 100-mile scar cuts diagonally across Florida, a testament to the ambitious, eccentric, and ecologically devastating feats of engineering undertaken to make Florida what it is today. I think this is a great example of how Florida is, despite being the oldest state in some ways, you know, the first state contacted by Europeans, it is also the newest society in the United States, as it was all engineered in the very recent future, in the very recent past, by these various land speculators using modern construction and earthworking technologies to make this land habitable for essentially white civilization. Because this whole level of social and hydrological engineering is not really paralleled anywhere else in the U.S., I gotta ask you, Jackson, do you think the Florida suburban worlds can be understood as a weird kind of intentional community?

Well, the people have been sort of looking at that one suburb in Florida that was intended to only have gondolas like Venice. And so the streets are like horrible and traffic is terrible.

Cape Coral.

Yes. So there's certainly echoes of a sort of ill-conceived sort of intentional community there. But like I think on a deeper level, it's very interesting that like you said, Florida alongside like maybe some other sort of more significant suburban settlements in like places like California.

Yeah, Arizona.

Arizona, like the sort of Sun Belt, it is probably the most sort of intentional, sort of non-social engineering or like non-intentionally sort of conceived of as social engineering, like areas of settlement in the United States, right? It is, most of the sort of new growth suburbs are planned ahead of time. They're not just like people live there and then it expands, right? So like the villages, for example, which we haven't really talked about, but is sort of because it's kind of beyond the scope of this episode, but like these communities in central-ish Florida that are basically entirely populated by retirees and they have like age covenants where you can't like be below a certain age and live there. Like those are those are very like those are very sort of utopian community-esque ideas, right? Those are sort of those are sort of the utopias of America that we sort of build today, like for retiree boomers.

So I think that there is something to the idea of Florida as a sort of intentional community.

The dream of new harmony alive in the villages.

Exactly.

Well, yeah, well, so Jackson, you're really kind of there, you were the guiding light behind this whole series. Just curious, any really closing thoughts not only on the development of Florida in the 19th and 20th centuries, but on this whole Florida project we've been doing here?

Apologies to Sean Baker?

Florida, America distilled

I think that if we kind of want to sum up the episode and maybe the project as a whole, is that by the time of World War II and sort of the post-war era, Florida had sort of undergone another sort of great change from where it had been after the Civil War, right? It was transformed physically, but it had also been transformed socially. It had entered into, finally, into close connection with the rest of the country, and it had developed something like its modern economy that was based on tourism, some industry, and sort of citriculture. The railroad had spread American life into swamps previously inhabited only by refugees and runaways, and the influx of all different types of people into the peninsula had created one of the more unique politico-social landscapes in the nation.

Yeah. Wetlands that, since the Spanish era, had been impenetrable to any but the most skilled and hardy navigators now teemed with subdivisions and suburbs.

I think that it's interesting to end this series here right around the World War II era because most people are probably familiar with the era after this in Florida history, right? This is that would be the era of Epcot and sort of Walt Disney company moving into and basically taking over central Florida.

Yes.

The expansion of Miami and its various Caribbean communities, especially the very politically influential Cuban community after the Cuban Revolution. And it's especially if they're familiar with Florida, it would be its journey from Democrat stronghold to the swingiest of swing states to, you know, nowadays, of late, it is sort of the shining city on the hill for right-wingers. But that's sort of a more familiar story to non-Floridians. And I think that it's interesting to end this here because a lot of what we now consider to be Florida sort of society, right? The suburbanization, the draining of the wetlands, right? The reclamation or the development of previously very dense and very sort of biodiverse in a lot of cases, like wilderness, that had already been established by this era.

There was even a politically active Cuban community a century before, you know, Cuban immigrants started arriving in the 1960s.

Exactly. And I think that what this series in general, like if there's an overarching point to it, and I think something that could be hammered home at the end, it's that Florida is not just a unique place because of Disney and the space shuttle and, you know, hanging Chads and like the 2000 election, right? It has been unique and weird and wild and sort of, you know, eccentric basically as long as people have lived there, right? And it's also been changing as long as people have lived there. Now, that's true of most places, but I think it's probably the most radically true of Florida, right? The landscape looks so much different now than it did even 50 years ago, let alone 200 years ago, that it really is a trend in all of America that is most sort of concentrated and visible in a place like Florida.

Yeah, and that's the thing, you know, Florida, it's the first state, it's the last state, it's the least American part of America, it's the most American part of America. That's why I really wanted to do this whole series. And I think it's a tragedy that Florida history isn't really widely discussed. Like, you know, I highly doubt a single one of our listeners has ever listened to a podcast about the history of Florida before.

Yeah, it's, it's, I think it is, especially as America becomes more suburban, which it already has become more suburban over the decades, but it's a trend that doesn't really seem to be stopping, right? People are moving, moving out of rural communities and into suburban communities. They still do that. The things that make Florida unique, I think, are going to be seen in a lot more places as these sort of trends continue, right? So like knowing about Florida history is not just important because it is sort of interesting or because it's unique, but it also is like, in a lot of ways, it is the first place that sort of new ideas sort of percolate into America as much as it is a place where the rest of America sort of gets mashed up into one big sort of unique stew, right? So.

Yeah. And again, that's something like the whole, I don't know if we emphasized this enough earlier, but the entire idea of a vacation resort, that did not exist before Henry Flagler. Florida was basically the birth of the modern tourism model. The whole idea of a beach vacation, it's not entirely based on Florida. You know, people were going to the shore in New York, in England, for centuries. But the idea of the tropical beach paradise, that is pioneered by the Florida hotel civilization.

Right. And the extent to which America is sort of influential in the Caribbean, I think is because of Florida, right? It's because it possesses Florida. And the extent to which the Caribbean economy is now has transitioned from a sort of extractive agricultural economy to a tourism economy, I think is also in part due to the influence of Florida, at least by way of popularizing the tropical vacation in the minds of sort of vacationers from the United States, right? So I would say that it is at least as sort of important to understand the sort of Henry Flagler model to understand why people now go to, you know, Caribbean island cruises as much as it is about those islands themselves, right?

Yeah, yeah, this generic tropicalia, which is something that I've thought about a lot, actually.

Yes, you're very into the tiki thing.

Yeah, you sort of see that. You're very into that.

Sort of auto-orientalism, yes.

Yeah. All right. Well, I think, man, that wraps it up. It's been three great episodes. Thank you, Jackson.

Yeah, good stuff.

Wrapping up the series

Man, this is a great one. Really, there is nothing like Florida. If you have never visited, I cannot in good conscience tell you to visit. But if you do, you will have a lovely experience. You will experience some of the most beautiful natural landscapes in America, some of the most beautiful artificial landscapes in America, and a really genuinely unique culture. Even though Florida in many ways feels very commercial, almost kind of homogenized, there are very interesting elements of the local Florida cultural landscape that do still survive, especially in South Florida, in my opinion. It really is, you know, it's a state I love to visit, even though I no longer live there. And I hope that our listeners have realized that there's a lot more to Florida than the Florida Man headlines. It really is one of the most exciting and interesting places in the United States and has been for 500 years, since long before the United States existed.

It doesn't really have this reputation. Because it's such a lot, so much of the state, so much of the places where people live are very new, it doesn't really have this reputation. But like, it has to be one of the best states to go to if you are a history lover. Like, if you like history, like, there is just so much of it there because, you know, sort of literate sort of sort of record-keeping societies have been there for so long that it is like there is just so much to sort of to take in if you know where to look for it. And even in places that are fairly new, like sort of Miami or to a lesser extent, Tampa, there's always something that is sort of older than you might expect in each of the places that you would see in Florida. So I think that if anyone who is listening to this show is like, why would I listen or why would I go to Florida?

It's like, well, there's actually a lot more for you than you might think there. So.

All right. Well, thank you for guiding us down this lovely tour of the Sunshine State. And remember to all our listeners, it's five o'clock somewhere.

Yes.

Wasting away in Margaritaville.

This episode on Spotify

The show is also on Apple Podcasts, Overcast, Pocket Casts, Podcast Addict, YouTube, RSS and Patreon.

More listening